Issue Five

Paternalism and Reproductive Agency: On Abortion

by Rebecca S. Bergfjord

I was wearing my grandfather’s cap when I had my first abortion. It was a gray tweed Irish newsboy flat cap with a snap that had torn through more than once. Two tiny gold safety pins held the visor and brim together, and I always wore it akilter. This memory wasn’t something I realized still sheltered in the dendritic tips of my mind until, shaken loose, it surfaced. I’ll admit to you now, I was unaware that there were lost parts of me sunk in a submarine deep in a turbid and glaucous sea, and when I offered to write this essay, I’d unthinkingly decided to open the hatch. I didn’t know where to start, what to include or exclude, what mattered most. I didn’t want to write another sad or tragic abortion story — ultimately my story is one of triumphant reclamation — yet brash and brave are not the same animal. I wanted to show that how our culture interprets and discusses abortion largely serves to privilege and amplify narratives which only reinforce patriarchal power.

The truth is that some weeks after I agreed to write this piece, the self-manufactured inundation of trying to incorporate all of the story of abortion, replete with urgent and appalling statistics from Gambia and Venezuela, the wild variety of ways abortion can be used as a weapon against women, and how it all interweaves with grief and confusion and fear and triumph and race and sexuality and relief and fury, overcame me brutally as though I found myself standing between countless open hydrants, understanding how I — how women — came to be there, but unknowing what to do with the violent volume of these conflicting, roaring, immobilizing flows.

How does one begin to write about the experience of abortion? How to explain that abortion and reproductive sovereignty are the story of centuries of fundamental injustice for women at the hands of men? Or that women’s reproductive wisdom, which we are largely ignorant of and alienated from today, is our ethical and material birthright? To do this one must ford the fear of exposure to judgement and criticism. I must acknowledge that, even though my body no longer contains any of the cells of the woman who once lived through these things, I’ve unwillingly left pieces of myself behind for self-preservation, and though there will be commonality, I cannot seek to represent or account for vast suppressed, unrecognized, and untold women’s stories. Many years have passed since I had my first abortion, and I have been wading, waiting, so let’s start there.

At the time of writing, 25 states in the US require a waiting period, typically 24 hours at minimum and up to three days or more, between the initial counselling visit and the procedure. This is the legislation of infantilization. The fiction that legally enforced waiting period restrictions were established to obtain informed patient consent and provide time to access needed information and objective, empathetic guidance amounts to an additional layer of reproductive policing, and does no more than complicate an already challenging situation. A national survey of abortion patients conducted in 2008 found that 92% of women reported they’d made up their mind to have an abortion prior to even making an appointment, indicating that waiting periods are unnecessary.1 Implicit in this legislative restriction is that in the eyes of a patriarchal state — which seeks to impose reproductive control over women’s bodies — women’s decision to have an abortion must be managed and supervised, if not outright discouraged.

Waiting period restrictions inconvenience women who have access to more resources, forcing them to travel back and forth to the clinic over several days in order to fulfil this legal requirement. For women with fewer resources — women in poverty, without a car, without a network of connections, with children at home and no alternative childcare — this restriction can eliminate the possibility of getting an abortion at all, leading some women to resort to desperate and dangerous attempts to miscarry. The realities of obtaining an abortion are far more complex and varied than mainstream political narratives would ever have us believe.

And yet the state chooses, legislates ! to infantilize us, a legal acknowledgement that they only grudgingly allow women reproductive control over our own bodies in the first place, happily, gleefully ! raising up these ridiculous hoops we must jump through for our primal sex-based right to our own reproductive sovereignty. Women are told to wait if we need an abortion, are told to wait, sometimes for years ! if we want sterilization, are told to wait for the day our rights will at last be given over to us. Reproductive control over women’s bodies is a form of discipline and it is screaming Grade A patriarchal bullshittery.

I had my first abortion in February 2004. I had just turned 23 and was working in the produce department of the Whole Foods in a wealthy area of Philadelphia. I lived in Fishtown in a cramped shared rowhouse with low ceilings. My boyfriend M. and I met a couple months prior when I’d moved into the house, oddly into the very room he was moving out of. He’d been cleaning out the closet-sized room I was considering renting, and months of his lost long hairs had snarled around the vacuum brush, causing the motor to squeal and smoke. I’d flipped the machine over, taken the knife from my belt, and cut the hair away before handing it back to him without saying a word. He said later he felt both supremely emasculated and deeply impressed.

I’d surprised him, my hair cropped into a mohawk, wearing men’s heavy canvas pants, leather biker jacket, my tweed newsboy cap, hard as glass and fleeing an experience which had left me traumatized, and barely hanging onto the world. M. was a phenomenal bassist, a scholar of Nietzsche and Marx, and his fearsome radicalism and waist-length hair drew me to him. In retrospect, it’s clear neither of us was anywhere near stable. I chose to find him at the corner bar one night and we gravitated precipitously and irreparably towards each other. He didn’t move out, much to my new roommates’ chagrin and/or despair. He just moved back into his old room alongside me.

