by Anna Ziggy Melamed
The question of social reproduction reveals how the inequality of the sexes is woven into the functioning of capitalism. The pandemic has exposed the stark reality of gender that props up modern patriarchal capitalism, and shown us that the gains of liberal feminism will be meaningless without an active revolutionary Marxist-feminist movement. I am going to give a quick overview of social reproduction in modern capitalism before looking at how the house of cards came tumbling down in the pandemic and how our struggle might go forward. Enjoy.
1. WHAT IS SOCIAL REPRODUCTION IN MODERN CAPITALISM?
In all societies, work needs to be done to reproduce humans. We are gestated, birthed and nurtured as children, fed and clothed, cared for and listened to as adults and as older people. We are also socialized, educated, and disciplined with the necessary skills and knowledge to play the required roles of that society. In capitalism that includes ‘knowing your place’ as a future worker, boss, care-giver or receiver. In capitalism social reproduction is at once: an act of love and affection; an act of reproducing labour power for the needs of capitalist exploitation; and a mechanism by which class, sex and race inequalities are learned and reinforced.
The history of ‘work’
The advent of industrial capitalism in Europe forced us to accept the wage as the principal form of subsistence for small family units, and created a divide between the public and private spheres.1 Mostly, men took on the responsibility for the waged work (even if ‘his’ wife and child also did some of it): ‘important,’ visible, directly surplus-value producing, and regulated by certain formal social contracts. Partly due to the care of small children, including breastfeeding, the woman ended up in the private sphere: unwaged, ‘unimportant,’ invisible, necessary for capital but not directly surplus-value producing, and unregulated.2 This family-household system, embedded by the mid-19th century, is at once the social relations and concept of the family, and the economic unit of the household.3 This assumed (and sometimes enforced) heterosexual system hinges on the idea of the family unit being dependent on the man for the wage and on the woman for the invisible domestic work, setting up unequal power relations. The myth perpetuated is that of ‘naturally’ gendered and hierarchical roles forming a loving bond of kinship, a private haven away from the harsh world of ‘work.’Work under capitalism produces profit for capital in an immediate sense (the boss paying you less than what the product is sold for). Social reproduction, however, produces the workers who do the work, i.e. it produces the labour power, or potential labour power, the only commodity that produces surplus value that can be extracted in the form of ‘profit.’ 4 What is considered ‘necessary’ to reproduction changes according to the norms of that historical moment in that place; for example, central heating and the internet are now necessary.
Much has changed in terms of work organization over the last 60 years in Europe and elsewhere. Women, who have always done paid work, are increasingly represented in all areas of public life. Many women, especially middle-class women and those without children, have achieved the liberal aim of ‘equality.’ Although a nasty surprise awaits such a woman when she has children and finds out that the ‘second shift’ is still very much a thing.
The myth of ‘natural’ femininity
The biggest trick that patriarchal capitalism played on women is the pretence that social reproduction is not work, but rather a natural ‘feminine’ activity. The great insight of the Wages for Housework movement was the articulation and demand that it is work. Giving birth does not translate into an automatic responsibility for the laundry, cooking, toilet cleaning, homework help, etc. for the next 18 years. It is naturalized to the extent that women are actually seen to have some of these characteristics as innate; that women are more caring, patient, kind, ‘good at multitasking’ and naturally skilled at cleaning. Nevertheless, it needs to be done. Again and again and again, on a daily basis, by humans. Some of this is organized as waged work, and some not, some in the home, some not, varying according to the specific economic, social and personal situation at any time. What is true is that it is still overwhelmingly done by women.Unwaged in the home
The thing we mostly think of as social reproduction is the unwaged work done in the home: the childcare, cooking, cleaning, relationship maintaining and emotional labour, typically done by the woman in the family-household system. It is so undervalued and so invisible that it is only seen when it is not done (the unwashed dishes, the neglected child). In the UK, and in fact globally, in heterosexual families with both partners working, women still do the bulk of the domestic work.5Waged in the home
One example of ‘waged in the home’ is the urban middle classes employing low-waged, often black, brown or immigrant women, to do domestic work such as cleaning, childcare, or care for disabled or elderly relatives. This is transferring the work down the class chain, the sex element staying the same, with some women even moving countries to do domestic work, leaving their own children with their grandma.6The work remains not only done by women, but still the responsibility of the woman of the house. According to bourgeois ideology the individual middle- or upper-class woman may go to her career job when she has arranged for the cleaner and childminder to do ‘her’ work. It is not seen as the responsibility of the system or even the family system to ensure this work gets done.
