Issue Four

Would Twitter Ban Engels?

by Rachel Broady

Editors’ Note: An earlier version of this article was written as an academic paper intended for a journal celebrating 200 years of Engelsist thinking. It was withdrawn by the author before publication when the subject matter and research was described as ‘highly controversial’ by the journal editors. It has been shortened and edited for THE RADICAL NOTION.

Would Twitter ban Friedrich Engels? In light of the many prominent accounts punished by the social media platform for discussing female sex-based rights, it’s a question worth asking. I sought to explore this question by analysing accounts that were limited or suspended for breaching Twitter rules by referring to sex-based power inequalities, and linking them with Engels’s writings on the oppression of women under capitalism. The results, I think, are revealing.

WHAT DID ENGELS CONTRIBUTE TO FEMINIST THEORY?

Engels saw nothing natural in the oppression of women. He recognized that women as a sex class were historically subjected to domination by the male, as part of the capitalist exploitation of the means of existence and reproduction. We’ve recently seen celebrations of 200 years of Engels’s thinking, which has been enormously influential on leftist parties and politics. But significantly, many publications on the British left that wrote about his centuries-long influence ignored his contribution to feminism. A Socialist Worker article said Engels wrote of the horrific conditions endured by workers; of course he did, but he was consistently specific about the particular burdens of women workers. Socialist Appeal, in their celebration of Engels, did not mention women at all. The socialist group Workers’ Liberty wrote only briefly of his advocacy of women’s rights. Despite left-leaning groups and publications currently failing to acknowledge it, Engels’s contribution to feminist debate cannot be overstated. Engels saw an end to the exploitation of women as central to a socialist future. In this world, he said, there would be

a generation of men who never in their lives have known what it is to buy a woman’s surrender with money or any other social instrument of power, a generation of women who have never known what it is to give themselves to a man from any other consideration than real love or to refuse to give themselves to their lover from fear of the economic consequences.1

Engels’s writings consistently denounced women’s oppression and, especially in The Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State, set out the system by which this subjugation developed to suit the needs of capitalism. He wrote of the experiences of female mill workers, of the oppression of bourgeois and proletarian women under monogamy, of the exploitation of prostitution, the damage certain types of work did to female bodies, the different sexual standards for men and women, women’s lack of community childcare, and the impact of motherhood, among other topics. Engels advocated for women’s rights to condemn sexual harassment, and for women’s access to childcare; he highlighted women’s low pay, and challenged the exploitation of female workers and their exclusion from unions. His work remains a common reference point in feminist discussions about the origins of women’s subordination.

Engels provided an early challenge to the idea of women’s oppression being natural and universal. As professor Janet Sayers asserts, his writings were “virtually the only account within Marxism of relations between sexes and the possible means of uniting the struggle for social advance with sexual emancipation.”2 His work is further described by Paul Blackledge as “remaining a fundamental resource for anyone wanting to understand the oppression of women as a capitalist form.”3

FEMINISM AND TWITTER

Twitter was created and founded by four men in San Francisco in 2006, among them Jack Dorsey, who remains its CEO. Over the last decade and a half, Twitter has become central to political discourse and activism, including as a valuable venue for feminists. The global hashtag trend #MeToo is perhaps Twitter’s most famous feminist engagement. Started by Tarana Burke, an American actress and activist, to challenge male power and sexual harassment in the workplace, it reportedly resulted in 19 million tweets and spawned a global movement. Similarly, #EverydaySexism was started in June 2014, by a British project of the same name, collecting women’s experiences of being sexually harassed.

