Issue Five

Cancel Culture and the Puritan Imagination

by Jane Clare Jones

In recent years, the theory and practice of allegedly progressive politics has undergone a radical transformation. The outlines of this shift first became evident in the early years of the last decade, with the rise of ‘call out culture,’1 a punitive authoritarian tendency that has now mushroomed into the full-blown ‘cancel culture’ we see today. The naming of this tendency is disputed and varied; options include ‘identity politics,’ ‘social justice activism,’ ‘political correctness gone mad,’ ‘the successor ideology,’2 and ‘wokeism.’ None of these labels quite does the job, and there is reason to object to all of them.

As Aisha Hashem points out on page 27, many feminists have concerns about the ‘wokeism’ label, because ‘woke’ originally derives from black American nomenclature for someone awake to the realities of structural white supremacy. Here we encounter a double-edged sword, one which is itself rather illustrative of the way radical materialist feminists find themselves pincered in this debate between two movements. On the one hand, there is something exemplary about the evolution of ‘woke’ from a term designating opposition to one axis of material structural oppression into a political tendency overwhelmingly focused on representational marginalization, empty performative gestures (often by large corporate interests), and an apparently unquenchable desire to discipline people for thought and speech crimes. On the other hand, we must remain ever attuned to the array of right-leaning political interests who are using the critique of the authoritarian overreach of ‘wokeism’ to try and put the analysis of structural oppression firmly back in its box. And that, to be clear, will include radical and materialist feminism.

Helen Pluckrose and James Lindsay’s Cynical Theories — which lays the blame for contemporary cancel culture firmly at the door of academic ‘postmodernism’/‘critical theory’ — is, I would suggest, representative of this latter impulse. Pressure of space will not allow me to here detail my many problems with their excessively flattened and frankly, shoddy, intellectual history, but the bones of my critique are this: a) there is no particular reason to attribute the “belief that society is formed of systems of power and hierarchies” specifically to ‘postmodernism,’3 when such ideas arise much earlier in the histories of social movements opposing class-, race- and sex-based inequalities; b) the political phenomenon in question only arose in the last decade, and Pluckrose and Lindsay’s narrative gives no clear explanation of why a theoretical movement which arose in the late 60s should have waited 50 years to mutate into contemporary ‘cancel culture’; c) whatever we might think about the epistemic relativism attributed to ‘postmodernism,’ it is manifestly the case that ‘wokeism’ is characterized by a form of absolutist moral and epistemic certainty which runs entirely counter to the anti-authoritarian impulse of postmodern scepticism. Which is all to say, Pluckrose and Lindsay’s account does not explain what it purports to explain, and, despite making a big song and dance about being the voice of impartial reason vis-à-vis ‘activist scholarship,’ their interest in using ‘wokeist’ overreach to dismiss of all forms of structural critique is political through and through.

A better explanation of the emergence of ‘cancel culture’ is to be found in what happens when materialist accounts of structural oppression are run through a specifically American cultural matrix, infused with the individualist and idealist legacy of American Puritanism. As Ellwood Johnson suggests in ‘Individualism and the Puritan Imagination,’ it is well established that “American individualism has its source in an individualism inherent in Protestant theology.” According to Johnson, the Calvinist heresy propagated by Jonathan Edwards’s Treatise Concerning Religious Affections “may be taken as the root statement of individualism from which has stemmed the indigenous Puritan culture in America.” Edwards’s doctrine centred on the belief in the possibility of the “purification … of the heart,” through which the individual might prepare themselves for salvation, thereby turning themselves into one of the elect. For Edwards, this process of preparation was predicated on the belief that a man’s identity was a product of his will, and in particular, of turning his will towards God. This choosing of religious faith was an entirely mental process, and the moral status of an individual flowed directly from it. That is, Johnson writes, “moral good describes only … states or acts of mind, rather than deeds themselves.” This then leads to a split which, Johnson notes, characterizes American literature and culture, in which the “spiritual world of the mind and heart” is considered “more real … than the material world,” and the individual spirit has an almost superhuman capacity, or “divine light within,” that is capable of “render[ing] truth into reality.”4

