by Esmée Streachailt (unabridged)
“Like anything that has general popular support, the critics are grasping at straws and are trying to make an emotional and fear-based argument against the constitutional equality of women.”
— State Rep. Abigail Spanberger, Virginia Democrat, Hearing on the Ratification of the ERA, 2019
“What’s the most common word in the English language that does not appear anywhere in the U.S. Constitution? The answer is a revealing one: she.”
— Garrett Epps, for The Atlantic
WHAT EVEN ARE RIGHTS?
US rights movements are met with a lot of resistance. This makes basic and inalienable rights so difficult to secure that they feel like Magnificent Human Flourishing.
Rights are not as rare as self-actualization. Rights don’t make us stunning and brave. Rights just create the civil ‘space’ where we might self-actualize.
Rights are boundaries of a kind. They do not describe people, they describe what governments, corporations, employers, civil institutions, and other people can do to people and what they cannot do while escaping any negative consequences.
Rights are basic. Rights are ground. Rights enable. Rights are material elements of economic and civic, and some social, life that a government is responsible for defending on behalf of its people. They are shared among us all, equally. Rights subtend higher, more parochial, or personal development and elaboration of ambition, community, identity, self-hood, talent, or vocation.
The rights protected by the amendments in the Bill of Rights are material:
-
- Freedom of religion, speech, press, assembly, and petition.
- Right to keep and bear arms in order to maintain a well-regulated militia.
- No quartering of soldiers.
- Freedom from unreasonable searches and seizures.
- Right to due process of law, freedom from self-incrimination, double jeopardy.
- Rights of accused persons, e.g. right to a speedy and public trial.
- Right of trial by jury in civil cases.
- Freedom from excessive bail, cruel and unusual punishments.
- Other rights of the people.
- Powers reserved to the states.
These are not as clear-cut as they seem, as much jurisprudence attests. But, generally, rights one through nine applied to white, land-owning, men. These rights were designed by a newly post-colonial ruling class to prevent the kinds of tyranny they suffered under the British colonial regime, providing white-landed-men with the ‘space’ to elaborate their life projects, their pursuit of happiness (figuratively, and geographically to our shame).
Women. Enslaved people. Indigenous people. These did not have freedom of speech, due process of law, the right not to testify against themselves. Women had the access to these rights allowed by the whims of their male guardians. Peoples of colour had no access to these rights. These groups, and especially women, have a patchwork of rights built up of various laws and court decisions interpreting the law, and every one of them might be suspended by new law. What’s happening in the struggle between Roe v. Wade and the Texas ‘Bounty on Abortion’ law is a case in point.
The 14th Amendment (A14) extended these rights to formerly enslaved black men under the ‘equal protection clause’ after the Civil War. All women were deliberately excluded from this equal protection until the Supreme Court decision in Reed v. Reed which extended equal protection to women in 1971. 1971. My mother gave birth to my brother in 1971, which means that until she was 28 years old, she did not share in the equal protection of the US Constitution. The ERA would cement this protection, and it would be handy indeed given the challenges of a newly hard-conservative Court and incursions from the authoritarian left.
The Civil Rights Act of 1964 protects the following material elements of life in its titles (titles are elements of an act):
-
- Voting Rights.
- Public Accommodations.
- Desegregation of Public Facilities.
- Desegregation of Public Education.
- Civil Rights Commission.
- Non-discrimination in Federally Assisted Programs
a) Prohibited discrimination by recipients of federal funds on the basis of race, colour, and national origin. - Equal Employment Opportunity.
a) Outlawed employment discrimination by businesses affecting commerce with at least 25 employees on the basis of race, colour, religion, sex, or national origin and created the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. - Registration and Voting Statistics.
- Intervention in Court Cases.
a) Permitted the United States to intervene in pending suits alleging a denial of equal protection of law under the 14th Amendment to the United States Constitution on account of race, colour, religion, or national origin (Reed v. Reed protects women under this title and A14). - Community Relations Service.
- Court Proceedings and Legalities.1
The Civil Rights Act of 1964 prohibited discrimination based on race, religion, color, or national origin in public places, schools, and employment. However, discrimination based on sex was not initially included in the proposed bill and was only added as an amendment in Title VII to prevent its passage.
Congressman Howard Smith (D-VA), Chairman of the Rules Committee and a staunch opponent of civil rights, had let the bill (H.R. 7152) go to the full House only under the threat of a discharge petition. During the floor debate, he offered an amendment that added sex to the four original categories, but only in Title VII (equal employment opportunity). Although Smith had supported the idea of an Equal Rights Amendment for women for nearly 20 years at that point, his amendment to the civil rights bill was likely intended to kill the measure.2 (emphasis mine)
The mostly male-controlled US Congress always loaded the dice against extending the mantle of humanity. Rights may not be pie, but they portion out material benefits and deficits. In our rights discourse, rights are ‘won’ and ‘lost’ and ‘suppressed’ like territory because they are enacted in a material world. As we are learning all over America while COVID-19 rages on, you might have the right to care when you are hurt or sick or pregnant, but access to that care is very much a limited resource. Rights are not pie, resources are. The ERA would prevent politicians from any further empty virtue signalling or assumption of women’s support or using our issues as bargaining chips in other business.
What we often refer to as ‘Title IX’ is a title of the Education Amendments of 1972 to the Higher Education Act of 1965 which strengthened the educational resources of our colleges and universities and to provide financial assistance for students in postsecondary and higher education. Basically, the Higher Education Act of 1965 created the modern US system of higher education as part of President Johnson’s Great Society Doctrine. The amendments passed in 1972, signed into law by President Nixon, mostly expanded and reinforced the 1965 law. It covers things like funding for building academic facilities and the rules for grants and loans to students and researchers. Very administrative, and not very much focused on rights. Title IX of this act established The Prohibition of Sex Discrimination, and states:
No person in the United States shall, on the basis of sex, be excluded from participation in, be denied the benefits of, or be subjected to discrimination under any education program or activity receiving Federal financial assistance.
Women’s right to education, protected for men of colour under the Civil Rights Act, is a title in an amendment to an education act that did not originally include women. It gives women access to rights men have, but none of our own. And remember, when we refer to ‘Title IX,’ we refer to a right that is not mentioned in the Civil Rights Act even though sex is a less alienable (changeable or removable) trait than religion. Women’s equality is not explicit outside of suffrage, employment, and education. So, even in these most basic elements of legal personhood, women are an afterthought, our life projects unimaginable. 15A conferred women citizenship (along with every other person born on US soil), but not equality. The ground on which we are to elaborate our life projects is softer and more given to drift than men’s grounds. We feel this as American women as we fight the same damn fights over and over again. So many equal pay acts, so many sexual harassment cases. In the US, women have no positively articulated sex-based rights.3
An aside: for a sense of the depth of commitment the US has shown to women’s rights, consider this. Clarence Thomas was the head of the Equal Employment and Opportunity Commission (1982-90) established by Title VII, charged with women’s employment protections, and in that job he was sexually harassing Anita Hill. Then, despite her hesitancy and courage to testify before an all-male Judiciary Committee, Thomas was confirmed to the Supreme Court in the face of this clear perversion of his responsibilities. The double-layered scandal was swept away with Thomas’s protests of “an electronic lynching” and easy clichés about women’s sensitivity, hysteria, and vanity: ‘Hill fantasized that Thomas was attracted to her, and besides she was not pretty enough to harass.’4 Thomas was merely part of a tradition of faux-commitment. In the five years after the passage of the Civil Rights Act and the establishment of the EEOC, “it received 50,000 sex discrimination complaints. But it was quickly obvious that the commission was not keen to pursue these complaints.”5 The National Organization for Women (NOW) took up the problem in 1977 and “argued the issue [actually enforcing the law, that is] all the way to the Supreme Court to make it possible for a woman today to hold any job for which she is qualified” and eliminate classifying employment listings by sex.6
WHAT IS THE ERA?
The Equal Rights Amendment (28A) consists of three (3) sentences, written by Alice Paul and introduced into Congress in 1923.7
Section 1: Equality of rights under the law shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any state on account of sex.
Section 2: The Congress shall have the power to enforce, by appropriate legislation, the provisions of this article.
Section 3: This amendment shall take effect two years after the date of ratification.8
The purpose of the ERA (28A) is to secure inalienable rights for women by forbidding the withdrawal of rights because we are female. It’s meant to do this in the same way that A15 does with race, and the Civil Rights Act does with race, colour, religion, and national origin. By establishing the legal equality of women in the Constitution, the ERA would only strengthen these earlier civil rights codes by explicitly extending their franchise to the women of all races, colours, religions, and nations of origin.
14A and 15A did not address women as persons in our own right. Our absence was debated publicly by many, including Elizabeth Cady Stanton, Lucy Stone, and Frederick Douglass (who argued against votes for women). Then as now, the tensions between sex and race were deeply fraught. Black men won the vote, rightfully, and Cady Stanton predicted votes for women would take a century longer. As women’s suffrage was won in the throes of Reconstruction and Jim Crow, it did take several more decades (during which riots of angry white people destroyed several black cities and many hundreds of lives in the US: Rosewood, FL, East St. Louis, IL, and Tulsa, OK, among them).9 Regarding the vote, many states placed conditions on voting, arguing under ‘states’ rights’:
to circumvent the Constitution and prevent blacks from voting. Poll taxes, literacy tests, fraud, and intimidation all turned African Americans away from the polls. Until the Supreme Court struck it down in 1915, many states used the ‘grandfather clause’ to keep descendants of slaves out of elections. The clause said you could not vote unless your grandfather had voted — an impossibility for most people whose ancestors were slaves.10
The point of the amendment is to write all women into the Constitution as full and equal citizens to men for purposes of law, rather than the precarious access to our rights we have now depending on the state we live in, the current executive administration and its desire to enforce these rights, or the vagaries of the judicial system and whether we can afford an attorney to sue when they are abrogated. It is meant to create unobstructed access to education, employment, housing, etc. It would effectively protect women as a class. 28A has nothing to say about identity, as identity has nothing to do with rights.
AMENDMENTS VS. ACTS
The ERA’s only consistent champion was Senator Martha Griffiths, and the ERA had little support for about 40 years. As the Johnson administration waffled on sex-based rights in the Civil Rights Act, US feminists returned attention to the Equal Rights Amendment.11 Part and parcel with the early radical Women’s Liberation Movement, the ERA was met with the same fierce resistance.12 In 1972, the ERA finally passed both houses of Congress (the vote 354-23 in the House) and went to the states for ratification.13 Constitutional amendments must work through both houses of each state’s general assembly (state-level houses of representatives and senates) until 38 of the 50 states have ratified the bill. This process assures a ‘measured’ rate of historical change and extra-double-plus endorsement by the people, which we need because of the states’ rights enshrined in 10A in the Bill of Rights. At 38 state ratifications, the bill is considered ratified and published into the Constitution, where it cannot be replaced by new law (other than another ratified amendment), overruled in court decisions, or left to languish.
