by Bec Wonders
Embittered, broken-hearted, hurt, upset: these feelings are all too familiar amongst political activists, and particularly feminists. When we feel wronged by someone internal to our political circles, the assumption of having been betrayed by someone whom you trusted to be on the same side can cut deeply. “Sisterhood is Powerful,” claimed the now iconic 1970 anthology edited by Robin Morgan, but sisterhood is also difficult, and it certainly is not a given. The word sisterhood is defined by Merriam-Webster’s Dictionary as “the solidarity of women based on shared conditions, experiences, or concerns.” Coming to an understanding of “the commonality underlying the diversity,” as Juliet Mitchell puts it in Woman’s Estate, is most important in developing feminist consciousness. Such commonality, however, is nearly impossible to identify, for very good reasons.
Most subjugated groups in society do not interact with their subjugators and are geographically separate, whereby physical exclusion acts as a foundational mechanism to maintain the power imbalance. Developing a sense of togetherness in these conditions doesn’t require much campaigning — it results quite obviously from the material set-up. Women, on the other hand, are everywhere. We’re everywhere, in every single facet of society, in every class, in every ethnicity, in every religion. In this case, we are kept separate from one another both within and outside of our immediate circles, while also being deeply integrated in the foundations of keeping patriarchal society running. We are violated and controlled by the closest people to us — our fathers, husbands, boyfriends, brothers. If male access to our domestic, sexual, reproductive and ideological servitude were eradicated, the world would turn upside down. This deep-seated, foundational control makes it near impossible for us to understand ourselves as a historically subjugated class, aided by the fact that mistrust is stoked between generations of women in order to prevent any continuity of feminist knowledge. Developing sisterhood in these circumstances is a tall order and requires not only an extensive awareness of the barriers between us, but also willingness to accept that conflict will necessarily arise out of our differences and complexities. As Sarah Schulman says in Conflict is Not Abuse, “Conflict, after all, is rooted in difference and people are and always will be different.”1
When some of us finally do manage to realize female friendship and feminist energy, the feeling is often euphoric. Suddenly we move from understanding our condition as an individual problem to something that is experienced by other women. In the 1970s consciousness raising circles amplified the message that, indeed, “the personal is political.” In other words, the possibility of sisterhood lies in coming to consciousness that our condition is not simply personal, it is political, and one should also add that it is global. Experiencing sisterhood for the first time is a feeling of belonging, of acceptance, of love. Not only does it provide reprieve from our subjugation, it is also a political necessity in advancing the feminist cause. Janice Raymond dubs female friendship as “Gyn/Affection” (as first coined by Mary Daly). She argues that the potential of female friendship lies in affecting, moving, stirring and arousing each other to full power, beyond the personal nature of these bonds, and towards a fuller understanding of the social and political powers we embody.
But with sisterhood also comes difficulty and conflict. When we come to understand the political significance of female friendship, and for whatever reason these friendships then disintegrate or splinter, the ensuing distress felt by feminists is a multiple of the pain felt when we are betrayed by men. Feminists expect hetero-relations to go awry (platonic, familial and romantic), and indeed any feminist framework recognizes the historical conflict of interest between men’s socio-political advantages and a feminist worldview. The cracks and fissures within female friendships, and most pertinently between feminists, challenge our core beliefs and experiences of the sisterhood we all seek to envision.
“Why can’t we just all get along?”
“We’re on the same side!”
“Infighting doesn’t help our cause.”
“I don’t have the energy for this anymore.”
But it is important to remember that conflict is at the heart of any political progress. Without conflict, political ideas would remain stagnant and inflexible, and personal growth would cease. Conflict should evoke interest from all members, not to avenge one particular person, but to grow and sustain the group as a whole. Well-expressed criticisms can lead to clarifying ideas and drawing out political issues instead of obscuring the underlying issues in a fog of personalizing and defensiveness.
One of the most fundamental texts that deals with political criticism is Gracie Lyon’s 1976 Constructive Criticism: A Handbook. It was a small-press bestseller aimed at providing tools for honest and productive disagreement, based on the premise that criticism is necessary for any political movement to enact fundamental change. Lyons lays the groundwork by arguing that within political groups,
the first mistake is to emphasize unity at all costs. People who fall into this position fail to make a correct distinction between allies and enemies, or between working-class and ruling-class ideology. As a result, they seek to smooth over differences. They think that any struggle is bad, instead of seeing the difference between principled struggle, which is necessary to advance the movement, and dogmatic factionalism. This position often springs from the fear that “someone might feel bad” if a struggle goes on, or from an opportunist desire to maintain a vague, unprincipled alliance. In either case, the fear of struggle usually boils down to the fear that things will be messy for me if the struggle gets hot. This kind of liberalism arises from narrow self-interest, from thinking about what is good for oneself or a small group, and not about what is good for the whole movement.4
Lyons outlines eight guidelines for engaging in constructive criticism, divided into “How to Do Criticism” and “How to Receive Criticism”:
HOW TO DO CRITICISM:
- Getting Your Head Together, or the Importance of Having Good Intentions: is my intention to protect and educate this person (or organization) to strengthen them for the class struggle, or is my intention to punish and coerce?6
- Being Concrete: separating subjective opinions from objective facts; in other words, I want to distinguish my inferences about people from the actions I saw that led me to my conclusion.7
- Describing Feelings: encouraging the disclosure of one’s own feelings before the criticism is shared, which helps me get a handle on my feelings, so they don’t go underground, outside my conscious control, where they could burst out in destructive ways.8 This also helps me to take responsibility for my own end of the contradiction, and thus avoids laying the blame entirely on the other person.9
- Stating Wants: say directly whom you want to do something, rather than leaving it vague. Specify concretely what you want the other person(s) to do or say, rather than what you want them to be or feel. Stress what you do want, rather than just what you don’t want.10
- Explaining the Purpose: relying not on punishment or bribery, but on education, education based on the dialectical conception that the process of change begins primarily with internal commitment.11
When you do A (observation), I feel B (emotion), and I want you to do C (action-want), because of D (purpose).12
HOW TO RECEIVE CRITICISM:
- Paraphrasing: paraphrasing someone’s criticism would assure both parties that their criticism was getting through in the way they intended it. It would also give them a chance to correct any misinterpretations that might have occurred.
