Issue Five

THE RADICAL NOTION Global Panel Discussion: Part 1

by Cátia Freitas, Aisha Hashem, Erin, and Gabi

Cátia Freitas is a community and union activist. She is @Mocha_Soul on Twitter where she gives an online voice on women’s rights understood in the complex contexts of working-class politics, internationalism, and race. She speaks on men’s violence against women from her direct experience as a user of domestic violence services.

Aisha Hashem is an academic who, for years, described herself as ‘egalitarian’ rather than ‘feminist’ in response to a certain, rather sadly ironic, type of paternalism directed at women from the Global South by Anglo-European political feminism. She has, however, come to see that certain rights can only be achieved and retained by foregrounding the source of their need—the specific issues faced by female people. She’d now term herself a ‘postcolonial feminist.’

Erin is a Japanese woman living in Ireland, whose main interest has always been in analytic philosophy. She had read some feminist theories in philosophical contexts but never really considered herself to be a feminist … until she accidentally found out about gender-identity ideology. She is absolutely infuriated by the feminist philosophers who have abandoned ordinary women and is now determined to fight for their rights.

Gabi is a dual citizen, living in Poland. She teaches English, speaks English and Hungarian fluently and is currently acquiring a third language. People call her a radfem in feminist circles, although she isn’t particularly attached to any feminist label, with her main interests actually being Marxist philosophy (particularly Engels) and scientific scepticism.

Cátia: It’s a massive problem right now that there are a lot of white women out there who don’t see a problem with colonialism. [I was shocked at] the amount of women who supported [Conservative MP and UK Minister for Equalities] Kemi Badenoch recently when she said, “Oh, I don’t care about colonialism, because it just went and replaced the autocracies of the time.” The thing she forgets is that without colonialism, those people would have risen eventually against their rulers. Colonialism came to bolster. Colonialism is like any other market thing: people see an opportunity and they will just join that market, even if it’s grounded on blood. I can’t believe she says that. Not only regarding colonialism, but also its child, neo-colonialism, that’s been going on since the 60s or the 70s.

Aisha: It’s continuing; it never really ended. It just shifted from boots on the ground to occasional boots on the ground but mostly economic manipulation — and cultural and political. And the occasional coup whenever you don’t like what they’re saying.

Cátia: It’s amazing that, on the one hand, we have managed to build a great movement in [the UK]. It seems like a very rational, quite progressive movement. And at the same time, when it comes to race, it all falls. I mean, you just know as a black woman in Britain, you’re on your own.

Aisha: When it comes to — ironically because people use the word intersectionality wrong very often — when it comes to the intersection of being a woman and being black, they act as though the woman bit cancels it out. They don’t understand that intersectionality is meant to be: you’re at this node where multiple things come together to form your experience. They think it’s arithmetic: plus or minus female equals, you know, whatever.

Gabi: Well, they have that ridiculous points chart, don’t they? 

Aisha: By definition, that’s the opposite way to look at it!

Cátia: I’ve had a few conversations with other black women who say, “I ended up not being able to talk to black women who are TRAs, because they cannot see the ‘woman’ part in ‘black woman.’” And I have to say, I have a lot of sympathy with that position, too. Because among Woman’s Place, THE RADICAL NOTION, Karen Ingala-Smith and so on, they have a good idea of the intersection of race with sex, but out there, elsewhere? 

Aisha: The way these theories that have been developed is not truly effective. They are talking about anti-colonialism, anti-racism, or intersectionality, but they’ve been deformed to the point that people now get resistant at the sound of their names, which removes these useful tools from us. But that’s the thing with intersectionality: it’s just been completely shifted to this arithmetic. And it means that people are resistant to understanding what it is to be a member of multiple groups that are marginalized, and how that works and how they act on each other. And you’re at an intersection where none of the people advocating for the various groups that you’re part of like each other or want to talk to each other. And so you have to choose between the people who hate you as a woman, or the people who hate you as, say, a Muslim or an Arab or whatever. There’s no one group that talks for all of the things that you are.

