Issue Four

“Avoid ‘Feminism’”: Swimming Against the Tide in Academia

by Cassandra Adaryn

My friend and I are in the park, sitting under a tree. It is 2017 so the sun is shining and no one is wearing a mask or being careful not to touch their friends. However, I am about to detonate a conversational bomb that I have no idea exists.

“The interesting thing is,” I muse, nonchalantly, “when Ludovic in Ma vie en rose finally does get to wear girls’ clothes, he doesn’t really dress like a little girl. He wears lipstick. What seven-year-old female child does that normally? He wears a pink, froufrou-ish dress. All the little girls I know wear jeans and T-shirts. He’s not dressing like a seven-year-old girl, but like a caricature of ‘female’ … like drag, I guess.” There is a silence, but we are relaxing in the sunshine so I think nothing of it. Then I hear her stand up and I open my eyes.

“Aren’t you worried about how you sound?” she says.

“How I sound?” I am confused.

This is the start of a short, painful discussion. At the end of which she says: “You are very behind the times. When a male person realizes they are female on the inside, they become female.”

“They become female? How do you mean, ‘become’? What about changing rooms?” I say. “Surely they would need to have some sort of operation or take hormones or something before they use women’s spaces?”

“They may not want to do that!” she sputters, obviously exasperated. “You want to control what drugs they take or what operations they have? Who made you the gatekeeper?!”

I can see we are heading for the rocks, but I still want to push it because I am sure I must be right, and because I can never resist pushing things to their inevitable end.

“But, if they’ve had no hormones or operations … aren’t they still really … men?”

Boom. The bomb drops.

I don’t know quite how bad it is going to be, but I have an inkling. My great friend, my lovely bestie, whom I can talk to about anything, looks me in the eyes.

“I find your views disgusting,” she utters, quietly, and walks out of my life.

As part of the final year of my degree, we are asked to write an essay critiquing the work of an academic of our choice. I choose Judith Butler. The week before, during a seminar, our tutor had told us: “I met Judith Butler once, at a conference. Well …” she smiled wistfully, “not met. I stood near her while she shook hands with some other academics. I so wanted to go and say hello, but I was too shy in the end … you know … it’s Judith Butler!”

It’s hard to convey her uncharacteristic girlishness with just her words, but it reminds me of how my mum used to talk about Billy Bragg. It is awe.

I write an essay called ‘Is Judith Butler a feminist?’ Here is a bit of it:

Having read much of Judith Butler’s work, I sense a bias. It is not so noticeable in Butler’s texts, which, notoriously hard to understand, are like walking through a densely packed forest with no path: one rarely sees the light of day, but blames oneself for not understanding the map. When interviewed, Butler’s bias is more obvious. When asked in an interview about the potential risks to women of having natal males in their women-only spaces, Butler replied:

If she [J. K. Rowling] really thinks that by virtue of having a penis … the presence of the penis is a threat, then I think she should perhaps rethink her ideas about anatomy, because I know a whole lot of people with penises who never threatened anybody. And most trans women who continue to have penises are precisely stepping out of the gender norms that wield the penis in a threatening way. So, I feel like there’s a fantasy going on about what people with penises can do. People with and without penises can assault each other, you know? Many people were beaten by mothers or have been the subject of corporal punishment by women teachers. They didn’t have penises and they beat people mercilessly. You know? I mean, that kind of assault doesn’t emerge from the penis, it emerges from patriarchal power, and trans women are opting out of patriarchal power because it hurt them too. But somehow the TERFs cannot hear that very simple thing.1

The use of the words ‘cannot hear’ is interesting, because, to me, it seems that if women speak up to defend their need for female-only spaces they are told to be quiet and ‘not heard.’ It also seems that the age-old idea that women can’t have desires of their own is prevalent in the discussion about female-only spaces: as if we weren’t entirely animate, like de Beauvoir’s “marvellous doll[s].” The feeling I get from this is that if the males need something of us … we must just give it to them and be quiet.

Secondly, Butler’s answer entirely obscures the data of worldwide male violence against women and girls.2 In addition, statistics show that trans-identified males commit crimes in accordance with their natal sex.3

Thirdly, if one was asked, “Is racism a problem amongst white people?” one could answer by talking about different countries, different attitudes to race, and how to solve racism among white people, but one could not sensibly say: “Many people have been beaten mercilessly by black people” or “I know a whole lot of white people who’ve never been racist to anyone.”

Statistics show that male violence is high. Introducing ideas like ‘some women are violent’ or ‘some men are gentle’ seems disingenuous, and both these introduced ideas are also obvious false dilemma fallacies. Just because some men are gentle, it doesn’t mean women don’t need female-only spaces. Both statements can be true.

Finally, the use of the word ‘fantasy’ here, combined with the usage of ‘the penis’ as if penises acted independently, seems to have the effect of belittling women’s fears and casting them in a risible light, in a way that looks a lot like patriarchy.

Butler professes to be a feminist, but I am not sure this is correct. Feminists are on the side of women and girls in general, tend to believe in the oppression of females as a class, are concerned about (and discuss) issues such as male violence against women and girls and FGM. They amplify problems like the inability to work due to the lack of cheap childcare, raise awareness of girls not being educated, child marriage, and the global rise in trafficking. Butler doesn’t seem to centre these issues. I have never heard any other feminists saying things like “people … without penises can assault each other” and referring to ‘merciless’ abuse at the hands of mothers and female teachers. Of course, some women can be abusive, some women can be murderers, but these are unusual things for a feminist scholar to want to highlight when asked about the need for women-only spaces, especially bearing in mind the lived reality of women around the world being one of oppression and violence. In the UK, 99% of rapes and 92% of murders are committed by males.4 If Butler is a feminist, it is a new kind, one I have not come across before.