An amendment can be qualified but not removed or overturned. An amendment establishes a kind of legal ground. An act (or regular law) tends to define what can be done (enacted) on the ground created by amendments. Acts do not have the force or durability of a constitutional amendment and must be reaffirmed by Congress periodically to stay on the books or continue funding. Enforcement of acts has more to do with politics than ‘facts of law’ and the nature of each executive administration, and acts can be superseded by new law as well as contested in federal court.
In this way, the changes in language proposed by the Equality Act would affect all previous civil rights laws, overwriting them. That is the purpose of the bill.
The Violence Against Women Act (VAWA), for example, recently found itself on hiatus, captive on then-majority-leader Senator McConnell’s desk as Republicans (supported by the National Rifle Association) did not favour taking guns away from violent domestic or intimate partners. The renewed VAWA would have closed the coyly named ‘boyfriend loophole.’ Because America.14 During this time, a great deal of support for victims of male violence and their agencies was also on hiatus.15
RATIFICATION ROULETTE
“Pay inequity often means women, who are the income earners, work more than one job, have less time to spend helping their children have academic success, and more women retire below the national poverty level than men.”
—ERA Coalition
Publication of 28A should have proceeded smoothly, if only the ERA were not an amendment affirming the legal personhood of women, and so reconfiguring the social contract and possibly two-thirds of the US economy.16 Instead, we get one of the longest and most complicated legislative lobbying efforts and series of court battles in the history of the nation. It has drained life-energy and resources for three generations of feminist activists. There is this matter of the 1979 deadline (most irregularly) applied to 28A when it was submitted to Congress for the second time in 1971 (later extended by Congress to 1982). Again, that was thanks to rigorous actions and lobbying by women’s organizations (see ‘Not for lack of trying’ in the RADICAL NOTION archive). There are ongoing lawsuits challenging the constitutionality of this deadline and its enforcement. They are not going well, and indeed the Biden Administration is arguing against publication just as did the previous administration.
Anyway, after 1982, betting that the right Congress or court case would do the job, activists went on organizing and lobbying for the ERA right up to January 2020 when Virginia, previously a more conservative state, went heavily blue in the reaction to Trump’s presidency and became the 38th state to ratify the ERA. It was the first order of business of the 2020 session and put something of a notice out to conservatives—elections have consequences, women deserve the full protection of the law.17 The ERA became the 28th Amendment.
Kind of.
The question of the deadline still stands, even though activists have been taking all open paths to finally get this done, including various civil suits. The fate of the 28A swirls in the currents running against, around, and right through women’s rights and lives in the US. Its success rests mostly on the political courage of President Biden and US Attorney General Merrick Garland, and so … well.
The genuinely strategic and wily William Barr, Trump’s Knight Templar of the Culture Wars, sent a letter to the United States Archivist forbidding him to publish the ERA—in 38 pages of other words that come down to, “Congress may not revise the terms under which two-thirds of both Houses proposed the ERA Resolution and under which thirty-five state legislatures initially ratified it.”18 As if publication ratification now would somehow insult their work, or undo it! As you may have divined by now, the reasons for this are dodgy and labyrinthine. Both Garrett Epps and Robinson Woodward-Burns of The Atlantic elucidate them brilliantly if you would like a dive into that Charybdis.19
Intrepidly, Democrats in the 2021 House and the Senate are trying to reaffirm support for 28A and find a way around the obstacle of the deadline. Bills in both chambers argue that if a deadline can be added, and then extended, it can also be removed.20 Meanwhile, the House has created a kind of placeholder bill in Joint Resolution 28 (get it?) which has 97 co-sponsors and no text. All we have is a summary stating that the bill would start the ratification process from scratch by proposing a new amendment addressing “equal rights for men and women” (that language is not ideal). At the same time, the House also filed Joint Resolution 17 to remove the deadline for ratification and return to the original terms of ratification from 1972. Should this pass in both the House and the Senate, and be signed by President Biden, then the ERA could be published into the Constitution.
But that is very uncertain given the wobbly political courage of the men involved.
Biden’s attorney general, Merrick Garland, is also arguing in federal court against publishing 28A. If that succeeds, we will need the new amendment and an even more complex and unlikely ratification process than we faced in the 1970s. It’s not like the political ‘mood’ of the nation has become more favourable. Sure, as always, a large majority of Americans support the ERA, and as always just enough (now plenty of) very determined conservative politicians oppose it. The President accused Facebook of killing people with rampant vaccine misinformation, but on 28A he “won’t dictate an outcome” despite early vociferous support for the amendment.21 US Attorney General Garland remains mum on the ERA, saying only that “decisions on whether to withdraw an Office of Legal Counsel opinion [‘the Barr Memo’] would be based on ‘careful attention to the facts and the law.’”22 And that means about as much as you think it does.
Where we stand as of summer 2021 is quite literally outside the front door of the Department of Justice, where Equal Means Equal has stationed ERA sentinels to harry the conscience of the department’s employees. As women have over the century since 1923, we are standing vigil for the Equal Rights Amendment.
The flurry of hopeful articles published early in 2021 have rather fluttered to the sidewalk.23 The Archivist sits on his hands as he has since January of 2020.24
The fact is that the ERA would supersede the Equality Act in force of law. Where the Equality Act can overwrite other laws, remember, it cannot overwrite amendments. The language in 28A protecting ‘sex’ cannot be affected by the language in the EA where “sex” becomes “a sex stereotype; pregnancy, childbirth, or a related medical condition; sexual orientation or gender identity, and; sex characteristics, including intersex traits” (see ‘The (In)Equality Act’ below). The conflicts are very, very clear. And Biden, Garland, Harris, and everyone else in those marble halls knows it.
As constitutional scholar Akhil Amar, Sterling professor of Law and Political Science at Yale University, says, “It’s all procedurally irregular.” Or, as The Daily Beast put it quoting an activist, “This is some bullshit!”25
NOT FOR LACK OF TRYING
All this is an object lesson in how much the US does not want to admit that women are human. In 1972, when Congress sent the ERA forth to the states to test her fate, they appended a deadline for ratification of 1979, and when three states failed to ratify, Congress extended the deadline to 1982.
Women agitated and organized throughout the 1970s for the ERA, and against it. Their work and stories are an object lesson for US feminists today, one that I have found the most inspiring and grounding in all my research for this article. Back in the 1970s, while many states ratified the ERA very quickly after it was sent to the states, Virginia was one of the holdouts as it was governed by Republicans and Democrats of a more conservative persuasion. But, as 1979 approached, things were getting desperate. The ERA would be introduced for consideration in the Virginia General Assembly, and the Democratic Majority Leader Jim Thompson would always make sure that it never got out of committee for a floor vote. The bill would die every January, only be reborn every August. The inspiring archive of this history is an informal oral history taken during a gathering of activists on the evening of the memorial for a storied women’s rights advocate Jean Crawford in 2014 is preserved at The Virginia Foremothers Project on YouTube.26 Tired of this eternal return, the group ERA NOW (split from Northern Virginia NOW chapter over the former’s embrace radical direct action tactics) organized a march from Alexandria to the capitol in Richmond, Virginia, so 90 miles to be covered in five days in January of 1975. The women practised distance walking for months ahead of time to get strong enough to walk 20 miles per day. They planned a route with stops at diners and other facilities along the way, and they had the ERA van for support carrying water, food, dry socks. As the women walked, the van would cycle from the front to the back of the line along US-Route 1, driving nearly 900 miles as the women walked the 90, providing water, gorp, and dry socks. Route 1 is best described a one long string of small-town, working-class America running from Ft. Kent in the Northern Maine along 2,391 miles of the Eastern US to the very last tip of Key West, Florida.
With some lucky publicity at the start, one of Time magazine’s women of the year that year, was an irregularly ordained Episcopal woman priest, Alison Cheek, who came to bless the walkers on their journey, and a terrible cold snap had rolled in. The high that day was only 9F. It rather heightened the drama of the moment. So, the press turned up to film it. That news alerted America to the effort and along the way to Richmond people opened their houses to give the women places to sleep and bathe, a hotel let them stay a night free of charge, and at least one diner they stopped in refused to let them pay for their meals. People honked and waved from cars, and more and more it became clear that the ERA was not just the pet project of some rich, educated, white women who wanted to make more money (though these women had the capacity to train for a long hike and take a whole work week to complete it). Turned out that the ERA was a favoured policy of the working classes, too, who knew what it would mean for employers and unions and insurance companies to have to treat women workers equally to men. It would benefit their families enormously.
As the march approached the outskirts of Richmond on the fifth day, an old man walked right up to Mary Ann Beall, crying as he hugged her to show love and support. He said he was so happy to see them because his wife was a big supporter of the ERA and she had died just two week prior to the march.27 The House of Delegates in Richmond was gearing up for its 1975 winter session and took notice of the developing support and enthusiasm for the women’s march and support for 28A. They could no longer pretend ERA was a niche issue, but they also did not want it ratified, and called the vote before the 14 women arrived at the capitol. In a closed-door meeting of the Judiciary committee, unwitnessed and untallied, a few delegates voted to kill the ERA. This was 1975.
Then as now, the smoke from the gaslights was thick. After the march, one reporter asked Georgia Fuller, just as she’s learning that after all these years and months they had lost: “The John Birch Society says you’re all ‘professional walkers.’ What do you say to that?” Then as now, women gather in a capitol, children organize against the guns used murder them in their schools, black American’s block highways to raise hell over state murders of black people by police, and these are all ‘professional protestors.’ This playbook is unchanged since 1975.
Jim Thompson was a personal enemy of the ERA, and after he led that cowards’ vote, the women of Northern Virginia NOW and the Alexandria Democrats asked 26 Democrat candidates to run against him and all said no. Fowler finally found a Republican lawyer to put up for the House of Delegates as a PRO-ERA candidate, and in 1977 Jim Thompson lost. It was personal. Even though Marianne Fowler had insisted they not use Thompson’s personal life against him (he was a closeted homosexual), the fight to get him out of the way was fierce. In 1975, after the ERA was killed in committee, Fowler remembers Thompson saying to her, “‘Every year you’re a little bit faster, and every year I’m a little bit slower, and one of these years you’ll get me.’ I was so pissed! The condescension of it, talking to me, to me, like women’s rights were a fun game for him!!” Fowler swore to herself that she would see Jim Thompson out of office by the next term, and she did.28
But things really heated up between 1979 and 1982. Phyllis Schlafly and the Eagle Forum of Illinois worked tirelessly against the ERA, coming from the mainstream ‘Moral Majority,’ and aligned with some very radically conservative elements of the religious right from Southern states (I’m looking at you, Texas). More than the Vietnam war, the matter of black people’s and women’s legal equality and its larger cultural implications were the real spark of the Culture Wars in the US. Schlafly argued that the ERA would mean “men abandoning their families, unisex toilets, gay marriages, and women being drafted.”29
Well!
