by Elizabeth Judd
FALL 1986
My first year in Berkeley has left me with a feeling of unreality — almost a feeling of dissociation, like being in a car accident or being mugged. I’m disappointed that the feminism I’ve encountered in California (like the pro-pornography and pro-prostitution movement) seems so strongly tinged by male-left politics, and that I haven’t been able to find the kind of nurturing, supportive feminist community I thought would prevail here. When I left to teach at a German university in 1974, the US women’s movement was at its peak and we thought the future belonged to us.
After a decade abroad and home in Hawai‘i, I took it for granted that if there was one place I’d find that movement again, it was the San Francisco Bay Area. But where is the dynamic movement I remember from my graduate school days? Where have all the brave, visionary women activists of the 1960s and 1970s gone? How could something so vibrant, so promising, have just disappeared?
I was extremely dispirited by the kind of politics considered ‘progressive’ in the supposedly feminist paradise of Berkeley and Oakland. It would never have occurred to me that a community could be labelled progressive in which women were routinely threatened with weapons or knocked down or spit on in the street, in which newspapers reported numerous harassment incidents targeting African American women on the UC Berkeley campus, in which it was open season against lesbians, in which older people were huddled behind locked doors, afraid to come out because of crime and disrespectful behaviour, or in which it was too dangerous for children to venture out alone in public, let alone roam free, as I’d done in my Hawai‘i childhood.
In retrospect, I was glimpsing the earliest phase of the virulent backlash that would engulf the country in the following decades, mostly forcing feminism underground and spawning everything from the men’s rights movement and porn culture to rabidly right-wing politicians.
I was caught off guard by the inordinate role of the male left in this backlash. From the time I’d arrived in California I’d detected the unmistakable misogyny of male-left politics, all too familiar from earlier decades, except that in the Bay Area of the 1980s, it was no longer a fringe phenomenon but seemed embedded in the cultural fabric. I was disgusted to find the Bay Area was many second-wave feminists’ worst nightmare — run by the male left — though now those self-styled male ‘radicals’ and ‘revolutionaries’ had refashioned themselves as ‘progressives.’
Of course, I shouldn’t have been caught off guard. It wasn’t as if I’d forgotten the outpouring of feminist essays, manifestos, and speeches around 1970, many with titles like ‘Leaving the Left,’ signalling women’s repudiation of the male left because of its misogyny and other retrograde values.1 I eventually learned there’s a term for these men: ‘bad-faith reformers.’ These are people who can’t openly oppose social change for fear of alienating peers and losing jobs, so they adopt social-justice rhetoric to gain credibility, then do their best to block the same movements.
I began to grasp that universities and university towns were a microcosm of these battles, because they tend to be at the epicentre not only of social progress but of backlash politics. The greatest irony was that in my youth, when educational discrimination was at its worst, I never hesitated to walk around any university campus. When I worked near Georgetown University in Washington, DC, in my late teens and early 20s, my women colleagues and I would often eat lunch on the campus or join the crowds on the lawn to catch a glimpse of a visiting dignitary. We couldn’t have attended the university as students or probably entered their auditoriums or other facilities. But no one bothered us when we walked across campus or sat on a bench to eat lunch.
A generation later, the UC Berkeley campus was a different story. To take a small example, I encountered many feminist writers in the 1980s and 1990s who wanted to use the outstanding UC Berkeley library facilities — some had even moved to Berkeley mostly for that purpose — but were making do with lesser alternatives because they couldn’t stand men’s harassment and violence toward women on and around that campus.
Another problem — not limited to the Bay Area but especially virulent there — involved personal attacks against women shattering glass ceilings, often attacks by other women. ‘Trashing,’ as second-wave feminists often called this phenomenon, has damaged many lives.
Trashing is defined in a classic essay by Joreen (the pseudonym of Jo Freeman, a feminist scholar and activist) as “a particularly vicious form of character assassination which amounts to psychological rape. It is manipulative, dishonest, and excessive. It is occasionally disguised by the rhetoric of honest conflict, or covered up by denying that any disapproval exists at all. But it is not done to expose disagreements or resolve differences. It is done to disparage and destroy.”2 Psychologist Phyllis Chesler, whose influential book Women and Madness gave her the kind of public exposure that invited attack, elaborates: “I saw feminists steal each other’s work, money, jobs, spouses, physically hit each other, padlock doors, turn other feminists in to the police. I saw feminists either refuse to pay or grossly underpay their female employees, or ‘groupies,’ whom they sometimes also treated as if they were stupid, slaves, or servants … I saw feminists instigate whisper-and-smear campaigns to wreck each other’s reputations, both socially and professionally.”3
Women who stand out—politicians, activists, writers, artists, and others — have been the most common targets of these attacks. Though couched in the language of political purity, the attacks often seem motivated by plebeian emotions like jealousy. An underlying factor is often ‘misdirected fury,’ a phrase used by Carolyn Heilbrun, a pioneering academic and novelist, to explain the relentless attacks on Gloria Steinem by other feminists, but one that could be used more generally of women’s tendency to take their anger over men’s misogynist behaviour out on other women.4
As Heilbrun asks in the chapter titled ‘Trashing’ in her biography of Steinem, “The hard question … is why, as their frustration and anger mounts, women attack one another rather than the [patriarchal] establishment in any of its myriad forms.”5 She speculates that the underlying causes include not only rage but self-esteem problems and poor coping skills, resulting in the ‘tall-poppy syndrome’: the impulse to cut down those who stand out.6
Others point to deeper roots of the trashing problem. Feminist theologian Catherine Keller says “the monstrous rage expressed in the image of the Gorgon’s head, the primal fury of a power suppressed and repressed” can indeed be “turned often against other women, just as often as against men.” She continues that “such a second-order, decapitated rage makes scapegoats of those closest to us, rather than directing itself at the larger situations of patriarchal injustice.” This rage has “deeper wellsprings, shared with the ancient Furies. These Furies … embody the insatiable resentment of the superseded Mothers.”7 In short, trashing could be seen as the rage of the “superseded Mothers” at men’s usurpation of women’s power—rage misdirected at other women.
