Issue Five

The Crises for Grassroots Radical Feminism in the US

A Conversation with Elizabeth Miller, Erica Orson and Kasey Craig

Elizabeth Miller the contributing editor of Spinning and Weaving: Radical Feminism for the 21st Century, is a Chicago feminist activist who runs the Chicago Feminist Salon and co-organised the Women in Media Conference, a radical feminist conference held in Chicago in 2018. In recent years, she worked on the successful campaigns to get the US Equal Rights Amendment ratified in Illinois and to enact Illinois House Bill 40, which ensured that abortion will remain legal in Illinois even if the US Supreme Court overturns Roe v Wade. Among other projects, she is currently working with the US radical feminst organization Feminists in Struggle to lobby Congress to pass legislation protecting women’s sex-based rights and the rights of lesbian, gay, bisexual, and gender-non-conforming people, and administers the Radical Feminist Resources community on Facebook. 

Erica Orson is (the pseudonym of) an undergraduate student and writer who was born and rasied in the American South. Her writing focuses on the unique influence Southern culture has on religion, politics, and the experiences of women within and outside the LGB community. She also often writes about the harms of gender-identity ideology, pulling from research and her own past experiences in the less-than-inclusive ‘LGBTQ+’ community. You can follow her on Twitter @EricaOrson

When Kasey Craig is not working at her day job, she splits her free time evenly between writing, painting, photography, sewing, and crocheting, and is consequently passably good at all these things and a master of none of them. She is lucky to have a wife who supports her artistic endeavours and washes many more dishes than she does. Together they enjoy hiking all over Scotland with their two children and discussing how the scenery is very different from Texas, where Kasey grew up, or Mexico where she was born.

Esmée: Generally, the question that the magazine is trying to find insight into is: what’s in between American women and a really revivified grassroots women’s movement? I feel like we’ve got so much pressure from several directions all at the same time. It feels like we’re in a position almost like the second wave was in the 60s when they just had to start and build something that responded to a patriarchal world. Right? And they did, and ten years later, they were in Congress making changes. So I’m wondering how that looks to you.

Elizabeth: Well, I have some initial thoughts to share. I think about this a lot because I see what’s happening in the UK, where they’re able to get the ears of their legislators and make things happen with some efficiency. I have to admit, I get a little sensitive when I see people saying, ‘Well, women in the US, why aren’t you doing anything?’ So, okay, first of all, we are doing things, but one big problem is that everything gets very diluted here, because we’re an enormous country. And it’s so hard to just travel here. In England, they can have all those meetings very easily. Maybe someone has to drive for like two hours or take a train for two or four hours. Here, if I want to meet with someone in California, that’s an enormous commitment. It’s a three-day drive to get there from Chicago. It’s three days if you fly: two days travel and one having the meeting.

Esmée: That’s a good place to start. There’s that geographical problem. I think much of what we might bump up against is going to be structural, right? It’s going to be geography, it’s going to be travel and what that costs. Gathering will mean different things across the regions that we live in given people’s access to travel and money and time. Gathering in Vermont is a very different proposition to gathering in Texas.

Elizabeth: Which is a huge thing, because I think meeting in person is quite different from meeting online. I mean, Zoom is kind of a blessing in disguise from the pandemic, but it’s still not the same as being in person.

Esmée: There’s an energy that people share together, right?

Kasey: Women in the UK are talking about organizing in the United States: ‘Why don’t you organize the same way? You don’t have a feminist tradition.’ It hits me the wrong way. It feels unhelpful. I loved living in Scotland, but it’s not some mecca for women. There’s pros and cons about being a woman in the UK and in the US, but the UK did not feel significantly better. I really admire the organizational work that women in the UK are doing, but to look at the US and say, ‘Okay, you’re this huge monolith that doesn’t have any organization or anything possible,’ to me that feels a little bit off.

Erica: I was just thinking about the point that Elizabeth made about how we are a gigantic country, we are huge. And the sexist hurdles faced by a woman in a poor corner of Mississippi are going to be completely different from a girl who grew up in upstate New York and is going to NYU. I’m in college, I see girls from these two walks of life butt heads over what’s important. The girl who grew up in the Mississippi Delta area, she’s been put down by men, or been made to feel she has to brush off sexual harassment or assault. And the more Ivy League woman has been told by transactivists that if she doesn’t keep quiet she will be pushed out. So I do support maybe different chapters regionally to address these different problems, but they’re all kind of rooted in the same thing. Patriarchy.

