by Joan Smith
The congregation assembles, hushed and expectant. The priest arrives, resplendent in her robes and bearing a leather-bound book. She ascends the pulpit, opens the volume at a well-thumbed page and spreads it before her. She lifts her head, checking that everyone is paying attention. Then she begins the familiar liturgy:
“Transwomen are women.”
“Transmen are men,” the worshippers chant in return.
“Non-binary people are non-binary,” the priest declares.
“All gender identities are valid,” they respond with enthusiasm.
The priest closes The Book of Trans and looks on benignly as the worshippers exchange hugs, bathing in the warm glow of inclusivity. But there is another side to religious fervour, especially when the religion is a recent invention and puffed up with its own importance. Heresy cannot be tolerated, critics are targeted with violent rhetoric and woman-hating is an essential part of the package. “TERFs” — trans-exclusionary radical feminists — may have replaced witches, but the loathing of women is all too familiar.
I’m not talking here about people who have gender dysphoria and use a variety of stratagems, most of them private, to deal with it. It’s perfectly possible to sympathise with the distress they feel, and believe it’s right that they’re protected from discrimination and violence, while holding very different views about whether human beings can change sex. Many feminists (and some trans people) believe that third spaces for things like changing rooms, shelters, and hospitals would allow transwomen safety and privacy without coming into conflict with the rights of natal women. But trans activists reject this compromise, demanding public validation of an identity that often seems to involve a kind of performative misogyny. They’ve turned “transwomen are women” — though not so much “transmen are men” — into an unswervable test for anyone who wishes to avoid accusations of “transphobia.” It’s telling in this context that trans ideology focuses so obsessively on the rights of transwomen, making nothing like as much fuss about the rights of transmen to use male changing rooms or be housed in men’s prisons. But if you’re on the Left in British politics, you’re no longer allowed to say you believe sex is dimorphic, with one organization after another introducing penalties for anyone (especially any woman) who refuses to deny biology.
Institutional capture, where a whole series of bodies adopts a controversial ideology with little discussion or thought for the consequences, is visible across the board in the UK.
The Greens are a small political party, with only one MP, but their youth wing has been widely mocked for abandoning the word “women” in favour of “non-men.” Women who want to be selected as parliamentary candidates for Labour, which remains the largest opposition party in England and Wales, can expect to face an interrogation about why they follow the social media accounts of some feminist organizations. During Labour’s leadership contest in 2020, no less than five female MPs signed a series of pledges drawn up by the unofficial and obscure Labour for Trans Rights calling for the expulsion from the party of “those who express bigoted, transphobic views.”1 No definition of these terms was offered, potentially opening the door to a witch-hunt, but Rebecca Long Bailey, Lisa Nandy, Dr Rosena Allin-Khan, Dawn Butler and Angela Rayner were all happy to sign. The eventual winner of the leadership contest, Sir Keir Starmer, held back but he did add his name to another list of pledges, asserting among other things that “trans women are women.”
In Scotland, where the Scottish National Party is in power, the government has published statutory guidance allowing male-bodied transwomen to take women’s places on public boards. The then leader of another opposition party, the Lib Dems’ Jo Swinson, lost her seat in Parliament at the 2019 general election after proving reluctant to say whether or not she believes that biological sex exists. But her colleague Layla Moran MP learned nothing from this humiliation, and struggled to give a straightforward answer to the question “what is a woman?” during her unsuccessful bid to replace Swinson. Moran had previously expanded on her views during a debate in Westminster Hall in 2018, giving this reply to a question about whether she would be happy to share a changing room with someone who had a male body:
I believe that women are women, so if that person was a transwoman, I absolutely would. I just do not see the issue. As for whether they have a beard, which was one of the Hon. Gentleman’s earlier comments, I dare say that some women have beards … I see someone in their soul and as a person. I do not really care whether they have a male body.
Moran may not care about sharing intimate space with male bodies, but thousands of women do. There are powerful arguments in favour of women-only spaces: From the earliest age, girls become used to unwanted attention from males, and avoiding isolated places where they might be vulnerable to assault becomes second nature.
Moreover, sex crimes are not rare in this country, with an estimated 510,000 women experiencing sexual assault in England and Wales in the year ending March 2017, according to the government’s own figures. (The same source suggests that one in five women will experience some type of sexual assault in her lifetime.)2
Most men accept that this is the case, putting the safety of women and girls before any hurt feelings they might have about being excluded from women’s hospital wards or ladies’ toilets, but transactivists in the UK have set about demolishing even this fragile solidarity between the sexes. Some activists have demanded the abolition of the women-only spaces currently permitted under the UK’s equality legislation, arguing that excluding male-bodied transwomen is “cruel.” They also want to extend what’s known as self-ID, effectively deregulating the process of getting a new birth certificate that hides the holder’s original sex, even though we know that the vast majority of transwomen haven’t had surgery.3
The idea that such a change could be made without some form of external regulation is alarming, as well as being open to abuse: if male-bodied transwomen were granted an absolute right to access women’s facilities, how could we refuse access to anyone with a penis? It looked for a while as though extensive lobbying by transactivists had worked but in September 2020 a government minister, Liz Truss, announced that most of the requirements for getting a new birth certificate in England and Wales are to remain unchanged. (In Scotland, the Scottish National Party [SNP] has drafted a bill that removes the need for a medical diagnosis and reduces the period people have to live in the acquired gender from two years to six months.) The same announcement upheld the right of service providers to restrict access to single-sex spaces on the basis of biological sex, prompting widespread relief. Put simply, we have no way of distinguishing between Moran’s “women with beards” and a voyeur who wants to take clandestine photos of women and girls undressing.
