by Jane Clare Jones
Dixie Chick is a data analyst from Georgia, USA with master’s degrees in Social Work and Criminal Justice. She has worked in child welfare for more than two decades and is politically active in that area. This interview with Jane Clare Jones took place in September 2021 by video call, and it has been edited for length and clarity.
Jane Clare Jones: We’re doing this issue of THE RADICAL NOTION on the situation in the United States, looking at various aspects of the impact of trans ideology, and exploring the difficulty for women in mounting resistance. It seems from this side of the pond that many liberal American women are caught in a kind of culture war pincer movement, and also — and this is one of the things I’m particularly interested in talking to you about — that America’s racial history is really complicating the situation. Firstly, because it feels very difficult to express the idea that women have specific needs that should be accommodated without people responding with a knee-jerk ‘that’s separate but equal,’ and also because of the way certain arguments are deliberately using that history to manipulate people, in a way that is actually serving the interests of white males.
Dixie Chick: Yeah, that’s how I got into this thing, the whole gender war. Around 2013 or 2014, somewhere in that timeframe. I had just had a baby, who was two or three years old at the time. I wasn’t really into social media, but had always been political and thought I needed to get my toes back in, so I started following some feminists on Twitter, like Trudy (@thetrudz) and Imani Gandy (@AngryBlackLady). One of Trudy’s posts said something about ‘cis,’ and I was like, ‘What on earth is that?’ I went and looked it up, and was like, ‘Oh, that’s not good.’ [Laughs] And of course, she did what they always do and said, ‘Well, that’s Latin.’ Yeah, but it’s bad Latin.
So, I said, ‘I don’t like this “cis” thing.’ I was not that deep. I wasn’t raging about it, I was more like, ‘That makes no sense, so don’t call me that.’ At that time, I didn’t mind calling trans women ‘women.’ I had always supported gay rights and just assumed this was part of the gay rights movement, and so I was, ‘Okay, they want to be called women, fine.’ I didn’t know at the time that they meant it literally. So, I said, ‘I don’t like “cis,” and if I call you a woman, you don’t get to decide what to call me, it’s a mutual respect thing.’ And then this transactivist, Sophia Banks, Darryl Banks, told me I was oppressing him.
He’s a middle-aged Canadian business owner, and he is telling me, a black Southern woman who grew up poor, that somehow, I was oppressing him because of ‘kyriarchy.’ And Trudy, who is a black feminist, gave me what for about this, and told me that I needed to ‘educate myself.’ And I was like, ‘Oh my god. Am I being homophobic? Am I being transphobic?’ I panicked, because I had always been a lefty but also, it makes no sense. Not even just the bad Latin, which really annoyed me. You’re not even pronouncing it right. So anyway, I went and educated myself. Because I’d been out of pocket since grad school. I’ve been being a mom, doing the grind and all that stuff. So, I decided to find out what was going on and I started reading. And God help me, I started with Judith Butler. [Laughs]
I asked Trudy, ‘What should I be reading?’ And she said, ‘Oh, you need to read Judith Butler and Julia Serano’s Whipping Girl.’ And about three chapters into that book I was like, ‘Are y’all serious?’ I couldn’t have gotten away with this at an undergrad level. You’re supposed to be academics. This makes no sense. I kept trying and trying but, no. And I got back online, and someone called me a TERF. I didn’t know what a TERF was, so I googled it and praise be to God, I found Gender Trender, I found Gallus Mag, and she saved my sanity. Because I’d thought, ‘I’m this horrible person.’ Not because I’d supposedly oppressed Darryl, because that’s bullshit, but because I was thinking that I was being homophobic. I’d always been very much supportive of gay rights, even as a teenager. And when I found Gallus, I found that something like a veil was lifted.
