by Sarah Field
There is a rotten core of misogyny in Leeds. And the heart of the matter is the city’s so-called ‘managed approach’ to prostitution. It is an approach that has become so entrenched—its ideology reeled off in careless monotone — that the ever-mounting evidence of its abject failure means nothing to Leeds City Council’s administration.
The ‘managed approach’ was piloted in October 2014 by Leeds City Council and extended in 2015. The core principle of the policy is that men are allowed to buy sex between 8pm and 6am within a designated zone just outside the city centre in Holbeck. Holbeck itself is a mixed residential and entertainment neighbourhood, with two trendy and updated areas designed to attract young professionals and new families. The managed zone is ‘limited’ to an older, rather bleak industrial area in Holbeck that directly abuts a dense residential area. The claim is that the zone is policed and that drug use, trafficking, organized crime, coercion and indecency are not tolerated, therefore keeping the women safe. Over the years since I resigned the Labour whip in 2017 to become an independent councillor, I’ve seen the reality of this monstrous experiment and have been campaigning to divert the funds into proper, robust, and meaningful exit strategies for the prostituted women of Holbeck.
Indeed, this is in line with the best practice guidance issued by the Association of Chief Police Officers in 2011, which explained very clearly that street prostitution should be tackled in a three-pronged approach:
This strategy, therefore, promotes a holistic approach to the policing of prostitution that keeps in balance the three essential elements of individual, community, and the investigation and prosecution of those who exploit and abuse. It is not possible to effectively choose between these three facets of effective policing; they must operate simultaneously and sustainably.1
The money from the council (around £300,000 per financial year) is currently spent on street cleansing associated with the detritus of the sex trade, the salaries of two police officers, and funding for Basis Yorkshire. Basis is an organization which “works to end stigma, create safety and promote empowerment for sexworkers.”2 Rather than freeing women from prostitution, it believes ‘sex work is work’ which can be made safe for women, and respectable for men, to engage in as an entirely normal and empowering transaction. They also heavily lobbied the council to actively tolerate demand by incorporating impunity for punters into council policy.
According to the Facebook page of the Joanna Project, a charity helping the women with frontline support such as food and clothing, 16 prostituted women have died in recent years; there is a memorial stone for each of them in their garden.3 One, Daria Pionko, was brutally murdered. I’ve spent many hours in Holbeck (in reality, street prostitution is rife outside the boundaries of the official zone and is especially problematic in surrounding residential and industrial retail areas) and talking to local people.4 The area is awash with the very dregs of male degeneracy. Pimps and johns openly roam around the streets, parks, and playgrounds. I was approached for sex twice in the early afternoon, just standing on a pavement for a period of 20 minutes. The prostituted women of the managed zone are emaciated and virtually all of them are hooked on heroin or crack, according to sources within the outreach teams that work in Holbeck. One only has to take a cursory look at the various punter networking sites to see that Holbeck is a sex-tourist destination. I’ve seen rows of cars parked up by the main children’s playground, with men sitting and watching pornography on their phones. In November 2020, the head teacher of The Ruth Gorse Academy Ben Mallinson said he feared his pupils would be harmed, as a 13-year-old girl spoke about being approached by men for sex. 6 Many women do not go out after dark.
The local residents’ group Save Our Eyes (SOE) was set up to lobby the council to scrap the managed approach. They recently gave me this statement:
We do not accept the cohort of women trapped in street prostitution in Holbeck are there by choice. We see them living in abject poverty, sometimes searching street bins and gutters for scraps of food or cigarettes. Yet these women are some of Holbeck’s highest earners … so where does their money go? Far from empowering them to live comfortable lives and own their own homes, the money goes straight to their drug dealers and pimps/boyfriends. The women live on benefits and food bank donations while their earnings are stripped from them systematically, along with their health and mental well-being. SOE eventually saw that the situation is more akin to modern slavery. Due to media reports that Leeds now had a ‘legal red-light zone’ where predators would not be arrested, men flocked here from other cities by car and train to consume the women. This led to more women being trafficked into Leeds to meet the new demand. These men cruise the residential streets looking for women and children to purchase sexual services from. Female residents and school children are approached on a daily basis. Any woman, of any age, is a target. Sex acts take place in residents’ gardens, the parks, the streets, and the phone box on the high street. Used condoms and drug syringes are ditched at the point of use.7
The report shows that, by any measure, from limiting the areas where prostitution happens to limiting the time of day or the presence of other anti-social factors like hard drugs, the managed zone is a manifest failure. What I’ve come to learn is that there isn’t a single radical feminist among the 35 women in the Labour administration in Leeds. This is a party I supported, lived and breathed for decades. And Holbeck is yet another example of how it has abandoned class analysis in favour of gender-identity ideology and identity politics. You would think that women on the left could get behind a radical feminist analysis of prostitution and that they could grasp the clarity of women such as Fiona Broadfoot and Julie Bindel. That they could want for other women’s daughters what they want for their own. But no. They are unwilling, and perhaps unable, to see women as a sex class and therefore address the contextual and systemic issues around violence, education, and employment that box women into this ‘free choice,’ which is precisely what they should be concerned with. And this dearth of feminist analysis is evident across the council and its policymaking. The last-minute capitulation to extreme transactivists in 2018 is a notorious example. This saw the cancellation of a Woman’s Place UK meeting to discuss the proposed reforms to the Gender Recognition Act. The meeting was cancelled on the day it was due to take place because Labour councillor Jessica Lennox demanded it in an email to the council leader, in