Unwaged outside the home/community networks
Community networks are built up by women including neighbours, friends, relatives, and the mums of your kid’s friends, and are a vital informal unpaid resource for things such as reciprocal childcare arrangements, handing down of clothes and equipment, advice and support, and free childcare. These are necessary for the private family sphere to function. The idea of the self-sufficient ‘nuclear’ family is a myth of storybooks. The emotional and social labour of keeping good relations with your community (kinkeeping) is work in itself, and can be absolutely necessary for survival, especially for low-income women. At best, this is enriching for women and children and a site of potential ‘commons’ — the practice of reproduction outside of capital relations whereby the group holds and shares resources, knowledge and time to the benefit of the group, and develops its own structures; a political practice of reclaiming what was enclosed by capitalist relations.7 At worst, this keeps women stuck in situations that are potentially abusive or damaging, as leaving the community would make her social reproduction impossible, with exacerbating factors including poverty and regressive or conservative cultures.Waged outside the home
There is a growing formalized sector of social reproduction outside of the home. The education system from pre-school to college is essential to reproducing potential labour power, and of course functions for childcare, socialization, feeding the children, and nursing minor injuries.In hospitals and care homes this work can never be automated, but it can be organized with a tendency to intensification and division of labour, and it becomes increasingly alienated. Even jobs such as midwifery take on this character in busy maternity units with several wards. The woman moves from room to room depending on if she is in early labour, in established labour and delivery, or immediately postnatal.
There are all those cooking in schools, nurseries, workplaces, and lunchtime cafes. Those preparing the sandwiches and ready meals necessary to feed the workers and their families faster, so they can spend more time on labour that does produce surplus value. In this sphere there is a debate as to what is counted as ‘social reproduction,’ and what is simply ‘production,’ such as the profit-making leisure industry.
Just before the pandemic, some middle-class women, even with children, were living a relatively ‘man-like’ existence, albeit with some extra work arranging childminder contracts, paying the cleaner and receiving the veg box. Some working-class women were working and doing the ‘second shift’ at home but making it work with a patchwork of statutory provision and a network of informal help. And then…
2. SURPRISE!!! ALONG CAME A PANDEMIC!!!
This fundamentally altered the possibilities for how social reproduction is organized and in doing so revealed some painful truisms about the myths of gender equality in neoliberal capitalism.
Social reproduction structures removed
Many of the structures propping up the ever-shifting pendulum of how we organize social reproduction simply ceased. Much of the waged, public-sphere structure shut: schools and nurseries, after-school and weekend clubs, cafes providing relatively cheap meals, sports facilities. Much of the unwaged informal structure was no longer possible: grandparents, neighbours, reciprocal mum-to-mum childcare. All but the lifesaving waged work in the home ceased: cleaners, childminders, babysitters all stopped coming. Leaving only the one form: unwaged, in the home. The house of cards came crashing down. Middle-class families came face to face with the reality that they had been reliant on other (poorer) women’s reproductive labour to function and to prop up the illusion of gender equality.Dumped back into the home—and, it soon became clear, dumped primarily on the woman — was the need to replace all the things that were being done: schoolwork, nursery care, kids’ sport and social interaction, lunch production and clearing and more.8 Women were asked to do all that and still do their 37 hours at paid jobs. The reason this was even considered possible was because all the work had previously been invisible.