I was very angry with Trudy, much more than I was with Darryl, because she should know better. We, as black women, we’ve heard this before; this is not new. People have taken the black civil rights movement, people misquote Dr King, saying he said, ‘We should all join hands and sing kumbaya.’ Yeah. No. Not really. She and I went back and forth several times before she eventually blocked me because I was like, ‘Well, you have to know better than this.’ So, I stopped following pretty much all of them, but it was an eye-opening experience. After that, around 2016, a transactivist doxxed me. It ruined my writing work, but thankfully I didn’t lose my job, which is what he was gunning for. So, if I wasn’t a confirmed TERF by then, I certainly was after I went through all that crazy stuff.
It was very frustrating. I posted some stuff about it on my blog, and I went back and forth with some other writers, and they were saying to me, ‘Well, how can you be for black women? And you’re not for all black women?’ … Because they’re not women. It really was like talking to a wall. And of course, most of it is performative. I have no doubt in my mind that for the most part, these people do not believe that. I have to believe that they don’t really believe that, because if they do, then I probably need to find myself another planet. I think that most of them are afraid to say what they really think. Because they don’t want to happen to them what happened to me. Which, you know, that’s fine, but at least don’t try to bullshit me about it.
Jane: This is one of the things I want to unpack, how trans ideology has this way of using comparisons with the civil rights movement, analogies with segregation — which is the place where you and I started communicating online — and also this argument about how white feminism has historically excluded black women. As we’ve pointed out, that argument actually ends up reducing to, ‘If black women are women then trans women are women,’ which is unbelievably racist. I wanted to ask you what you think is going on with that, how is it working? This story about ‘exclusion’ … obviously there is a complicated racial history in feminism, but when [transactivists] say, ‘black women have been excluded from womanhood,’ the claim they’re actually making is that the concept of ‘woman’ and the concept of ‘patriarchal white femininity’ are the same concept. Which they’re not.
Dixie: If you’ve spent any time on Lipstick Alley, which is where I spend most of my time, there’s a gender-critical area.
Jane: Oh, I know Lipstick Alley well because I’ve spent a lot of time reading the Prince threads there.
Dixie: Well, head on over to the feminist womanist section, you would be amazed. Most black women think this is bullshit. They do not buy into trans ideology. We’re having issues even with gay trans women: Laverne Cox has said things like, ‘Well, black women need to make black men stop killing us.’ And I’m like, ‘A black woman is killed in this country every 19 hours. We can’t get black men to stop killing us. How are we gonna get black men to stop killing you? And why is that on us?’
The only black women who are openly supportive of the trans agenda are those feminists on Twitter, who are basically grifting, and black women in publishing who really just want to keep a contract. I spend almost all my time talking to black women about this, you know, ‘That’s nonsense,’ ‘That’s crazy.’ But unfortunately, they’re not the ones with the microphones. It’s definitely a struggle, especially with the black trans women. I remember Monica Roberts, who did the TransGriot blog, was very typical of the gay black men who decided to become trans women and who thought black women owed them something. Because of our history, there’s this mindset in the black community that we have to protect black men. And when black women say anything about black men abusing us, or oppressing us, then we are playing into the white supremacy. Well, no. We don’t want to play into the white supremacy, we’re not crazy, but we would like you to stop killing us. That would be good. And the amazing thing is that these trans women claim to be women, but they expect the same thing … for black women to defend them. Even if it’s at our own cost.
Jane: It’s interesting what you say about the history, because that adds an extra dimension to the entitlement that’s already there. We see that entitlement as well, basically, ‘Women, your job is to accommodate our needs, move over.’ But here, because of the history of white supremacy and the violence directed at black men, there’s an added level of manipulation. I think it is difficult from an intersectional perspective for black women with respect to police brutality, for example, because obviously many black women have male partners and sons who are subjected to that kind of violence. And then, at the same time, that does not negate the fact that there’s still patriarchal violence happening against black women. One of the things I’ve been thinking about is how intersectionality only seems to work in one direction. Which is the one benefitting men. It seems that a discourse that was developed by black women is being appropriated, and now it’s been weaponized against black women?
