Issue Five

Both/And: Working With the Religious Right: What’s the Harm?

by Elizabeth Hungerford and Amy E. Sousa

‘Both/And’ is a semi-regular feature that aims to break down oppositional ‘Either/Or’ thinking in favour of the ‘Both/And’ thinking of difference and connection. It will stage contemporary feminist debates in this light, creating a space for differing and perhaps irreconcilable perspectives to co-exist. In that spirit, we are proud to present this dialogue between Elizabeth Hungerford and Amy E. Sousa in which they explore the difficult issue of whether working with organizations of the religious right can have a part to play in advancing feminist ideas or policies. The arguments made here by both women are their own views, not those of the magazine or its editors.

DEAR AMY,

Thank you for being willing to engage in this conversation about the fight for women’s sex-based spaces and political tactics. Specifically, I want to discuss the merits of working alongside organizations with conservative religious values to raise public consciousness about the conflict between sex and gender.

By way of introduction, I am politically left or progressive in American terms. As a feminist, I believe that sex matters and that one of feminism’s primary tasks is to name and illuminate women’s oppression and exploitation as a political class under capitalist patriarchy. I understand feminism as a set of ideas and values that centre women with the goal of liberating women from male violence, control, and oversight. It is therefore both a lens or way of seeing the world — through women’s eyes — and a vision for a radically different and better future for women because we value women. This woman-centred perspective and liberatory goal must be the foundation of all feminist work.

When feminists choose to partner with people and organizations whose opposition to ‘gender ideology’ depends on essentialist notions of traditional ‘family values’ and the proper role of women in relation to men, including divinely ordered heterosexuality, the difference between feminist values and Christian family values becomes invisible. Merging feminist objections with conservative Christian messages makes it difficult, perhaps impossible, for audiences to appreciate any difference in values or policy positions between feminist and conservative Christian organizations.

The very act of working together may also minimize perceived differences among the participants themselves as they unite against a common enemy. Before you know it, lifelong Democrats are voting Republican (but not vice versa)! Parties and observers on all sides may begin to feel quite justified in collapsing the two types of actors into one as they continue to orbit together, packaging up a single message or simply making the same arguments in the same places and at the same times.

Even if some people find such partnerships intriguing or amusing, many more will happily use the opportunity to dismiss feminist concerns about sex and gender as functionally equivalent to Christian gender essentialism. The practical effect is that, as the more powerful party with a widely understood theological framework, conservative Christian concerns easily take centre stage while feminist values remain in the shadows.

These are just a few of the reasons that I oppose any attempt to leverage the vastly superior resources of ‘family values’ type organizations to promote purportedly feminist policy or legal positions. I look forward to hearing your thoughts about the benefits of working with political conservatives to defend women’s right to sex-segregated spaces.

Be well,

Bess

DEAR BESS,

It’s always lovely to meet and be in conversation with other feminists. I’m excited to be having a public conversation around alliances between feminists and the right as it is one that I often engage in privately.

I was raised in a Christian Republican home. I grew up with the guidance that men are the natural heads of the household. By high school I was very uncomfortable with the gender roles taught and practised by the church. I found radical feminism in college. The critique of gender made by radical feminism seemed a perfect expression of why I was so frustrated with the strictures of my church. As to my politics, I am a registered Democrat, although currently I would say I am politically homeless as neither party expresses values that I support.

I believe we are very much in agreement in our understanding of feminism. I see feminism as an analysis of capitalist patriarchy which identifies that the root of women’s and girls’ oppression is the exploitation of female reproductive capacity by men. I am with the original ‘Women’s Libbers’ in that the goal of feminism is liberation from reproductive oppression and exploitation as well as from oppressive gender roles. In my own activism, I stress that feminism is a liberation movement, not an equality movement. We want liberation from patriarchal control, not equality within the patriarchy.

Having been raised in a religious right-wing home, I have a unique insight into their belief system. Although I departed from both the religion and the politics of my family, we still share many of the same underlying values for humanity.

My overarching belief is that right-wing/Christian organizations have much to gain from working with feminists and vice versa. When feminists and Christian organizations align, both sides are bound to receive push back from their group members for breaking barriers of their ideal value set. Feminists, rather than being fearful that they will become sullied by association, should support and applaud right-wing/Christian groups for their willingness to listen to and respect feminist voices and concerns.

If the major critique that feminists have of working with right-wing/Christian groups is that the difference between feminist and Christian values becomes invisible, then the same analysis would be true of feminist and left-wing values.

The mainstream Democratic left is the father of gender ideology. The left supports pornographers and the rights of Johns. Democrat controlled states are putting men in women’s prisons, women’s sports, and women’s shelters.1 The current mainstream left wants kids to be exposed to kink, pornography, and to be indoctrinated into the belief that sex is a social construct whereas gender identity is innate.2

Gender ideology and ‘trans’ branding, rather than being a human rights campaign or social justice cause emanating from a marginalized group seeking representation and resources, is a top-down corporate agenda flowing from the highest echelons of finance, government, media, and law, whose mission is profit driven and control oriented.

Feminists such as Jennifer Bilek,* Alix Aharon, Patrick @StillTish, and Kat @thedeprogrammerxx have documented what @thedeprogrammerxx describes as “the collusion of public, state, corporate, and private interests to make legal and social changes resulting in the termination of women’s rights, as well as issues of health and safety for children, under the guise of promoting LGBT rights.”3

Notable left-wing NGOs such as HRC, ACLU, GLAAD, and GLSEN have championed gender ideology and ‘trans rights,’ in government, education, media, and law. One of the biggest examples of this top-down leftist Democrat-driven influence comes from the highest branch of government, the executive branch. In January 2021, newly elected President Biden created Executive Order 13988 which effectively erased the category of sex and replaced it with the category of ‘gender identity.’ This order impacts all organizations and agencies that receive federal funding, including public schools.

Alix Aharon has documented what is happening in the US public school system. The partnership of Tumblr, Planned Parenthood, and GLSEN is creating a curriculum about gender.4 She observes that “they’re operating on the opioid model. They create the patient, then they create the cure.” As their forces join to push gender unicorn ‘anti-bullying’ curricula in schools, they create the concept of gender identity and then provide education about it. In short, they describe the problem and then provide the solution, which is cross-sex hormones and referrals for surgeries. As Aharon describes it, “They have a very solid business model. Because when you’re going into K-12 and you’re teaching through GLSEN, and you’re leveraging Planned Parenthood’s name in order to do that, you’re investing in your future Planned Parenthood patients, because they are the number one providers … It is grooming.”5

In view of these things, while we may not wish our message to be conflated with the values championed by the right, the left is no longer a place to call home. It is urgent that feminists use every available means at our disposal to both ensure child safeguarding and protect the sex-based provisions already in place for the safety of women and girls.

There is plenty to critique on both sides of the political spectrum. Both parties hold values that are contrary to radical feminist values. And it is up to feminists to present critiques whenever and wherever women and girls are being exploited or told their boundaries don’t matter.