Esmée: I think the regional variation you’re talking about is huge, even between parts of states. I grew up in Illinois, and Chicago is not downstate. They’re just not the same world. More regional organizations, smaller groups that are connected to each other might be the way to build because you can’t have a national NOW conference for a new organization. I maybe wouldn’t even try for an organization. Presidents and vice presidents and bureaucracy, that’s not the work.

Kasey: I agree. The things you’re facing in, say, San Francisco where my sister lives vs. in Texas, where I lived, are really different. I remember a few years ago, the very first time I talked to my sister about transgender ideology, she said, “I totally understand what you’re saying, and I agree with you, but you don’t understand how uncomfortable it feels for you to say these things out loud.”

Esmée: Where you each are, how informed even are women about our status, the forces that are moving around and often against us in this country?

Elizabeth: I think they’re really poorly informed through no fault of their own. And I think that segues into another problem that I wanted to raise, that I’m sure we’re all very aware of, which is the total institutional capture of all liberal feminist organizations. The National Organization for Women was always very lib-femmy and what I would consider conservative in its goals, but they’re much worse now. Planned Parenthood doesn’t really focus on women’s reproductive rights very much anymore. They’re much more focused on providing hormones to trans-identifying people, because that’s more lucrative for them and also gets them a lot of big donations. The National Center for Lesbian Rights has been the biggest organization for advocating for and litigating things concerning lesbian rights, and they hardly mention the word ‘lesbian’ anymore. Go down the line, every single huge, rich, liberal organization is anti-feminist. And the ACLU (American Civil Liberties Union) is incredibly rich; when Trump got elected, they got millions of dollars in donations. Unfortunately, most of the work they do hurts women and girls. So I think that’s an enormous structural problem, that we have no allies.

Esmée: I fear that’s exactly right. I’m always amazed at how NOW, for instance, continues to advocate for the Equal Rights Amendment, but at the same time is signatory to the GLAAD letter that was so condemning toward radical feminists.1 I mean, a public letter referring to women like us as bigots, almost murderers.

Elizabeth: Yeah right, that’s hilarious.

Esmée: And NOW and the Feminist Majority and a whole bunch of, like, 200 different organizations signed on to that letter but are also still operating as if they will be able to work for women’s rights in that context. And I have walked around for the last several years going, how does that work in their heads?

Elizabeth: There’s mental capture from all the propaganda. Everything in the public sphere is ‘transwomen are women, we need to fight for the rights of all women.’ And they never understand that some of those so-called rights are directly in opposition to the rights of actual women … I’m a lifelong Democrat. So this is not coming from a right-wing perspective. But the Democratic party does not represent me anymore. These mantras that ‘good liberal people’ just unquestioningly accept, these four or five sentences that are constantly repeated so that people come to feel, ‘Oh, yes, those are our sentences. I will repeat them.’

Erica: I definitely agree. I’m 21. I’m very new to radical feminism, less new to gender-critical thought. At university, I spent my first three years working in a gay rights group on campus. I lived with a transactivist until recently. And if you sit down and talk to these girls between the ages of 18 and 25, you will hear that half of what’s keeping them from seeing what’s going on is these thought-stopping phrases like ‘transwomen are women.’ And many girls in my age group or in college are unfortunately victims of sexual assault on campus. And these young women, they’re angry, they’re sad, and they think, ‘I am more than my vagina. I am more than just that.’ And then transwomen say, ‘So are we, we aren’t just this [genitals].’ So, these girls are more or less coerced or coaxed into this movement. There are young girls who are trying to stand up for themselves and don’t really know how. They’re up against everybody. And lesbians? There’s nothing, there’s nothing left. I swear I don’t know a single masculine lesbian who hasn’t started shooting T [testosterone] or gone on to mastectomy surgery. It’s terrible.

Elizabeth: Young women need safety, liberation, radical feminism. I have found that they want it just as much as older women do, but there’s so many things working against them. I run a monthly group in Chicago called The Feminist Salon, and we have recently had a bunch of young women find us and join us, and they come to their first meeting, and they just cry with relief. They’re like, ‘I finally found a place where I don’t have to lie. I don’t have to censor myself, I can see other women just existing … women who don’t wear makeup, women who have short hair, women who are lesbians, and will say the word “lesbian,” you know, women who speak out.’ As Erica was saying, they think, ‘If I’m brave, if I’m strong, if I’m butch, if I have short hair, I guess I’m not a woman.’ This is so incredible to me, as somebody who grew up in the 70s, with Free to Be … You and Me, and everyone did the same gender-non-conforming things. And that was my entire childhood. That’s how every kid was.