Trans ideology insists that biological men should be treated as if they were women, something that would wipe out our existence as a separate sex class: you can’t admit someone to a category that by definition excludes them without destroying that category in the process. It inevitably becomes mixed, like the “women’s” hospital wards which admit men who claim to be women or the ladies’ toilets that blithely advertise themselves as “women and all genders.” At a moment when we are living through an epidemic of sexual and domestic violence, the idea that women should surrender the few protections we have is truly shocking — and the attempt to present it as “hate speech” is inexcusable.
Like “transphobia,” the phrase “hate speech” is employed as a deliberate tactic to smear opponents. When I say I don’t believe transwomen are women, it doesn’t mean I hate them; I don’t believe in God either, but it doesn’t mean I hate Christians. Disagreement isn’t hate, and it’s equally disingenuous to suggest that the debate is “toxic on both sides.” There has barely been a debate, because transactivists often refuse to discuss any of the issues with feminists. When I was invited to appear on BBC Radio 4’s Woman’s Hour programme to discuss my opposition to changing the law to make self-ID easier, no one would appear with me — even in the middle of the COVID-19 lockdown when we wouldn’t have been in the same studio.
Where there isgenuine hate speech around this issue, it’s in the other direction. Today’s activists may not be familiar with the Malleus Maleficarum, the 15th century witchfinders’ manual I wrote about in my book Misogynies, but it displays the same visceral dislike of women. Any critique of trans ideology supposedly puts the lives of transwomen at risk, even though there’s not a shred of evidence that anyone has ever attacked a transperson after reading an article by a feminist. But we are in the midst of a contemporary witch-hunt that has seen women sacked from their jobs (in a think tank, in literary publishing), banned from social media sites, and ostracised by erstwhile friends and colleagues.4 Writers have been subjected to baseless accusations that their work has caused trans teenagers to kill themselves, yet most prominent people who would leap to the defence of any other unfairly targeted group fail to condemn the abuse — even when the target is one of the UK’s most admired and successful authors, J. K. Rowling.5
Heresy hunters have always gone after books, many of which were burned during the religious conflicts of the 16th and 17th centuries, but the peevish reaction to Rowling’s comments about women’s rights and her own experience of sexual and domestic abuse has been shocking to witness. Two of the main Harry Potter fan sites sniffly announced they would no longer include links to her website or use photos of the author, while some staff at the publisher Hachette objected to being asked to work on her children’s book, The Ickabog, because of her supposedly “transphobic” views.6 (They got short-shrift from Hachette, which issued a robust statement supporting freedom of speech.) Even worse was an article written in June 2020 by a Labour MP and shadow minister, Lloyd Russell-Moyle, which accused Rowling of using her own painful history as a “justification” for discriminating against transwomen. If ever there was a moment for a leading politician to intervene in defence of a maligned public figure, this was it — yet the Labour leader, Keir Starmer, said absolutely nothing. During the furore that followed, Russell-Moyle apologized but he was allowed to remain in the shadow cabinet, resigning the following month and portraying himself as the victim of the episode.7
In August 2020, Rowling decided to return an award to the Robert F. Kennedy Human Rights organization, which had, somewhat bizarrely, denounced her “transphobia” only a year after celebrating her achievements. A self-described transactivist, Serena Daziari, weighed in on social media: “J. K. Rowling is a bitter hag riding the coattails of her one success, a book she wrote a million years ago, who is now trying to reinvigorate her fame and make a splash by attacking trans people. It’s time for her to retire to her mansion & put down the pen.” The language positively drips with envy and the kind of misogyny often directed at older women (Rowling is in her fifties). Another tweet, from @onlyanna, who claimed to work for a community organization in Houston, Texas, expressed the hope that “J. K. Rowling gets punched in the face today” — and fantasized about blood gushing over the author’s clothes. The following month, when Rowling published a new novel under her crime-writing pseudonym Robert Galbraith, she was wrongly accused of writing a book “about a transvestite serial killer” to upset transpeople. The book isn’t about this character, a minor figure who uses a variety of disguises and stratagems to fool his victims, but soon the menacing hashtag #RIPJKRowling was trending on Twitter.