MID-1990s
I’m increasingly shocked at how isolated many feminists have become. My efforts to create a women’s discussion group that would meet every few weeks in one of the many cafés near a subway station or bus line in Berkeley or Oakland have come to nothing. The women I contacted were mostly enthusiastic, but their comments were demoralizing. One said she’d been working on a book on matriarchy for decades but that I was the first person she’d mentioned it to, because of the trashing she expected from family and friends. We were able to meet only a few times before the group foundered. The reason was that many of the women — who were middle-aged and sometimes ill or disabled — were extremely poor and couldn’t afford bus fare or coffee or tea. This was heartbreaking for some participants, who, like me, were looking for the sisterhood we’d often experienced in the 1970s, instead of the relentless trashing by other women that seems to have become normative. Something appears to have changed. Trashing has been around as long as I can remember, but this feels much worse — almost as if it’s coming from a different, more misogynist generation. The ideal of sisterhood, as imperfectly realized as it often was, seems to be giving way to something more sinister.
Saying I was in a state of culture shock in my early years in the Bay Area would be an understatement. After a decade in Europe and Hawai‘i I felt like I’d come back to a different country, one I hardly recognized. Other than in totalitarian regimes, I’d never heard of so many people — let alone a whole subculture — that considered it desirable to damage the lives of everyone around them. My initiation into these practices came when I joined various Bay Area women’s groups, only to be repeatedly informed that my PhD and tenuous academic career made me “complicit in the patriarchal establishment” and that I should walk away from it all. A zealous trasher went further and warned that it was her “political duty” to end the careers of women scholars, including mine.
Before I could extricate myself from those circles, she and others engaged in verbal abuse and sabotaged professional opportunities. A memorable example involved a paper I’d been invited to give at a conference in Oakland, which I’d hoped might help reactivate my career. The night before, one of the trashers showed up and banged on my bedroom windows in the middle of the night to make sure I was exhausted by the time I gave my 8am presentation. I was both exhausted and furious, so of course it went badly.
More typically, the trashers blocked networking opportunities, sabotaged job applications, spread innuendos about personal lives, or otherwise ensured that many feminist scholars would remain marginalized. This destructive behaviour, which dominated my life for several years and poisoned my move to Berkeley, was severely stressful and helped block my return to university teaching.
What was so bizarre was that the trashers loved my matriarchy and goddess research (highly unusual in academia)—some flocked to lectures I delivered and gave me standing ovations — yet they showed an astonishing personal hostility. And I saw many other feminist scholars and writers treated the same way, especially those barely clinging to an academic career as I was. Astonishingly, the trashers never seemed to target male scholars or the few women who had made it into the upper echelons of elite universities, one of many Orwellian aspects of the trashing phenomenon that took me years to understand.
What was also bizarre was that many trashers were among the most privileged individuals I’ve ever met; a few (approaching middle age!) had never had jobs but were still being supported by wealthy parents or were living off a bewildering array of government benefits. Yet they thought nothing of ending the career of someone who’d spent nearly 20 years going to night school or relying on other work-study combinations to get undergraduate and graduate degrees, as I had. I marvelled that I’d never seen this vicious behaviour from the struggling plantation workers I grew up around in Hawai‘i, or from other marginalized people I’d known, but only from affluent Bay Area ‘progressives.’
As the years passed and I watched this nihilistic behaviour spread outward and become part of the US cultural fabric, it increasingly made sense. I realized my initial mistake: the trashing wasn’t just coming from women but also from men, especially on the patriarchal left, who were manipulating disgruntled, insecure women into engaging in ‘mean girl’ behaviour to damage other women’s lives. The prevalence of trashing in misogynist leftist strongholds, as academia was increasingly becoming, suggested it was a divide-and-conquer tactic serving the interests of the larger patriarchal society.