We had only been together for a couple months when I became aware I was pregnant, the cause likely the one time we couldn’t find a condom and we’d decided foolishly, drunkenly to just keep going. At the time, condoms were my primary choice of birth control, but their success depends entirely on having one in hand at the right moment, and they’re vulnerable to tearing, spillage, oils, time, and heat. Unlike hormonal birth control, which gives a woman far more personal control over her own fertility decisions, condom use involves additional layers of trust and consent. A woman often must not only convince her male partner to agree to wear one, but she must also trust him to wear it responsibly, and not surreptitiously remove it midway through. The hormonal methods I’d personally used impacted my mental and physical health to such a degree to make them untenable. But for many women, the side effects of hormonal birth control are negligible or manageable, and it enables her to regain full guardianship over her reproductive choices, frees her to choose when and if she wants to procreate, and historically has led to bounding increases in women’s education, career engagement, civil freedoms, and personal wealth and independence.

Worldwide, between 2015 and 2017, nearly a quarter of women ages 15 to 49 used some form of hormonal birth control.2 Curiously, patriarchal overlords around the world provide over-the-counter, governmentally subsidized, or free access to birth control pills in a great many countries, and withhold it or gatekeep access in others. The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists released a report in 2012 indicating that not only are women capable of using self-screening tools to determine their eligibility for birth control pills, “over-the-counter access to hormonal contraception should be the ultimate goal.”3 Yet in “higher income countries—western Europe, Australia, Japan and North America,” access to birth control pills typically requires a prescription, and these prescriptions are not always covered by insurance.4 In my mind, the deeper driver here is a capitalistic cash grab through the medi-pharmico infantilization of women; both the abortion industry and the pharmaceutical industries derive vast income streams through the continuation of depriving women of easy, inexpensive access to hormonal birth control. Such a complexity of effects is produced when Patriarchy and Capitalism embrace.

Once upon a time there was a fantastic plant called Silphium that when regularly ingested by fertile women was as effective as birth control pills, as well as an effective abortifacient. Used from the 7th century BCE through the times of Ancient Greece, it grew in a very narrow band, perhaps 30 miles wide, on the hills facing the Mediterranean in an area we now call Libya. It’s speculated that it went extinct from over-harvesting and the expansion of grazing into this region, but I wonder if the market (yes, there was a terrific export market for it) wasn’t a player in Mother Nature saying, Nope. Too many dudes profiting off this gift to my daughters, gonna have to pull it. 

In other countries, nearly all forms of modern birth control are precipitously expensive, barring access for the majority of women. In Venezuela, in early 2021, “a pack of three condoms costs $4.40 USD — three times Venezuela’s monthly minimum wage of $1.50. Birth control pills cost more than twice as much, roughly $11 a month, while an IUD, or intrauterine device, can cost more than $40 — more than 25 times the minimum wage. And that does not include a doctor’s fee to have the device put in.”5 These are tactics — to keep women always on the back foot. These systemic policies reveal the deep-seated patriarchal fear that loss of control over women’s reproductive power would inevitably lead to men’s inability to maintain the misogynistic, hierarchical, and at times, violent status quo in social, economic, political, and personal realms. There is a great well of patriarchal rage over its inability to bring human fertility fully to heel in the way they have more or less managed to do with other realms such as agriculture, medicine, ‘nature,’ and other living creatures.

It’s funny. I didn’t quite believe I would actually get pregnant that night. Maybe I thought I’d just get lucky this one time. Perhaps it was a sort of delusion brought on by the driving DNA replication urge, a pre-conscious, self-destructive, last ditch attempt to make something out of the nothing I’d been driven to think I was. Perhaps it was something else entirely. We do not always know why we make choices that we only later realize wildly complicated our lives and shunted us down avenues we didn’t expect to ever find ourselves on. What I did know for certain was that I never intended to have children.

Plan-B, or the ‘Morning-after Pill,’ a newer type of hormonal emergency contraceptive, had not yet been approved for over-the-counter usage at that time, but could have provided me a last-ditch option to potentially prevent pregnancy. Currently in the US, Plan-B, either in generic or brand name forms, costs somewhere between $11 and $50 dollars and is widely available in pharmacies. Yet, women are often socially stigmatized and treated with scorn and contempt when trying to acquire this type of contraception, as if merely purchasing emergency contraception indicates a woman is careless or promiscuous. I myself have stood in front of pharmacists who didn’t bother to conceal their disdain and open judgement for asking to purchase Plan-B. In reality, however, there are innumerable reasons why a woman may choose to use emergency contraception — some of which, like in the case of rape, are far more devastating and traumatic than a simple oops or broken condom, and the public condemnation and not-so-subtle ‘walk of shame’ many women experience when trying to access this option is egregious, misogynistic, and yet another instance where women are emotionally manipulated and socially humilated for even engaging in sexual activities in the first place.

But what does ‘public condemnation’ mean when conservative men sneeringly proclaim “I don’t consent to my tax dollars going to pay for abortions and contraception!” In the eyes of the patriarchal male, women are for titillation or procreation, and are seen as the public or semi-public property of men, to be taken and then be discarded if they so choose. The culture of sexualized advertising in the US (compounded meteorically by the advent of freely available digital pornography) has over decades repeatedly declared open season on women’s bodies, to slap, ogle, fuck, and abuse, and to utilize for cheap or free labour and care. And when the results of the societally encouraged, entitled sexual predation upon women leads to the ever-present possibility of pregnancy, those same women are openly painted as tax-stealing harpy sluts. It is men’s rejection and denial of their leading role in the use and abuse of women’s bodies that serves to springboard further patriarchal control and use of women’s bodies. That is disgusting.