Esmée: And it scared the shit out of the world.

Elizabeth: And now, how did it go away? What happened?

Esmée: The 80s??? Neoliberalism?

Elizabeth: This is weird, but I actually blame Disney. In the 90s when Disney started coming out with all the new princess movies, suddenly, instead of toys being Legos and blocks, they became pink. I guess I didn’t realize how much our gains would be whittled away. Now girls get the message that ‘girl and woman means makeup, high heels, being weak and quiet, not having any thoughts.’ And if you don’t fit in that horrible little description, you’re a man. I can’t believe that’s where we are.

Kasey: And if that draws young women to say, ‘Oh, I reject that view of women and I’m therefore non-binary,’ that should be encouraging to us. Women see that that’s not them. I don’t remember who said it, but ‘society is telling you that a woman is this sexualized object; any woman who feels like she’s not that feels like she’s not like the other women.’ And how do you harness that? How do you make those connections? I came to radical feminism from a very different direction. I was raised incredibly conservatively in Texas, and had rejected a lot of those ideas, but basically in my late 20s came to terms with the fact that I was a lesbian. And then I started seeing transgender ideology everywhere, on dating apps and things like that. I thought, “Wait a second! I did not just endure almost 30 years of compulsive heterosexuality to now be told that I need to date men again? What is going on here?”

Elizabeth: I’ve never fulfilled any of those stereotypes in my entire life. But guess what, I’m a woman. This is a way to be a woman. This is one of the billions of ways there is to be a woman. But these poor young girls are given this shitty message, so they figure, ‘Well, I guess I’m a man or I need to be a man. Or maybe I’m non-binary, since I don’t really like the male stereotypes either.’ It’s just a nightmare. I asked the young ones, “How did you get past that?” And they’re like, “I found some radical feminism. And I read it. And I was like, Oh, my God. Thank you.”

Esmée: And it blows your mind open. Yeah.

Kasey: Yeah. Back to that original thought about how aware women are: we have the institutional capture, but that’s transferred over to individuals. I’ve had three conversations with left-leaning women in Texas, in Utah, and in California. And the initial reaction from all three of them was, ‘You’re being so mean to trans people.’ That’s the reaction of people who think that they don’t have any skin in the game, and two of them never got past that emotional response. I really think that in order to organize and address this, in the United States, there will have to be a counter-emotional response, right? I don’t know if any of you have read the book The Righteous Mind. It’s about how people make decisions, but especially political decisions. Basically it says that people don’t really listen to arguments, they’ve already made up their mind in an emotional way. When people start at ‘you’re being so mean to trans people,’ it is hard to intuit them out of that! It’s hard to get them to feel any kind of indignation for themselves, to get them to feel any kind of powerful emotion that would counter that ‘you’re being mean.’ That’s been my experience with women’s awareness in the US in general.

Elizabeth: What you’ve said is especially true for women, because that’s a big part of our socialization: never think about how anything hurts us. That’s like a huge forbidden area for women. I’ve been reading a lot of historical books about feminism this summer, going back to the 1840s. And it’s always been true, whenever women started organizing … a lot of early organizing was around making incest illegal, having a minimum age for being able to consent to sex, because there wasn’t a minimum age at all! And men would say, ‘But men have needs, men need to have sex.’ Any time women brought up any kind of boundary that they wanted to have enshrined in law or just respected in culture. I think a huge barrier is that women and girls are told from birth, basically, you’re here to serve men. You don’t really have needs. It’s not just institutional capture, it’s capture inside our minds: these days, there’s a massive amount of cultural suppression and so many women are terrified to say anything out loud. Kasey’s sister is a perfect example of that: ‘I agree with you, but oh my God, it’s so uncomfortable to hear you say that out loud.’

Erica: If more young women were around groups of friendly radical feminists, or even if there was a circulation of a newsletter, that just somehow wasn’t censored or caught … that would just be amazing. Just the transmission of information. It’s been something we’re really lacking in this movement.