Erin: Yeah, about intersectionality — I’m really exasperated. Most Japanese people can’t read English — and don’t know the notion of intersectionality through actually reading Kimberlé Crenshaw’s articles. I’ve also read Jane’s account of intersectionality. So I know that when TRAs are talking about intersectionality, it’s a completely corrupted form. But the notion of intersectionality is introduced to the Japanese public through liberal feminist, queer feminist academics, and when intersectionality is then talked about in mainstream media, or even in Japanese versions of, say, Vogue or Vanity Fair, what they have there is a corrupted notion of intersectionality. I’m frustrated that Japanese women have, I think, a distorted view of what feminism really is, because the only thing they have access to is what liberal feminists say. 

Gabi: That’s true of all the countries, isn’t it? The mode of operating is that the people with power are going to translate it, so it’s going to be in their language. And the only way it’s going to be accessible is through the dissemination of it through the various channels that exist, which are always going to be in favour of the people that came up with it.

Aisha: But even within the same language … I mean, in the UK, for example, they use ‘woke’ as a pejorative, not understanding that in its initial form, it was a way to articulate the experience that black Americans had, being in a society that was hostile towards them. I try so hard not to use it because, again, it served a useful purpose and now it’s been deformed.

Cátia: Well, black people in the US itself have started using it to get back at the hypocrites, because they themselves noticed that it was now just a badge. Oh, it’s like ‘#BLM’ in people’s profiles. I don’t believe anybody’s profiles these days. Were you around when that guy @GlobalGamer0 decided to denounce me to Black Socialists in America because I was the wrong sort of black woman?! An ideology that infuses people with this sort of attitude is not there to unite anybody. It’s not to resist anybody. And what we’ve been talking about here, with the snatching of internet intersectionality from black women, is the snatching of resistance.

Gabi: The snatching of the tools itself, isn’t it?

Aisha: Yeah. And they do it across the board. My pet peeve is where people come up and talk, with absolutely zero understanding, about how colonialism invented the sex binary and beforehand everybody was non-binary and happy. They’re using the noble savage trope; they’re using the colonial tool of speaking for indigenous people by turning them into this homogenous mass of whatever they want them to be. They’re performing colonialism while calling other people colonizers. It’s infuriating. And then everybody watching sees colonialism being used in that context and thinks it’s ridiculous. And that removes, again, another tool from our ability to talk about power dynamics in the world today. Actual power dynamics that actually negatively affect people’s lives.

Cátia: Yep, it’s appropriative. 

Aisha: Yeah. It functions so well to entrench the status quo, while being used by people who claim to be against that.

Erin: Are they doing it consciously? I kind of understand, if you are anti-feminist/anti-women, and you find this really clever, cunning and devious way to undermine everything feminism has achieved … In that sense, what they are doing is effective, but I can’t really think—

Gabi: I don’t think it’s deliberate. I think the reason they’re doing it is they have to do it for the ideology to make sense. Because it is a capitalistic liberal ideology. And I guess it’s cognitive dissonance, right? They don’t want to admit that it’s a liberal capitalist ideology, so they make this stuff up like, “Oh, we’re not the colonialists; you are!” Obviously, people from other countries didn’t know what sex was until white men introduced it to them, and therefore white people are bad …

Aisha: Even though the person saying that is invariably a white person. 

Gabi: I think they’re sleepwalking. Honestly, most of the people that repeat this stuff, I think they’re just sleepwalking and repeating nonsense they’ve heard.

Aisha: I think it’s between cognitive dissonance and conscious desire. I think it’s a subconscious desire. I think these tend to be people who are by any metric quite privileged, who the status quo actually functions for. So I think subconsciously they are ensuring that it cannot be overturned, especially [with] this focus on calling out individual people and witch hunting individuals. And imbuing individuals with all the ills of the world that they claim are out there, rather than actually grappling with the fact that it’s systems of inequality. And systems aren’t sexy; systems can’t be gotten after with a pitchfork and a torch; systems require slow, conscious deliberate change, and solidarity building, and consensus building, and all of those things that are not going to feed your id. Whereas picking someone out from the herd and turning them into the sacrificial effigy of everything that you came to hate is so much easier — and gives you that rush.