This was, of course, utter nonsense (but nonsense I will recall later in this piece when I have at — I mean discuss — the objections of the ERA currently published by Women’s Liberation Front). Most of the money behind the Eagle Forum came from the corporate sector and the health insurance lobby in particular. US health insurance is tied to employment, and it turns out that women’s healthcare, what with our female capacity for reproduction, is much more expensive (dangerous to women, risky for underwriters) to cover than men’s healthcare. Many insurance companies and employers did not cover costs related to pregnancy and childbirth, much less the cancers and other ailments that affect women. Schlafly was the perfect frontwoman for this deep-pocketed obstruction, an eloquent, attractive, Mid-Western Athena fighting for father and country. The last book she wrote was The Conservative Case for Trump, so she was consistent. The Hulu series Mrs. America never touches on the sources of support for The Eagle Forum (depicted as purely a grass-roots operation, still functioning), but it does capture the conflict between conservatives and the women’s movement with some insight.30 The fact is that the ERA has huge economic and structural implications and therefore huge resistance from the corporate sector, like all real justice.
These days, most conservatives and liberals will blithely dismiss the ERA saying that women already have access to our civil rights through other laws and court decisions, so the amendment would be redundant. They are pretending that laws cannot be repealed or superseded—which they very much can be, for instance through court cases. They are pretending that a law like Texas’s new anti-abortion law would never set private citizens against each other with $10,000 bounties for reporting women/providers for abortions performed six weeks after conception with no exception for rape or incest. ‘This never happens.’ Indeed, with 28A published into the Constitution, this would never happen. But, we now have three justices on the court, thanks to Pussy-Grabber-in-Chief Trump, that lean very hard toward the positions and philosophy of Antonin Scalia who famously pointed out in 2011:
Certainly the Constitution does not require discrimination on the basis of sex. The only issue is whether it prohibits it. It doesn’t. Nobody ever thought that that’s what it meant. Nobody ever voted for that. If the current society wants to outlaw discrimination by sex, then we have things called legislatures, and they enact things called laws.31
Of course, “voted for that” is just a wee historical fiction. Women didn’t have the vote to vote with!
Because men in power have always said snidely clever things like this, the women of ERA NOW who did direct action for the ERA got braver and took bigger risks as the 1982 deadline loomed. When the GOP removed the ERA from its party platform with the conservative swing ushered in by Reagan’s ascendancy, ERA NOW worked out a plan to shut down the Republican National Convention Headquarters (RNC) in Washington, DC. This was their first arrestable direct action. DC was a much more relaxed place in 1980. No 9/11, no Jan-6 to balkanize the place. The RNC is near the Capitol building and the House Office building, so there was an audience of federal workers and tourists. With a well-planned crew of peacekeepers and legal observers, ERA NOW had planned for a long day. According to the women interviewed for the Virginia Foremothers Project, they strategized to find a chain too large for the bolt cutters used by the DC Metro Police, practiced getting the chains on and locked in under ten seconds (so not to be stopped by the building security), and survived the shattering of a glass door only a foot away from them in order to carry out their protest. They had developed some relationships with the police over the years of the White House Vigil for the ERA, and many of the police agreed with their struggle because they knew that the ERA would mean that their spouses/wives would be paid better, and their families could prosper. A working-class wage required a second income even in the early 1980s. The chain (a piece of which is shown throughout the Foremothers videos) was indeed too big for the bolt cutters, so the police simply had to wait for the women to unchain themselves after business closed for the day, and as they were no longer committing crime at the point, let the women go home.
As brash as some of the direct-action women were, and as bold as Fowler was in the political world, not every woman could risk arrest or find the time to edit a newsletter like THE ERA TIMES. But they could be legal observers at a vigil or an action, they could give a few hours to phone banking for campaigns, they could take turns looking after each other’s children and cooking meals among families. No single act, no single approach to the work took precedence for ERA NOW. For every one woman on the line in an action there were ten in various support roles, and as much redundancy as possible among activists. There always had to be cover for an illness, for childcare, for the generally unexpected.32 Women understand each other’s lives like that; how we are so rarely afforded the support needed to be single-minded.
What kept the group running for the whole decade of campaigns and direct actions were two things: no one got ‘important,’ and all had an iron-cast moral certainty in the justice of the ERA and the demonstrated impeccability of each woman in her commitment.33
After the arrest for climbing the White House fence in 1981, one of the feminists discovered that the officer processing them was hoping to get a promotion.34 Being a Spanish-speaking Puerto Rican, however, his English was not as formal as that of the officer class of the police, and it was proving a social barrier to his advancement. Georgia Fuller had taught English in other contexts, so when she and the other women were sentenced to 20 hours community service with “no need to do anything other than what you’re doing now,” because the judge was pro-ERA and this was pre-9/11, but the women broken the law,35 Fuller clocked half of those hours making the officer a booklet of exercises to help him get his promotion. It’s this kind of deeply grassroots intersectional work that made these protesting feminists as strong as they were. They knew that racism and classism worked against families just as much as misogyny did and they understood solidarity.
The action did not get the ERA restored to the Republican Party platform, but that was not the point. The point was to make sure that every Republican woman knew that their party no longer had their backs. Often the point of action is not the policy itself, but the publicity and awareness shared outside of narrow political circles.
ERA NOW also held a daily vigil at the White House, and over that time they got familiar with some of the police on that beat and some of the Secret Service officers. They were all there at the fence for so long that the activists learned the officers’ birthdays and brought them cookies. Since several of these women were mothers, they brought their children with them to the vigils, sometimes babies and diaper bags in tow. This is one of the ‘scary’ things about women, the way some of us can mother, community build, and raise hell at the same time — especially when we share the load. This is the real danger of women’s spaces to male domination. Not only crisis centres that support us when men rape or abuse us, not only changing rooms where we might pit our bodies against the male gaze manifest as fashion, not only multi-stall public toilets where we would like to pee without fetishists masturbating in the next stall, not only our clubs and women’s poetry-writing groups where we strengthen each other’s creativity and courage — no. Women’s spaces can become women’s connection that become women’s organizing that become women’s power to determine their own course. And that might mean standing vigil with a huge banner for the ERA just outside the White House, every day, in all weather, for years.
Not long after Reagan was in office, the White House sued all the demonstrators (feminists, but also anti-nuclear demonstrators, peacenicks) claiming that they posed a threat to the security of the White House. Back when the ACLU has its wits about it, they defended the women and other demonstrators and won. Sure, they went over the fence, but a lot of people did that in the 1970s and 80s. These women had their kids with them, and the Peace Protest against nuclear arms was three people in a tent with signs. The most persistent of them was a tiny woman in a babushka, and refugee from fascist Italy , Concepcion Picciotto. Terrifying. I tell you what.36
This work cost these women. As Fuller puts it in Part 7 (7:29) of Foremothers, “We borrowed against our health and against our careers. It took me several years after the ERA failed to get my health back.” Earlier in the same video she notes that the arthritis in her knees is in part a legacy of the March to Richmond, she also laments the rift between her and son over these years of her being ‘a bad mother’ to him. Marianne Fowler was purged from the Democratic Party by a surprise vote of the Virginia Democrats, showing there was no room in the Democratic Party for women like her. You know the kind: witty. Southern. Determined. Brave as Fuck.37 Then as now, official parties find the strongest and most effective women deeply threatening when those women side with their own sex.
By the time Sonia Johnson proposed the hunger strike at the Illinois capitol building for the final 40 days before the Illinois vote in August of 1982, many of the ERA NOW and Northern Virginia NOW women were already too weakened to risk such extremes. Of the women in the oral history, Mary Ann Beall and Pat Harley remember the fast in Illinois; they knew they would likely lose the vote and ratification. Mary Ann Beall emphasizes, “We were very aware of the sharp edge of grief. We weren’t there because we thought we’d win. We were there to witness and to be a presence of women’s anger and steadfastness,” so the fasting protestors were surprised at the love people showed, the women who came from around the country to help them and protect them. The protestors of ERA NOW and the women who joined them were seated daily in the centre of the capitol’s rotunda, and one thing these women from all over did for them was form a guarding ring around them.
Then as now, trolling was a thing. During the fast 40 women drove three hours to the capitol in Springfield from Carbondale, IL just to stand in front of the protestors, unwrap chocolate bars and eat them at the women.38 In spite of that, the war that must have been in their eyes. Before the end of the fast, Beall collapsed and was taken to the hospital. As much as the women trained and followed the methods developed by hunger strikers in Northern Ireland, bodies differ. As she was released, ABC television fast-talked her into debating Phyllis Schlafly (who lived just north of Springfield in Peoria, IL). Beall attributes to her exhaustion the fact that she did not tell Schlafly that she owed her law degree to the women who risked their wellbeing before her, that Schlafly would do well to acknowledge that women helped women through the world.39 In this, Schlafly’s denial of female solidarity reminds me of Judith Butler’s, shall we say, persona.
This activism, the 12 or so unrelenting years of it, also cost the people around them. Mary Hartzler’s husband’s family cut him out of their bosom entirely because he supported Mary’s work for women on domestic violence and the ERA particularly. When he died, she remembers calling them after many years not speaking to let them know and invite them to the funeral. None came.40
Not everything these women did was on the up-and-up. They always played fair with individuals. Even when Marianne Fowler learned that Majority Leader Jim Thompson was as closeted homosexual, she refused to use it against him in the campaign to remove him in 1977. No one should be personally destroyed in a legitimate political fight. As Marianne put it, “No, we couldn’t do that. If we have to do that, we’re just like them.”41 But, ERA NOW and NOVA NOW were the underfunded underdogs in this fight, so they frequently jacked the system. To get the maximum possible phone lines installed in a couple of women’s houses (four lines), the women claimed long-term visits by relatives with substantial socializing needs. They scrimped and saved. Pat Harley, learning that mimeograph ink went on sale every December, would stock up then. The Voter Registration lists and the Haines Directory, two key political organizing resources, were both public information, but access to that information was controlled by men hostile to the ERA. The Haines Directory was the most up-to-date source of addresses and phone numbers for the phone banks to call and solicit support for the ERA each voting season, and it was kept in a real estate office. The secretary was easily persuaded to let ERA NOW photocopy it after hours as she was often the target of the men’s sexual harassment.42 This way, the activists could call Democrats registered in Thompson’s district and let them know how he worked against the interests of women. One member worked in the offices of the US Navy at the Pentagon, and they had a hefty over-supply of index cards that suffered a ‘midnight requisition.’43 There was much grift in the name of the cause.
