by Paula Alice
Debra Soh, The End of Gender: Debunking the Myths About Sex and Identity in Our Society (New York: Threshold Editions, 2020), 336pp., £12.99.
It will not have escaped the notice of this magazine’s readers that over the past decade, some very strange beliefs about sex and gender have taken hold in surprisingly mainstream places. One by one, they’ve slipped from Tumblr pages and gender-studies classrooms into news outlets, schools, and the social media feeds of trusted organizations to baffle the wider public: sex is a spectrum, a colonial invention, too complex to pin down, a mere label; gender is innate, fluid, unchangeable, innumerable. Sex and gender are different—except when they aren’t. You could hardly blame a casual observer for being confused, but where to turn for the truth when respected publications, medical bodies, government agencies, and even scientific journals all seem to be prioritizing ideological concepts over truth, clarity, and evidence?
In steps Dr. Debra Soh, a Canadian sexologist and neuroscientist turned journalist, promising the straight facts about the increasingly murky topics of sex and gender. Soh has faced her own battles in the politicized field of sex research, where attempts at suppression — traditionally expected from the right, when you’re studying things like paraphilias and sexual orientation — are now coming more and more from the left, leading to a worrying climate of self-censorship. “Science denial, policy changes, mob mentality, shaming, and allegations of hate speech” are among the now-routine consequences of ideologically unapproved research that drove her out of academia, but Soh continues to speak the controversial truth, as she sees it. The End of Gender is structured around nine ‘myths’ — including ‘Biological Sex Is a Spectrum’ and ‘Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity Are Unrelated’ — which Soh promises to debunk, cutting through orthodoxy using “science and facts.” Feminists who view sex as material reality and gender primarily as a coercive social system will find themselves cheering on Soh’s takedowns and rolling their eyes in equal measure, but — as she wisely says — “You cannot know whether your perspective is correct without considering arguments against it.”
She begins with the biological basics: contrary to Twitter threads about slugs and that one headline from Nature, humans come in two sexes, male and female. Sex is defined not by chromosomes, genitals or hormones, but by gametes, of which there are only two, sperm and egg; sex, then, is binary (and no, differences of sex development and menopause aren’t proof otherwise). Not long ago, these facts were so basic as to be not worth saying, but now, even medical societies promote the fiction that sex is ‘assigned,’ and worksheets for schoolchildren ask them to identify their anatomical sex on spectrums of ‘femaleness’ and ‘maleness.’1 As Soh points out, claims about the alleged complexity of sex categories are not based on new evidence, but reverse-engineered to serve an activist goal: “the separation of sex from an objective basis in reality.”
But equally unscientific, she thinks, is the idea that gender is constructed; it too, she claims, is biologically based and binary. Soh rightly points out the slipperiness of that word, ‘gender’ — how its double-sidedness allows it to slide by with its implications unnoticed, meaning sometimes-sex, sometimes-other-than-sex — “an ephemeral, intangible thing, something that can’t quite be described or explained beyond one’s personal experience and self-identification.” Yet her own writing doesn’t quite pin down what she means by ‘gender,’ either. She avoids defining the g-word in itself, but describes gender identity as “how we feel in relation to our sex, regarding whether we feel masculine or feminine,” and gender expression as “how we express our gender through our appearance, like clothing and hairstyle choices and mannerisms.” (Both, she says, are ‘biological.’) As far as definitions of ‘gender identity’ go, that’s not the most opaque one out there, but “how we feel in relation to our sex” is open to interpretation (disliking your body? Feeling atypical for your sex? Being annoyed that your sex is the one expected to make dinner?), and not necessarily the same thing as “whether we feel masculine or feminine.” Not to mention that many of us don’t feel particularly “masculine or feminine” at all, or don’t find these helpful concepts with which to define ourselves.