The social media site is notoriously reluctant to remove even violent threats against prominent women, but it’s not as if such bile is confined to the virtual world. In 2017, a transactivist expressed the wish to “fuck up some terfs” in a message on Facebook before heading for Hyde Park in central London, where some gender-critical women were holding a rally; Tara Wolf attacked a feminist called Maria MacLachlan, smashing her camera, and was subsequently convicted of assault and fined £150.8 Both the Guardian columnist Suzanne Moore and the feminist campaigner Julie Bindel have been harassed by transactivists for more than decade, and one of them tried to assault Bindel as she left a meeting in Edinburgh last year.9 Events organized by women’s organizations to defend single-sex spaces and women’s participation in sport have been targeted by extremists who obstruct entrances, bang on windows and try to drown out the speakers.10 Some go even further in their attempts to intimidate feminists: I was at a meeting of Labour women in West London in March 2020 when smoke began drifting into the room, making us think for a moment that the building was on fire. It turned out that the transactivists who had kept up a barrage of noise for more than two hours were letting off smoke bombs outside, within sight of the ruins of Grenfell Tower.11 It takes a brazen species of narcissism to do this close to the worst civilian conflagration in the UK since the Second World War, but today’s witch-hunters are too self-obsessed to care.
We’re not even allowed to talk about our own bodies any more. When the American Cancer Society advised “individuals with a cervix” to get a smear test, Labour MP Rosie Duffield pointed out on Twitter that “only women have a cervix.” An organization called LGBT+ Labour sprang into action, deeming Duffield’s reference to the female body so offensive that it demanded not just an apology but “reparations,” a word usually associated with payments made by the defeated side at the end of a war.12 When the MP did not immediately give in to this attempt to bully her, the organization huffed about being “deeply disappointed” and called on the Labour party to take action. Finding herself apparently being stalked by the ghost of Stalin, Duffield apologized and provided the public display of self-criticism required of anyone convicted of wrong-think. It’s striking that her offence wasn’t saying something that was untrue or harmful to transpeople; it was her failure to adhere to current doctrine. Heresy, in other words.
1 Jessica Parker, “Labour Leadership: Long-Bailey Backs Call to Expel ‘Transphobic’ Members,” BBC online, 12 February 2020, <bbc.com/news/uk-politics-51465800>.
2 Office for National Statistics, “Sexual offences in England and Wales: year ending March 2017,” Office for National Statistics online, 8 February 2018, <ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/crimeandjustice/articles/sexualoffencesinenglandandwales/yearendingmarch2017>.
3 James Kirkup, “How Women Won the War Against Gender ‘Self-ID,’” The Spectator, 22 September 2020, <spectator.co.uk/article/how-women-won-the-war-against-gender-self-id>. For additional context, see also Catherine Fairbairn, Douglas Pyper, and Sarah Pepin, “Proposals to Allow Self-Identification of Gender,” House of Commons Library online, 16 November 2018, <commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/cdp-2018-0254>.
4 Owen Bowcot, “Judge Rulse Against Researcher Who Lost Job Over Transgender Tweets,” The Guardian online, 18 December 2019, <theguardian.com/society/2019/dec/18/judge-rules-against-charity-worker-who-lost-job-over-transgender-tweet>. See also Jo Bartosch, “Sasha White and the Woke War on Feminists,” Spiked! online, 27 August 2020 <spiked-online.com/2020/08/27/sasha-white-and-the-woke-war-on-feminists>
.5 J. K. Rowling, “J.K. Rowling Writes about Her Reasons for Speaking out on Sex and Gender Issues,” 10 June 2020, J. K. Rowling.com, <www.jkrowling.com/opinions/j-k-rowling-writes-about-her-reasons-for-speaking-out-on-sex-and-gender-issues>.
6 Katherine Cowdrey, “Hachette Moves to Back Rowling After Staff Raise Concerns,” 16 June 2020, The Bookseller, <www.thebookseller.com/news/hachette-moves-to-back-Rowling-after-staff-concerns-1206777>.
7 Andrew Woodcock, “Lloyd Russell-Moyle: Labour MP Apologises After Accusing J. K. Rowling of Using Her History of Abuse in Transgender Row,” The Independent online, Sunday 28 June 2020
<independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/lloyd-russell-moyle-jk-rowling-apology-transgender-sexual-abuse-a9589616.html>
8 Jen Izaakson, “Trans-Identified Male, Tara Wolf, Convicted of Assault After Hyde Park Attack,” Feminist Current, 27 April 2018, <feministcurrent.com/2018/04/27/trans-identified-male-tara-wolf-charged-assault-hyde-park-attack>.
9 Gina Davidson, “Feminist Speaker Julie Bindel ‘Attacked by Transgender Person’ at Edinburgh University After Talk,” The Scotsman online, 6 June 2019, <.scotsman.com/news/scottish-news/feminist-speaker-julie-bindel-attacked-transgender-person-edinburgh-university-after-talk-545841>.
10 “Women’s Meeting Besieged by Raging Crowd,” Morning Star: For Peace and Socialism,
<morningstaronline.co.uk/article/f/wpuk-fringe-report>.
11 “Grenfell Tower: What Happened,” BBC online, 29 October 2019, <bbc.com/news/uk-40301289>.
12 Editors’ Note: In the US, “reparations” are more frequently referenced in proposals to redress the continued disempowerment of Black people and communities in the wake of slavery and segregation through combinations of institutional reform, loan forgiveness, and direct payments.