Twitter presents itself as a public sphere, and one of diversity and free speech. But Twitter’s initial emphasis on unrestricted expression also made it a site where misogyny, threats, and harassment flourished. A study by Amnesty International concluded that the violence and abuse many women experience on Twitter can lead to them self-censoring or being driven off the platform entirely.4 Even British female MPs have been subjected to misogynistic abuse: Stella Creasy condemned Twitter’s inadequate response to rape threats, and Jess Phillips called for an end to account anonymity after receiving 600 rape threats in a single night.5 In response to increasing criticism, Twitter began strengthening and enforcing its policy against ‘hateful conduct,’ adding a ‘report abuse’ button in 2013 and, starting in 2015, adding increasing rules aimed at restricting harassment and threats on the basis of certain characteristics.6

Significantly, Twitter’s hateful conduct policy, which lays out the grounds for restricting and banning accounts, defends ‘gender’ and ‘gender identity’ (both of which are undefined) but does not list ‘sex’ as a protected characteristic. It does, however, list ‘sexist tropes’ along with ‘content that degrades someone.’ Yet sex is a protected characteristic in many countries, including in UK equality law. Twitter states:

You may not promote violence against or directly attack or threaten other people on the basis of race, ethnicity, national origin, caste, sexual orientation, gender, gender identity, religious affiliation, age, disability, or serious disease.7

In opting to exclude sex as a characteristic, Twitter naturalizes the exclusion of sex-based oppression from political discourse. This policy has allowed misogyny to adapt, with many women’s accounts being targeted for ‘hateful conduct’ for prioritizing female interests and questioning aspects of activism related to gender identity. The BBC reported in 2018 that ‘Twitter bans women against trans ideology, say feminists’ and Fair Play for Women declared Twitter’s policies “a concerted attack on women’s free speech.” 8  Two prominent accounts were suspended simply for posting the phrase “men aren’t women tho” — the Canadian feminist Meghan Murphy, in 2018, and Father Ted writer Graham Linehan, who repeated the phrase, in 2020. Twitter decisions of what constitutes ‘hate’ can appear arbitrary. The hashtag #RIPJKRowling trended in mid-September 2020 when it was misleadingly reported that the author’s latest novel was about a cross-dressing serial killer. The RIP hashtag prompted the New York Post to ask ‘Is J. K. Rowling dead?’ However, three weeks later, following tweets apparently wishing US President Trump would die of COVID-19, Twitter reminded its users, “Tweets that wish or hope for death, serious bodily harm or fatal disease against anyone are not allowed and will need to be removed.”

Twitter, as a company, takes conscious political positions, for its users and for its shareholders. Dorsey, its CEO, publicly shares his political thoughts, and has claimed the platform has a “left-leaning bias.” Twitter’s ownership priorities mean it chooses which speech to censor and label as hate; it can exclude voices that deviate with unacceptable content. It outlines the rationale behind its “hateful conduct policy” as a “mission”:

to give everyone the power to create and share ideas and information, and to express their opinions and beliefs without barriers. Free expression is a human right — we believe that everyone has a voice, and the right to use it. Our role is to serve the public conversation, which requires representation of a diverse range of perspectives.9

Twitter, then, claims to be protecting free expression and diverse perspectives by restricting what they deem ‘hateful conduct.’ But in practice, the site has often restricted diverse expression by prioritizing one form of feminism — a neoliberal, identity-centred feminism that is arguably the current dominant mainstream framework and certainly the most apparent on social media — and by restricting a more materialist, Marxist feminism that focuses on the shared experience of female bodies. It is apparent the latter feminist approach is less welcome than conversations that consider individualist identity and the idea of woman being discursively constructed.

Digital feminism emerged right alongside the growing hegemony of neoliberalism, privileging individual choice over challenging social structures. This type of feminism can be described as hyper-individualistic, encouraging women to perceive themselves as human capital which, in turn, is of value to Twitter in creating a user-generated ‘prosumerism’ (the involvement of customers in the production process). As such, it has abandoned key feminist terms such as liberation and social justice.