Further, the left is currently deplatforming women at every opportunity. Women who speak are losing their jobs, being booted from academia, and can’t get interviews on MSNBC or CNN. If Fox News is the only major media platform giving interviews, it doesn’t behoove feminists to be so pure in their ideology as to silence themselves. If Christian orgs are giving women the platforms denied by academic conferences, then to refuse is to participate in self-silencing. The issues surrounding gender ideology need as much air, light, noise as possible. If right-wing/Christian outlets are willing to give feminists a voice, they should be applauded, rather than the feminists who dare to speak being vilified.

This is an all-hands-on-deck situation. The cult of gender ideology is teaching kids that body dissociation and self-harm are the answers to internalized sexism. The rights of women and children to boundaries around their bodies are a concern for all thinking feeling humans. We need the right as well as the left to speak out on this.

I look forward to hearing more about your thoughts.

Best to you,

Amy

DEAR AMY,

Thank you for sharing your thoughts about feminist political engagement with religious conservatives. You have given me a lot to consider and, though we may agree to disagree on most points, I think this is an increasingly urgent and important conversation for feminist women to engage in, both publicly and privately. I hope our exchange will prompt others to do the same!

I will start by agreeing that there is plenty to critique on both sides of America’s two-party political system. You list a number of harmful public policies that Democrats support, and I admit this is true. But it is critical to put these facts into the larger political context — both historically and relative to the broader cultural strategy of the religious right.

Taking a long view of political history, it’s clear that there has always been significant misogyny on the left. This is patriarchy after all; we’re swimming in it. Misogyny in the civil rights movement was a major catalyst to the rise of second wave feminism. Women were tired of making coffee for the boys and standing in the back of the room. So they held their own meetings; wrote their own journals and newsletters; built their own organizations, shelters, and festivals — some of which still survive today. The male left has never been a political home for women. No party, right or left, has ever been a true political home for women. Women’s only political home is the one we build for ourselves.

Instead of forming coalitions and sharing political messaging with conservative Christian organizations, feminists should be continuing the slow and painful work of advancing a material analysis of women’s oppression independent of the reactionary ‘family values’ crowd. We have created our own platforms before; we can do so again.

Family values is a term you probably know well but I want to be clear that I am pointing to a specific set of policies platformed by Republicans and promoted by Christian dominion theologists since at least the 1970s. ‘Family values’ represents opposition to homosexuality (and more recently, transgender identities), secular government, and women’s reproductive rights in the form of access to abortion and birth control. The policies are designed to serve the patriarchal fantasy of a Christian society made entirely of heterosexual, two-parent families. This is what I mean by the broader cultural strategy of the religious right.6

Within this worldview, conservatives know that sex matters. They know material reality, but they also believe that gender roles are divinely ordered. When religious conservatives say that sex cannot be changed and that sex-role (aka gender) non-conformity is not a medical condition, they do so using a moral framework whose authority is a patriarchal and sex-based-social-role-loving God.

Conservatives, unlike feminists, locate responsibility for perceived social ills and suffering in the individual and encourage people to change themselves in conformance with God’s vision. Liberals or leftists, on the other hand, and very much like feminists, believe that inequality, poverty, and oppression are social constructs which must be analysed and collectively deconstructed. Liberals do not perceive inequality as a consequence of God’s natural order, but as the tragic result of unnecessary abuses of power.

You argue that if feminists are concerned about feminist critique of gender becoming indistinguishable from the right’s gender conservativism, then we should also be concerned about feminist analysis being associated with a subset of misguided policies adopted by liberal Democrats. Yet feminist values, on the whole, align much more closely with leftist or progressive frameworks for understanding social structures and the institutional critiques necessary to improve them. A feminist and woman-centred worldview is more consistent with policies advanced by Democrats on issues such as abortion access, homosexual rights, worker and environmental protections, teaching ‘critical race theory,’ expanding healthcare, funding public education, immigration, prison and police reform, and many others, because these policies are informed by material analysis of inequality and opposition to oppression and domination.7 I am very happy for my feminism to be associated with these policies and the values that inform them. I cannot say the same for the ‘family values’ informing conservative and Republican policies.

In particular, I am concerned that some feminists are drifting away from a structural understanding of transgender identity into positions that are influenced by the condemnatory views of their right-wing collaborators. Transgender identity is fundamentally an attempt to understand the self in relation to others and find belonging. It is entirely foreseeable, or at least deeply understandable, that neoliberal individualism might collide with capitalist consumerism and this new kind of gender essentialism to produce a significant number of transgender identifying individuals. A feminist analysis of gender is a structural one.

It is therefore a mistake to allow feminist critiques of gender roles to slide into a conservative understanding which labels individuals within a psychiatric framework. Yet this individualist framing of transgender people and politics is embraced by many feminists who have chosen to share messaging and platforms with the religious right. In doing so, I believe that feminist values become visibly distorted. This is my greatest objection to coalition between feminists and conservatives: it leads women away from critiquing gender as a social institution that is both a primary mechanism of women’s oppression and cause of transgender pain.

Regarding deplatforming, self-censoring, and the ability to reach an audience, I believe the kind of audience matters. If we are not reaching the right audience, our purpose will be frustrated. Are we working to change hearts and minds? Or are we preaching to the converted? Is it possible that conservatives have intentionally diverted women’s attention from the true site of struggle? The religious right’s audience already rejects the legal displacement of sex by gender identity. They don’t need any convincing from feminists. When feminists are offered access to conservative audiences, feminists are not reaching people whose hearts and minds must be opened to the idea that sex matters.

The audience in need of convincing that sex matters is liberal Democrats! Radical feminists must reach the people voting in favour of the Equality Act and overextending the Supreme Court’s holding in Bostock at every opportunity.8 But while feminists talk instead to conservative audiences the people who most need to hear our critique of gender are alienated from ever learning about the very real problems with sex self-ID. This is self-censoring on a wholly different level. Feminists must acknowledge the way that liberals and Democratic decision makers — our most important audience — view feminist coalitions with conservatives and the shared messages these coalitions create. If messages do not reflect shared social values, they will not reach hearts or minds nor change the way liberals think about sex and gender.

As such, I don’t consider feminist access to conservative audiences, platforms, and resources as feminist progress, even if it does make a lot of noise.

I hope this gives you a better understanding of why I believe merging political messages and allying with organizations promoting family values not only distorts feminist values (many of which are shared by liberals or leftists) but also frustrates feminists’ ability to effectively influence liberals and Democratic decision makers.

I look forward to your reply!

Bess

DEAR BESS,

I so appreciate your thoughtful engagement. It is a pleasure to share ideas and create new radical feminist discourse with you. As you have said, although we disagree, the urgency of this conversation should not be ignored by feminists. I look forward to others continuing to build on the ideas we put forth here.

