Issue Ten

From Talking to Women to Trauma Counselling

A Personal History of Fighting Male Violence Against Women and Girls

by Morag MacSween

“WHEN DID WE STOP CALLING IT TALKING TO WOMEN?”

I was sitting at a kitchen table in Manchester sometime in the 90s, talking to the woman I shared a house with. We both volunteered at Manchester Rape Crisis. Her comment really struck me. When I started as a volunteer at Glasgow Rape Crisis in 1985, we offered ‘non-directive counselling.’ It had never occurred to me that something else might have come before. My housemate told me that when she started in MRC, they didn’t use the term ‘counselling,’ and that it had shifted over time.

Our conversation resurfaced in my memory when I worked, for a very short time, at a sexual assault service here in Australia in the 2020s. I’d been pretty much out of sexual violence work by that time for nearly two decades. A lot had changed, and it took me a while to get to the bottom of my sense of unease at some of the changes. My thinking began to crystallize when I encountered the ‘five Ps’ approach to case conceptualization that counsellors were using.

Case conceptualization using the five Ps is a model that comes from cognitive behavioural therapy. The aim of conceptualization is to bring together the information from assessment of a client into a hypothesis about the client’s issue(s). From that hypothesis, the ‘treatment plan’ is developed. Counsellors were writing conceptualizations that were many pages long. Most of them strongly disliked the process. Some shared my difficult-to-articulate unease. One counsellor told me that case conceptualization was introduced to ‘borrow legitimacy’ from clinical psychology.

I worked out my unease by writing a feminist version of the five Ps, just for myself:

The five Ps case formulation shows why the client is vulnerable to the condition.

Predisposing factors contribute to client risk
• He is a boy/man in a society which implicitly condones sexual violence
• She is a girl/woman in a society which implicitly condones sexual violence

Precipitating factors trigger onset of the condition
• He chooses to use sexual violence
• She encounters a boy/man who chooses to use sexual violence

The Presenting Problem
• He is not held to account and remains a risk to girls/women
• She has a normal human response to trauma and expects justice

Perpetuating factors maintain the condition
• He continues to choose to use violence
• Her response to trauma is pathologized and she is implicitly held to account

Protective factors (strengths or supports) mitigate the impact of the condition
• He is among the 1.5% convicted, is held to account, and chooses not to use violence
• She receives justice and is supported to work through her normal human response to trauma

I knew I didn’t see being subjected to sexual violence as a ‘condition.’ And I was equally uneasy about the concept of the ‘treatment plan.’ This concept reminded me of my (again short-lived) experience volunteering in an Australian rape crisis centre in 2003. Their approach felt very different from the way we’d worked in the UK – and not in a good way. Two examples: we weren’t allowed to accept calls from phone boxes (this was considered ‘unsafe’); and we were supposed to bring up the concept of ‘transference’ in the second call. I had no success in getting across why I found the assumption that adult women couldn’t make competent decisions about their own safety or the practice of introducing random elements of psychotherapy into rape crisis work so wrong, and I left.

Although I hated the five Ps, the idea of needing to ‘legitimize’ feminist counselling resonated strongly with me. Despite my four decades in sexual and domestic violence work, on some level I have continued to see my skills as inferior to those of the social workers and psychologists I have seen as a client, worked with, and supervised. I’ve been reflecting on why, as a radical feminist, I have so devalued my lived experience as a survivor, my decades of experience in feminist sexual violence support services, and my work as a consultant in domestic violence. I’ve reconnected with feminist thinking on counselling and trauma, with feminists running violence against women services today, and with some of the women I worked with in Glasgow in the 80s. This has been incredibly illuminating, and has changed my thinking significantly.

Borrowing legitimacy, or the ‘real’ experts

‘Bitter Ironies’ is an article about child abuse written by Liz Kelly in 1989.1 She observed that just as feminists appeared to have successfully forced awareness of sexual abuse into the mainstream, our insights were being side-lined by the burgeoning “incest industry.” As she noted sardonically, “We are on occasion credited with having raised the issues, but it is clearly now time for the ‘real experts’ to take over.” Kelly argues that feminist analysis has been co-opted and watered down, with serious negative impacts: gender-neutral language masking gender-specific behaviour and screening out the feminist understanding of child sexual abuse as male violence; the language of ‘disclosure,’ ‘diagnosis,’ and ‘victim’ making survivor resistance invisible; and child sexual abuse being framed as “lifetime traumatisation which can only be halted by therapeutic intervention.” She concludes:

If we are to have any chance of resisting total professional take over, any chance of providing alternatives to adult women, young women and children, we cannot afford to lose any part of grass roots services organised by women for women.