Gabi: The whole thing about system denial is interesting, because they also deny the sexed body as a system in and of itself. An organism is a biological system. A dog is a biological system. There’s not one part that you can take out of it that stops it being a dog. The same with a person, you chop off someone’s arm, it doesn’t stop them being a human. Because the whole thing about organisms and the natural world is that these systems are not just the sum of their parts, they exist as a system in the whole. And they do that with the female body as well: ‘Oh, well, if you take away a woman’s womb, is she no longer a woman? Is that what you’re saying?’ It’s like, no, because ‘female’ is a system as well. Similarly, if you can deny the system of capitalism, when you go after the individual parts, this person or that person, it’s never going to be defeated, because you fundamentally misunderstand what a system is. And in denying the system, you effectively are defeated straight away. 

Aisha: That’s exactly what they do, when you bring up biological sex, and they’ll say something like ‘genital fetishist’ or ‘why are you focused on vaginas or uteruses?’ They fundamentally think that we’re Lego people, that you can pop out one part and pop in another, rather than: it’s our tendons, it’s our ligaments, it’s our bone structure. It’s every aspect of our body, which is why one of the ways in which we’re marginalized is medical neglect, because we’ve been treated as deficient men throughout history.

Gabi: Yeah, and not a system in and of itself. If you deny the systems of people, like the biology of people, then you can also deny the systems that humans set up. For example, the colonial power infrastructure that goes on, you can’t just get one person out the loop. You get a corrupt politician, or you get a corrupt police officer, you get rid of him, and suddenly everything’s okay. Well, no, because the issue isn’t the part, the issue is the system itself. And sometimes you can change that system. And other times, you’ve got to accept it. Now, obviously I believe that political systems can and should be changed when they’re deficient. But you can’t do that with organic matter. Look at the ecosystem as well: you take one part of the ecosystem out and it collapses on itself. So there is a difference between political, social systems and organic, natural systems.

Aisha: I think it’s a marriage of this hyper-individualistic ideology with alienation from nature. It’s a form of solipsism, almost ‘the world is what I say it is.’

Cátia: The amazing thing about women, especially the ones who have kids, is that at some point in our lives, where we’re not just one being, we are two. When we are pregnant, you know, it’s a system in and of itself. And they try to deny that. And they try and say, ‘Oh, yeah, but that doesn’t make you a woman.’ It’s bonkers that pregnant women are called ‘pregnant people’ and ‘birthing bodies.’ And [yet] ‘trans women are women.’ It’s [like] the right calling us ‘host bodies,’ because to them we are not a system when we’re pregnant, we are separated somehow.

Aisha: That’s the logic behind surrogacy as well. And all these other modifications of the female body.

Cátia: Absolutely. One thing that I was thinking is that they even extract the profound meanings from certain cultures. For example, with Two Spirit, they snatch the profoundness of the meaning behind the traditions, and then they westernize it. Those cultures don’t deny material reality. 

Aisha: That’s the thing about this use of third-gender cultures worldwide. That’s why they’re called ‘third-gender’ cultures, because it’s in addition to the understanding that there are male and female bodies. There are cultures where they create an extra space, usually for male individuals who don’t fit in with the masculine mould. There’s a few that have extra spaces for female individuals, like in Afghanistan, where if you didn’t have a son, you could have your daughter be in that role, until you had a son, at which point your daughter would go back to having to live in the very restrictive roles set aside for women. I don’t think I’ve ever come across an example of a culture that had an additional role that didn’t function in some way to reaffirm the social roles set aside for men and women.

Gabi: I was under the same impression. These cultures tend to be a lot more patriarchal because the extra gender actually gives the space to reinforce those stereotypes and social expectations. So the whole point of them is that if there’s not enough men, you just shove some women into the male box for a while and then move them back. But you’ve not actually done away with the power structure.