Dixie: Yes. And it’s bad enough when black men do it, but when it comes from white men, I’m like, ‘Are you serious? You’re going to let them get away with that?’ Yesterday I got into this back and forth with a Canadian woman, and she was saying the same thing: ‘Well, that’s segregation. That’s Jim Crow.’ And I’m like, ‘You don’t know anything about Jim Crow.’ And she said, ‘Oh, you’re saying that you’re afraid. You make it seem that women should be afraid of men, the way white people were afraid of black people.’
Jane: Can you just unpack why that analogy doesn’t work?
Dixie: Women want to be separate from men for safety and privacy and dignity. White people who wanted to be separate from black people didn’t fear black people. White people have the ability to kill black people with impunity. They are not afraid of black people. They want to oppress black people, they want to show their superiority to black people, which is why they imposed segregation. They want to keep us in an oppressed position. Women aren’t trying to oppress men. Women are trying to get away from men primarily for safety but also because they perv on us, which I guess is the same thing. That’s why that analogy doesn’t work. Getting away from your oppressor is not segregation. Getting away from your oppressor is a human right. Totally different story.
Jane: Right, the analogy only works if you think that women are the oppressor group. And what’s being effectively propagated all the time is the idea that women are not oppressed. I’ll tell you a story: I got into an argument with a Georgetown philosopher, who used to be called Rebecca Kukla and is now called Quill, about excluding males from rape crisis centres. She used the segregation analogy, and my response was, ‘Women are not the white people in this scenario. Because women are an oppressed class.’ And she turned around to me and straight up said, ‘Cis women are not oppressed as such.’
Dixie: That’s what ‘cis’ is about. I know you know that. But it’s genius. It’s genius. I hate to give them that much credit, but I swear they couldn’t have done better if they’d sat down to plan it. Because that whole ‘cis’ thing is a way to turn around and say that women are oppressing men. I have to believe that someone had to sit down and think that up, because it’s freaking genius.
Jane: Exactly, it flips the axis of oppression and you can position women as the oppressor. That’s why they won’t allow us to refuse it.
Dixie: You know, the terminology is the same kind of mind game men have always played on women. And the fact that so many women don’t recognize it as such is very disturbing to me. Because it’s really obviously the same type of thing. And it works. But these black feminists on Twitter? This is what they do. The grift. That’s how they’re getting by. They have all these followers, and they have to say this stuff. Right?
Jane: I think it’s very interesting in relation to the original critique of white feminism. Like bell hooks’s original idea was about liberal feminists that colluded with capitalism. And I would say that’s structural: it’s in the interests of the system to allow a certain portion of women who have more social capital to kind of escape — it’s a safety valve which releases pressure for more fundamental structural transformation for the entire class. Because that’s going to take a lot of resources. The material investment that would be needed to address issues about maternity leave, and childcare, and support for reproductive labour, and for the black community in terms of addressing generational poverty and investing in infrastructure — that’s going to cost a lot of money. No one really wants to do that. But what they do want is this kind of performative social justice thing that doesn’t require anybody to start investing resources to actually address inequality. And what’s interesting is that now the critique of ‘white feminism’ is being used by people who, as you say, are doing this kind of social media grift, and is being weaponized against the people who are actually asking for more material changes.
Dixie: Yes.
Jane: And the reason we don’t want to give up our sex-class analysis is because that’s the analysis we need in order to demand the kinds of material things that women would need, like maternity care, reproductive rights, and a more just division of labour. They’ve taken the discourse and twisted it. Sex-class analysis is not white feminism. Capitalist feminism is white feminism.