Quite by chance, I recently found a discussion paper written for a grassroots service – an English rape crisis centre – in 1995. In ‘Counselling vs Feminist Support Work,’ the (unnamed) author talks about “a dribble of disagreement” among the collective for years over whether ‘counselling’ or ‘talking to women’ should be used to describe one-to-one support work. For some, ‘counselling’ brings “encroaching professionalism” and doesn’t support women being “politicised by the experience” of connecting with rape crisis. Counselling is “another way of keeping women isolated and politically silent”; it promotes “individual ‘cures’ for social ills” and seems “wrong” and “pathologizing.” ‘Talking to women’ allows women “to understand their experience politically” and “puts the politics up front.” But it also brings “accusations of amateurism,” and can fail to ensure that women are “protected from unethical or incompetent ‘help.’” The author’s conclusion was that feminists can’t avoid engaging with counselling and therapy, but that our engagement should be collective, critical, and feminist. Without this “we all may be trogging off down divergent paths and, potentially at least, becoming more ‘therapist’ and less ‘feminist’ in our work.” If counselling is what women want – rather than assumed to be what they need – “we have an obligation to provide something decent; feminist, yes, but also well trained, experienced, properly supervised, with appropriate boundaries and accountability. After all, we would use these ‘professional’ criteria in choosing a counsellor for ourselves.”

Talking to women

I wanted to test my memory and my emerging thinking, so I reconnected with three of the women I’d worked with in Glasgow over Zoom. It was a fantastic conversation that covered much more ground than I can do justice to here, but we did talk about all the themes that were troubling me.

The first thoughts of the Glasgow women were that we’d talked about listening and support work, not counselling, because a) we wanted to distinguish ourselves as an alternative to mainstream services, and b) what we offered was broader than counselling; it didn’t ‘fit the mould.’ However, one of the women had kept archived material, and looking through that told us that not only had we talked about counselling, we had trained volunteers in non-directive counselling. This led us to reflect on what counselling had meant to us at that time:

I’m not sure when counselling became a known qualification. In the 80s counselling would have had a very different connotation than it does now, so we weren’t defining ourselves as the same as or different from a well-known profession. We would never have seen ourselves as what would be described as counsellors now. We did use all those words—but they didn’t mean the same. Nowadays counselling is everywhere.

One of the women had continued to work in rape crisis. She said:

Even up until I left last year, I was always reluctant to use the word ‘counsellor.’ Even though some of the workers had counselling qualifications, I was reluctant—none of what we did fitted into a specific discipline. We were also doing quite a bit of advocacy as well, which falls outside the counselling role. We did get workers that were a bit miffed and wanted to be called counsellors.

None of us had joined rape crisis to do counselling, or start a counselling career. Our motivations were political:

My sister gave me The Female Eunuch when I was 14; for me it was absolutely political. I didn’t think, ‘I want to be a counsellor,’ I thought, ‘I want to fight against violence against women and meet other women who felt the same way.’ At least half of what I did wasn’t supporting individual women, it was doing talks, writing to the paper, legal campaigning. It was 50/50 support work and political work.

One of the women had started in rape crisis in 1981 and had no training, learning from experience. When we started training in Glasgow, we covered a feminist analysis of sexual violence as well as non-directive counselling. We knew about trauma, but it wasn’t our dominant language:

Women usually said, ‘I didn’t fight back so it wasn’t really rape.’ We did understand fight or flight, but we didn’t have the words for it. We said to women that the fact that you didn’t fight back is a normal response – and that was different to all the other messages women were getting. The normal response for most women was to freeze. What we were doing was passing on other women’s experiences: ‘This is what women are telling us.’

The Glasgow women shared my recollection that we didn’t talk about experiencing vicarious trauma:

I never felt totally dragged down by listening to women. You then went and talked to a group, and had a great discussion, and came out really buoyed. Or you would do a bit of campaigning work and get your message into the press – so you knew you were changing stuff as well.

One of the key strengths of our practice was that we didn’t practise alone, we practised together:

You always knew there was somebody there listening – now shadowing would make you paranoid, but then you just took it for granted. You were aware of the other person, you kind of forgot they were there but you knew they were there, you knew you would get feedback. And it was the culture, you’d get off the phone and go, how did that go? It was instant supervision, training, and coaching.

