by Madeline Bennett
I’m 28 years old and headed for law school. It was a decision born of intensifying necessity: women’s rights in the United States are under constant threat from left- and right-wing misogyny. With leadership in powerful institutions having utterly failed to protect our interests, women and girls urgently need more radical feminist legal representation. Galvanized by a sense of gravity, I studied hard for the entrance exam, performed well, and naturally wondered, should I apply to Harvard Law School? The odds of admission are slim even for the brightest applicants. Still, I took my chances and eagerly awaited the first rounds of acceptances in January — that is until my hopeful enthusiasm was crushed by the indignation soon to follow.
On 7 February 2021, The Harvard Crimson, the university newspaper, published an article online describing the tendentious new research authored by Harvard Law professor J. Mark Ramseyer.1 I read the Crimson article once in disbelief, then again in anguish.
My dismay lay with Ramseyer’s egregious assertion that sex slaves of the Imperial Japanese Army known euphemistically as ‘comfort women’ willingly entered into contractual prostitution and wielded a large measure of power over the terms of their ‘employment.’ In his paper, he implies that, actually, those forcibly prostituted women were well compensated, that they were incentivized to “exert effort” in spite of their tendency to “shirk,” that they had regular access to healthcare, and that they could “take the money and run” at any time they felt they were being treated unfairly. Indeed, the word ‘work’ appears 69 times in the paper while ‘slavery’ and ‘oppression’ appear just twice and once respectively and are used only to deny the existence of both. Atrocity, effectively sanitized.
The Japanese military began entrapping sex slaves in the early 1930s and continued throughout World War II. It is thought that up to 200,000 women—largely Korean, Chinese, and Filipino nationals — were abducted, tricked, and forced into slavery characterized by continual rape, beatings, disease, and starvation.2 A United Nations tribunal estimated that 90% of these women had died or were killed by the end of the war.3 Many deaths were unfathomably vicious; some women were even “locked in submarines scheduled to be sunk in a deep sea.”4
Extensive documentation of these grim realities belies Ramseyer’s game-theorized reinterpretation of history, a delusion wherein the mass rape and torture of East and South-East Asia is completely stripped of its horrors. While I can stomach that dubious revisionists, who recast misogyny as empowerment, increasingly plague academia, I cannot forgive the law school for its craven silence in the face of righteous pushback from students, faculty, and historians alike. It demands asking: just how little regard does Harvard Law School have for the humanity of Asian women?
Being a descendant of survivors of Imperial Japanese occupation, I immediately withdrew my application. Below is a modified version of the letter I sent to the school’s Office of Admissions.
Dear Harvard Law School Admissions:
It is with regret that I withdraw my application. More specifically, I regret having ever applied.
This afternoon, I read a disturbing article in the Harvard Crimson detailing Mark Ramseyer’s repulsive pseudo-research insinuating that the rife, coerced, violent prostitution controlled by the Imperial Japanese Army during World War II was nothing more than anodyne economic transactions in which enterprising young women profited from the urgent and understandable sexual needs of those lowly, pitiable soldiers. If only.
The truth is that Ramseyer’s arrogant, reality-defying assertions are tantamount to Holocaust denialism. That the school has not vociferously renounced his intellectually lazy, repugnant ‘findings’ betrays the school’s unapologetic racialized misogyny. As an avowed radical feminist, sex-trade abolitionist, and self-respecting Filipino-American woman, I can plainly see that Harvard Law is not an institution where I or my ideas will be taken seriously. Nevertheless, I feel compelled to instruct you on the hellish facts of Imperial Japanese occupation.
My grandfather, now a moribund octogenarian, saw his meagre bamboo domicile, characteristic of his impoverished neighbourhood, razed to the ground by Japanese forces in Iloilo, Philippines. He was perhaps eight years old when he watched them burn what little his family owned to ashes. You can’t begin to imagine how that early exposure to brutal violence and trauma impacted him and our family across generations. As for my grandmother, her family fled to a remote part of Luzon to take shelter in the mountains. Her older sisters were the first to be sent away to hide from lecherous soldiers whose reputation as merciless rapists preceded them. Her uncle, a guerrilla fighter, was gruesomely beheaded à la ISIS by these depraved imperialists.
To this day, my grandma maintains that the Japanese soldiers were worse than the Nazis. I can’t disagree, though I would argue it is men who are the problem — men like Ramseyer, who can’t fathom a Servile Nubile Asian Girl turning down the Lucrative Job Opportunity of getting fucked for crumbs.
If I’m wrong, then tell me: why has Harvard declined to renounce Ramseyer’s obvious fabrications? Moreover, to borrow Cathy Park Hong’s phrasing, what do we Asian women have to do for you to regard us as full human beings who feel pain? It isn’t Ramseyer’s stupidity that has pushed me to withdraw, but rather that the law school chose not to refute his lies. Reflecting on the implications of Ramseyer’s paper and the university’s tacit support for him has reduced me to tears; this whole scandal has dredged up the never-ending trauma of being seen, both privately and publicly, as nothing more than the literal object of a trillion racist rape fantasies.
So what, then, is an Asian woman to you? Are we merely exotic masturbation fodder for the online masses of men? Here’s what it’s really like for us: the existence of our sentience is debatable, and our pain, if we truly feel it, is only real if it pleases a man to see us in pain. Our vaginas, mouths, assholes are, apparently, special-made for penile probing. Surely, Ramseyer speculates, those hundreds of thousands of nameless asshole-vagina-mouths did it of their own volition. Yes, we’re ‘people’ when our ‘consent’ needs giving, but men like Ramseyer always say so with a wink to the camera.
In the end, Ramseyer served a purpose to a useful end: he exposed the absolute anti-woman rot at the very roots of Harvard Law School. The school’s silence — that is, its utter failure to acknowledge the humanity of women who were raped day in and day out until their untimely, violent deaths — is absolutely deafening. It screams, “The atrocities committed against Asian women were and are just transactions, their trauma and pain are imagined, and we won’t even deign to pretend to believe otherwise.”
Your message was sent loud and clear: I can only ever aspire to kiss ass as your functionary — a workhorse that can be ridiculed openly and humiliated sexually to my face and behind my back. And yet, Harvard University’s prestige, academic excellence, and relevance are thanks in large part to the collective brilliance of Asian women; you’re second-rate without us, and you know it.
So, I’m no longer interested. Offer your overpriced eminence to some mediocre white guy whose parents are friendly with the faculty.
Signed,
Another asshole-vagina-mouth
Madeline Bennett is a feminist from the Southern United States and advocates for women and girls in Washington, DC
1 Ariel H. Kim and Simon J. Levien, ‘Harvard Professor’s Paper Claiming “Comfort Women” in Imperial Japan Were Voluntarily Employed Stokes International Controversy,’ 7 February 2021, The Crimson,; J. Mark Ramseyer, ‘Contracting for Sex in the Pacific War,’ International Review of Law and Economics, 65 (2021).
2 Asian Women’s Fund, ‘The “comfort women” issue and the Asian Women’s Fund,’ 2003.
3 War and Public Health, ed. by Barry S. Levy and Victor W. Sidel (Washington, DC: American Public Health Association, 2000), p. 190.
4 War and Public Health, p. 190.