Men want women to be sexually available, to slake their tremendous urges in our bodies, but do not want to allow women the right to say, Nope. No babies. Despite what sexual pleasure women may experience with men, under patriarchy our pleasure is always secondary. Under men’s hands our pleasure is entwined with the loss of this birthright, irreparably twisted through with pain. Without these miracles of birth control — condoms, the Pill, barriers and herbs and spermicides — expressing desire and engaging sexually with men, for women, is inevitably risky, and comes with considerable physical, social, even mortal risk. Any risk men experience doesn’t compare. Male and Female sexuality is more than just a joining of two individuals, it is a potential and/or inevitable entanglement of their futures that begins on the genetic and biological levels. If a child results from the union, this connection can expand in complexity into social, ethical, caretaking/giving, geographical etc. entanglements, and it is rare for women to be able to opt out of these responsibilities in the way men can. The biological vulnerability of women began here, with her fecundity, and man’s response has been to exploit our vulnerability through shame and control, tying Woman’s spirit to her reproductive function.

As Maya Yonika aptly puts it, “Women’s bodies carry the burden of sexual consequence,”6 and our female bodies’ unruly fecundity is treated as either welcome resource-to-be-tapped or, when the ramifications are unwanted, disobedience. Disregarding, demonizing, and punishing us when the outcomes of our fertility become too problematic to fully control — and in the case of black and brown and indigenous women, increasing the domination of their reproductive sovereignty to more fully dehumanize and eugenicize entire populations. Controlling traditionally ‘othered’ women’s bodies is a vicious rot at the centre of the punitive abuse of women’s fertility. However, so many of these things I only learned much later.

I could feel it, honestly, being pregnant. There was a prickle of energy running from my belly button down through my urethra. It was distinct and constant. I was also experiencing morning sickness that never relented, lasting all day and all night. Two positive pregnancy tests later my mind began to whirl. I knew how I felt about having children. For many women, having children is a longed-for experience, welcomed even when circumstances and timing aren’t entirely ideal or rosy, but for me, children were never in my life plan at all.

At first, in desperation, I tried an herbal approach for forcing a miscarriage I’d found on the internet (ah, miscarriage — the word itself implying mis-handling, carelessness — there is blame of women found inside our language too), desperate for the 10 days or so I strictly followed these instructions, going to work, smiling blithely, helping customers, the realization at how entirely fucked I was dawning by the moment, that this clearly wasn’t working. I catch myself even now as this admission is dangerous. My position — now, as a trained Western clinical herbalist — is that the legacy of herbal abortion knowledge ought be kept hidden, well away from public view. It is a route of desperation, and should never replace safe, legal, clinical abortion care.

Unfortunately, “the declining availability of affordable and accessible abortion services is leaving some women who want to terminate their pregnancies — but who live in hostile geographic areas, and have limited resources and little support — with no practical options other than to self-induce, which in turn may put them at risk of prosecution.” Horrifyingly, “thirty-eight states … now allow a person to be charged with homicide if she or he is deemed responsible for the unlawful death of a fetus, and not all of these laws clearly exempt the pregnant woman herself from being charged.”7 In El Salvador, where abortion is illegal altogether, at least 27 women were convicted and imprisoned on the charge of self-induced abortion between 2000 and 2011, even though many of these women denied even knowing they were pregnant or claimed they’d simply had a miscarriage.8 Damned if you do, damned if you don’t.

Yet our glorious fecundity is abundant. Nearly all women carry some 300,000 eggs inside us that formed as we grew inside our mother’s wombs. The egg that made me was created by my maternal grandmother’s body. The average number of children a woman successfully raises to age five varies throughout history and from culture to culture, but never could a fertile woman come close to exhausting her potential. Out of that vast number of large gametes each woman carries through the world, only a few ever make it to potentially implanting into the layers of endometrium that make up the uterus. Breastfeeding an infant will cause a mother to be largely infertile whilst milk production and suckling are in progress, protecting her against heaping yet another infant on her too soon. Women understand the material cost of adding more individuals to our population, as each person enters this world through the channel of woman, is fed through the body of woman, is dreamed of and made real through our labour, our breath, our blood. Often the price of birthing a life is our own lives. This price, these risks and rewards can only be understood by women, in a way men cannot ever experience. This may also be why men are such fucking dicks.

But, at last, when it was clear the herbs weren’t going to get me out of this, I began looking into abortion clinics. There were a couple of clinics in the city — the closest was the Planned Parenthood downtown. The cost was staggering — $600 — nearly impossible for me to raise in time for the procedure. I made very little money at the time, perhaps a thousand dollars give or take each month, and with food and utilities and train fare, there was little left over. I talked the situation over with M. For some strange and unjustified reason, he’d long believed himself to be infertile — I can’t say why — and while he was in agreement that we needed to choose abortion (he hadn’t planned to ever have children either, nor could he afford to have a child at that point any more than I could) he was quietly delighted his swimmers were in working order. I wasn’t in agreement about that, as if he had actually been infertile I wouldn’t be in this predicament in the first place, but I was relieved that unlike countless male partners who mistakenly believe themselves to be infertile, he accepted the news that he was wrong, and did not accuse me of infidelity or become violent. He blanched when I revealed the cost of the procedure but said he would figure out a way to pay it.