Engels demystified sexism by revealing it to be a class relationship between the sexes, just as racism is a class relationship between races. As Martha Gimenez argued in 1987, the idea of discursive construction—prioritizing language over material reality around gender, sexuality, and the human body—seems to have severed the links between Marx’s work, feminist theory, and women’s liberation.10

@ENGELS

For Engels, women’s liberation and socialism are inseparable; he recognized the political significance of biological sex to female oppression and its roots in class exploitation. He asserted that “the inequality of the sexes was one of the first antagonisms within the species” and that it coincides with the development of monogamous marriage. But today, how would these views fit within Twitter’s acceptance of the neoliberal feminist approach, which prioritizes liberal status equalization, and its side-lining of sex-based exploitation? Could @Engels on Twitter survive?

To consider this question, I sourced 48 tweets between 25 March 2018 and 7 September 2020 via the account @sambarber1910, which has collated a list of tweets punished by account restriction or suspension during the time period. As all tweets must be deleted as part of any punishment, this sample relies upon only those with screenshots of the original tweets. Each tweet in the sample contains the following warning from Twitter for accounts that have been suspended (that is, closed) or locked (meaning temporarily restricted):

We have determined that this account violated the Twitter rules. Specifically, for: Violating our rules against hateful conduct. You may not promote violence against, threaten, or harass other people on the basis of race, ethnicity, national origin, sexual orientation, gender, gender identity, religious affiliation, age, disability, or serious disease.

I found that the tweets could be divided into two categories: (i) identifying male violence and male domination, and (ii) mentioning sex. Each subject can correlate to a position put by Engels. Excerpts from Engels’s writing in The Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State and The Condition of the Working Class in England are used for direct comparison.

MALE VIOLENCE AND MALE DOMINATION

The first tweet from the sample asserts a recognition of the global predominance of male violence. It reads:
We need to talk about male violence. Males kill trans women. Males kill women. Most killers are male. (25 March 2018)
This tweet does not appear to breach the policy as outlined. It does not “promote violence against, threaten, or harass other people on the basis of race, ethnicity, national origin, sexual orientation, gender, gender identity, religious affiliation, age, disability, or serious disease” (unless Twitter would somehow claim that identifying male-pattern violence is threatening to males as a ‘gender’). It does not even suggest that trans women are male. The desire here is to talk about the global phenomenon of male violence. In 2017, there were an estimated 464,000 homicide deaths worldwide; about 90% of those recorded were perpetrated by men.11 Mass killings have been increasing since the 1970s, with over 350 incidents of mass violence (defined as having four or more victims) between 2006 and 2017 in the US alone, almost one every two weeks: all the perpetrators have been men.12 A United Nations study revealed that around the world, six women are killed by men every hour, mostly by their male partners or family members.13 By citing these statistics, I don’t intend to present them as unworthy of challenge or debate but to highlight Twitter’s decision to conclude that the very act of discussing male violence on its platform is punishable. Discussing male violence is not a ‘hateful’ topic. These discussions are had within charitable organizations, feminist groups, parliamentary debates — and yet Twitter classes them as breaching its policy. If they do in fact breach its policy, users deserve an explanation of why, and how a policy can be justified that deters women from discussing male violence. How does this relate, then, to Engels and his potential contribution? After all, Engels discussed male violence, including the way male violence was assumed as a husband’s right:
In order to make certain of the wife’s fidelity and therefore the paternity of the children, she is delivered over unconditionally into the power of the husband; if he kills her, he is only exercising his rights.14
Twitter’s assertion that accounts breaching its hate policy have threatened, harassed, or promoted violence against certain groups seems unreliable and arbitrarily applied, as is revealed by these tweets restricted by the platform:
It is not about the individual, it is about the class of people. My male partner is no risk to women, yet he understands and accepts the right of women to exclude him from their spaces because of those members of his sex class who DO pose a risk. (24 October 2019)
All rapists are men. In UK law, rape is a crime committed by a person with a penis. (17 November 2018)
This — if men didn’t keep beating, raping and killing women, I wouldn’t be so uncomfortable with them in women’s toilets. (22 September 2019)
Men are the main perpetrators of rape and violence. Trans women are potential rapists and killers just as other men are. (29 August 2018)
Women cannot rape. Men rape. You need a penis to penetrate an orifice under UK law. (undated)
If they could stop assaulting, raping and murdering us that would be a great start. (undated)
Over 80% of violent crime and 99% of sexual assaults are committed by males. (18 October 2018)
Here, the discussion considers UK law, which under the Sexual Offences Act 2003 classifies rape as an act in which “he [the accused] intentionally penetrates the vagina, anus or mouth … with his penis.” In this context, rape is a crime that can only be committed by those of the male sex. If a trans woman retains their penis and commits a sexual assault this would be rape under UK law. Thus a recognition of females as a sex class and a discussion of the factual basis of UK law are restricted by the platform. Sexual violence and male dominance are indivisible in Engels’s analysis. In The Conditions of the Working Class in England, Engels acknowledged the sexual exploitation women endured in English mills, writing:
If the master is mean enough, and the official report mentions several such cases, the mill is also his harem; and the fact that not all manufacturers use their power does not in the least change the position of the girls.15
Engels here is alluding to the rape of young women in the mills. He concerned himself with the workplace and its impact on women’s lives; he talks further of the threat of being sacked forcing young women to succumb to the sexual advances of their employers. Engels also wrote of the “brutality of women which became firmly rooted in the establishment of monogamy,” the first site of male domination.16 For Engels, this submission of women began with the redistribution of division of domestic labour and property between man and wife and, where the woman had previously held power in the domestic sphere, her labour lost significance. This surrender of women is an historical event:
The first division of labour is that between man and woman for child breeding. And today I can add: The first class antagonism which appears in history coincides with the development of the antagonism between man and woman in monogamian marriage, and the first class oppression with that of the female sex by the male.17