This seemed an obvious reason why the trashers’ targets weren’t men or conservative women; the trashers were colluding with men in derailing the feminist activists, politicians, scholars, and others that men found most threatening. Men’s encouragement of trashing and the debilitating conflict it causes among women would reflect their intense fear of female solidarity, and of the personal and political consequences of that solidarity. This calls to mind the poet Adrienne Rich’s words: “As a lesbian/feminist, my nerves and my flesh as well as my intellect tell me that the connections between and among women are the most feared, the most problematic, and the most potentially transforming force on the planet.”8 So from this standpoint, trashing could be seen as a hybrid product of women’s internalized misogyny and self-esteem issues and of the male left’s war on feminism.
As to why the Bay Area would be an epicentre of leftist forms of misogyny, including trashing, an intriguing possibility is that leftist misogyny is rooted in frontier cultures where a deeply uncivilized stratum has been papered over with a veneer of feminism. Few areas of the United States were more patriarchal and lawless than California in the 19th century, and its “monstrously imbalanced” sex ratio in the decades surrounding the Gold Rush of the 1840s and 1850s seems to have left an unsavoury legacy.9 To borrow a striking metaphor for this legacy, “It is taxidermy. It is men hunting down feminism, scraping out the inside, keeping the skin, and filling it up with basic patriarchal principles.”10
Years later I happened to read Dorothy Thompson’s famous 1941 article ‘Who Goes Nazi?’ which provided another piece of the puzzle.11 Thompson (1893-1961) was a pioneering print and radio journalist who witnessed the rise of Nazism first hand as head of the New York Post’s Berlin bureau. In 1934 she became the first foreign journalist expelled from Nazi Germany because of her negative depiction of Hitler and his movement (after interviewing him she offered this unflattering portrait: “He is formless, almost faceless, a man whose countenance is a caricature, a man whose framework seems cartilaginous, without bones. He is inconsequent and voluble, ill-poised, insecure. He is the very prototype of the Little Man”).12
In ‘Who Goes Nazi?’ Thompson described a parlour game she played with acquaintances in which they speculated on the kinds of individuals susceptible to Nazism. Noting that it’s “the disease of a generation,” she identified a soulless quality in those likely to “go Nazi”:
He has been fed vitamins and filled with energies that are beyond the capacity of his intellect to discipline. He has been treated to forms of education which have released him from inhibitions. His body is vigorous. His mind is childish. His soul has been almost completely neglected …
Kind, good, happy, gentlemanly, secure people never go Nazi. They may be the gentle philosopher whose name is in the Blue Book, or Bill from City College to whom democracy gave a chance to design airplanes—you’ll never make Nazis out of them. But the frustrated and humiliated intellectual, the rich and scared speculator, the spoiled son, the labour tyrant, the fellow who has achieved success by smelling out the wind of success—they would all go Nazi in a crisis.
Believe me, nice people don’t go Nazi. Their race, colour, creed, or social condition is not the criterion. It is something in them.13
As to the feminist trashers and their male-left enablers I’ve known and observed, there seems to be “something in them,” too: a disengagement from others produced by excessive affluence, a reduced capacity for empathy, a hostility and cynicism, a destructiveness that comes from too much urbanization and alienation from nature.
Regardless of its exact causes, trashing has done profound damage to women’s lives. In her exposé of the FBI’s infiltration of the women’s movement, Letty Cottin Pogrebin concludes: “Sadly, what the FBI has done best is to compile a catalog of the Women’s Movement’s self-destructiveness and our lost opportunities — a requiem for once thriving coalitions killed by the death wish of ideological purists and a nostalgic reminder of extinct organizations and names long since burned out and retired from activism.”14 A typical example is the sad story told by psychologist Naomi Weisstein in a reminiscence titled ‘Days of Celebration and Resistance: The Chicago Women’s Liberation Rock Band, 1970-1973.’15 In 1970, angered by the misogyny of male groups like The Beatles and inspired by the New Haven Women’s Liberation Rock Band, Weisstein decided to create a feminist rock band in Chicago. “My goals were much too ambitious — a common problem at the time — but the band turned out to be remarkably successful in achieving many of the goals,” she says.16 “Surely, we felt, we had produced a new world that would never go away, that would never fail us.”17
It did fail them. Taking a cue from dysfunctional aspects of the larger women’s movement, the members began to trash each other. A major conflict surrounded the question of leadership, a question that “was to rend the women’s movement from coast to coast.” Weisstein elaborates:
Committed … to what turned out to be a myth of equal skills, the movement applied the same kind of thinking to leadership, declaring that there should be none. For instance, as my reputation as a public speaker increased and my speaking invitations multiplied, the CWLU [Chicago Women’s Liberation Union] decided that I should refuse further invitations, lest I emerge as a ‘star.’ I willingly went along with this … But no matter how self-abnegating leaders were, it was not enough. The utopian vision became cannibalism, and the movement ate its leaders: in city after city, they went down.18
Weisstein was no exception. The band survived for three years, then shortly after she was forced to take a leave of absence, it “broke up in an agony of hatred and hidden agendas.”19 Weisstein was left with lifelong regret, both because of the personal toll the experience had taken and because of the cost to the women’s movement: “I will mourn the break-up of the band for the rest of my life … It is an irony that the revolutionary vision of utopia that had made our performance so powerful was the same ingredient that had destroyed us.”20