We agreed that the shift to a mainly service-delivery focus, and to services being provided mainly by paid workers practising solo, took us into very different territory:

Paid workers doing eight hours a day, one-to-one support, you do need to think about vicarious trauma and external supervision. But the answer for me personally was always, do bits of group work, do other kinds of activities.

I asked the others what they thought about the shift away from sexual violence support agencies overtly defining themselves as feminist or as by-women-for-women services:

We weren’t just doing service delivery, we were also fighting back, in a group of strong independent women. We’re all women, we’re all powerful, we all have things to say – new volunteers came into that women-only space, that freedom, experiencing what women are like when we’re ourselves. It’s such a loss for young women.

We all joined because we wanted to be active in moving forward the women’s movement, whereas it’s become professionalized, it’s a job. Personally, I was on a mission. We were on a trajectory; we were fighting for systemic change.

The Glasgow women agreed that there are real depoliticizing pressures on services now:

It’s part of – I was going to say diminishing and dilution, but I think it’s active undermining of the feminist movement. The waters are so murky now. A lot of organizations are frightened of saying that they’re feminist. For the backlash and threats, and also from funding bodies. It’ll have to be gender neutral. It’s really hard for feminist organizations to hold their ground as feminist organizations.

The feminist activism part of rape crisis has been diluted, co-opted into the mainstream of service delivery.

The influence of gender-identity ideology is critical to the current pressures on both by-women-for-women and single-sex services, sitting alongside other cultural shifts:

When I reflect on the trans issue now, that reflects a very male-defined image of what a woman should be. The feminist and women’s rights bit got taken away, and I think that links to the shift to counselling and professionalizing, because it all then became about mental health and trauma; it’s nothing to do with being a woman, it’s nothing to do with men being abusers, this is about people being harmed and us supporting them. It’s not about men and women, it’s about people, and there’s this kind of people, and that kind of people. Be Kind.

We recognized a continuum of abuse that every woman will experience in her life, that 100% of women experience – that’s been eaten away at. And we seem to be back to: there’s ‘normal men’ and there’s other men. We’ve lost an understanding of the systemic nature of male violence in our culture. We were saying: this isn’t about bad apples, it’s systemic.

The amateur/professional debate in my thinking and in the 1995 paper did not resonate with the Glasgow women:

I don’t think I ever felt that we needed more skills. I’m here to listen and I’m here to support, and there’s some things I can’t help with. You just needed to be with the woman and help her find her path, whatever path she takes out of it.

New workers were often dead scared to ask women things – what if she does this? What if she says that? Just ask her, she’s a grown up, she’ll tell you. You were another human being, another woman in the room, not ‘I’m the professional here.’

That was then, this is now

“We recognise that gender is not a binary category of sex difference and offer therapeutic services to any person affected by family or domestic violence.”2

The social context around sexual and domestic violence work has changed significantly. Counselling is dominant, services are staffed by employees rather than by volunteers, and workers are more likely to be professional counsellors than feminist activists. Even though funding is much more secure, the social and funding barriers to providing by-women-for-women or single-sex services are stronger, and feminist politics are significantly less likely to be up front. ‘Trauma’ and ‘gender’ are much more prominent terms than ‘woman’ and ‘feminist,’ and service users are usually described as ‘people’ rather than ‘women and girls.’ What does feminist engagement with counselling mean in these changed circumstances? And does counselling through the trauma lens unproblematically co-exist with a feminist analysis of sexual violence?

Counselling and feminism

As one of the UK women I spoke to said:

It is indeed really interesting to see how counselling has become so dominant as a service response, particularly in SV [sexual violence] work. At the same time, there is a tendency for counselling models to be incredibly distanced from the political dynamics of VAW. I worry that counselling is seen as ‘treatment’ these days, and that women taking it up are so easily pathologized. I also feel frustrated by the limitations on counselling models that are available these days to students, so that those who have qualified often lack the knowledge to bring feminism into the counselling space … [it can be] difficult to find women with a strong understanding of feminism as it can be used in counselling.

This is unsurprising. One of the articles I found while writing this piece was a discussion between four feminist counsellors:

My feminism has been silenced. I do not believe I, or others, have done this with conscious awareness. Nevertheless, I experienced little feminist theory in my training and I’m not aware of feminism within psychotherapy or counselling special interest groups. I’m aware of nothing that would support an awareness of feminist theory within the sector or provide a support network for feminist practitioners.

