We play and know that we play, so we must be more than merely rational beings, for play is irrational.1
Play has little to do with innocence and is not limited to children. Johan Huizinga, who was perhaps the first dedicated play theorist, understood play as fundamental to human culture and dependent on its limitations in space and time; play emerges and persists in relation to limits or bounds. Subsequent play theorists, including Roger Caillois, who articulated the tension and relationship between flippant or anarchic play and rule-bound games, expanded this argument, and created a conceptual bridge to Jacques Derrida’s notion of play, or freeplay, as the “wriggle room” in relation to a central, holding principle of a structure.2 The greater the hold of the centre, the less freeplay; when the central presence or holding idea has a less total hold, freeplay — perhaps usefully thought through the lens of the mechanic or engineer, who might use the term “play” to describe a lack of rigidity in the relation between moving parts—increases.
Play as a mode of human expression (from writing, plastic arts and music or dance, to flirtation and amorous exploits) occurs in relation to the limitations presented by boundaries or structure. It makes art possible, and it is also that which makes play pleasurable, or even bearable. Imagine a party that never ends, with inebriated guests who never sober up or go home; normality never resumes, and you never get to brush your teeth and go to bed. Or worse, you are at the mercy of someone else’s idea of never-ending fun, and you cannot leave. You have no power over the direction of events, and you cannot predict which way they will turn. Your host is starting to act ever more unhinged, and you start fearing for your safety and sanity. This is not play, it is madness or worse: tyranny.
The value of play beyond pleasure lies in the articulation of adaptation and mutation, some of which might renegotiate the possibility space and become incorporated into that which is known or fixed. This emphasizes the idea of negotiation: the connective tissue between play and its limits. This is an intrinsic feature of play; we cannot play if it is decoupled from that in relation to which its subversive, disruptive or flippant codes are formed. Its meaning derives from the tension that is created as it pushes off and twists away from the structure within which it takes place, echoing the root meaning of “kink”; to bend or twist. Its hedonic value derives from the twisting itself; if you shift or loosen the structure, the specific expression of that form of play will also shift. Boundaries fulfil the same role in relation to transgression. Those who find their pleasure in transgression depend on the structures and boundaries that make their play transgressive. Play exists and can only exist in relation to that which holds; the destruction of structure will destroy play, and a cultural climate where bounds and structures are challenged simply by virtue of being limits will also be destructive to play.
Sheila Jeffreys writes of the pleasure of the powerful, “who can imagine themselves deliciously naughty. It depends upon the maintenance of conventional morality.”3 Actual change is not the intention; “There would be nothing to outrage, and the delicious naughtiness would vanish, if serious social change took place.” In the second part of the paragraph, Jeffreys discusses how one man’s play is the tyranny of another by way of unequal power. The freeplay or wriggle room of one is the imposition or oppression of the other. If mutual, or ethical play is to be possible, there must be a shared recognition, appreciation and negotiation of boundaries. Fundamentally emergent, such negotiation cannot be prescribed, but its conditions of possibility may be created by mutual recognition of difference, situational awareness and open-handed invitation. Without this, the advance or progression of one actor, however playful their intentions, becomes the transgression of another.
The boundaries with another are where we might find and generate play; transgression without mutual and emergent negotiation produces tyranny and oppression. What’s worse, the powerful, who are in a position to frame and contain the consequences of imposition within bounds that they determine, will be the last ones to recognize their part in oppression and the destruction of play.
Blob. Vive la différence. Le Blob, @tryingattimes.
1 Johan Huizinga, Homo Ludens (London: Routledge, 1946), p. 4.
2 Roger Caillois, Man, Play and Games (University of Illinois Press, 1961); Jacques Derrida, Writing and Difference, trans. by Alan Bass (London: Routledge, 1966).
3 Sheila Jeffreys, Unpacking Queer Politics (Cambridge: Polity, 2003), p. 43.