Dixie: The only reason they’re able to do that is because most people have not studied it, and don’t understand, and they flip the script. I mean, they’ve heard the words, like Trudy’s telling me, ‘kyriarchy.’ They have the words, but they don’t know what they mean. They have not done the analysis. They haven’t read bell hooks. They wouldn’t know bell hooks if they ran into her in a parking lot. They have a very surface understanding of what’s going on. I see that with a lot of these kids coming off Tumblr. They’re quoting all this gender theory, they’ve not read any of it. No one has read Judith Butler, it’s not possible to read. They can throw those words around and say these things, and they can say ‘white feminism’ and ‘Jim Crow,’ and people just lose their minds. There’s no nuance, there’s no real understanding. And because there has been an adversarial relationship at some point between black women and white women, and there’s been some conflict there, people [conclude] ‘I don’t want to be on that side.’ Well, you’re on the side of white men.
Jane: Right. It feels like there is something here about America’s inability to actually look at its racial history. That as soon as you bring it up, people’s brains just stop working. And then you can manipulate them into whatever you want to …
Dixie: Yes, we’ve never dealt with it. It’s our original birth defect. And for whatever reason — and we could go on all night about why — we’ve never addressed it, and we don’t want to address it. Because it’s scary. And you have to get real, you have to be honest about it, and people don’t like that at all. So we get into that performative business of, ‘Oh, my gosh, was I being …?’ You know, it happened to me: ‘Was I being homophobic?’ And I understand the initial reaction when somebody says, ‘Oh, that’s segregationist.’ It terminates thought right there. Because you have to stop and think, ‘Am I being segregationist? Oh, my God, I don’t want to be racist. Oh, no.’ And then you’ve lost, you’re done, you can’t. And that’s the whole point. Because we’ve never really stopped and looked at it, learned about it. Even now, they’re arguing about what to teach. My God, we’re 150 years on and we still can’t even decide what to teach, how to teach it, when to teach it.
Jane: There’s something I noticed about America when I lived there … wanting everything to be sanitized and shiny. The food doesn’t decay, right? We’re going to make everything so it doesn’t rot. There’s a kind of inability to just deal with darkness. That’s why I like Buffy the Vampire Slayer, or American Gothic generally. We’re going to show you this perfect shiny thing. And then we’ll have zombies coming out of the lawn. Something about that feels true to me. Because the entire society is built over this cataclysmic human rights abuse …
Dixie: Yes.
Jane: … that people cannot look at. And that’s why I don’t like Robin DiAngelo, because it’s still a form of deflection. You’re pretending to look at this, but you’re actually just going to do this performative self-flagellation where you’re not going to confront what this is really about, or address what needs to be addressed.
Dixie: Yeah. You’re right. People are convinced that if you tell the truth, warts and all, that the kids or the people will hate the country. The fact is this country was built on stolen labour of one group and stolen land from another. There’s no getting around that. And that continued for hundreds of years. And it continues now in the exploitation of capitalism. We are addicted to slave labour in this country. And it’s continuing with the immigration situation. I mean, we can sit down and come up with a reasonable immigration policy with a guest visa policy, but then we wouldn’t be able to exploit people. It’s all the same thing.
They’re afraid that if we stop and really look at that, then people will rise up and hate this country. We’re not the only country that’s done terrible things. You look at it, be a grown up, this is our history, this is what went down. These are the things that we’re trying to do now. We feel bad about that. But there’s nothing we can do about it now. Now, we can come up with a decent labour system where people don’t feel like they’ll be fired. And all these types of things, the immigration system, the labour system, my goodness, the lack of maternity leave, all that stuff — it comes from the same system. Our country was built on slavery, and in many ways, we still think that way.
Jane: A black friend of mine in the States said exactly the same thing. America is still on the plantation. No one will actually recognize the value of the people’s labour and allow people to unionize and deal with it ethically. Because we just expect to get this stuff for free. And that’s never been accommodated. I think it is slightly different in the UK. The British also did terrible things, of course, but because that was elsewhere, I think it didn’t affect the social contract in quite the same way.
Dixie: Right, it makes a whole difference when you don’t have a homegrown system of terrorism in your own country, like Jim Crow, or even like what went down with the labour movement and the fights for that. When the British imposed their terrorism and colonialism, that was offshore; here in America, we had it at home. That makes a difference. And if we were ever to look at that, there would be a revolution. That’s why they don’t want us to look at it.
