Issue Three

Giving Birth in a Sisterhood

by Anna Bindoff

This is an essay about birth, chiefly about my own experiences of giving birth. I’m only too aware that as such it requires no further trigger warning — the word ‘birth’ serves that purpose in its own right for many, many women. Birth trauma is common and women who have suffered as a result of over-medicalized birth can feel additional shame when confronted with an idealized narrative of natural birth. Pregnancy loss is common too. Women who don’t have children by choice are often stigmatized and marginalized in the dominant culture; women who don’t have children though they wanted them carry personal anguish but also are treated by society at large as though they have failed at a fundamental level.

I want to write about birth despite all this pain, because giving birth is a defining act in many women’s lives and because my experiences of giving birth were very unusual. I gave birth in a female environment and my will, my choices, my needs, and my boundaries were, for the first and only time in my life, paramount. I was at the centre, surrounded only by persons of my own choosing who attended to me. The midwives and I formed a temporary, impregnable sisterhood, and my husband was not deferred to in any way (which to his credit he fully accepted). 

The majority of women in the UK give birth (figures from the Office for National Statistics show that in 2018, 81% of UK women aged 45 had given birth), and they give birth within pretty raw patriarchal structures, where it is the case both that social injustices tend to be magnified and that no amount of privilege counts for much when weighed against the reality of being female under medical management. It is no surprise then, really, that I have hardly ever heard a narrative of birth experience which mirrors my own, though I have heard dozens which detail women’s loss of autonomy and dignity, and the horror of being treated like a piece of meat. I have heard many accounts of women made to labour while flat on their backs when it has been known in the UK for decades (and for much longer in other parts of the world) that women generally prefer to be active and upright. I have heard of internal examinations which were indistinguishable from sexual assault, and of the devastating effects of the ‘husband stitch.’ Women here are not the centre of their own birth processes. Their wills and choices, their needs and boundaries are disregarded, if not outright violated. 

That each woman who suffers in this way, as with other assaults on her, suffers alone; that each one is tacitly convicted of her own private failure under these wounds that have been inflicted — this is perhaps the essence of being female in patriarchal culture.

Yet there is no male counterpart for birth. Birth belongs to women. Men may deeply desire offspring but only women can bring new lives into being.

I don’t imagine that any woman reading this will struggle to understand why labouring women are not at the heart of our birth culture. I want to affirm that alternatives exist, however, and that they are real possibilities: options that allow labour and birth to unfold in their own ways and time frames (always allowing that unforeseen emergencies can happen on occasion), options which allow births to be genuinely empowering rather than endured or deeply traumatizing.

When I first became pregnant, through a combination of luck and judgement I hired Independent Midwives (fully qualified midwives who have chosen to work outside the NHS in a self-employed capacity). Obviously that choice is beyond the financial means of most women in the UK, despite the considerable efforts by IMs to make their services widely available. I believe the choice to be cared for by known midwives, who have time to develop a relationship with you during pregnancy and who have sufficient experience in normal physiological birth to give the necessary support, should be available for all women.

I felt I had little option but to go outside the NHS as I already knew a number of women who had experienced significant birth trauma in hospital settings. Conversely, a close friend was very interested in birth politics and had hired an IM for her own labour. I had also done some work with Sheila Kitzinger (the social anthropologist and natural childbirth campaigner), who spent the last years of her life taking calls from women who had been highly distressed by their experiences of birth and who had nowhere else to turn in a culture which insisted that they focus only on how lucky they were that their babies had survived.

I had, consequently, a much better idea of what a medicalized birth was likely to entail than do many women. For the record, had either I or my baby needed medical intervention I would have been entirely grateful to receive it. Neither am I advocating home birth per se: I believe women should give birth in a place of their own choosing. I know that midwife-led centres are, in theory, the ideal halfway house between care by midwives at home and the medical model; I know also that the practice all too often bears no relation to the theory. While I acknowledge that some women’s birth experiences are fine, no woman giving birth in the NHS (and I love the NHS as much as the next person) can expect to be centred in her labour, or for her birth to flourish into its full power, because the medical model does not value or support this. Not only that, but the very environment of a hospital is inimical to everything we know about the needs of women in labour — seclusion, privacy, quiet or at least noise of one’s own choosing, freedom to move and to vocalize, strong boundaries around who is present — and this all too often leads again to a conviction of personal failure, when in fact women are being set up to ‘fail.’