Aisha: Which actually, when you think about it, is a very good parallel to the current movement, because it seems that in a lot of those places it’s the rigidity of the boxes that necessitates having that extra space to organize the culture. And this is the regressive movement that we’re in now, where[as] a few decades ago, we were getting away from the gender stereotypes pushed onto women, pushed on to men. And it seems that now this movement is reinforcing them … It codifies these boxes.

Gabi: Yeah, it’s no surprise that these boxes are being more and more enforced. Globally, there’s a massive attack on women’s rights, not just in the UK: in America with abortion rights, in Poland, in Hungary. It’s no surprise really that as the expansion of these ideas of gender are growing, actually the rights of women and same-sex-attracted people are being rolled back, not just in the West but everywhere, because [these regressive ideas are] being filtered down. 

Aisha: And it’s absolutely predicated on reinforcing regressive gender stereotypes and roles. Because when you ask someone, ‘What do I have in common with a trans woman?’ and they say, ‘You both identify as women’ — that’s circular reasoning. Well, I identify as a woman where ‘woman’ means ‘member of the female sex.’ What do you have other than the idea that there’s some kind of feminine essence to you?

Cátia: I have to say, before I got into this fight, I had already been pondering on the question of identity. Because I started seeing a lot of people going, ‘I identify as black.’ And I’m like, I don’t identify as black! I speak as a black person in political settings, you know, in political contexts. I don’t wake up in the morning thinking that I’m black, denying that I’m black, or confirming that I’m black. I don’t even think of myself as ‘Cátia,’ you know. There’s something inside of me that doesn’t even have a name. And I don’t get this ‘I identify as a woman.’

Erin: I feel that way about my being Japanese, because I don’t identify as Japanese. But I’ve thought a lot about my kind of ‘Japaneseness,’ because I left Japan when I was quite young, in my early 20s, and I’ve lived in Ireland, and in Wales as well, for more than ten years now. My Irish friends say “Oh, you are practically Irish!” you know, as a joke. And sometimes I feel I’ve really partially become Irish, because I’m now used to Irish ways, and I certainly feel distance from my Japanese friends. My thinking has changed a lot and my feelings have changed as well, and so now I feel some distance between me and Japan. But I still think of myself as Japanese and, even now, sometimes I find myself thinking, “Oh god, did I react to this because I’m Japanese, because I was brought up in Japanese culture?” There is never any doubt that I’m Japanese, even though, quite often, I don’t feel Japanese. And so, I do have an ambiguous or ambivalent identity as a Japanese person. I am Japanese because I was born in Japan and I was brought up in Japan. But it’s never about me actively identifying as a Japanese person. And it’s the same with being a woman: I was born female, and I was brought up as a girl, and everybody in society treats me as a woman, and so, because of my experiences being treated as a woman in society, obviously that certainly affected the way I feel about myself, but I’ve never understood this whole notion of ‘identifying as.’

Cátia: ‘Identifying as,’ it’s — it’s just weird. I have a not-so-dissimilar history and lived experience to you, Erin, because I was born in Angola. The main difference between me and you, I suppose, is that I arrived in Portugal at 18 days of age, because my mum had to run from a war. What I had was the Portuguese-Angolan world in my house, inside my home, because my own mum’s dad was white — and then I had the Portuguese world outside. I won’t ever forget, for example, that in the late 80s, there was a Portuguese song sent to the Eurovision Song Contest called ‘Conquistador.’ It was all about the Age of Discovery, because the Portuguese were big on that. It went to the top of the charts, and then I’m thinking, “Oh my gosh! What this song is celebrating is slavery, apartheid — which was never called an apartheid state in Angola. This is what this song symbolizes.” From that moment on, I was like, nah, I can’t really be Portuguese. Now I’ve been in this country for longer than I lived in Portugal. Am I English? No — it would be a bit more difficult, because I came to this country at the age of 22 or 23, but I’ve been here for a lot longer. And sometimes I’m talking to my mum, or I go to Portugal, or I just go to the Portuguese area in London, and it already feels like another world. And one that I find difficult to adapt to. 

