by Aisha Hashem
What does the word ‘imperialism’ mean today? There are those who consider it to be a historical artefact — a system by which Anglo-Europeans conquered territory in Asia, Africa, South America, and Oceania and established their own outposts. Built roads, took over governance, exported their culture, brought brutality and (in the eyes of some) enlightenment. A bad thing, perhaps, that also did some good, and, at any rate, is obsolete — only namechecked in this day and age to imply culpability in the innocent for the sins of their forefathers. They can’t understand why people insist on dragging its spectre into conversation. ‘Fine, it was a bad thing, but it’s been over with for decades. What does it have to do with anything now?’
Except that it never actually went away, and when we talk about it in the context of the modern day, we’re speaking of more than just the economic, societal, and political (and often physical) scars it left on the places and the people it subjugated (though those are certainly bad enough). We’re speaking of a modern geo-political system in which the old empires have ostensibly removed their overt physical presence from most, though not all, nations in the global South while maintaining systems of economic, societal and political coercion that continue to treat them as resource, playground, and occasional source of domestic political capital. Imperialism extends beyond boots on the ground — it encompasses a tangled history of interference and influence. And that means devastation on the ground those boots occasionally tread. We bring it up to citizens of the former Anglo-European empires because their current governments are just as deeply enmeshed in the political and economic impositions of neo-colonialism and neo-imperialism as their historical governments were in traditional varieties.
This is the reality that has been elided in so much coverage of the recent US withdrawal from Afghanistan. You cannot look at the 20 years of American occupation in a vacuum. Not in a country that, in the past two centuries, has been variously fought over by the British and Russian Empires, the United States and the Soviet Union, and, most recently, the United States and … Terror? A country that, from the time of that first 19th-century proxy conflict between the British and the Russians, became a receptacle for imperial foreign ‘aid’ aimed at controlling and disrupting its political, diplomatic, and economic systems — creating an eternally unstable dynamic of nepotism, corruption, and vastly unequal concentrations of wealth. A country in which any brief vestige of stability or self-rule has consistently been demolished by externally trained and funded militant groups supported by foreign powers.
I’m not from Afghanistan, nor is it my field. It’s not, therefore, my place to speak for the Afghan people. What I can and will speak to is the colonial narrative into which their struggle has been subsumed. The impact of empire, of colonialism and imperialism of both the traditional and neo varieties, has been a personal and academic interest of mine for decades — and the same tropes have been deployed to justify imperial intervention in Afghanistan as have been used in the Arab world. In feminist discourse, the most pressing of those tropes is the noble impetus of saving brown women from brown men who, as a result of culture and/or religion, are lamentably primitive and must be brought into advancement through the universalization of enlightened ‘Western’ principles.
The idea of a linear progression of cultural advancement — with the ‘West’ just happening to be further down the line and the ‘East’ stuck like a fly in amber in an eternally primitive state that they must be educated, or bombed, out of — is, of course, self-serving, self-aggrandizing nonsense. It erases the complexity of our cultures and histories and ignores decades upon centuries of external intervention in those cultures and histories.
Feminists are very good at recognizing this when proponents of gender-identity ideology deploy a ‘noble savage’ trope to claim that all indigenous people lived in blissful multi-gender harmony before white colonizers forcibly imposed a belief in binary sex upon them. Feminists are not always very good at recognizing this when they do it themselves — to decry brown or black cultures as inherently and eternally misogynistic.
When it came to the American withdrawal from Afghanistan, the feminist debates I witnessed gave me the same sinking feeling I get whenever the topics of Islam or the Arab world arise in certain circles. Women who raised the issue of colonialism, who brought up the fact that the American occupation was a bad thing in its own right, were shouted down and treated as anti-feminist. As though you can’t be pro-woman and anti-occupation at the same time. As though many Afghan women aren’t themselves both of those things. Again, remember that this is a country that has been the recipient of imperial attention, by four separate empires, for over two centuries. Watching the imposition of systemic misogyny on such a grand scale leads to impotent rage, and empathy and heartbreak for its victims, but simplifying the complexity of their situation doesn’t help them, it just perpetuates that cycle by evoking imperialism’s symbiote: Orientalism.