Jane: But there needs to be an accounting …
Dixie: Yeah. Certainly not in my lifetime, and probably not in my children’s life. But if it doesn’t happen, we’re gonna end up in another civil war or something worse. But I don’t know, we’ve been so sedated with all this stuff, materialism and all that, that I’m not even sure that we have it in us anymore to burn it all down, which is what should happen. So anyway, because we’ve never really addressed that, they can shut down any kind of thought, or any kind of objection by saying, ‘Oh, well, you’re just being racist.’ And everybody freaks out. But this is absolute nonsense. Look, listen to who this is coming from. How are you going to have [a] man telling you that women wanting to be separate from men is like white people oppressing black people?
Jane: I was also wondering how you think the ‘culture war’ frame is playing into this manipulation here.
Dixie: Here in America, we are screwed on so many levels. Because [there’s] the whole, quote-unquote, ‘left/right’ thing. We really don’t have a left at all, but the whole left/right, red/blue, whatever you want to call it … Anything that the Republicans have fought for, the Democrats have to be against, even if it’s something that’s good. So we have that. And then we have the race thing. And it’s just so much crazy that no one in the rest of the world even comprehends, and I don’t blame them, because I live here, and I can barely comprehend it.
Jane: It is crazy. One of the things that is really bonkers is this whole managing to convince people that sex is some kind of artefact of white supremacy. Like, can somebody actually explain this to me in a way that doesn’t rely on these bullshit analogies? It’s all wrapped up as anti-racism, like ‘colonialism invented the gender binary.’ So basically you’re saying that non-white people didn’t understand how human reproduction worked before white people came along???
Dixie: The whole goddamn movement is so white supremacist that I’m just like, ‘Are y’all serious? Have you done any thinking at all?’ That’s the part that drives me crazy. I think there’s a lot of white guilt. Let’s not leave that part out. You have the white guilt, you have black resentment. So of course, ‘We don’t want to ally ourselves with those people.’ So, you’re allying yourself with the people who perpetrated the oppression instead?
Jane: Yeah, this whole thing of ‘we’re decolonizing.’ You’re decolonizing by agreeing that black people didn’t understand how sex worked before white people explained it to them, by agreeing that because black women are female somehow male people are female, or by agreeing that women wanting spaces for themselves is like segregation. One of the things I’m very interested in is how this discourse replaces the idea of class politics with this very individualist analysis … In the British resistance, we want to talk about material class politics, about the specific needs of women, and then people turn around and say, ‘separate but equal,’ or ‘this is segregation,’ and it feels like, ‘Can you stop imposing your history on us?’
Dixie: Funny thing is that we don’t have that class discussion, because we’ve replaced it. That’s something Toni Morrison said, that if it weren’t for black people this country would have fallen into the type of balkanization that happened in Eastern Europe with the immigration of all these different cultures. But everybody was able to become, quote-unquote, ‘white,’ and distance themselves from black people. And so instead of the class struggle, you have a racial struggle, because everybody else can identify themselves as white. We don’t get into class, though God knows it exists. They distract everyone with the race issue, and we don’t ever address class issues. But yes, this whole gender thing is an American concept. It makes no sense anywhere else. Well, it makes no sense here either, but it really makes no sense in the context of other countries, because other countries have the class issue. They’re just repeating this stuff, parrot fashion, even in a context where it makes no sense. In Australia it doesn’t make any sense, in the UK. It only makes sense in America, and maybe a little bit in Canada.
Jane: I mean, it makes some sense in Australia and New Zealand, because they did have indigenous populations. I noticed the other day that people have started using the acronym BIPOC [Black, Indigenous, and People Of Colour] in the UK. And I’m like, which indigenous people? Do you mean the Celts? It’s such an obvious example of the importation of an American formulation that doesn’t make sense in Britain.