Aisha: I had a similar trajectory to both of you. I’m the palest member of my family. It’s a genetic quirk; I’m much lighter skinned than my siblings. So at home, I always got treated as an outsider. If I was speaking to someone in Arabic, they’d reply in English assuming that I wasn’t Arab. So I had that sense of dislocation at home. And then when I went and studied in the UK and in America, they’d say things to me, like, ‘Oh, but you’re not really one of them. You know, you’re a good one, you’re like us, actually. You’re not really Arab, you’re not really a Muslim.’ And I’d be like, ‘No, I am. That’s my culture, that’s my religion.’ And it was, again, those boxes — where because I didn’t fit their idea of what I should look like or sound like, then I must be them, I must not be me. Whereas, as with being female, the very existence of me proves that those boxes are restrictive. And in fact, it’s a problem of how you’re looking at people. Why would they look at me and not see my existence as someone that they liked as a way of opening up their understanding, rather than just taking me out of one box and putting me into the other? With women, we’ve come back to this point where it’s feminine identity and you ‘identify as’ and you’re submissive and whatever other sexualized, dehumanizing qualities get projected onto us. But I’ve never identified as a woman. I know I’m female, and I know I’m not those things, which means that being a woman isn’t tied to those things.

Gabi: Yeah, my story is pretty similar as well, actually. My mother was Hungarian and my father was English. Pretty much my mother tongue was Hungarian, and culturally I was way more tied to my mother. So we had the Hungarian on the inside, and outside the house everything was England. You can’t tell by my features, but the difference was still obvious in the classroom … I behaved differently. I didn’t think in the same way, because the language that we were speaking in at home was different and led to different cognitive responses. It was noticed by even the children, and it led to a lot of rejection. I wasn’t one of them. And then I’d go to Hungary, and I wasn’t one of them either — though, to be honest, it was a lot more welcoming than the UK. I never really identified as English. Or as Hungarian. And actually, I think the luxury comes in being able to identify as something. Being able to identify as something is a luxury. Because if you can do that, it means you haven’t really been rejected.

Cátia: Absolutely. It’s a funny one. Because when I went to the navy, still in Portugal, I spent a lot more time in Lisbon. And Lisbon was where black people were. So I went after the Angolan communities and tried to get acquainted with them. My thirst for it was everything! And then they hear me speak. And my mum did not allow us to develop a regional accent. So they hear me speak and they go, ‘Nah, you’re Portuguese.’

Gabi: I had a very similar situation myself. I was born in Tooting and my mother, being Hungarian, would not let me take on this South London accent. She point blank refused to allow me to speak with a cockney twang to my voice, which alienated me even more from the local community. So people identified me as something else when I was living in England, and when I went to Hungary, people identified me as something else. And now people identify me as something completely different because I live in Poland. So even now, I don’t identify as anything; rather, people identify me as whatever the hell they want to, and there’s nothing I can do about it. And why should I care really? As long as people treat me decently, who cares how people identify me? But then, it’s not an active thing. It’s something that happens to you. And it happens to you [because of] reasons and perceptions.

Aisha: It’s interesting what you both said about the language. So my thing is, I speak Arabic as a native, and have the native accent of my country, but because my skin was lighter, people wouldn’t accept me as that. That’s the thing, for me, being Arab, being my nationality, it’s not about qualities, it’s just a thing that I am. And it’s the same with being female: it’s a thing that I am that affects how I move through the world, but it doesn’t say anything about my personality. There’s no connection. 

Gabi: And what’s more, I can’t dictate to people how they should see me, either. I’m not going to dictate that people see me as something that they don’t see me as, because what use would that be? 

Erin: As I said, my friends joke about all of us being practically Irish, and it’s flattering because it shows they accept me, but I don’t expect them to treat me as native Irish, and that’s okay. I don’t understand these people who insist that they be treated as they identify as, because at the end of the day, what matters is, no matter what race or sex or sexuality [you belong to], you are treated as a human being and don’t get discriminated against on the basis of your race or your sex. This idea of ‘being treated as a woman’ always puzzled me, because being treated as a woman in a patriarchal society basically means being treated as subhuman. But haven’t feminists been fighting to be treated as human beings who just happen to have female bodies? We are not subhumans, we are humans, we just have different bodies from men. So, when I hear that trans women want to be ‘treated as women,’ I can’t possibly treat them as women have been traditionally treated, because that basically means treating them as subhuman, and I don’t want to do that, obviously. But what else do they expect when they say, ‘Why can’t you treat us as women?’?