The move in these instances was to find people in agreement with you, who work in useful positions, but who can’t risk taking action and offer them an opportunity to help you take that action. As Mary Ann Beall says, they found the allies “who knew but could not do.”44
The lesson of these stories is to organize everywhere, any way, and to “work the system against itself and lie to the enemy.” When ERA NOW were planning to go over the White House fence in 1982 (Georgia Fuller and Mary Ann Beall and others actually did the climbing), they were so nervous that they broke their No Phone Rule about planning actions. The point of the action was to give President Reagan a petition with thousands of signatures supporting the ERA. They knew some of their phones were tapped by the FBI and realizing their mistake after a few days they called each other and said it would be too much of a risk so they would just chain themselves to the gate again. Well, wouldn’t you know, on the day they did go over the fence, the Secret Service, Park Police, FBI, and DC Metro police were already at the gate about two blocks away! As the women put it, if the FBI had tapped their ceilings (at which they often stared from the floor as they made plans) instead of the phones, they would have known!45
These videos are tonic, medicine. Not only the Foremothers on the March, but the whole archive. All these old women, some of them wizened, some of them glamourous, Quakers, Episcopal Christians, atheists, lesbians, moneyed and not, in teams and alone — they found what needed doing and supported each other in learning how to do the things that had to be done. In the end, they were beaten by betrayal. They did not fail. The ERA did fail. They were straight-up cheated. The ERA had huge popular support, but a few men in a few key states eschewed their sacred honour and broke faith with these women.
The great betrayal — 1982
Among the interviews in the Virginia Foremothers oral history project, Barbara Irvine of New Jersey is the most focused and poignant with regard to the near death of 28A in 1982. Irvine knew of the intense pressure around the ERA that year and the importance of Virginia to its success, so she came to Virginia with money raised by her chapter of NOW and stayed four months to assist with the political campaign.46
On the day of the final vote, activists from all over the state were at the capital. Thanks to the absence of Jim Thomson — defeated in 1977 by some of these same women and the white-hot organization efforts of women in NOW chapters and other organizations all over the state — the ERA had made it through committee to the floor of the General Assembly to find her fate. This, as Irvine puts it, was the culmination of a decade of focused, exhausting, sometimes dangerous organizing, and both the gallery of the General Assembly and the hallways of the capitol in Richmond were at capacity with women, many with their daughters, there as witness.
Now longtime savvy political operators, the women had secured personal promises from their delegates, especially the Democrats, who had promised these women they would vote in favour. These women knew the vote count down to the man. They expected to win by only one vote. Irvine could not get into the gallery above the Assembly floor, so she was in the hallway when word came out of the room. One woman from way out west in the coal country of Blacksburg had lobbied her delegate for nearly six months, and that delegate had promised her he would vote for the amendment.
He voted NO.
That woman collapsed on the floor, sobbing in rage and exhaustion.
Two others who had also promised to vote yes stepped out of the chamber to the men’s room (allowed then) and were recorded as abstentions.
The ERA failed to ratify in 1982 by three votes. Three men ended the work of three generations of activists in a heartrending defeat.
True, Illinois did not ratify either. Nor Nevada. But these three men in Virginia would have been enough, all by themselves, just by lying for months and taking a coward’s leave, to drive a knife into the hearts of women all over the country. And so they did. What’s power if you don’t use it?
It was, as Irvine tells it, the “most overwhelming sense of sorrow and grief”; after a decade of relentless organizing in Virginia, “it was utterly deflating.” Irvine, like the others, was emotionally exhausted and returned to New Jersey “flattened with depression. It was very hard,” she said. It took a few years before some women could return to any kind of activism, but so many did come back! Even after that “deliberate choice, more cruel than death,” in Irvine’s words, many have continued to this very moment working for ratification, along with a host of issues its failure leaves vulnerable (abortion, equal pay, child care, health insurance … never mind the revolution).
And now, joy of irony this, the matter of the 28A’s protection for women’s rights is in direct (if unacknowledged) conflict with both the language and the implications of the Equality Act.
As Irvine says at the close of the second of her videos, “What’s needed is a critical mass of awareness, urgency, of desire about it!”
Truly, women in the US have no idea how very fragile, unstable, and very temporary our rights to speech, assembly, and participation in the public life of the nation are. But what I know from watching these videos is that these women just ad hoc’ed it. They held faith in their ability to learn whatever skill or information was needed, to bend themselves to the shape needed to get the thing done. As Irvine says, you must “work in deep concert, let the synergy work along with you, get a plan, make noise to draw people in, and learn to raise big money and to use it.”47
THE (IN)EQUALITY ACT
Almost all the large US women’s NGOs are now captured by gender ideology and its corporate sponsors. GLAAD’s open letter supporting transwomen and girls (but not transmen, you will note) is famously signed by 450 feminist leaders who include the daughter of a former US president, a famous Millennial astrologer, celebrities and activists from across the US’s many kinds of difference, and every single women’s organization you can think of, from Iowa Coalition Against Domestic Violence to The National Women’s History Museum. They all co-signed a letter the bulk of which rebukes gender-critical and radical feminist women:
The women’s movement has seen doctors targeted before for providing us with necessary medical care and services [abortion], and we refuse to let youth endure that now [blockers, surgery]. Plus, we know that anti-trans sports bans are as unnecessary as they are harmful — and that women athletes at both the professional and college levels support inclusion.
These bigoted efforts are also aided by a contingent of self-identified [nice one] feminists, who have been promoting damaging and violent ideas about trans people for years in the United States and internationally. Their vitriol is, in fact, not feminist at all [tone policing much?]. True feminists do not wish to limit any woman’s identity or freedom to fully be herself. Allowing transphobic rhetoric to go unchecked also strengthens the legislative efforts of anti-trans politicians — who now cloak their bigotry in language about protecting or supporting women.
Further, all verbal attacks support the ongoing epidemic of murder and violence plaguing Black and Latinx trans women. 2020 was the deadliest year on record for the transgender community, seeing more than 44 killings, and, so far, there have been at least nine deaths reported this year.48
The public opinion of the National Organization for Women (which supports the ERA) is that we who publish in these pages support the murder of transwomen in the US. I remind us all, just one more time, that men in the US murder more than 44 women, family and familiar, every fortnight. But that, of course, is not relevant to questions of feminist activism for support and protection of women, noooo.
What GLAAD is defending is the Equality Act (HR5). HR5 has passed the House of Representatives, and is awaiting a vote in the Senate. Most US women have no idea that it exists or what it says. President Biden has promised to sign it. The bill is currently stuck in the same gaping maw of inertia as other bills with a tied 50/50 Senate and a few Democrats too conservative to rubber-stamp Biden’s wish-list.
Basically, HR5 would complicate the hell out of everything because it fatally confuses the terms used to protect women and LGB and trans people in civil rights law and gives trans people and men rein to define their terms and rights however they like whenever they like. By never clearly defining ‘gender’ or ‘gender identity,’ and by not setting any standard for medical transition, HR5 would make Self-ID the law of the land. Despite protestations to the contrary by transactivists, this arrangement means that women’s and LGB rights will remain as they are where they do not regress. And regression is very possible.
There is a virtuous impulse behind HR5 — to include LGB and trans people, and people with disabilities, in the civil protections afforded by the Civil Rights Act of 1964. It wants to do what the UK Equality Act did in 2010: get all the protections together in one place. It just ‘happens’ that it erases women by making men-also-women.
Discrimination against transgender, transsexual, and LGB people is precisely a matter of sex discrimination, and as such need not be made to conflict with the rights of women. See pages 88 to 91 for a careful feminist analysis of the Bostock judgement, which protects LGBT people from employment discrimination on the basis that this is a form of sex discrimination, already prohibited by Title VII.
Quick Disclaimer: I am not an attorney or a law scholar. I argue first as a philosopher. There are some very basic errors of logic here that will have real-world effects. My second perspective is as a social justice advocate and organizer. Below, by my own reason, and my reading of others, I parallel the arguments put forward against or modifying HR5 (and Biden’s EO 13988). These arguments are most robustly made and lobbied for by the Women’s Collective on Law and Policy and Feminists in Struggle (FIST).49
One problem is the definitions in HR5 and the scope which applies them to all previous civil rights legislation. Basically, HR5 is a document designed to revise the Civil Rights Act according to gender-identity ideology and queer theory. Here are the act’s two specious definitions (the others are logically sound, thankfully, but they are also borrowed from previous law):
(2) GENDER IDENTITY. — The term ‘gender identity’ means the gender-related identity, appearance, mannerisms, or other gender-related characteristics of an individual, regardless of the individual’s designated sex at birth.
(4) SEX. — The term ‘sex’ includes —
(A) a sex stereotype;
(B) pregnancy, childbirth, or a related medical condition;
(C) sexual orientation or gender identity; and
(D) sex characteristics, including intersex traits
This definition will have real-world consequences on a national scale because, in addition to its queering of definitions, HR5 explicitly forbids excluding anyone from any space on the basis of “sex (including sexuality and gender identity).”50
Section 1101.2: “(with respect to gender identity) an individual shall not be denied access to a shared facility, including a restroom, a locker room, a dressing room that is in accordance with the individual’s gender identity.” Other spaces specifically mentioned in Findings and Purpose in the bill are “restaurants, senior centers, stores … establishments that provide entertainment, health care facilities, shelters, government offices, youth service providers including adoption and foster care providers, and transportation.” Women, the Findings go on to say, “face discrimination in … stores and restaurants, and places or establishments that provide … entertainment or transportation, including sexual harassment, differential pricing for substantially similar products and services, and denial of service because they are pregnant or breastfeeding.” This bill is not without some merit. But it does reiterate the phrase “strike ‘sex,’” i.e. from previous law, about a dozen times.
Sex and ‘gender identity’ become so entwined as to be inseparable in revisions of all civil rights legislation. Much of the bill is instruction on which sections and paragraphs of law will be rewritten.
The perniciousness of this conflation comes clear later in the bill. The section on Construction of Claims, defining causes to sue if people think their rights have been violated, stipulates that all protections that apply on the “basis of sex [also apply] on the basis of pregnancy, childbirth, or a related medical condition, sexual orientation, gender identity, or a sex stereotype.”51
When the ERA was drafted by Alice Paul, she used ‘sex’ specifically because it is not an idea or presentation, not a bias or social construct or ideology, but the very thing about which the bias is held. Sex stereotypes are the very content of ‘gender.’ What troubles me so deeply here is that if gender identity is made of sex stereotypes, and if gender identity is protected as an element of sex (as this bill repeatedly states), then sex stereotypes are being protected as an element of sex, too. I fear there may be a double erasure of sex lurking here. These definitions are really, really going to matter. Even if their implications are scattered throughout the bill.
First, you have to define gender — and I promise there you will find the ‘sex stereotypes.’ Texas made a similar mistake back in the early 2000s in an attempt to prohibit gay marriage. For about a month all marriage was illegal in Texas, because they had banned anything that was ‘identical’ to marriage. Turns out the only thing identical to marriage is … marriage. That’s what ‘identity’ means, sameness.
Law is largely an exercise in definition.
Making ‘gender identity’ a collection of ‘gender-related identity traits’ smuggles in Self-ID without saying so. Such subterfuge protects only the interests of men, whether they are transgender or transsexual, or voyeurs/pornographers/sex offenders/abusers, or not, and is already leading to some worst-case-scenarios that we have all been assured by blue-tick trolls and legal scholars will never happen.
