by Min Donner
Witches didn’t like to talk about it, because they’d made a big mistake about the elves. They’d seen through the buggers in the end, of course, but it had been a close thing. And there’d been a lot of witches in those days. Too many women found an empty cradle …1
When Sir Terry Pratchett wrote Lords and Ladies in 1992, he couldn’t possibly have foreseen what an apt metaphor it would be for our own GC struggle in these days of plague. The 14th book in the Discworld series, a loosely connected set of fantasy pastiches that increasingly used the setting to explore complex real-world themes, is the third to feature his squabbling three-witch coven as main protagonists. The story is, on the surface, a mix of Celtic folklore and A Midsummer Night’s Dream, with hostile magic forces trying to break through into the human world to take power and cause havoc. But for adding a mythic sheen to our journey, we could do far worse than this as an analogy — it’s an old tale of female power brought up to date with Pratchett’s wry, humanist storytelling.
Let’s meet the witches.
Nanny Ogg, urban matriarch, is a jolly old grandmother with one remaining tooth and “an expression of near-terminal good nature,” growing old disgracefully as everyone’s favourite badly behaved nana (p. 17). As the Mumsnet analogue, she’s the cheerful heart of the community who will nonetheless stop at nothing to defend her family.
Magrat Garlick, with a hippy-art-teacher wardrobe and an “air of good-natured hopefulness” is our younger libfem, full of cringing platitudes about “empowerment” and a tendency to prefer shiny fairy tales over reality — but, once peaked, she has enough inner witchiness to join the good fight (p. 17).
And then there’s Granny Weatherwax, a hatchet-faced crone who might be described as “striking” but never “beautiful,” and whose iron self-control is proof against whatever the world can throw at it. The unofficial leader of the coven, she represents uncompromising materiality and practical action; she knows about hard work, hard choices and hard realities. She can recognise a magical unicorn as nothing but “a damn great horse with a horn on the end,” and she’d be picking pieces of Judith Butler out of her teeth (p. 171).
It’s Midsummer in the mountain kingdom of Lancre, and strange things are afoot. The walls of the world are thin, and the elves are looking for a way in. These aren’t Tolkien’s saintly elves, or twee Victorian fairies — these are the cold, cruel sprites of older myth, whose only aim is their own pleasure, and if that comes at the expense of others’ pain, so much the better. The elves do have a queen, but I think it’s no accident that the rest of them are coded male.
What they like to get from us is our fear. What they want from us most of all is our belief. (p. 101)
Belief and fear are the elves’ main weapons — they project a glamour that makes their ordinary, foxy faces appear beautiful; they can read minds, so people try to think the right thoughts in self-defence.
You can tell when elves are around. People act funny. They stop thinking clear. (p. 117)
The townsfolk appease them by leaving out gifts and adapting their language; elves can only be mentioned using polite euphemisms (“the fair folk,” “the shining ones”), until words change their meanings altogether. So far, so stunning and brave; these standard hallmarks of tyranny have a very familiar feel.
The thing about words is that meanings can twist like a snake, and if you want to find snakes look for them behind words that have changed their meanings. (p. 123)
When you’re lonely, and people around you seem too stupid for words, and the world is full of secrets that no-one’ll tell you … (p. 101)
They haven’t yet learned the wisdom to first examine what the costs of this power might be, or to realise when they’re being used.
She gave you power for a while … And then there is less power and more price. And then no power, and you’re payin’ every day. They always take more than they give. And what they give has less than no value. And they end up taking everything. (p. 101)
Of course, the elves find a way in, and there follows a long night of cruelty and destruction as they indulge their whims and attempt to gain a permanent foothold in the world. But the witches fight back. Mumsnet Nanny rounds up the townspeople into a makeshift army; Libfem Magrat discovers a core of radfem steel; and Granny stands off against the Queen, anchored in her long experience of the earthy realities of births and deaths, of growing and ageing, and of what’s real and what isn’t—the iron in the head that fairy magic can’t withstand.
Ultimately, the witches triumph — but instead of destroying the elves, something much more interesting happens. Nanny brings the boys in to get their house in order.
Because, it turns out, there’s another fairyland, split from the original by a long-ago disagreement — the home of mythic masculinity. I don’t even have to stretch for this analogy; it’s right there explicit in the text, spelled out with hilarious crudity that’s also rather the point. The entranceway is narrow and guarded, and there’s not much room inside, fitting well with the rigorously enforced bro-code of male gender conformity, where man-cards can be revoked at the drop of an insufficiently manly hat. Nanny, wise in the ways of the world, knows that only by reconciling these two branches of fairyland can the errant faction be stopped from trying to break out and take what isn’t theirs. And, in no uncertain terms, backed up with threats of iron, she tells the King to come get his people.
Wack-fol-a-diddle, etcetera.
Right now, the night of the elves is upon us; the castle walls are being breached and our forces are scattered. But the lessons from Lancre are good ones. We hold firm to reality, we grow our forces, and at last we hold to account the gatekeepers of traditional masculinity who helped to create this monster. When there’s a place within manhood for gender-non-conforming men, the few predators among them will have one less place to hide, and our boundaries will be strong enough to keep them at bay.
Gather your broomsticks, sisters; we have work to do.
Min Donner is an artist and book critic living in West Sussex, UK.
1 Terry Pratchett, Lords and Ladies (London: Gollancz, 1992), p. 98.