[There is] a gap – the lack of a feminist ‘infrastructure’ for therapists, a lack of discussion and debate in the counselling world about feminist ideas and strategies: What does feminism mean for clients and practitioners now?…Why is it that, when sexism is still so alive, and there is a clear response in other areas of work and study, counselling and feminist practices seem to be estranged?3

My experience in Australia is that a feminist analysis of violence against women and girls is neither sought from nor taught to counsellors. In the absence of a ‘feminist infrastructure,’ counselling dominates over other forms of support, and from what I have seen, it is usually ‘more therapist, less feminist.’ When I talked about this to friends and colleagues who have ‘real’ qualifications – social workers, psychologists, therapists – they were pretty uniformly amused that someone with decades of experience would see herself as an ‘amateur.’ They also roundly argued against my assumption that I would never have been out of my depth in counselling if I had more formal qualifications. Reflecting on these conversations, and on my experience in ‘clinical’ roles in community and human services, I realized that applying the labels of ‘expert’ and ‘amateur’ is by no means simple. Qualification in and of itself does not guarantee that practice will be, as the 1995 paper described, “well trained, experienced, properly supervised, with appropriate boundaries and accountability.” There is surprisingly little clarity about, or oversight of, the core concept of safe and ethical counselling: scope of practice.

Scope of practice is the area of the profession in which a counsellor has the knowledge, skills and experience to practise competently, safely, and lawfully, in a way that meets standards and does not pose any danger to the public or to themselves.4

Over the past decades, there has been an explosion of counselling models or ‘modalities.’ Each has its passionate advocates; most argue that they are evidence-based. What this means in practice is that women’s agencies employing social workers, psychologists, and counsellors are likely to be offering a range of approaches, more often determined by counsellor experience or preference than conscious agency determination or feminist analysis. What ‘counts’ as adequate training is incredibly variable. For example, EMDR (increasingly practised within trauma counselling) is practised by some after a couple of days of training, while others undertake substantial training and supervised practice from an EMDR-accredited practitioner. Experience in generalist counselling before offering sexual or domestic violence counselling – invariably described as ‘specialist’ – does not seem to be a standard requirement, and there is no standard expected approach to supervision, evaluation, or quality assurance.

For me, this means that feminist engagement with counselling is simultaneously more difficult and more necessary. The challenge in ensuring that we are providing counselling which is feminist, trauma-informed, and ‘decent’ is compounded by the lack of ‘feminist infrastructure’ for counsellors, and the constant, insidious, and powerful pull of de-politicized models of sexual violence and trauma which support rather than threaten patriarchy and capitalism.

Trauma and feminism

“This book owes its existence to the women’s liberation movement.” – Judith Herman, Trauma and Recovery

At the heart of the trauma approach is reframing traumatic stress from pathology to “a normal reaction to an abnormal event.”5 Like many feminists, I received my first understanding of trauma from Judith Lewis Herman’s Trauma and Recovery: From Domestic Abuse to Political Terror.6 For Herman, public awareness of trauma depends on the co-existence of a political movement; lessening of the power of those movements leads to trauma ‘disappearing.’ Bearing witness to trauma, accepting the reality and frequency of the abuse to which it is a reaction, is an inherently political act. Feminism is the “intellectual mainspring” of Herman’s work. Towards the end of Trauma and Recovery, Herman considers the future for trauma studies if their place in public awareness is sustained:

Legitimacy can be a mixed blessing. The next generation of researchers may lack the passionate intellectual and social commitment that inspired many of the most creative earlier investigations. In this new more conventional phase of scientific inquiry, there is some cause for concern that integrative concepts and contextual understanding of psychological trauma may be lost, even as more precise and scientific knowledge is gained. The very strength of the recent biological findings in PTSD may foster a narrowed, predominantly biological, focus of research. As the field of traumatic stress studies matures, a new generation of researchers will need to rediscover the essential interconnection of biological, psychological, social and political dimensions of trauma.

From a feminist perspective, what has been the impact of legitimacy on our understanding and application of trauma theory? I discovered three inspirational feminist perspectives.

Emma Tseris argues that “the ascendence of the trauma lens” in contemporary thinking is more often co-opted within the medical model than used to critique it. She argues that trauma therapy can be used “to reduce complex social justice issues into psychological symptoms, which are then thought to be curable through expert mental health treatment … reproducing, rather than disrupting, the tendency within psychiatry to de-contextualise women’s distress from its social and gendered context.”7

Theo Kohler talks about “‘the triumph of the therapeutic’ … the way psychiatric ideas have become part of everyday discourse.”8 Kohler argues that the origins of trauma theory in feminist and anti-war activism “seems to be a conveniently buried history,” and that “a logic of individual pain tends to prevail, ironically running the risk of obscuring the causes of structural violence and inequality.”

