by Jean Braithwaite
The first time one of my girl students transitioned in front of my eyes, I was horrified. Not least because I was the proximal cause. She enrolled in my undergrad non-fiction class, and wrote a powerful essay about growing up in a conservative family. The Christian grade school her parents had chosen enforced gender roles strictly, since that was God’s will. For many years prior to puberty she begged God, in her nightly prayers, to relent, and make her a boy instead. She also adopted the habit of pounding at her chest with her fists, hoping she could thereby stave off the sprouting of her breasts.
Perhaps I should not say ‘girl,’ in reference to a legal adult? But when you’re two decades older than they are, and then three decades, and then four, when you’re well into “I could be her mother” territory (and then “grandmother”) – well, it’s kind of hard to see them as fully baked. Especially when they’re under 25 and you know darn well – remembering your own youth – that their brains are not fully myelinized.
Let’s call the first girl Jackie. Later she became Jack. And what is the etiquette here? Must I change every pronoun, retroactively, to masculine? “Later he became Jack.” And if I also replace every instance of Jack’s deadname and swap out every gendered descriptor with a masculine counterpart, then we have “Let’s call the first boy Jack,” an absurdity. For public purposes, like the classroom, I’m careful with pronouns, as polite custom now dictates. But these are my own thoughts, which require more leeway.
Jackie’s essay showed such flair that I invited her to join my graduate workshop. She was wasted among undergrads. She would benefit from a higher level of conversation, and they would benefit too, from her intense engagement. I scheduled her essay first on the workshop calendar.
“Let’s begin,” said I, “by discussing the obvious. The narrator’s gender dysphoria.” Guess what? Jackie had never heard the words ‘gender dysphoria’ before. This was a while ago, 2012-ish. But even now, a decade later, plenty of people remain more or less unaware of the exploding trans phenomenon. I was talking to my 92-year-old mother, this month, about the gender wars in the UK, and the controversy about housing natal males in women’s prisons if they identified as women. “Oh,” said my mother, laughing at the sheer ludicrousness of the idea, “of course they’ll never do that.” No, Mom, you don’t get it: they’re doing it; it has happened already.
Right after workshop, Jackie googled ‘gender dysphoria.’ Immediately she learned, one, that YouTube was teeming with young women like her, and two, that some of them were doing something about it. She didn’t, after all, have to be a woman. Before the semester was over, she was on T, owned a variety of binders, and was planning her top surgery.
Should I have told Jackie I didn’t think it was a good idea? To me it seemed clear that she should shuck off not her breasts and her endogenous hormone balance but the religious teachings from her childhood. I didn’t say so, but she could see I wasn’t completely enthusiastic, and was a bit surprised. She had thought I would be pleased and proud. Wasn’t I her liberator, who had unlocked the first door? Her euphoria was flaming too high to be damped down by my little hesitation. A few years later, I wrote a strong letter of recommendation for Jack to enter a graduate program in gender studies at a prestigious East Coast university. In the letter, I faked the unequivocal pleasure and pride I believed the GS department would expect; I wanted to maximize Jack’s chances.
I should perhaps mention now that horror is not my only reaction to all the transitioning girls. Nor guilt either. Though am I even implicated, really? Wouldn’t Jackie have found her way to the gender-identity movement anyway, sooner or later? Yeah, maybe. But maybe not, or not until after her brain was fully myelinized. In any case, I am far from certain that my relatively passive approach was, is, the morally correct one. I am uneasy. I am full of pity and dread for these girls. And yet there is also fascination, and – why not admit? – a trickle of envy.
See, the thing is, I didn’t want to grow breasts, either, as a girl. Oh, I never had dysphoria comparable to Jackie’s, or that of certain other women I’ve known. I was only ever, shall we say, dys-curious. Or maybe dys-adjacent. My girlfriend V gave serious consideration to what we used to call a ‘sex-change operation’ back in the 1990s. I don’t think she ever went through with it, though; a little maudlin late-night googling a few years ago produced some hits under her birth name.
Like Jackie, V grew up in a conservative family. Her childhood had been shaped – stunted – by traditionalist gender roles. V when I knew her had been almost 40 and still mourning over her lost boyhood, the exuberant boyhood she knew she deserved, but which had been ‘stolen’ from her. For V, I crafted increasingly elaborate fantasy tales featuring the two of us as Victor and Gene, boy buddies. Reader, this is how I won her love.
