Issue Five

Absence/Presence

by Sarah Lucia Hoagland

1980s

At Midwest SWIP (Society for Women in Philosophy), María Lugones formed and, with the help of Jackie Anderson, sustained for many years, a Woman of Color Caucus. It gave women of colour, both community women and academics, a place to present their work to each other without white women’s presence (vocal or otherwise), making a space for creative and experimental thinking in new directions. This was the only concurrent session Midwest SWIP scheduled.

This practice, together with the other aspect of it, made blaringly clear over the years to us white women the consequences of the loss of women of colour’s presence: we would not be able to hear those papers, and we would not have the benefit of their thoughts and discussion on the concurrent paper by a white woman. An uncomfortable critical lesson about absence.

CIRCA 2011

A white female student, as the class was discussing relationality and white solipsism, claimed the discussion wasn’t relevant to her because “there are no blacks where I live.”

Another student asked, “Has anyone ever made a racist joke, or a racist comment at a party where you live?” She was silent. “Then there certainly are Blacks where you live.”

As Jackie has noted: Black people are present everywhere in the US.

EARLY 1990s

During discussion after one paper at Midwest SWIP, a white feminist suggested we think about how white women can protect women of colour from being silenced. María and Jackie simultaneously turned and hooted: “Women of colour are not silenced, we have been speaking all along.”

CIRCA 1996

At a philosophy talk a Jewish feminist, considering the ways nice white folks ignore racism, took up a number of issues. Challenging the stereotype of blacks as lazy, she offered fine political analyses of social policies that fail, and argued that “even if certain stereotypes are true for some, it doesn’t mean they will be for their kids too.” She challenged the Moynihan Report, Moynihan’s claim of the failure of the black family and the lack of strong father figures, countering that there were violent gang members coming from communities with strong father figures, notably Italian and Jewish. She continued with many challenges to racist narratives.

Critiques…
…absent Black agency/subjectivity/resistance.

1980s

Ok, so I’m a dyke. If there’s anything I hate, it’s passing men on the street and having my demeanour, behaviour, looks, or anything else remarked on. So I would just pass by, giving no attention, barely allowing any sensing energy to go out except the bit alert for danger, basically not noticing, ignoring.

However, in Chicago, particularly on the North Side (it’s different on the South Side outside of Hyde Park), I found myself in a quandary. If I walked past a black man, fairly purposefully ignoring him, it could/would be interpreted as my racism. However, if I turned to say ‘Hi,’ it could/would be interpreted as a ‘come-on.’

As I bungled through encounters, I started noticing white working-class men passing each other. One would give the other a quick nod and pass on as the other gave a quick nod of acknowledgement back. And, having learned the ‘dyke nod,’ I thought, let’s try it, a nod.

It works.

There’s another piece: I’m older now, well actually, old, and in my neighbourhood, I regularly say hello and smile at a black man (or woman) walking.

CIRCA 2004,
writing sarcasm in a moment of irritation with white women’s anti-racism groups:

Ahem, ahem, AHEM. Excuse me, may I have your attention?
Thank you.
Whiteness.
Yes, whiteness. WHITENESS. WHITENESS.
It’s invisible.
Here, look, see! It’s invisible, look here, look here, oh yes and over here. Oh, and there, there, and right here, oh, and look at this. And then there’s this. And this. Wow, and look at that. Geesh, look over there. It’s all so invisible!
I was blind, but now you see.

Ok, ok, ok! Hold on a minute, we’re almost done.
Now here’s what you need to do. Unlearn your racism: DON’T THINK OF A BLUE HORSE. Got it? Ok next, recognize your privilege and finish your peas. Think of all the starving children in Africa.

Ok, I’m ready now.

Ahem. We have something to say:
We are WHITE. We have PRIVILEGE. We are your OPPRESSOR.

CIRCA 1978

It was an NWSA meeting or some other organization of feminists. One session listed was on issues faced by Black women. I went, wanting to learn. I saw I was the only white woman, and trying to be a responsible feminist, as they began I asked if they would rather have a Black women-only session. Immediately one woman spoke up and declared to the others at the session, we’re not spending time with this.

And they didn’t.