Butler either isn’t aware of the data, doesn’t want to acknowledge it, or thinks it is somehow flawed. If she isn’t aware: how is she a feminist scholar? If she doesn’t acknowledge it: why not? If she thinks it flawed: why doesn’t she explain how?

Butler is fond of quoting de Beauvoir’s famous line, “One is not born, but rather becomes, a woman,” citing it as an example of femaleness being something any human can identify into.5 However, as Holly Lawford-Smith explains in a video with Kate Phelan discussing Butler’s interview, what de Beauvoir actually means is “female people are not born, but are, in fact, made, feminine,” and, as Phelan says, this is obvious from the rest of the book: “all the chapters in [The Second Sex] – Childhood, Girlhood, Marriage …”6 In other words, it is the process of being born female and going through life as a female in society that makes women feminine.

I attend a webinar with Julie Bindel organized by Cambridge University Radical Feminist Network.7 Bindel’s forthrightness is invigorating. I have the live webinar on rather loud, as I’m also frying eggs, when my housemate comes in. As she walks through the door, Bindel is talking about prostitution and is saying, with emphasis, “… bend over and take it up the ass!” My housemate looks at me. I snort and smile rather nervously. I am seen as an oddball. “It’s feminism,” I stammer.

I ask my question in the webinar: is there any college or university in the UK where a person could go to study ‘radical’ feminism? The answer from Bindel comes back; regretfully … “No.”

I visit a friend. Her daughter, Grace, is eight. I’ve known her since she was a baby. In ripped jeans and a monkey T-shirt, she is wild and unfettered, giggly and full of life. She bounces on the trampoline, then races round the edge like a cartoon character while I sit in the middle, warping the fabric like a black hole bends space. She is at the age just before girls start to lose their confidence and their ability to speak up.8 I somehow want to protect her from that, but know it’s impossible.

She asks questions relentlessly. She shows me the video of ‘Roar’ by Katy Perry on her phone.

“Look!” she says, showing me Perry: triumphant, sitting on a throne wearing a leopard-skin bikini at the end of the video. “She survived … but where did she get the lipstick from?”

The video is feminism of a kind. The lyrics “I used to bite my tongue and hold my breath/Scared to rock the boat and make a mess/So I sat quietly, agreed politely” are not just thoughtless pop. The narcissistic boyfriend is eaten by a tiger; Perry’s character learns to survive by herself on a jungle island and finds her inner ‘roar.’

Grace is so credulous, so open to ideas. She asks questions that show she is fascinated by the far-off island of womanhood, shrouded in mists and mystery. I do my best to answer. She wants me to watch the video again. “Oh look! It’s from a fruit!” she exclaims. “She makes lipstick from a fruit … Hm …” She cocks her head thoughtfully and I sense she is filing this information away for future reference, as if we, the grown-ups, make sure that all the ideas she is exposed to are relevant, useful, and true. Little does she know, much of the information she’ll get from culture will be either ineffectual or actively harmful.

I used to have a niece. I remember her at eight: earnest, mildly autistic, intelligent, wanting to save the whales, good at maths. Now in her 20s, she has gone through the process of being ‘affirmed.’ This seems like dystopian science fiction to me, and the more I research the medical, physical side, the worse it is. She, sans breasts, deep-voiced, hair dyed inky-black, is no longer a lesbian, no longer my niece. Now I must accept that she is ‘he’: a diminutive, diffident, straight, fresh-made ‘man.’ Outwardly I do accept, of course, I use the right pronouns, buy cufflinks for Christmas, earnestly do everything I am meant to, and convincingly cover my feelings up, but inside I am so sad and hope there is never any regret.

Towards the end of my degree I am asked to write my final ‘long essay.’ I know what I want to write about. It includes feminism; it involves critiquing beauty norms in a niche area of culture. It is rejected.

“If I were you, I’d avoid ‘feminism,’” my tutor says breezily during our online one-to-one.

“Avoid it?” I enquire.

“Yes,” she confirms.

I get the mark back for my Butler essay. My tutor wants me to know that many people consider Butler a genius. Butler’s a very deep thinker. I need to be aware that it perhaps looks intellectually arrogant to think I could understand ‘gender’ better than Butler. I am asked if I realize that the number of Great Women Academics that have made it to the top of their fields and influenced public opinion is a very short list.

“Butler identifies as non-binary,” I reply, “and uses the pronouns ‘they/them,’ so I guess you can’t really include them on your ‘Great Women Academics’ list.”

It has taken me a long time to feel my voice is valid, that what I have to say isn’t worthless or irrelevant: girls learn early to be quiet and let the boys answer the questions.

I’m not going to avoid feminism.

Cassandra Adaryn is a student, illustrator, and writer.

1 ‘Feminist philosopher Judith Butler: Why gender still causes trouble,’ Radio New Zealand, 17 October 2020.

2 World Health Organization, ‘Violence against women,’ last updated 9 March 2021.

3 Fair Play for Women, ‘Transgender women exhibit a male-type pattern of criminality: Implications for legislators and policy makers,’ 12 December 2020.

4 Office for National Statistics, ‘Homicide in England and Wales: Year ending March 2019,’ 13 February 2020.

5 Judith Butler, ‘Sex and Gender in Simone de Beauvoir’s Second Sex,’ Yale French Studies, 72 (1986), 35-49, doi:10.2307/2930225.

6 Feminist Heretics, ‘Judith Butler vs The Radfems,’ YouTube, 17 October 2020.

7 Cambridge Radical Feminist Network, ‘In conversation with Julie Bindel,’ YouTube, 16 March 2021.

8 A Mighty Girl, ‘Girls’ confidence plummets starting at age 8,’ 12 May 2020.