Issue Two

Editorial Statement

by Daisy Gudmunsen

I’m always inclined to channel voices that aren’t mine: the editorial instinct gets the better of me, and my writing ends up peppered with quotations. Though I may be a bit of a necromancer in that regard, I respect the dead. Patriarchs, on the other hand, are what Mary Daly calls “necrophiliacs” (there I go already).1 They claim to love what they want to kill. These are the bomb-makers and planet-polluters of the world, “who try to turn the earth into their Poisoned Apple.” Not content with boiling up the planet, the patriarch is also fond of human sacrifice; he seeks to poison women with a slow-acting potion that saps our vitality. A peculiar exchange occurs. Expelling and projecting his darkness onto us, he starts to feel better, while we choke on the bitterness.

Rebecca West, contributor to and board member of Time and Tide magazine (reviewed by Susanna Rustin), identified this mechanism of exchange many years ago: your death secures my life. In 1930s Macedonia, she witnessed a ritual slaughter of animals. The sacrificial rock gleams with fresh blood as the men seek “to smash what [is] whole, to puddle in the warm stickiness of their own secretions.”2 This sacrifice is a patriarchal fertility ritual, predictably ornamented with images of seeds and swords. It would be masturbatory if it didn’t make such extravagant use of other bodies. And the rock becomes a symbol for the “huge and dirty lie” at its heart: “if one squares death by offering him a sacrifice, one will be allowed some share in life.”

Of course, suffering and damage can’t be exchanged in return for happiness. Death can’t be exchanged for life, and you’d be wrong to try. But the lie is remarkably persistent. Many of the pieces in this issue attest to and critique the continued existence of this simplistic, transactional economy. Gender, religion, and technology fall under this rock’s glooming shadow when they attempt to supplant responsibility and reality with a neat, harmful lie. “For a woman to be good, she must be dead, or as close to it as possible.”3

Meanwhile, our lives actually depend on the “body and bowels” of a much larger rock, the planet Earth (as Jane Clare Jones explains). This oceanic blue dot is our home. And here, at least, we have the opportunity to rock the boat. As Sonia Johnson puts it, “when [women] understand that the penalties are the same whether we disobey a little or disobey completely, but that the rewards come only when we disobey completely, then we are ready to be free.”4 Rebellion, it seems to me, is the opposite of sacrifice. We all want “some share in life,” but rather than getting there through zero-sum bargaining, an unruly resistance—united by a common condition and set of needs—does the difficult work of making that share. And so we carve out a space in this spinning rock, a new cave within her belly for our acts of rebellion.

Daisy Gudmunsen is completing a DPhil in modern French thought, structural analysis, and poetic form at the University of Oxford. She currently lives in Paris and teaches at the École normale supérieure. Daisy loves fiddling with words, especially other people’s.

1 Mary Daly, Gyn/Ecology: The Metaethics of Radical Feminism (Boston: Beacon Press, 1978)

2 Rebecca West, Black Lamb and Grey Falcon: A Journey Through Yugoslavia (Hong Kong: Penguin Books, 1984), ‘St. George’s Eve: II.

3 See Andrea Dworkin’s reading of Snow White in Woman Hating (New York: Penguin, 1974), p. 42. This falsehood is the real ‘Poisoned Apple’ of the tale.

4 Sonia Johnson, Going out of Our Minds: The Metaphysics of Liberation (Freedom: Crossing Press, 1987), p. 25.