CIRCA 1993

One Central APA (American Philosophical Association) meeting, a number of us were asked to speak on a panel organized by the Committee on the Status of Women to give testimony on discrimination we’d experienced. I described what had happened to me, others told their stories, all to varying reactions of belief. I left the session uneasy, wishing I had not gone, had not participated.

Later I thought about my reactions. Certainly I had told my stories before, but there was something about this APA session, something absent. What was the energy of that room? Maybe other women did not want to hear this as normal, did not want to think about structural and systematic framing. Instead we who were telling our stories were telling something individual that happened to us, something out of the normal.

Prior to that moment, when I told my stories I was a resister, surrounded by feminist and lesbian activists and existing within the context of the feminist movement: This is what I faced, and this is what I did, this is what I came through, this is how I continued on. But at the panel, I came away feeling, for the first time, a victim, absent of any agency.

Later I came to understand this is why some women students would refuse feminism: rejecting the agency of feminism, they saw and didn’t want to see themselves as victims.

CIRCA THE 2000s

As I was teaching various classes at Northeastern, I came to realize that it was much easier for me to teach radical material on racism and colonialism than it was to teach radical material on sexism and misogyny. I realized that I felt much more relaxed and confident introducing radical material focused on colonialism and racism.

As I periodically thought about this in talking with students about class material, it hit me: in talking about racism, I was in the structural power position. I was the teacher, of course. But also I was white and could counter doubt and reluctance and denial and confusion from that position, assure students, particularly white students, that something we’d read by an author, Black or Latino, male and female, challenging white sensibilities, was accurate. I realized that addressing racism and colonialism, I was not easily dismissed in getting students to take up the material.

But introducing radical material on misogyny and sexism, while I was the teacher, I would be dismissed, as was true of colleagues of colour addressing racism. After all, I wasn’t objective (as one of my white students argued to me about one of the Black authors we read analysing racism). Unless it was a class of all or mostly women there to absorb and digest radical feminist material, by having students directly take up issues of sexism I found my credible authority, my presence, diminished. I remembered my testimony years earlier at the Central APA and realized that in directly addressing misogyny and sexism in my classes, it was much harder for me to maintain class energy and not be dismissed as a victim who was using the pulpit to whine.

At times, I flat-out avoided it.

CIRCA 2000

I was enjoying working on John Austin’s performative utterances (not speech acts) in my senior seminar on Philosophy of Language. In particular, we were thinking about ways to render a performative utterance infelicitous, to undermine it. In that section of the class, we’d read Words That Wound, Only Words, and Excitable Speech. I loved Charles Lawrence’s proposal that every time a racist act occurred on campus, the administration should add another person of colour to the faculty as a strategy to render such behaviour infelicitous—in such cases, having the opposite of the desired results.

At one point when I was meeting with students to discuss their final seminar papers, I suggested to a middle-aged African American man that he do his paper on Austin, using the example of hate speech to explore the theory and ways of creating infelicities. As was my practice in classes, I encouraged students to take theoretical material and try applying it to some experience in their life to see if the theory was useful in framing and thinking about it (e.g. Foucault on discipline discussed by a student who’d been in the foster system, military, jail, etc.). I was thinking this student could take something he had experienced and explore it using Austin’s theory.

He was quiet at first. And when I talked to him about his final paper the next week, again suggesting Austin and hate speech, he said:

“I don’t want to.”

CIRCA 2003,
writing in another moment of irritation:

I am racist. God this is hard for me. But I am going to drag it out in excruciating detail so you can see what I have done, how I have betrayed you, how I am like all the other white scum you’ve had to deal with. So that you can see that I can be your ally.

And you other whites, you white scum, know yourself for what you are and repent.

But back to me. God I’m awful. How could I have done this? I can’t trust myself anymore, I will listen to what you say and do exactly as I imagine you want me to, I will prove myself by recanting so that I can distance myself from other white women and prove to you that I am the exception, that I am not really white, that you can trust me, that I am worthy of being your ally. God I disgust myself.

But I am showing you this so you will know that you can trust me, don’t need to walk away from me. You can see how brave I am. By exposing myself this way, I have made it so you don’t need to point out my racism. I’ve already done so; in fact for you to do so now would be rather crass.

