Issue One

Table for Diferencias Irreconciliables: Self-ID in Spain

by Estela L. U. Vara

 

Opposition

 

Extreme right wingers

Vox: Against all things LGBT, yet more enthusiastically anti-feminist and anti-immigration. Francoist nostalgics. Vox will occasionally spout some traditionalist bullshit, but they are surprisingly quiet about Self-ID. They seem to be enjoying watching lefty people fight among themselves. They first entered Congress back in April 2019 (24 seats), then more than doubled them in November. Seats at Congress: 52.

Many members have ties to Hazte Oír, which are Focus on the Family types who were responsible for a controversial bus – emblazoned with “Boys have penises, girls have vulvas. Don’t let them fool you.” – back in 2017. 

 

Right wingers

Partido Popular (PP): Main opposition party. Social conservatives. However, they’ve “evolved” and now they are best described as indifferent to LGTB issues and dutifully paying lip service to gender equality. They haven’t weighed in as to whether women exist. Seats at Congress: 88.

Self-IDing as 

centre

Ciudadanos: Choicey choice liberals, in favour of all things alphabet soup. Yet they’ve voted in favor of alliances between PP and Vox in some autonomous communities so they are oftentimes booed at Pride events. They lost many representatives back in November. Seats at Congress: 10.

Coalition 

Gov.

Centre-left(ish)

Spanish Socialist Party (PSOE): They’ve voted for problematic regional laws and their electoral program insisted on the need for an Integral National LGTBI Law. However, recently a statement entitled “Arguments Against Theories which Erase the Reality of Women” was conveniently leaked to some feminists, and some important voices in the party have come out against any form of Self-ID proposal. Seats at Congress: 120.

Another issue, I suspect, is that because the Spanish right can be so socially conservative (to the point of some right-wing politicians not hiding their nostalgia for the Francoist dictatorship), the response against Wokey Bullshit from people on the left hasn’t been as decisive as it has been in the UK, though that’s changing. 

The people’s front of Judea 

The coalition of Podemos, their regional offshoots and Izquierda Unida is now Unidas Podemos. Populist, anti-austerity and (Self-IDentifying) lefty coalition. It is supposedly to the left of the Socialist Party but it’s proven to belong to the woke and the wacky. Unidas Podemos is firmly in favor of Self-ID, to the point of not being quite sure whether women exist. In other feminist issues (e.g. prostitution, surrogacy) they flip-flop. Basically, there’s no Left left. 

Partido Feminista Español was a part of Izquierda Unida until they came out with a manifesto highly critical of Self-ID and transitioning children back in December 2019. IU voted to expel the Feminist Party this past February. Funnily enough, Unidas Podemos is a playfully “feminist” name. Instead of using the generic masculine (Unidos Podemos) they w–ent with the feminine form. Seats at Congress: 35.