by Dena Attar
In November 2020 Google used its landing page to promote and celebrate a company producing so-called chest binders, “garments used to flatten the chest.”1 In these extraordinary times of biology denial, young women are being encouraged to disguise their bodies, and are being persuaded to crush their breasts flat, at whatever (never to be mentioned) painful cost to their health and ability to breathe. It was bad enough for women and girls when our breasts were constantly judged, gazed at, fetishized, deemed too obscene to be shown, or depicted as easily replaceable by bags of silicone. Things are far worse now the media depicts breasts as unnecessary objects women and girls might reasonably want to get rid of, and there is wide promotion and acceptance of the damaging idea that young girls should be scared of developing breasts and encouraged to imagine themselves without them. The rationale that people born female can, for real, opt out of their own bodies in favour of a preferred alternative and can choose not to be or not to become women may well disturb those of us who have had mastectomies and already know that losing our breasts does nothing to change the fact that we are women.
Women who have had breast surgery as part of cancer treatment have been allotted non-speaking roles in the drama of gender transition. We are pointed at rhetorically to contrast the fears and anxieties of ill women having to wait for mastectomies with the frustrations about delay expressed by some would-be transitioners. It’s as if the main connection is one of competition over resources and who deserves them most. It is also suggested that women who have already lost their breasts through cancer are particularly if obscurely affected when we hear about medically unnecessary mastectomies.
I don’t object to having my experience indirectly invoked in such ways. I do feel intense distress and anger about those other losses. I don’t wish to emphasize or exaggerate any argument about resources, although I remember how fearful it was to hear about waiting times when I had a growing tumour. We are in truth connected groups of women, I would argue, both those whose breasts were removed in the cause of saving our lives and those others who wanted theirs removed in the process of renouncing their own female bodies. We are linked through the simple fact of a shared experience with lifelong permanent effects. We also have much else in common, whether we like it or not. We are all still female. The removal of our breasts does not change our sex. Beyond that, whether or not we ever intended to breastfeed or actually have breastfed an infant, losing breasts also means losing a bodily function. Keira Bell’s evidence in her case against the Tavistock and Portman NHS Trust included the purely factual statement that mastectomy had deprived her of the possibility of breastfeeding any future children. Breast removal is irreversible. Our female breasts are sensitive, changeable organs with milk ducts, and are not functionless appendages stuck on to women’s bodies for no purpose other than the possibly ornamental. As they are a part of us, we don’t feel them only from the outside. We experience how they change at different times of the month, how variously they react to hormones, temperature change and touch. Women who have ever breastfed know their breasts can react to a baby’s cry. Our breasts are an integral part of our female sexuality and physical knowledge of ourselves in the widest possible sense. Breasts cannot be replaced, whatever the charlatans advocating and profiteering from unnecessary irreversible surgeries have to say. So-called reconstruction is not like having a heart or kidney transplant. It is intended to fix appearance, but cannot fully restore a functional female breast.
As groups of women who apparently seem to be worlds apart, we may also, strangely, have a common desire to rid ourselves of our breasts — if only temporarily, and for our own distinct reasons. I first wrote about my own experience of cancer treatment while still recovering from surgery, and I tried to explore and understand my ambivalence. I felt I ought to mourn losing a breast together with its previous function, but alongside any regret I also felt profound relief. My body had already in some way gone wrong and the tumour was a threat to my existence.
Of course, there is still a huge difference between my experience and that of women who choose mastectomy when there isn’t such a threat. The greatest contrast is between those of us who, with whatever degree of unhappiness, accepted the need for mastectomies to stay alive but knew the value of what we had lost, and other women and girls who felt unable to value their breasts or even their female bodies. I’m still here and can appreciate living with the one and only body I will ever have, so those other losses seem sadder to me. I know I gained something. I know it was a necessary loss.
The normalization of a cruelly antagonistic attitude towards female bodies seems to have happened astonishingly fast from one perspective, but it has been a long time in the making. The sources now include not only the standard misogyny which is a constant, exhausting theme in our lives, but the more recent notion that allegedly non-female identities and appearances should be chosen and somehow or other acquired because they are self-evidently superior to low-status ordinary female bodies. There is also an avoidance of the material reality of our bodies from less obvious sources, ranging from outright denial to flinching away. In the aftermath of the judicial review into the Tavistock and Portman NHS Trust policies, one woman commented publicly that she disliked the reference to breastfeeding. She claimed it was oppressive in her view to be reminded that female breasts were functional, rather than being upset that a woman had lost that potential function after being led to make irrevocable decisions when far too young. But the fact that our breasts have evolved for the express and essential purpose of feeding human infants does not force any woman into motherhood or breastfeeding, and there is nothing inherently oppressive about referring to the realities of female bodies in a context where they clearly matter. We live in a social system designed to make femaleness oppressive, though femaleness itself is not.