I agree that a structural critique of gender ideology is necessary. I also agree with your analysis that neoliberal values have collided with capitalist consumerism. However, although you characterize gender ideology as a ‘subset of policies’ of the progressive Democrats, this is not what I observe. Capture by gender ideology isn’t some minor faction of the left; the capture is global in its scope and invasive in its reach into every facet of public and private life. We live in an environment where parents are losing custody of their kids for not ‘affirming’ their gender beliefs, where this ideological programme is institutionalized on the federal level by executive decree of the President, and where every major corporation has a gender campaign.9 Gender ideology pervades public education, policy, and law, has been adopted in prisons, and has enshrined an ‘affirmation only’ model in the fields of medicine and psychology alike. This is not a ‘subset’: it represents the dominant cultural narrative and power structure. And this dominant structure actively vilifies, deplatforms, silences, and harasses feminists who dare critique the narrative.

Not only are radical feminists not being granted interviews in mainstream leftist media, but they are being banned from social media sites including Twitter, Facebook, YouTube, Patreon, Instagram, TikTok, Reddit, Tumblr, and even Etsy. These sites represent the global public commons of discourse. Captured left-wing organizations which formerly championed the sex-based rights of women now openly fight to erase the category of sex in language and law.

More and more, the Democratic left has aligned itself with corporate power, identity branding, and vulture capitalism. The values you ascribe to the political left seem to be Marxist values(?), which are not exemplified in the policies and practices of mainstream left-wing democrats. While Biden may be putting policies for prison reforms in place, he is also working to put incarcerated women in danger by campaigning to house men in women’s prisons. In April, the Department of Justice filed a statement of interest in the Georgia lawsuit of a man attempting to gain access into a women’s prison.10

Gay and lesbian sexual orientation is becoming erased by the TQA+++, in a wave of ‘woke’ homophobia and ‘progressive’ gay conversion therapy. Women’s ability to fight for single-sex spaces and sports is also becoming erased by policies that value men’s ‘special identity’ claims over women’s and girls’ material reality.

My point here is not to say that the right is better than the left in any moral sense, but that the left is also preaching, practising, and implementing policies that are wholly at odds with radical feminist values.

Liberal values are getting us nowhere in our analysis of institutionalized sex-based hierarchies. Radical feminism must stay radical in its approach. Lierre Keith has spoken eloquently about the difference between liberal and radical values. One main problem of left-wing progressive values is their idealist beliefs about social reality, which they believe ‘is made up of attitudes, of ideas, it’s a mental event and therefore social change happens through education, through changing people’s minds.’ In contrast, radicals are materialist. We see that society is made up of ‘concrete systems of power, not by thoughts and ideas, by material institutions.’ Radicals see that the world is not an internal ‘mental state.’11 The postmodern ideology taken up by the left which posits gender as an innate quality of humans makes the sex-based oppression women and girls face look natural or voluntary. The mental state of ‘gender cultists’ is taken as reality, and women’s physical reality is disregarded.

Because of my upbringing, I am well aware of how fundamentalist thinking functions in practice. The dominant left currently holds fundamentalist values in their beliefs about gender. Gender ideology amounts to belief in a ‘gendered soul’ that is separate from the body. Liberals are creating a doctrine that enforces in law the very sex-based stereotypes that you critique on the right. The ideologies the left pushes are just as religious as those pushed by the right.

So what is worse, the ‘family values’ crowd that acknowledges sex but attaches gender roles as natural to sexed bodies, or the ‘postmodern’ crowd that erases sex but sees gender identity as an innate quality of humans, thus making our sex-based oppression seem voluntary? Both are worse for women and girls. One sees gender as a natural expression of sex, and one sees gender expression itself as natural while erasing sex. Lierre Keith points out that “just as naturalism operates in the service of power, so does volunteerism.”12 Radical feminist values are not in alignment with the woke postmodernism now championed by the left.

Given that feminists owe no allegiance to the male-dominated left, why shouldn’t we reach out to women who feel more at home in the Republican Party? You critique ‘family values’ conservatives, but this is a small fraction of overarching right-wing politics. When you advise that feminists should organize ‘independently’ from the ‘family values’ crowd, who does that include and exclude? Many Republicans vote that way because they adhere to fiscally conservative values, advocate free market systems, and hold libertarian beliefs. There are LGB Republican organizations as well, including Log Cabin Republicans, GOProud, and the Republican Unity Coalition.

I would argue that accepting platforms on Fox News or with the Heritage Foundation is not an endorsement of the values held by those organizations; it is a strategic partnership that understands the visibility to be gained. Feminists who have taken these platforms have been given the freedom to speak as they choose without censorship.

Organizations that bring together radical feminists and Christian and Republican women, like Hands Across the Aisle, follow in a long tradition of conservative and liberal women creating alliances in order to enact political change. Women have the vote today because of complicated alliances. Notable American feminists such as Andrea Dworkin and Catharine MacKinnon also worked side by side with conservative women on issues of prostitution, pornography, and trafficking, creating alliances that instigated the successful creation of multiple laws protecting women.

I disagree with you that feminist analysis of gender ideology is being distorted by our alliances with conservatives. I think the notion that there are ‘transgender people’ is inherently anti-feminist. ‘Trans people’ only exist in the sense that there are ‘scientologist people’ or ‘flat-earther people.’ People who disbelieve reality are still people, but they are not a separate class of humans. Believing that you are ‘born in the wrong body,’ or that you can ‘feel like’ the opposite sex, is a religious belief. Believing that the locus of human identity lies in a particular set of internal organs (reproductive organs) is a religious belief. Secular religions are still religions: they constitute a way of thinking that requires belief in ‘otherworldly essences’ and disbelief in observable reality. Not only are these beliefs wrong-headed, they pose a danger to women and children who are taught to ‘trust what the stranger tells you about himself’ before trusting their own instincts.

You say that any feminist alignment with the right will distort feminist values. But whether you or I like it or not, feminist values are already distorted within liberal feminism and the mainstream left wing. As I argued earlier, the left has adopted a set of consumerist ideas which run counter to women’s material interests. We should stop attempting to fit in with a left that devalues, deplatforms, and prosecutes us for our heretical beliefs. We need to critique gender roles, gender ideology, and sex-based exploitation and oppression wherever it exists. And we should take every opportunity we can to do so. If the right provides us platforms where we are free to speak our message in our own words, we should do so. They are not attempting to censor us nor are they misrepresenting our words.

You argued that appearing on right-wing news media doesn’t allow us to reach the right kind of audience. I would remind you that half of the country constitutes the Republican right. Are none of these people the right kind of audience? Is half the country the wrong kind of audience? Fox News has a reach of over 87 million viewers, are all of them the wrong kind of audience? Our purpose is to fight on behalf of women and girls as a sex class. Currently the left is trying to legally erase our ability to do so, and they are largely succeeding. We need to rally as many people as we possibly can to our cause and legally protect our sex. Now is not the time for purity politics. If our so-called ‘opponents’ are willing to be educated by us and willing to fight on our behalf, we must not simply passively allow them to do so, we must encourage and support their efforts.

Beth Stelzer, of Save Women’s Sports, has successfully had bills proposed in 37 states because she is willing to work with Republicans and Democrats alike. This is no small feat; this is an accomplishment we should all look to as an example of how to get things done. Purity politics is not getting the job done. Working across party lines works.