Contra Pluckrose and Lindsay, the basic claim I want to make here is that ‘wokeism’ is not explicable simply as a descendent of political traditions which understand society to be structured by material hierarchies of power, but rather, that it is an extreme deformation of structural analysis produced by a Puritan sensibility which has reinterpreted material oppression through a lens concerned principally with the moral ‘goodness’ or ‘badness’ of individual hearts or souls. One way to trace this deformation is through the fate of the much-leveraged concept of ‘privilege.’ In the context of material analysis, ‘privilege’ once usefully referred to the fact that people who occupy dominant positions in class-based systems of oppression do not have to deal with all kinds of shit that happen to people in subordinate positions. To follow the thought from Marilyn Frye’s famous essay ‘Oppression,’ structural subordination involves encountering networks of obstacles that limit your choices and life-opportunities, which people in dominant positions simply do not encounter.5 Hence the truth of the claim that ‘privilege is invisible,’ and the tendency of people in dominant class positions to dismiss the testimony of those in subordinate positions. (Here we arrive at the value of Standpoint Epistemology, although the way this has been translated by ‘wokeist’ discourse into ‘you must accept everything someone in an alleged subordinate position says about anything and if you so much as question it you are an agent of the status quo’ is another of their many distortions.)

The central role the concept of ‘privilege’ has played in the Puritan deformation of structural analysis is that it serves as a vehicle by which the happenstance of someone’s location within a system of hierarchical class-based power can be seamlessly individualized as a property of that particular person, and most importantly, as a property of the individual’s moral character or soul. From the perspective of materialist analysis, people in dominant class positions, often through no individual fault of their own, can’t see certain things by virtue of where they are positioned, and, if they care about a more just world, then have some moral responsibility to try and understand how people in subordinate positions experience things, and how they as members of a dominant class may be implicated in perpetuating oppression. In the hands of modern Puritans however, ‘privilege’ has become an avatar of ‘sin.’ It is the mark of the moral ‘badness’ — the corruption of the purity of the heart — of an individual, an inherent stain which needs to be acknowledged, ‘checked,’ and in that acknowledgement, performatively cleansed. Those who perform these public moral ablutions retain their status among the elect, while those who resist them are confirmed as sinners. It is irrelevant that we may be resisting because we think corporations spending truckloads of EDI money for their employees to self-flagellate about, say, the original sin of slavery, is a facile diversion from the task of addressing the legacy of material inequality that continues to afflict African American communities, and one that is principally about rewarding flagellants with their own moral feel-goods. Within the Puritan logic of ‘wokeism,’ the direction of the moral will, and the individual worth that follows from it, is the alpha and the omega. Material exploitation is immaterial.

There are three important consequences of this individualizing dematerialization of the analysis of structural oppression. The first is a complete flattening of any distinction between class-based material exploitation (sex, race, and class) and systems of discrimination that are not class-based material relations (e.g. heteronormativity, disability), a move which has fostered the proliferation of ‘oppressions’ applied to a wide variety of conditions which present an individual with challenges. In its original form, the ‘privilege’ that comes from membership of a dominant material class inheres in freedom from certain limits. In the ‘wokeist’ imagination, which has stripped away the material substratum of structural analysis and replaced it with the simplistic rubric of ‘privilege-as-oppression,’ any person not experiencing limits for any reason — being mentally healthy, being thin, being right-handed — is suddenly recast as the ‘privileged,’ the ‘powerful,’ and ‘the oppressor.’ That there is no class-based relation of material exploitation between righties and lefties, or thin and fat people, or indeed, between straight and gay people, is thoroughly obscured. While discrimination has material impacts on people’s lives, addressing ‘oppression’ not based in extractive class relations does not demand fundamental transformation of exploitative practices and has limited impact on corporate bottom lines. ‘Thank you very much,’ says the multi-million-pound EDI industry. ‘Would you like a rainbow lanyard with that?’

