Issue Three

Craftivism: Isabelle Tracy in Conversation With Emma Dolan

Emma Dolan is a textile artist from Leeds who went from happily making Harris Tweed teacups for galleries and museums such as the V&A and the British Museum to creating banners and other artworks for feminist actions. She spoke with Isabelle Tracy, her sometime collaborator, over Zoom.

Isabelle Tracy: To get the ball rolling — how did you and I meet?

Emma Dolan: I attended a workshop that you ran, organized by Leeds City Council in 2018, to make electric wire banners for the Light Night parade. You did a bit of a spiel about famous suffragettes from Leeds that you’d researched, and then the woman from city council said, “But you can just make your banner about family and love and unity and strength,” which sounded a bit fluffy. I was undercover, not being openly feministy at all, and I was very suspicious of you! But then you showed your sample banner and it had two XXs, and three woman symbols with linked arms, and a load of purple and green. And then I sidled up to you at the end to ask if you were on Twitter.

Isabelle: I said, “I am, but it’s all a bit political these days,” and we made eye contact, and that was that. Then soon after, you came over [to Isabelle’s house in Hull] and we sewed our banners for the parade. I’d done all of the workshops, and I heard the women’s groups being told, “Just write Love and Unity,” and then the transgender workshop being told, “Be as political as you like — no debate, trans women are women.”

Emma: Which would have turned the parade into a load of females trundling along in loving unity behind ‘TWAW No Debate’ placards. Instead, we made electric wire banners out of the purple, white and green sashes that were left over from the Artichoke Trust Processions [a 2018 mass participation artwork celebrating one hundred years of votes for British women]. We put vivid neon light-up writing on them, one saying ‘Adult Human Female,’ and one saying ‘Bellos,’ because Leeds had just stopped [black lesbian feminist activist] Linda Bellos from speaking. We marched up to the front of the parade, so it went Giant Suffragettes, then Samba Band, then Adult Human Female neon banners.

Isabelle: What was your first piece of feminist art? Spare Rib?

Emma: Yes, I suppose that was my first contact with what would be called feminist art. I sent them an illustration, an Art Nouveau woman, and asked if they needed any help. They must have had a good laugh, because it was so sincere, but rubbish. I got a lovely letter back saying, thank you so much for your submission, so glad to know that you’re a reader of the magazine and keep in touch. A couple of years later, I made a few pieces on my foundation year at Jacob Kramer Art College in Leeds. I suppose you could call those feminist now. They were about marriage. But I definitely wouldn’t have called anything I did feminist at the time.

Isabelle: That Art Nouveau lettering, which is a big part of the aesthetic of your pieces—is that an explicit link with the suffragette movement?

Emma: It wasn’t consciously, at first. But if I think of pieces I’ve done through different periods of my artwork, Art Nouveau-y women have been a recurring theme. Mainly, I think, because they combine lots of patterns.

Isabelle: By the time you started doing your recent feminist activist work, did you take it for granted that political acts and actions were a part of art or were distinct artistic practices in themselves?

Emma: In my mind, there was a clear separation between the banners, the politics, the actions, the demos, and then the artwork I was doing in my studio. I made banners because, very simply, if you go on a march, you hold a placard or a banner—it was as straightforward as that. I suppose my first piece of ‘feminist activist art’ (if you insist!) was the ‘Save Our Sex’ banner, for the Million Women Rise march. That was only a couple of weeks, maybe a month, after I first heard anything about the idea we were meant to believe that women could have penises. I’d been thrown in the deep end on social media, and met a whole load of women in a chat group that I now know to be feminist superstars — journalists and activists. At the time, I felt like I wanted to grab everyone I saw and say, “Do you know what’s happening?!” And the best way I could think of to do that was to write it as big as I could and walk around with it. I didn’t really want to say it was art. I definitely didn’t set out to do Art Activism with a capital ‘A.’ I was going on a march. It was obvious I was going to make a banner.

Isabelle: I think that’s part of what art activism is about — there isn’t a gap between Art with a capital ‘A’ and the rest. Did you consciously design it in the tradition of trade union banners?

Emma: For the first couple of banners, the ‘Arse’ one with Leeds Spinners, for example, it was just a design style, but the rest, definitely yes. I researched the way the trade-union-style banners were made and tried to mimic them, even to the point of how they were constructed with a pole going across the top and tabs and tassels, and all the lovely holsters for holding the poles.

‘Arse’ was a response to a piece by Owen Jones in the Guardian.1 I was on the Million Women Rise march with the ‘Save Our Sex’ banner, getting lots of lovely responses. Someone in the group mentioned Owen Jones, and I said, “Wrong side of history, my arse.” Everyone was laughing, and I said, “Well, that’s my next banner, then.” It was an answer to the current notion that there is a right and a wrong side of history, and a certain ‘Marxist’ knows exactly which side we’re all going to be on. I pictured a banner that would catalogue some of the horrendous things that were being said to us — all beautifully hand-embroidered, of course.