-
- California, Washington, New Jersey, Illinois, Virginia, and Maine transfer men to women’s prison on the word of their self-declared identification.52 These men transfer to the women’s prison and are housed with female cellmates and circulate in the general population (women’s prisons are not maximum-security facilities). Regardless of their crime, its violence, or its sexual nature. In many cases, we are protecting violent men from other violent men by placing them with women because they claim to be women, too. Women are being assaulted and raped and impregnated in these prisons at the permission of the state.
- Men’s crimes are recorded as committed by women. When we confuse sex and gender and rights, as in this case in Canada, we wind up blurring crime statistics, and much more importantly twice traumatizing the young boy in the case. Once when this man sexually assaulted him, and again when he will be asked to refer to his rapist as a woman and ‘she’ in court. He was only six years old at the time of the attack.53
- Forcing women to risk encountering a sexually aroused transwoman in public restrooms, and possible harm when that transwoman enacts male pattern violence at any objection to their presence. I googled ‘trans masturbate in public bathroom’ and Google returned “About 2,850,000 results (0.70 seconds).” I do not recommend clicking that link, but include it as evidence of fact … and to suggest that lots of heterosexual men seem to get off on men with breasts and large penises masturbating.54
- Already, US women, like UK women, have faced huge resistance, threats, and danger for organizing to protect our rights, even when explaining our own political positions. The saga of a 2014 event called Radfems Respond in Portland, Oregon, is an excellent example. The event’s “organizers hoped to refute charges that the desire to ban prostitution implies hostility toward prostitutes.” Transactivists intimidated the Quaker Friendship House that hosted by accusing the Quaker congregation (Quakers now!) of being “complicit in the violence against them.” When one mistakes an identity for a right, meanings of words like ‘violence’ also become ontologically wobbly, making opinions seem to have the same force as the gallows.55
By including ‘gender identity’ in the definition of sex, the Equality Act performs a similar sleight of hand to Title VII of the original Civil Rights Act of 1964, which strengthened the definition of a ‘corporation’ as a legal ‘person.’56 The thing most likely to discriminate against you, your employer, is protected in the very same breath as you are. What we got is a situation where the ‘person’ with most lawyers will still get their way.
The vortex created by these new silences, over-generous inclusions, and logical enmeshment in the Equality Act is the hole through which our newly minted activist conservative judiciary can drive a train of discrimination. Were he alive, Justice Scalia would read this and rub his hands in glee.57
Title IX, which touches on women’s sports, is not a title of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 (as we learned at the top) and the American Bar Association notes it protects women’s access to education generally, and equal treatment only in that context. How the EA would revise Title IX could allow universities to count transwomen toward the number of women in applications for federal funding. Similarly, late-transitioning men who made their academic careers as men could be counted as women for employment statistics. This would situate transgender women as the ‘corporations are people, my friend’ of sex equality, and create a rights conflict where there need not be one.
As concerns the progress built on legislation in the US, I remind us, we have passed three equal pay acts: 1963, 2010, and 2020. None of them have been well enforced, and all are subject to renewal and the whorls of the political winds.
Bella Abzug’s (that old, white, radical feminist!) Equality Act of 1973 was an all-out full-frontal assault on deep resistance to the Equal Rights Amendment, for which women had been organizing since 1922.
So, Bella, being Bella, went in.58 The original Equality Actdemanded more than validation of identity:
Equality Act – Prohibits, under the Civil Rights Act of 1964, discrimination on account of sex, marital status or sexual orientation in places of public accommodation, and under cover of State law.
Provides for civil actions by the Attorney General where there is discrimination on account of sex, marital status, or sexual orientation in public facilities or in public education.
Prohibits discrimination on account of sex, marital status, or sexual orientation in federally assisted programs, and in housing sales, rentals, financing, and brokerage services.
Provides penalties for anyone who wilfully injures, intimidates or interferes with any person because of his or her sex, marital status or sexual orientation.
Defines the term “sexual orientation” as used in this Act as meaning choice of sexual partner according to gender [sic].59
The original Equality Act would establish total personal and financial independence for women, forbid discrimination against single/divorced mothers, protect gays and lesbians from all economic and social discrimination, make the state and not the individual responsible for defending the rights of minorities, and it sneaked in a hate crimes clause in the bargain! It could have achieved this miracle, because it held to the common definition of sex as biological reproductive differences in human mammals.
Obviously, Congress said, ‘No.’
Rights are not magic. Rights are meant to be inalienable—they cannot be detached from a person and are part of what constitutes legal personhood. For that reason, they tend to attach to material elements of a person to protect them from oppression/discrimination elaborated on those material elements (sex, skin colour, national origin). The only changeable/alienable element protected in the US is religion, as one can change or give up religions. Gender, too, is alienable/changeable in that like religion it is a human-made construct, a set of codes for appearance and behaviour, intended to maintain a particular social order. We protected religion because the colonists regularly killed each other over their faith confessions (it was once a crime against the state to profess Anabaptism, a faith born on this invaded soil). Protecting gender and ‘gender identity’ this way puts them on a par with religion and may require them to be structurally accepted as of a kind with it. One cannot change sex, skin colour, or where one comes from, so the denial of rights in the forms of institutional sexism, racism, or nativism is hard to escape for most. If all you must do is identify as a woman, as is the case in some parts of Mexico, then this town council is gender balanced:
As I write this in summer 2021, HR5 sits in the Judiciary Committee with the full support of its Democratic majority, ready to move into the Senate. It’s waiting because we have a little thing called the ‘filibuster,’ which is the Pit of Despair to which bills go to die.60
THE WOLF AT THE DOOR
WoLF holds against 28A for several specious reasons — most of which turn on matters not covered in civil rights law but in social mores, family law, and criminal justice. The landing page for ‘The feminist argument against the Equal Right Amendment’ summarizes their position thus: “Protecting single-sex spaces for women and girls requires the ability to sometimes discriminate on the basis of sex.”61 This is pretty obvious, and weirdly misleading. It is wholly possible, just for example, to preserve single-sex spaces—you literally just write it into law and get it passed. That performative function of language is astonishing.
But, there’s more. WoLF present a handful of ‘arguments’:
not all discrimination based on sex is illegal or harmful. For example, Title IX prohibits sex discrimination in education generally, but the regulations permit discrimination based on sex in facilities and athletics because such discrimination is necessary to ensure equal opportunity for women and girls. Without the law recognizing the difference between men and women, sex-separated locker rooms and sports teams would be a violation of federal law. In fact, legal sex discrimination has also given us things like women’s shelters, sex-segregated prison housing, and the right to request a same-sex health care provider for intimate exams and procedures.62
This argument, that 28A would void Title IX, makes a kind of category error. It takes equality in law (as prescribed by 28A) to mean the same thing as ontological sameness and ignores the fact that two different kinds of things can be treated the same way in some contexts and not others without any infraction of dignity or access to the basic elements of society that allow one to prosper. There is more than one reason that we acknowledge the difference between strict equality and equity or justice.
Given that the entire point of 28A is to grant rights and not abridge them, we could quite easily specify women’s rights to bodily autonomy, personal safety, psychological wellbeing, and privacy that entail that some public and semi-public spaces be reserved for women only, such as women’s shelters, prisons, etc. We can agree that legal equality of rights does not instantly make women the same as men in every way or render the world safe from male violence, and act accordingly.
We can still ‘discriminate’ (i.e. differentiate) to recognize and honour differences rather than to use it as an excuse for material oppression.
WoLF takes three more whacks against 28A, none of which feel stronger to me than this first one. They are:
• First, what do women need from our government in 2021? Are there barriers that our government is putting between us and equality? When our abusers are private entities or individuals, what power does the government currently have to cure what still ails us?
Me: It would have quite a lot if it were not so neoliberal an organ. Government could be doing quite a lot to proactively prevent, regulate against, or prosecute such abuses. Like, enforce the Equal Pay Act, for example. Or set mandatory minimum sentences for domestic abuse and sexual assault as it did for non-violent drug offences. Easy.
• It would not give the government tools to intervene and enforce these laws that are not already available to them.
Me: So? 28A would forever force interpretation of 14A and 15A and the Civil Rights Act as requiring enforcement. Law would have to be written in that light, courts would have to interpret laws that way. It would make a huge difference to enforcement as the Executive would be bound by it.
• Supported by massive resources from special interest groups, lawmakers and judges have been — for several years now — gutting women’s rights. They are not doing this by reversing or overturning laws that guarantee equality between men and women, but by changing the very definition of sex so that the law no longer recognizes the differences between men and women.
Me: Again, as I explained above, the ERA would be big trouble for the EA. 28A would give reason to maintain the definition of sex … to consider legal equality, biological sex, and social gender for the three different kinds of phenomena that they are. The fact that transgender ideologists have been moving against women for a long time does not mean that 28A would not put a rather large spoke in their wheel.
• Equality is not synonymous with liberation. If the law is not permitted to recognize the distinction between the sexes, it cannot recognize and account for the needs and vulnerabilities of the female sex class with regards to pregnancy, motherhood, and susceptibility to male violence. Women’s liberation means freedom from oppression by men, and this freedom is an essential precursor to equal status under the law.
Me: Well, no shit, but you have this backwards. Without well-rounded, permanent, inalienable access to our rights in law, we cannot leverage other elements of society toward our liberation; we are too busy defending what little support and provision we have.
• Second, will the ERA compel the government to give us what we need? Will the government utilize its power to help women when we are exploited or abused?
Me: As we have seen with other rights and social ills, this is a matter of politics, not law. We will have a government that supports women’s being and prospering when we build the political alliances and develop the power that will let us make that government. What are you, new?
• Third, how will opponents of women’s liberation use the ERA to attack us? How might they weaponize a sex-blind legal system?63
Here WoLF accepts and presents a regular Gish gallop of extreme MRA arguments against the ERA. Most of them turn on a reading of the 14th Amendment that is just wrong.
WoLF claim that the ERA would:
• Further empower men to sue for joint custody and/or visitation rights if a child is born of their rape of a woman;
WoLF cites an Alabama case, but reading into the story, we discover that as of 2019 Alabama was one of only two states that Do Not Terminate custody/visitation rights in the case of rape.64 So why would this result arise? If punishment for violent crimes against women had the same enforcement as others, say as hate crimes, and women were granted full civil and bodily autonomy under 28A and Women’s Bill of Rights (see below), how would a man claim the impregnation of such a woman? In a world of law that still takes women and children to be a kind of property, men in many states can so sue and win, and are mostly encouraged by conservatives as a bulwark against a woman choosing to abort. It’s not even the child they’re interested in, the right just wants to end abortion. It’s not even the child the rapist is interested in, he just wants to continue to control and dominate the woman he violated. The right is fine with that. Nonetheless, WoLF have not chosen the strongest possible example to rest their argument on. The accused has not been indicted on any charges, in spite of two rape allegation investigations — which seems the bigger deal to me.65
• Create more leeway for ‘financial abortion’ or men choosing during the pregnancy to ‘opt out’ of financial responsibility for the child under the premise that Roe v. Wade would equally apply to men.
