by Hannah Simpson
Moxie, dir. by Amy Poehler (Netflix, 2021).
There is an American cinema tradition that has no British equivalent: the High School Movie. These are not just coming-of-age dramas but films in which school is the centre of the action. In a straw poll, friends and I struggled to find many British ones. G. (50s) came up with St. Trinian’s, L. (40s) suggested The Inbetweeners, T. (20s) gave us Angus, Thongs and Perfect Snogging. Criminal dolly birds, men in drag, knob gags, and tit-size anxiety — all very British, but it’s not an extensive line-up. (And those of you shouting ‘Harry Potter’ have done the wrong genre homework and need to see me after class.)
So when we think of the High School Movie we’re really thinking of America. Yet we Brits know this cultural landscape so well. Perhaps because we lack a home-grown tradition, many of us went to this pop culture high school too. Molly Ringwald sat next to us. Andrew McCarthy was our crush or our beautifully louche hair goals. Sean Penn and Matthew McConaughey ate all our brownies. And our Principal was, of course, John Hughes. We know that there is an accepted cast of characters in this world: The Jock, The Stoner, The Tough Guy, The Cheerleader, The Good Girl, The New Kid, The Nerd. We know the rules of this world: The Tough Guy has a dark past but a heart of gold, The Cheerleader feels isolated by her beauty, The Jock has a secret crush on The Good Girl which can only be revealed after her makeover. Women also know the rule that this is a world run by The Boys. These are films about The Boys. Even when a girl is ostensibly the star (oh, hi again, Molly), the leading lady’s action is all about choosing The Boy, getting The Boy, kissing The Boy. They are the sun around which she revolves. There are, however, excellent outliers to this formula — Heathers, Mean Girls, Ginger Snaps — and I was excited to see another of these troublemakers appear on Netflix.
Moxie, adapted from the YA novel of the same name and directed by Amy Poehler, got me very excited indeed because it’s about a high school feminist uprising.
To begin with we’re on very familiar ground, with an unsettling opening dream sequence that only hints at rules slowly being shaken loose. Our lead, Viv (played with the requisite wide-eyed aplomb by Hadley Robinson), is a Good Girl and so is her bestie, Claudia. They encounter The New Kid, Lucy, who immediately runs into trouble with The Jock (more James Spader in Pretty in Pink than Emilio Estévez in The Breakfast Club, Patrick Schwarzenegger gives the character an oily swagger). What gets our attention is The Jock’s reaction to this New Kid challenge; her boundaries are meaningless to him. His entitlement, reinforced at every turn, is rage-inducing in its familiarity. The Jock owns the school, doesn’t she know the rules? Viv advises Lucy to keep her head down, to which Lucy responds (in a note-perfect delivery by Alycia Pascual-Peña):
“Thanks for the advice. But I’m gonna keep my head up. High.”
When Lucy is reporting The Jock’s harassment, we meet another familiar character in her school Principal: Expediency Woman. Expediency Woman is not just limited to High School Movie world; she’s known to us all. She’s been in every office I’ve ever worked in. She’s present in most families too. This is the woman who learned the rules so well she will go to almost any length to preserve them, including keeping other women quiet while she’s busy forgiving, minimizing, or appeasing even the worst of male behaviour to ensure a calm sea. Desperately preserving the status quo because she knows things can always get worse (at least for her), she’s the one-woman equivalent of villagers leaving a virgin tied to the rocks to spare their own daughters from the dragon. Britain arguably gave the world its best example in Margaret Thatcher, transforming herself into a living statue of unimpeachable respectability — The Iron Lady — while discreetly pulling up the ladder into The Boys’ Club behind her. Our Expediency Woman here, played by Marcia Gay Harden, rules the school with that same brittle, sickly-sweet ‘nice girls don’t make a fuss’ attitude, sending out the clear message that this is how you succeed as a woman. Suddenly the High School Movie world rules seem less reassuring, less safe, and now Lucy is on her own.
Meanwhile, that line about keeping your head up high has reminded Viv of a song her mother played to her when she was little, and she’s told it was ‘Rebel Girl’ by Bikini Kill. Lisa, Viv’s mom (played by director Poehler), was a Riot Grrrl. It will come as no surprise, then, that the soundtrack is joyous. Along with ‘Rebel Girl’ we have great tunes to delight those of us who remember, but also a shining introduction for younger viewers to the concept that women making rock music primarily for other women is not a novelty but an embarrassment of riches.
There are the usual teen tropes to be explored here, including a male-ally love interest (of course! It’s High School Movie world!), but it’s those generational influences the film keeps pulling us back to. Inspired by rediscovering the song, Viv goes through some of her mom’s old things and finds a Bikini Kill zine, a staple of Riot Grrrl feminism. Reading Kathleen Hanna’s feminist manifesto aloud against the backdrop of her mom watching the latest ‘Me Too’ shock waves on the evening news sets the tone for everything to come. Just as the term ‘third wave’ was coined by the daughter of a second-wave feminist, Viv’s awakening is informed by her mother’s feminist consciousness. There is a tension inherent to mother-daughter relationships — each of us trying to be our own voice, not merely an echo of our mother’s. But as we join this particular choir, each of us has a realization that, yes, our mothers faced this silencing too. Specifics of their experience cannot help but cast a long shadow across our own lives; some experience, however, is universal. There’s a moment between Viv and her love interest when she says, uncomfortably,
“you’re really looking at me”
and we get the sensation common to every generation of women, of being ever under the male gaze but rarely clearly seen. It’s at these moments of intergenerational influence and confluence that the film is most sure-footed.