This ingredient also destroyed Sagaris two years later. Named for the Amazons’ double-edged sword, Sagaris was a feminist summer institute that had been the brainchild of faculty and students at Vermont’s Goddard College; according to novelist Blanche McCrary Boyd, a founder, it was intended to “build a bridge between movement activists and movement intellectuals.”21 In 1975, women from around the United States — “teenagers and grandmothers, welfare women and PhDs, radical lesbians and ex-nuns” — converged on the campus of Lyndon State College in rural Vermont for two five-week summer sessions.22 The first session, with a faculty that included feminist scholar Mary Daly, novelist Rita Mae Brown, and others, was relatively successful. A news report described organizers’ high hopes for the future: “The [first] session resulted in plans for publication of a book of the lectures and formation of feminist and lesbian organizations and a feminist news service. Sagaris has started a second session, and Ms. Boyd hopes it will become a permanent institution.”23
But the second session erupted in hostility, and “the dream met a nasty death, unraveling amid fierce political and cultural conflicts, crushed by a collision between purists and pragmatists that would have seemed familiar to political activists in all periods of history.”24 These conflicts centred around allegations that the institute was being financed by ‘tainted’ money from the Ms. Foundation, which had provided $5,000 for the first session and offered $10,000 for the second. In May 1975, the Redstockings — a radical feminist group — had issued a press release charging that Gloria Steinem, co-founder of Ms., had been a CIA agent. This charge stemmed from Steinem’s involvement in the late 1950s and early 1960s with the CIA-supported Independent Research Service, an organization enabling US students to attend communist-sponsored youth festivals abroad to build bridges and proselytize on behalf of American culture.
While the allegations about Steinem’s CIA role seem ridiculous in retrospect, they had a chilling effect. Most members of the Sagaris community voted to accept the Ms. grant, badly needed by the underfunded institute, but ideological purists split off and the institute unravelled. “By the time it limped to a close,” a New York Times article concluded, “it had become a kind of psychodrama for the movement’s woes.”26 In her insider’s account of second-wave feminism, Susan Brownmiller pronounces judgement on the “CIA contretemps,” including the Sagaris disaster:
It did write ‘The End’ to the longest chapter in the movement’s life, although in truth that chapter had been concluded a few years before. A second wave of theorists was forcing new breakthroughs—in rape, in battery, in sexual harassment — but by 1975 most of the early all-purpose agitators, the sine qua non of Women’s Liberation, had played out their historic role. Like most utopian visionaries at war with the world, they lacked the flexibility and the practical skills to triumph on the larger stage they had brought into creation.27
No one was exempt from this internecine warfare, but few women were targeted more vehemently than matriarchy scholars. Perhaps this was because the subject of matriarchy and the origin of patriarchy reminded women they were ‘superseded Mothers,’ to borrow Catherine Keller’s phrase. There was intense interest in matriarchy among rank-and-file feminists between the 1960s and 1980s, reflected in a steady stream of publications. But as interest in matriarchy was rekindled after its heyday in the 19th and early 20th centuries, it met with a ferocious backlash and not only from men. Many in the women’s community ridiculed the idea of matriarchy and savagely attacked anyone writing on the subject.28
Many academic feminists expressed the same opposition. Influential feminist scholars rushed into print with pronouncements like these: “The search for a genuinely egalitarian, let alone matriarchal, culture has proved fruitless”;29 “There is no evidence whatever for the existence of matriarchal societies in the ancient world”;30 “The myth of matriarchy is but the tool used to keep woman bound to her place. To free her, we need to destroy the myth.”31 Sherry Ortner’s influential 1972 article ‘Is Female to Male as Nature Is to Culture?’ had an especially damaging impact on matriarchy scholarship.32 That article, as well as many other publications by women anthropologists, classicists, and historians in those years, helped close the door on matriarchy scholarship in the United States for two generations.
This backlash obviously had its roots in the larger patriarchal society, but it was disproportionately destructive when it came from those whose opinion we cared about most and whose criticism and intolerance stung most: other women. Trashing had a devastating impact on matriarchy research and on many of the individuals involved.
Some matriarchy scholars paid the ultimate price; the suicides of Elizabeth Gould Davis (author of The First Sex) and Elizabeth Fisher (author of Woman’s Creation) come to mind.33 Davis faced unrelenting criticism of her book and had serious health problems; she shot herself to death in 1974. According to Kate Millett — author of the groundbreaking work Sexual Politics and one of the most gifted and influential second-wave feminists34 — Fisher, too, was demoralized over the reception of her book. She committed suicide in 1982, three years after the book was published. “Elizabeth [Fisher] is dead, and I must live to tell the tale,” Millett says, “hoping to tell another generation something I’d like them to know of the long struggle for women’s liberation, something about history and America and censorship.” She reminds younger readers of the costs of social change, and laments feminists’ inability to create enough community and continuity: “I might also hope to explain that social change does not come easy, that pioneers pay dearly and in unnecessary solitude for what their successors take for granted.”35
SPRING 2021
The women’s movement is back, but myriad forms of backlash seem to have taken a terrible toll. The obliteration of institutes like Sagaris as the activist phase of the women’s movement ran its course, the purging of the more radical feminists from academia, and men’s takeover of most women’s studies programmes (subsequently converted into ‘gender studies’ programmes reflecting a men’s rights mentality) were only a few of the developments contributing to profound generational discontinuity. The distortion of feminism and the intrusion of misogynist men in women’s lives in the guise of the transgender movement have only worsened this discontinuity, leaving young women with few feminist role models and without the feminist legacy that should be their birthright.