Engels unambiguously recognized the way male dominance emerged through patriarchy, monogamy, and the family. This suggestion of male dominance, however, and the recognition of females as a class oppressed by males, may be punishable on Twitter, as revealed in the following tweets:

It is amazing you think you know what it is to be female. The sheer male audacity. (21 July 2019)
Males don’t get to tell females what feminism is, especially when your goal is to centre men in it. (9 February 2019)
Biological/natal males who cannot take NO for an answer and don’t understand consent with their definitely male genitalia. (8 November 2018)
I wonder if it’s male pattern behaviour marking out and claiming territory. (24 October 2019)

In Origin, Engels further writes of the “surrender of the female slave” (p. 95), of the “exploitation of women,” of women “forced into second place” (p. 199) and how “men had gained the victory over women” (p. 200), with the “modern individual family … founded on the open or concealed domestic slavery of the wife” (p. 200). In Conditions, he focuses on the particular exploitation of teenage females as being “absolutely the slaves of their employers” (p. 235), writing:

these unfortunate girls are kept by the means of the moral whip of the modern slave-driver, the threat of discharge, to such long and unbroken toil as no strong man, much less a delicate girl of fourteen to twenty years, can endure.18

If discussions of “male audacity” and “male genitalia” and a determination to centre females in feminism can see an account restricted for breaching the platform’s hate policy, it is fair to wonder what would happen if Engels were on Twitter today discussing patriarchy, male domination, and the exploitation of women by men—understood as sex classes.