After all, I have made myself vulnerable to you. And you, now, are my ally.

1961

While living in Chile I read The Ugly American, a fictionalized account of Americans abroad. Exactly, I thought. Most Americans here, Gringos, would not learn much Spanish or engage with Chileno culture. They socialized with each other, had no Chileno friends.

Two years later, living in Panamá, I could tell when a tourist ship had arrived. Presence leading to absence. The city’s energy shifted.

NOVEMBER 2018

So I was sitting in the airport waiting for my flight. I reached down to plug in my iPhone to recharge, and a woman two seats over asked if she could plug in too. I said of course and suggested she move to the seat next to me. We began chatting. She was waiting for a later flight, going home to Georgia having come from Wisconsin, where she had been visiting her mother. As can happen among chatting women strangers, at least ones I encounter, we started talking about our dogs (or cats). She told me about hers and I told her about mine, of course getting out a picture. And we talked about dog training methods, giving tips, strategies for reducing separation anxieties. We talked about dogs we’d lost, and the courage it takes to welcome spirits, especially rescues, into your life when you know their life-span is much shorter than yours. We were sitting there, chatting, for 45 minutes or more. I was beginning to tune out, chatting not really being my forte, as we got onto the elections from two days earlier, and the ballots then being recounted. I made some quick remark, probably about the intensity, but I don’t remember. And she said, “It’s the blacks.”

I went cold, what the fuck do I do now? I said some drivel like whites are just as corrupt if not more corrupt than any black people in office, not even sure if she was talking about Chicago or Atlanta, or even Madison. And she replied something, I don’t know what, as the barriers went up, I was sitting there still in shock.

I was floored. Here was what I thought was a very pleasant white woman, probably about ten years younger than me, not particularly excited about having visited her mother, nor about going home to her husband, but happy talking about dogs and various dog-human interactions, someone I’d felt comfortable with in friendly exchange, someone taking me thoroughly by surprise. As I reflected on it the next day, relaying this to others, it sank in.

This was something I knew perfectly well but hadn’t experienced so viscerally: that someone I could feel very comfortable, even ‘safe’ with was someone dangerous. Such a disconnect between spaces: a space, an interaction among whites where I am comfortable and at ease, the space where Black friends walking in are in danger.

CIRCA 1995

I asked her to come to my Women’s Studies class to read/perform some of her poetry, poetry which every time reaches into your soul to have a conversation with it. She had one poem (among many) I really wanted the class to experience. It was about moviemakers being so clever, movies about women and girls attacked, slashed, raped. Movies whose story lines have us questioning why the woman attacked did that or didn’t do this; movies that have us wanting her to be taught a lesson.

e nina j writes of violence head on.

She resisted my request for a while, performing at the Black woman-centred POW WOW (Performers or Writers on Women, Words on Women’s issues) weekly gatherings on the South Side. But one day she said yes, she’d come read in my class.

That day she arrived, really nervous, and we walked to class. She sat down to read and said, looking down, “Don’t look at me, I can’t perform the piece if you look at me.”

Jackie kept the faith, was her mentor over the years. Got this Black Lesbian to come to Midwest SWIP as a community member and read both in the Women of Color Caucus and the Midwest SWIP meeting as a whole. She again not looking at anyone as she performed. Yet saying clearly and emphatically to white women: there is a pile of shit in the living room. Don’t tell me about it, clean it up.

This Black Lesbian who now looks her audiences in the eye, and calls some forward to join her coming forward.

This Black Lesbian who is quick to forgive stupidities, like the time recently when I was hyper bossy with her after one of her performances at the 2018 Ohio Lesbian Festival, saying, after I apologized, “I love you sis.”

This long-time friend of Anne’s and mine, this performer whose poetry enters your spirit and takes up residence, this poet whose performances offer more beauty and clarity than any philosophical argument I have encountered (and I love many philosophical arguments), this Amazon gets nervous before having dinner with us. As we, differently, get nervous before having dinner with her.

APRIL 1968

The energy changed on campus. The few black students I’d been sometimes hanging out with were no longer hanging out. Black students campus-wide stopped talking to us white students.

