Issue Six

Finding Balance in Science and Nature

by Paula Alice

‘Science’ is one of those words, like ‘essentialism,’ that’s gone a bit funny in recent years. A concept once associated with a process of acquiring knowledge (asking questions, observing, gathering evidence) now more often seems to be spoken of in the language of faith: Trust Science, Believe Science, Science Says. To the proponents of identity, ‘science’ has become a sort of wereword (see Lucy Tatman, ‘Attack of the Werewords,’ Issue Two), used not to enlighten but to attack, gesturing to authority rather than attempting to persuade. Carrying the weight of the most simplistic media-activist-institutional consensus, this sort of ‘science’ is incurious, unquestionable, infallible, and capable of enacting almost anything within human imagination (surely, without the suppression of science by the forces of bigot-normativity, the distribution of uteruses would already be much more inclusive).

 

‘Nature’ is something to which the proponents of identity often make appeals while fundamentally treating it antagonistically. Depending on whom you ask and on what day, a transition to the desired persona might be simply the unfurling of a chrysalis: the revealing of what nature already put there, helped along with bloodless euphemisms (affirmation, confirmation). Ask again and you might get a less romantic view of the natural—as raw, lifeless material, meat suits, arbitrary bodies; inconvenient matter to be moulded by the mind, harnessed and shaped as its ‘owner’ sees fit; as vessels to be ‘captained.’[1]

 

There is science that seeks to support human flourishing through understanding and respecting nature, and natural limits. And then there is science that seeks to advance ‘progress’—often closely entwined with ‘profit’—through dominating and controlling nature, and pretending it is limitless. It was science, though they might not have called it that, when mothers, grandmothers, and other wise women gathered the knowledge of botanicals and their properties over hundreds of years—how and where they grew, their medicinal and poisonous qualities, how to use them for contraception and healing. It was another sort of science, a patriarchal and colonial sort, that dug up those plants, put them in jars, and carried them across the ocean, where the fraction that survived would be catalogued, renamed, their descriptions given by women rewritten; they would be displayed in botanical gardens or drawn in books on blank backgrounds, deprived of the context of their ecosystems and all the other plants and animals in them. Science was the knowledge of Indigenous peoples in the Americas that low-burning, regular ground fires in the forest were regenerating, not destructive—making space and light, germinating seeds, and encouraging new growth. A white person’s version of science thinking itself more advanced suppressed fires, banned traditional gathering practices, and planted trees and monocrops in straight rows, only beginning to awaken to the limitations of its understanding many decades later.

 

Capitalist-patriarchal science is taking apart healthful plants for their components, processing them into easy-to-swallow units that lack the full complexity and all the supporting qualities of the foods they once were. It is treating animals as units of production, lines on profit and loss sheets, even attempting to grow their sellable parts in labs while doing away completely with their inconvenient animality. This sort of science is characterized by a lack of respect for systems, for interconnections, and for any knowledge that comes from outside of its own structure, which often means from women.

 

The tension between nature and patriarchal science often plays out in women’s bodies. From a production standpoint, women are, like nature, suboptimal: too irregular, too messy, too tied to their bodies and babies, too unable, at least for long, to pretend they’re not animals. In the medical-capitalist view, femaleness is a problem to be solved. Deprived of the knowledge of our bodies, we have their ‘solutions’ sold back to us as pills and procedures subject to men’s laws. Better than nothing, maybe: whatever the flaws of the profit-seeking pharmaceutical industry and a paternalistic medical system, many women are profoundly grateful for their interventions. Decisions around contraception, pregnancy, birth, and babies are subject to so many pressures, from the over-idealization of the natural to the vesting of authority in a male-dominated science that often ignores the reality of women’s lives (see Charlotte Russell, ‘Birthing Misogyny,’ Issue Three), and clear information and options should always prevail over shaming and dogmas.

 

But whatever choices we make, bodies are never arbitrary. Nature is never arbitrary. We aren’t limitless. The oil that built our modern capitalist culture is running out, and the metals to replace the oil are running out too. Even clouds of data ‘in the sky’ depend on metals from the ground, which always come with a cost: to human bodies, to the water, soil, and air we need to survive.

 

Can a generation raised with its head in those clouds grasp that reality? I recently watched Euphoria, a TV programme in which dead-eyed teenagers played by 25-year-olds punish themselves with bad drugs and grim sex while saying things like, “The world’s coming to an end, and I haven’t even graduated high school yet.” It strikes me that the show takes place in a world with almost no natural spaces—no green, no trees, no parks or beaches—and I can’t help wonder about the link with its young characters’ joyless disconnection. “They think they can just delete themselves and start over,” my daughter says of her classmates who live in a rainbow fantasy of anime and pronouns. Young people fear, rightly, the damage we are doing to the earth, but can they feel themselves a part of nature enough to want to save it?

 

The ‘natural’ can be simplistically elevated: as it’s been said before, poisonous mushrooms are natural, while plenty of helpful things of high benefit and low risk are not. And the idealization of the natural has certainly been used, sometimes horrifically, against all sorts of people: the disabled, the different, the ill, the same-sex-attracted, the infertile, the childless, the old. Nature causes plenty of suffering, and so does a capitalist-industrial system; there is, and should be, no shame in making use of the marvels of human medicine and technology to support our health and flourishing, or to ease difficult situations. And without judgement, it should be possible to distinguish between things when they need distinguishing: natural variation is not pathology, and vice versa; it isn’t helpful to treat something that causes distress as if it doesn’t. Wearing eyeglasses, taking birth control, and having surgery are quite different degrees of intervention, and none of them make us cyborgs. The statement that, all things being equal, it is better to keep healthy body parts and functions than not should not be taken as a statement that those who lack or lose parts and functions are less valuable as people, less capable of leading full lives, that they should be viewed as damaged. It’s simply a call for humility about the complexity of our bodies, of nature; a recognition that we don’t get to press delete and start over, and that we can’t always understand the cost of our pushing of natural limits. We aren’t really the captain of the ship (and we’re not the Ship of Theseus, with infinitely replaceable parts). We are passengers with a single body, a single brief life, granted the gifts of a resilient but finite planet, an ever-growing wealth of human knowledge, technology, and imagination, and the wisdom—let’s hope—to take none of it for granted.

 

Paula Alice is an editor, writer, and mother who lives in Canada.

 

[1] Inspired in part by Juno Dawson, “If my body is a vessel, I am its captain,” from ‘Living in a woman’s body: My body belongs to me. I can harness and shape it as I see fit,’ The Guardian, 11 February 2022.

a
Categories: Both/And
a
Tags: Issue 6