What if the two of us had been born decades later than we were? I have no doubt that V would have transitioned. And I think it’s at least possible that I would have. The barriers are lower than ever, the visibility and positive messaging high. If I were 20-ish right now, what are the chances I’d already be remaking myself into John, or Gene? Not insubstantial, I figure. Let me be clear: in this respect, I’m glad I wasn’t born later.
One way I was different from Jackie and V is that religion was not a thing in my immediate family. Neither of my parents ever made a to-do about gender roles, either, though only an idiot could fail to notice that their contributions to the household were significantly different. Nobody influential in my early life suggested that girlhood limited my options. I was my father’s firstborn, and he took an unstinting delight in my intellectual achievements from a very early age. I reminded him of himself. For my mother, I was the fourth child of five, and accordingly less of a novelty.
There were – to put it crassly – many penises in the house where I grew up. My father slept in the nude. And my little brother and I got bathed together when we were very small. I took an interest in anatomy. Well, I was interested in a lot of things. I studied things, and that included myself. I examined my own thoughts closely enough to remember them and notice how they shifted over the years.
Long before I learned the technical terms for penis and vulva, I could clearly see that the penis was the inferior organ, being not just visually unattractive but also impractical, likely to snag on things and be always in the way when climbing and straddling things. Climbing was my other specialty, besides reading and thinking. I could climb any tree in anyone’s yard, hoist myself up by the arms, hang comfortably by hands or knees as long as I liked, and swing arm-by-arm across the playground equipment better than any other kid I knew, boy or girl. I was Tarzan!
Perhaps because of my father’s delight in me, and despite my mother’s periodic efforts to rebalance the playing field for the benefit of my younger brother, I always assumed I was someone important. In my early life only two things caused me to view girlhood as a disadvantage. One was having to cover my chest in public, when my brothers could always go bare and free; that resentment extends so far back in my life that I can’t really date it to a specific age. The other has a precise date: second grade, when I entered the Texas public school system. Reader, perhaps it will not shock you to hear that as of 1969, Texas imposed a gendered dress code.
I had been in school for three years already, at a sort of ranch/daycare/kindergarten that involved swimming and horses in addition to normal schoolwork. I was familiar with children’s ways, how they enjoyed ganging up to ridicule someone. The playground chant, “I see London, I see France, I see [somebody’s] underpants” was employed every day against at least one person. I don’t recall that only girls were the target, but of course wearing a dress made one far more vulnerable. By the age of four I was savvy enough to know dresses were a poor choice for an active and ambitious person.
And now school authorities would force me into dresses. It was a catastrophe. How would I be able to hang by my knees on the playground? My mother did go to bat for me, to an extent. The school agreed that I could wear shorts or pants, as long as I also wore a dress on top of that. I remember thinking this option over and deciding for myself not to exercise it, because it would make me freakish. The amount of comment it would excite would likely be even worse than the underwear chant. I chose what I believed was the lesser of two evils, and wore dresses for an entire school year, hating it passionately.
I did not think I’m really a boy. What I thought was that many people, even adults, were stupid and wrong about girls. Looking back from later years, I often wished I’d made the other choice. If I could do my life over again without the mistakes, I’d wear those shorts, play hard, and damn the torpedoes. A best friend of mine in junior high school caused me a considerable pang of envy: her mother told the school district that unless they wanted to buy all her daughter’s clothes, they could mind their own business. My friend’s mom made it stick! My mother simply bought a wardrobe of school dresses for me and let it go at that. Perhaps she believed I was less uncomfortable than I actually was. Or perhaps it was her brusque pragmatism. She went to work every day in a dress, didn’t she, to provide for our family?
