Issue Two

Race, Gender, Class

by SolAura

INTERSECTIONS AND NORMS

In the United States it has long been (and continues to be) the norm that the Good Negro Person is amicable, compliant, obedient, unassuming, helpful, self-effacing, and non-threatening. A failure to sufficiently comply with these norms was (and still can be) an actual death sentence for people of African descent in this country. But where did this norm come from? The answer is Gender. Women under patriarchy are expected to be all of these things as well. And why under patriarchy are women expected to be this way? Because those are the expectations we have for the Good Child. Children are the underlying model for femininity under patriarchy due to the belief that women are in fact undeveloped men in the same way that children are undeveloped adults. Under patriarchal pseudoscience, the fact that women are on average shorter and weaker than men is a sign that they are less evolved or developed than men are. Indeed, this pseudoscientific belief that some adult human beings are less evolved and less developed than other adult human beings due to their superficial appearance is the basis of pseudoscientific theories about so-called ‘racial’ differences as well. Moreover, in patriarchal societies, at what ages are ‘women’ typically married off and placed under the control of men? It has been the norm to marry off teenage girls before they have reached full physiological maturity (here I am also counting brain development, which is not complete until the early 20s). This norm that women are most desirable when they are not yet fully developed also informs white Western beauty standards, inclusive of the idea that women are most sexually appealing when they are essentially hairless from chin to toe. Gender also informs norms around Class. Which class of people are responsible for ensuring that you have food to eat and do not live in filth? Which class of people are responsible for taking care of the children and the old people? What do these people look like? Are they well paid? Are they respected? Do they have power? The work of ensuring basic civility and welfare is considered to be ‘low-class labour’ because this is the work that women have traditionally done for free in the home under patriarchy. The point is this: Gender is the template for both Race and Class. As such, it is impossible to develop a robust understanding of what both Race and Class are and how they operate if one does not understand their intersections with Gender and patriarchy.

CONSTRUCTION BY DESTRUCTION

Race, Gender and Class are all social constructs (i.e. fictions) that have been created to deconstruct and ultimately destroy the real object upon which they are overlaid: Race overlays Ethnicity. Gender overlays Sex. Class overlays Human Labour. The deconstruction and destruction of Ethnicity, Sex, and Human Labour are accomplished by two primary means: inversion of value and erasure.

PERVERSION BY INVERSION

Inversion of value means that that which is essential is made superficial, while that which is superficial is essentialized. This perversion of reality has real consequences, many of which are now becoming clear as so-called ‘Western Civilization’ teeters on the brink of collapse. The value of Ethnicity is inverted by Race such that the most superficial aspects of identifying one’s ethnicity (phenotype, skin colour) are deemed essential to the individual’s ‘race,’ while the essential aspects of ethnicity (deep culture) are minimized and dismissed. The end result is that Race trumps Ethnicity. This leads to individuals of differing ethnicities being considered as belonging to a single ‘race.’ The value of Sex is inverted by Gender such that the most superficial aspects of identifying one’s sex (clothing, make up, breasts) are deemed essential to the individual’s ‘gender,’ while the essential aspects of sex (reproductive organs) are minimized and dismissed. The end result is that Gender trumps Sex. This leads to individuals of different sexes being considered as belonging to the same ‘gender.’ The value of Human Labour is inverted by Class such that the productive human labour which is essential for ensuring a functioning society is devalued, while those not engaging in essential productive human labour (i.e. the idle rich, entertainers) are valorized, celebrated, and economically rewarded. The end result is that Class trumps Human Labour. The slow economic and political decline of the middle class into poverty and powerlessness speaks to the way in which Class ultimately devalues all human labour. Note the way in which billionaire technocrats continuously speak of ‘the end of work,’ and the idea that robots are capable of replacing all forms of human labour. While Race, Gender and Class are social constructs, they become materially inscribed as a quasi-reality, which is to say they become partially true. However, because these social constructs require a conceptual inversion of actual reality, they can never actually be made true. Indeed, attempts to make these social constructs real leads to the destruction of the material reality on which these constructs are overlaid.