Elizabeth: The second wave started with consciousness-raising groups that grew into a massive political movement and women’s bookstores, women’s everything … And it all started in consciousness-raising groups in women’s living rooms.

Esmée: Yeah, there was a whole world!

Erica: The social media I have with people in my area who I know through my involvement in gay groups, a lot of them are a non-binary-identifying women. They’re not really being who they are; they are capitulating to a different group’s stereotype. I’m trying to think of what turned me away from that when I was younger. Honestly, I’ve got a Tumblr, I’m not gonna lie. It’s just an echo chamber. These girls and boys are stuck in there being shown the only way out of reductionist sexual stereotypes is this, like, rainbow-wrapped version of reductionist sexual stereotypes. So I don’t know how it could be advertised to them in a way that they would glom onto it.

Kasey: That perfectly touches on what I was trying to express earlier about providing an emotional response. The response that I’m getting is emotional and there needs to be an alternative to that, it can’t just be these facts, right?

Esmée: That’s not even helping us in American politics anymore. You say, ‘Look, we did a study and we piled up all this information. And now we would like to build a policy.’ And people go, ‘Mmm, uh-uh, nope. That doesn’t feel good.’

Elizabeth: I wonder what the emotional response we can provide is, because part of the problem is that people don’t care about women, people don’t care how we feel. And a lot of male-centred women don’t care. What is the emotional response that’s going to actually resonate with people?

Kasey: I think that’s a tough one. Because women are so willing to be indignant for other causes, and less willing to be indignant for themselves. Touching on what Erica said about social media, I think it has really exacerbated individualism in the past 20 years, but the United States was plenty individualistic on its own. It’s hard when you have a culture that didn’t necessarily value community and community organization already. Then you add social media to it, and boom!, everybody’s on their own little planet on the internet. It is really hard to provide larger emotive messaging the way that ‘transwomen are women’ does. What is the alternative emotion?

Esmée: Honestly, I think in many ways we are so behind the eight ball, that the consciousness raising is probably where it’s at. I’m almost starting to think, what if there was a ‘Consciousness Raising for the Gender Era,’ like, two pages, you could mail it to your friends, you know, get two people together and start talking, invite another couple of women, right?

Elizabeth: Visibility is so important. This past summer I went to the Michigan Family Reunion. One of the workshops was called the Intergenerational Lesbian Workshop. There were a ton of women there, from 18 to 75 in age. Some of the older women were saying, “What can we do for you? What do you need from us?” And a lot of them said, “Just seeing you is a huge help.” A lot of them said, “I have never seen a butch lesbian before. Ever. Just seeing you exist over there is huge for me.” And it made me feel that visibility of lesbians and feminist women is very important. So maybe women start YouTube series, very low-key, just ‘this is me doing my day as a woman who doesn’t wear makeup, or has short hair, or maybe has long hair, but a loud mouth, and here’s the things that I do in my life that don’t fit into gender stereotypes.’ Naming it: I’m a woman and here are 50 ways I live my life that don’t fit into stereotypes of what women are ‘supposed to be.’

Esmée: There’s a lot of stuff every woman does every day, just being a person, that isn’t feminine. Right? That isn’t the little box.

Kasey: The current era of stereotypes is different. Nobody would think it was weird or bad if a woman was fixing a car as long as she was hot while she was doing it. Now there’s no real walls about women doing anything that is ‘not feminine.’ For the most part, women have broken down those barriers, but they still have to look really good while they’re doing it, you know, really good from a male point of view. Especially women past middle age, or women who choose not to dress for the male gaze. The Twitter response to the Scottish women recently with the Women Won’t Wheesht! [campaign] really shows this. How much their appearance was the focus of insult while they are just being regular, not-young women. That alienates the generations from each other. Young women see how older women are treated and think ‘I don’t want to be that!’

Elizabeth: The way out is the support of other women and community with other women. That’s the true way out of patriarchy. And that’s the message that we have to get across to women.

I think one thing we have to do there is not let men or TRAs drive us off in a different direction, don’t let them capture the conversation. Just disengage from them and go make our own groups, and do what we need to do to protect them. Because that’s one of the many ways men prevent women from making progress. By demanding that we argue with them—and if we comply, then we are investing time and energy in them. And I think a solution is to stop that and invest our time and energy in women.