Leeds Spinners were born when I advertised three free drop-in workshops entitled ‘Craftivism, Banner Making and RadFem Revolution.’ If you look closely at the detail of ‘Arse,’ you can see embroidered contributions from the other Leeds Spinners too, and a few of our daughters. It had its first outing that June at Processions, then went up to Durham Miners’ Gala, and over to Manchester. Down to London another few times as well. It gets a good response. And I thanked Owen Jones on Twitter as my muse. And he replied! Sent me a GIF — “Why are you so obsessed with me?” — which was quite funny. Why he replied, I really don’t know.

Isabelle: I’ve been looking at the tradition of humour in art activism, as a considered political tactic … 

Emma: Well, it’s just such a powerful tool to use, isn’t it? I wanted to make a response that was funny or ridiculous or sarcastic, because at the time, I just could not get over how ridiculous the arguments that we were having to have were. They were just so nonsensical that to write anything super serious, anything really sincere or heartfelt or moving, didn’t seem appropriate.

Isabelle: I’m interested in the Situationist International art movement, the Council for the Liberation of Everyday Life, using pranks and turning the power that you are resisting back onto itself — like subvertisements, which take the language of advertising and subvert it. As a movement, it all fell apart eventually; it was also mostly blokes. But it had an enduring influence. Did you take it for granted that those kinds of things could be, or are, a part of art? A lot of what happened at Greenham Common was pranks and guerrilla and funny actions. Yet sometimes there’s an objection to humour, that we’re not taking serious matters as seriously as they should be taken.

Emma: There was something the Leeds women did as part of a national ReSisters United action, putting ‘Adult Human Female’ T-shirts on statues of women. We decided we were going to do it in daylight and not try to be clandestine — just brazen it out. We wore Mrs Mop costumes, housecoats, dusters, and head scarves, with some in Hilda Ogden masks, looking very matronly and 1950s. It was like a uniform, that brought us together collectively and distanced us from worry about breaking the law. I don’t know how much press attention we would have had if we hadn’t been in costume. The photograph of us with feather dusters and head scarves was picked up by Leeds Live, who ran a big poll to ask if our action had been offensive or not. I think at the end of the tally, 80% said ‘no’ — of course not, it wasn’t offensive. 

Isabelle: Another thing that the Situationists were into was deconstructing the city and our relationship to it, which has turned into a strand of art called psychogeography, and it uses a lot of maps …

Emma: Well, because we’ve more or less sorted out the gender problem [much laughter], obviously, in Leeds, the big thing is the Holbeck situation, the ‘managed zone’ [for prostitution: see Sarah Field, ‘The Managed Zone’ in this issue]. I don’t know whether I would call this art activism or art I’ve been doing for myself. I was going on walks every day during lockdown in Roundhay Park, and the main thing going through my head was, “Holbeck is a disgrace.” I’d started looking into the Peter Sutcliffe murders as well. I was looking at maps and the geography of where things have happened to me, and there was a feeling of being in parallel to things that have happened in Leeds, various incidents of misogyny. I was looking for imagery as I walked, looking at trees and branches. And every time I looked up and saw trees, I saw maps everywhere. It’s mapping misogyny, basically.

Isabelle: But done in beautiful embroidery …

Emma: Yeah, deliberately stitched in a lovely non-angry way, printed and then coloured in and painted and then stitched with silks. The mapping is a little device because I wanted to say, “Look at this, this is the zone and this is where these things happen. And all these other women are living their lives in these same places. And these things are happening to all women as well. It’s just everywhere and every day.” And it’s a way of illustrating that — actually, literally putting it on a map, and having a little X-marks-the-spot where each occasion of horribleness has happened.

Isabelle: And where are these maps going to be, and how are they going to be?

Emma: I started thinking about patchwork quilts, coming from the work you and I did together curating the display in the lobby of the Woman’s Place conference in 2020, which included banners and some amazing quilts by Holly Smith. A lot of my work has been about creating small units of design, and then putting them all together and maybe turning them into a pattern. The maps are all going to be put together at some point into a quilt or series of quilts of some sort. It was a conscious decision to start doing work again that I actually would call artwork rather than big painted banners. 

Isabelle: With the Holbeck managed zone, what would you like your activism to do?

Emma: To raise awareness amongst the rest of the public, the half of Leeds who don’t know what’s going on there. And I suppose to give the people there hope, so they know that there are people out here recognizing the shit state they’re in.

It’s a specific area of streets just out of the city centre where prostitution is legal between 8pm and 6am. But it doesn’t stay there. It’s spread into the residential surroundings, outside people’s homes, schools, businesses, at all hours. A resident I spoke to yesterday talked of clearing away “sex and drug litter” from outside the house before she’d take her kids out. Kids are coming out of the doors at school seeing a punter and a woman having sex in a car. The popularity of the zone with punters around the region has meant demand has gone through the roof: there were 30 to 40 women on the streets when the managing began, and there are 140 to 150 now. How can that be right? It is growing the demand from the men and attracting tourists.