SEX

Engels recognized the domination of the female sex as an historical event, which was in part determined by biology. He wrote that the change in women’s status — their being forced into “second place” by the division of labour — arose from the interaction of the biological needs of reproduction and the changing social relations of production: the monogamous family could not develop without the monitoring of females as producers of heirs and of labour. Perhaps the most striking example of Twitter prioritizing identity-based politics over a materialist feminism that recognizes biology is in the censure of the following tweets referring to sexed bodies, one replying to an account identified as being a trans woman and one to an account identified as a trans man; all were punished:
It’s different definitions of ‘woman’. Mine is sex-based, yours is GI [gender identity] based. According to mine, I’m a woman and you are not (simple biology, says nothing about personality, gender expression or feelings). According to yours, you are a woman, but I’m not a woman. (9 August 2019)
I’m sorry you aren’t male and transwomen aren’t female. I genuinely have no wish to hurt your feelings. But you are trans, not male and that should be okay, something you should be able to feel proud of. (5 May 2019)
But I was specific: if a trans woman (male) and myself had unprotected sex with a man (male) who is likely to get pregnant? The answer is me because a trans woman produces small gametes and cannot get pregnant. (undated)
These tweets, perhaps unlike others in the sample, are difficult to perceive as intentionally rude or cruel. Although some might consider it cruel to name the reality of sex, these conversations are engaging in questions about identity while going to some pains to be polite. Nevertheless, this discussion of the experience of the female sex — of pregnancy in one tweet — is considered to breach Twitter’s hate policy. Lise Vogel is right in stating that for Engels “the social superiority that men enjoy over women under patriarchy is not an internal, biological phenomenon but is rather the product of a certain stage of economic development.”19 However, Engels was aware of the unique experience of female biology — of women’s sex — and of the personal and political significance of it. In Conditions, Engels wrote about the specific experience of women working in mills and this labour’s effects on their bodies. He wrote that the “disordered functions of the uterus are almost universal among the girls” working in mills (p. 219). He described women suffering from “all manner of disorders in the development of the female organism” (p. 236). He quoted a testimony of working women in which it is described: “My breasts have given me the most frightful pain and I have been dripping wet with milk” (p. 172). He wrote of the health of female lace makers being “constantly and deeply undermined” with complaints of anaemia, difficult childbirth, and miscarriage (p. 220). Engels did not avoid discussing the experience of females, uniquely subjugated, oppressed, and persecuted because of their sex.
Such commentary, however, might be banished from Twitter if used to highlight issues that affect women due to biology rather than identity. An example of another tweet punished in this category reads:
Only females get cervical cancer. (7 September 2020)
Further, Engels’s translated writings refer to “the female sex,” “the male sex,” “both sexes,” to “female parent,” “female slave,” “female labour.” Arguably, such statements could now be restricted on Twitter, where gender identity is prioritized over sex to the extent that sex is not a protected characteristic in the platform’s policy. Sex is not even allowed to be identified if it conflicts with gender identity. The recognition of the difference between the male and female experience, and specifically of sexed bodies, saw the following eight tweets punished:
Men aren’t women tho [sic]. (11 October 2018)
How are transwomen not men? What is the difference between a man and a trans woman? (15 October 2018)
Penis present? Not a woman. (21 August 2018)
If you have a penis, you cannot be female. (undated)
Women do not have a penis. (undated)
No, absolutely no woman has a penis and testicles, you’re thinking of a transwoman. (undated)

TWITTER WOULD BAN ENGELS

 

Twitter is a dominant part of contemporary social production, and its casting out of socialist feminist positions from its permitted discourse affects mostly women. Twitter’s seeming prioritization of ‘woman’ as a discursive construct rather than a biological reality means that public digital debate about male violence, male domination, and sex is suppressed. Twitter is using its commercial and social power to shape and dominate feminist discourse. It is labelling one feminist approach as “hateful,” positioning it in debate as abuse to be censured. Its rationale states that punished tweets are those “motivated by hatred, prejudice or intolerance … that seeks to silence the voices of those who have been historically marginalised.” But by failing to include ‘sex’ in its protected characteristics, Twitter leaves women open to abuse based on their sex while at the same time making discussion of women’s sex-based oppression open to accusations of hatred, prejudice, and intolerance. This inequality in digital discussion is, as Engels noted in relation to marriage, “a legacy of previous social conditions and is not the cause but the effect of the economic oppression of women.”20

