by Joanne Beattie
My babies were what were then called ‘bad sleepers,’ and I was a connoisseur of methods to make night times more tranquil. One was popularly called the ‘shush-pat’ technique.1 I remember someone suggesting that the reason it works is that babies can’t concentrate on more than two things at once. So if you pat their backs and whisper “shush” in their ear, they aren’t able to bend their mind to crying as well. This was combined with what the internet called the ‘put down pick up’ technique. Once the baby has stopped crying, you can put it in the cot – I used to pick the baby up again if it didn’t go to sleep – and this goes on, as I recall, until one or other of you passes out from exhaustion. My father roared with laughter when I explained all this to him at the time. I gather he slept through the nights of my own babyhood, which perhaps explains his light-hearted approach to the matter.
We all get more sleep these days, but I still remember ‘shush-pat.’ I’ve no idea if it’s true, but the notion of a mind that can only hold onto two ideas at once is quite compelling. It occurs to me that sometimes mothers are treated as if we have this limitation as well. We are encouraged to focus on the superficial and personal elements of being a mother at the expense of our structural location as societal punchbags; and to disapprove of other mothers rather than organizing and acting as a supportive community.
We are shushed with all the shallow aesthetic and cultural considerations of motherhood, and in case that doesn’t work we are also patted and prodded into hostility to other mothers’ choices.
While we seek the perfect changing bag, the buggy with coffee-cup holder (what luxury! Unheard of in my baby days), or the exercise class to reduce the post-partum tummy, in the brief pauses between feeding, changing, and encouraging our babies to sleep we are not wondering what our earning power or promotion opportunities will be should we request part-time work after maternity leave. If we buy into the ‘yummy mummy’ myth, we are doomed to spend endless days arranging the paraphernalia of childcare in aesthetically pleasing shapes, capturing the good bits on film, and ignoring the rest.
And even while we enjoy the podcasts, the novels, the sitcoms which accurately reflect our own chaotic, exhausting days, we tend to be reflecting on the singular and the personal experience depicted there, rather than the deep-seated unfairness of all the ways mothers are judged, blamed, and discriminated against in our culture and in our day-to-day lives. A mother’s place is often in the wrong, indeed; but make her laugh enough and she may not take umbrage at the fact.
Shush, Mummy, how about a sheepskin rug to aid sleep?
While we bicker online about nursery vs. childminder vs. staying at home, we mostly ignore the fact that childcare is prohibitively expensive in the UK, acting as a drag on women’s careers and thus on our entire economy. We may also forget that regardless of whether we use childcare or not, whether we work longer hours or make more money than our partners or not, we end up doing the lion’s share of childcare and housework.
We are encouraged to focus on natural birth vs. Caesarean or the breast vs. bottle debate. Both are important issues at a societal level but a source of trickery when used to suck us into culture wars. Our disagreements go round in inconclusive circles as we point out each other’s failures, real and imagined, rather than consider the structural failings of the way our society treats mothers.
Pat, pat, pat. Tut at the woman on her phone while she pushes the swing, and don’t wonder if she’s feeling lonely at home with a small child all day, or if she’s checking work emails on her so-called ‘non-working’ day.
Or roll your eyes at the bottle-feeding newborn, but don’t rage at the paucity of breast-feeding resources and the advertising muscle of the formula companies.
All that time spent trying to make little creatures sleep like socialized adults feels like a terrible waste looking back; and maybe it’s symptomatic of the way mothers and babies are supposed to fit in to our madly over-scheduled society without inconveniencing anyone else. Instead of searching the ‘baby sleeping’ boards on internet forums, I could have been rocking my babies to sleep the way they preferred while browsing the pages which discussed politics and related campaigns, working out how to campaign for better maternity care, cheaper childcare, and a more equal society. I’m delighted to see that Mumsnet now has a dedicated ‘campaigns’ area. And if the next generation can harness the energies of new parents to be more outwards-facing, and less critical of themselves and each other, who knows what they might achieve?
Jo Beattie is a mother of two daughters. She loves them fiercely but didn’t particularly enjoy looking after newborn babies. Representations of motherhood in popular culture and fiction are of great interest to her.
1 See Tracey Hogg with Melinda Blau, Secrets of the Baby Whisperer (London: Vermilion, 2001), Kindle ed. pp. 233, 328, whose suggested methods were taken up by the internet, simplified, and given these names.