Radical feminists must admit that we are in an emergency. The state of affairs is dire and women are being physically harmed. Gender is appearing in glossy advertising campaigns that follow in the footsteps of the ones made by Edward Bernays for Big Tobacco. Chomsky’s analysis is relevant here: the media and advertising “are effective and powerful ideological institutions that carry out a system supportive propaganda function, by reliance on market forces, internalized assumptions, self-censorship, without overt coercion.”13 Gender ideology constitutes a product that is being marketed and sold for profit. The supply is creating the demand and not the other way around. Gender clinics have exploded from a handful ten years ago to over 300 now. These clinics have a purpose, and it’s not altruistic: they are actively marketing dissociation and self-harm. Jennifer Bilek* has documented the profit being made by the gender industry and big pharma in The 11th Hour Blog and part of my overarching analysis has been influenced by her work. Multiple strategies are necessary, we must attack this ideology on all kinds of levels, and making alliances with the right is a useful and proven strategy in women’s rights movements.

I believe that what you are arguing for is a political position that is so pure that it is disempowering and demobilizing at a time when collective mobilization is essential. We must be willing to ‘roll up our sleeves’ and grapple with the reality of our situation. I believe that future generations will look back on this ideology as one of the most barbaric social programmes in history. We must fight this ideology and the policies it implements wherever we have ground to do so. Instead of vilifying the feminists who take the platforms they are given, we must applaud media outlets and organizations that offer radical feminists free speech. Maybe we’re rubbing off on them and not the other way around?

Thank you again for the exchange, you have continued to give me much to think about. I eagerly anticipate your response,

Amy

DEAR AMY,

Your most recent response is full of ideas and I thank you for your engagement with this difficult and complicated subject matter. As I reread our responses, I see many points of disagreement, but I also notice that we are using political terms differently.

Feminists’ ability to differentiate conservative frameworks of sex and gender from feminist values and frameworks about the same policy issues is critically important intellectual work. It cannot be neglected or skipped over because it is difficult and we are emotionally overwhelmed and desperate to change the situation for young girls. I believe that you—and many other women—have confused conservatism with feminism, as I will explain below.

First, to answer your question about who the ‘family values crowd’ includes and excludes, I am referring to people who support a specific set of public policies defined by opposition to abortion, homosexuality, and secular government. In naming Christian dominionists as the political promoters of ‘family values,’ I refer specifically to a vast network of interconnected organizations, including but not limited to: the Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF), The Heritage Foundation, the Family Policy Alliance, and Concerned Women for America. For example, ADF’s Who We Are webpage champions “generational wins that change law and culture” in five key areas including ‘Marriage and Family,’ where ADF is “ensuring the law respects God’s creative order for marriage, the family, and human sexuality.”14 This is where their opposition to transgender identity fits; it is a threat to God’s creative order and any law that recognizes or protects transgender identity must be opposed. So while social issues may not encompass all of right-wing or Republican politics, ‘family values’ underpinned by a philosophy of Christian nationalism undeniably characterizes the political agendas of the organizations that American feminists are working with—feminists representing WoLF and WHRC USA have worked with each of the named organizations.

Because they have done so, and because of the direction in which they are taking their brand of ‘radical feminist’ policy positions on sex and gender, we have a responsibility to become knowledgeable about their much more powerful political partners. It is critical for feminists to understand the political objectives of the Christian right and the trajectory of the US Republican party since the 1970s, culminating in the Trump administration and the attempted coup on 6 January 2021. There is not space here for such an overview, but this historical information is freely available.15 American feminists in particular should learn this history to appreciate the long, intensely focused political game that the ‘family values crowd’ is playing.

Because the primary organizations driving the Christian right’s political and cultural agenda were formed in the 1970s or more recently, comparisons to feminists working with conservatives in earlier historical eras are misleading. None of the feminists who came before us were being instrumentalized by a multi-million-dollar network of Christian conservatives with a clearly defined, generations-deep political agenda to maintain male supremacy over women according to their religious traditions.

Today, leaders and spokespersons from certain radical feminist organizations actively coordinate with conservatives to create shared political messages and actions including joint rallies,16 panel presentations,17 and mutual position statements.18 They also encourage their followers to intermingle and share social networks by cross posting content produced and published by conservative media outlets. By contrast, Catharine MacKinnon and Andrea Dworkin designed their own legislation and refused to applaud their conservative counterparts’ legal strategy even when it targeted a seemingly shared goal (i.e. reduction of pornographic material through greater enforcement of obscenity laws).19

There is one comparison, however, that we should not overlook, and that is the possibility of reproducing a historic split between white women and women of colour.20 Making and defending political alliances with organizations that actively oppose recognizing systemic racism and making friendly appearances on a Fox News show hosted by a known white nationalist demonstrates wilful ignorance about the racist dimensions of these chosen associations.21 This is doing business with and standing on stages set by a network of forces indistinguishable from organized white supremacy. Being willing to work, repeatedly, with these particular organizations and people deepens divisions between the millions of women of colour harmed by these ideas and the mostly white women making these ‘strategic alliances.’ If feminism is to be the political home we build for ourselves—for all women—it must be actively anti-racist. This is not purity politics; it’s just basic feminism.

I cited individualism as a fundamentally conservative value and you pointed out that many leftists also support individualism in the form of gender identity and sex work. You argue that feminist values have already been distorted in the form of liberal feminism, which embraces choosey-choice consumerism. Here, we agree. Postmodern individualism is antithetical to materialist analysis and leftist politics. My point is that where leftists adopt policies based on individual choice theory, they depart from their traditional mode of analysis. This is not a feature of leftist politics, as you suggest, but a clear distortion of it.

Similarly, radical feminists who pathologize transgender people by labelling them as delusional or narcissistic depart from feminist values and join their conservative allies in framing transgender identity as an individual failure or illness. In doing so, these feminists simultaneously appeal to and reinforce the authority of an oppressive and deeply misogynist institution: psychiatry. Feminists should not confuse biomedical explanations of behaviour with political analysis nor use the language of psychiatry to discredit transgender people (and detransitioners). We must not fall into the conservative trap of individualizing distress and appealing to patriarchal authority.

Gender dysphoria is not most usefully understood as a ‘mental illness.’ Body-based dysphoria is a reasonable and predictable response to a society strictly organized by sex-based social roles. This analysis does not require any particular position on the necessity or sufficiency of medical treatment for distress associated with so-called gender dysphoria. It simply rejects the need for psychiatric labels to describe an unhappy relation to the social constructs of gender.

Until 1973, homosexuality was listed in the DSM as a ‘mental illness,’ as gender dysphoria is today. But that’s not accurate, nor is it politically insightful. Both homosexuality and ‘gender non-conformity’ are normal variations of human diversity. Some people experience distress. Some do not. Medical intervention is not a cure, even if treatment for depression, anxiety, or other intrusive symptoms is needed. The distress, if any, associated with these normal human experiences should be understood as a social and political, not a personal, problem.22

A true feminist analysis focuses on the authoritarian nature of our role-based social structure and critiques its dehumanizing effects; it does not rely on amateur pathologizing to demonize individuals trying to escape this dysfunctional social structure in ways that are politically counterproductive. We do not know individual transgender people’s mental states any more than we know what is best for their bodies. We may be very concerned for their wellbeing; we may even be desperate to prevent a loved one from making a medical decision we are convinced she will regret. But we cannot substitute our judgement for hers. Feminist values require us to reject the condescending paternalism exemplified by Abigail Shrier’s book Irreversible Damage, published by ultraconservative Regnery Publishing. Feminist applause for this book and its sensationalized, degrading representation of the bodies of transgender people represents the uncritical embrace of conservative frameworks, often by the same feminists who participate in or support alliances with conservatives. When self-identified radical feminists embrace legal and medical paternalism towards transgender people they distort ‘radical feminism’ beyond recognition. They also alienate and insult transgender-identified females, many detransitioners, and those who love them.