In her PhD research into trauma-informed refuges in Australia and Canada, Leticia Funston found “a continuum of trauma informed care … ranging from politicised to behaviour management models of practice.”9 From this, she argues that “trauma informed care is a site of social and political struggle.” Politicized service models “struggled to maintain legitimacy” for two reasons: the dominance of mental-health-framed trauma approaches; and “the corporate calculus of human service delivery” which prioritizes short-term interventions and ‘turn-over’ of clients. For Funston, these influences “have rapidly transformed anti-violence against women work into a trauma recovery industry.”

The power and importance of naming women’s responses to violence as normal human reaction rather than pathology cannot be overstated. But I think Herman was incredibly prescient about the risks of legitimacy. Newer findings about the physiological mechanisms of trauma are a double-edged sword, prioritizing calming the nervous system over finding meaning. It is assumed that our heightened perception of danger is caused by our activated nervous system rather than by our heightened awareness of the thick thread of male violence which runs through our lives. Women’s greater likelihood of being diagnosed with complex PTSD is sometimes acknowledged but is rarely explained by the reality of pervasive and normalized male violence against women and girls.10 And as Liz Kelly argued about child sexual abuse, the dominant picture of the victim-survivor ‘disappears’ her resistance into a narrative of “lifetime traumatisation” requiring “therapeutic intervention.”

I’m left feeling pretty naïve about my previous uncomplicated view of trauma. For a sociologist and a feminist, it should have been absolutely unsurprising that a political explanation for trauma would be co-opted and watered down. After all, the biological and psychological elements of trauma are palatable and unthreatening to the social order, and it is entirely convenient for its social and political elements to fade quietly into the background. Reconnecting with the Glasgow women and women working in the UK now has re-politicized me. In my own practice, and in my own experience, I’ve seen and experienced the burden-lifting, light-bulb-moment impact of the Power and Control Wheel,11 of explaining the commonality between perpetrator tactics in sexual abuse and military tactics used with prisoners of war, and in providing a solid, unequivocal answer to the questions ‘Why did he do it?’ and ‘Why did he do it to me?’

I remember and reassert that the feminist analysis of male violence and of women’s reactions to it is unrivalled among the range of meanings available to us – both for its explanatory power and for its grounding in the evidence. This perspective explains why women can feel so bad, for so long, why we freeze, and how we resist. It de-individualizes our reactions to trauma and to the daily acts of sexism and misogyny we encounter. It locates blame in perpetrator behaviour, not with victims, and explains male violence as something to fight rather than an inevitability.

It seems to me that maintaining a feminist or a politicized trauma perspective in sexual and domestic violence services is now harder than it ever was. It means swimming against a powerful mainstream, in the context of a reenergized men’s rights activist movement, and negotiating with “the corporate calculus of service delivery.” In my view, we need to re-purpose ‘the masters’ tools’: develop service models, program logics, and evaluations to demonstrate, in language more likely to be heard, that feminist sexual violence services are evidence-based and effective.