Dixie: This person was telling me, I think she was French or something, that if you’re black, no matter where you are in the world, they call you an African American. You could be a black person from Norway. Are you an African American? Like, no, you’re an African Norwegian. But that’s the Americanization of most of the world. And this is most unfortunate, because again, we’ve got lots of birth defects that we don’t need to be exporting anywhere.
Jane: Yeah, it really concerns me that young people are learning to interpret everything through American history. Someone said to me the other day, ‘I’m beginning to seriously suspect that some of these kids who have been raised on Tumblr don’t realize we never had Jim Crow laws in Britain.’
Dixie: They don’t. I was on Tumblr for three years: I can tell you, they don’t. And part of the problem is, again, so few people in America know American history. Studying history is just not something that is being taught effectively in this country. They think they’re learning about Jim Crow, but they’re not. They have no idea what Jim Crow was. It’s just surface knowledge. I had a woman tell me once that the whole purpose of the civil rights movement was so black people could shop in the same stores as white people.
Jane: We want equal access to capitalism! What???
Dixie: I just had to shut down on the conversation, because I’m like, if you’re coming from that, we really can’t have a conversation. You need to go ‘educate yourself.’ [Laughs] But yeah, I think a lot of these kids are being educated on Tumblr. Were you ever on Tumblr?
Jane: No. I’d be very interested in your thoughts about this, because I know the discourse came from Tumblr. I use this phrase ‘Tumblrization’ to refer to the distorted form of intersectionality. I never spent time on Tumblr, because the first time I ever went there I felt like someone had smashed a jar of marbles inside my brain. It’s like all of these memes loosely associated. Trans ideology is the perfect expression of Tumblr, because it’s just things placed next to each other that have some vague connection to each other, but nobody understands clearly how they’re related. And this is now in academic discourse. They’ll say something about colonialism and the gender binary, and then something about rape in the antebellum south, and then about white women excluding trans women just like the American suffragettes excluded black women, and then the next thing you know, ships in the middle passage are suspended in white women’s tears. And I’m just like, ‘You’re going to have to do some serious work to explain precisely how all these things relate beyond “it’s all racism,” and how “it’s all racism” somehow proves that male people are female.’
Dixie: Yeah, yeah, that’s it. Do you know the TV show South Park?
Jane: Yeah.
Dixie: They had this episode, called the ‘Underwear Gnomes.’ I don’t know if you ever saw it?
Jane: No, but I like the title already.
Dixie: The premise was that the underwear gnomes come and steal your underwear. And the kids are all saying, ‘The underwear gnomes are stealing our underwear.’ And finally, they tracked down the underwear gnomes and the underwear gnomes are like, ‘Step A: Steal underwear.’ And then they, like, skip Part B and go straight on to ‘Step C: Rule the world.’ [Laughs] And so they get stuck on that ‘Part A’ bit about stealing the underwear. And that is very much what Tumblr is to me. It’s the underwear gnomes.
Jane: [Laughs] That’s what it feels like. Because they all suddenly appeared, and we were like, ‘Somehow you’ve been convinced that if everyone believes that humans aren’t sexed, the entire structure of white supremacist patriarchal capitalism will just collapse overnight.’ And it makes no sense, no sense, none.
Dixie: It’s the underwear gnomes. [Laughs] I ended up on Tumblr as part of a fandom for a TV show that’s now defunct. That’s how I got introduced to the concept of shipping. And slash fiction. And you could not have a conversation about any TV show on Tumblr without them imposing all this slash and shipping stuff. And finally, I was like, ‘Who are these people?’ And this was about the same time I was having my big falling-out on Twitter. And that’s when I discovered the trans-identified girls. It was a sad situation, because what you have on Tumblr is this hellish landscape of very young kids, adult males like Zinnia Jones, who’s all over it, and a ridiculous amount of porn. I would try to have conversations with these girls. Again, I’m from the American South, I’m intimately familiar with this history, and I’m like, ‘That makes no sense.’ One of them called me an Uncle Tom. And I’m just sitting there going, ‘Oh, you poor darlings.’