Last year I had two trans-identified females in my undergrad classes, one he/him and one enby. The he/him’s voice was already roughening from testosterone though the face and basic body pattern still looked more feminine than not to my eye. His loose, layered shirts kept me from being sure about what he did or didn’t still have on his chest. The enby wrote about ambivalence, possible downsides of medical transition. They were so pale and thin that I wondered whether there was anorexia in addition to dysphoria. In a small-group workshop, I accidentally referred to their narrator as ‘she,’ and they huffily corrected me in their piping soprano voice. They had some writing talent, and I continued to mentor them, at their request, even after the semester ended. I recommended other reading. Cautiously, I mentioned a detransitioner whose videos they might find interesting. “She’s gender-critical now,” I said, “do you know what that is?” They did. They recoiled physically, raising fragile arms before their narrow ribcage, delicate features grimacing indignantly. “I’d never look at anything like that! You don’t understand: those people hate me.” In the face of such certainty, I am helpless. My coming out of the closet as GC myself could not possibly benefit this young person. The odds they will consider me more reliable than themself on this subject are zero. How tragic, that each new generation of activists feels that activism only truly began in their lifetime, that every generation before theirs must be mired in, blinded by, oppressive convention.
I remember the fierceness, and the agony, of being 20. I remember how childhood felt, then puberty. The years in which my fertility surged up within me and then, ever so gradually, ebbed again. Now I am considerably post-menopausal. Change is continuous. This is a thing that the young don’t understand, biologically can’t fully understand. No one ever really feels young at any age, because everyone is always the oldest age they’ve ever been. When I was seven, then eight, then nine, I was sure my body had already matured to utter perfection. I didn’t want to develop any further, gain adult breasts. Breasts were not as bad a defect as a penis, I thought, because they were better positioned. But still they would be an encumbrance, a superfluous appendage stuck onto my now-self, a beautifully streamlined silhouette. How I loved my flat, tree-climbing body!
Gabriel Mac has recently written about his phalloplasty for New York magazine. I show my mother the cover picture. She recoils. “Her leg!” Mom is choosing her pronoun based on the obviously feminine waist, I assume. I find the picture attractive, and say so. That flat front! The slight puckering scar below the right nipple is no serious blemish, and the abs, chest, and arms are all believably masculine…Even the massive crater in the right thigh does not really displease me. The bulge in the jockeys? Meh. If it were me, I’d rather be flat there too.
“Let people act however they want,” my mother says, passionate. “Let them have sex with whoever they want, give themselves a new name, wear whatever they want -” The echo of J.K. Rowling is astonishingly close, but my mother is not on social media and she knows nothing about all that. So she winds up in a different place: “But to take a knife to your flesh? It’s so wrong! Why would any doctor be willing to do that?”
“Two possibilities,” I say. “They’re shameless profiteers, or they buy into the same worldview.” Or halfway both, of course. On the one hand I completely agree with my mother. The body is the self, and is to be cherished and protected; it is not the prison from which the self is to be liberated; it is not raw clay from which we can sculpt any self we desire. Biology may not be destiny, but it’s not chopped liver, either. On the other hand, when I see a picture of a very successful double mastectomy – Elliot Page, say, standing shirtless by the pool – I sometimes have a fleeting thought, or impulse. It’s not quite I wish I looked like that. It’s not quite That’s the real me. But it’s not 100% not those things, either.
I did play with the question, at various times in my life. Would it be better for me to have been a boy? When I read books where the main character was a boy or man, I had no trouble slipping into that persona. In games with other children, I eagerly took on masculine roles. Nine-year-old Paul moved in next door when I was seven. When we played Tarzan, it was a foregone conclusion that he was going to be Tarzan; second choice fell to me as the second-oldest and second-most aggressive. The role of Jane held no appeal. What did she ever even do, except housewifery, albeit in a tree house? In a dress. So I ceded Jane to Paul’s little sister, playing Boy myself. My little brother got the role of Cheetah the monkey – better than nothing, I thought, and certainly good enough for the likes of him.
In the fourth grade my best friend was a horse-loving sixth-grade girl who wanted to play Black Stallion and Flicka. I accommodated her suggested storylines with pleasure, and invented new plot twists of my own. Since the two horses inhabited different fictional worlds, ways had to be devised for them to meet. Soon after, they fell in love, then mated in an ingenious variety of positions, and Flicka bore their children. It surprised me that my girlfriend didn’t even want to take her fair turn as the Black. I was able to figure out that her attachment to femininity must be stronger than or different from mine, but still – wasn’t it obvious that it was better to be the dynamic Black?
If this essay ever makes its way into a mainstream publication, then someone is reading these words and thinking it’s all simple, the narrator is clearly transmasculine, but also in a state of transphobic denial about it. Out of a fetish for social conformity, they have contorted their true inner self to fit a feminine mould.