Orientalism ‘Others’ a target group. It dehistoricizes and decontextualizes the heterogeneous, folds it into two-dimensional homogeneity, and creates a malleable, amorphous mass that can be shaped into whatever form the Orientalist needs — something that validates his or her political views while also serving as a shadow self against which his or her sense of self can be defined in contrast. As Edward Said writes in Orientalism,
to the extent that Western scholars were aware of contemporary Orientals or Oriental movements of thought and culture, these were perceived either as silent shadows to be animated by the Orientalist, brought into reality by him, or as a kind of cultural and intellectual proletariat useful for the Orientalist’s grander interpretative activity, necessary for his performance as superior judge … the Orient is all absence.1
This is what happened to the discourse on Afghanistan and the rights of women in order to justify the original American invasion, and it is what has happened in the aftermath of their withdrawal. Afghanistan’s complex history and cultures, the interweaving of external power, influence, and coercion — economic and political as well as military — that has shaped it, have been obscured for the sake of political expediency and cultural projection.
This can be intentional or unconscious, done out of positive or negative impulses. Think of the gender-identity ideologists who claim that sex is a colonial construct; they think positively of the indigenous people they’re claiming to speak for, they’re imbuing them with qualities they consider to be good — they’re still making it all up, erasing complex and varied cultures and histories, still treating their peoples as puppets to speak through. Still dehumanizing them. It’s no less Orientalist if you do it on someone’s behalf. What you’re doing is projecting what you think they need onto them — removing the complexity, the reality of their lives. If you’re a feminist in the Anglo-Eurosphere arguing, for instance, that the only Afghan refugees let into your country should be women and children, you are absolutely not arguing for Afghan women with husbands, brothers, sons, and fathers from whom they’d be permanently separated. You’re not arguing for them; you’re arguing against what you think their men are like. And you’re projecting your own interpretation of who they are and what they want onto both groups.
That’s the rhetoric used to justify invasion and colonization, and it doesn’t help the women it claims to want to save. In November 2001, Laura Bush gave a radio address in which she said, “Because of our recent military gains in much of Afghanistan, women are no longer imprisoned in their homes. They can listen to music and teach their daughters without fear of punishment. The fight against terrorism is also a fight for the rights and dignity of women.”2 A month later, President George W. Bush claimed that “the central goal of the terrorists is the brutal oppression of women,” and that America’s invasion was not only a fight “for our security” but a “fight for values we hold dear.”3
That fight, those values, meant some improvements in the lives of women in urban centres. It also meant two decades of civilian casualties. Over 170,000 civilians dead: 12% of them women, 30% of them children, and the rest of them the male providers for both — without whom rural women struggled to get by, often needing to remove their children from school, or sell their daughters into marriage, to help eke out a precarious living. It meant night raids that terrified rural women and children. It meant property damage that was enough to send families into poverty. It meant widows at risk of domestic and sexual abuse. It meant women who were injured or disabled as a result of the violence suffering social stigma and sexual harassment — even by the government officials meant to help them.4 And despite the rhetoric, the ostensible concern for the rights of Afghan women, only around 0.5% of the over 141 billion dollars funnelled into Afghanistan by the Americans over the course of 20 years was specifically set aside to help those women.5
The plight of Afghan women is real — in all its horrible complexity. Imperialism isn’t an excuse; it doesn’t give an out to the men who have created the structures that are imprisoning, beating, and killing those women. But without understanding the role it has played in creating those men — directly, through foreign funding and training (including from Anglo-European sources), and indirectly, through the kind of sustained instability and violence that radicalizes (also a result of Anglo-European action and influence) — then you can’t help those women. You simply become another external force imposing its own structures and strictures on a native population and expecting them to live within those alien constraints. They won’t. They’ll always resist, and, as history shows, that resistance will always hit women hardest.