I scheduled the abortion for the following week. The woman I spoke to at the clinic said it was strongly recommended I take at least a week off from full duty work afterwards, as the strain of lifting heavy waxed cardboard boxes of butternut squash and apples to refill produce bins could cause a haemorrhage. She suggested I request light duty tasks for at least five days following the abortion. I went into a state of panic after my manager refused to reschedule any of my shifts to allow me this small bit of time off. None of my co-workers were willing or able to pick up any of my shifts either. As for light duty, my boss said it was completely out of the question. My entire job was physically demanding, trundling eternally in and out of room sized coolers, lifting lifting lifting all day long. There was no way to make any of it ‘light duty.’ They refused to budge even after I came out with a half-truth that my doctor had said I needed an urgent medical procedure, and that I could give them a note.

I wondered if the recently passed Family and Medical Leave Act,9 which insured a worker’s job security in case of certain emergencies, might be a way for me to at least retain my position, but when I asked Human Resources about it, they told me I’d need to disclose the details of my situation before my eligibility could even be determined. I didn’t understand the law myself, but certainly did not want to disclose why I needed to have a few unexpected days off. It was only in researching this very essay that I learned that I hadn’t been eligible for coverage under FMLA because I hadn’t been at the job for more than a year, and I suspect that their mischaracterization of my eligibility was calculated to intimidate and emotionally coerce me into continuing to work without interruption as it would have inconvenienced management. This is but one example of how employee/employer relations under a cut-throat capitalist system lead to the more vulnerable party always being under threat of exploitation. Complexity of the law is part of the systemic oppression of women which undermines our personhood and reproductive freedoms. My boss’s position was that I either show up and do all of the job, or find another one elsewhere. Feeling trapped, I called their bluff and resigned, hoping I could find something else quickly when it was all over — that I would somehow find a way to survive this, too.

On the night before the procedure, M. and I had a huge fight; there are deep textures that surround abortions, the lives of women, both coddled and compromised. He had been unable to come up with the money. I’d come to learn over the couple of months we’d been dating that he drank himself to near or total oblivion on a semi-regular basis, purchased and smoked enough pot to sedate a mule, and blew most of his money on eating out, partying, and other puerile trash. I wasn’t surprised he couldn’t come up with the money, but something hardened inside me then against him. He couldn’t even be relied on to pay to resolve this damn situation. So, on the day of the abortion, we took the EL downtown and I cleaned out my bank account. And now I no longer had a job. In the US in 2014, the majority of women who chose abortion already had at least one child.10 If I had other children to care for, losing my job and spending my last $600 on a needed abortion could have absolutely devastated my life and the lives of my children, potentially forcing us onto the streets or into a shelter. The expense of abortion is rarely, if ever, covered by insurance, and as three-quarters of women who seek abortion care are low income, the appalling economic decisions women must make can ripple alarmingly into all other aspects of our lives.11

M. and I walked from the subway station over to the clinic, but due to safety concerns he wouldn’t be allowed in. The history of terrorism and violence directed both at women who seek abortion and at abortion providers and clinic staff and unfortunate bystanders is horrifying. Clinic invasions, kidnapping, arson, vandalism, death threats, bomb threats, actual bombings, murder.12 In recent years, abortion clinics have taken extreme bomb-proofing measures, appearing more like bunkers or prisons than medical facilities. Decades of religious extremist onslaught has only made abortion care more expensive to offer and to obtain, and furthermore, has made providing amenities, comfort, and humane environments to deeply vulnerable women far more difficult to do.

While Philly is definitely not the Deep South, there still was a crowd of hecklers outside the high-rise office building housing the Planned Parenthood clinic, carrying signs with splashy colour pictures of dead foetuses smeared with red. The two-deep string of people, carefully skirting the line of demarcation on the sidewalk where they were allowed to stand by law, shouted unceasingly at women who seemed they could be entering the building. Some 20 people harassing women in the dead of winter on the grey streets of Philadelphia, calling out to strangers to reconsider their choice to “murder their own babies.” I told M. I’d meet him after, and perhaps due to the fact that I was an anomaly — my hair short, my stance tall, and dressed like a boy — I strode by the protesters to the entrance before most even realized I was female and planned on going in. They hadn’t identified me as a target for their righteous torment, and while I counted myself lucky, the experience of abuse, the shaming and bullying and intimidation upon entering a clinic can be deeply traumatizing for women who are undergoing one of the most challenging and fraught experiences of their lives. That this is even allowed to happen is a travesty, a glaring indication of how women are devalued, and further evidence that the patriarchy considers women mere objects of procreation and not persons.

I remember little of what happened after, the hours of waiting in a locked room full of creaking fibreglass chairs. I was the only white person in the entire place apart from the male doctor, but only registered that fact years later when trying to recall details of that day.13 I handed over my money. I was given a basic ultrasound which confirmed I was nine weeks pregnant. I overheard one woman say to another that she already had three kids, there was no way she could support another one. Another woman quietly admitted that her boo had forced himself on her when he was drunk. It was the grimmest place in the universe.

When at last I was brought in for the procedure, I was told that all they could give me for the pain would be a single shot of Novocain administered by needle into my cervix. After being told to strip naked from the waist down, I climbed up on the table. I kept my hat on, that Irish newsboy cap I’d inherited from my grandfather. I can’t tell you why — only that I felt I needed my armour. When the doctor and surgical aides came into the room, they didn’t acknowledge me, not as a person, not as a patient. They talked loudly amongst themselves about what they’d gotten up to over the weekend, the party one had thrown for their kid’s fifth birthday, the hassles they’d encountered with parking that morning, as though I simply wasn’t there. My legs were up in stirrups, but I was falling through the floor. There was a nasty pinch and burn as the Novocain went into my cervix, then a terrible shearing and tugging. The doctor looked at me at last, eyes meeting as he said, “Are you ready?” Then, he turned the machine on and I passed out.