It is not so simple. My early reading also included plenty of books with brave and adventurous female protagonists. Often they successfully resisted sexist stereotypes, sometimes posing as male to do so. Having seen the penises, I knew early on that there were biological differences between male and female. My mother had also talked to me a little bit about childbirth, which was, she said, “hard work, like pushing rocks uphill.” I made a mental note to get some rocks and practice in advance, to be ready when the time came. Yet there was something amiss in people’s thinking about girls that had nothing to do with vaginas and babies, and I knew that early too.
Circa age seven, I tried to explain to my father my sense that girls and women led more encumbered lives than those of boys and men. The worst of it was the dresses and the rules about covering chests. But the babies were also an issue. My father had gotten both me and my little brother for free, without pushing any rocks uphill. Penises, to be sure, were a disadvantage on the male side, but that was the only one.
My father didn’t register any of it except the baby part, and he smiled at my naïveté. Yes, he said, it was unfair that only one sex had to have the babies, and long, long ago, all the people in the world had had a conference and agreed to reverse the roles, to counteract the unfairness. That was exactly why women were now the birthing sex. His humour may have been kindly meant, or at least not meant as savage mockery. And I understood his point well enough, though he had missed mine: with only two sexes, one of them has to be the baby-making sex.
I dropped the subject then, but my father was so proud of his little just-so parable on sexual reproduction that many years later he still remembered and repeated it to me. By then I was at the height of my heterosexual phase, living with my first serious boyfriend, contemplating marriage and motherhood with real enthusiasm. Yeah, Dad, bully for you, dude, I actually still remember the first time you brought that little gem out.
The first issue of Ms. magazine was published the same month that I turned ten, and my father immediately got a subscription; thus, he was actually responsible for a lot of my early feminist education. When I was 13, I found my older sister’s copy of Our Bodies, Ourselves on one of the several overflow bookshelves out in the shed. That beautiful book came into my hands at exactly the right time to assist me through puberty.
The actual growing of my breasts as living flesh on my real body felt nothing like what I previously imagined. For one thing, breast development coincided with a hormone rush so strong that a lot of everything I had ever thought about myself was upended. Maybe I didn’t even want to be Tarzan anymore? At least…not as much as I wanted other things. Would I, actually, rather…be Jane now? Prior to the hormone surge, my romantic impulses and fantasy life were always most strongly oriented toward girls. (Recall how the Black Stallion mounted Flicka.) In some ways I’d been sexually precocious, in others not. I had done some library study as well as some practical experiments, and by age eight, I knew how to give myself orgasms. But as of junior high school I was just about the only girl in the PE showers who still had a flat chest and a hairless crotch. Alongside the physical changes, puberty opened up a whole new realm of desire in terms of both degree and kind.
From age 13, I looked at boys differently, and I was glad I could sincerely desire them. The social freakishness of lesbianism in the early 1970s daunted me in the same way that the idea of wearing shorts under a dress daunted me five years before. My new breasts were annoyingly sensitive, and the wearing of a bra was an outrage to all human ideals of freedom. But…as I contemplated my own nude self in private, I liked them, shallow cones that sat high and firm on my chest rather than bunching and settling as they did on the bustier, more popular girls. A classical, athletic look, I thought. The sort of breasts you’d see on a statue of Artemis, not Aphrodite. These breasts suited me, even though apparently everyone else in the modern world preferred Aphrodite. Boys had let me know they considered me a ‘dog.’ One mean-girl bully nicknamed me ‘Flatsie.’
For the next few years I was much drawn to the type of fantasy stories where a heterosexual couple goes adventuring together and the woman’s combat skills are equal to the man’s. Megan Lindholm’s first Ki and Vandien story appeared in the Amazons! collection in 1979. My breasts were the Amazon type, I thought. I loved my newly breasted body every bit as much as my before-self had loved her before-body. Though I registered the discrepancy, I also felt there was nothing surprising or contradictory about it. I knew better now, that was all; breasts were part of the larger epiphany of sexual desire, and just looking at them gave me pleasure, though I had no urge to touch them. I wouldn’t experience the oxytocin-releasing properties of nipples until I was in college and began to have actual lovers.