Closely connected to this phenomenon is the way that oppression has come to be seen as entirely about issues of ‘marginalization,’ ‘stigmatization,’ and ‘representation,’ rather than material extraction. The ‘privileged’ are free to move easily through the world not because they have more material resources and opportunities, but because they are not ‘marginalized,’ while the oppressed are not oppressed because they’re exploited, but because they’re ‘stigmatized.’6 This was driven home to me the other day when Judith Green contrasted the abject lack of class analysis in contemporary ‘wokeist’ politics with the common concern about ‘classism.’ Apparently, it’s fine to carry on exploiting people, paying them shit wages and subjecting them to precarious employment, just as long as you don’t have any nasty, bigoted ideas about them.

This brings us to the last, crucial consequence of the Puritan analytic: the reduction of systems of oppression to aggregations of bad ideas and attitudes. In conventional materialist analysis, social attitudes, and political ideologies, are the product of material class relations, and exist in order to reify, justify, and perpetuate those relations. In the ‘wokeist’ mind, oppression is a consequence of people being a bunch of nasty ‘bigots’ or ‘-phobes,’ and, with staggering circularity, it seems many people now believe that ‘privileged’ people hold bad, bigoted ideas simply because they are bad and privileged.7 Here the idealist individualism of the Puritan sensibility comes sharply into focus — and with it, the utterly misguided belief that oppression can only be dealt with by quasi-religious means. By hunting down those with impure hearts and minds, subjecting them to inquisition, making them recant (motherfucker), and then extracting elaborate public displays of atonement which will never be sufficient to appease the vengeful crowd, or allow you readmission to the community of the elect. There’s a reason so many of us feel like we’re live action role-playing The Crucible every day on Twitter. Puritans are the witch-hunters extraordinaire.

1 Jane Clare Jones, ‘Bad-faith justice: Ethics of the call-out,’ Sarah Ditum blog, 23 February 2014 2 ‘Successor ideology,’ Wikipedia 3 “The postmodern political principle: A belief that society is formed of systems of power and hierarchies, which decide what can be known and how.” Cynical Theories: How Activist Scholarship Made Everything About Race, Gender, and Identity—And Why This Harms Everybody (Pitchstone Publishing, 2020), p. 31. One could argue here that Pluckrose and Lindsay are only concerned with critiquing the epistemic implications of some applications of structural analysis. However, the text is littered with phrases such as: postmodern “thinkers argued that the powerful have … organized society to benefit them and perpetuate their power,” (p. 36) as if such statements are evidently absurd, and as if they meaningfully distinguish postmodernism from other forms of structural analysis, including Marxism and feminism. 4 Ellwood Johnson, ‘Individualism and the Puritan Imagination,’ American Quarterly 5 Marilyn Frye, ‘Oppression,’ in Gender Basics: Feminist Perspectives on Women and Mened. by Anne Minas (Belmont: Wadsworth, 2000). 6 It is important to note that representational marginalization should not be completely dismissed. Aisha Hashem suggests on page 35, mechanisms of hierarchical ‘othering’ brought to the fore by post-structural, postcolonial and feminist writings do play a very significant role in maintaining systems of structural oppression, by denying humanity, voice, and political agency to subjugated peoples. However, these mechanisms often exist in order to facilitate material exploitation of bodies, labour, and land. While ‘marginalization’ is psychologically and materially harmful in itself, there are significant problems in eliding the material substratum of structural analysis and allowing ‘marginalization’ or ‘stigmatization,’ to come to stand in for the entirety of the analysis of oppression. 7 It is on the basis of this circularity that ‘wokeism’ is characterized by the belief that someone’s ‘privilege’ can be automatically read off the fact that they hold a particular ‘bigoted’ belief, which can also then be automatically dismissed, because it is evidence of ‘privilege.’ Ergo, women who think humans are sexed are white, middle class etc., even when they’re not.