by Shambolic Neutral
What’s wrong with you? Why are you like this? Why do you always do this? Must we go through this again? Why can’t you be like the other girls? You’re not normal. You’re hard work. Just calm down. Stop being so excited. Why can’t you remember things? Why aren’t you more like your female cousin/female friend? That’s not ladylike. Why don’t you behave like a proper girl? No one likes girls who are loud/funny/clever. Why won’t you tidy your room? Stop showing off. Stop thinking the rules don’t apply to you. Sit down. Sit still. Stop it. Stop that. Stop. STOP.
Women like me have lived half, or maybe more than half, of our lives being made to feel like we are losers, freaks, weirdos, failures, abnormal, unnatural, not real girls, and certainly not proper women. Knowing that we are different. Blaming ourselves and being blamed by others when jobs, relationships, friendships and more go wrong.
But it’s not like we’re the only girls and women who are treated like this. To be female is to be automatically wrong and a failure under patriarchy. The story of women with ADHD is the story of all girls and women, really. It just throws certain things into sharper focus. Failure by a medical community which uses the male body as the default setting for humans and which is under increasing ideological pressure to deny that female bodies even exist. Being treated as though we are freaks and inferior females if we do not or cannot conform to gendered expectations. Condemnation of behaviour that in boys would be perfectly acceptable or would gain them an early diagnosis of ADHD, but which in girls and women is wrongly pathologized as mental health issues or personal moral failings.
When you read a comprehensive list of the traits of ADHD, you will see a pattern emerging: many characteristics that we code as masculine are also indicators of ADHD. Boys and men with ADHD are failed when such traits are dismissed as “boys will be boys” or “you know what men are like,” but these gender stereotypes also make their behaviours more socially acceptable. Whereas girls and women receive no such understanding for their ADHD traits. There is little scope in a gendered society — a patriarchy — for us to understand or accept that ‘female’ can be messy, daredevil, loud, non-domestic, highly sexual, and so on.
Briefly put, ADHD is a neurological disorder caused by an imbalance of, or an inability to efficiently utilize and regulate, certain hormones and neurotransmitters within the brain: primarily dopamine, but also adrenaline and noradrenaline, epinephrine and norepinephrine. Wrongly thought of by many as a mental health condition, it is in fact the world’s most common learning difficulty, one which doesn’t negatively impact the intellect. Across its three subtypes, ADHD leads to a host of difficulties, primarily with executive function, which is what some call ‘adulting.’ Organization, motivation, task prioritizing and task switching, setting external goals, time management, being able to follow sequences of activities, setting up positive habits, delayed gratification, and consistency of effort are incredibly difficult, often impossible, for people with ADHD. Short-term memory issues, restlessness, extreme fidgeting, and a lack of social inhibition and object permanence, including towards people (which most people conquer in early childhood), complicate things further.
People with ADHD suffer very easily from ‘overwhelm,’ have poor emotional regulation, are usually either hypersexual or asexual, and have sleep and circadian-rhythm issues; the majority have a comorbidity called rejection sensitive dysphoria, which makes you believe that you have to be perfect, that no one could like you or want you, that everything you do is terrible, inadequate, and a failure. Impulsivity, a lack of sense of danger, and the drive for more dopamine mean that people with the condition struggle to focus on the entirety of a situation, spot red flags, and conceptualize potential outcomes. People with ADHD are therefore extremely vulnerable to things like abusive relationships, exploitation, getting embroiled in petty crime, addiction, and dying in accidents or causing them. Contrary to common myths, ADHD is not a condition where you lack focus or attention, but where you actually focus too much and too widely without discriminating. It is hard to concentrate on what someone is saying when information about everything else in your environment, including the dust motes in the air, is flooding your brain at the same time, and is given equal importance by that brain.
Again, many of these things are routinely excused in men and seen as masculine: being forgetful, not listening to people or remembering what they’ve said, not being able to organize themselves at home despite being dynamic at the job they love (the classic ‘man baby’ trope), being brash, opinionated, tactless, impulsive, and horny. All of these things are entirely familiar to us in men … but what about women with these traits? There is no mental or physical space for us; that women like this exist is ignored and denied.
There are many benefits to having ADHD, but even its positive expressions are coded as masculine or as desirable, meaningful and normal only in men. Hyperfocus (which people on the autistic spectrum also experience) can allow ADHDers to produce dazzling, visionary and groundbreaking work in relatively short periods of time: Einstein, Stephen Hawking and Walt Disney all had ADHD, as do Olympic gymnastics great Simone Biles and acting polymaths including Zooey Deschanel, Michelle Rodriguez and Audra McDonald, winner of more Tony awards than any other performer in history. Being charismatic, creative, funny and iconoclastic is actually part of the diagnosis for ADHD, exemplified by Robin Williams and Jim Carrey. ADHD exists evolutionarily to produce people who are great in a crisis, courageous without care for self, and able to keep others safe and happy: people with ADHD still display these qualities every day.
The trouble with all these noteworthy characteristics is that women are not gender-coded as funny and charismatic. We’re not gender-coded as brave or courageous or heroic. We’re not gender-coded as groundbreakers and rebels. We’re not gender-coded as the mad professor, the rockstar, the romantic artist (starving in his garret), and we’re especially not gender-coded as the visionary pioneer. No, what women and girls are gender-coded as is quiet, self-contained, passive, inactive, docile helpmeets who exist to please and to toil domestically for others, keeping them organized and making their real lives possible, and as sexual objects with no agency of their own, glittering surfaces onto which men can project their desires, hopes, needs, fears and hatred.