Waged work into the home
The other major change was the relocation of some waged work into the home, where the unwaged work has always been; mums have always ‘worked from home.’ The public/private split partly functioned to make the social reproduction work invisible and ‘natural’ by positioning ‘real work’ (waged, valued, regulated) as something done in a workplace for specified hours. So, what happens if waged and unwaged work both take place in the home? In households with heterosexual couples where both are in paid employment, the woman is by default expected to pick up the slack. A recent study showed when both partners are ‘working from home’ the woman does one hour of uninterrupted paid work at a stretch, compared with three hours by the man.9Working class essential workers still working
Enabling those working from home to protect their health are low-waged essential workers still going out to work. Here again women are disproportionately represented. Women are more likely to be doing both unpaid social reproduction inside the home and paid social reproduction outside the home. Many jobs done by men, especially middle-class white men, moved online and into the home, and these men were less likely to leave those jobs to care for children. The ‘essential’ work includes a large proportion of women doing social reproduction work because, in the end, it is reproducing our daily life that is classed as essential. In the US, one in three jobs held by women has been designated as essential.10Low paid, with a low social status (until the new craze for clapping and the ‘heroes and angels’ narrative further reinforced the idea of the work as an innate attribute)—it is women, often black and brown women, cleaning the hospitals, working in the care homes, packing food in supermarkets for next-day delivery. Women are disproportionately doing hands-on care work, exposing them to COVID-19 risk. In the UK in 2020, 79% of health care workers hospitalized with the virus were women.11
Recession, inequality, and unemployment
Due to both their position in the labour market and their assumed responsibility for the domestic sphere, women have suffered most of the job losses in the pandemic. In the UK, a report by the Institute of Fiscal Studies published in May 2020 showed mothers were 47% more likely than fathers to have permanently lost their jobs or quit during the crisis.12 In the US, 2.3 million women left the workforce altogether to care for their children due to the lack of the social structures of school and nursery.13
US scholar Catherine Powell points out that, in the US, “Blacks and Latinxs are more likely to be unemployed due to the impacts of the pandemic on the labor market, but they are also overrepresented among essential workers who must stay in their jobs, particularly lower-skilled positions, where they are at greater risk of exposure to the virus … women and people of color make up the majority of both essential workers and the unemployed.”14
If you liked school, you’ll love work!
Schooling — both education and childcare of four- to 16-year-olds—has been in the public sector for so long that it is not seen as ‘domestic’ work, but it is nonetheless essential social reproduction. The shock of ‘home-schooling’ has led to an appreciation of teachers, an appreciation of the childcare and socialization that school offered, and a host of comical stories and memes as parents try and fail to follow the government curriculum. Due to their assumed responsibility, and assumed innate ability to do with all things children, women are finding themselves in the impossible role of homework discipliner, and expert on maths, grammar, geography, chemistry, etc. On the flipside there are also examples of families and children enjoying the release of not having to follow the workplace-like discipline: a break from the morning rush of trying to adhere to ridiculous uniform policies and find two matching black socks and a regulation hairband, all by 7:45am. A break for the kids from teachers monitoring their every move and being told when they can and can’t speak. For some, this opened a space for more cross-generation interaction and a possible imagining of the different forms education could take. Perhaps we really could throw the homework on the fire and take the car downtown? (Please check authorized local travel restrictions for details before taking car downtown.)
Sadly, what has also become clear is the vital role schools play in child safeguarding and in providing children in overcrowded housing a space to play and explore. Along with Guardian articles about days spent identifying leaves in the woods, there are new referrals to social services for child safeguarding or domestic violence.
