Issue Five

Captured: Gender-Identity Ideology Takes Women’s Spaces

by Erica Orson

I attend a Southern state school in a city with a rich history and culture that is also unfortunately riddled with poverty and crime. Considering our area’s need for educational equity, and the high rate of sexual assault cases in the area, it was especially good for my university to become a Title IX institution in an attempt to create an environment “free from discrimination and harassment on the basis of sex.” However, during my freshman year, I was made uncomfortably aware of not only how necessary sex-based protections are, but how an administration can twist them to satisfy their own agenda.

I moved into my college dorm a week before classes began, bursting with excitement to meet new people and enjoy the freedom that came with living on my own. Of all the wings in the building, mine is remembered as being the most ‘tight-knit.’ For better or worse, we shared the unique bond created between women who come together when one suffers at the hands of a man. A young woman on our hall was nearly assaulted by an older male student, who pressured her for sex. Despite his wish to be read as ‘more than male,’ he was simply seen as a predator, and treated like one, thanks to the curfews and restraint orders the cops hit him with in accordance with the Title IX enforcement policy. That day, the solemn-faced boyfriend of that assailant’s former roommate told me that the perpetrator had a track record of attempting to coerce male roommates into sex as well. My floormates and I began looking over our shoulders when outside our dorm, resenting how one unhinged and entitled man cast a cloud over the beginning of our college experience.

In the middle of the second semester, a new student transferred to our girls-only residence hall. Let’s call her Mary. We quickly learned that she preferred holing up in her room and smoking to socializing. We ignored how she set off the fire alarm in the wee hours and left a mess strewn about our hall. The depth of her voice, how her build mirrored that of my athletic nephew, how she walked and talked like my gay guy friends—every red flag was invisible to me, blocked by the wall I’d been encouraged to build between myself and reality.

I continued to refuse to see what was right in front of me until it was almost too late. Mary had begun stealing our belongings. We reached a watershed moment when she nabbed a sweater gifted to my next-door neighbour and had the audacity to wear it in front of her. What followed could have been much worse had my friend not been thinking on her toes.

“Mary, give me my sweater back. This is ridiculous. I’ve been missing that for days and would recognize it anywhere.”

“This isn’t yours,” Mary snapped, pastel purple sleeves straining.

“Yes, it is. I’m not stupid.”

“Oh, I know you aren’t calling me a liar, bitch. Are you that fucking pressed?” she shouted, throwing her purse down and moving toward my friend. I moved from where I’d been watching in my doorway to my friend’s side, hoping Mary would back down. Mary moved to punch her, but my friend bobbed out of harm’s way, grabbed my arm, and dragged us into the open bathroom, locking the door.

As I sat on that tiled floor watching the door shake on its hinges, the wall between me and the truth came crumbling down. Mary wasn’t a woman. The university had begun moving transwomen into girl’s dorms, and now one was wearing my friend’s clothes and trying to beat us for saying he couldn’t. In the aftermath of these events, I learned of his official status as transgender along with his well-established record of aggressive behaviour. The university knew all of this going in and still gave him unfettered access to 15 freshmen girls.1 All 15 of our futures, our lives, and our safety were deemed forfeit in the name of faux inclusivity.

Ironically, it was the policy that had meted out appropriate punishment to the offender from the first semester which granted Mary the ‘right’ to move onto our girls-only hall.

The policy supporting this kind of outrage is outlined in a 2016 guidance from the U.S. Department of Education Office of Civil Rights and the U.S. Department of Justice Civil Rights Division, which reads, “As a condition of receiving Federal funds, a school agrees that it will not exclude, separate, deny benefits to, or otherwise treat differently on the basis of sex any person in its educational programs … The Departments treat a student’s gender identity as the student’s sex for purposes of Title IX.”2 This is institutional capture at the highest levels.

In a more overtly totalitarian move, the University of Minnesota recently adopted a “pronoun policy” which allows the school to terminate or expel anyone who fails to refer to staff and/or students with their “preferred pronouns.”3 Representatives of the student senate took issue with this flagrant abuse of power, but the faculty senate approved it, following an intense three years of debate.4 And so, those who should safeguard the right to free speech dragged the school into a no-man’s land of censorship, securing a 4.5-star review on the LGBTQ+ Campus Pride Index site. 5

The next year, I moved into another dorm. At first, it seemed that I was surrounded by other masculine lesbians, and I heaved a sigh of gratitude and relief. However, to my surprise — they all identified as transmen. We became friends and would stay up late playing cards and chatting. In all our conversations, not once did they ever mention wishing to transfer to male dorms. They seemed to thrive in female-only spaces even though they detested being seen as anything remotely close to a woman. For the longest time I struggled to understand why.

In her book Gender Hurts, Sheila Jeffreys states that “For lesbian feminism — or indeed feminism — to exist, it is necessary for women to be able to think of themselves as women and as lesbians. But this is very hard for many young lesbians in the present, who come out into a queer community in which only manhood has value.”6 She hit the nail on the head. We can’t organize or support each other as women if we can’t name ourselves.