Jane: It’s very interesting. Because if you look at the history of trans ideology, most of these ideas were fashioned in the 90s, then they started doing legal activism, which picked up towards the end of the 90s, into the early 00s. And then there was this Tumblr phase that seems to have started in the late 00s into the early part of the last decade. When it exploded onto Twitter, I didn’t realize at first it had come from Tumblr. I was like, ‘What? Everyone’s just got some crazy download.’ I really want to talk to some of the detransitioners about their experience of receiving it on Tumblr. You say people like Zinnia Jones were there? Because I’d like to understand the role of older trans women in what happened on Tumblr.
Dixie: Oh, Zinnia was there. Autumn Sandeen was there. Zinnia had all those videos. And a lot of young followers. So, very much you had these adult male trans people. There must have been ringleaders in this whole intersectional thing. Let’s face it, most of these are suburban white middle-class kids; they had to come up with other layers of oppression because if you’re just a middle-class white kid, you’re at the bottom … [unless] you’re an enby, or a demisexual, or non-neurotypical. For a while there was multiple personalities, just anything that they could come up with, to make themselves not a white middle-class kid. I used to say it was like the worst middle-school clique, which would have been silly and stupid and about as annoying as the vampire craze, had there not been so much porn and adult men there.
I think it’s where we were as a world at that time, because social media was comparatively new. Many of us adults weren’t really that plugged in. I think a lot of parents just knew their kids were on the computer all the time. They didn’t understand — I assume if most parents had known what was going on, they wouldn’t have had their kids on there. They would have done something. I reported a lot of stuff. Some of the stuff that went down on that site was absolutely hellish. There was a ridiculous amount of grooming. There was a ridiculous amount of porn. And most of these kids were under the age of 15. And, yes, it was very much bred. If I were back in grad school … Someone needs to do a postdoc or something on that site, because it was, you know …
You also have to understand that the pro-ana thing was very big on Tumblr as well in the mid-00s. And to me, gender dysphoria … it’s the exact same thing. The problem is that instead of being able to look at this as a psychological or sociological issue, it’s been weaponized for the benefit of adult men. One of them, maybe Julia Serano, even said out loud that as long as there are trans kids, that takes the sex out of it. They totally understand the benefit of having these children involved in this movement. I said to one of my friends who was arguing at me that they’re really women inside — I was like, ‘Okay, so what happened to the transvestites? There used to be a time when we knew that this was a sexual thing. Where did all those people go?’ But it’s most unfortunate. It’s a perfect storm of really bad things coming together at the same time. And I have no idea, especially in this country, with the political situation, how we’re going to get our way out of it.
Jane: In America, it seems much more difficult. I think one of the reasons we’ve had a bit of room for manoeuvre in the UK is because this discourse actually isn’t ours, and we’re not hemmed in by the culture war discourse and the same racial discourse. And so, we’ve managed to wiggle around it a bit.
Dixie: And don’t forget the fear of being fired. You all have far more employment protections. And of course, health care. You know, we’ve had crazy stuff come along before, but we’ve never been polarized to this degree. And if they pass this Equality Act, we’re never going to get it back, because once it’s in law it’s damn hard. Most American women have no idea this is happening. My friends are like, ‘Oh, the Equality Act, that’s so great.’ You know, gay people will have rights. And I’m like, ‘Yes. But look, if you replace sex with gender …’ And they say, ‘Oh, that’s not what they mean.’ Yes, that’s exactly what they mean. Every time I speak to anyone about it, they’re like, ‘What? Are you sure?’ They’re absolutely stunned. And so, we don’t even have that much knowledge yet. And I don’t know when we will. Or if we ever will. Because we are a country legendary for sticking our head in the sand. Greatest export. Sticking our head in the sand. Because we don’t like looking. We don’t want to look at that stuff. That’s not pretty.