3. WHAT HAVE THESE CHANGES REVEALED ABOUT SOCIAL REPRODUCTION?
Discovery 1: The invisible became visible through not being done
No one apart from mum used to notice or appreciate that grandma took the kids to the park every Tuesday, until she couldn’t, and suddenly the kids had pent-up energy and needed to go to the park and mum is working at home. The kid’s sleepover at their mate’s suddenly seems more important to society when the single mum nurse can’t do her nightshift due to childcare issues.In the US, the echoes of the radical Wages for Housework demand have returned in a glossy liberal form, in the shape of a Marshall Plan for Moms, because they are “tired of working for free” and “It’s time to put a dollar figure on our labor. Motherhood isn’t a favor and it’s not a luxury. It’s a job.”15 That this plan has all the backing of the impressive list of people and groups shown on their website is not because this is a recent discovery, but because the COVID-19 pandemic has meant that it has hit those who thought they were immune: the middle-class women.
However, unlike the Marshall Plan for Moms, the feminists behind Wages for Housework always intended it as a provocative statement to highlight the contradictions inherent in capitalism. In terms of profit from the commodity that is labour power, it would be impossible for capital to meet the demand for wages for housework, and so the demand itself reveals the need for a revolutionary overhaul of society. Any actual transitional demands made by the group at the time were for services such as children’s daycare.
Discovery 2: You cannot do a 37-hour-a-week paid job and also 24 hours a day of unpaid social reproduction
What a surprise that you cannot do a full-time job and the entire work of social reproduction simultaneously! It turns out it takes hours, and is impossible without the structures outlined above. A UK survey undertaken in July 2020 of 20,000 working mothers showed that 72% were forced to reduce their waged work hours because of a lack of childcare, 60% struggled with childcare provision, and 45% said a lack of childcare provision played a role in their redundancy. Of the employed mothers surveyed, 81% said they need childcare to be able to work, but 51% do not have the necessary childcare in place to enable them to do their job.Discovery 3: We still assume that it is ‘women’s work’
As Federici stated in 1974, the idea of Wages for Housework is:the most radical perspective we can adopt because although we can ask for everything, day care, equal pay, free laundromats, we will never achieve any real change unless we attack our female role at its roots. Our struggle for social services, i.e. for better working conditions, will always be frustrated if we do not first establish that our work is work. Unless we struggle against the totality of it we will never achieve victories with respect to any of its moments.17
(my emphasis)
And this is exactly what we have just witnessed. We had the daycare, the legal equal pay, the washing machine, but when the chips were down — because we still had our so-called ‘female role’ of natural caregiver — it all came back down to us. The myth that it is not really work, that it is our ‘natural role,’ revealed itself to be as strong as ever. “We are all housewives because no matter where we are they can always count on more work from us,” as we see from the changes to the labour market outlined above.18
It turns out, however women identify — as empowered, as a career woman, maybe not even as a woman anymore but as a non-binary person — when things are stripped back, it’s you with your toddler or teenager and the washing up. Gender is the justification of the hierarchical power-relation of the sexes, and the basis of oppression and exploitation of female labour.
Discovery 4: The myth of liberal feminist female empowerment/liberation is a concession that can be snatched away all too easily
For a certain set of women (and for the bourgeois press) the battle may have felt won as they were able to live equal to a man in a man’s world, with feminism repackaged as a seat at the boardroom table. Women went to work, had relative liberty and a social and intellectual life, and could parcel off the bit of social reproduction they didn’t fancy and keep the bits they did. They still did the ‘mental load,’ but may have enjoyed the status that came with that. But in fact these women who thought themselves insulated from much of the patriarchy were surprised when the props were removed and the gendered nature of social reproduction was laid bare.Discovery 5: The family is not always a haven in a heartless world
Without the formal and informal social structures, the family unit can provide neither basic social reproduction needs such as childcare and food production nor the ‘safety and comfort’ prevalent in mythologized versions of the heterosexual nuclear family unit. Domestic violence, intimate partner homicides, and child-safeguarding referrals have all increased over the pandemic. Additionally, the reports of domestic violence concerns from third parties have increased, revealing both the previously hidden levels, and the power of community networks.194. STRUGGLE
Reproducing revolutionaries
Along with the dual character of labour comes a dual character of the family: at once a site of exploitation and repression for some, and a site of nurturing. The family, as bell hooks explains, has for many black American women also been a place of refuge from the subjugations and humiliations of the workplace.20 She pointed out in 1998 that the liberation of the workplace fought for by liberal feminists soon soured in the reality of sexism in the workplace and the double shift. “The women’s liberationists who wanted to enter the workforce did not see this world as a world of alienated work. They do now.”21Within the complexities of the relationships of social reproduction we also have the power to subvert and revolutionize when we encounter those same relationships in moments of struggle.22 As Dalla Costa points out, each place where the woman struggles outside the home “offers to explode … the contradictions, the frustrations, that capital has wanted to implode within the family.” She writes that the female interest has been “castrated from all its connections by the capitalist organisation of the family” and in struggle these connections are found.