Feminist, yes, but decent

I think the 1995 paper is spot on in identifying “collective critical feminist engagement” with the theories and practices of counselling as core to running a service that is both feminist and ‘decent.’ I’d add that we equally need to engage in this way with the theories and practices of trauma, and with the impact of a shift to full-time counselling roles. For me, engagement would be supported by three things: a service model developed through collective critical feminist engagement; a rethinking of vicarious trauma; and a rethinking of ‘counselling-only’ roles. In my short-lived return to sexual violence support management in Australia, I began to develop a service model which would allow women and girls to choose the service they wanted – crisis support, witnessing, advocacy, short-term counselling, or long-term trauma therapy. The model set out the experience, qualifications, and scaffolding required to provide those services safely, well, in a trauma-informed way, and within a feminist analysis of sexual violence. From the experience of writing this piece, I would now add that we need to:
  • adopt a clear agency position on the counselling approaches or modalities used
  • recruit counsellors with experience and adequate training in those approaches
  • provide training in feminist analysis of sexual violence, trauma, and counselling
  • provide supervision which supports in-scope, feminist, and trauma-informed practice.
We didn’t talk about vicarious trauma or compassion fatigue in Glasgow Rape Crisis in the 80s, but then we didn’t have paid workers doing full-time counselling; we were activists as well as service providers, and we practised in pairs. From my experience of supervising workers in full counselling roles, I think a focus on vicarious trauma is absolutely critical. I also think we need to be aware of its potential to become depoliticized and detached from context. Vicarious trauma is too often individualized, with the response being ‘self-care’ by the worker rather than a comprehensive response by the agency. The source of vicarious trauma is too often located solely with the client, rendering invisible the impact of supporting survivors in a culture of misogyny, injustice, and re-traumatizing systems – also known as “bullshit fatigue.”12 The potential for developing vicarious resilience and compassion satisfaction from working with amazing, powerful, resisting victim-survivors and through “fighting back, in a group of strong independent women” needs to be recognized and fostered. When counselling runs in parallel to other forms of support, systemic work, or collective activism, rather than being integrated with them, it is fertile ground for vicarious trauma. One of the tenets of counselling that I think we should push back against is the idea that counselling cannot co-exist with other forms of support, such as advocacy or ‘case’ management. Indeed, this is what women are telling service providers they want, when they choose to listen. I am more convinced than ever of the compelling need for an alternative to the mainstream, delivered with proudly and explicitly feminist expertise and professionalism. An alternative which understands, puts up front, and is consciously and collectively shaped by the continuing and pervasive reality of male violence against women and girls:

Hatred of women is not just an accidental characteristic of some men, it’s systemic. It’s a feature, not a bug, of the type of world we live in … violence against women happens day in and day out, and blights hundreds of thousands of lives, but the misogyny that drives it is so pervasive and normalised it is really hard to get many people to notice, it’s just the wallpaper, it’s the background of their consciousness.13

The last line of Against Our Will reads: “My purpose in this book has been to give rape its history. Now we must deny it a future.” The world has come to understand rape much more clearly, but we have not eliminated it.14

Morag MacSween has worked in the MVAWG movement for over 30 years, in Scotland, England, and Australia. She has also worked in child protection, mental health, and trauma services, and is interested in the ways that feminist analyses of sexual violence are ignored, attacked, and co-opted, and in how dominant explanatory frameworks in turn shape feminist services. She is a radical feminist, Marxist, and proud Scot that is, proud of the women of Scotland, not the government of Scotland. She offers consultancy, coaching, and clinical supervision. She lives in Tasmania with her partner, Charmaine, and their cat, Angelica.

1 Liz Kelly, ‘Bitter Ironies: The Professionalisation of Child Sexual Abuse,’ Trouble and Strife, 16 (1989). 2 Extracts from Australian sexual and domestic violence service websites. 3 Jo Crozier, Kathryn Morris-Roberts, Patience O’Neill and Jeannie Wright, ‘Feminist Ideas and Counselling,’ Therapy Today, 27.1 (February 2016). 4 ‘Scope of Practice,’ Psychotherapy and Counselling Federation of Australia. 5 American Psychological Association website. 6 Judith Lewis Herman, Trauma and Recovery: From Domestic Abuse to Political Terror (New York: Basic Books, 1992). 7 Emma Tseris, ‘A Feminist Critique of Trauma Therapy,’ in Routledge International Handbook of Critical Mental Health (Milton Park, UK: Routledge, 2017). 8 Theo Kohler, ‘Trigger warnings: A feminist theory of trauma versus the neoliberal university,’ Overland, 27 September 2016. ‘The triumph of the therapeutic’ is a term coined by sociologist Philip Rieff. 9 Leticia Funston, ‘In the Business of Trauma: An Intersectional-Materialist Feminist Analysis of “Trauma Informed” Women’s Refuges and Crisis Accommodation Services in Sydney and Vancouver,’ PhD thesis, University of Sydney, 2019. 10 See for example the ‘complex PTSD’ diagnosis in the International Classification of Diseases 2011. Most descriptions of trauma which I have seen identify people with disabilities and LGBTQIA+ people as disproportionately impacted by trauma, but not women and girls. 11 Understanding the Power and Control Wheel,’ Domestic Abuse Intervention Programs. 12 Allan Wade, Centre for Response-Based Practice. 13 Jane Clare Jones (@janeclarejones), Twitter. 14 Quoted in Denise C. Webster and Erin C. Dunn, ‘Feminist Perspectives on Trauma,’ in The Foundation and Future of Feminist Therapy, ed. by Marcia Hill and Mary Ballou (Philadelphia: Haworth Press, 2005).
a
a
Tags: Issue 10