Aisha: You’re right. That’s the way I would like to be treated as a woman: to have my needs met, not ignored, and to be treated as a full human being, who’s capable of any kind of personality or likes or dislikes. Just like any other human, you know. 

Cátia: Absolutely. Before I understood that ‘trans women are women’ was to be taken literally, I just thought that it was a slogan to promote their acceptance in society. 

Aisha: Cátia, I think most of us had a very similar trajectory, where even five or six years ago, I thought they were just saying sex and gender are different. And I was fine with that. But then it started being this gender-cannibalizing-sex thing, and it was actually Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie, the first time, where she was being monstered for saying ‘trans women are trans women’ … I just couldn’t understand what was wrong with that. You’re not literally female if you’re literally male.

Cátia: To be quite honest, when she spoke, I just thought the media was just being racist. I didn’t pay attention. To me, it was another storm in a teacup, [and then] the Anarchist Book Fair debacle happened. Helen Steel was bullied out of the Anarchist Book Fair, and I was like, ‘No, Helen Steel? I know that name, I know that name very well. No, no, no, there must be something behind this.’ The Anarchist Book Fair ended. It was a stalwart of freedom of speech in this country, and it ended, and I thought, ‘This is serious.’ Even then, I did not think that the issue was trans women and women’s rights. 

Aisha: I never referred to myself as a feminist. My understanding of feminism in my 20s was that it had quite colonial undertones, a lot of white women trying to save brown women from brown men, and Islamophobia, xenophobia, racism. My idea was always that it was so blind and closed to the voices of women worldwide that I didn’t want to be a part of it. It’s this whole situation that’s made me say, ‘You know what, I’m not going to let the word mean what other people say it means.’ For me, it means fighting for the rights of female people. And that’s it. And so now I am a feminist.

Cátia: I developed such a bad idea of feminism in this country that I did not think that radical feminism actually existed here. To me, from a young age, feminism seemed like another set of chains. Because on the one hand it spoke about women’s independence. But you know what? Yeah, we could go to work. And we would still be lumped with domestic labour. I knew that from my mum. And then I got pregnant, and it was about the friggin’ baby monitors. I was thinking, who the hell has a house so big that they can’t hear their baby cry? I mean, seriously? Okay, so what are the feminists doing? Is this feminism? Is this taking care of women? In a way, I thank gender-identity ideology for infusing women with more thoughts about themselves and about their lives.

Aisha: Yeah, it ends up with us building a coalition, solidarity worldwide. Because unlike Judith Butler’s assertion, there is a form of oppression that women worldwide can recognize, can build solidarity over. If they’ve woken us up and gotten us vocal, and we can actually use that energy to improve the lives of women everywhere, then they’ve done us a huge favour.

Erin: Yeah, that’s true. I now see that Japanese women are actively trying to connect to feminists of other countries, which is really nice. I think before, like Aisha said, many Japanese people, at least Japanese women, felt that feminism was imported from the West. So it sounds nice and progressive and civilized, but it’s not really that relevant to Japanese women.

Aisha: And it imposes Western ideas of what you should do on you.

Erin: Yes, but I think that’s because, again, they only know fashion magazines like Vogue and Vanity Fair that talk about feminism, but the kind of feminism discussed there is basically a feminism for well-off middle-class women, and I think many Japanese women are attracted to that view and that type of feminism in the same way of many Japanese people are attracted to Hollywood or the celebrities and that whole spectacular, sparkling scene of civilization. And a lot of Japanese women, especially from working-class backgrounds, felt that it’s again a completely different world. It’s nothing to do with them. But now I think people realize that radical feminism and a more socialist-Marxist-oriented feminism exist, and I think Japanese women relate to that sort of feminism, and now they realize that there are other women in other countries who feel the same.