From sex-class consciousness to the radical struggle
Social reproduction is the only work that produces the commodity that can produce surplus value (labour power), hence the constant drive to cut the cost to capital of this work (and why ‘Wages for Housework’ is a provocative statement). Although the wealth of societies appears as an “immense collection of commodities,”23 in truth, the wealth of societies is knowledge, nature, relationships, and activity. This gives us the leverage insofar as how we organize our own social reproduction, and a back door to rebel and exit the excesses of late capitalism. Struggle against the present conditions of social reproduction, and self-organizing in new ways, could lead to forms of collective, sustainable social reproduction, and potentially, sex equality.Gonzalez states, “the reproduction of capitalism daily hides the social character of necessary gendered exploitation, and it will remain structurally obscured unless its social character is exposed by struggle.”24 We haven’t had the open struggle on a mass scale as yet, but it is starting to be structurally observed through the changes the pandemic wrought. However, class consciousness, and sex-class consciousness as developed by the ‘second wave’ feminists, is a political and structural understanding and active engagement with struggle.25 So, after the big reveal that the core gender system remains unchallenged, despite the formal wins of liberal feminism, we need to move to the next phase and use any tendencies towards the commons to ensure any movements are based on feminist principles of sex equality.
The commons
Once we have seen and quantified what we do, once we have identified the good and loving and necessary bits, and had the insight to reject what is unnecessary, what are we left with? What would radical, liberatory social reproduction look like? We can all see that social reproduction is much more valuable and important than market research, the finance sector, the production of unnecessary goods with built-in obsolescence. The ecological damage done by the drive for constant capitalist growth, and the obsession with ‘the economy’ as abstracted from real people’s lives, leads to the same question. What do we want to salvage from the wreck of late capitalism in terms of truly valuable, loving, sustainable and ecological social reproduction, and how will we do that?The self-organized social centre, with a community kitchen, childcare, resources for organizing, renters’ or squatters’ advice sessions (and even parties when the virus is gone), may originate from necessity and survival, but may well shift or even transform the social relations of those using the space. When work is done visibly, and in a social setting, an open conversation about the sex division of labour becomes much clearer than when this conversation takes place in a family setting with established sex roles (“Oh, the kids like Mummy putting them to bed, so it is just easier that way, and John always does the weekly recycling.”)
It is in the doing, in the coming together and struggling together that radical ideas, collective power, and new forms of social relations are built. For example, spaces such as the ZAD in France, over 4,000 acres of an autonomous rural community, or Grow Heathrow in the UK (sadly now evicted), are radical ecological spaces defending land from airport expansion where social reproduction was organized along egalitarian, collective, non-hierarchical lines (if not yet achieving sex equality).26 Or the ecological women’s village of Jinwar, part of the Rojava movement and built from absolute necessity; the women there are developing new collective social practices including feminist education.27 These spaces all have a connection with the land and an element of food production, and have collectivized social reproduction to a large extent. This changed the gender roles for two reasons: firstly due to the social structures that enforce these roles (practically or culturally), such as the heterosexual family, playing a much-reduced role in the organization of social reproduction. And secondly as the act of making conscious decisions about life and work organization brings up the absurdity of counting some forms of work but not others, and so makes the work visible. Once you are having a discussion about who will manage the chickens, drive to town and build the barn, then, of course, who will look after the children and cook the lunch becomes part of that discussion. Thereby the gender roles are clearer to see and change. This is not to point to such collectives as the only model or roadmap to revolutionary change (far from it; we do still need the global working-class revolution), but rather to see them as a tendency towards the commons and radical change within the cracks of a capitalism in crisis.