You disagree that there are ‘transgender people’ on the basis that they embrace a wrong-headed and dangerous belief system. But how can you possibly know what all transgender-identifying people think or believe? Just as radical feminists reject being called ‘cis,’ we should not presume the ability to mind-read the beliefs or unstated claims of people who identify as transgender. These both represent inappropriate and unfair ideological projections. I therefore reject your assertion that acknowledging people as ‘transgender’ requires us to co-sign a regressive ‘religious’ belief system that, in fact, many transgender people do not hold.

Similarly, employing the word ‘transgender’ is not a magical spell: respectfully agreeing to use someone’s preferred pronouns or acknowledging them as a ‘transgender’ person does not transmute their biological sex. All the information the listener needs is in the word itself: ‘transgender’ properly signals a change in social identification across the gender binary. Feminists need not fear that our language will be contaminated by use of this term for it actually communicates helpful information. Unconditional rejection of the term ‘transgender’ is a form of purity politics that nests perfectly with outrage about violations of ‘God’s creative order.’

We also disagree about what constitutes a feminist approach to defending women’s sex-based rights (or more accurately, permissible single-sex classifications). I am strongly in favour of protecting women’s right to certain sex-based classifications against male intrusion on the basis of mere self-identification. Such commitment, however, does not require opposition to legal protection for transgender people in contexts where sex does not matter. I believe that framing women’s sex-based rights as fundamentally in conflict with recognition of transgender people is legally inaccurate. The legal conflict exists only where gender identity is allowed to displace sex and only in contexts where sex-based classification is legally permissible. This is the same legal position I first took over ten years ago.23

I am well aware of the polarizing political situation and brutal treatment served by transactivists to women who dare to insist that sex matters. I have had my social media accounts suspended and my employment attacked. I’ve lost friends and been repeatedly libelled. But knowing the legal problem, understanding institutional capture, and even being personally harmed do not motivate me to seek comfort and support from those who would like to deny me the right to work free from discrimination as a lesbian, the right to full legal custody of my child as a same-sex parent, and the right of millions of women to access reproductive services. The situation is urgent, but it is not more urgent than any of the other issues at stake.

If we agree that feminism requires material analysis and structural critique, then I will repeat that on the whole, feminist values are more aligned with Democratic policies on issues such as access to abortion and birth control, homosexual rights and protections, labour and environmental protection, police and prison reform, public health, public education, immigration, housing, taxing the rich, and limiting the reach of religious exemptions than they are with Republican policies on these same issues. Women’s lives are specifically shaped by the way these governmental policies play out across various social dimensions including race, economic class, and sexuality. Feminist political action must therefore reflect an understanding of women’s diverse needs and interests that goes well beyond the legal and linguistic replacement of sex with gender.

Feminists have lost this deep and broad perspective when they argue a false equivalence between liberal/Democrat/left policies and conservative/Republican/right policies, as if they can’t be meaningfully compared or judged because, at times, both are very bad. Gender identity’s social and institutional capture may be global in reach and invasive in practice, but the simple truth is that the totality of Republican policies are substantially more harmful to women, not to mention anti-feminist by design.

It serves these Republicans exceedingly well that some radical feminists are willing to take a myopic focus on transgender politics and cast it as an all-powerful emergency that eclipses every other issue. If it is an emergency, it is not one that conservatives can fix, nor one that feminists can fix by forging ‘strategic alliances’ which alienate women of colour, transgender females, Democratic voters and elected officials, and leftists generally.

The ‘right’ audience for this conversation is those who need to be convinced that sex matters. If that meant conservative Christians and Republican voters, then Fox News’s 87 million viewers might be perfect. But it’s not them. They already agree that sex matters. You say that people watching Fox News constitute an audience that may not have heard feminist arguments before. While that may be true, this audience is not hearing arguments from feminists that threaten or challenge their belief systems. There is no call on Fox News for conservative women to divorce their husbands and refuse to do the grocery shopping.

The so-called feminist arguments that these audiences hear are carefully tailored to confirm their existing beliefs about both women and transgender people. They hear that women are vulnerable and need to be protected from dangerous trans people; they hear that transgender people are predatory or mentally ill; they hear that feminists want to appeal to the state to strengthen parental rights over children. They hear validation for their own alarm and disgust about transgender people’s bodies; they hear conspiratorial beliefs about the pharmaceutical industry actually creating, rather than merely capitalizing on, the recent explosion in transgender identities. All of this is put forth by women who may (or may not) identify as radical feminists but have willingly embraced these conservative frameworks in exchange for airtime.

Earlier this year, Kara Dansky promoted by name, on Fox News,24 the research of a woman you also mention, Jennifer Bilek,* who has suggested to her followers that they might want to explore Keith Woods’s ideas about the “Jewish aspect” of the intersection between transgenderism and transhumanism because she finds it “fascinating.”25 Being appalled by this antisemitism isn’t purity politics, it’s just a necessary recognition that some women’s associations with conservatism have taken a seriously wrong turn.

You conclude your response by saying ‘Maybe we [radical feminists] are rubbing off on them [conservatives] and not the other way around.’ When feminists first started allying with conservatives, I also took a ‘hey, wait and see, maybe it won’t be so bad’ approach.26 Unfortunately, the shared messaging developed by these strange political friends over the past several years has consistently failed to deliver a feminist message.27 Continuous close association with more powerful political partners has overshadowed and warped feminist analysis, bending it unacceptably towards conservatism.

Following their success in weaponizing same-sex marriage, Republicans have spent the past few years developing a well-documented strategy to leverage the conflict between sex and gender as a political wedge issue.28 They have invited some feminists to join them as a means of putting a bipartisan gloss over their patriarchal ‘family values’ while simultaneously exploiting divisions among liberals and leftists to their own political advantage. Some radical feminists are playing into this strategy with no regard for the collateral damage: as I stated in my first message, many lifelong Democrats were successfully persuaded to vote Republican in 2020 (even for Trump!) over this single issue. Feminist ideas are not rubbing off on them, but the opposite.

To take a well-known example, instead of arguing that transgender people should be protected from discriminatory firings, WoLF chose to support a defendant represented by their previous political partner ADF. Harris Funeral Homes had fired a long-time employee for merely expressing an intent to socially transition. A feminist analysis of this situation would acknowledge that transgender people deserve to work free from discriminatory firings and that Harris Funeral Homes’ decision was unjust. Yet WoLF chose to side with ADF. This is conservatism dressed up as radical feminism.