There are missteps. There’s a question about dairy being bad for you which reminded me of the scene in Pride where someone asks if all lesbians are vegetarian. Being of Lisa’s vintage myself, I did wonder if I should throw open my window, like Scrooge on Christmas morning, and shout at a young person, “Are all the new feminists vegan now?” And although we do get to see women actually eating on screen in this film (baffles me how little that happens), some salad chat made me roll my eyes. Other observations about women as caretakers are handled more deftly. Fathers are absent from this; it’s the women doing the domestic and professional heavy lifting as well as the rebellion. There’s a moment when Viv has news, opens her front door, and in typical teen fashion, without preamble, just immediately begins speaking, as if all her mother does in Viv’s absence is wait, inert, for Viv to animate her life. It’s not just men who make glib assumptions about mothers.
Back at school, The List is published on social media. This is a ranking system made by The Boys to put the girls in their place. There are categories like ‘best ass,’ ‘best rack,’ ‘most bangable’ (Viv gets ‘most obedient’). This happens at the start of each school year, but this year there’s a new category. The humiliation and anger of the girl it’s ‘awarded’ to leaks through the screen. She’s been voted something which is never expressly stated but is implied in Viv and Claudia’s exchange,
“Do you think we should say something to her?”
“I don’t wanna have to say the c-word out loud!”
We never actually hear the word ‘cunt,’ and presumably this was to skirt the rating system, but it’s a device that works to startling effect because in its silence it has never seemed so loud. Aware as I am of the distaste some women have for that word, I myself am a fan and enthusiastic user. That none of the women here say it or hear it, but all feel its impact nonetheless was enough to give me a taste of why it can be so loathed. The dismissal of this by Expediency Woman as “sticks and stones” fills Viv with such a sickening sense of injustice that The Good Girl starts to rebel.
With Viv using the cut-and-paste collage techniques of her mom’s originals, new feminist zine Moxie is born. Viv, with much trepidation, leaves copies in the girls’ bathroom anonymously. As they get picked up and pored over, her questions and her anger start to spark the same in the other girls. That old truism that once you notice something you see it everywhere spreads through them like wildfire: dress-code hypocrisy, body shaming, the ever-present spectre of sexual assault that pushes the film to its denouement. The Boys’ football team is on a losing streak and the girls’ soccer team always wins, yet we all know who gets the crowds, the pep rallies and, crucially, the cash for scholarships (seen through this lens, fears about encroachment into women’s sport seem even more justified). A campaign to right this particular wrong takes shape, along with a series of other targeted protests. All coordinated by the anonymous Moxie.
Or is it? And this strikes me as the real heart and strength of this film — Moxie is anonymous; she could be any of them. The parallel with many women on social media needing anonymity due to the hefty consequences of rebellion is impossible to ignore. But more than that, Viv is not a natural leader. Instead, by making Moxie, she opens the floor for natural leaders to find their place. Lucy becomes the eloquent firebrand around whom they all rally; other girls become a voice for the disenfranchised soccer team. These young women begin to meet, to plan, to collaborate: poor girls, rich girls, black, brown, and white girls, straight girls and lesbian girls. The sporty and the bookish, the shy and the bold all holding space for each other. Here The Boys aren’t the agents of The New Kid becoming a linchpin of the group or The Cheerleader becoming a vulnerable friend; the other girls are. Suddenly the rules of the High School Movie are being subverted from within.
But in the midst of this intersectional feminist utopia, a warning note is sounded. Claudia, Viv’s Good Girl bestie (played with an immaculate delicacy and controlled, wounded frustration by Lauren Tsai — in a very capable young cast, she’s my one to watch), is getting left behind. When the girls are drawing hearts and stars on their hands as a show of solidarity, she is the only one who asks,
“Why?” “What’s the goal?”
foreshadowing deeper questions her character goes on to raise. We are suddenly brought up short by Claudia, reminding us that there are those who simply cannot afford to take a risk on empty gestures. Reminding us that intersectionality isn’t a mere social flex, a word to be thrown confetti-like at social media. Rebellion against unfair norms is not just a cool rite of passage but something vital to levelling the most uneven of playing fields, or even securing a field to play on at all. Claudia reminds us that challenging those very inequalities could put some girls in the way of issues and harms that may not even be on the radar of their peers. For Claudia it’s her mother’s immigrant experience and the differences in cultural expectations with her classmates. There’s a confrontation with Viv as these differences come to a head, where Claudia outlines Viv’s lack of understanding in the starkest of terms:
“You don’t get what’s going on with me because you’re white.”