Yet giving birth is so obviously a threshold event, a rite of passage, a trial of strength. Such things require autonomy to an acute degree if their power is to be fully integrated by the woman who traverses them.

My first experience of giving birth was a deep physical and psychic struggle. It turns out that if you spend decades girding your loins against an ever-present threat, let alone if you have experienced sexual violence, it can be quite difficult to open up enough to let life come through you. Surely this must then be a very common experience for women, and yet I have never heard it discussed other than in the most oblique ways which allow that first labours are often difficult and lengthy. The processes by which this fear can be released remain unspoken in our culture, as do the very practical things like foetal positioning which can make a huge difference to labour. The culture does not think to inform us because we do not really matter. I know that I would not have been allowed to work through those processes in hospital (again, for the record, we were both being closely monitored by two very experienced midwives), and I know I would have been deeply harmed if my baby had been pulled from me before I was ready.

My experiences of giving birth, it must be said, were profoundly unfeminine. Many of those things considered obscene in women under patriarchy — the uncontrollable body, the blood and shit, the gaping flesh and leaking breasts — featured heavily. It was vitally important to me that those attending my births were not threatened by such things but were instead seasoned enough to recognize and understand birth for what it is — something fundamentally of the female body — and to stand in sorority.

I emerged from my own experiences with a profound respect and love for my body, and an enduring confidence in it. During my labours I discovered that my body knew exactly what to do in each case and the more I could get out of my own way, the better. My body, without interference, without strangers coming and going, without anyone shouting instructions or chatting to my husband over my head, without the lighting and smells and bustle of hospitals, knew exactly what to do. Giving birth in that sisterhood gave me a deep and continuing sense of what I can only describe as ‘satisfaction,’ both bodily and emotional.

There is power to lay hold of here: the power of the female body freely channelling the power of creation. It is surely partly in unconscious fear of this power that our birth experiences are so stringently supervised and curtailed.

Giving birth unmarked by external psychic and physical wounding (as distinct from the potential impact of the process itself) is a direct connection with the vital force of life — not only in a spiritual sense, although for me it is that too, but in a very practical one. A form of life which did not exist before grows to existence within our bodies, and we bring it into the world. I felt a new and real connection with all living things, especially with all other mothers, both human and animal, after giving birth. Acknowledging and nurturing this connection is of obvious importance in the age of globalization and environmental abuse. Giving birth also gave birth in me to what could perhaps be considered the defining genius of mothers everywhere — a sense of the common good, a sense of balancing needs so that the whole can thrive.

Never, however, have I felt more the need for ritual, especially after the birth of my first child. We have strong rituals for death, and for formalizing partnerships, but neither christening services nor naming ceremonies have a place to centre the woman who has given birth in the way I was crying out for. Ironically, the old ‘churching’ tradition — a service of thanksgiving following childbirth in some Christian churches, rarely offered now due to its old association with restoring ritual purity — probably came closer. My husband said a blessing prayer we had chosen, and we had a tiny naming party with immediate family, but I longed for something more substantial, and more collective. Something which could acknowledge and contain the change in me. I remember clearly the disquieting sense of being ‘ghost-bellied’ for a few days, where I was troubled by the loss of that extraordinary life energy which had resided within me for those long, short months. I felt open in ways which sometimes felt threatening, even in the shelter of my own home; some ritual around that would have been helpful too. I was helped, it must be said, by the fact that our midwives left a powerful herbal bath concoction which needed to be brewed up in batches, and both my mother and mother-in-law did the honours on different days. That was the sole taste of the ritual I longed for, that witchy medicine, and that steadying service of my dear matriarchs.

My hope, in this extraordinary and wonderful time of renewed commitment to the liberation of women from male dominance and male violence, is that we can bring some of our focus to better births. Historically, we have asked so little and have been expected to be grateful for it. It is not too much to ask that every woman have a birth which is at least centred on her. It is not too much to ask that the birth environment be properly female in its culture. It is not too much to ask that all women be allowed to encounter the full power of their own birth experiences in the ways they see fit.

Anna Bindoff is a poet who can be found on Twitter at @a_bindoff.