As some structures are stripped away in the pandemic, the assumptions that ‘this is the way things are’ start to crumble. This may get some (men) to see the ridiculousness of the way women have assumed responsibility for social reproduction. The landscape of the sexual division of labour has been laid bare. The map to a more equal and more sustainable form of human social reproduction is made in real time as we aim toward deeper understanding of the structure and how it operates. This has to include men as well as women as we reach out for ways of organizing and transforming our lives.
The seeds of the new growing in the rot of the old
In contrast to the intentional communities or commons described above, the pandemic has laid the ground for horizontal organizing to spring up in small ways in a range of ‘ordinary’ settings as we find new forms of community organizing: for example, the flourishing of neighbourhood WhatsApp groups, of mutual aid and food distribution networks.28 This is important for two reasons. Firstly, it decommodifies our work, taking it out of the sphere of the circulation of capital so no one can exploit it for profit. This is communism, or the commons, in the everyday: the better world growing in the shadow of the old. At its heart the idea of mutual aid as a community resource is more radical and empowering than the concept of charity. With this we are learning that in fact we don’t need the bosses to organize things for us; we are capable of doing it ourselves. We are learning that people are basically co-operative and helpful. And we are also finding out some mundane practical skills like how to organize, who can help fix your drain, who has a socket set, who in your area has a cooking pot for 30 people and knows how to use it. In these practices we can see forms of collectivized social reproduction that are neither mediated through capital nor retreating back into the gendered, isolated roles in the family-household system. A community kitchen is qualitatively different from the drudgery of a woman cooking alone in her kitchen. Community life where the production and reproduction are not separated off, where responsibility is collectivized and social reproduction is prioritized, become more human, more ecological and more creative spaces. Once the work is visibly for everyone, then there is a leverage or tendency for it to become done by everyone, women and men (after all, being acknowledged for one’s work makes it more appealing to do!).And the second reason is that when we struggle, these are the networks we will use: the informal and community networks of social reproduction, alongside waged workers’ struggle based on connections made in the formal workplace.
This pandemic has stripped bare what was always true but hidden about the realities of work, social reproduction, and the sexual division of labour. But also about what is important and valued in our lives, and the wealth we have in our own communities. And therein lie the vibrant shoots of a better world.
Anna Ziggy Melamed lives in the UK and works for the NHS in women’s health. She has been a political activist and thinker as long as she can remember, mostly in the autonomist Marxist, anti-capitalist and left-feminist movements. She tweets at @sally_paradise.
1 Friedrich Engels, The Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State, trans. by Alick West (New York: International Publishers, 1942; first published in Hottingen-Zürich, 1884).
2 Gabrielle Palmer, The Politics of Breastfeeding (London: Pinter & Martin, 1988)
3 Michele Barrett, Women’s Oppression Today (London: Verso Editions and NLB, 1980).
4 Johanna Brenner and Maria Ramas, ‘Rethinking Women’s Oppression,’ New Left Review 1.144 (1984); Leopoldina Fortunati, The Arcane of Reproduction: Housework, Prostitution, Labor and Capital (Brooklyn, NY: Autonomedia, 1995); Maya Gonzalez, ‘The gendered circuit: Reading the arcane of reproduction,’ Viewpoint Magazine, 28 September 2013.
5 According to data from the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, the number of minutes women in the UK spend on unpaid work per day is 249 compared with 140 for men. In Ireland the ratio is 293 to 127. ‘Employment: Time spent in paid and unpaid work, by sex,’ OECD.
