by Dani Ahrens
Alison Phipps, Me, Not You: The Trouble With Mainstream Feminism (Manchester: Manchester University Press, 2020), 205pp., £12.99.
This book’s declared aim is to raise “difficult and painful questions” for mainstream feminism in a world in which “‘White power’ in the form of ideological fascism, border regimes and hoarding of resources, is being reasserted in response to economic and ecological crisis” (p. 11). As a white, middle-class, left-wing feminist, with a political commitment to acting in solidarity with black and working-class people, I am the book’s target audience. However, I found it unimpressive, unfocused, unconvincing and unhelpful, other than as a case study in understanding the extent of the left’s weakness as we face up to the overwhelming crises of these times.
What is “mainstream”?
Throughout the book, Phipps defines her terms without reference to previously established theoretical traditions within feminism. This makes it difficult at times to identify who and what she is talking about. “Mainstream feminism,” for example, is defined on page 5 as:
mostly Anglo-American public feminism. This includes media feminism (and some forms of social media feminism) or what media scholar Sarah Banet-Weiser has called “popular feminism”: the feminist ideas and politics that circulate on mainstream platforms. It also includes institutional feminism, corporate feminism and policy feminism: the feminism that tends to dominate in universities, government bodies, private companies and international NGOs.
Already, I have questions. Surely feminism can’t be meaningfully categorized according to whether it appears in the media (or social media!)? Isn’t feminism in universities very different from anything that might be called feminism in government bodies, and different again from the policies adopted by private companies? Come to that, what does “Anglo-American” mean? The political landscapes of the UK and the USA are very different, yet Phipps never distinguishes between them, frequently juxtaposing examples from the two contexts without any qualification.
Somewhat puzzled, I read on, to find a further definition: “In other texts, it has been called ‘neoliberal feminism,’ ‘lean-in’ feminism and ‘feminism for the 1%.’ This is because it wants power within the existing system, rather than an end to the status quo.” This is slightly easier to grasp — she seems to be talking about what I would describe as liberal feminism. But I am thrown again by the next sentence, which declares that mainstream feminism is “exemplified by campaigns such as #MeToo.”
As Phipps notes, the #MeToo hashtag appeared in an estimated 19 million tweets in the year after it went viral in 2017 (p. 35). This “mass disclosure” was – inevitably – extremely varied and without centralized direction. Phipps criticises several aspects of a media narrative that has developed around the movement, but never critically assesses the process by which this narrative has been created. Indeed, this book is arguably a contribution to that process, responding to the media narrative at face value, rather than interrogating and investigating the power relationships that produce it. Phipps does not clearly distinguish between the intentions and motivations of the mass of women who participated in the social media wave and ensuing protests, and the way these actions were interpreted and incorporated by powerful institutions such as media organizations and the criminal justice system. Using this incredibly diverse and diffuse phenomenon as part of the definition of “mainstream” renders that definition practically useless.
#MeToo
The first half of the book takes us through her criticism of the #MeToo movement on the basis of its “political whiteness.” Phipps introduces two more novel categories of feminism (“carceral feminism” and “colonial feminism”), and makes some important points about the self-defeating nature of performative outrage as a political method.
As an example of “political whiteness,” Phipps criticizes an implicit expectation among participants in the #MeToo movement that the public voicing of their trauma will be recognized as naming injustice. She writes:
In 1971 philosopher and essayist Susan Griffin wrote: “I have never been free of the fear of rape.” Forty-seven years later, novelist Barbara Kingsolver wrote: “If the #MeToo revolution has proved anything, it’s that women live under threat. Not sometimes, but all the time.” This imperilled femininity is white. It depends on tropes of racist domination, even while it articulates the gendered harm of sexual violence … In contrast, Jamilah Lemiux argues, Black women “know that [they] need to tuck that shit in and keep moving.” (p. 74)
At the start of the #MeToo process, I had some sympathy with this point — the idea that simply voicing (again) the fact that women routinely experience sexual violence would surprise anyone, let alone result in change, struck me as naïve. Absolutely, black and working-class women were right to point out that without a meaningful challenge to the structures of power, your outcry does nothing but expose your vulnerability. The fact is that sexual violence is baked in to the system and appealing to the authorities for justice only reinforces their power.