At least part of what Soh means by ‘gender’ is, well, pink and blue brains. Science has proven conclusively that male and female brains are different, she writes. I’ll leave it to those more knowledgeable than I to debate the significance of amygdala size and grey-matter volume, but anyone who has read the careful and detailed work of Cordelia Fine or Gina Rippon analysing the dubious science of sexed brain differences is unlikely to be convinced by Soh’s simplistic and broad assertions. As an example of the ideologically driven denial of innate gender, Soh refers to Daphna Joel et al.’s well-publicized 2015 analysis of over 1400 brains: the study found that our brains are ‘mosaics’ of different features, some more common in males and others more common in females, with the vast majority of individuals having a mix of ‘male-end’ and ‘female-end’ features.2 Soh claims that the researchers’ conclusions were debunked by other studies showing that it was in fact possible to identify the sex of a given brain with around 70% accuracy. But, as Joel et al. wrote in their reply to these critiques, they didn’t claim that you couldn’t predict someone’s sex by looking at their brain — but rather that you couldn’t predict what their brain would look like from their sex. That is, there are differences, at a group level, between male and female brains, but brains don’t come in two distinct types in the way male and female genitalia do.3
Anyway, as Gina Rippon wrote, “a gendered world will produce a gendered brain,” so how do we know the sexed differences that have been observed are innate?4 Soh doesn’t give much weight to things like socialization and life circumstances, and dismisses neuroplasticity — the way the brain changes through experience — in two paragraphs, comparing it to trying to force a left-handed child to use her right hand: you can force someone to go against their natural instincts, but why bother? Social influences can affect the degree to which we express our innate characteristics, she says, but they don’t fundamentally change us. Instead, she turns to evolutionary psychology to explain everything from dating to cosmetic fillers to women’s lower rates of participation in STEM fields (men evolved to hunt, women to have babies and gossip, you’ve heard it before). Obstacles like sexism and harassment still exist, Soh acknowledges, and held women back in the past, but whatever social discrepancies exist today are mostly because women prefer it that way — and efforts to push them into careers that don’t interest them, or to get them to stop shaving their legs, are self-defeating.
Some of Soh’s points are responses, if misguided ones, to the failures of liberal and third-wave feminism, which have erased the importance of recognizing difference in favour of mushy notions of equality, sold self-objectification and a male-orientated version of sexuality to women as ‘sex positivity,’ and taught them it’s more important to validate their individual choices than to see them as part of larger patterns. Yet her solutions seem mostly like regression: if many women are wary of macho professions that offer little flexibility for care responsibilities, they can stick to some nice, lower-paying ‘people’ jobs—the women who really want to do the ‘manly’ jobs will persist through any obstacles. If women aren’t fulfilled by bleak hook-ups, they should try some benevolent chauvinism, waiting for the man to make the first move. If women feel judged by feminists for wearing make-up, they should keep contouring and carry on — it’s just the way evolution made them.
Soh often paints a picture of a kind of anti-gender dystopia, where women are mocked for feminine beauty practices and children’s bedrooms are decorated in joyless greige, without a doll or truck in sight. At several points I had to wonder, what world is she living in? What she describes may be a reality among a subset of educated urbanites, or in hip boutiques where baby onesies in tasteful neutrals cost as much as a week of groceries. Still, the vast majority of our culture encourages and rewards femininity in women, and in the wider world of children’s toys and clothes, it’s still a pink-and-blue, unicorn-and-robot world.
As you might guess, Soh isn’t a fan of ‘gender-neutral parenting,’ though she conflates two quite different approaches under that term. One, simply offering children a variety of toys and activities while avoiding imposing stereotypes. Two, the recent trend sometimes called ‘theybies,’ where parents refuse to call their child a boy or girl until the child is old enough to declare their ‘gender,’ likely based on whatever stereotypes they’ve managed to pick up along the way — a defeatist practice equivalent to trying to end racism by having everyone put bags over their heads. She lists bonkers examples of ‘gender neutrality’ (Planned Parenthood announcing that reproductive organs aren’t male or female) alongside benign ones (girls being given gender-neutral names like ‘Skyler’) as equal absurdities. The sillier examples do her no favours, undercutting her important points about what would be better called ‘sex erasure.’ Still, in the end, Soh’s parenting advice is no different from what most feminists would advocate: “exposing kids to a variety of activities and ways of expressing themselves that are gender-typical and atypical, without making any assumptions about their inherent interest or ability. Let boys—and girls—wear pink ball gowns or short haircuts and play with whatever toys they want.”
