Issue One

On Female People

by Aisha Hashem

An inexhaustive list of things experienced by female people because of their membership of the female sex class:

FIRST, THE THINGS THAT NO AMOUNT OF “PRIVILIGE” CAN INNOCULATE AGAINST:

  • Sexual assault and domestic violence on account of being female. Sexual assault and domestic violence that is compounded by the fact that female bodies are generally smaller, our bones are less dense, and our muscles less powerful. Sexual assault and domestic violence that is compounded by the fact that society views female bodies as inherently sexualized, passive, receptive.
  • Being sexualized from the moment we hit puberty. Dealing with the pain and stigma of periods. Dealing with societal pressure as to how our bodies should look, be clothed, behave.
  • Fearing unwanted pregnancy — particularly as a result of sexual assault or rape.
  • Being on the receiving end of pseudoscience about how we’re naturally more understanding, more nurturing, more flexible. Being pressured to fit that mould and being punished if we resist or if we set boundaries.
  • Being on the wrong end of actual science…
  • Dying of heart attacks because we don’t know the symptoms, how they affect female bodies differently. Suffering through cardiovascular disease for the same reasons.
  • Dying of certain cancers because enough research hasn’t been done into how they affect our bodies differently.
  • Maternal heart attack. So sorry, don’t know what caused it or why your friend died a day after giving birth.
  • Autoimmune disease that disproportionately affects female bodies — with no knowledge of cause or cure because not enough research has been done into how and why our immune systems differ from males.
  • All the complications, physical and mental, that come along with pregnancy — many of them life-altering and permanent.
  • Chronic pain and illness that are treated as hysteria, not taken seriously, go on for years.
  • Having our reproductive ability controlled.
  • Being judged if we choose not to or we can’t reproduce.
  • Being reduced to being named by our reproductive capabilities.
  • Being treated as though our reproductive capabilities are the only thing that differentiate our bodies from male bodies when, in fact, our immune systems, skeletal structures, ligaments and tendons, cardio-vascular systems, bone density, skin thickness, core body temperature, heart and lung size all differ as well.
  • Existing in a world in which everything around us has been designed for a default male body — male hands, male chests, male height, male body temperature.

AND WORST OF ALL. THE THINGS SOME WOMEN ARE SPARED – WHILE REMAINING HORRIFIED AND OUTRAGED AT THE TREATMENT OF THEIR SISTERS:

  • Genital mutilation.
  • Chest ironing.
  • Period poverty.
  • Menstrual huts.
  • Female infanticide.
  • Forced marriage.
  • Child marriage.
  • “Honour killings.”
  • Forced surrogacy.
  • Forced prostitution.

We talk about being female, about female people as a class, because we are part of a group that faces specific issues, specific forms of discrimination and oppression, that require legal, societal, and medical recognition. Because talking about the issues we face doesn’t mean we’re denying the issues faced by others. Because implying that it does — placing us in a hierarchy of oppression where being recognisably female in a world that commodifies, abuses, controls, and ignores female bodies is seen, somehow, as a privilege — does actually deny the issues that we face. 

Because no other marginalized group is criticized when they advocate about issues that affect them specifically. Because no other marginalized group is told that their rights movements must include everyone. Because no other marginalized group is told that all members of that group must experience exactly the same marginalization in exactly the same way in order to qualify as a group.

The vast majority of us believe that sex does not equal gender. Anyone should be able to access a feminine gender identity or expression. Anyone should be free to reject the gender identity and expression associated with their sex. Anyone should be free to reject even the concepts of gender identity and expression. 

All should absolutely be free from discrimination levied against those choices. And it’s entirely right that people with feminine gender identities or expressions should find solidarity and support with each other on the level of gender identity and not sex. 

Why aren’t members of the female sex class afforded the same respect? Why must our category be cannibalized to protect another? Why is “erasure” (that dreaded word) acceptable only when it is the existence of female people being erased? And how is removing one protected class more progressive than acknowledging the existence of two protected classes and that differences exist between them? 

We use the word “woman” when talking about being female because it is the only word that refers to the female of our species. And if you take it away, make its meaning about gender and not sex, then we have no word left to describe our experiences. Our marginalization. Our discrimination. Our oppression. Give us another word if you like, but allow us to organize around it, to push for societal, legal, and medical protections that are relevant to the category we belong to and the issues we face as a result of that. Don’t tell us that sex doesn’t matter when it so clearly does.

Aisha Hashem is an academic who, for years, described herself as “egalitarian” rather than “feminist” in response to a certain, rather sadly ironic, type of paternalism directed at women from the Global South by Anglo-European political feminism. She has, however, come to see that certain rights can only be achieved and retained by foregrounding the source of their need—the specific issues faced by female people. She’d now term herself a “postcolonial feminist.”