For this reason, I initially considered #MeToo to be a disheartening illustration of the lack of progress made by the women’s movement during my lifetime. Speaking out about rape and sexual violence is an essential first step in feminist consciousness-raising, but our mothers knew that fifty years ago. We don’t need an awareness-raising campaign, we need a political movement for justice.
Nevertheless, as the movement gathered momentum, I understood that each woman adding her voice to a chorus, and then a roar, was doing so in order to stand alongside all the others, collectively making a statement that was neither a plea for help nor a redundant reminder of our victimization, but an assertion of our humanity. It was the mass nature of #MeToo that made it significant, and which gave it the potential to become a bridge across the very real differences between women that Phipps identifies.
The missing element, needed to make those millions of initial brave statements of solidarity into a force for change, was a feminist analysis. More concretely, feminist organization – a way for women to meet each other, talk about how institutions continue to fail us, examine why removing “bad men” doesn’t solve the problem, and create shared demands on the basis of mutual respect and recognition of each other as equals.
However, Phipps’s analysis of #MeToo is devoid of political agents and lacks focus. Her contention is that “acts, threats and allegations of sexual violence are all tools of oppression” (p. 10, emphasis in original). This paragraph sums up the core of the argument:
The impulse to punish in response to outrage produced a key tension in #MeToo between the desire to expose the “everydayness” of sexual violence, and the outcome which was the “bringing down” of a number of individual men. While we get our rage out, we want its subject out – out of our institutions, out of our communities, out of society for good. We want Harvey Weinstein in prison. We want Brock Turner to have a longer sentence. We want Judge Aquilina to sign Nassar’s death warrant. We rely on a third party to take these “bad men” away, usually in the form of an institution or the state. And this White Knight or Angry Dad is patriarchy personified. This is how our outraged activism fails to dismantle the intersecting systems of heteropatriarchy and racial capitalism that produce sexual violence – and strengthens them instead. (pp. 95-96)
While I agree that the “eye for an eye” sentiment expressed by Judge Aquilina in her sentencing of serial abuser Larry Nassar was an expression of her power in a deeply patriarchal and racist justice system, I think Phipps’s summary of this episode missed the most important aspect of the court case – the judge’s decision to permit dozens of Nassar’s victims to speak in open court about the impact of his actions on their lives. This was – like the #MeToo movement overall – ultimately a collective act, in which those women and girls were supported by each other in their refusal to be dehumanized by his abuse.
And while I agree that the notion of white women’s vulnerability to sexual attack by “outsiders” has been used to prop up white supremacist and patriarchal power, I don’t think it is true that articulating the universal female experience of sexual violence is an inherently racist project.
White supremacist ideas about the predatory nature of black men and the construction of rape as a cultural incursion are thoroughly integrated into the patriarchal power structure which sees women as objects, property or territory, rather than full human beings. It is this core patriarchal idea which places white women in a position of apparent power over black men, but leaves them without agency and subordinate to white men. Phipps’s analysis does little to challenge this issue at its root. Women discussing and analysing sexual violence on our own terms has the potential to break apart this poisonous nexus between racism and male power.
Phipps’s failure to clearly identify the different actors involved in #MeToo leaves her interpretation of events lacking in explanatory force. Who is “we” in her argument? Who exactly is wielding the tools of oppression? How did the mass outpouring of women’s rage and pain through the #MeToo hashtag become channelled towards punitive responses towards individual powerful men?
I would answer that this resulted from the weakness of real-world feminist organization, leaving the field open for capitalist media and state institutions to take control of the narrative. Phipps points instead to the narcissistic need for control of a disembodied feminist mainstream, but this explanation obscures our ability to understand the real power relationships at play here.
TERFs and SWERFs
Halfway through Chapter 4, the focus of the book shifts towards “white feminism” and yet another new category, “reactionary feminism,” defined in passing as “trans-exclusionary and anti-sex-work” (p. 133). This whole second half of the book drifts away from the stated aim of examining mainstream feminism (however loosely defined) and shifts into what can only be described as sectarian point-scoring.