There has been a strand of thought, even amongst feminists, that seeks to include some aspects of our bodily experiences while excluding others. A collection of articles published in 2000, Ideologies of Breast Cancer, focused on mastectomy, using a feminist analysis, in part, but was much more concerned with the language and imagery around breasts and mastectomy than with their physical realities.2 None of the authors had experienced breast cancer themselves. Their diverse accounts and critiques, under the two headings ‘Meanings’ and ‘Discourses,’ discussed environmental issues, campaigns, media representations, memoirs, and artworks by women with cancer, and their decision-making, including choosing reconstructive surgery or preventative mastectomy. The focus on language and ideas rather than bodies and experiences reflected the now tediously familiar idea of bodies as socially constructed, which was already considerably influential with academic writers, including some feminists, two decades ago. The authors were understandably wary of heroic or self-sacrificing images of women battling or nobly suffering disease, and critical of any connections between breasts and femininity or womanhood. But their critiques of how women with cancer themselves spoke or wrote, and of how others referred to them, left hardly any space for seeing any possible remaining impact of surgery. It was as if those myths mediated every woman’s experience to such an extent that she could not have any alternative or more direct responses to surgery.
My perhaps unfair impression was that the authors were unable to separate any depictions of our breasts and their loss, or even accounts of life-or-death decision-making about surgery, from everything about ‘femininity,’ ‘womanhood,’ conventional appearance or male-defined sexuality that we might want to keep our distance from and condemn. They were more interested in exploring and contesting ideas and language about the approved ‘femininity’ women are expected to display and maintain physically, which must be produced, disciplined, and properly maintained, rather than embracing unadorned, real female bodies of those women who had or feared having cancer. While that might be a justifiable goal for a collection of academic studies, there is a pervasive irony in critiquing the idea that breasts are signifiers of femininity while also assuming that what most affected women who underwent surgery lost were signifiers rather than functional parts of their bodies—as if abstract significance can obliterate experience and feeling.
In my reading of Ideologies, the only position seen as remaining free from such oppressive discourses, and perhaps even to be celebrated, was the defiance most boldly illustrated by scarred, breast-free torsos displayed in the style of Kathy Acker. The cover blurb quoted an extraordinary phrase from one article that seemed to capture a bizarre and toxic ideology of the breast itself. The phrase that jumped out at me was “maternalized breast,” presented as an ideological construct which required critique. Critiquing the sexualized breast, as the authors also did, was clearly reasonable, but I wondered how the term ‘maternalized breast’ could ever come to make sense. The concept that an association between the female breast and giving birth or feeding an infant is an ideological imposition is as bizarre as claiming that wombs or ovaries are unnecessarily ‘maternalized,’ as though they can be separated in any way from their reproductive functions. It’s as if thinking of breasts as functionless add-ons was so unremarkable that no one noticed it is an entirely weird assumption.
The shudder of ‘maternalized’ expresses a fear that biology itself could somehow diminish our humanity and autonomy, or that breastfeeding might be turned into an obligation imposed on us rather than simply an innate capacity of our female bodies. This is the same shudder that led to the comment that Keira Bell’s statement might have the unfortunate effect of making some other women feel uncomfortable. Possibly even when women are fully informed about how physically complex breasts are and how lactation is inseparable from human reproduction, many cannot politically tolerate the thought of what that means in case it gets turned to our disadvantage. These are not wholly unrealistic fears given that breastfeeding has had religious and quasi-medical strictures imposed on it in the past, and there are still many situations in which women don’t have reproductive control. Ideologies of Breast Cancer was political on some levels, attempting to pay attention to women’s experiences in the contexts of thoroughly unequal societies, but it completely avoided dealing with breasts having an actual function. The one connection to physical maternity, quite apart from accounts of women, who in various other respects prioritized their families over their own health, appeared fleetingly in that disparaging reference to ‘the maternalized breast.’