When I came to, the nurse assured me it sometimes happens. “Vasovagal response, you know.” She walked with me as I wobbled my way down the hall to the aftercare room. Several other women were already there, feet up, blanketed and sipping on juice boxes. I was offered my choice of apple or orange, and was given a stack of three battered Nila Wafers nestled in a little paper cup meant for ketchup. I looked at them for a long time, listening to the other women talking. Some seemed sad or upset or quiet, but all seemed deeply relieved. And I was just there, amongst them, feeling nothing. I was required to sit and drink my juice and then after 30 minutes I had to check my pad, to ensure I wasn’t bleeding too heavily. As soon as I was stable enough to walk, I was released, out through a door which disgorged onto a sheltered back street, one small concession that I wouldn’t have to face the vicious objectors again.

It was overcast, frigid and I met up with M. I hadn’t eaten anything but those fucking Nila wafers all day, so we went to a diner and had tuna melts even though I wasn’t really hungry. I ended up paying because he was even broker than me. The only thing I felt sitting in that diner was anger — a yawning chasm of anger and desolation, at him and his abject uselessness. I had paid in blood and in coin. I paid with the loss of my paltry financial freedom, numb from how impersonal, cold, and brutal the experience was.

In the following weeks, M. tried to pick up the slack, but he began to show the strain of trying to come up with our rent until I could find a new job. I slid into a phenomenal depression, and he slid into a manic-depressive state of psychosis. One night, we had a huge blow-up and he called me a revolting-privileged-bourgeois-whore, disgusted that he’d ever thought he loved me at all. After I slapped him in the face I went for a walk to cool my head, and he locked me out of the house. I slept in the doorway on the stoop, not exactly the safest thing to do in Fishtown. At last I found another job, in a boutique wood shop as an apprentice cabinet maker. When money started coming in again, things lifted a bit.

We limped along, swinging from blissful and high on copious amounts of beer, and falling into tempestuous, increasingly violent philosophical altercations. One night, I came home to find him in the unfinished, coal-dirt-floored basement dazedly recounting the argument he’d been having with the spider in the corner. Another night, in a surprising fit of fury, rare for me even to this day, I turned away from him during a heated debate about who needed liberation first — woman or the worker — and pummelled the fridge door, splitting open my knuckles and leaving very visible dents in the front of the machine. He lost/left his job, and then, quite alarmingly, I was supporting both of us. My depression, which had lifted slightly after I’d begun working again, rebounded ferociously. 

I left work exhausted each day, coated head to toe in sawdust, powdered paint, and clearcoat, even my eyelashes furred with the toxic stuff, riding the train home abject, ghostlike. The labour was immense, wrestling 14 ft beams of dense, resinous Brazilian mahogany up onto workbenches (each some 200 lbs each), manipulating 10 ft sheets of weighty MDF onto a tablesaw the size of my living room. I milled 7000 ft of hickory tongue-and-groove flooring, hauled it up three flights of stairs, and laid it in 105-degree heat that summer, without help. I began to find I couldn’t concentrate — obsessive thoughts of unthinkingly sliding my hand my arms my face into the 14” saw blade were a running horror movie on non-stop repeat in my head. My memory became that of a goldfish, blink blink what? No, seriously, what was that measurement again? Then, I began to pass out. 

It happened first in the bar on the corner of our street, a regular and familiar hangout where M. and I had first seriously connected. I wasn’t drinking. I’d had a pint of milk and a cheesesteak, began to feel dizzy, but unlike every other time, the static creeping in from all sides of my vision didn’t clear. I took two steps across the bar and blacked out. When I came to some two or three minutes afterwards, I promptly puked all over the floor. The following week it happened again, and then again only days later. Some occult part of me was demanding that this intense litany of traumas must be heeded, acknowledged, healed, or my body would be forced to shut everything down. While our physiological responses to trauma can vary, what’s not often given enough emphasis is how the physicality of stress and trauma can impact our lives, our relationship dynamics, our jobs, our sense of reality, even our ability to survive. Passing out abruptly (and in potentially dangerous situations at my job) was unthinkable. In late August, I told my boss I needed to resign for health reasons, and I left M. and Philly, and went home to live with my parents. 

What-ifs begin to swarm … What if I couldn’t return to the relative safety of my parents’ home and care? How would this story have been different if I didn’t have the option of a temporary haven where I could regain my footing and health, or if I’d had additional responsibilities like caring for children or other family members? What if I’d had the personal financial means and resources to take that time-out my body was demanding I needed, if I had been emotionally supported through the compounding snarl of traumas I’d been wading through? Yet so many women are not supported, do not have better options, and must press on into this infernal gorge, carrying the weight of our own pain and the needs of our dependents, barely holding on through the swirling destruction that may follow. 

Abortion itself is not an inherently traumatic event. Each woman’s feelings about her own experiences are justified and legitimate. But what is not acceptable is the way our patriarcho-capitalist system forces some women to believe they have no other choice, and stigmatizes and discourages others from choosing it at all. What is inadmissible is the degrading way women are often treated before, during, and afterwards, how our very understanding of the mechanisms of this oppressive system only serves to reinforce shame, silence, and sow narratives of disempowerment and weakness. We must lean into revealing how and why women make these choices for themselves, and look critically at the structural, social, and deep undercurrent of misogyny that runs through women’s lives and realities, which twists and constrains our rightful power and reproductive authority as well as our understandings of ourselves and our potential.