In another example, you say Beth Stelzer “has successfully had bills proposed in 37 states” and that “this is an accomplishment we should all look to as an example of how to get things done.” Yet this is a misstatement of how the political process works. Stelzer didn’t write those bills and she is not a legislator who has the elected power to propose them. These legislative proposals would be advanced by Republican law makers like Florida governor Ron DeSantis with or without the support of radical feminists—and I don’t believe that Stelzer describes herself as a feminist, let alone a radical one. When women count Republican successes as their own, they overstate feminist influence while failing to acknowledge the conservativism embedded in these political proposals.

Deeper analysis of state-level legislation to ‘save women’s sports’ reveals conservative, not feminist, values. Instead of requiring routine sex-verification as a mandatory entrance requirement at the beginning of each season, many of the statutes (following the Idaho model championed by WoLF) create an invasive dispute process that allows students’ sex status to be interrogated during the sporting season.29 As many liberals and at least one high profile lawsuit filed by the ACLU have complained, this dispute process predictably creates the opportunity to disruptively target gender-non-conforming students as a means of harassment after the team has been assembled.30 The law should be revised to mitigate against this foreseeable disadvantage to gender-non-conforming children, but feminist influence has not been sufficient to tweak the Republicans’ favoured statutory structure. The conservative and more powerful side of the ‘strategic alliance’ is either not being counselled by radical feminists about this problem or they refuse to take such counsel. Either way, feminists are clearly not rubbing off on conservatives.

Additionally, many ‘save women’s sports’ statutes overreach the harm identified by a feminist legal analysis (i.e. safety and fairness) by requiring non-competitive club and intramural sports to be designated exclusively by sex,31 while other bills apply to elementary school aged children who have yet to experience pubertal differentiation.32 Several Republican-sponsored bills introduced during the 2020 legislative season even prohibited females from playing on male teams, despite the fact that Title IX regulations make explicit allowance for this in cases where a comparable female team is not available.33 When ‘saving women’s sports’ means legally prohibiting any co-ed sports—even for small children or non-competitive activities—these laws overreach the actual harm caused to girls and women. This is because the Republican-designed statutes reflect the Christian value of strict sex separation, rather than the feminist value of sex separation only when supported by evidence of harm to female humans. Again, feminists working with conservative lawmakers have either failed to identify this as an overreach or have failed to influence their Republican allies to adjust their legislative schemes accordingly.

I therefore found it quite shocking to read that you think “we must not simply passively allow them to [fight for sex-based rights], we must encourage and support their efforts.” Women have no obligation to feel gratitude for, nor to encourage the efforts of people whose long game is to enforce their God’s patriarchal order on our female bodies. I will not stand by your ‘family values’ man. He is misogynist, racist, and homophobic. Perhaps he makes you feel listened to and takes you out to network with his well-connected friends, but he is not nice to other women. His attention, resources, and political manipulations are destructive to true feminist consciousness and solidarity.

Women’s political home can and must be feminism. We must build this feminist home ourselves, as women in the UK have done and are still doing. This is a much better example of whom to applaud and how to get things done. I’m very proud that our conversation here, in the fifth issue of THE RADICAL NOTION, will be a small contribution to their work of (re)building women’s political home. We have much more of this independent construction work to do in the US.

Unfortunately, some women have allowed their perception of an urgent problem to lead them into an ill-advised alliance with more powerful partners who promised unparalleled political access. This has prevented coalition building with other groups and revealed a widespread inability to differentiate feminist values and concerns about sex and gender from conservative perspectives.

As I have argued here, a true feminist analysis does not pathologize transgender people, it remains focused on structural critique of sex-based social roles. A true feminist analysis does not misrepresent respectful acknowledgement of trans people’s existence and their legal protection from discrimination as an inherent threat to women’s rights, it seeks to protect transgender people and women at the same time while never losing sight of when and why sex matters. A true feminist analysis does not applaud the conservative crutch of paternalism or the use of the state to prohibit medical transition; it understands that destabilizing sex-based social roles and making authentic resistance possible is the only way to curb the superficial resistance of changing individual bodies to serve a gendered fantasy.

Generational feminist change requires the long, slow, and hard work of building trust with a deep and wide coalition of people who share our commitment to material structural analysis, including anti-racism. The hasty decision of some feminists to ally with the ‘family values’ crowd is not part of, but has become yet another obstacle to, this work.

Thank you again for engaging with these complicated and politically volatile issues. We may not have come to any closer agreement in the process, but I am grateful for the opportunity to carefully consider my arguments. I hope our conversation inspires others to think more deeply about political frameworks, feminist values, and the true strategic worth of making alliances with conservative Christian nationalists.

I look forward to your final thoughts and wish you well!

Bess

DEAR BESS,

Thank you for clarifying your terms and bringing more nuance into this discussion. Although we greatly disagree, I remain enthusiastic that our public conversation will help expand feminist critique on this matter.

In light of defining terms, I want to dig into the term ‘trans people’ itself. 

First, I simply do not know who the term ‘trans people’ explicitly refers to. It means various things at various times to various people. The term has no discrete meaning. It’s not a scientifically verified category with any distinctive physical or psychological criteria. When you refer to ‘trans people,’ you could be talking about any number of different self-ascribed identities claimed for any number of reasons. You could be talking about those with body dysphoria or autogynephilia, those with internalized homophobia, or celebrities claiming niche identities like agender, non-binary, libragender, demi-boy, maverique, neutrois gender, or any of the other hundreds of special identities which fall under the ‘trans umbrella.’ 

That umbrella covers people as diverse as Grace Lavery (who claims that “being treated like shit by shit men … feels like affirmation itself, like a cry of delight from the deepest cavern of my breast”), Caitlyn (‘the hardest thing about being a woman is figuring out what to wear’) Jenner, and the clearly heterosexual Lily Cole, who gallingly stated in an interview for Them. magazine, “If I were living in another country today, my queerness would be a crime.” It also, heartbreakingly, covers the young boys groomed by their parents to hate their bodies, like Kai Shappley, who was featured in the documentary series Trans in America. In the ACLU documentary, Kai’s mother is recorded as saying, “I remember thinking even before Kai was 3, this kid might be gay and I thought that cannot happen … We started praying fervently. Prayers turned into googling conversion therapy, and how can we implement these techniques at home to make Kai not be like this. Putting her in timeout for acting like a girl, for stealing girl toys. Spanking her, really spanking her, every time she said ‘Mommy, you know I’m a girl.’” The ‘born in the wrong body’ narrative teaches dissociation, disembodiment, and dismemberment as a solution to parental homophobia.

I agree with you that ‘trans identity’ is inextricably entangled with gender stereotyping. The very notion that there is such a thing as a ‘woman identity’ is extreme sexism. It is exactly the kind of sex-based stereotypes projected onto human bodies that feminists have been fighting against for centuries. That’s why I say that the use of gender jargon, including preferred pronouns and the word ‘transgender,’ are not benign and come at the direct expense of safeguarding for women and children. Participating in a dogma that promotes such regressive notions of women and men causes direct harm to the fully embodied humanity of us all.