Phipps’s method, throughout the book, is to juxtapose ideas and events, sometimes from widely different political traditions or national contexts, and declare them to be “linked.” This habit is at its most disingenuously intense in Chapter 6, where the “reactionary feminist” movement is described as “tightly networked and highly organised” despite its small numbers, with tactics “similar to the notorious harassment campaign Gamergate.” Her (unreferenced) examples of “harassment” by “reactionary feminists” include women resigning from the Labour Party in protest at women-only shortlists being opened up to male people who identify as women, an open letter to Stonewall, signed by over 10,000 people, and a social media campaign using the #GettheLOut hashtag, following a protest by a small number of lesbians at London Pride in July 2018.
In reality, none of these episodes matched her characterization of the events, therefore I can only conclude that her failure to provide supporting evidence was a deliberate decision. This was a pattern I noticed on 15 other occasions, where Phipps’s unreferenced description of an event or action gives it a certain spin, but upon further investigation the actual facts are open to a quite different interpretation or, in the worst instances, are entirely at odds with the account presented in the book.
To give just one further example, Phipps claims on page 136 that “trans-exclusionary feminist Janice Raymond – author of the notorious The Transsexual Empire – had written a paper for the Reagan administration which guided its 1981 decision to deny Medicare for sex reassignment surgery.” This is given as an example of “synergy” between feminists and the religious right. No evidence is given for this allegation, which is unsurprising as it is not true. Janice Raymond, in response to repeated and widespread rumours of this kind, has a whole section of her website dedicated to fictions and facts about her 1979 book and subsequent work on transgender issues. As well as publishing the full text of her book, Raymond directly refutes the false suggestion that she guided the Reagan administration and addresses another persistent untruth, also repeated by Phipps, that “Trans women are defined as rapists and child abusers who, in Janice Raymond’s words, should be ‘morally mandated’ out of existence” (p. 152).
As Raymond points out, deliberately misquoting another author’s work is, to say the least, “intellectually irresponsible.” It is really quite shocking that Phipps and her editors included these easily falsifiable rumours in a supposedly serious text.
Similarly to her willingness to accept the mainstream media’s presentation of #MeToo, and her failure to unpick the patriarchal and racist framework surrounding rape, Phipps seems keen to go along with attempts by the US religious right to co-opt the arguments of feminists in order to promote their own conservative agenda. Extrapolating from the existence of Hands Across the Aisle, which claims to be a coalition between feminist and conservative women against gender-identity legislation in the United States, Phipps presents a sequence of sleight-of-hand arguments in an attempt to associate left-wing British feminists with the decision of American “radical feminist” organization WoLF to make a formal alliance with right-wing forces such as the Alliance for Defending Freedom.
In fact, British organizations Woman’s Place UK and Fair Play for Women have (correctly, in my view) explicitly spoken against alliances with the religious right, and have distanced themselves from racist, homophobic and transphobic elements within the broad “gender-critical” milieu. After paying lip service to these clear distinctions between the actions of WoLF and the largely left-wing gender-critical feminist movement that has been building in Britain and around the world, Phipps blithely continues with her character assassination, pointing out imagined “similarities” and “echoes,” based on a (presumably wilful) misinterpretation and downright misrepresentation of gender-critical feminist ideas about biological sex, gender essentialism, safeguarding and the silencing of women’s voices.
Examining all of these misrepresentations would take a whole book in itself. To look at just two examples, Phipps writes that “Trans-exclusionary feminists and conservatives are both deeply attached to the binary of ‘biological sex,’ despite mounting scientific evidence that sex is more complex than previously thought” (p. 141). A few sentences later, she claims that “Conservatives and trans-exclusionary feminists also share with anti-sex-work feminists the idea that the male body is inherently violent.”
For Phipps, “the idea that there are two immutable, biological sexes and that you cannot change from one to the other” is a discredited right-wing notion, comparable to the idea that variations in intelligence are attributable to race or that disabled people should be sterilized. No supporting evidence is given for this extraordinary claim, other than an opinion piece from the journal Nature, a discussion of research into rare differences of sexual development which is largely factual, but irrelevant to its concluding suggestion that subjective gender identity should be taken as a determinant of biological sex. The author of the piece has publicly stated (@ClaireAinsworth, Twitter, 21 July 2017) that her article is not an argument for the existence of more than two sexes.