During high school, most of the people I got crushes on were male. Not quite all, though. I was sufficiently juiced to range pretty widely. For a year or two I harboured a never-declared love for my tenth-grade best friend, with her silky long hair and Aphrodite breasts.
There was a period lasting some 15 years during which I experienced definite yearnings toward pregnancy and birthing. Frequently, from about age 17, seeing a woman with an infant evoked a bodily response as physical as sexual arousal, and akin to it, though also distinctly different: my womb throbbing inside me. But I didn’t get around to pregnancy in time, and by age 40 the urge had faded away to almost nothing. Oh! The number of different phases this female body has gone through. Change is continuous.
So, I have never lactated nor breast-fed, and my breasts, in that sense, never filled their primary biological purpose. I got quite a lot of mileage out of them for sexual activity, though, over the course of several decades. I have been at both ends of a sexual breast, giving and receiving pleasure, and either way there is a milky kind of quality to it, an inner fluid release of rich sweetness, an intimacy-building that goes beyond the merely erotic. Although, to be sure, it was also erotic.
Public service announcement, for whoever needs to hear this: men’s nipples are erogenous too, oftener than not. If you are intimate with a man, you should at least give it a whirl. Put one in your mouth and take one in your hand, and that still leaves you a hand free for other business. In the repertoire of love, there is some overlap between women and men. Some.
I would not want to have gone through life never having felt these breast-related sexual/romantic sensations. Yet prior to having them, I could never have predicted how intense and desirable they would be. In childhood, I would gladly have traded away the prospect of future breasts for something else, better sports performance, say. The right to go bare chested in public.
Among the top-surgery outcomes one sees on the internet, there are some spectacular botches. These are outliers, I suppose, but then the really ideal outcomes must be outliers too. Elliot Page has resources beyond those of most trans boys and men. I wonder about average long-term top-surgery satisfaction. The gathering of accurate data must be severely compromised by the current state of the culture wars. Natal females whose transformative drive takes them as far as complete mastectomy must at that point be subject to incredible pressure both internal and external not to repudiate that decision. Because the only alternative would be to admit that their goal of transition was always only a delusion. And the trans community polices its members as rigorously for apostasy as any other faith community. So you’d be losing your entire self-image and your adoptive tribe on top of the already-sacrificed breasts.
Within the exact span of time that my breasts grew, I also outgrew my aversion to the concept of breasts. But I never stopped resenting the social and legal regulation of my female chest. And I never will. How dare you, how dare you, it is the grossest injustice that I, but not a man, violate public decency if my nipple is seen.
Look, I’m not transphobic, I’m transphilic. I had a trans sex partner before it was cool, in the 1990s. And before I soured on the idea of holding up more trans models for my young students, I sometimes assigned trans memoirs as required reading, most recently Cyrus Dunham’s beautifully written A Year Without a Name. For a time I was quite taken with the writer Danny Lavery, née Mallory Ortberg. I read Something that May Shock and Discredit You when it came out in early 2020. The structure was too odd for me to consider assigning it to a class – relatively inaccessible, I judged, although I did mention it to a couple of students I thought might be interested. And then I went back and read Ortberg’s pre-transition writings. Over that summer and into the fall I listened to a few years’ worth of the (Ortberg-)Lavery era of Dear Prudence, attending closely to pinpoint when his voice changed. Though old enough to be Lavery’s mother, I was often impressed with his insights.
Lavery described how his eventual transition began as a persistent thought: “What if I was a man, sort of?”
I got in the habit of reading Lavery’s blog and Twitter postings, and that led me to Grace Lavery’s blog and Twitter postings, and then I began to read the writings of various people Grace had denounced or feuded with. So, it was the Laverys, ultimately, who peaked me. But that’s a whole ’nother story.
Meanwhile, I was having a little persistent thought of my own: do I want to bother with breasts anymore? What puberty had wrought, menopause, to a large extent, unwrought. My sex drive had dwindled to almost nothing. Were breasts, perhaps, now superfluous after all? I wanted, like Cyrus Dunham, to drive in a convertible and feel the wind on my naked chest. How keenly did I want it? Enough to get surgery? Well, not really, but –
Now that I lived in the age of choose-your-own-gender, I was freer than ever to wear the masculine clothes I preferred, sport the minimalist hairstyle I preferred, and speak openly about a same-sex partner. But I still couldn’t go outside without my shirt on.