An undergraduate at the University of Colorado, I had been taking a new course that had us reading Huey Newton, Bobby Seale, Angela Davis, the Black Panthers, SNCC, Fanon, and more. The class, the students, black and white, the white (I believe Jewish) professor, and the books were incredible. On campus the Black students were demonstrating, demanding Black Studies, and the administration was refusing to meet with them because they were . . . well, demonstrating, and Black. Comfortable with talking to the dean, who I had met at a campus philosophy gathering, I went to his office. Using every bit of my white middle-class training, I assured him these students had a legitimate request.

Then this change on campus that April, with Dr King’s assassination, the loss of the energetic presence of the Black students . . . it was palpable. I was hurt, I felt hurt. And sad. And in critical ways, left alone. But I learned two important lessons.

Sometimes you close ranks, and what presence means.

2018

Lucy came to our place in Michigan for a few nights.

Presences around our place in Michigan: around the house is a few acres of woods, including poison ivy and bog, but beautiful. Across the road is the public access site (complete with outhouse) to one of Michigan’s thousands of small lakes. Often visited by locals on a work break because it’s soul satisfying and because, well, it has an outhouse. Ice fishing when the lake is frozen over. One white regular, always saying hi that summer when he saw us, showing us what he’d caught, small fish he was bringing home for the stray kitten he’d rescued, a kitten who had refused all other food until the man happened upon this solution. No doubt, like most white men, a Trump supporter. Adjacent to the lake is a patchwork of communities, each with their own interactions and legacies. Wetlands are interspersed through waves of humans. A little south and down the road is the Rush Lake Indian Cemetery, burial site of Simon Pokagon, Chief of the Potawatomi Indians, established 1851. It’s a small cemetery, with neighbouring roof-covered picnic tables and freestanding fire pits, surrounded by grass and woods. Periodically, Potawatomi celebrations are held there. It’s an eight-minute drive to the 24-hour Four Winds Casino Hartford, which is home to 560 slot machines and nine game tables (no entertainment, and no real food). Much of the far lakeside has small homes where over the years SUVs with Illinois license plates have replaced pickups with Michigan plates in the driveways. A holdout to this trend is a long-standing trailer park north of us on the lake for ‘snowbirds’ who grew up around here. On the other side of our house, farmland takes up most of the acreage, growing mainly GMO corn and soy for ethanol and livestock feed, both crops locally useless. But big agricultural business and GMO farming is established here. This farmland houses communities of migrant workers in permanent ‘temporary’ housing. Pesticide use is prevalent, and we can bring samples of our well water in once a year to a state lab for free contamination testing. Every year the DNR (Department of Natural Resources), which is in charge of our lake, dumps chemicals in the lake and posts signs against swimming for a day after the dumping. Livestock is warned away for three days. We stick with the livestock rules. State police are a rare sight at the public access, but the outhouse hosts its share of regular visits of officers from neighbouring towns and tribal police. Further north, the town of Covert has a great rib place owned by a black couple with a sauce to die for, the husband holding the secret recipe, the wife a welcoming soul, and whose overhead TV had on Al Sharpton talking about gay rights the first time I walked in. Covert has about 20% Blacks and 25% Latinos, and a history with white farmers respecting and protecting Black farmers against government officials after 1865 when slavery ‘ended’ in the South (not necessarily in the North); for example, the Covert school board neglected to include the race of the neighbourhood school children in their report to state officials who were collecting information on schools in towns, for otherwise the Black students would have been forced out of the school. And someone had donated a large number of abolitionist books in those years for Covert’s small public library. (For more of this story, read A Stronger Kinship, Anna-Lisa Cox.) And a couple of miles closer to us, a Mexican market/restaurant run by a Mexican woman who was on top of information about everyone coming and going, including me.

Lucy came to visit Anne and me in Michigan.

We had invited Lucy to come on different occasions. Jackie regularly came to our place in Michigan. It’s a great place to come for quiet, to write, to relax, to play games, swim, walk in the woods. Dykes gathered here in August for the trek to Festival.

On this occasion, Lucy said she’d like to come for a few days so we could help her ‘edit’ her book of poetry. “What?” I asked? “Me? I’m not a poet, and I’m white.” “Yes,” she said. Turns out she wanted help in figuring out how to organize her poems.