While Soh believes the majority of females and males fall clearly into feminine and masculine categories, she does admit the wide variation within each sex, and rejects the idea that ‘outliers’ should be classified as another sex or gender. (She considers herself among them: “Despite appearing very feminine, I am and have always been male-typical.”) According to Soh, prenatal hormones explain these differences: the amount of testosterone we’re exposed to in utero, she says, is what determines our sexual orientation, degree of masculinity or femininity, and gender typicality or atypicality. (This theory is given some support by studies on girls with congenital adrenal hyperplasia, exposed to higher prenatal testosterone, who have more ‘boy-typical’ play patterns and are more likely to be lesbian as adults.) Interestingly, she suggests that what our brain-genders are drawn to aren’t intrinsic ‘masculine’ or ‘feminine’ qualities of toys or clothes, but rather toys or clothes classified as ‘masculine’ or ‘feminine’ — that is, prenatal testosterone doesn’t predispose you to like things that happen to be coded as masculine, but to like things because they’re associated with males. If this is true, it implies a lot of flexibility to the system — couldn’t we change what we consider ‘masculine’ or ‘feminine’ over time, and perhaps even change how much we see those qualities as opposite and distinct?
Soh pushes back against the concept of non-binary gender, though she is sympathetic to those drawn to adopt other identities: “No one is saying to them, if you feel you don’t fit in, it’s okay to be a different kind of woman or a different kind of man.” She also criticizes the appropriation of traditional ‘third-genders’ (“Applying the transgender label to people who live as a third gender in these cultures is reinterpreting their way of living through a Western lens”). Lest we worry that she’s going social-constructionist on us, she clarifies, “Individuals who are considered part of a third gender are classified this way due to biological influence (specifically, prenatal testosterone exposure), not the influence of society.” But whether the origin of non-conforming behaviour is completely biological or not, it’s society that applies the gendered lens to these behaviours and offers the categories and labels that people use to explain themselves; the same person in a different time or place might be called hijra or muxe or genderqueer or simply a man. Whatever Soh’s intentions, perhaps a culture that views femininity as abnormal in men, or masculinity as abnormal in women, is more likely to encourage reclassification and identification out of manhood or womanhood.
As for ‘transgender,’ Soh defines it narrowly, based on dysphoria and medical transition rather than self-declaration. She points to the lack of solid research on ‘transgender brains’ (similarities may be explained by shared sexual orientation rather than identity), and matter-of-factly explains autogynephilia (“the number one reason why you will rarely, if ever, see sex researchers — or any expert, really — criticizing the transgender community”), but fundamentally believes adults should be free to do as they wish. On the rights conflict between transwomen and women, she tries to stake out a common-sense middle ground: while she doesn’t believe transwomen should be prohibited from women’s spaces, she bemoans the lack of “nuanced discussion” and the way “women and girls continue to be punished for holding an opposing view, leaving them little recourse.” Her ultimate solution: “If a transgender individual is in the presence of someone who appears to be uncomfortable, whether it’s in a bathroom, locker room, or shelter, let it be up to the trans person to decide what’s appropriate.” (A nice idea, but under present conditions, one that would have the effect of sorting the transwomen who respect women’s boundaries from the ones who don’t in exactly the wrong way.) About transwomen’s participation in women’s sport, perhaps the ultimate spiritual test of the gender-believer, Soh is less equanimous: “The advantages that trans women have from being born male are not just flukes bestowed from nature; they are because individuals born male belong to a different physical category than those born female.”