It’s a sad reality that many colonized people find themselves needing to define themselves in opposition to the colonial force. They recreate an imagined history that places them at the opposite cultural and ideological pole to that of the invaders. Under traditional colonialism, the men of colonized nations found themselves forced to interact with the political and economic systems run by the men of colonizing power. As a counterbalance, they invested all their imagined history and tradition in the bodies and freedoms of their women — to be hidden away and protected. Sadly, that dynamic hasn’t much changed in the intervening period.
In ‘Afghanistan and the colonial project of feminism: Dismantling the binary lens,’ Ruhi Khan discusses how, for rural and tribal populations in Afghanistan, the repeated foreign invasions (Russian, British, Soviet, US) “only fuelled a revival of extreme religious bigotry as a mode of what they term ‘self-preservation’. The foreign occupying army has been equated with ‘liberal thought’ and the resistance against both has been building.”6 It’s a felt force, a lived reality, outside academic analysis. It was experienced during the American occupation and it’s certainly being experienced now. In the ‘Support for Gender Equality: Lessons From the U.S. Experience in Afghanistan’ packet compiled in 2020 by the US Special Inspector General for Afghanistan Reconstruction, a female member of a civil society group from a rural province is quoted as saying “that many conservative families ‘believe that the West tries to change Afghan women and make them as modern as their own women … In response … they implement more strictness on girls and women.’”7
This form of ‘self-preservation’ is no more indigenous to a colonized people than the
culture of their colonizers: it is, in fact, a creation of the colonizers’ presence and activities. Nonetheless, it exists now; it creates violence, misogyny, and misery today. So, what can be done about it?
There was no more visceral rebuttal to it than the #DoNotTouchMyClothes, #AfghanWomen, and #AfghanCulture campaigns on social media in which women from all over Afghanistan showcased their various forms of tribal and traditional dress — colourful, bright, intricate, vivid, and alive, the very qualities that the Taliban are attempting to quash in them. It’s only right that it should be Afghan women speaking for themselves and their heritage that formed that rebuttal. They’ve been spoken for over and over, used as others’ propaganda, since the first days of the US invasion. Khan talks of how a “visual palette” was created of “Afghan women in short skirts alongside those now in full burqa, or of Western women enjoying a music concert with veiled young girls huddled together outside a closed school.” Static images and contrived Orientalist symbols, voiceless, ventriloquized to cheer on their invaders. How tragically fitting, then, that the end of the war should be marked by their genuine self-expression, their own voices and images raised in defiance to the colonially shaped forces to which they were abandoned by their erstwhile ‘saviours.’ How painfully ironic that it is only at the end of the 20-year invasion that we see a true juxtaposition of Afghan culture versus the oppression of the Taliban — rather than the false ‘palette’ created between the Taliban and the West.
If the Americans were truly interested in liberating Afghan women rather than remaking them in their own image (as an expression of the latent belief that backwardness and inferiority are inherent to Afghan culture), they could have easily chosen any of a number of native examples of strong, unbowed, independent Afghan women from just the last century.
Queen Soraya Tarzi, wife of King Amanullah Khan (who successfully liberated Afghanistan from British control in 1919) was known as ‘the Human Rights Queen of Afghanistan.’ She and her husband presided over a number of reforms including the “abolishment of slavery and the banning of child marriage, polygamy, revenge killing and ‘bride prices.’”8 They gave women the right to vote in 1919 (before women in either Britain or the United States were granted that same opportunity). She set a public example by ripping off her veil after Amanullah gave a speech asserting that veiling is not, in fact, an Islamic requirement. She was the first female Minister of Education. She “founded a grievance centre for women suffering from domestic violence and created a special task force — a kind of an all-women secret service — to monitor men who abused women.” In 1926, she famously said,
Independence belongs to all of us and that is why we celebrate it. Do you think, however, that our nation from the outset needs only men to serve it? Women should also take their part as women did in the early years of our nation and Islam. From their examples we must learn that we must all contribute toward the development of our nation and that this cannot be done without being equipped with knowledge. So, we should all attempt to acquire as much knowledge as possible, in order that we may render our services to society in the manner of the women of early Islam.9
With such historical templates to draw upon, what force but imperialism, what ideology but Orientalism, could see the United States, after 20 years spent fruitlessly attempting to impose their own cultural views on the Afghan people, come up with a ‘Lessons Learned Program’ report that begins with such gems as this?