Lucy is a city girl. But she was raised country and her daughter went to college a little north of here, so Lucy knew the area, and preferred to drive through Michigan without using the interstate.

She arrived, and settled in and relaxed and worked on her poems. I started reading them and started arranging them (they were in alphabetical order when she brought them). I have utterly adored her poems for years; she’d read them at performance gatherings on the South Side embracing those listening. Her ability to be in a situation, describe it with such precision and detail, and bring her audience physically, emotionally, in spirit with her emerges in every poem. I was thrilled she had decided to create a book after Jackie’s death as Jackie had been her strongest mentor/encourager. So here she was, to work on finalizing it. As we were walking around the yard with the dogs, and she was taking it all in, I said I’d love to see what she’d write in describing this place.

The next afternoon we walked across the road to the lake’s public access. We stood there, looking for the swan family, looking out across the water, the clouds lazily moving by.

A car drove in and we both turned. A man got out and walked to the outhouse. I would have waved had he looked our way. I turned back to the lake, to the swan family, but kept aware of his presence at my back. He was in a uniform, ‘DNR’ written on his car. Lucy did not turn her back on him. Having used the outhouse, he returned to his car and left. Shortly we returned to our house.

A while later Lucy said that she had been meaning to ask Anne if she should carry her ID to cross the road to the lake. In Chicago she would never go anywhere without her ID. But she hadn’t asked about carrying ID across the road here. (Had she asked me, I would have said, of course not.) But as she told me she had not asked Anne about carrying her ID to cross to the lake, I realized that when the government car drove in, her heart had sped up. I had been aware but not alert. Aware of the DNR guy and what he was up to, but not alert to Lucy’s tense shift in energy.

That afternoon she said, I’ll tell you what I would write: When I came and we were hanging out and walking in the yard and eating and talking about poetry and talking about Jackie and gossiping, there was Anne & Sarah & me. And then there was

Anne & Sarah…and me.

THREE VIGNETTES, NEBRASKA, CIRCA 1975-76

She came bursting into my office, “You’re teaching Fanon now, wow, never thought I’d see that in a class.” I was using Wretched of the Earth in a philosophy class to open discussion about violence, how Fanon expanded the notion of violence way beyond typical philosophical analysis. Harriet couldn’t take the course, but we became friends.

One day she called, freaked out: “Regina’s mom threw her out of the house, she has no place to stay.” I told her Regina could stay with me, I had a spare bedroom in the house I was renting. My belief at the time (and basically still now) is that if a wounded being can have a place to retreat to, away from violence and basic pressures of survival, they can have a chance to rest and collect themselves, possible heal some. Rwgina moved in, and I pretty much let her be alone. (I could tell you more but that would leave me too much in control of the narrative.) Over time we stopped communicating. Regina had joined the basketball team and was apparently quite good. She also had started up with a Black lesbian, Twin, who had absolutely no use for me. At the end, angry and looking for a fight, Regina came in one day and said she’d quit the basketball team ’cause I was going to brag about her success on the team as my accomplishment (probably Twin’s narrative). I was shocjed, hadn’t accorred to me. But, trying to be open – middle-class white girl sensitivity and all – I didn’t say “No,” I responded, “It’s possible” (remember, I’m teaching philosophy, the opposite of anything not analytic is possible). “It’s possible,” I said, “but to the extent it’s true, I’ll work on it” (intending to really think about this).

Regina glared.

She moved out soon after. I never heard from her again. I still think of her, and of me, then.

I needed Harriet to translate between us, Regina and me.

But by then, Harriet had drifted away. We had been friends for a while, until the language of meaning and sensibility I was raised with took me too far from having anything useful or interesting to say given her language of meaning and sensibility. Unlnowingly, I lost what she offered.

…

A Black woman in my feminist philosophy class that year ‘discovered’ that I was a lesbian and freaked, approaching me somewhere away from class to confirm for herself by my response. Which was not to deny it. I could see the horror in her eyes.

She never came back to class after that nor turned in any remaining assignments. She had been doing well up to then in the class. At the end of the semester, I was faced with giving her a grade. My usual choice, when students hadn’t finished everything, was to turn in an Incomplete. I knew, however, that she would see that as me trying to keep control of her or make her come to me.