Full ftm transition was never on the table. With my hips I could never pass, even if I wanted to, and I didn’t care enough to want to. No social identity matters much to me anymore. Bottom surgery has always struck me as either a mistake or a fraud. Working genitalia can be provided only by nature, not human medicine. I’ve had my face close up to one neovagina: it was…not a persuasive simulation. It’s a bad, bad idea to mess with your natural plumbing.
But top surgery seemed comparatively simple and superficial. Granted, of course, a gal shouldn’t have to remove her breasts to secure the simple freedom that should be her human birthright, but the chances of changing society enough to ever claim my rights in my lifetime was approximately zero, I figured. And if I did modify my body, I would only have to do it once, whereas the benefits thereof would continue forever…
If I, at my wise old age, was thinking even to this minor extent about surgical adjustments, what must it be like for young women in their fullest hormonal flowering? For some brief amount of time, the summer of 2020 and into the fall, the idea of ditching my breasts came into my mind, lightly, sporadically. Never did the thought leave the hypothetical, never did it ripen into yearning.
Whether it would have, could have, gone further under some conditions is impossible for me to know. It was nipped in the bud all at once, and permanently, the day I saw that TikTok video. You probably know the one, where the…young person – sorry but I just can’t not see her as a girl – she seems to be autistic, or else in some other manner socially or mentally atypical. She complains about somebody having “gotten hold of” her now-amputated nipples and continuously pinching them. The horror, for me, is magnified in that it’s not clear whether her words are intended as a metaphor for the phantom nipple sensations or whether she literally believes it’s possible for detached body parts to fall into malicious teasing hands.
In any case, I’m out. If there is any chance, I don’t care how minuscule, of phantom nipple sensations, under no conditions am I willing to risk that outcome. I’ll just wear a mother-fucking shirt until I mother-fucking die, then, I guess.
Case closed, never to reopen. Me and my breasts have just celebrated our diamond anniversary, and now I know we will never be parted – well, except in the unlikely event of cancer, of which there is precisely zero incidence in any of my family. But let me just add one more brief word before dropping the subject forever:
Fuck you, anyway! Not my breasts, that is. They’re fine, they don’t bother me. No, I mean those fucking bastard cheats, that pack of bullies, and fascists, and robbers, stealing life-joy and freedom from me from way back in 1969 in Texas. You never had the right to compel my compliance, you didn’t in the second grade and you don’t now.
And okay, all right, I know, it’s no big deal, it’s not like FGM, it’s a pretty small-ish injustice in the grand scheme of things, I guess, okay, but still – isn’t it all part of the same infernal system?
I was already over 30 when I started taking fiction classes. My first story, ‘BOYS,’ was a fictionalized account of what it might have felt like to grow up like V, with boyhood seeming the only route to a life of adventure and freedom. One of my classmates objected to the narrator characterizing herself as a ‘sexual eccentric.’ There was nothing, he scoffed, eccentric about a girl wishing to be a boy. That was just normal! Certainly all of his sisters had wished to be boys. Every girl he ever knew wanted to be a boy, pretty much.
I suppose that if a guy feels it in his bones that being male is inherently better than being female, then he would naturally assume that every girl must be filled with yearning envy of his state. Cf. Freud, etc.
The boy in my workshop was only about 20, and I wasn’t going to lower myself to engage him. Maintaining silence and a bland expression, I mentally reviewed the reasons he was full of shit. I’d been more boyish than the average girl, and even I never really wanted to be a boy. But even if this nimrod – not to mention Dr Freud, and a posse of other smug, strutting men through the ages – even if he was somehow right about the average girl’s envy, he was still wrong, in fact wronger for being right. Because under those circumstances, how could you even enjoy being a man? How could you be perfectly content to live in a world where the typical girl was so repelled by the deal offered to girls that she wanted to un-girl herself?
Jean Braithwaite teaches creative writing at the University of Texas Rio Grande Valley, in the United States. She has previously published short fiction and non-fiction in a variety of outlets, as well as a literary memoir and a smattering of scholarly writing. Her curricular interests include literary appreciation and analysis, wordcraft, science writing, and narratology. Extra-curricular include biology, consciousness, and ethics.
