Issue Two

Sex Isn’t a Western Construct – Gender Is

by Alina Shoukry

I was born and raised in the Middle East, which was absolute hell as a woman, a closeted lesbian, and an open feminist. I was constantly ostracized and harassed by schoolmates, colleagues, family, and even people I considered friends, all because of my unapologetic views on women’s rights. When I had the opportunity to go to college in Canada, I practically jumped at it. I couldn’t wait to be in a place where I could be feminist without backlash, and more importantly, where I could be gay.

As a result of being raised in a very conservative culture and family, with no other gay people in my real life, I turned to and became deeply involved with Westernized internet spaces, where everything LGBTQ was open and celebrated. To a little lesbian, the West seemed like an idyllic safe haven where everybody could be themselves, free from discrimination. The internet is also where I discovered the existence of trans people, who I understood to be people ‘born in the wrong body.’ They were painted as the most oppressed, marginalized, endangered group in the LGBT. I felt immense sympathy for them; I knew that in my country gay people could be disowned, arrested, and murdered for being gay, so I was shocked to hear that trans people apparently had it even worse. Knowing the pain of being trapped in the closet unable to safely come out, I tried to be the best ‘trans ally’ I could be. I religiously practised my online friends’ pronouns, I retweeted their e-begging posts on Twitter – hell, I probably reblogged a post or two on Tumblr with “terfs don’t interact” tacked onto the end. All this is to say: I came to Canada with a completely open mind about trans people, willing to support them as best as possible. If anything, I was kind of excited to meet my first trans person in real life after making so many trans friends online.

Well, it didn’t go well. During a party on my first day in the university dorms, I was introduced to a self-described “straight transwoman” (i.e. attracted to men) who did all of the following during our very first meeting: groped my breasts and said he wished that his would get that big someday, made inappropriate comments about my clothing, and gave unprompted graphic details of his sex life. I was taken aback, but I kept telling myself that this was normal; I was just being conservative, I needed to be more open-minded. Sure, his behavior was predatory and very male, but sex is a Western construct, right? He’s really a woman in his heart and mind, right? I kept telling myself the same thing every time I walked into a women’s bathroom and saw a man, even though it automatically made my heart race and stomach turn because, back in the Middle East, being alone in a bathroom with a man meant certain doom.

(Sidenote: I was reaching out and trying to make friends with other Middle Eastern immigrants during this time, and I remember hesitantly asking a Muslim girl what she thought about the whole bathroom thing, seeing as it goes against Islam – males and females cannot be alone in intimate spaces, and most hijabis remove, adjust or re-tie their hijabs in the bathroom, which men are not allowed to witness. She told me that it made her very uncomfortable and she often had to avoid public bathrooms because there were men there. Still, she’d never say anything because she didn’t want to seem like a stereotypical homophobic Muslim, and because she knew that she’s the one who would be asked to leave, not the man. And here I was thinking Western liberals were supposed to care about anti-Muslim discrimination.)

As I met more and more trans people, I began to truly despair that I was the bigoted one for noticing unsavoury behavior from them. My friend circle was extremely ‘queer,’ and it was evident that the ones who identified as trans in some way were often abusive, narcissistic, and manipulative, but we weren’t allowed to confront it because there was this unspoken rule that you cannot criticize anything a trans person does. Even outside my friend group, I couldn’t escape it. A transwoman in one of my classes ranting about TERFs and cissexism in a text from the 1600s. A trans coworker throwing a fit because someone accidentally said ‘he,’ and demanding that we all go through mandatory gender-sensitivity training as a result. A non-binary girl I went on a date with talking incessantly about how much she despises ‘cis lesbians’ with ‘genital fetishes.’ And even though I tried desperately to ignore these red flags and continue uncritically supporting them, still it seemed like I couldn’t do anything right. I shared uterus art during the 2016 Women’s March and was gently berated by a non-binary friend for being exclusionary. I made a joke about hating dick at a party, and if looks could kill I’d be dead. I talked about FGM in the Middle East, and was asked to refer to it as just “genital mutilation” because vulvas weren’t necessarily female. And the worst crime of all: deep down, in my heart of hearts, I just could not force myself to believe that men could be women and women could be men.

I don’t remember exactly when I lost hope in Western activism. Maybe it was when I realized that people here want me dead for being a homosexual woman, same as in the Middle East. Maybe it’s when I realized that gay people were having hormones pushed onto them to cure homosexuality, same as in the Middle East. Maybe it’s when I realized that I had again been brainwashed at a young age – first into Islam, then into gender ideology and liberal feminism – and I was once again realizing that I couldn’t keep pretending to believe in the lies. For the second time in my life, I had to leave a misogynistic, homophobic, harmful, cult-like religion. Muslims call me kafira; transactivists call me TERF. At the end of the day, both words mean the same thing: nonbeliever. Traitor. Somebody who dares think, question, and decide their own morals instead of blindly believing in a religion that tells them the sky is green and down is up.

And to all white liberal feminists who argue that “sex is a colonial Western construct”: trust me, people outside the West know what sex is. In the Middle East, they know which sex of baby to kill or mutilate at birth. They know which sex to deprive of education and rights. They know which sex to force to cover their bodies and hair. Islam, created far before Western colonization, says that a man’s brain is equivalent to two women’s brains. My homophobic Muslim father believes that gay people are born in the wrong body and need hormone therapy to turn them straight. But please, oh holy woke queer activist, tell me again how brain sex is real and women who break gender roles actually have the brains of men. Tell me again how prepubescent children require blockers and hormones that will sterilize them. I know a lot of misogynist, homophobic, religious fanatics who would agree with you.

Alina Shoukry is a North African feminist, a proud lover of women, a university student and a cat enthusiast.