Isabelle: Without giving away anything, have you got any further actions planned in relation to this? 

Emma: Yes. [Laughter.]

Isabelle: A lot of the work you’ve been doing since lockdown has been solo, and very personal — your walks and maps and reactions to places. But you’ve still done collective actions, like the ones about Leeds promoting itself as a cultural destination for tourism whilst running part of the city as a brothel. 

Emma: From Leeds City Council’s point of view, we are a Woman-Friendly City! And they’re meant to be proud of that. And it’s just a nonsense. So, our response was the blue plaque. I was messing around with wording to put on it — ‘Red Light Zone,’ ‘Legalized Sex,’ etc. — and then you came back with something nice and direct: just stick a big ‘BROTHEL’ on the front. It was perfect. We put it on the nice city-council flower bed at the entrance to the city, the gateway to Leeds when you come off the main motorways. I’ve still got it — it’s rolled up and tucked away somewhere. We can do more with it after lockdowns. 

There was also the ‘City of Punters’ banner, which we hung across a street billboard in Leeds. The main thing I’m proud of with that action was working out how to hang it — filling the tights at each end with rice and making little tabs. And on the ‘Women Are Not for Sale’ sign, filling the little weights with £5 in coppers, the price of a blowjob. But I don’t think of it as art, because anyone could do it.

Isabelle: The way I see it, all of these different things that you are doing fit together as art activism, but you seem to be resistant to, or maybe ambivalent about, that idea. I’m trying to get to the bottom of this—is it the art vs. craft binary? Or the collective vs. personal binary? Or the politics vs. art binary?

Emma: I am not impressed with a lot of fine art which is strong on concept and weak on execution — the skill of how it is made — and a lot of which is bullshit. So I don’t want to be lumped in with that. In art school, I picked what I liked doing — textiles — because I liked it. Not because it was seen as the feminist thing to do, but because I was interested in what was visually pleasing to me. 

So, I really wanted to paint a massive banner. But I wouldn’t have done it without the rest of the group — you coming up with a slogan, actually putting it up there, finding a good site, liaising with press and getting coverage for it. Because would it have been as successful if there hadn’t been good images of it? No. So, okay, yes, it’s art. But it wasn’t beautiful; there wasn’t balance in the lettering, in the design of it. Whereas ‘Brothel,’ that had some skill in the making, not just the concept, and not just the political action. 

Isabelle: I’ve just written down, “Is Leeds on the country’s ley line of feminism versus misogyny?” But what were feminists doing in between Reclaim the Nights and the managed zone, for example? Did we drop the ball? Did we stop paying attention, especially to all the Humpty Dumpty stuff in academia about words meaning whatever I say they mean? What do you think happened?

Emma: From my perspective, I really don’t know what was happening with feminist groups in Leeds in between those two sort of cultural landmarks. Because I just wasn’t involved then. I think I naively presumed it was still going on. There were still feminists out there. But maybe everyone did like I did and just, you know, had a normal life. Got on with the day to day, all the demands of domestic life that get in the way.

Isabelle: Do you think that the general assumption was that things were getting better?

Emma: Well, it did seem better. Some things had improved. I remember my mum not being able to sign off on a new insurance policy that she wanted to take out — she had to wait for my dad to come home to give his permission. That kind of thing changed, and so the activism wasn’t carrying on with as much anger and in as many numbers as it was in the early ’80s. The warning signs were there in the early ’90s with all that liberal feminist, girl-power stuff, the Spice Girls and shit. It was so obvious, but we just weren’t looking at it.

Isabelle: So, what did the term ‘feminist art’ mean to you at the time? What did you think of it?

Emma: Honestly? Purple and turquoise. Organic felted vaginas. Meret Oppenheim’s furry cup and saucer …

Isabelle: I went to Leeds University, and it was politics, it was feminism, it was the Subversive Stitch, Judy Chicago’s Dinner Party. The words ‘biological essentialist’ and ‘gender’ were already being bandied about, and then it was a whole load of postmodern cobblers and word games which I declared myself against there and then, and I haven’t shifted on that. In terms of the 1970s vaginal imagery, I have shifted on that; because of this assault on reality that’s going on right now, I have a great deal more respect for the vaginal imagery than I used to. It’s going to have to be Viva La Vulva again. Maybe when we were young, looking at that imagery, we couldn’t understand why the women in the ’70s were so focused on the vagina, because their work had already had its impact on our world. In the same way that we’re wondering, “How come younger women think it’s all okay, and it’s sorted?” And we think, “Well, you’re going to find out, maybe not yet, but in a few years’ time.”

Isabelle Tracy is an artist, curator, and producer based in Hull. She studied fine art (and activism) in Leeds from 1981 to 1985.

1 Owen Jones, ‘Anti-trans zealots, know this: History will judge you,’ The Guardian, 15 December 2017.