For the second claim, that gender-critical feminists (or, for that matter, conservatives) believe male people are inherently violent, Phipps presents no evidence at all.
Just to be crystal clear, gender-critical feminists and conservatives do generally take it as given that there are two biological sexes, and that humans cannot change sex. However, almost everybody in the world takes this fact as given, so this is not really an indication that gender-critical feminists are in league with the forces of conservatism.
The claim that gender-critical feminists believe that males are inherently violent is a bizarre misrepresentation of what Phipps must know is a complex area of feminist thought. Looking purely at the facts, it is clear that almost all violence is committed by male people, and at the same time, most male people do not routinely act violently. Attempting to understand why male people are – under current circumstances – much more likely to be violent than female people is at the heart of the feminist project. So is dealing with the consequences of that fact for women and children subjected to male violence. Neither endeavour is helped, in my opinion, by attempting to blur the categories of male and female.
The weakness of Phipps’s argument here is, I think, a consequence of her lack of clarity about her own standpoint. Is she representing the consensus of acceptable opinion, or railing against it?
Is Alison Phipps mainstream?
Phipps – a professor of gender studies at Sussex University – often identifies herself as part of the “mainstream” she is criticizing. In one particularly striking example, she writes:
white subjectivities are shaped by the structural position of white supremacy, and … whiteness and class privilege are fractured, but not erased, by gender and other social relations. In other words, being a victim of gender violence does not absolve me of being a perpetrator of white supremacy and capitalist exploitation. (p. 60, emphasis mine)
And yet, she consistently presents ideas and arguments that most people would consider extreme as if they are incontestable and require no supporting evidence (thus uncritically leveraging her mainstream status). She then attacks women grounding their arguments in reality as dangerous extremists.
Some of the ideas that Phipps espouses here are in one sense indisputably mainstream. Versions of them are incorporated in workplace training courses in hundreds of public institutions and private companies, they are taught on gender studies courses in universities, they guide the policies of international NGOs, healthcare providers and political parties.
At the same time, however, they are shocking and unfamiliar to most people. As a recent YouGov poll showed, for example, the majority of people in the UK do not support a change in the law to make it easier to change one’s legal sex. Support for trans women being permitted to use women’s changing rooms drops from 42% in favour to only 26% in favour when the question makes it clear that the hypothetical trans woman has not had gender-reassignment surgery. It seems that fluid biological sex isn’t such a mainstream idea after all.
This situation – where the leaders of institutions, parties or organizations hold views that are more extreme than those of the grassroots members, voters or supporters – is an uncomfortable one for everyone concerned. When coupled with a refusal to debate any idea relating to personal identities, there seems no possibility of creating a true consensus or developing a movement with mass support.
Phipps and her co-thinkers in academic institutions want to have the cake of mainstream status and power and eat it too, by presenting themselves as edgy outsiders. This self-perception is threatened by the emergence of a real grassroots feminist movement, where all ideas are up for questioning.
Through the looking glass
Every few pages, while reading this book, I was struck by how closely Phipps’s criticisms match those made by gender-critical feminists negotiating a political space in which trans ideology has become mainstream. Indeed, the whole book could almost have been written as its own mirror image, in which the denial of biological sex and advocacy of prostitution are the extreme endpoint of a mainstream liberal feminism that has been led into unholy alliances by its unthinking acceptance of individualized explanations and “choice” narratives.
The specific characteristics of “political whiteness,” which Phipps ascribes to mainstream, carceral, colonial and reactionary feminism are summed up as “narcissism, alertness to threat…and an accompanying need for control” (p. 59). Phipps rightly criticizes the political method of investing trauma into the online “outrage economy,” with its unhealthy consequences of denying the trauma of one’s political opponents.
Standing on the other side of the culture wars fence, I have seen these qualities and this method exhibited numerous times by supporters of the ideas Phipps espouses. Use of the “outrage economy” method of argument is pretty much ubiquitous in online spaces, and it is particularly disingenuous of Phipps to suggest, as she does on page 107, that a shared usage of this technique is evidence of a connection between gender-critical feminists and the right, when by that logic every commentator who leverages elevated suicide rates among trans-identified young people would also be “linked” to the right.