Years of trashing of my generation of feminists by misogynist men and complicit women haven’t helped.36 It’s not hard to see the ghost of matriarchy scholarship — or more generally, women’s vibrant exploration and rediscovery of our own biology, history, politics, spirituality, and other phenomena between the 1960s and 1980s—behind the backlash. The transgender movement in particular, with its fixation on defining biological women out of existence, surely reflects a deep-rooted male fear that the pendulum is swinging back toward ancient female-centred gender categories and social forms.
Predictably, the marginalization of feminists as this backlash has gained momentum has increasingly deprived us of a voice and often of an income, leading to pervasive poverty and exacerbating generational discontinuity, as one blogger recognizes in explaining the silence of older women on the internet:
I think this is first a class issue. Large numbers of older feminists, I would say by far the majority, are not heterosexually married or otherwise partnered, are lesbians, are single, are low income or in poverty (they are also often disabled or very, very ill). I’ve known some of these older women to post from the library—sometimes having to take several buses across town to do so and then limited as to how much time they can spend by library rules. They can’t afford a computer, can’t afford an internet connection, can’t afford internet cafes or Kinko’s, can’t afford carfare, busfare, and they sure can’t keep up with blogging and discussions if they can only get to the library an hour or two a week.37
Another factor contributing to this silence is the unprecedented ageism of middle-aged and younger Americans. This doesn’t seem to resemble the old-fashioned, patronizing ageism faced by women in my parents’ and grandparents’ generations. It resembles the harsh sexism and racism of 50 years ago. Many gains made by the women’s and civil rights movements haven’t been extended to older women, undoubtedly because older women are the most threatening cohort from men’s perspective.
As a final word on the isolation of feminist pioneers, journalist Susan Faludi has written a moving article on the mental health issues and suicide of Shulamith Firestone, a founder of radical feminist groups in the 1960s and author of The Dialectic of Sex.38 Describing the 2012 memorial service for Firestone, Faludi says: “It was hard to say which moment the mourners were there to mark: the passing of Firestone or that of a whole generation of feminists who had been unable to thrive in the world they had done so much to create.”39
Sadly, even when we have been able to pass on a feminist legacy to younger women, they haven’t always been able to survive the onslaught of trashing. A hauntingly tragic case is that of Denice Denton, an engineering professor and university administrator who came to national prominence in January 2005, when she criticized Harvard president Larry Summers’s misogynist comments about the underrepresentation of women in science and engineering. Summers had partly attributed this underrepresentation to biological differences in aptitude, insinuating that women don’t belong in those fields, and Denton appeared on national TV in the US as well as in Canadian and British media to rebut him.
Denton assumed office as chancellor of the University of California at Santa Cruz in February 2005, only a month after the Summers controversy. The Santa Cruz chancellorship was to have been her dream job, but she committed suicide a year and a half later, at the age of 46. Three years before her death, Denton had given lengthy interviews as part of an oral history project at the University of Wisconsin and was optimistic about the progress women had made since she began breaking barriers as a young engineering professor almost two decades earlier.40 She seems unaware in the interviews that a more hostile generation was emerging that would make the obstacles she faced early in her career look like child’s play.
People disagree on the details of this long, sordid story, but one thing everyone seems to agree on is that Denton profoundly misread the culture of Santa Cruz, expecting both the university and the town to be far more progressive than they were.41 She had grown up in a hardscrabble Texas environment, raised by a single mother, and was a lesbian. She went to MIT on a scholarship, where she flourished in the electrical engineering program. In 1986, in her mid-20s, Denton was offered a position at the University of Wisconsin, where she became the first tenured woman engineering professor. She later moved to the University of Washington, where she became the first woman dean of the engineering school and worked with Bill Gates in building a new engineering centre. Despite those accomplishments, she encountered a hostile research climate, which caused her to make a major transition to academic administration.42 Her friends described her as being on top of the world after she won the Santa Cruz chancellorship from among 700 applicants. She’d been breaking barriers all her life as a woman in an unconventional field, as a lesbian, as someone from a working-class background. Now she had a chance to ‘come home’ to a place where she’d finally belong, or so she thought.