My account of my own cancer experience, a poem in five sections, is titled ‘The Common Cancer.’3 The first two sections are reproduced below. We speak of the common cold, and in everyday language the word ‘common’ does more than describe the frequency or familiarity of cold viruses. It puts colds in their place as minor illnesses. The term ‘common cancer’ calls attention to the high incidence of breast cancer but also tries to refuse it any elevated, remarkable status. In the first section I attempted to make sense of the unexpected euphoria I felt. I knew it was partly the relief of coming round after surgery, and while it was perhaps induced by painkilling drugs — before those brought on nausea — there was also joy in being alive and seeing family. Yet the lines also contradict the euphoria and relaxed normality, demanding that more is required. Something serious has happened and there is a loss and a history that must be acknowledged. Breastfeeding was not merely a metaphor but a past function. I saw the material reality of breasts and their function of being physically nurturing as linked to the abstract idea of humans as mutually caring and the concrete experience of being cared for as a patient. ‘Nursing’ is also used to refer to breastfeeding, and the overlap in language reflects what the activities have in common — a relationship and connection that seeks to preserve health and life. Becoming a dependent patient made me reflect on my role reversal and how I was no longer physically able to nurse.
The second section, ‘Marvels,’ recognizes the physical and mental ordeals and endurance of women with cancer and of mothers, and also of anyone whose everyday struggles against adversity are invisible — the “courage of ordinary life.” Breast cancer is overwhelmingly a disease of women and is the most common cancer in females in the UK. It occurs in one in seven women, and is extremely rare in men — in general affecting men over 60 when it does occur. While I was still in shock at receiving my diagnosis at a relatively young age for this disease and wanting to know why, a specialist nurse told me the most common reason for developing it was simply being female. It is not a single disease and it is not possible to identify any single cause for all its variants.
One unavoidable surgery was enough for me and I never wanted the option of further ‘reconstructive’ surgery. In the clinic at the time of my first prosthetic fitting, the huge number of women who have had mastectomies hit me with a shock, and I felt huge distress. I’d wondered if even a prosthesis was essential until I found how mastectomy would affect my shoulders, back, and entire posture. The breast care nurse took me into a room lined floor to ceiling with boxes of prostheses. I wanted to fall to the ground and weep at the sheer volume of women the boxes represented, their pain and loss.
The other flash of realization was that I had gone through a profound, permanent physical change and crossed suddenly to a new identity, joining a vast crowd of others who had done the same. We all know many other women who have undergone such transformational experiences involving hard effort and endurance which is often unseen, unnoticed, and unacknowledged. Mostly, they get on with life as best they can. They might be travelling to and from chemo or radiotherapy sessions on public transport alone, for instance, or be required back at work while still exhausted. They might still be the main carer in their household, and not a recipient of anyone else’s care. I thought myself lucky in comparison with many. That particular appreciative connection to other women was another long-lasting impact of mastectomy. Nobody seriously treats cancer like the common cold, but like childbirth, it doesn’t limit or define us, and many may not wish to consider ourselves victims or dwell on past experience of pain or loss. That might have to stay in the background while women get on with other stuff.
So, yes, those of us who unhappily needed mastectomies are likely to be distressed by celebratory hype around accounts of young women propelled through deceit, persuasion, or genuine self-loathing of their female bodies either to have healthy breasts removed or to painfully attempt to crush them into non-existence. It is atrocious and enraging that instead of being encouraged to courageously cope with reality, young people are celebrated for taking refuge in the artificiality of identity and for denying or even despising facts about their female bodies. Mastectomy can be lifesaving, can be survived, and most women do survive it. We may feel lucky to have been treated, all the while still regretting the need and the loss, but it is hardly a wonderful experience to be celebrated, as claimed by some of those caught up in the mindset of transitioning, or far worse, those who profit from it. There isn’t a single, right way to feel about mastectomy. Feelings change over time, and while I might still occasionally have moments of sadness about mine there are many more days when I never think about it. ‘The Common Cancer’ captured my feelings in the immediate aftermath. I tried to deal with the bodily experience I shared with so many other women as honestly as I could manage, without glorification, sentimentality, or tragedy.
THE COMMON CANCER
2. Marvels
I saw after first giving birth
That women are walking marvels.
Marvellously flat-bellied when they’re flat
And marvellously round when they are round.
For most are mothers, statistics say, yet they appear
With or without their children, everywhere
Bearing incredibly such knowledges
Of fear and pain, of crossing boundaries.
Walking, laughing, working, travelling
Every day everywhere around the world,
Carrying change forever, marked in skin,
In memory, in muscle and stretched mind.
I saw again, observing in corridors
And hospital waiting rooms: women are marvels.
The courage of ordinary life
revealed itself, invisible before.
I learned a new statistic: not most women
But one in ten, one woman in eleven
Or even one in eight, meets this disease.
Women with fears and scars, with histories,
Walking around, at work, on buses, joking,
Pick up round lives or flat, their kids, the shopping,
Carrying this and bearing up; they treat
The common cancer like the common cold.
Dena Attar has been writing about feminism and researching women’s and girls’ education since the 1980s and thinks this is no time to quit.