ERASURE: MATERIAL, CONCEPTUAL

The process of realization of social constructs erases the objects upon which they are constructed. This erasure is always both material and conceptual.

Material erasure

Racial realization has resulted in the actual erasure (i.e. genocide) of tens of millions of Indigenous people in the Americas and the ethnicities to which they belonged. It also resulted in the erasure of the ethnicities of tens of millions of people of African descent who during enslavement were stripped of most of the deep culture which constitutes an Ethnicity—language, traditions, cosmology, chronology, etc. Both Africans and Indigenous people were also stripped of their children who were sold for labour or sent to re-education camps. This theft of children is a direct attempt to prevent a continuation of ethnic lineage which is not merely genetic, but cultural. Ethnicity is in a real sense a form of consciousness, and children are the vessels through which an ethnic lineage transfers and transforms the contents of its collective consciousness. Gender realization has resulted in the actual erasure of tens of millions of women across Asia due to the selective abortion and femicide of female foetuses and girls. This erasure of women is also seen in patriarchal norms of women being forced to remain home-bound and being erased from the public square and political power. Class realization has resulted in the actual erasure of tens of millions of jobs via automation, industrialization, and outsourcing. A lack of any concern for the economic and psychological depression that results from this has led directly to the rise in addiction and dysfunction that defines the social condition of the so-called ‘rust belt.’ The erasure and devaluing of essential Human Labour is also seen in where poor vs. rich people live. Poverty actually pushes people to the periphery of society—into homelessness, or into the outskirts where they remain largely unseen by the rich.

Conceptual erasure

The current so-called ‘transgender rights’ movement allows us a window through which to view the idea of conceptual erasure in real time. In the name of being ‘inclusive’ of male beings in the category called ‘women,’ women are expected to refer to themselves not as women, but as ‘gestators,’ ‘menstruators,’ ‘vagina people,’ ‘uterus havers,’ ‘chest feeders,’ ‘birthing persons,’ ‘pregnant people,’ and so on. I have even seen language suggesting that we use ‘internal organs’ rather than specifically uterus, ovaries, cervix, vagina, etc., lest one accidentally trigger ‘gender dysphoria’ in males who believe themselves to be women and covet their bodies. What we have here is the linguistic erasure of women, resulting in the linguistic deconstruction of what a woman is. That is, women are being linguistically reduced to their constitutive parts and functions without ever naming the word ‘woman,’ the term which holistically references them. This is what dehumanization actually is – a reduction of the human being to parts and functions without ever naming or seeing the whole person. If we consider social movements to legalize prostitution and commercial surrogacy, that is, legally sanctioning and economically incentivizing women to participate in their own deconstruction and dehumanization, it becomes even more obvious just how insidious this kind of linguistic reductionism really is. Moreover, given that the United States has a grotesque history of actually deconstructing, that is, vivisecting and dismembering live human beings into their constituent parts as a bonding ritual, this foray into conceptual deconstruction of women is far from benign. I encourage you to look at the violent rhetoric directed at women who have the temerity to say that there are no males who are women. Black people have been subject to actual deconstruction by violent, angry mobs for far less than asserting obvious and basic truths. The belief that the violent rhetoric shown on terfisaslur.com will not eventually lead to real violence against women who fail to go along with Gender ideology is laughably and dangerously naïve. As Ed Pilkington’s article ‘The sadism of white men: Why America must atone for its lynchings’ helps us remember, this kind of violence was not indulged in merely by lowlifes and rednecks, but by entire communities. Indeed, these acts of mob violence were led by the most respectable members of society – lawyers, doctors, and even clergy. That doctors, lawyers, and increasingly even clergy are willing to sanction the destructive, inversive, erasing logic of Gender while turning a blind eye to the violent rhetoric and abusive behaviour of Gender-ideology advocates speaks to the malignant culture that remains firmly embedded in the collective consciousness of the United States. It is not a matter of if non-compliant women will be lynched for rejecting Gender ideology, but rather when they will be lynched. The current sanctioning of this dehumanizing language, the willingness of the medical community to engage in the actual erasure of Sex through Gender-confirming genital-deconstructing surgery (note here the actual, material erasure of Sex) all but guarantees that those who do eventually engage in lynching a woman will feel fully supported and sanctioned in doing so. Indeed, the fact that in medical schools there has been a very intentional failure to engage the ethics of affirmative protocols in the care of ‘gender dysphoria’ in children, especially as it relates to whether a child can give informed consent for permanent sterilization and amputation of healthy body parts, even as they cannot consent to engage in sexual intercourse, get a tattoo, watch an R-rated movie, or even vote, speaks to the current level of moral bankruptcy (or is it fear?) that has taken hold. It also speaks to a civilization that no longer believes in its own future. This willingness to throw away a child’s reproductive capacity (again, children are the vessels through which a people transfer their culture) in the name of affirming a delusion shows that the United States is still fundamentally unwilling to end its own delusional beliefs and embrace a future grounded in reality.