I had my second abortion when I was 29. I was living in Asheville, NC, by then with a different boyfriend, a tall and obscenely intelligent fellow who I’d met, surprise, while working at the local health food store. This time, it was he who worked in produce (when he wasn’t freelance writing), while I worked in the bakery, hand shaping hundreds of artisanal loaves each day. He was resolutely good, a graduate of a transcendental meditation college — good like clear water, good like newly turned soil. This time, there wasn’t a specific instance I could point to when the pregnancy could have happened. It just did. 

Again, the pounding nausea became my life, and I ate practically nothing during the pregnancy. He was lovely and kind, one of the best men I’d ever met, but neither of us wanted children, and in the course of days made the decision to travel to Charlotte for an abortion. Charlotte is a little over two hours’ drive by car from Asheville, and we were lucky that he owned a car and we both were working and could afford the procedure. It would have been much more difficult if I’d had to take a bus or find a ride, as many other women in North Carolina are forced to do. 

This abortion was a very different one from the first. My partner drove me to the clinic. We split the cost of the procedure, $250 each. Not a minor expense for either of us, but manageable. While most definitely in the Bible Belt now, we lucked out somehow and there were only two lone picketers, plunked in folding lawn chairs across the street from the clinic. They couldn’t even come onto the property — unable by law to enter into the parking lot — and as such, we were left with lots of space to eyeball them and walk in peacefully. I hadn’t even considered how walking into an abortion clinic unaccompanied can change the dynamic between women and those who show up to condemn and harass us. Had I been alone, without the social support of my very tall boyfriend, my vulnerability would have been more marked, further encouraging intimidation and heckling.

The clinic was almost pleasant, with several adjoining waiting rooms, comfortable chairs and curtains on the windows, allowing the women and their support persons a bit more privacy, as well as lending a homier feel. While the windows were bulletproof and the building itself surrounded by an earthen rampart, significant planning and funding had clearly gone into providing a dignified and supportive environment rather than one that dehumanized and promoted fear. We waited for several hours. He and I were both invited in for the required counselling session prior to the abortion, and the clinic director sat at a desk across from us and probed our states of mind, our motivations, and our relationship. She was respectful and kind. Mostly, she needed to ensure that we were sure of our decision, and didn’t have regrets or reservations about what we were planning to do. I recognize that the presence of my boyfriend changed how the counselling session played out, and that even having a man along supporting and agreeing to the abortion made me appear more respectable and rational. The sex and status of who accompanies a woman to an abortion should not factor into how we are treated, but these are the painful truths.

Here the protocol was different. Instead of waves of women being processed all day long by multiple doctors like in Philly, all the women scheduled that day had their counselling and ultrasound appointments in the morning. Then, in the afternoon, we were all brought back to a waiting room with books and couches and dim lights and soft music and given 10g of Valium each. The staff gave the drug time to kick in, then came and took two or three women at a time to the treatment rooms for the procedure. I was the last one called in because, after the experience of passing out during my first abortion, I’d hastened to tell the staff in Charlotte that I could, and likely would, pass out (and possibly lose control of my bladder, something that had happened more than once in the intervening years when I continued to intermittently lose consciousness at various times). I wanted them to be prepared for it. They made sure to check my blood pressure several times throughout the morning, and carefully made note to have ice packs on hand when I was having the procedure. It was a very strange experience being on Valium, sort of half-dozing in a warm and cosy room, waiting. After what had happened in Philly, this was unbelievably okay. Yes, the other women waiting with me were scared, or worried, or sad, or just wishing it would be over already, but there was a clear sense of care and acknowledgement of the weight of what we were doing, and the clinic staff and directors had gone to some lengths to ensure it was a relatively gentle, dignified, and humane process. I felt lucky. 

When they came to get me for the abortion, I was a long way off. Everything was coming in through a haze of molasses, though I was lucid and aware of what was being said around and to me. I was guided into a sterile-looking treatment room with lights blazing, but a nurse held my hand, and spoke to me with great compassion and sincerity. I wasn’t fully present this time around either, but their passion, care, and dedication made a world of difference. There was no Novocain this time, only the Valium, and the pain was very intense. I gripped the nurse’s hand, slurring at some point that I might be about to pass out. Instantly, a blood pressure cuff was slapped on my arm, and several ice packs were laid on my chest. One nurse kept ahold of my hand through all of this, telling me to be brave, that it was almost over, that I was doing great. I stayed conscious. 

Writing this now, this juxtaposition between these two experiences, makes me weep. Why was one so stark and horrific, and the other with mindful splashes of care and kindness and compassion? Shouldn’t every woman have the opportunity to have the latter experience if she were to find she needed an abortion? Over the years, my anger has grown that most women do not have the better of the two experiences, that they drive for hours, often across state lines, to find abortion care. Some don’t have anyone to drive them, don’t have anyone to watch their kids, don’t have a way to take time off from their jobs. Many cannot afford the fees. Many are treated with little respect or dignity leading up to and during the procedure, and while there are valiant, dedicated, and brave people who choose to work in this essential service, the systemic realities — legal restrictions which demand providers have hospital privileges (causing a vast number of clinics to shutter permanently), those arduous and unfair waiting periods, how some clinics force or trick women into viewing sonogram images of the foetus (it happened to me once), or that some pressure women to undergo certain kinds of ‘counselling’ (which amounts to religious manipulation and extreme guilting of women at their most vulnerable) — are brutal and oppressive in most states in the US. 