I stared at the grade book…….and turned in an A.

…

A close friend gave me an LP with the 1976 Broadway production of Ntozake Shange’s for colored girls who have considered suicide/when the rainbow is enuf. My friend had been a drama student at Vassar, and remarked that if there were more parts like that, she would have stayed in acting. The performance, tense, moving, angry, beautiful; so much faced, addressed, stories told, and finally, “I found god in myself, and I loved her fiercely.” The intensity of hearing the recording was like very little else.

I announced in my feminist philosophy class one day that I was going to bring the recording in to play the next class. One Black student made a small gasp. I noticed. And I knew there was intense criticism by some Black male commentators. But, I thought, when they hear it, the three Black women students in my class, they will see. The next class I carried in my turntable and little speakers and set it all up and played it.

The three were absent that day, absent for this presentation in the presence of white students and a white professor.

CIRCA 2004,
ok, one more moment of irritation:

Omph, what was that? A phantom, perhaps? No, a trace, a supplement, an excess. Aha!
I quote sub-them, therefore they are written.

I theorize sub-them. I am Professor Theorist of Academentia; I theorize, thus sub-they language. Indeed, deconstructing hegemonic discourse makes it possible for sub-them to language.

Should I engage sub-them, I might become languaged, spoken about, inscribed; I might lose my grounding in the hegemonic discourse I deconstruct. I myself might become present.

Rather I walk through this relationality of difference deftly but with perfect comfort, no essentialist identity washes off on me. I deconstruct.

Yeah though I walk through a field of deleted agents, I move at will.

I quote sub-them, therefore I write.

CIRCA 2006

Teaching critical race theory, I started with a problematic: critical race theorists argue that the US is not just historically or contingently racist. It is structurally racist, racism being at the very structure of US law and its institutions. These theorists and activists don’t believe that changing laws will change that structure. Yet, they are lawyers and students of law of colour who, while recognizing the structural framing of the legal system, nevertheless work within it.

So here’s the puzzle: if these theorists believe that changing laws will not change the structure, then why are they lawyers, activists, law professors? Why, while recognizing the structural nature of the legal system, do they nevertheless choose to work there?

Strategies: facing the ahistoricism in the alleged neutrality and objectivity of the US legal system and recognizing US law is held together with bailing string and bubble gum, strategies emerge.

A critical race theorist quoted Mrs Biona MacDonald as saying: “I lives to harass white folks.”

CIRCA 1977

It was Sally’s turn to have a potluck for her CR group. She had recently rented a bedroom to a Black lesbian, Deidre, who was my lover at the time and had moved from Chicago to attend the Wisconsin Conservatory of Music, in exchange for babysitting Sally’s three adopted, mix-raced kids when Sally was working or otherwise out. Deidre also had an outside job while attending the conservatory to make ends meet, and she was hardly ever around when Sally was home, or when she was around, was up in her room studying. But she and Sally would hang out briefly when Deidre was getting something to eat and they soon became friends.

Sally had told her CR group that she had rented to a Black lesbian, but none of them had ever seen her, since Deidre was always busy. And in telling me this story, Deidre speculated that Sally’s friends were beginning to doubt this absent housemate of Sally’s actually existed.

So the night of the potluck arrived. Sally had repeatedly invited Deidre to join them, and Deidre repeatedly explained that she had to practise and study upstairs, also not particularly wanting to hang out with a bunch of women she didn’t know. But Sally, her friends having arrived, asked Deidre if she would get the tea and coffee from the kitchen. And as Deidre brought them, Sally asked, “Deidre, would you mind getting the crackers and cheese?” And then, “Deidre, would you please bring the milk?” Deidre knew that Sally was just wanting her to make an appearance, wanting to show her off as really existing—‘proof of life,’ if you will—and hopefully have her stay and join the CR group for a few minutes.

With Sally’s next request, Deidre put her hand on her back and bent over, slowly shuffling toward the kitchen saying, “Yaas, Miz Ann.”

Sally blanched as Deidre chuckled to herself.