AFTERWORD: A FEW NOTES ON THE WHITE SUPREMACIST CAPITALIST PATRIARCHY

bell hooks coined the phrase ‘White Supremacist Capitalist Patriarchy’ to describe the form of rule in the United States. Each of its terms speaks to the three interlocking axes of oppression – Race, Class, and Gender.

Oppression is economic exploitation, that is, not actually benefitting from the labour one does which is essential for the survival of the community, while being simultaneously devalued and dehumanized. The solution to oppression is liberation from the oppressive social construct. This requires reclaiming the value of the real object overlaid by the construct.

It is important to clarify that oppression is not marginalization, though all oppressed people are also marginalized. That is, marginalization is a necessary but insufficient condition for being oppressed. Marginalization is social exclusion. However, marginalization is not in and of itself immoral. The morality of exclusion depends upon the reason for the exclusion, whereas oppression is always immoral because of its reliance on dehumanization.

Criminals (as opposed to the criminalized) are appropriately marginalized because their sociopathic behaviour is a direct threat to civil society. Criminals only become oppressed when they are forced into labour that generates profit for corporations and/or an oppressive state.

One way we know that the criminal labouring for a corporation is being oppressed is that this situation actually creates an economic incentive for creating criminals (that is, criminalizing people) which is, of course, socially destructive. Why pay people to labour when you can use prison labour instead? Oppression always creates perverse incentives that degrade civil society and human dignity.

The notion that Race, Class and Gender are interlocking axes of oppression clarifies why the argument in the US of ‘is it race or class?’ is a confused one. The answer is that it is both, plus Gender.

The working-class racist is doomed to poverty because he wants to overthrow Class while keeping Race. The white feminist is doomed to patriarchal subjugation if she lacks the capacity to fully value the input and perspectives of women who are not white or wealthy.

The transgender advocate working for racial liberation is a liability rather than an ally to those oppressed by Race, because he or she is essentializing Gender, the malignant construct which provides the template for the concept of Race.

An understanding of these interlocking dynamics also clarifies why we are seeing a resurgence and re-entrenchment of both patriarchy and white supremacy. The rise of the billionaires is a re-entrenchment of aristocracy (aka plutocracy, oligarchy, and monarchy) which is rule by Class. The re-emergence of Class rule will inevitably cause a re-emergence of the worst forms of white supremacy and patriarchy because, as already stated, they are all interconnected. It also reveals the strategy by which the White Supremacist Capitalist Patriarchy maintains its control. If one axis seems lost, simply prop up one of the other two and, eventually, the lost axis of power will return to their control.

It is worth noting that neither political party is immune to the machinations of White Supremacist Capitalist Patriarchy because both political parties are its invention. As I like to say, both the left hand and right hand are attached to the same sociopathic body politic.

This illusion of choice qua political polarization is precisely why those on the political left have been so uncritical in their embrace of Gender ideology, despite the fact that is actually the most regressive and violent form of patriarchy. They falsely believe that ‘left is good’ and ‘right is bad.’ This lack of critical thinking via polarization turns those who subscribe to it into useful fools who are easily manipulated.

SolAura is a black woman who thinks.