Claudia’s relationship with her mother, although loving, is a sometimes strained one — here we see that inherent tension again and the shadow cast across Claudia’s life by her mother’s sacrifices. Generational pain is familiar subject matter between fathers and sons on film but is dealt with less often (and often less well) between mothers and daughters. It’s only hinted at here but has much wider implications. Not all of us get to be Viv; we can’t all have the coolest mom in school. Not all of us get to be Claudia either. For those of us growing up in less financially comfortable or less accepting or frankly less safe households, what may seem like small acts of rebellion to some may risk far worse consequences than just falling foul of school policy. So Claudia is also obliquely asking an uncomfortable question of Lisa’s third-wave choice feminists — is it really an empowering choice, when making it will cost some of us so much more? And what does bravery really look like in this context? It’s a moment of real power, and in an unashamedly mainstream film (with an unusually diverse female cast) it’s a point that I’ve rarely seen made with such clarity.
This is an impressively ambitious grab for new High School Movie territory, but sadly it doesn’t always work. A prime example being a character who is a wheelchair user but is so underused she feels little more than tokenistic. When we shout ‘more visibility’ I’m pretty sure we don’t just mean ‘being seen in a group shot’; like Viv, we want people “really looking.” We want awareness of the rampant ableism, sexism, racism of these tired old film tropes, but we don’t want to just end up being the ‘-ism’ illustration — flat and 2D. Surely the point of inclusion is that we are seen as a fully rounded whole beyond that? There is also an issue with the final scene. It’s important to say that this is an adaptation and the scene is lifted from the book, but a question does need to be asked about the framing of disclosure of sexual trauma as public spectacle. The aim here seems to be to bring home what happens when girls are silenced and boys are treated like demigods, and also the courage and defiance that can come through support and solidarity of other girls. That this happens in front of the whole school, however, means it doesn’t land quite right, and not only does it feel unrealistic but the way the scene then moves on from it feels clumsy. This is frustrating when we know that so often in the real world, ‘trauma story as spectacle’ seems to be the implied requirement in order for the realities of sexual assault to be acknowledged and believed (along with the need for protection from it and consequences for it). Being more charitable for a moment, it is also true that we have vanishingly few mainstream films like this one, wearing their feminism proudly, and in film, as in life, we’re all learning a new language. Clumsiness in our attempts are to be expected, and at a running time just shy of two hours, how many stories can you tell? All this does, however, jar against the overall feel of authenticity.
Some of the press reaction to Moxie has also picked up on this clumsiness, and I can’t disagree. Criticism has come as well for the film lacking the knockout cruel humour of its counterparts, with Peter Bradshaw brilliantly quipping that rather than Mean Girls this is Mutually Supportive Girls. To my mind, though, it’s this deliberate lack of cruelty or meanness among the girls that makes Moxie so different from the High School Movie pack. This isn’t high school football; there’s no captain on this team, and we’re currently witnessing the power of that mutual support in the UK’s own feminist movement, especially in its successful crowdfunding of legal challenges. In fact the reaction of the UK press to an out-and-out feminist film was interesting to see, with those two apparent opposites the Telegraph and the Guardian both giving it a paltry two-star rating. It is worth noting here that both papers thought the best judgement of a film about teenage feminist rebellion would come from two straight white men (Robbie Collin for the Telegraph and Bradshaw for the Guardian). There does also seem to be a strange British blind spot in being unable to distinguish between ‘film made by a woman with women in it’ and ‘feminist film.’ Both make unfavourable comparisons with Olivia Wilde’s Booksmart, and as much as I loved that film (and I loved that film), it’s not about a feminist awakening. At all. Similarly, comparisons with the classic Mean Girls, written by Poehler’s long-time friend and collaborator Tina Fey, do feel inevitable, because God forbid two women who know each other would make two completely different films centring the experiences of teen girls. Some cynics might even suggest that men with lofty platforms being leery of the film’s attempt at intersectional feminism while inadvertently straying into divide-and-conquer territory is precisely why we need them both.
Some of you will have young women in your lives who are starting to ask, like Lucy,
“Why should I have to ignore him? Why can’t he just not be a dick?”
This is their film, and it’s their verdict that will matter most.
My verdict? It made me nostalgic for a time when the biggest alt-rock star in the world, Kurt Cobain, made the anthem of a generation from a nascent feminist’s graffiti (and occasionally wore a dress to perform it), strange, heady days … but this film is definitely not just a nostalgia fest. Ultimately it’s a flawed but uniquely charming call to arms. It’s full of hope, it’s full of heart, and it screams ‘girls to the front!’ And even though the rousing finale might elicit another eye roll from the more jaded (who know that all the unresolved trauma and the inevitable boys’ backlash are begging for their own stories), this is still a wryly funny, brave, and timely film that deserves its place in the High School Movie roll of honour. It’s a film about women finding their voice, and it’s a film that finally lets the girls become The Girls.
Rebel Girl, Rebel Girl—Rebel Girl, still queen of my world.
Hannah Simpson lives in a council flat in a high-rise block on top of a windy hill. She works as a carer, and when she’s not doing that can be found being chased by angry geese along Black Country canal towpaths or making profanity-emblazoned knitwear. Although hated by her cat, she maintains her heart’s in the right place. She also sometimes writes.