- Empathizing: by disciplining myself to empathize, I was able to stop my knee-jerk defensive reaction. This counteracts a punitive dynamic; when someone feels heard, they’re less likely to escalate an attack, they’re more likely to listen in return.13
- Preventing and Handling Defensiveness: defensiveness originates not in resistance to the content of the criticism, but rather in resistance to what the receiver hears as the intent behind the criticism. When someone believes that a criticism is really a personal attack, demand, threat, or guilt-trip, defensiveness comes to the fore.14 If I believe that a defensive reaction is likely, I can draw attention to it by prefacing my criticism with words that try to head the problem off.
Instead of seeing struggle as bad, it can be understood as necessary to advance the movement and ideological thought. Conflict is not necessarily evidence of failure, but rather of a diverse, self-critical, and ever-evolving sisterhood. In the same vein, Helen Lewis argues in Difficult Women that “women’s history should not be a shallow hunt for heroines.”15 Not only does this flatten the complexities of women’s lives, it also erases the very conflicts that necessitated growth and change. Female alienation is produced when we are unable to foresee the horizontal animosity and hostility coming from other women themselves. When we are too wounded to be wounded again, it is enticing to surrender oneself to a nihilistic view about the movement, one which turns away from women in general. But, as Raymond argues: “the best that women can make of this is to know precisely that this behaviour will occur, face this knowledge head-on (but perhaps more importantly ‘heart-on’), and act in a more Gyn/affective way because of and in spite of this knowledge of the mind and heart.” 16 Perhaps most pertinently, she reminds us that friendship is an ongoing process of “repeated acts” — a habit which recurs “despite betrayals, ruptures, and disaffection from women.”17
And so, we continue to struggle. We struggle for a vision of female friendship, not one based on any essence of natural female vitality or nurturing, but a vision grounded in the “historical, cultural, and material bonds that women have created for our Selves in spite of the ‘State of Atrocity.’” Shallow sentimentalism about female friendships is both unrealistic if we are to mobilize women from all walks of life, as well as being the condition for disappointment: “to ground Gyn/affection in a natural capability of women to bond with each other is a false optimism that will betray itself.”19 To appreciate the obstacles we face in cultivating Gyn/affection is to recognize the profound transformative and political strength of female friendship with scrutiny and discipline. Perhaps this is the way forward in embodying strength across difference.
For more writing on feminist conflict, see “Mapping Second Wave Feminist Periodicals: Networks of Conflict and Counterpublics, 1970-1990” by Bec Wonders in Art Libraries Journal, 45.3 (2020), 106-13.
Bec Wonders is a feminist researcher in the field of feminist conflict, the Women’s Liberation Movement and feminist publishing networks at the Glasgow School of Art. She co-founded the Vancouver Women’s Library and currently runs Frauenkultur: an online archive of second wave feminist writing. Bec is also a freelance illustrator and printmaker. Her work can be found at becwonders.com
1 Sarah Schulman, Conflict Is Not Abuse (Vancouver: Arsenal Pulp Press, 2016), p. 20.
2 Janice G. Raymond, A Passion for Friends: Toward a Philosophy of Female Affection (Boston: Beacon Press, 1986), p. 197.
3 Mary Daly, Pure Lust: Elemental Feminist Philosophy (Boston: Beacon Press, 1984), p. 112.
4 Gracie Lyons, Constructive Criticism: A Handbook (Berkeley: Issues in Radical Therapy, 1976), p. 22.
5 Note that this is a shortened summary of Lyon’s guidelines and her full analysis should be read and understood carefully before implementing any conflict resolution strategies. Importantly it relies on in-person communication.
6 Lyons p. 37.
7 Lyons p. 42.
8 Lyons p. 51.
9 Notice that saying things like “I feel betrayed” or “I feel judged” is conveying what you think, not what you feel. If I think you are judging me, I might feel various ways — angry, or vulnerable, or hurt. Differentiating between feelings and thoughts is at the heart of this guideline.
10 Lyons p. 67.
11 Lyons p. 73.
12 Lyons p. 78.
13 Lyons p. 87.
14 Lyons p. 93.
15 Helen Lewis, Difficult Women: A History of Feminism in 11 Fights (London: Jonathan Cape, 2020), p. 3.
16 Raymond, p. 198.
17 Raymond, p. 199.
18 Raymond, p. 211.
19 Raymond, p. 211.