Cátia: We can’t ever forget all of this — that the feminism we actually ended up growing up with, that was the feminism of Gloria Steinem, what people now refer to as liberal feminism, white feminism.

Aisha: Shiny feminism, glossy feminism, feminism that actually puts more restrictions on you.

Cátia: Oh, absolutely! And it does nothing to actually challenge the whole of the system. I grew up in a particular context — it just put me off. And having found all of these women now, it’s brilliant that they don’t judge. I even find the ones who do … the young ones, the radical feminists, the ones that go, ‘Oh, you should not paint your face!’ — even them, I love them. I know they are a bit lacking in understanding but, you know, I love them. Because they are actually confronting the system, or they try.

Aisha: I think there is a tendency towards tribalism that I’ve certainly noticed. It’s not great. But I’m happy that there are spaces now for young women to feel comfortable being that vocally critical of the systems. That’s wonderful. You know, they don’t have to go underground. They don’t have to be ashamed that they’re loud and they’re proud and they’re not having it.

Cátia: And they’re not having it. Absolutely. And I think one of the things that I have against gender-identity ideology is that it snatches that from them. It portrays itself as the resistance and it actually isn’t. And it’s sad, and it’s infuriating, at the same time.

Erin: I don’t know if you’ve heard of this radical feminist movement in South Korea called Take Off the Corset?

Aisha: Yeah, they’re amazing. South Korean rad fems are incredible.

Erin: Yeah. One of my friends was saying that TRAs are really critical of the Take Off the Corset movement and are calling those radical feminists who endorsed that movement ‘masculine,’ saying that they are trying to be masculine and masculinizing women. That’s actually what made my friend think there is something wrong with this whole transgender ideology. The Take Off the Corset movement is great, especially in South Korea, where I think female appearance is really rigidly controlled. But Aisha was talking about tribalism, and some Japanese radical feminists seem to think that if you are a feminist, you have to take part in this particular movement, otherwise, you’re no feminist. I don’t know: on the one hand, I think it’s really great that there is this community where women feel they don’t need to put on makeup or they don’t need to dress up, but at the same time, the pressure not to do it can be as oppressive. 

Aisha: I completely agree. It’s the tribalism and the individualism we were talking about earlier. The focus should be on the systems, not the people caught in the systems. If you’re telling women — it’s the same one that they always bring up about women veiling or dressing modestly or whatever. I hate the veil. I don’t think it’s Islamic. I think it’s a cultural thing. But I would never take away a woman’s right to do it if it was her choice. And yeah, I think hyper-sexualization and hyper-modesty are two sides of the same coin, where they’re culturally mandated ways for women to be. And makeup is a similar thing. Talk about the system. Talk about what it does. Don’t punish individuals who are caught in it.

Cátia: Yeah. Taking into account the fact that those women live in communities themselves. And sometimes to survive in your community, that’s what you got to do.

Aisha: To get a job in these places you have to wear makeup, you have to do a certain thing, you have to have your hair a certain way. 

Cátia: I totally agree with you: always point out structures rather than individual women. 

Erin: Yeah, I’ve noticed that on Japanese Twitter, even those who call themselves radical feminists seem to have some strands of individualism, where they demand that individuals be strong and always fight against the system. Human beings aren’t perfect; we always try to do the right thing, but at the same time, sometimes situations just don’t allow us to act in the way we would like, and I don’t know, I just wish sometimes that people were a bit more understanding of this kind of human frailty or human weakness. Which comes from living in a community, living with others. We can’t ignore other people. 

Cátia: It goes along with solidarity, because solidarity is not just about empathy; it’s about standing with you, even though you might not even partake of the same opinion. Because I’m not particularly interested in building a world of complete robots, automatons with the same kind of thinking — there goes creativity out of the window, straight off. But we can change bits of the system in order to allow each other to live our lives the way we want or can. 

Aisha: I think it’s ironic, because a lot of the radical feminists who are so strict, as Erin was saying, they’re very anti-liberal-feminist, but it’s the same mentality, where all of the focus is on choice. And not enough of the focus is on the structures that limit the choices.