While this mass immobilization has impacted all American women at varying levels, it has ripped a vast hole in the lesbian community by peddling us repackaged sexist stereotypes tied up neatly in a rainbow ribbon. We are bombarded with regressive rhetoric: I will never forget opening the HER lesbian dating app’s April newsletter to read the headline, ‘Microdosing testosterone (HRT) — What you need to know.’7 At this point, anyone who refuses to see how lesbians are being directly targeted by the trans pharmaceutical market is in deep denial.8

There are few cases of female erasure more sobering than the complete capture of the National Center for Lesbian Rights. Scroll to the bottom of their website to watch an animation of the original ‘NCLR’ logo expand into ‘NCLGBTQR.’ You might go on a scavenger hunt for mention of lesbian-specific initiatives or female-specific language. If finding next-to-nothing gets too depressing, crack open their 2017-18 annual report. You will find the word ‘woman’ once — in a conservative’s quoted definition of marriage.9

Gender-identity ideology’s destruction of the female category has taken a toll on lesbians’ social lives as well. In the US, there were once approximately 200 lesbian bars, but today only 21 survive.10 The Lesbian Bar Project was launched to promote and preserve this hopeful handful. Yet their mission statement claims “the label ‘Lesbian’ belongs to all people who feel that it empowers them.” The only shred of truth in their mission is this: “When our history isn’t protected, we must protect it ourselves.”11

Gender-identity ideology wants to capture more than institutions: it wants to capture the history of the gay rights movement. The majority of the young US ‘LGBTQ+’ community accepts the doctrine that ‘transwoman and drag queen Marsha P. Johnson threw the first brick at Stonewall and started the riots. Because of her, we owe our rights to transwomen.’ However, Johnson revealed in interview with journalist Eric Marcus that he was neither transgender nor present at the start of the riots.12 Witnesses point to Stormé DeLarverie, Black lesbian drag king and jazz singer, as the one who kicked off the revolt.13 DeLarverie, cuffed and bleeding as the cops dragged her out of the bar, yelled into a crowd of bystanders, “Why don’t you guys do something?”14 which incited the crowd to rebel against the police. She is remembered as a “fierce defender and protector,” who refused to tolerate disrespect.15 Fifty-two years later, in the face of so much corruption, there’s never been a better time to honour her legacy. Heed her call to action.

1 This order of events parallels the more recent case in Loudoun County, Virginia. A boy who self-identifies as a transgirl is now charged with the violent sexual assaults of two girls, in two different schools in the district. The boy was allowed to transfer schools after the first assault, and even after the second (and more violent) attack, the Loudoun County school district adopted a gender-inclusive policy over the objections of many parents. See Graham Linehan, ‘Shenanigans in Loudoun County,’ The Glinner Update, Substack, 14 August 2021. See also this post, with a warning that it includes graphic descriptions of the sexual assaults: Graham Linehan, ‘America wakes up to a nightmare,’ The Glinner Update, Substack, 14 October 2021.

2 Marcia Segal and Vasilikie Demos, Gender Panic, Gender Policy (Bingley: Emerald Publishing, 2017), pp. 220-21.

3 Ian Smith, ‘University of Minnesota pronoun policy should not be enacted,’ Star Tribune, 19 July 2018.

4 Anemona Hartocollis, ‘Gender pronouns can be tricky on campus. Harvard is making them stick,’ New York Times, 19 February 2020.

5 ‘University of Minnesota Twin Cities,’ Campus Pride Index, 2021.

6 Sheila Jeffreys, Gender Hurts: A Feminist Analysis of the Politics of Transgenderism (London and New York: Routledge, 2014), p. 46.

7 Dorothea Delaney, ‘A room of her own: The lesbian dating app that wants to T the gay away,’ Savage Minds, Substack, 29 April 2021.

8 According to a study published by Global Marketing Insights, the global sex reassignment surgery market value will skyrocket from its present $316m value to $1.5b by 2026. This report specifically cites “favorable US policies” as one of the top three growth drivers of this market. See Rupali Swain and Sumant Ugalmugle, ‘Sex Reassignment Surgery Market Size … 2020-26,’ Global Marketing Insights, March 2020.

9 ‘2017-2018 NCLR Annual Report,’ National Center for Lesbian Rights, 2018, p. 10.

10 ‘Here are the final 21 surviving lesbian bars in the U.S.’ Out Traveler, 16 August 2021.

11 Home page, The Lesbian Bar Project.

12 Avery Poerio, ‘No, Marsha P. Johnson didn’t start Stonewall, black lesbians did,’ Vocal Media, 1 May 2021.

13 Poerio.

14 Poerio.

15 Erin Drinkwater, ‘Remembering Storme DeLarverie,’ Go Mag, 14 June 2014.