Esmée: It’s amazing how different our voices and body language and topics are, and how loud we laugh, when it’s just women together. Because with any man around there’s a sense of being observed, and that woman-togetherness goes away. Men can be dangerous as hell. And especially for the last four or five years now, we have been witness to spectacular displays of men being threatening in public without consequences. The Proud Boys and Antifa fighting each other in the streets last summer. The 6 January Insurrection. Sure, some of those folks are women, but a lot of those folks are men going at each other like bulls in a field. A lot of people are armed in this country. And that changes the mood and the calculus.

Elizabeth: That absolutely does. Any time somebody is a total jerk in public, I think, ‘Okay, how much risk do I want to take in responding to this person?’ Because they might very well have a gun. So that is just another piece of life in the US, unfortunately.

Esmée: This is the hard thing about all cultural work—it feels like there’s two approaches that need to happen simultaneously. One is to carefully protect spaces just for women because we know how aggressively men and AGP transwomen are trying to get into them. Those are places where we can do our work. And then also a public-facing way of connecting with each other that acts like a little beacon for other women. It feels kind of like stages.

Erica: Now women around my university who want to congregate with other women and only other women are calling their groups ‘menstruators’ group,’ or ‘period-havers’ group’ or something like that.

Kasey: The one thing that I could think of is a book club. I don’t think it gets any easier than that, something that you can drop in on, no big deal.

Erica: The last actual outpost of a female-only space is women’s college dorms. Girls put up pamphlets and flyers for Girls’ Bible Study or Women Decompression Group. However, transwomen are being transferred into women-only dorms.

Elizabeth: It’s interesting because when women are in women-only space, amazing things happen organically. But there’s just this one step right before that which seems to be a big sticking point. Like, just how do you enable that to happen? And men are being very successful in getting in our way at that step.

Esmée: More of an underground. I was thinking about the French Resistance in World War II. The country was completely occupied by Nazis. Actual Nazis. Hitler was in Paris. They used everyday activity as the cover for the subversive activity. Maybe it’s just a couple of friends having coffee. Maybe it’s girls’ night, maybe it’s a book club, but whatever the real thing is, it’s only spoken about underneath … I cannot believe I’m talking about this!

Elizabeth: I know, how sad that ordinary women have to act like the French Underground to talk about our interests? Like, what kind of world are we living in? I’ve seen the model of starting with just a couple of people chatting and growing into something huge. The night that Trump was elected, everyone on Facebook was freaking out, and then they just organically started doing things. When Trump stopped letting people in at the airports, I got involved in a group that helped rehouse refugees in Chicago. So it’s not that hard to do. It happens a lot in the world outside of radical feminism, because nobody’s trying to stop those people from doing that. Nobody’s like, ‘You bigot! How dare you try to rehouse political refugees, you Nazi!!’

Esmée: Yeah, I remember Jane [Clare Jones] saying, “Just get six women in a library and things will start.” You’ve got to get those six women who are not afraid to be called a bigot.

Erica: A pause, though. A lot of young gender-critical women do not have our foot in the professional door yet. We are figuring out where career paths are taking us and are scared that if we stand up for women and girls, then any career prospects will just dissolve. I really love seeing women who have some sort of platform create these groups or take these stands, but I’m not trying to wish my life away. But I think we need to stand up, be fearless, and say, “So be it, we have to stand up and do something, or else a future where we can’t speak the truth really is the future.” But there’s still that worry of just not being able to make it.

Esmée: Absolutely. And seeing [the magnitude of the] problem puts me in a hurry in terms of organizational questions, because part of what can answer that is having well-organized groups of older, established women who are willing to support, to defend, to literally fill coffers if necessary, to help young people take those risks. But that takes an incredible amount of organization.

Elizabeth: I also agree that older women have to support younger women. And that’s yet another thing that patriarchy does: it tries to separate women from each other, especially women in different generations, or different economic levels and different geographic areas. They’ll find whatever ways they can to separate women because women will tend to support other women, if we have any way of even talking to each other.

Esmée: Yeah, and we know the resistance to radical feminism is as strong as it is because the patriarchal world intuits how transformative that can be.

Elizabeth: I think in any movement for people’s liberation, there’s always going to have to be people who put themselves out there at great risk and are very vocal. They inspire and give a huge mass of ordinary people courage to do what they can do. And people have different amounts of risk that they can take in their lives. Organizing also means bringing in the contributions that people can safely make. I think we all have to push ourselves, but everyone has to make their own calculus as to how much you can afford to do that, and the movement should respect that.