First, men already just go to the corner store for ice cream never to return. That a man may sue for custody of an unborn child does not mean that the ERA would automatically burden him with fatherly responsibility. Indeed, a woman who wants to keep her child has to sue the father in order to force him to partially support the child’s financial needs. Second, Roe v. Wade said not one damn thing about financial responsibility, it did not ‘means test’ privacy, it does not force men to help pay for abortions. Third, the relevant case, Dubay v. Wells, was dismissed twice. Dubay had been ordered to pay child support for Wells’s child whom he fathered, and he challenged the decision:
On March 9, 2006, the National Center for Men [a men’s rights organization] challenged the child support order in District Court. Michigan’s Attorney General made a motion to have the case dismissed, and on July 17, 2006, District Court Judge David M. Lawson agreed and dismissed Dubay’s lawsuit.
The National Center for Men appealed the case to the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit on May 14, 2007 … The appeals court affirmed the District court decision, noting precedent stating that ‘the Fourteenth Amendment does not deny to [the] State the power to treat different classes of persons in different ways.’
In its dismissal of the case, the U.S. Court of Appeals (Sixth Circuit) stated that: Dubay’s claim that a man’s right to disclaim fatherhood would be analogous to a woman’s right to abortion rests upon a false analogy. In the case of a father seeking to opt out of fatherhood and thereby avoid child support obligations, the child is already in existence and the state therefore has an important interest in providing for his or her support.66
Different classes of persons can be treated differently when that treatment is in the compelling interest of the state, such as the support and wellbeing of a child.
In WoLF’s legal minds, 28A would also:
• Further empower a man to force a pregnant woman to carry to term, on his word that he is the father;
See above. Why on the whole green earth would a judge not insist on a paternity test? This world is not the one where men just Self-ID as the fathers of other men’s children. What WoLF are implying here and above is that legal equality is the same as social equality, and making the same form of fallacious argument that gender ideologists do when they elide sex and gender. Such a bill is proposed in Tennessee, but has not passed. Such powers are not yet foregone conclusions. Further, if women were protected by both the Equal Rights Amendment and Women’s Bill of Rights (which does protect the right to abortion at the federal level) such state laws would be moot. Of course, 28A would not put an end to patriarchal domination. That is work at the community and social level. A13 certainly did not lead directly to a world free of white supremacy.
• View sexual/domestic violence as gender-neutral [sic. sex-neutral] problem, including through funding and service availability;
No such language exists other than in the Equality Act.Funding for violence against men would not ever be numerically equal to such funding for violence against women — indeed if we protected men from male violence at all, there would be no funding for anything else! Rather, funding could not be denied to a shelter for men from men’s or women’s violence. The federal budget for such shelters would not have to be split 50/50 because the rate of such violence is profoundly uneven.
• Reduce enforcement of marital-rape laws.
I’m not sure what world these men inhabit, or why any group of women would accept this argument. Sexual equality in the law in no way makes a crime not a crime. And again, there is no right to sexual relations unless one of the relations is property to the other. It was as chattel that women were obliged to be fucked by their husbands when they were not feeling receptive. No element of legal equality under the law would make women chattel again. Quite the opposite.
• End female-only scholarships;
Harumph. 28A would not make men and women the same kinds of people with magically the same history and prestige. History can still be taken into account as creating conditions that affect current real, material, access to education — even in federally funded scholarships. If we want to write the law that way. Private entities can designate scholarships and grants in any particular way they see fit, and likely always will. Women are the majority of university and postgraduate students now, by a good margin. It’s not lack of access to scholarships that prevents men from attending, so it’s very possible that scholarships are a non-issue in a post-28A world.67 WoLF’s example is a scholarship in the tech industry that sends women to a major conference to learn from and network with major players in the industry. In a sector so very deeply dominated by men, it seems that, from the reading of A14 in Dubay v. Wells, different classes of people can be treated differently and that’s not the same thing as oppression.
• Prohibit networking events and other mentoring for women in underrepresented industries (as has already been happening in states that have added strict scrutiny into their state constitutions).
Again, even here, this kind of equality of access would only be possible in federally funded networking events, like those mandated in unemployment support. The case WoLF cites here is the usual MRA shenanigan pushing on boundaries set by women to support women in contexts that have historically discriminated against us. And it’s only a case brought, not a case decided. It’s a harassing suit, meant to cost the organizers time and money more than actually change men’s access to the space. WoLF offer no support for the parenthetical claim there.
WoLF’s reading of the trans rights challenge to 28A seems to hinge on transwoman Charlotte Clymer’s reading of and enthusiasm for the ERA. They quote him as saying, somewhat confusingly:
The Equal Rights Amendment is different. It says that you are protected on the basis of gender [sic. sex], so all genders are protected and all [sic. both] sexes are protected. So what you are assigned at birth and how you express yourself in the public square, these two are overlapping with the Equality Act but it’s not the same thing. So we need to pass the Equality Act but we also need to ensure that we get the ERA passed and ratified.
Noooope. Not on the basis of gender. On the basis of sex. Both sexes would be protected from abrogation of their rights under the law. You have to, as Clymer’s bit of (performatively ditzy?) word salad does, conflate sex and gender in order to protect trans women as women in the ERA. Which, as the bulk of this magazine, the whole radical feminist tradition, and many new women’s organizations are trying to make clear, one should not do. However, protecting transwomen and transmen from discrimination on the basis of sex would indeed protect them as transpeople, in that no legal behaviour or presentation that seems to ‘diverge’ from one’s sex would be acceptable cause for discrimination.
28A will not protect anyone’s rights from bad interpretation or regressive social movements or strategically gauzy thinking. Look at what’s going on in the wake of the Citizens United Supreme Court decision (money is speech, corporations therefore have more speech than persons) or what’s happening now to voting access all over the US South. Rights are not impervious to qualification, or even perversion. But that is not a compelling reason not to have them. Also, Charlotte, the ERA had ‘passed’ in the House and Senate by the time you were speaking.68 Plus, without the Equality Act, 28A touches not at all upon gender or Self-ID.
WoLF also quote Clymer from the Ordinary Equality podcast to say: “What the Equal Rights Amendment does is that it moves up sex discrimination which is currently interpreted to protect all LGBTQ people to a strict scrutiny class, meaning any discrimination against LGBTQ people, period, and specifically trans people because of that gender piece, will be protected.”69 Again, this requires a conflation of biological sex and gender identity (plus some Intelligent-Design-level ‘science’70) — something the gender system that supports patriarchy actually does — and would need the legal support of the Equality Act to accomplish.
Charlotte Clymer is a powerful voice in this debate, but no law scholar. Her pronouncements on the meaning and implications of law have about as much reliable authority as mine do. Clymer worked as a press secretary at Human Rights Campaign, so the most we can say about this now self-employed trans woman is that her opinion represents that of a fully captured segment of the LGBT movement.
WoLF worries that publishing 28A into the Constitution would require that all these issues be judged with ‘strict scrutiny’ standard, and that this would necessarily impinge upon and injure women. A layperson’s understanding of strict scrutiny would be something like:
In U.S. constitutional law, when a court finds that a law infringes a fundamental constitutional right, it may apply the strict scrutiny standard to nevertheless hold the law or policy constitutionally valid if the government can demonstrate in court that the law or regulation is necessary to achieve a ‘compelling state interest.’ The government must also demonstrate that the law is ‘narrowly tailored’ to achieve the compelling purpose, and uses the ‘least restrictive means’ to achieve the purpose. Failure to show these conditions may result in a judge striking down a law as unconstitutional.71
Strict scrutiny tends to apply when someone sues the government, not another person or private entity. Cornell University Law School describes it this way: “Strict scrutiny will often be invoked in an equal protection claim. For a court to apply strict scrutiny, the legislature must either have passed a law that infringes upon a fundamental right or involves a suspect classification. Suspect classifications include race, national origin, religion, and alienage.”72 Strict scrutiny does not apply in custody cases, criminal cases, or in the process of suing your employer or university, because those already have tested laws in these areas.
CORRECTION: Conversation with Wendy Murphy, a lawyer working with Equal Means Equal, revealed that, indeed, strict scrutiny would apply in these cases and would have excellent effects like reducing the number of convicted sexual predators who get light sentences and greatly reducing the types of cases in which sexual harassment could be addressed with ‘in house mediation.’
28A might result in sex’s inclusion in suspect classifications. (In the UK these are called ‘protected categories,’ but in the US we write law extra-double-plus abstruse, so these ‘suspect classifications’ sound menacing but the suspicion applies to the laws that might oppress these people.) But, then again, it might not. The Supreme Court has so far refused to apply strict scrutiny to Second Amendment cases, for example, and that’s a ‘sacred article’ of the founding document cherished by men all over the country even though it results in clockwork-like deaths of schoolchildren all over the country.
It seems to me that continuing to see marital rape as a violent crime would be in the state’s interest, along with scholarships for women in industries where they are underrepresented. Strict scrutiny is a good test, but again, that test is subject to the vicissitudes of politics as much as any other. A host of gun laws on the books in US states are likely not in the state’s interest, just in the politicians’. Human need, fancy, and fear are still the case. The law does not cement culture in place nor end history. WoLF seems to feel that it will or wants us to feel like it will, as though women’s legal equality supported by the force of a constitutional amendment will somehow strengthen the patriarchy.
The problem of institutional capture will continue with the woke-gender-narrative of ‘so-called biological sex’ and gender identity overwriting biological sex and ‘so-called gender identity.’ That is part of a fight related to civil rights and cultural change, but it is not the one that attaches to 28A’s publication into the Constitution. If sex is redefined by the Equality Act as ‘sex stereotypes’ and ‘gender identity,’ 28A will not make the problems worse, since the HR5 would rewrite all the language in all these laws as it stands presently. But, when the EA is discovered to be the ontological, biological, social, health care, and economic clusterfuck that it is, 28A could still be standing there to support women’s and LGB and T rights that ground our pursuits of happiness.
Look, I get it, we’re all squeezed between the neo-liberal 8-Ball and an increasingly hostile ecosystem. I know, we are all low-key freaking out all the time. And, women/feminists in the US are squeezed between a right wing that would render us all lobotomized worker-baby-makers and a ‘progressive’ ‘left’ that, in the name of being kind to trans women, would render us all lobotomized worker-baby-makers.
I know that what’s happening to women in Bangladesh, and Palestine, and Somalia, and Bolivia, and right here in the US too, is all an affront against the Divine and Nature. I know this is no fun and frankly the stakes are as high as they can get in democratic political terms.
But.