Soh is at her most righteously scathing on the topic of ‘trans kids,’ which first led her to speak out against the politicization of gender issues. She reviews the “irrefutable” research studies showing a majority of gender-dysphoric children resolve their feelings by puberty, and are likely to be gay or lesbian adults — a well-established and consistent finding that activists have nevertheless rebranded an anti-trans myth. Childhood sense of ‘gender identity’ is flexible, Soh writes, and “in many cases children will say they are the opposite sex because they want to do the things that the opposite sex does, and this is the only language they have to communicate this.” But in the current ‘affirmative’ climate,
parents will be praised as open-minded, examples of what true love and acceptance looks like, “on the right side of history,” when in actuality, some are homophobic and endorsing a repackaged, socially acceptable form of conversion therapy. In some cases, a child may internalize their families’ antigay sentiments, which will add to their desire to transition.
She also discusses Lisa Littman’s 2018 parental survey on ‘rapid-onset gender dysphoria,’ which suggested strong social motivators for the rise in teenage gender epiphanies, and the resulting outcry. Activists often refer to this study, too, as discredited, though a post-publication review affirmed its findings, and the pattern of teenage girls seeking escape from their sex is impossible to deny. In a heartbreaking passage about the trauma that can lead girls to want to transition, Soh quotes psychiatrist Susan Bradley:
“I saw a young person many years ago who came to the clinic with an expressed wish to be male. And after we’d done our interview, it was really clear, she had been sexually abused by a couple of boys and she felt horrible about it and she started to put on weight and started to change her appearance so that she was bigger and stronger. And she said, ‘Nobody would bother me now.’”
Soh despairs at the way young people, in her view, are being carelessly put on a medical pathway — she quotes one detransitioned woman who was prescribed testosterone at 18 after a one-hour appointment — and predicts more detransitioners, class-action lawsuits, and a painful reckoning to come. “Personally, I cannot believe this is happening,” she writes. “I have spent countless hours in discussions with colleagues, shaking my head, hoping that we’re wrong … When society looks back on this in horror — we tried to warn you.”
In spite of its flaws, this is probably the best book currently available that explains some of the problems with gender-identity ideology and activism to a broad audience. It’s accessible and free of jargon, and will help readers new to the debate to clarify their understanding, even as it will also solidify some hoary stereotypes. Soh deserves admiration for her passionate defence of children’s right to reach adulthood without their non-conformity being medicalized away; her empathy for outliers of all sorts is clear. But her outlook is ultimately a confining one for women as a whole; she can see how social factors act to pressure girls to identify out of their sex, but not how the social norms of femininity are coercive and cause suffering too, and how the reification of femininity can’t be disentangled from the desire to escape it. In a way, she has crafted her own, scientifically justified escape route: what’s the difference between ‘most women are cis, but I, clearly, am not’ and ‘most women have feminine brains, but I, clearly, do not’?
“The success of the feminist movement does not require the claim that men and women are identical,” Soh writes, and that’s true enough. But recognizing difference shouldn’t mean accepting a supposed natural order that has never benefitted women. Soh might have intended her book’s ambiguous title as a warning, but feminists will read it as a hope: it’s only when we reach the end of gender that we’ll know how different we really are.
Paula Alice is an editor, writer, and mother who lives in Canada.
1 See ‘The Gender Unicorn,’ confusing children in a classroom near you.
2 Daphna Joel et al., ‘Sex Beyond the Genitalia: The Human Brain Mosaic,’ PNAS, 112.50 (2015), doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1509654112.
3 Daphna Joel et al., ‘Reply to Del Giudice et al., Chekroud et al., and Rosenblatt,’ PNAS, 113.14 (2016), doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1600792113
4 Gina Rippon, Gender and Our Brains (New York: Penguin, 2019), p. xix.