Esmée: It’s not wrong to make sure that you can survive in a neoliberal economy, full of patriarchal pressures coming from both directions. Actual oppression creates actual vulnerability, and we are all negotiating that. Just support other women in knowing their own truth, reminding each other that an illusion is being cast over the world. It’s powerful and sustaining to gather four people in your living room so they’ve got a minute to go, ‘It’s an illusion. Two plus two is not five. Eurasia probably doesn’t exist. There is no war.’

Erica: One of my friends is gender critical, and we used to go on long walks and talk about these things freely. And she would say, “I’ve never felt this way. But I feel like I’m being lifted up. But also, I’m still very scared of these thoughts. I’m not sure how to move forward.” I’m not sure how to go about finding out if other friends of mine feel that way.

Elizabeth: That dovetails with something I was just thinking, which is that the model in which saving the world is on top of our regular lives is not a good model for us. A better model is saving the world as part of our regular lives. If there isn’t childcare, then we take turns and provide childcare for each other so that women who need childcare can do feminist work. We have to incorporate it into our lives and make our lives more women-focused. We need to be thinking about how to make it an integral part of our lives to be women-centred and help women and girls. 

It’s the emergency we’re facing, but we have to remember that not everything has to be about transgenderism. I sound like a broken record, but that’s yet another way that patriarchy deflects us from our interests. I’m not saying it’s not a real threat. But abortion was just outlawed in Texas! We can organize around other feminist issues and not even talk about the transgender issue. There’s a bill in front of Congress right now, the Women’s Health Protection Act, that would prevent states from doing what Texas just did.2 So it would basically enshrine Roe v. Wade in a federal statute. Lobby for that.

Kasey: Creating a resource pack for women across the country who would be willing to have a group might be a place to start. I think that a lot of people would probably be willing but find it daunting, especially for a fledgling group of women. You can put it up with an anonymous email address and a Google Doc that’s shareable. The doc could crowdsource ideas for content or areas of focus. It’s just hard for most people to start from scratch.

Erica: In my college campus women’s restrooms I often see a poster that asks, “Are you in a bad situation? Are you being abused? Do you need support? Take this phone number.” And there’s a little segment of paper with a number you can text later. But our poster could say, “Do you worry about gender identity enforcement, do you feel stifled, are you dissenting and don’t know where to go? Text this number and let’s start something!” That might be another way to actually get women together.

Elizabeth: Yeah, it might fit on a sticker! “If you’re interested in women’s issues, here’s a QR code!” And then from there, the people putting up the stickers can decide how public or private they want to be. They could meet in a park to be seen and overheard, or meet more privately—everyone bring a friend that you know and trust. There are so many ways to gather women, and they can all become grassroots organizing.

Erica: Before COVID-19 hit, one of the biggest places for gay women to commune was gay clubs—not lesbian clubs, those are all gone, just gay clubs. And it was almost as if the lesbian woman there had a certain way of figuring out who felt like we do about certain politics, almost like they had a code. And it was interesting to watch. It really was. Some way we could have that sort of secret communication out in the big real world outside of a dark little club.

Elizabeth: Handkerchiefs! Oh my God! Your gender-critical handkerchief!

[Laughter]

Kasey: Maybe just focusing on other parts of feminist movement will be what brings other women in. I mean, the abortion issue in Texas, I think a lot of people who don’t really understand gender-critical or radical feminism would be surprised these days by us showing up for that. Because they see anybody who opposes trans ideology as, like, super conservative. Working on things like childcare and a social safety net is valuable and it’s a less controversial way to start a conversation with other women. And when people see clearly that the same women are organizing local social safety nets, and trying to keep prisons single sex, and supporting abortion rights, then people will start to see, ‘Okay, this is not a being-mean-to-transpeople thing. This is a women thing.’

Elizabeth: Right. Because a lot of the women that the social safety net is failing might be women more likely to be imprisoned for crimes that other, more privileged women are not imprisoned for, so they’re more impacted by prisons not being single sex. It’s all connected. Real intersectionality.

Kasey: Those women who need a strong social safety net are also probably the women who have the least time for the luxury beliefs we are opposed to. For a while I was a social worker in Texas for Child Protective Services. And I got to know the kinds of women who really need a social safety net. But these women are probably not the kinds of women who would give a shit about whether or not you think ‘transwomen are women.’ Most of them are worried about getting to their weirdly timed shift at Burger King for minimum wage, and getting childcare for their children, while taking a bus that takes them one hour to get there. So these women would really benefit from this kind of feminist organization.