which she claimed that WPUK is a transphobic organization that wanted to hold, in Lennox’s words, “a hate rally.” The lack of feminist analysis was also evident when council officers refused to acknowledge any feminist objections to the inherent misogyny and associated social-media output of its ‘drag queen story hour,’ hosted by Leeds Libraries. Many women objected to children being presented with the sexualized stereotypes of drag, features the council called ‘nuances,’ which children are too young to understand. The photos of small children touching the drag queen’s fake breasts, his teaching children as young as three that men can be women and declaring that “love has no age,” also present, at the very least, problematic questions around whose rights are being centred at Leeds Libraries.9Daughter walking down Rydall Terrace … man approached her in a car and asked if she wanted to earn any more, when she said no, he asked if her friends did … She was also approached whilst at high school in her uniform, she was asked if she wanted sex, if she would give a blow job … It has happened to my friends’ children too … this was at 2.15pm in the afternoon, outside of the zone. — Resident, July 2019
A man said that “my wife doesn’t feel safe going out” (February 2019), a sentiment that was echoed by other men in relation to their partners’ safety, and several women. He went on to talk about the ‘Holbeck Look’ that women get from men looking for sex, when they are debating if female residents are sex workers or not: “That is what my wife says, she says I can feel safe … but she can’t … I don’t have to think about what I wear … my wife on the school run will wear jeans, a baseball cap, hoodie … she hasn’t got a choice … I tell her to get a taxi but she feels that we shouldn’t have to pay when we should be able to walk. — Male community resident from Beeston, July 2019
Radical feminism is given no truck whatsoever by Leeds City Council. And I’ve come to the conclusion that it must be due to either laziness or just an intellectual inability to grasp why issues such as prostitution and our sex-based rights are vitally important. I, and others, have offered many times to develop a different approach to Leeds street prostitution. In May 2019, I chaired a conference at Leeds Civic Hall with international survivors of the sex trade. Not one single councillor from the administration attended, despite all being invited. They display a wilful misunderstanding of the Nordic Model, which I’ve spoken about three times in full council and implored them to consider. Either way, it’s a tragedy for women and for local government. Why are women afraid to speak out and stand up? Since when did being a local councillor mean you had to abandon feminism? Some might claim to be feminists, but the council is so firmly entrenched in the liberal view that prostitution can be a normal, modern, and go-getting career that I reject any claim they make to being woman-centred in any practical, material, or ideological sense.
I see this time and time again. At a recent licensing panel where a large festival was up for consideration, there was only an obsession with ensuring the provision of mixed-sex toilets. This at a time when we know young women and girls are at risk from sexual assault and drug crimes at such events. Indeed, our own segregated restroom for female councillors is now open to any male councillor who says he is a woman, even if part time, whatever any of that actually means. This is a telling detail; Leeds has introduced self-identification in all of its buildings and services. Self-ID can be done online with no requirement for a Gender Recognition Certificate. The central thread running through Leeds policy making is the centring of the male. Whether it’s wearing fake breasts to read to infants, capturing female spaces on their say-so, or using women for sex under the guise of a benign financial transaction.
This flagrant violation of women’s fundamental sex-based rights is evident at its most acute in the managed approach. It is managed for men, it is managed for the police, and it is managed for the drug dealers and the pimps and the traffickers. Where is the ideological condemnation of this hell hole? How can this have continued for eight years without council members standing up for the abolishment of street prostitution as a primary aim of any public policy? The only conclusion I can reach is that the position has become entrenched: anything is permissible to avoid a political volte-face. The purposeful refusal to listen to feminists and survivors of the sex trade, such as Rachel Moran, who writes in her book Paid For that “a woman’s compliance in prostitution is a response to circumstances beyond her control and this produces an environment which prohibits even the possibility of true consent,” means the streets of Holbeck are our national shame.10
What’s more, prostitution should be abolished. It is an entirely reasonable imperative. And the only way to do that is to tackle the demand. The managed approach treats men as consumers who can drive demand with impunity. It’s the demand, the consumers, who really keep this whole thing happening, and the zone offers not only immunity from prosecution but a veneer of dignity to their ‘hobby.’ To end prostitution, five things must happen:
- Decriminalization of those who are prostituted.
- Provision of high-quality services and ring-fenced funding for those in prostitution.
- Criminalization of buying sex.
- Resourcing and prioritization of policing for sex trafficking, to include procuring and pimping.
- Establishment of widespread holistic approaches to public information campaigns, education programmes in schools, and training for the police.
Cllr Sarah Field is a local councillor who represents the Garforth and Swillington ward in Leeds, as a member of the Garforth and Swillington Independents Party. She is from Leeds and read English Literature at Edinburgh University. A mum of two, Sarah lives in Garforth and is a radical feminist.
1 DCC Simon Byrne and DI Marcus Noden, ACPO Strategy & Supporting Operational Guidance for Policing Prostitution and Sexual Exploitation, Association of Chief Police Officers, October 2011, p. 4.
2 Basis Yorkshire, ‘About Us.
3 Joanna Project, Facebook post, 9 December 2020.
4 To get a flavour of the issues raised by the managed zone for local people see the ‘Holbeck Managed Approach’ section of local news website Leeds Live
5 Kristian Johnson, ‘Life for Leeds sex workers told through the sordid online reviews left by punters,’ Leeds Live, 28 July 2020.
6 ‘Pupils approached for sex in Holbeck’s managed red light zone,’ BBC, 10 November 2020.
7 Note to readers: the landing page at Save Our Eyes is deliberately graphic. ‘About the Zone,’ Save Our Eyes.
8 ‘Listening Well Report: Findings,’ South Leeds Life, January 2021.
9 Leeds City Council, email to Angryresister, cited on Mumsnet, 23 October 2020.