Now, tell me how you can be and do all those things when you have a severe executive-function disorder which renders you neurologically incapable of organizing housework, of seeing that repetitive chores need to be done, not once, but over and over again. When your impulsivity and lack of social introversion mean that you are not always reliable and that you will not stand for any shit, not for yourself or for anyone else — you will always speak your mind, always answer back, always argue, always challenge and scorn authority. When your emotional dysregulation means that you’re not going to be all sweetness and light. When you are hypersexual and the urge to obtain dopamine from sex drives you far more than any cultural ideas about how females should behave sexually. When the very nature of your brain means that you cannot sit still, will not sit still, cannot be docile, cannot remember the rules of how to be a girl and then a woman, and don’t see why you should obey them anyway.
People with ADHD exhaust themselves by doing something called masking. We learn to pretend to be things that we are not, to try to fit in, to try to at least appear acceptable—whatever that means. Women with ADHD have to learn to wear the mask of femininity, and there is a high price (social, cultural, familial, religious, relational, etc.) when we do not or cannot mask in this way. But don’t all women mask, and exhaust ourselves in the process? Gender is the demand that we mask our true selves and present only the face allowed for us by patriarchy. This is because gender is, of course, the tool utilized by patriarchy to naturalize and legitimize the oppression of girls and women by men. Gender-identity ideology, meanwhile, has been increasingly reifying gender as an immutable truth about humans, essentially insisting that gender stereotypes are what make a person male or female, not their physical sex. This is posited as progressive, liberal and inclusive, but is, in fact, deeply regressive, conservative and exclusionary. More and more, young women and girls are receiving the message that they have gender-non-conforming traits because they are actually male, rather than the truth: all these things are just as habitual in some women as they are in some men.
A 14-year-old lesbian with ADHD who prefers to wear trousers, keeps her hair short, can’t be bothered with make-up, and is loud, sporty, and boisterous can’t possibly be female, according to this movement, because she fails to identify with femininity. So, transitioning is now being quietly touted as a magical cure-all for ADHD and autism. It is alarming how many parents would rather have a trans son (with potentially lifelong medical issues) instead of having a gender-non-conforming daughter with a learning disability—instead of having to do the work, both inner and outer, to examine their own misogyny, ableism and desire to conform at all costs; and to create changes within the family structure to make it a safe place for a gender-non-conforming, neurodivergent and possibly lesbian daughter to flourish and be accepted. But we can’t entirely blame the parents. They are only reflecting the society they live in, where being female in itself is seen as a genetic, moral, cultural and even spiritual failure, before you add anything else which patriarchal-capitalist society deems inferior: race, disability, homosexuality, age, class, mental illness, neurodivergence, and so on.
What young woman would want to be a woman on those terms? Murdered at the rate of 2.5 women a week in the UK, endemic levels of rape, sexual assault and domestic abuse, brands and organizations falling over themselves to exclude any mention of the word ‘female,’ women still not paid the same as male counterparts even though the Equal Pay Act made that illegal back in 1970, job opportunities scuppered for mothers by a work culture that acts as though every employee has a 1950s housewife at home while childless and childfree women are treated like pariahs, sexualization everywhere you look, widespread normalization of violent pornography and sex practices, women still unable to walk alone after dark, women treated by the medical profession as though every issue we have is caused by mental illness, reproductive assistance and care a postcode lottery, and so much more. What girl would opt into all that, while also being told that there is no such thing as a biological woman, that a woman is a gendered essence, a gendered soul, a gendered state of mind?
And dissenting voices — who can offer all girls, but especially GNC and/or neurodivergent girls, a different way of living and understanding themselves and their world — are silenced and slandered. This alienates young women from finding ways to grow into their own power, from experiencing sisterhood, and from being told that gender is not the truth about anyone and you don’t have to do or be anything it says. Middle-aged and older neurodivergent women, so many of whom are only now being diagnosed themselves, are here to show younger neurodivergent women that you can indeed be a strong and powerful woman by refusing to have your personality, your quirks and strengths, labelled male.
As I mentioned earlier, ADHD is an evolutionarily advantageous trait, designed to make those with the condition alert to danger long before anyone else senses a thing. Girls and women with ADHD are not faulty females or half-men; we are the canaries down the gender mine. We are here to show you what happens when society invests in gender, from the women locked up in asylums a hundred years ago merely for being opinionated, feisty or sexual, to the sad-eyed, fidgeting girls sitting in gender clinics so they can finally have a chance at being the group leader, the class clown, the football champ.
We are also here to show you the way out. I did not find a diagnosis of ADHD depressing, stigmatizing, embarrassing or limiting. Quite the opposite. I found it thrillingly freeing. I am a woman who is funny, loud, a natural leader, outspoken, eccentric, crass at times, highly sexual, intelligent, opinionated, physical and expressive; I have a brain which won’t let me be anything else and I love it. But all women have gender non-conformity within them, regardless of brain type. We have to resist gender. We have to resist every word and demand of any school of thought which gives credence to gender and the hateful concept of being ‘cis.’
We resist. We be ourselves. We do not comply. We make our own rules. We make a fuss and a mess. We don’t sit nicely and we don’t stop it. As I said, the story of women with ADHD is really the story of all women. We just get an earlier start on rebellion.
Shambolic Neutral is the pseudonym of a Gen X, British radical feminist who’s been active in campaigning, studying, public speaking and writing since her teens. Being diagnosed with ADHD in 2019 has given her a new direction and she now advocates for girls and women with ADHD on social media and in her writing.
1 Sari Solden, A Radical Guide for Women with ADHD (Oakland, CA: New Harbinger, 2019).
2 Burcu Yildirim et al., ‘Gender Dysphoria and Attention Problems: Possible Clue for Biological Underpinnings,’ Psychiatry and Clinical Psychopharmacology, 3.27 (2017).