WoLF conclude their presentation of ‘maybe and perhaps’ against the Equal Rights Amendment this way: “The embrace of the Equal Rights Amendment by opponents of women’s sex-based rights is not a reason to reject it; but it is a reason to pause and reflect on their arguments. We find their case persuasive.” Soooo, they reject the ERA because their opponents accept it. Just like that, without much at all in the way of reasoning or real legal analysis, just claims they agree to for Gaia-knows-why.
WoLF is gaslighting American women about the ERA.
Sometimes the enemy of my enemy is just more problems.
Missing from the document
Many vital words are not in the Constitution: freedom, slave, privacy, climate, police, assault rifle, wiretap, internet. Woman. Women are not in the Constitution, and even with 28A we will not be positively represented as women with rights specific to our sex. On that point, WoLF is correct. There is, however, an existing radical feminist answer to that deficit.
Women should not be the same as men — in language or in law or in biology. For one thing, that would be aesthetically boring. For another, it would be the biological end of the human species. Given that liberal political theory assumes male people as the model of persons, it’s difficult to recognize women in the law as something other than ‘also-men.’ A radical feminism based in difference (like mine) goes further to argue that women must undertake to articulate The Feminine (in all its valances and embodiments) in every element of human life for there to ever be two fully human subjects in the world. That is, we should also represent women-as-women in the law.
The ERA does not mandate that women be treated as if we are men or vice versa. It does not make men and women the same kind of subject in the law. It allows for difference of sex, just not discrimination due to a person’s sex. It does not create a false identity of men and women — that’s the Equality Act does that. It simply means that no right can be withheld from any person because of their biological sex or ideas about what it means: to vote, to work, to own property and money, to education, to housing, to medical care, or to public or other accommodations specific to female biology. No right shall be abridged or denied on the basis of sex. That means we can make positive discriminations involving sex-specific judgements or have sex-specific protections, for example, as feminists are hard arguing in the context of women’s sports. Equality of biologically sexed people before the law does not mean mandated 50/50 parental custody any more than our current arrangements do — custody is decided in the interest of the child, or should be. Legal sexual equality does not create a right to sex, or to attention, or care, or to do violence, or to harm other free people. 28A does not create or reinstate a right to domination. It in no way forces single-sex domestic violence shelters to become ‘gender inclusive.’
And to hell with that language too. Domestic Violence. Gender-based violence. These are polite terms for brutal physical and sexual violence done to women and girls by men. These are, as the British call them, refuges, refuges from the incursions of men against the bodies and personhood of female people.
28A in no conceivable way re-legalizes marital rape or erases all of patriarchal history and our social, psychic, and bodily inheritance of it in one fell legal swoop. It does not automatically create mixed-sex sports, or prisons. It does not accord privilege. 28A makes women’s lives, in every area and pursuit, possible without the imprimatur of or coverture of a man. Women would have access to the condition of inalienability under the law. The ERA entails a change of both legal and ontological status for women — entails but does not describe.
QUICK HISTORICAL SPIRAL BACK TO 1968
Lots of good things came into the world in 1968. Sesame Street, jazz fusion, the Big Mac, the first interracial kiss on US television (Star Trek), and the National Organization for Women Bill of Rights (WBR). Just as the US Constitution did not spell out the rights of white, male citizens in the young republic, neither does the Equal Rights Amendment do so for women. By contrast, NOW’s Bill of Rights is cleverly liberal in conception and radical in effects. It reads:
NATIONAL ORGANIZATION FOR WOMEN BILL OF RIGHTS IN 1968
(ADOPTED AT THE 1967 NATIONAL CONFERENCE)
I. Equal Rights Constitutional Amendment
II. Enforce Law Banning Sex Discrimination in Employment
III. Maternity Leave Rights in Employment and in Social Security Benefits
IV. Tax Deduction for Home and Child Care Expenses for Working Parents
V. Child Day Care Centers
VI. Equal and Unsegregated Education
VII. Equal Job Training Opportunities and Allowances for Women in Poverty
VIII. The Right of Women to Control Their Reproductive Lives
We Demand:
I. That the United States Congress immediately pass the Equal Rights Amendment to the Constitution to provide that “Equality of rights under the law shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any State on account of sex” and that such then be immediately ratified by the several States.
II. That equal employment opportunity be guaranteed to all women, as well as men by insisting that the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission enforce the prohibitions against sex discrimination in employment under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 with the same vigor as it enforces the prohibitions against racial discrimination.
III. That women be protected by law to insure their rights to return to their jobs within a reasonable time after childbirth without loss of seniority or other accrued benefits and be paid maternity leave as a form of social security and/or employee benefit.
IV. Immediate revision of tax laws to permit the deduction of home and childcare expenses for working parents.
V. That childcare facilities be established by law on the same basis as parks, libraries and public schools adequate to the needs of children, from the pre-school years through adolescence, as a community resource to be used by all citizens from all income levels.
VI. That the right of women to be educated to their full potential equally with men be secured by Federal and State legislation, eliminating all discrimination and segregation by sex, written and unwritten, at all levels of education including college, graduate and professional schools, loans and fellowships and Federal and State training programs, such as the Job Corps.
VII. The right of women in poverty to secure job training, housing and family allowances on equal terms with men, but without prejudice to a parent’s right to remain at home to care for his or her children; revision of welfare legislation and poverty programs which deny women dignity, privacy and self-respect.
VIII. The right of women to control their own reproductive lives by removing from penal codes the laws limiting access to contraceptive information and devices and laws governing abortion.73
This text mentions women eight whole times! It’s unambiguous, specific, inclusive but not universalist or idealist. Certainly, these rights would facilitate women’s participation in a liberal, capitalist system rather than inaugurate the Fifth Spiral Galaxy, but they would be ground from which to launch.
To this very day, US women are fighting for most of these policies (I’m looking at the abyss of your conscience, Senator McConnell). Childcare funded and tended to as a major civic institution! Bodily sovereignty! Tax deductions for home and childcare expenses! It costs a family about one million dollars to raise a middle-class child to adulthood in the US. Even 10% of that is USD $100,000 per family, per child over 21 years. At this writing, there are 71.4 million children in this country. That would be around $71 trillion over 21 years. That is a fuck-ton of federal tax deductions.
According to the UN in 2016, the “global cost of violence against women was estimated … to be USD 1.5 trillion annually, equivalent to approximately … the size of the entire Canadian economy.”74 Yet, nations do not undertake to eliminate it. Somewhere there must be an actuarial table showing the cost of eliminating sex-based violence would be a great deal more than 2% of global GDP. Designing a society that actually supported women (and children) on a par with its support for men would be very costly indeed, possible but costly. Like, climate-change-level costly. The WBR would create upending change across all sectors of liberal society and economy. It would contribute to a care economy. It would entail a robust social safety net. It would reduce the survival-stress in working families to a level of chill I don’t think we can imagine in this gig-and-hustle neoliberalism of permanent precarity and starvation wages for most. The stakes we are fighting for are very, very real.
Women have been working to materialize these rights and social changes for generations. These rights, the funding and programmes needed to make them real, would give women, all kinds of women, something vital to all growth — security. Grounding. Breathing room we need to build what comes next. These rights amount to what Alice Paul might have called ‘the full complement of dignities to accord with our sex.’ Feminists are obliged to accommodate our minds and efforts to match the scale of the demand we rightfully make. We are not asking for a 3% raise or a break on the cost of shampoo. The costs of our demands are enormous because the returns on that investment are of epochal consequence.
28A and the WBR have confronted fervent refusal and enervated support all this time because they are dangerous to neoliberalism and male domination. Men don’t want this, and the men who say they do don’t put much enforcement behind their words or policies.
Joe Both-Sides-of-Your-Mouth Biden.
Let’s begin to imagine it — the world that also suits women. Maybe a lottery system in which women of all classes rotate three-year shifts working in childcare centres and community building. Maybe a kind of feminary — a seminary, but make it feminist — in which women re-claim and newly articulate our female relationship to the animating forces of life. Time to design seat belts that don’t kill us, and scalable food economies that are actually nourishing. Luce Irigaray argued that women need spaces of our own, to be with each other, to develop our sense of selfhood as reflected by the feminine gaze, in the company of women (as fraught as that can be, it is not fraught with the turbulence of the male gaze), to develop lineages within and among our communities that we may be linked culturally and historically and strengthened such that when male violence or coercion arises we each have no doubt that hundreds or thousands of sisters will come to our protection and show those men the goddamned dialectical door!
Esmée Streachailt, PhD is a nom de guerrière. Esmée’s cultural and organizing work leverages strategic alliances across difference for the liberation and flourishing of humans and the ecology in which we are embedded. Her writing embraces feminist critical theory, cultural hermeneutics, comparative religion, and poetics. Esmée is a co-founder and contributing editor with THE RADICAL NOTION: A Feminist Quarterly and a lecturer at the Centre for Feminist Thought.
1 ‘The Civil Rights Act of 1964: A Long Struggle for Freedom,’ Library of Congress. Also archives articles on the politics leading up to the act’s passing.
2 ‘Women’s rights and the Civil Rights Act of 1964,’ The National Archives.
3 The Center for American Progress offers a quick and excellent breakdown of the rights and protections at stake in this long-drawn-out-and-deliberately-delayed-and-derailed ratification process. They use the language of ‘gender’ to talk about ‘sex,’ so that’s not helpful, but the implications of the ERA and its absence are made clear. See Robin Bleiweis, ‘The Equal Rights Amendment: What you need to know,’ Center for American Progress, 29 January 2020.
4 Some of these comments were made by media personalities, but they were on a par with what senators said to Hill’s face in the Judiciary Committee hearing. See Adam K. Raymond, ‘A Brief Guide to the Joe Biden-Anita Hill Controversy,’ New York Magazine, 7 May 2019.
5 ‘History of the Women’s Rights Movement,’ Nation Women’s History Alliance (NWHA).
6 NWHA.
7 I refer to the Equal Rights Amendment as ‘28A’ is a kind of shorthand used by policy wonks in the US. I use it for the ERA because it has goddamn well been ratified and it took 98 years to do it.
8 The two-year clause was intended to give states and businesses time to change their laws/policies to conform to the ERA rather than find themselves on the sharp end of legislation for which they were unprepared. A kindness not extended, for example, by the Equality Act. See ‘Frequently asked questions,’ Equal Rights Amendment (Alice Paul Institute), 2018.
9 See ‘History of women’s suffrage: 14th and 15th amendments,’ The National Women’s History Museum, 5 October 2015.
10 ‘Voting rights for African Americans,’ Library of Congress.
11 NWHA. “The omission of sex in [Johnson’s] Executive Order 11246 was finally rectified in Executive Order 11357 on October 13, 1967. In a letter to President Johnson, the leaders of the National Organization for Women (NOW) hailed the correction but remained unsatisfied with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission’s (EEOC) in making the new order effective.”
12 The videos cited here are quick and excellent sources for more history and detail than I am compiling here. PBS’s project Retro Report offers a great history. See ‘From women’s suffrage to the ERA: A century-long push for equality,’ Retro Report, 11 June 2020.