Denton began to be enveloped by the politics of hate even before she took office. A few weeks after the University of California issued the press release that she and her partner were being hired — the partner, also a distinguished engineering professor, had accepted a position in the UC system headquarters — things began to unravel. On 20 January 2005, everyone woke up to an inflammatory headline in the San Francisco Chronicle: “UC hires partner of chancellor: Creates $192,000 post for Santa Cruz chief’s lesbian lover.”43 It all went downhill from there. It would take a book to chronicle the abuse Denton experienced; there was harassment, death threats, acts of violence. The abuse came from all sides, but mainly from the misogynist and homophobic so-called left, from men but also from women. (After Denton’s death, many women came forward to express remorse for participating in the attacks on her.)
It’s hard to sort out the myriad forms of prejudice coming together in the attacks on Denton, but her appearance and high level of achievement obviously tapped into something primal. Her Southern working-class roots didn’t help; there were slurs against her speech, mannerisms, and taste in clothing. Most merciless were the attacks on her appearance. A notoriously bigoted cartoon appeared in an alternative newspaper, Metro Santa Cruz, showing Denton as a “fat, masculine-looking czarina, complete with stubble on her chin.”44 There was inordinate misogyny surrounding her hair; judging from photos, she had curly hair that sometimes looked unruly, and if there’s one thing that seems to terrify men, it’s wild hair on women. We only need to think of the Medusa in Greek myth — the female monster with a tangled mass of snakes in place of hair. Denton said the Metro Santa Cruz cartoon and other attacks in Santa Cruz were the worst prejudice she’d ever experienced.45
The last major incident, on 6 June 2006, was orchestrated by a 20-year-old, self-styled ‘progressive’ undergraduate.46 In a demonstration at Denton’s home, as many as 100 mostly male protestors reportedly surrounded her car, climbed on it or rocked it, and bullied her as she tried to return to work after lunch. Denton went on medical leave a week or so later, eventually checking into a mental health facility for depression. She got out the night of 23 June. Early the next morning she jumped off the roof of her partner’s apartment building, the tallest in San Francisco.
Denton was not only targeted because she was one of those so-called anomalous women men are so afraid of. They also seem to have been terrified of her vibrancy, her love of life, something that came through in many tributes to her at her memorial service and elsewhere. One, by an MIT biology professor who’d known Denton, was succinct: “I will miss her terribly and will long wonder if she paid a price for being too brave, for being different, and for being so deeply decent.”47
Denton’s story, and many other experiences, have inspired me to write the following:
LETTER TO YOUNG FEMINISTS
We’ve been waiting for you, our feminist daughters, for half a lifetime, and you’re finally here. Like many of my contemporaries, I’ve been eagerly following your progress on social media, in politics, and wherever else you’ve made your presence known. But as I watch you navigate your generation’s social and political upheavals, I’m struck by how isolated and embattled many of you seem, especially the more radical among you. Yes, social change is daunting; this description of second-wave feminism will surely apply to your generation, too: “We were young and felt invincible. We had no idea that this struggle would take a lifetime and be much harder than anyone thought. Holding one’s own against patriarchy, just holding one’s own is not easy. Resisting it — building a resistance movement — would take all we had.”48My generation’s time is nearly over and we’re not leaving you the world we’d like to have left. We “pried open the imagination of the world [and] opened ourselves to the cries of women in torment and to their yearnings for freedom and joy … We expanded the boundaries of what women could want.”49 But the revolution many of us envisioned has barely begun. And we haven’t been able to deflect men’s ferocious efforts to damage society in retaliation against feminism, nor have women been able to in other cultures. So we’re leaving you a broken world, a world imperilled by men’s fear of women’s rising strength.
Wherever we are, we’ll be watching and urging you on, like the mothers in that incendiary passage from Virginia Woolf’s Three Guineas. Woolf suggests that donations for educational reform be earmarked “Rags. Petrol. Matches.” These should be used to “burn the [traditional patriarchal] college to the ground. Set fire to the old hypocrisies … And let the daughters of educated men dance round the fire and heap armful upon armful of dead leaves upon the flames. And let their mothers lean from the upper windows and cry ‘Let it blaze! Let it blaze!’”50 So when you hear cries from above to “Let it blaze!” — not only in universities but throughout patriarchal society—remember us!
My generation’s gift to younger feminists is to have forged a tenuous path toward a world in which women can live authentically as women again. Carolyn Heilbrun movingly captured that gift, though she could as easily have been writing about the gift of pioneering first-wave feminists to my generation, or about the gains won by brave women in other times and places:
Early feminists of the second wave, their names now forgotten, bore the brunt of the opposition against them in academia, in religious institutions, in the corporate and legal worlds, and won ground for their successors at great personal pain to themselves. As Virginia Woolf once wrote of the great English composer Ethel Smyth: “She is of the race of pioneers, she is one of the ice breakers, the gun runners, the window smashers. The armoured tanks, who climbed the rough ground, drew the enemies fire, and left behind her a pathway — not yet smooth and metalled road — but still a pathway for those who come after her.”51
As you make your way along that tenuous path, try to do a better job than my generation has of taking care of yourselves and of each other. Try to form community. Build bridges with other women across political, cultural, ethnic, age, and class lines — in unity there’s strength. You’re all in this together, and what unites you far exceeds what divides you. Celebrate yourselves and each other; value all feminist contributions, no matter how small or large. Create safe spaces to explore disagreements. Be generous, not inquisitorial, toward women whose choices differ from yours. Put aside the divisive cancel culture and similar phenomena that, while they seem to be a hallmark of your generation, represent my generation’s ‘trashing’ in a new guise.