6 Barbara Ehrenreich and Arlie Russell Hochschild, Global Woman: Nannies, Maids, and Sex Workers in the New Economy (New York: Metropolitan Books, 2003).
7 For an introduction to these ideas, see The Commoner, 6 (2003).
8 Alexandra Topping and Niamh McIntyre, ‘UK school closures mean mothers will take twice as much unpaid leave as fathers—poll,’ The Guardian, 8 January 2021.
9 Alexandra Topping, ‘Working mothers interrupted more often than fathers in lockdown—study,’ The Guardian, 27 May 2020.
10 Campbell Robertson and Robert Gebeloff, ‘How millions of women became the most essential workers in America,’ New York Times, 18 April 2020.
11 Anoop S. V. Shah and others, ‘Risk of Hospital Admission With Coronavirus Disease 2019 in Healthcare Workers and Their Households: Nationwide Linkage Cohort Study,’ BMJ, 371:m3582 (2020).
12 Alison Andrew and others, ‘How Are Mothers and Fathers Balancing Work and Family Under Lockdown?’ IFS Briefing Note BN290, May 2020.
13 Arwa Mahdawi, ‘The pandemic made the childcare crisis an urgent talking point—will the US finally change things?’ The Guardian, 16 January 2021, ; Courtney Connley, ‘A year ago, women outnumbered men in the US workforce, now they account for 100% of jobs lost in December,’ CNBC, 11 January 2021.
14 Catherine Powell, ‘The color and gender of COVID: Essential workers, not disposable people,’ ThinkGlobalHealth, 4 June 2020.
15 Marshall Plan for Moms, www.marshallplanformoms.com.
16 ‘The true scale of the crisis facing working mums,’ Pregnant Then Screwed.
17 Silvia Federici, Wages Against Housework (Bristol: Power of Women Collective/Falling Wall Press, 1975), p. 6.
18 Federici, p. 8.
19 ‘Domestic Abuse During the Coronavirus (COVID-19) Pandemic, England and Wales,’ Office for National Statistics, November 2020.
20 bell hooks, Feminist Theory: From Margin to Center (Cambridge, MA: South End Press, 2000).
21 bell hooks, ‘bell hooks Revolutionary Parenting,’ in Families in the U.S.: Kinship and Domestic Politics, ed. by Karen V. Hansen and Anita Ilta Garey (Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press, 1998), p. 588.
22 “To meet your sons and daughters at a student assembly is to discover them as individuals who speak among other individuals; it is to present yourself to them as an individual.” Mariarosa Dalla Costa and Selma James, The Power of Women and the Subversion of the Community (Bristol, England: Falling Wall Press, 1973), pp. 36-37.
23 Karl Marx, ‘Ernest Mandel (Introduction),’ Capital: A Critique of Political Economy, trans. by Ben Fowkes (London: Penguin Classics, 1992), p. 125.
24 Gonzalez, ‘Gendered circuit.’
25 Jo Freeman, ‘The Origins of the Women’s Liberation Movement,’ American Journal of Sociology, 78.4 (1973), 792-811; “Thus we must never overlook the distance that separates the consciousness of even the most revolutionary worker from the authentic class consciousness of the proletariat. But even this situation can be explained on the basis of the Marxist theory of class struggle and class consciousness. The proletariat only perfects itself by annihilating and transcending itself, by creating the classless society through the successful conclusion of its own class struggle.” Georg Lukács, History & Class Consciousness, trans. by Rodney Livingstone (Great Britain: Merlin Press, 1967, first published 1920).
26 ZAD Autonomous Zone; see also Wikipedia, ‘Zone to Defend’; Grow Heathrow.
27 Jinwar Women’s Village, Facebook page, and ‘Jinwar Women’s Village,’ Co-operation in Mesopotamia.
28 For example, the women-run food co-op or www.actiontogether.org.uk/mutual-aid or www.opendemocracy.net/en/openmovements/creating-hyperlocal-infrastructure-care-covid-19-mutual-aid-groups/ or this zine introduction to mutual aid.