When men claim to ‘feel like a woman,’ we must thoroughly question what that means. There is no such thing as ‘woman feelings,’ because all emotions are available to all humans. The only ‘feelings’ that pertain to women are the physical sensations of the female body. Whatever ‘feelings’ men have in regards to their body dissociation, dysphoria, internalized homophobia, or fetishization they are having a uniquely male experience that is unrelated to the experience of existing in a female body. 

Therefore, a man holding the ‘special identity’ of ‘woman gender’ is a concept that makes no difference to our embodied responses, instincts, and intuition. Sex recognition is a survival instinct embedded into all mammals. Any movement that encourages women and children to distrust their own instincts by engaging in wrong-sex pronouns is a predatory movement. Women deserve to be able to accurately name the members of the oppressor class, to name the agents of the violence committed against us, and to be able to name our direct sensory responses without having to mentally analyse a man’s psychological reasons for his style choices. 

When you ask me, “how can you possibly know what all transgender-identifying people think or believe?” the answer is, I can’t know what people who make special identity claims through a process of self-declaration think or believe. I don’t care what people who make special identity claims think or believe, because they are all men/women, girls/boys. I don’t care about their identity claims surrounding gender any more than I care about their identity claims about their religion, passions, horoscopes, or Myers-Briggs assessments. 

I don’t agree that we are unhelpfully ‘demonizing’ ‘trans people’ when we observe the direct cultural impact of coerced language and men’s behaviour on women and children. You also say that to characterize those claiming special identities as ‘mentally ill,’ ‘delusional,’ or ‘narcissistic’ is similar to the ‘pathologizing’ that lesbians faced in the past for their sexual orientation. But the situation is entirely different. Unlike the term ‘trans people’ the term lesbian has a discrete definition: a woman or girl sexually oriented to other women and girls. The word lesbian can be meaningfully defined. 

Individuals who are suffering from body dysphoria, or individuals who are non-conforming to societal sex-role stereotypes already have the same rights as all men and women. They are not lacking any rights, nor do they require special rights. They have access to all human rights under existing laws.

The truth is, there are no special categories of humans who are more or less embodied. We are all fully embodied whole human beings. And the notion that a particular set of internal organs is specially related to human identity is a backwards sexist notion which only perpetuates harm to us all. The whole category of ‘trans’ is objectifying human sex. There is no third sex, no sex spectrum, and no ‘transgender’ people. The word is driven into the lexicon and into laws by institutions that have an investment in this issue.

While I appreciate the distinction you are making between conservatism and feminism, I still think it behooves feminists to utilize every available strategy, tactic, and tool in our arsenal in the fight to protect the sex-based rights of women and girls. When WoLF and WHRC have accepted platforms to speak publicly at Heritage Foundation or ADF the direct impact has been to spread awareness, garner publicity, and rally to action many who were formerly unaware of the massive organized assault that gender ideology and the attached industry pose to our sex-based provisions.

We could spend time arguing who is worse for women, Trump or Biden. You have presented a solid case against Trump, however Biden is the one who has effectively erased women’s ability to organize as a sex class under the law. In many ways, both these presidents and the political parties they front are beside the point. While voters had a choice to vote for either Trump or Biden, there was effectively no way not to vote for Tumblr, Planned Parenthood, ACLU, HRC, Dentons, Stryker Foundation, Arcus Foundation, and all the corporations profiting off of so-called ‘gender medicine.’ 

I don’t defend the right because I am deeply aligned with their position; it’s simply that I see no political agencies or organizations on the left who are standing up. The political democratic left is entirely captured by the notions of progressivism, inclusivity, and diversity in a way which turns women from a sex class able to organize on the basis of shared biology into an identity class open to all sexes, who can only organize on the basis of … it’s not even clearly defined … feminine stereotypes?

Perhaps it was a stretch to compare the alliances of historical feminists with feminists today, but I maintain that alliances are strategically useful when fighting an ideology pushed into language and law from the top down by highly financed corporations, lobbyists, and NGOs. The juggernaut we are facing is already out of control. To face it is beyond the capacity of individual feminist organizations whose annual donations amount to mere pennies when compared to the billions of dollars being made by the gender industry.

It is all well and good to say that the values of feminism are more aligned with certain Democratic policies, but it is the values of the Democratic party that are directly attacking the existing sex-based provisions of women and girls and degrading child safeguarding practices. So while I don’t argue in favour of Republican values, I do argue that we must utilize every available resource to confront a political party that is saturated by an ideology which literally works to erase the word ‘woman’ from public discourse. Frankly, I feel no love for either party, nor do I feel included in the values that either party promotes. My values are pro-women-and-children, and my strategy is to take advantage of money, media, and policy-making opportunities as they arise.

I personally know and have worked with Beth Stelzer. While she may not have publicly declared herself a feminist, she regularly supports feminist actions and her work could certainly be described as feminist-aligned. While you’re right that the bills she has testified on behalf of were proposed by Republican legislators, why should these law makers not be supported when their bills directly protect women and girls and our existing sex-based provisions? Beth has been instrumental in helping this legislation pass, so while it is not her sole victory, she is due credit for her participation and activism in this area.

Regarding the Hecox v. Little case, while no one wants to see non-conforming kids unnecessarily targeted, I believe the physical safety of women and girls in sports is paramount. I’m sorry that some individuals have had their birth certificates altered thus rendering them an ineffective means of verifying sex. But there are other non-invasive methods available. In her book Unsporting, Linda Blade lays out the history of biological verification in women’s sports, including such methods as check swabs. The question here is one of valuing girls’ overall physical safety. Hecox and other non-conforming boys have always been welcome to play on the boys’ team. Sex-based teams have always been open to gender-non-conforming kids. What concerns me is: why was safeguarding of girls not a priority in the first place? Why were girls forced to go against their own eyes and senses, accept a boy on their team and as a competitor, and be compelled to call him a girl? Where were the school officials and parents when this was happening? I feel for all the girls who were groomed and gaslit by the adults around them. The massive violation of their sensory embodied responses is horrific.

While you critique Save Women’s Sports, I see no argument for any occasion in which girls should be forced to pretend that boys are girls. Mixed-sex teams exist, and boys who wish to compete alongside girls are always welcome to join a mixed-sex team. But wherever single-sex teams exist, the bodily integrity of girls and their right to name reality accurately must be upheld. 

Neither political side has an agenda which is supported by feminist values. Participation with either side has its pluses and minuses. But as we grapple under a corporate ideology which profits from harm to children, sex denial, boundary violation, and female erasure, we must not daintily stand around our meagrely financed feminist non-profits and wait for institutional change to happen by way of Democratic-led politicians and organizations because they ‘look better’ to those already captured by a destructive ideology.

We simply do not have the time to do the “long, slow” work to create “generational” change. We are at war and we are losing. The fight for bodily autonomy requires that women be recognized as a sex class. The push to dehumanize women from our fully embodied humanity as adult female humans into a ‘special identity’ category that men can self-declare at will has lost us all ground to organize as a sex. We can’t organize and fight sexism if we are erased as a class of humans who have the trait sex in common!