There is no Dari or Pashto word for the terms ‘gender’ and ‘gender equality.’ In the development field, Afghans often simply use the English word without any translation.10
At the end of the day, multiple things can be true. That the radicalization of militant groups in Afghanistan happened because of decades of political and economic interference by imperial powers as they treated Afghanistan as a playground in their games of global brinksmanship. That the American invasion was an unnecessary, ill-conceived, and terribly executed act of imperialism that cost hundreds of thousands of lives only to end up with their ostensible enemy in possession of billions of dollars’ worth of American-made weaponry. That the withdrawal was just as devastating an act of imperial disregard for the lives of the Afghan people as the initial invasion — ill-conceived, terribly executed, and with truly destructive consequences. And that you don’t heal the wounds caused by Orientalist intervention — the type that is about politics at home, the universalizing of ideology, and not the lives and contexts of the people on the ground — with more of the same.
You heal those wounds by actually addressing the rest of the iceberg, not just the visible military action, but the larger inexorable force exerted by political and economic coercion that lies beneath the surface and seeks to turn the global South into a resource to be exploited. You stop the cycle of exploitation that creates puppet governments and pet dictatorships, that funds the militant groups who put them into power and then inevitably turn on them and their backers. You commit to the hard, slow, eternally frustrating slog that is the only way to achieve meaningful, systemic change.
You help Afghan women by listening to them. Not by deciding what you think they would want. Perhaps you heed the words of RAWA, the Revolutionary Association of the Women of Afghanistan. Founded in 1977, they are Afghanistan’s oldest feminist organization. Since then they have criticized the Soviet puppet government of the 70s, the anti-Soviet mujahideen in the 80s, the Taliban (and Pakistan’s role in its creation) in the 90s, and the US occupation from 2001 — all while “opposing fundamentalism, warlordism, and imperialism.”11 These are their words:
In the past 20 years, one of our demands was an end to the US/NATO occupation and even better if they take their Islamic fundamentalists and technocrats with them and let our people decide their own fate. This occupation only resulted in bloodshed, destruction and chaos. They turned our country into the most corrupt, insecure, drug-mafia and dangerous place especially for women.12
Aisha Hashem is an academic who, for years, described herself as ‘egalitarian’ rather than ‘feminist’ in response to a certain, rather sadly ironic, type of paternalism directed at women from the Global South by Anglo-European political feminism. She has, however, come to see that certain rights can only be achieved and retained by foregrounding the source of their need—the specific issues faced by female people. She’d now term herself a ‘postcolonial feminist.’
1 Edward W. Said, Orientalism (New York: Random House, 1979), p. 208.
2 Ruhi Khan, ‘Afghanistan and the colonial project of feminism: Dismantling the binary lens,’ LSE Blogs, 2 September 2021.
3 John F. Sopko, ‘Support for Gender Equality: Lessons From the U.S. Experience in Afghanistan,’ Special Inspector General for Afghanistan Reconstruction, February 2021, p. 21.
4 ‘Support for Gender Equality,’ p. 53.
5 ‘Support for Gender Equality,’ pp. 15-16.
6 Khan.
7 ‘Support for Gender Equality,’ p. 53.
8 Khan.
9 Khan.
10 Support for Gender Equality,’ p. 2.
11 Helena Zeweri, ‘For some Afghan women, the U.S. and the Taliban are a problem,’ Washington Post, 14 September 2021.
12 ‘RAWA responds to the Taliban takeover,’ Afghan Women’s Mission, 20 August 2021.