In a familiar evidence-free flourish, Phipps declares that “This politics does not focus on safer workplaces for all and better-funded women’s services. It is not centred on opposing the austerity budgets that have pushed many women into selling sex” (p. 107). It’s not clear to me who she is referring to here, but I would advise her to take a look at the Woman’s Place UK manifesto and the excellent resources produced by the Women’s Budget Group to see a feminist politics that does precisely this.
Identity politics or class politics?
Phipps is right that “outrage economy” discourse ultimately backfires when:
Sexual harassers and abusers are named and shamed and then airbrushed out of organisations and institutions while the structural problems that enabled the harassment and abuse remain. Indeed, the language of outrage – of predators who need to be punished – tends to distract from these structures and the generalised toxicity they produce. (p. 94)
Yet there is very little structural analysis in this book. Phipps sets up a dichotomy between “identity politics” on one side and its right-wing critics on the other. She does not acknowledge the rich history of left-wing and feminist thought about the dialectical relationship between individual identity and an understanding of structural power relationships between classes of people, and the complexity of fostering solidarity within and between oppressed classes across the differences resulting from intersecting oppressions.
Economic class is hardly mentioned in this book, except as an aspect of individual identity or as an adjunct to race-based descriptions (e.g. “bourgeois white women”). Even in instances where class is directly relevant, such as in a brief mention of “Save Our Eyes” – a local residents’ campaign against the managed approach to prostitution in the Holbeck area of Leeds – it is not considered at all.
The Holbeck situation strikes me as an interesting example of the complex interaction of gender, class and race/nationality issues that need to be confronted in any serious attempt to create meaningful solidarity among oppressed people. Holbeck is a working-class neighbourhood, chosen as the site of a “managed zone” within which prostitutes are permitted to work between certain times without fear of arrest. This experimental approach has become the subject of a highly polarized and politicized debate, in which facts and motivations are contested on all sides. The women and girls who live in the area are not the middle class white feminists to whom Phipps’s book is addressed, yet they are the ones whose lives are now routinely punctuated by approaches from kerb crawlers, attracted to their neighbourhood by a project intended to make prostitution safer. They ask why this has been deemed acceptable in the streets where they are raising their children, and not those where the “progressive” councillors who voted to approve the scheme live.
I don’t have any simple answer as to how to advance the political interests of both the local residents and the women working in prostitution. I think Phipps is correct to highlight the drawbacks of relying on a racist and punitive state to deal with a situation where women working in the sex trade are often vulnerable to immigration enforcement and violent mistreatment by the justice system. What I do know is that turning up in working-class communities with a ready-made utopian programme for revolutionary change is a surefire way to get people’s backs up. It seems to me that women’s shared experience of sexual harassment and violence is a firmer foundation for the slow, patient movement-building that is required. Only such a process of dialogue can generate the solutions that are needed.
In the concluding pages of the book, the (privileged white feminist) reader is left with a series of questions pertaining to her own, individual actions. I don’t think it’s a bad thing in itself for people to ask themselves questions like “Am I educated enough to be making an intervention on this issue? If not, how can I educate myself?,” “How much space do I occupy with my own experiences, needs and views?” or “Can I step back and let more marginalised people lead?” I have (of course) considered many of these issues in my own activism.
Alison Phipps is right to draw connections between sexual violence, a resurgent far right, extractive capitalism, and our rapidly destabilizing climate. But her rejection of a materialist class analysis means that this book’s final prescription is little more than a call for activism as ethical consumerism. Ultimately, it locates the power to effect change in the hands of the individual white woman, through her own efforts to act more virtuously.
I think we need to consider questions like “How can we develop our ideas in collaboration with each other?,” “How can we create spaces in which women with different experiences can really listen to each other?” and “What do our different experiences of race, class, disability and sexuality teach us about how patriarchy functions?”
Phipps’s decision to end the book with this focus on individual action, and her simplistic assumption that it’s obvious in any situation who should be considered “more marginalised,” are emblematic of the book’s failure to tackle the difficult questions it purports to raise.
