by Paula Alice
Andrea Long Chu, Females (London and New York: Verso, 2019), 112pp., $17.50 CAD/£7.99.
In spite of being anointed the literary world’s bright young transgender star, Andrea Long Chu is probably as unpopular among transactivists as among radical feminists. Over the last few years, the sardonic, witty writer has articulated a version of transness that sits uncomfortably alongside the sanitized, born-in-the-wrong-body pieties of the movement’s mainstream face. “I transitioned for gossip and compliments, lipstick and mascara… for Daisy Dukes, bikini tops, and all the dresses, and, my god, for the breasts,” Chu wrote in a 2018 essay. It was a claim to womanhood based not on innate identity but on desire: I want, therefore I am.
The criticism from transactivists tends to be that Chu is proving the TERFs right; the criticism from feminists is — well, come on, gossip and mascara? Still, you (or at least I) can’t help but respect Chu’s frankness: about the limitations of transition (“My New Vagina Won’t Make Me Happy,” published, masochistically, in the New York Times only days prior to Chu’s genital rearrangement surgery); about the relational nature of identity (“gender is something other people have to give you … you are not the central transit hub for meaning about yourself”); and about the entwinement of sexual desire with transness (“I have never been able to differentiate liking women from wanting to be like them”—or, in less wistful mode, “Sissy porn did make me trans”).
Females is all about desire, or maybe wishful thinking. The book’s nutty thesis: “Everyone is female, and everyone hates it.” The word “female,” of course, is not being used here in any sense that a reader without clownfish for brains might understand it. “I’ll define as female any psychic operation in which the self is sacrificed to make room for the desires of another,” Chu Humpty Dumptys. By “female,” Chu means not a biological state, or even a gendered one, but “a universal existential condition, the one and only structure of human consciousness.” (By “male,” Chu means, well, male.) “To be female,” Chu writes, “is, in every case, to become what someone else wants.”
It’s probably best not to strain too hard for logic here. (If “everyone is female,” and “to be female is to let someone else do your desiring for you,” then who, exactly, are the people doing the desiring?) Still, a reader grasping for scraps of truth might observe that Chu’s claims just about make sense if “female” is replaced with a different adjective: “vulnerable,” perhaps, or “self-abnegating,” or “masochistic.” At times Chu’s “psychic operation” sounds like an abusive relationship, or an addiction.
“But female already has a perfectly good and necessary meaning,” our reader might protest. “Why use it to mean something else entirely? And what word, then, should we use to refer to the people with uteruses and all that stuff?” Well, quite. It’s more than a little self-serving to redefine “female” as a “universal condition” when you yourself would really like to be redefined as “female.”
Still, if you overlook the gaping hole of meaninglessness at its centre, Females is a breezy, frequently entertaining read. It is not in any sense a feminist book, which Chu basically admits. Instead, it functions mostly as a strange valentine to Valerie Solanas, the SCUM Manifesto author and attempted Andy Warhol murderer — whom Chu seems to credit, or perhaps blame, for their gender transition — and as an elaborate defence of autogynephilia. Between recaps of Solanas’s raunchy play Up Your Ass, Chu touches on topics including Freud’s castration complex, the trans bombshell Gigi Gorgeous (“I envy her tremendously”), porn (“a quintessential expression of femaleness”), red pillers and The Matrix, sissy porn, Janice Raymond (“obviously a bigot” and yet “not entirely wrong”), Fight Club, more porn, and a woman who anally ingested puréed pages of Infinite Jest. (See if you notice a theme.)
Chu has a bad habit of conflating the patriarchal definition of a thing with the thing itself. For instance, here’s what Chu gets out of Catharine MacKinnon’s famous line, “Man fucks woman; subject verb object”: “To be female is to be an object — MacKinnon is right about this, I think.” A description of how sex is constructed in a male-centred society is flattened into a literal statement; MacKinnon’s only error, Chu believes, is in restricting the category of “fuckable object” to women. And then there’s the book’s most infamous line, in a passage about (guess what) sissy porn: its looping GIFs are “a kind of centrifuge for distilling the femaleness to its barest essentials—an open mouth, an expectant asshole, blank, blank eyes.” In sissy porn, “getting fucked makes you female because fucked is what a female is.”
How much does Chu really mean any of this? “Maybe I’m just projecting,” Chu writes at one point. At another, the author seems to suggest that this whole line of argument might be “commitment to a bit” — perhaps inspired by Solanas, who “would make statements not because they were accurate or provable, but simply because she wanted to.” This is writing that resists being taken entirely seriously, full of smirks and shrugs; try to engage with it and you’ve already lost.
Chu is scornful of Ray Blanchard, who coined the term autogynephilia — which might be described as the male desire to sacrifice one “self” to make room for another — but doesn’t disavow it, exactly. Rather, Chu writes, autogynephilia describes the structure of all human sexuality, and did someone mention projection? Solanas thought that weakness and passivity were fundamentally male traits, layered onto women — the stronger and cooler sex, in her view — to hide men’s own vulnerabilities. It’s the classic patriarchal trick: trapping women in a hall of funhouse mirrors, then pointing to the distorted reflections as the real thing.
“Gender transition, no matter the direction, is always a process of becoming a canvas for someone else’s fantasy,” Chu writes. But it’s notable how little any of this has to do with trans people of the actually female variety, so many of whom report transitioning at least in part as a means to escape objectifying desires. Does any of this have to do with female people at all, really? Chu reduces both sex and pregnancy to crude caricatures, where “the self is hollowed out, made into an incubator for an alien force,” leaving no room for the possibility of mutual desire that is not destructive, or for human relationships based on care and love, or for valuing maternity — which does not actually involve becoming a hollow shell for another, Russian doll-style — as a literally creative act.
Even Solanas, the ostensible muse of Females, seems to barely interest Chu beyond being a quirky character and an object of sexual fascination. (“I find Valerie extremely attractive, which probably means she never would have agreed to sleep with me,” Chu laments, incelishly.) If Chu has given any thought to the particularly female experiences that shaped Solanas — sexually abused by her father as a child, pregnant as a teenager, her son taken away from her, homeless and prostituted — it doesn’t show. Solanas “never had anything but scorn for art made by men,” Chu writes, surely with a hint of self-awareness. Troubled and erratic as she was, Solanas conceived of a world in which women were freer, larger, unconstrained. She may have written a play called Up Your Ass, but it’s Chu’s perspective that always seems to wind up there.
Paula Alice is an editor, writer, and mother who lives in Canada