Now is the time to think better faster. Rather than ‘aligning’ with the right, we are utilizing the right, their existing platforms, their money, and their audience to spread awareness and legally fight for the sex-based rights of women and girls.

Thank you again for your continued conversation. May this debate that we have opened be furthered and deepened by other feminists.

Best to you,

Amy

Elizabeth Hungerford is a feminist, lesbian, and non-practising attorney living in Massachusetts. She has a particular interest in the legal replacement of sex with gender identity and is a contributor to the anthology Female Erasure: What You Need to Know About Gender Politics’ War on Women, the Female Sex and Human Rights. She enjoys yoga, laughing, complaining, swimming, vintage charm, other people’s art, and being at home with her chosen family.

Amy E. Sousa (@KnownHeretic) is a writer, lecturer, and producer of radical feminist content. This year she was a co-founder of WomenPicketDC, the rally to protest Biden’s 2021 Executive Order on ‘gender.’ Her feminist activism includes testifying to state legislatures on behalf of Save Women’s Sports, speaking at feminist retreats, and participating in protests against child gender clinics. Before her feminist activism, she spent 20 years in theatre education. She was an Education Director at a WA regional theatre as well as a teaching artist in the NYC public school system. Sousa holds a BFA from New York University and an MA and PhD-ABD in Depth Psychology from Pacifica Graduate Institute.

* Editors’ note: THE RADICAL NOTION is aware that Jennifer Bilek has suggested a link between Judaism and a ‘transgender/transhumanist agenda’ and has shared material from antisemitic sources. We wish to make it clear that we do not agree with this perspective. 1 Adam Beam, ‘California will house transgender inmates by gender identity,’ AP News, 26 September 2020,; Wyatt Ronan, ‘A historic week for transgender athletes at the Tokyo Olympics,’ Human Rights Campaign, 2 August 2021. 2 Lauren Rowello, ‘Yes, kink belongs at pride. And I want my kids to see it,’ Washington Post, 29 June 2021. 3 Isabella, ‘Exposing the trans agenda w/TheDeprogrammerXX—part 1,’ Whose Body Is It, YouTube, 27 September 2021, 4 GLSEN, ‘Supporting trans and gnc students,’ GLSEN.org, . 5 Jon Uhler and Alix Aharon, ‘The dark reality behind transgender medicine (part 1),’ YouTube, 19 September 2021. 6 Stephanie McCrummen, ‘An American kingdom,’ Washington Post, 11 July 2021; Katelyn Burns, ‘One nation under God, even if you don’t want to be,’ The Outline, 27 August 2019. 7 Lauren-Brooke Eisen, ‘Breaking down Biden’s order to eliminate DOJ private prison contracts,’ The Brennan Center, 27 August 2021; Office of Public Affairs, ‘Department of Justice announces department-wide policy on chokeholds and ‘no-knock’ entries,’ Department of Justice, 14 September 2021; The White House, ‘Fact sheet: Biden-⁠Harris Administration lowers health care costs,’ White House Briefing Room, 10 August 2021. 8 For discussion of Bostock v. Clayton County, see pp. 88-91. 9 Jen Christensen, ‘Judge gives grandparents custody of Ohio transgender teen,’ CNN, 16 February 2018; Katelyn Burns, ‘What the battle over a 7-year-old trans girl could mean for families nationwide,’ Vox, 11 November 2019. 10 Ashley Diamond v. Timothy Ward, Case No. 5:20-cv-00453-MTT, U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Georgia Macon Division, Center for Constitutional Rights. 11 Lierre Keith, ‘RadFems respond, 2014,’ Women’s Liberation Front, YouTube, 28 May 2014. 12 Keith. 13 Noam Chomsky and Edward S. Herman, Manufacturing Consent (New York, NY: Pantheon Books), p. 306. 14 Alliance Defending Freedom, ‘About Us,’. 15 John Newsinger, ‘The Christian right, the Republican party and Donald Trump,’ International Socialism: A Quarterly Review of Socialist Theory, 10 January 2020, 16 Toni DeLancey, ‘Concerned Women for America partners with Women’s Liberation Front to stand up for women and girls,’ Concerned Women for America, 8 October 2019. 17 The inequality of the Equality Act: Concerns from the left,’ The Heritage Foundation, YouTube, 28 January 2019. 18 Natasha Chart and Penny Nance, ‘Feminists, conservatives join forces to oppose “Equality Act,”’ Real Clear Politics, 6 May 2019, . 19 Whittier, Nancy, ‘Rethinking coalitions: Anti-pornography feminists, conservatives, and relationships between collaborative adversarial movements,’ Social Problems, 61 (2014), 75-193, doi:10.1525/sp.2014.12151. 20 Ta-Nehisi Coates, ‘The great schism,’ The Atlantic Magazine, 18 October 2011, . 21 ‘Stand against racist critical race theory,’ Concerned Women for America, 2021; ‘Critical race theory,’ Family Policy Alliance, 5 August 2021; Heritage Explains, ‘How to identify critical race theory,’ The Heritage Foundation, 2021; David Smith, ‘How Tucker Carlson and the far right embraced Hungary’s authoritarian leader,’ The Observer, 7 August 2021. 22 M. N. Lafrance and S. McKenzie-Mohr, ‘The DSM and Its Lure of Legitimacy,’ Feminism & Psychology, 23.1 (2013), 119-40. 23 Cathy Brennan and Elizabeth Hungerford, ‘2011 letter to the UN on “gender identity” legislation,’ Sex Matters. 24 Kara Dansky, ‘Women’s rights groups join bipartisan outrage at Biden order,’ Tucker Carlson, Fox News, 23 January 2021, . 25 Content Note: antisemitism. We’re providing this link because we think it is important to evidence this allegation; we would advise readers that some of the content here may be disturbing. Jennifer Bilek, Facebook post, Webcache, 27 January 2021. 26 Elizabeth Hungerford, ‘Bad things and very bad things: Feminists working with the religious right,’ Sex Matters, 5 February 2020, . 27 ‘Family Policy Alliance & unique coalition launch first-ever parent guide on transgender issues,’ Family Policy Alliance, October 2018. 28 Gabby Orr, ‘The wedge issue that’s dividing Trumpworld,’ Politico, 8 July 2020,   29 ‘WoLF submits Amicus Brief in Idaho fairness in women’s sports case,’ Women’s Liberation Front, 20 November 2020. 30 ‘Hecox v. Little,’ ACLU.org, 13 October 2021. 31 See Florida Senate Bill 1028. 32 See Montana House Bill 112, ‘Require interscholastic athletes to participate under sex assigned at birth,’ LegiScan,  and ‘Testimony of Vajra Ma, Chair, Women’s Human Rights Campaign USA’ in support of House Bill 112. 33 ‘Subpart D—Discrimination on the basis of sex in education programs or activities prohibited: 34 CFR § 106.41 Athletics,’ Legal Information Institute, Cornell University Law School. 34 Linda Blade and Barbara Kay, Unsporting: How Trans Activism and Science Denial Are Destroying Sport (Toronto: Rebel News Network, 2021), p. 77.