The silencing of socialist feminism entrenches an egalitarian and identitarian approach to feminism and punishes a materialist — and Engelsist — one. To quote Engels, as he discusses the contradictions of monogamy and sexual freedom, it is women who lose out:

they are ostracized and cast out in order to proclaim once again the absolute domination of the male over the female sex as the fundamental law of society.21

Twitter, as a public forum of debate and a commercial organization, actively uses policy to punish the materialist feminist approach, and even labels such discussion as “hate speech.” Labelling materialist feminism as “hate” has become naturalized, with challenges to it demonized: as such, it is a form of ideological control. Twitter is defending neoliberal, pro-capitalist feminism: one that seeks to negate materialism and prioritize discursive challenges to the oppression of women. Under this feminism, the women Engels encountered would not be free from oppression but would be individualized, seen as having opportunities to be on a par with the male mill owner. That would be women’s equality. It is a feminism that would see the mill owners Engels described merely replaced by female bosses exploiting the working class. That would be her emancipation. The success of these female mill owners would depend on their contribution to maintaining the status quo, not challenging it. It is a feminism, then, that suits the aims of capitalism and corporations.

As such, Engels’s position would be the wrong one in the Twittersphere, and his analysis of women’s oppression would likely fall foul of Twitter’s moderation for prioritizing materialism over identity. Through account restriction and termination, the ‘wrongness’ of his position would be naturalized among the site’s millions of daily users. It is doubtful that @Engels would survive.

Rachel Broady is a lecturer in Media, Culture, Communication at Liverpool John Moores University. Her research focus is on class, in particular the representations of poverty in news media.

1 Friedrich Engels, The Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State (New York, NY: Pathfinder, 1972), p. 112.

2 Janet Sayers, Mary Evans, and Nanekke Redclift, eds., Engels Revisited: New Feminist Essays (Oxon: Routledge, 2009), p. 2.

3 Paul Blackledge, ‘Frederick Engels, Social Reproduction, and the Problem of a Unitary Theory of Women’s Oppression,’ Social Theory and Practice, 44.3 (2018), 297-321.

4 Amnesty International, ‘Toxic Twitter—A Toxic Place for Women,’ 2018.

5 Stella Creasy, 2013. ‘Twitter’s inadequate action over rape threats is in itself abuse,’ The Guardian, 27 July 2013; Kevin Rawlinson, ‘Labour MP calls for end to online anonymity after “600 rape threats,”’ The Guardian, 11 June 2018.

6 Sarah Jeong, ‘The history of Twitter’s rules,’ Vice, 2016

7 Twitter, ‘Hateful conduct policy,’ accessed on 9 July 2021.

8 BBC News, ‘Twitter bans women against trans ideology, say feminists,’ 30 May 2018.

9 Twitter, ‘Hateful conduct policy.’

10 Martha Gimenez, ‘Marxist and Non-Marxist Elements in Engels’s Views on the Oppression of Women’ in Engels Revisited, ed. by Janet Sayers, Mary Evans, and Nanneke Redclift (London: Tavistock Publications, 1987), p. 13.

11 United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime, ‘Global study on homicide, 2019 edition.’

12 USA Today, ‘Behind the bloodshed: The untold story of America’s mass killings.’

13 Douglas Broom, ‘As the UK publishes its first census of women killed by men, here’s a global look at the problem,’ World Economic Forum, 25 November 2020.

14 Engels, Origin, p. 132.

15 Friedrich Engels, The Condition of the Working Class in England (Herts: Granada Publishing, 1979), p. 177.

16 Engels, Origin, p. 101.

17 Engels, Origin, p. 720.

18 Engels, Condition, p. 236.

19 Lise Vogel, Engels Today: A Centenary Appreciation (London: Macmillan, 1996), p. 121.

20 Engels, Origin, p. 102.

21 Engels, Origin, p. 95.