I left that day, after being filled to the brim with apple juice (no difference there), an aftercare sheet in hand detailing not just physical, but mental and emotional tips and suggestions for recovering from the abortion, a 24-hour phone number to call if anything seemed wrong or if I began bleeding too much, and a little bag with a couple of pads and a chocolate bar. It wasn’t much in the grand scheme of things, but if I wasn’t fortunate enough to be provided emotional support at home, and to have some supplies to start, this small offering could have been lifesaving. I was shown repeated, clear indications of concern for my health and wellbeing. This critical emotional care can restore a woman’s sense of personal agency, dignify the weight of what has just occurred, and offer support and solidarity instead of heaping disregard, degradation, or condemnation onto her, which would only compound any resultant trauma further.

Afterwards my boyfriend and I drove home through the dark mountains, and he let me direct the conversation, talking when I seemed to want to talk, and allowing me silence and contemplation when the after-effects of the Valium made me sleepy and withdrawn. In the days following, no major hiccups were apparent. My employer shifted the bakery schedule around to allow me a few days off work without much additional guilt or pressure. But ever so slowly, my relationship with my boyfriend devolved into just-a-friendship. He was so terrified of ever getting me pregnant again that he couldn’t bear to touch me. It was a devastating time for me, everything turned on its head, now unwanted and rejected for the unappealing consequences of my fertility. We slept chastely side by side, all romance and desire squelched on his end for nearly a year before I finally broke it off.

My first two abortions largely brought relief and a distinct sense of rightness about my choices. In my early 30s, I had two more abortions. The later ones I feel more conflicted about, furious at falling again and again for my body’s coyote tricks. Wriggling Loki – an variations on a theme: the ticking clock many women say they begin to hear in their late 20s and into their 30s — that clock was my body’s private hellish metronome while my mind, my spirit, simply didn’t hear that click click click at all. This internal struggle of mind and body: what life would I have lived if I wasn’t made of this riotous fecund earth, potential embodied? I longed for an alternative to waiting for that clock to run out. 

So, I began to look into surgical sterilization. I researched the side effects, the long-term concerns, the risks, and the many methods available that would relieve me from this ever-present threat of pregnancy. For many women, having children is a deeply wanted experience. The bald realities of my health challenges — the saga of my still unexplained bouts of fainting, neurological and joint-related issues due to chronic Lyme disease, only somewhat managed with herbal medicine, the years of struggle with my mental health, and my cycle of choosing unsuitable or unstable partners — only made my decision clearer and more definite. I wanted a bilateral salpingectomy.

From my research I grasped that as an apparently healthy, intelligent, never-married white American woman in my early 30s, I would encounter resistance and derision from the medical community about my desire to have myself sterilized, but I was frankly appalled at how overt, saccharine, and infantilizing the process was. Here again were hoops galore to jump through. The first surgeon I met with was a man who began his interview with these questions: “So, how many children do you have now, Mrs Bergfjord?” and “What does your husband think about this?” Yes, I’m quite serious. In 2014. As though I’d only be allowed to bow out of any future baby making if I’d already done my ‘feminine’ duty and produced at least a few babies for the patriarchal cause. 

The second surgeon I interviewed was a Belgian woman with six children who chided me, “But children are life’s greatest joy!” and “Who will take care of you when you are old?” I refused to apologize or waver in my conviction and held firm, but it was a trial and a half to hold my tongue. Giving them an earful could have backfired if they deemed me incapable of making my own medical decisions due to ‘showing too much emotional lability in interviews.’ I finally settled on a different woman doctor who didn’t patronize me too much and was reluctantly willing to do the sterilization. The ‘finding the surgeon’ part of the process took nearly two years. It was as teeth-gnashing as you might imagine to have to repeat myself ad nauseam — ‘No, I could give a flying fuck what my future husband might think about it’ and ‘Yes, I am fully capable of understanding what “permanent” and “non-reversible” mean.’ Then, came the required waiting periods.

When my surgeon finally agreed to do the surgery, I was given several legal forms to sign indicating I was of sound mind, was making this decision of my own free will, that I understood that sterilization was a permanent procedure, and that I wouldn’t hold them liable if in the future I were to change my mind. Then, I had to wait six more months, and if I still wanted to have the salpingectomy done, I would be put onto the scheduling list, which was scheduling at least eight months out. In some sense, I can appreciate that the medical professionals I encountered were operating under a very specific ethical framework. Getting sterilized is a voluntary, non-essential surgery, and would forever alter the course of my life and fertility options. But it was striking how my choices were bound on all sides by a system which only seemed to want to remove my agency.

I also read and heard countless stories from women who had been coerced or forced into sterilization. Countless stories of women who desperately wanted one and were repeatedly denied. A co-worker told me before the birth of her third child that her doctor strongly encouraged her to “add on” a salpingectomy to her planned C-section to ward off any future “accidents.” Another woman told me when she’d had an emergency C-section, her doctor decided to give her an unneeded hysterectomy because she was already open on the operating table, informing her only after the fact. Then there are the reams of paper I’d need just to scratch the horrifying surface of the US government sanctioned and funded forced sterilization programmes of countless women from vulnerable populations. Black women, Hispanic women, developmentally disabled women, institutionalized women, women whose names and stories and histories have been forgotten and overwritten. I rage for all women who’ve endured crushed dreams, for the repeated egregious violations, and I grieve how this inescapable patriarchal system forced so many of us to surrender our bodily autonomy and personhood into its ravening maw. 