13 Brenda Erickson offers a full description of the process for The National Council of State Legislatures, in ‘Amending the U.S. Constitution,’ Legis Brief, 25.30 (August 2017).
14 Amanda Baker, ‘House passes Violence Against Women Act reauthorization in bipartisan vote,’ The 19th*, 16 March 2021. As noted, the ‘boyfriend loophole’ was the major hold-up. VAWA forbids gun ownership to husbands, ex-husbands, and fathers of shared children who have been convicted of domestic violence—because we know that tends to escalate to murder. But cohabitating romantic partners are not so constrained, and these men do use guns to murder women they have been abusing.
15 Not that this support is especially effective at addressing violence against women. Indeed, the murder rate of women killed by family and familiar has doubled in the last 30 years to approximately five women per day. Wendy Murphy had that and much more to say in her interview on the En(gender)ed podcast hosted by Teri Yuan on 21 May 2021.
16 The National Women’s History Alliance, cited earlier, offers an excellent overview of this history. I focus on only a few elements of it in the next paragraphs.
17 John Oliver, ‘Equal Rights Amendment,’ Last Week Tonight, HBO, 9 June 2019. The deep dive in the episode focused on Scalia’s wry observation that A14 does not cover sex or gender, though that’s precisely the ruling in Reed v. Reed.
18 Joan Walsh, ‘William Barr is neck-deep in extremist Catholic institutions,’ The Nation, 15 October 2019 and Epps below.
19 Garrett Epps, ‘Bill Barr doesn’t get to decide what’s in the Constitution,’ The Atlantic, 16 January 2020; Robinson Woodward-Burns, ‘The person who changes the Constitution,’ The Atlantic, 17 January 2020.
20 ‘With Virginia ratification, where does the Equal Rights Amendment go from here?’ PBS NewsHour, 16 January 2020.
21 Maureen Groppe, ‘Biden taking hands-off approach to Justice Department barrier on Equal Rights Amendment, White House says,’ USA Today, 15 March 2021.
22 Groppe.
23 Editorial Board, ‘ERA ratification: likely dead on arrival in the senate,’ Baltimore Sun, 13 Feb 2020; Emily Peck, ‘2021 could be the year women get full constitutional rights,’ Huffington Post, 22 January 2021.
24 ‘NARA press statement on the Equal Rights Amendment,’ National Archives, 8 January 2020.
25 Lloyd Grove, ‘“This Is Some Bullshit!”: Women’s groups rail against Biden inaction on Equal Rights Amendment,’ The Daily Beast, 10 June 2021.
26 The bulk of the story of 1975 Women’s March to Richmond is told in Parts 7 and 8 of the playlist ‘Foremothers on the March,’ Virginia Foremothers Oral History Project, YouTube, 2014, youtu.be/cpxm7kx9Fww and youtu.be/mv-ujlbSILA. A remembrance of Jean Crawford (1946-2014) can be found at The Veteran Feminists of America Pioneer History Project.
27 ‘Foremothers,’ Part 8, 9:11.
28 ‘Foremothers,’ Part 3, 4:11.
29 NWHA.
30 ‘Mrs. America,’ Wikipedia, April 2021.
31 For those of you interested in the really deep historical dive, ‘The Meaning of Equal: Does the Constitution Prohibit Discrimination on the Basis of Gender and Sexual Orientation?’ The Constitution at a Crossroads, Constitutional Accountability Center.
32 ‘Foremothers,’ Part 2, 2:16.
33 The women talk about these principles in Parts 1 and 3 of ‘Foremothers on the March.’ Images of the activists for this history are credited to their original sources where traceable, and are part of an wonderfully thorough collection archived at the Greensboro News & Record, ‘Historical Photos: The Fight for the Equal Rights Amendment,’ June 2018.
34 Georgia Fuller brought the chain, ladder, and the one boot she wore on the march that is not in the Smithsonian Museum. Both are resting on the table throughout the interview. In Part 12 (at 14:43), she describes how the women measured the fence with against their bodies (heights, lengths of forearm) to get the dimensions needed exactly right. They then trained for several months on similar fences around the Arlington and Alexandria, VA region so that they would be smooth and successful on the day.
35 ‘Foremothers,’ Part 14, 8:00.
36 Picciotto and two other protestors kept the Peace Vigil 24 hours a day for 30 years, as encamped protests (no longer allowed) had to be continuously occupied under Washington, DC statutes. For a good image of Picciotto from just before her death in 2009, see Marc Adams, ‘Picciotto’s Supporters Push for National Peace Memorial,’ WAMU-National Public Radio, 15 June 2012.
37 ‘Foremothers,’ Part 17, 11:29.
38 ‘Foremothers,’ Part 17, 9:46.
39 ‘Foremothers,’ Part 17, 5:44.
40 ‘Foremothers,’ Part 15.
41 ‘Foremothers,’ Part 8, 17:06.
42 ‘Foremothers,’ Part 3. 4:11.
43 Foremothers,’ Part 6, 13:39.
44 Foremothers,’ Part 1, 15:55.
45 ‘Foremothers,’ Part 4, 17:17.
46 These next stories are taken from part of the Foremothers interview with Barbara Irvine, in the parlour of the Paulsdale, the childhood home of Alice Paul and now the Alice Paul Institute. While living in Virginia, Irvine had helped found the Roanoke chapter of NOW. The history here is assembled from the videos ‘The mechanics of the movement’ and ‘Civil rights, the big blow, and recovery’ at The Virginia Foremothers Oral History Project on YouTube, youtu.be/TTGKQeaZp_A and youtu.be/2-sG6SyHHZo.
47 Virginia Foremothers, ‘Civil rights,’ 18:33.
48 ‘Open letter supporting trans women and girls,’ GLADD, 31 March 2021, glaad.org/tdovletter.
49 See ‘Feminist Amendments Documents,’ Feminists in Struggle, feministstruggle.org/feminist-amendments/faea.
50 Section 3 of HR5 defines public accommodations in comprehensive detail: “(4) any establishment that provides a good, service, or program, including a store, shopping center, online retailer or service provider, salon, bank, gas station, food bank, service or care center, shelter, travel agency, or funeral parlor, or establishment that provides health care, accounting, or legal services, “(5) any train service, bus service, car service, taxi service, airline service, station, depot, or other place of or establishment that provides transportation service.”So, the whole of the US will be Wi Spa, and somehow we will have to hope that security cameras are all upgraded with real-time facial recognition programmes trained specifically to the sex offender registration database. I don’t want to live in a world where women’s safety requires a surveillance state, but then aren’t we doing this already? See 117th Congress, ‘House Resolution 5: The Equality Act of 2019,’ The House of Representatives, 17 March 2021.
51 HR5 Section 1006, ‘Rules of Construction,’ para. C.
52 Adam Beam, ‘California will house transgender inmates by gender identity,’ AP News, 27 September 2020, apnews.com/article/us-news-laws-gavin-newsom-ca-state-wire-lifestyle-14cd954b06360d21349b77233318369e; Dori Monson, ‘DOC employee reports men are claiming to be women to transfer prisons,’ Kiro Radio, 8 March 2021.
53 Chris Doucette, ‘Woman accused of sexually assaulting boy in Toronto Park,’ The Toronto Sun, 14 July 2021.
54 Google search, ‘trans masturbate in public bathroom.’
55 Michelle Goldberg, ‘What is a woman?: The dispute between radical feminism and transgenderism,’ The New Yorker, 28 July 2014. Goldberg wrote this excellent piece before she knew what hell transactivists would rain on her. She will not discuss either the article or the issue to this day.
56 The 14th Amendment has been interpreted by a host of Supreme Court cases to extend to corporations.
57 But hey, this is a relatively low-risk way for the US centre-right (what we call a left here) to look progressive and cool. It is virtue signalling on a historical scale at the direct expense of women. As of this writing in summer 2021, just about all that stands between US women and HR5 is the refusal of a moderate Democrat of West Virginia, Joe Manchin, to vote to abolish the Senate’s standing-filibuster — a parliamentary function whose removal would allow the Democrats to pass laws with a bare majority of 51 votes (with the vice president as tie breaker), rather than overcome the current super-majority of 60 votes.
58 ‘Remembering Bella Abzug,’ The Charlie Rose Show, The Public Broadcasting System, 9 April 1998. In which Gloria Steinem remembers feminist activist and congressperson Bella Abzug. Charlie Rose was accused of sexual harassment and misconduct in the course of the #MeToo movement and removed from a co-hosting position on CBS’s This Morning news programme.
59 93rd Congress, ‘House Resolution 14752: Equality Act,’ The House of Representatives, 14 May 1974.
60 ‘Filibuster,’ Last Week Tonight, HBO, 9 September 2019.
61 WoLF, ‘ERA,’ Women’s Liberation Front, 15 February 2021.
62 WoLF, ‘The feminist argument against the Equal Rights Amendment,’ Women’s Liberation Front, 15 March 2012.
63 WoLF, ‘Feminist argument.’ All points represented in this section are found on these pages of WoLF’s website.
64 ‘Alabama court forces rape survivor to allow rapist to have visitation with children,’ KNOE-Monroe, CBS, 12 June 2019.
65 Snopes fact-checking turns up the following: “What’s False: Despite two formal investigations of rape and incest allegations against Barnett, one of which led to the empanelment of a grand jury, Barnett has never been convicted, or even indicted, on charges of rape or incest.” See Dan MacGuill, ‘Did an Ala. court force rape survivor to allow rapist to visit their children?’ Snopes, 25 June 2019.
66 ‘Dubay v. Wells,’ Wikipedia, 21 November 2020. My emphasis.
67 Jon Marcus, ‘Why men are the new college minority,’ The Atlantic, 8 August 2017.
68 The ERA Coalition is one of those legacy feminist organizations that supports the Equality Act, thinking that it and the ERA complete each other in some geometric harmony. See, ‘LGBTQIA+ & the ERA Town Hall,’ The ERA Coalition, 16 November 2020.
69 ‘Charlotte Clymer,’ Ordinary Equality, Apple Podcasts, 28 April 2020.
70 It did not take American jurisprudence too long to arrive at the Kitzmiller v. Dover Area School District decision, in which the judge took over 200 pages to utterly burn the fruit and salt the earth of the intelligent design argument. We no longer ‘teach the debate’ in the schools. ‘Federal court strikes down intelligent design curriculum,’ Pew Forum, Pew Research Center, 20 December 2005.
71 ‘Strict scrutiny,’ Wikipedia.
72 ‘Strict scrutiny,’ Legal Information Institute, Cornell University Law School.
73 ‘National Organization for Women Bill of Rights in 1968,’ archived at 350fem, Bryn Mawr College.
74 Lakshmi Puri, UN Assistant Secretary-General and Deputy Director of UN Women, ‘Remarks: The economic costs of violence against women,’ UN Women, 21 September 2016.