I wish I could convey to you that you have an extraordinary place in history, because you’re on the cusp of a revolution. Your generation will carry forward the struggles of our foremothers to overturn patriarchy — struggles reaching back thousands of years and entailing indescribable courage and progress as well as inevitable suffering and setbacks. Cherish the opportunity, don’t run from it. Above all, never lose sight of our destination. As the German feminist Hedwig Dohm put it in 1876, “Sooner or later you are going to see land: the country that, for centuries, indeed for millennia, you have searched for in your heart — the country where women belong not to men but to themselves.”52
Elizabeth Judd, PhD, is an independent scholar and editor. She helped introduce women’s studies courses at several universities in the United States and Germany but, like many second-wave feminists, she was forced out of academia in the 1980s—mostly for her research on matriarchy. This piece is an edited excerpt from a memoir in progress titled The Ghost of Matriarchy, about her decades-long struggle to bring a book on matriarchy to fruition.
1 A good example is Robin Morgan’s ‘Goodbye to All That’ (1970), reprinted in Dear Sisters: Dispatches From the Women’s Liberation Movement, ed. by Rosalyn Baxandall and Linda Gordon (New York: Basic Books, 2000), pp. 53-57. For more on the rift between feminism and the male left, see the chapter ‘Leaving the Left’ in Ruth Rosen, The World Split Open: How the Modern Women’s Movement Changed America (New York: Penguin Books, 2006), pp. 94-140.
2 Joreen, ‘Trashing: The Dark Side of Sisterhood,’ Ms. (April 1976), 49-51, 92-98 (p. 49). Freeman says in an introductory note on her website that the article “evoked more letters from readers than any article previously published in Ms., all but a few relating their own experiences of being trashed.” For a more recent discussion of the dynamics of feminist conflict, see Bec Wonders, ‘Feminist Conflict: Navigating the Complexities of Sisterhood, Disagreement and Internal Struggle,’ THE RADICAL NOTION, 1.1 (Autumn 2020), 99-101.
3 Phyllis Chesler, Letters to a Young Feminist (New York: Four Walls Eight Windows, 1997), pp. 56-57. Chesler explores trashing and related topics in more detail in her Woman’s Inhumanity to Woman (Chicago: Lawrence Hill Books/Chicago Review Press, 2009). Also see her Women and Madness (New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2005).
4 Carolyn G. Heilbrun, The Education of a Woman: The Life of Gloria Steinem (New York: Dial Press, 1995), p. 284.
5 Heilbrun, p. 284.
6 Heilbrun, p. 307.
7 Catherine Keller, From a Broken Web: Separation, Sexism, and Self (Boston: Beacon Press, 1986), p. 58.
8 Adrienne Rich, On Lies, Secrets, and Silence: Selected Prose 1966-1978 (New York: Norton, 1979), p. 279.
9 The phrase “monstrously imbalanced” is from Albert L. Hurtado, Intimate Frontiers: Sex, Gender, and Culture in Old California (Albuquerque: University of New Mexico Press, 1999), p. 130.
10 Yağmur Uygarkızı, in Bec Wonders, ‘Oil and Water: Young Migrant Women and the Promises of Liberal Feminism,’ THE RADICAL NOTION, 1.2 (Winter 2021), 36-46 (p. 38).
11 Dorothy Thompson, ‘Who Goes Nazi?’ Harper’s (August 1941), 237-41.
12 Dorothy Thompson, I Saw Hitler! (New York: Farrar & Rinehart, 1932), p. 13.
13 Thompson, ‘Who Goes Nazi?’
14 Letty Cottin Pogrebin, ‘The FBI Was Watching You,’ Ms. (June 1977), 37-44 (p. 44).
15 Naomi Weisstein, ‘Days of Celebration and Resistance: The Chicago Women’s Liberation Rock Band, 1970-1973,’ in Dear Sisters, pp. 303-07.
16 Weisstein, p. 304.
17 Weisstein, p. 305.
18 Weisstein, p. 306.
19 Weisstein, p. 306.
20 Weisstein, p. 307.
21 Blanche Boyd, quoted in Jurate Kazickas, ‘Feminist institute reflects diversities,’ Spartanburg Herald, 15 August 1975, A8. On Sagaris, also see Rosen, pp. 254-59; Susan Brownmiller, In Our Time: Memoir of a Revolution (New York: Dial Press, 1999), pp. 238-42.
22 Kazickas.
23 Kazickas.
24 Rosen, p. 254.
25 The institute’s financial problems are mentioned in Brownmiller, pp. 239-40.
26 Lucinda Franks, ‘Feminists torn by dissension,’ Daytona Beach Morning Journal from the New York Times News Service, 2 September 1975, A6.