Erica: I see that a lot here. I don’t know how we rank on poverty, [but] this city is probably one of the top five. These women are working crazy shifts because scheduling in those jobs is brutal and unpredictable. They don’t know or they just don’t care about the whole trans thing. They’re caring about how to feed their children, how to give them an education. And that doesn’t mean this movement is not for them, it’s especially for them. I think a lot of it comes down to how we advertise ourselves to everybody, and how we organize the work to make room for the conditions in these women’s lives. These women deal with the worst of the worst, and we have to make sure they are included and their voices are heard and lifted as well.

Esmée: It’s not going to help us to continue to erode the social safety net. We have just recently been reminded that when the world starts to fall apart, it’s women who have to stitch it back together, and to do that we have to quit our jobs. If middle- and working-class women are going to be kept in that kind of instability, it’s gonna be very difficult to gather the momentum, the energy, the time, the capacity to do anything else.

Elizabeth: Right? You just realize how many huge problems there are and then you feel overwhelmed. Poverty is a huge feminist issue. Having money changes everything. It doesn’t protect you from everything, but it protects you from a lot.

Kasey: I would say the majority of my cases when I worked at CPS were a result of poverty and not a result of bad parenting, or the bad parenting was a result of poverty. There were some genuinely heinous cases, but most of the cases I saw would have been completely prevented by universal childcare and really adequate public transportation and a slightly higher minimum wage. These families are just really stressed out. 

Erica: I have worked with different childcare groups in the area, and a lot of kids are in bad situations. I was very lucky as a child; my mom was able to be with me and my sibling, and I credit her presence for my being able to navigate through cognitive dissonance. So many kids don’t have that. And a lot of these moms are dying to be with their kids when they can. This is a feminist issue. How do we let these moms be with their children, read to them, raise them? I think that’d be something very important to focus on.

Elizabeth: And some of these problems are really easy to solve. We just don’t have the political will. Like just raise the fucking minimum wage, put more buses on the street, have more bus routes, you know, provide subsidized childcare. Those aren’t even that expensive. Someone just has to care.

Kasey: I was talking to a friend in the US and she asked if my younger kid was in school. Of course, she’s four, and then I realized that in the US, she wouldn’t be in school for another few years. That’s something I think would be super important for the US, just lowering preschool to two or three would make a huge difference both for the children developmentally but also for a mother’s ability to take care of the children and to work and have some energy to spend just as she wants to.

Esmée: Why have we designed one of the most advanced economies in the most punishing way? The thing that has always motivated me has been the question: “How do we create room for human beings to be as magnificently themselves as they possibly can? How do we get flourishing?” And I just keep running up against the fact that we have built a world that is completely designed against it.

So, rather than end on a down note, I want to ask y’all if there’s one last thing you want to say or the big point you want to raise that you haven’t had a chance to say yet?

Elizabeth: If I had to leave on a particular note, I would say I see this conversation as an invitation to women reading it to use it to think about things and then as a springboard for action in their lives. Maybe it will give them some ideas of ways they could organize or conversations they could have or types of groups they want to have in their lives. I hope that women who read this roundtable will get something from it that propels them forward in some way. This is an opening, it’s not a closing.

Erica: I definitely agree with that. If I was going to leave this conversation with just a final thought, it is that it’s completely wrong to think that we are taking a stand against philosophies like liberal feminism or transgender ideology because we hate difference. That is not why we’re doing it. We want to see where radical feminism can lead. We want to protect the rights of women and girls. In order to do that we have to ‘decriminalize’ speaking the truth of what’s going on. The most important first step is just having a dialogue and a conversation like this, like Elizabeth said—making an opening and continuing with a group of friends, wherever you are in the US. It can be daunting, it can be really scary, but it’s a very important first step, and I’m hopeful and excited to see where this could lead. 

Esmée Streachailt, PhD, is a nom de guerrière. Esmée’s cultural and organizing work leverages strategic alliances across differences for the liberation and flourishing of humans. Her writing embraces feminist critical theory, cultural hermeneutics, comparative religion, and poetics. Esmée is a co-founder and contributing editor with THE RADICAL NOTION and a lecturer with The Centre for Feminist Thought. She tweets at @EStreachailt.