The glib and bitter refrain of ‘the punishment is the point’ unfortunately doesn’t come close to revealing the complexity of women’s reproductive oppression under patriarchy. We must still continue to ask ‘The point of what?’ There are deeper dichotomies at work here. We must ask ourselves what really matters, who matters, and why women continue to be the ones who are judged and disregarded. Why is vulnerability — in women and in the natural world — continually, brutally exploited? Investigating how our human civilization assigns value, and who or what it devalues, is integral to understanding the philosophical, political, and emotional beliefs restricting, suppressing and conditioning women to accept the narrative that we are less than, that our fecundity is a weakness, that materiality should be scorned and discarded. The current structures around abortion and fertility punish women both for being vulnerable and for rejecting this vulnerability when it is not on our terms. Women’s oppression may be the story of what has been done to us, but we must not value ourselves the same way patriarchy does — always in grovelling relation to the vaunted subject. This will only lead to sprawling and self-destructive cul de sacs of internalized and largely unconscious patriarchal self-objectification. Everyday this challenge confronts me, and every day, somehow, I keep rising to reach for these answers. 

The dark corrosive ink of patriarchal rage and control — the rejection of the sanctity of Feminine power, and fury at our continued defiance, our unbreakability, our sacred gift of creativity — this apoplexy seeps to this day through the courts, into our schools, is shot through our industries, wicking its way through every country across this planet — miraculously still holding on through an ecological armageddon unlike any She has ever known. Again and again, the patriarchy points out that it believes women are responsible for the stain caused by this ink — which they use to write their meanings onto us as law. Meanwhile, they disdain us, as though we are men’s failed washerwomen, tasked with laboriously wringing out these Rorschach patterns of systemic violence, and doing a terrible job of it too. The neo-capitalist patriarchal call to abandon materiality, to reject the body’s frailties and failures, its claim that humankind will one day soon vanquish all corporeal weakness and ascend into the clouds — these are fever dreams of frightened hideous men, seething with a humiliation and shame of their own creation. After all, men dehumanized themselves first, and they must choose to see and do their own work, to scrub out this ink alongside all of us who also see and are doing our own work. And we are running out of time. 

I still carry quite a lot of subtle (and not so subtle) narratives that say my personal reproductive saga was ‘my own damn fault’ and also that ‘dudes are colossal assholes’ and boat loads of ‘I should be and feel a/shamed,’ but I am also choosing to work through my internalized patriarchal objectification, my learned self-objectification. So few in my life ever wanted me to be a human be-ing. Many only wanted a Mary Daly-esque ‘human do-ing’: a robot, a diaphanous fantasy, a mode of production, a mirror, a stack of folded laundry — a fold in the universe.

But women are not mere folds in the universe. We are embodiments of the universe, creating itself. This isn’t some fluffy woo-woo spirituality. This is but one way to begin to reclaim our personhood after a thousand generations of being continually devalued and objectified. You are sacred because you are a piece of the universe. You are the staggering and wondrous complexity and capacities of every body, a fluttering leaf in an aspen colony whispering to a starry sky, an ever-shifting fleck of mystery, your spirit and body perpetually in co-creation and support of one another. And that entwined being moves through a miraculous place we call Earth, where the supranatural and the scientific embrace in a kaleidoscopic and ephemeral becoming inside each and every moment. 

The rush of feeling that overwhelmed me when I began writing this piece has abated somewhat — the pressure beginning to equalize. While not true for all women, choosing to relinquish my fertility was one of the most freeing things I’ve ever chosen. I’ve occasionally fretted that by choosing sterilization I rejected the gifts of regeneration and creativity and female power and, yes, I’ve even had flashes of regret that because I’ve taken a radically different path than every single one of my ancestors — the successful genetic lineage that created me will also end with me. However, maybe those same ancestors might see this as a cause for celebration, because at long last one of their daughters had a choice! 

My old newsboy hat went missing one year as I moved from city to city, forgotten in a box, purloined by one of my brothers, lost in a bar, I don’t rightly know. My ‘fashionable’ armour fell away, and like a tree that grows too close to a chain-link fence, I didn’t even notice when instead I started carrying my armour close to my heart, embedded in heavy and gnarled layers of scar tissue. Encountering a tree like this, one studded with nails or bent over a barbed-wire fence long since rusted through, I can see both egregious trauma and a glorious symbol of survival. We are not our scars, but nor are we our stories, and poems and poems continue to wash up on my shores, and this marvellous, powerful community of women is rising, you, out of a tenebrous sea, and I’m finally recognizing that the mothering I most needed to undertake in this lifetime may have been for myself. Women are the keepers and arbiters of our species’ fertility, and while men may dislike this reality, and have made myriad attempts to enforce their unnatural ambitions, the systematic cross-cultural theft of power and manipulation of value that dictates to women what we can do and how we should feel about fertility is ours to reclaim.

Rebecca S. Bergfjord is a radical feminist and philosopher poet, living on the roundabout between periphery and precipice, napalms down-turned, dousing for rain. You can follow her @rsbergfjord on Twitter.