27 Brownmiller, p. 242.
28 The radical feminist opposition to matriarchy scholarship was typified by the Redstockings’ Feminist Revolution, a collection of essays published in 1978 that sometimes betrayed a Stalinist intolerance toward those felt to deviate from the party line. See Redstockings of the Women’s Liberation Movement, Feminist Revolution: An Abridged Edition with Additional Writings, ed. by Kathie Sarachild and Carol Hanisch (New York: Random House, 1978), esp. pp. 28-29, 81-82.
29 Sherry B. Ortner, ‘Is Female to Male as Nature Is to Culture?’ Feminist Studies, 1.2 (Fall 1972), 5-31 (p. 8); reprinted in Woman, Culture, and Society, ed. by Michelle Zimbalist Rosaldo and Louise Lamphere (Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, 1974), pp. 67-87 (p. 70).
30 Mary R. Lefkowitz, ‘Influential Women,’ in Images of Women in Antiquity, ed. by Averil Cameron and Amélie Kuhrt (Detroit: Wayne State University Press, 1983), pp. 49-64 (p. 49).
31 Joan Bamberger, ‘The Myth of Matriarchy: Why Men Rule in Primitive Society,’ in Woman, Culture, and Society, pp. 263-80 (p. 280).
32 The disproportionately damaging impact of Ortner’s article (cited in note 29) can be attributed to several factors: her perceived competence as an anthropologist (she won a MacArthur ‘Genius’ grant in 1990); her reputation as a pioneering ‘feminist’ anthropologist despite her conservatism; the fact that her article tapped into deep-rooted patriarchal stereotypes, winning the approval of the academic establishment; and the fortuitous circumstance that it was reprinted in Rosaldo and Lamphere’s widely read anthology, Woman, Culture, and Society.
33 See Elizabeth Gould Davis, The First Sex (New York: Putnam, 1971); Elizabeth Fisher, Woman’s Creation: Sexual Evolution and the Shaping of Society (Garden City, NY: Anchor Press/Doubleday, 1979).
34 Kate Millett, Sexual Politics (Garden City, NY: Doubleday, 1970).
35 Kate Millett, ‘Out of the Loop and Out of Print: Meditations on Aging and Being Unemployable,’ On the Issues: The Progressive Woman’s Quarterly (Summer 1998), 38-41 (p. 41).
36 Laura Miller, ‘A second look at the second wave,’ Slate, 21 June 2016.
37 Heart, 20 June 2006, comment 15 on Rachel S., ‘Feminist bloggers need to be more inclusive of older women,’ Alas! A Blog, 19 June 2006.
38 Shulamith Firestone, The Dialectic of Sex: The Case for Feminist Revolution (New York: William Morrow, 1970).
39 Susan Faludi, ‘Death of a Revolutionary,’ New Yorker, 15 April 2013. The article’s tagline is “Shulamith Firestone helped to create a new society. But she couldn’t live in it.”
40 See ‘Oral History #644—Denice Denton,’ taped interviews by Joyce Coleman, UW-Madison Oral History Project (Madison: University of Wisconsin, 2003), esp. p. 23.
41 On Denton’s suicide and the events leading up to it, see Diana Kapp, ‘Reporter’s notebook: The scandal, the scapegoats, and the suicide,’ San Francisco, March 2007, pp. 52-62, 148-55.
42 A biography of the 19th-century US astronomer Maria Mitchell compares Denton’s career with Mitchell’s and suggests Denton faced worse prejudice than Mitchell had faced 150 years earlier. Renée Bergland, Maria Mitchell and the Sexing of Science: An Astronomer Among the American Romantics (Boston: Beacon Press, 2008), pp. 250-52, 258. Denton’s friends said this prejudice was largely responsible for driving her out of research science (pp. 251-52).
43 Tanya Schevitz, ‘UC hires partner of chancellor: Creates $192,000 post for Santa Cruz chief’s lesbian lover,’ San Francisco Chronicle, 20 January 2005.
44 Kapp, p. 60.
45 Kapp, p. 60.
46 Josh Sonnenfeld, the demonstration’s organizer, tries to justify his actions in his ‘Mercury News continues misrepresentation of June UCSC protest,’ Santa Cruz Indymedia, 2 July 2006.
47 Nancy Hopkins, ‘Remembering Chancellor Denton: Remembrances from friends & colleagues,’ Office of the Chancellor, UC Santa Cruz, 2006.
48 Chesler, Letters to a Young Feminist, p. 42.
49 Chesler,Letters to a Young Feminist, p. 84.
50 Virginia Woolf, Three Guineas, ed. by Jane Marcus (New York: Harcourt, [1938] 2006), p. 45.
51 Heilbrun, pp. 295-96. The passage Heilbrun quotes is from Virginia Woolf’s The Pargiters: The Novel-Essay Portion of The Years, ed. by Mitchell A. Leaska (New York: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, 1977), p. xxvii.
52 Hedwig Dohm, ‘Der Frauen Natur und Recht’ [Women’s Nature and Rights] (1876); quoted in Marielouise Janssen-Jurreit, Sexism: The Male Monopoly on History and Thought, trans. by Verne Moberg (New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, [1976] 1982), p. 8.