1978

I hadn’t been teaching at Northeastern long. I was out as a lesbian, had been hired in Philosophy to teach feminist philosophy under encouragement from Women’s Studies. At some point, a Black lesbian came to my office to talk. She wanted lesbian energy. It turned out that the nationalism of several of the African American faculty had left her isolated. Sometime later, at a Women’s Studies faculty meeting, I mentioned lesbians, in particular Black lesbians, and was told by one of the African American faculty members that homosexuality was a Greek word and that the movement was designed to destroy the Black family. There were no homosexuals, there was no word, even, in Africa. I was in no way prepared to figure out how to address these claims of absence. But I had raised the issue, I was good with that much, and periodically did it again.

A year or so after that, I met African American lesbian philosopher Jackie Anderson (actually we were introduced by a Jewish lesbian wanting us to know each other because we were both philosophers), and we rockily began what became a 40-year-long deep friendship.

Anyway, early on I talked to her about some of what was going on on campus and some of the things I did, including raising questions about acknowledging Black lesbians in the Women’s Studies meetings. She listened, looked at me, then said: “You’re one of those white girls who, when things are going along just fine, comes along and stirs things up.”

What??!! Here I was fighting the good fight, struggling against odds, challenging injustice (fist raised) . . . I was totally deflated (fist back down). And I privately nursed my wounds as we continued to get to know each other.

And then one day a couple of years later, I woke up and said to myself, you know what? I AM one of those white girls, that’s what I do!

Years later, when I told this story at a gathering honouring Jackie, she just laughed.

CIRCA 1990

At a CPIC gathering (Philosophy, Interpretation and Culture, SUNY, Binghamton) called by María Lugones, I was participating in a number of evocative workshops. The last day everyone was going around with some final thoughts. There were maybe 20 of us. Three white women spoke, describing guilt and despair concerning racism, one or two breaking down in tears. A Latino, Manuel, spoke of difficulty regarding his father and sister—his father domineering and restrictive with his younger sister, she struggling against their father. He talked of trying to find ways to give his sister backup and yet not dishonour his father, caught in between them and wanting not to be thrown out of the house.

The contrast stuck with me, and I kept coming back to it, thinking about my irritation at the general framing of white women’s anti-racism declarations, particularly in the 1980s. I imagined being in a room that included anti-sexist white men confessing guilt and despair concerning sexism. And I thought about Manuel. He was describing a complicated situation where he found himself needing to do something and also limited in what he could do. What I could see was that he was struggling. He was working to figure things out while recognizing that he couldn’t make everything ok.

Going over my weekend notes and thinking about this later, I realized that what matters to me is that someone is doing their work, struggling to figure something out, often failing, carrying on, trying again having learned something. What I want is to see that people are doing their work. It’s not about whether what they do is successful or not (when it’s not, we often learn something for the next time). It matters that we are assessing situations, recognizing patterns, acknowledging them, and making choices.

CIRCA 2018

Recently, thinking about this, again, and talking with my partner, she began: Manuel recognized there was a risk he was unwilling to take; he accepted that and struggled to function within his location. We white women tend not to be willing to acknowledge that there are risks we are unwilling to take. Instead we say, “Well it wouldn’t do any good if I …” Or we beat ourselves up and cry. Part of the myth of ideal white womanhood is self-sacrifice—she should risk everything unstintingly, and without expecting recognition, for those she loves—husband, children, parents. We are supposed to self-destruct and not see it as self-destruction, to see our absence as fulfilment.

Manuel decided there was a limit. We white women may recognize we’re not willing to risk something, but when we do that, we often get belligerent about it and devalue it precisely because we are supposed to throw ourselves under the bus for important things.

María talks of white women’s failure of love for women of colour. White women are mostly trained that love is self-sublimation and self-sacrifice, that if we are worth anything then we can fix it, or die trying. So when we are not going to throw ourselves under the bus, we deflect, often reacting by crying and feeling guilty. That doesn’t change behaviour, it just leaves us blocked. And that is not seeing women of colour.

That ‘not seeing’ is the actual failure of love.

2016

The three of us, Anne, Jackie, and I, formed a lesbian group in 1992 that met once a month and had a summer retreat. It went through various permutations, and currently there are ten of us who meet once a month with two four-day retreats.

In the 1990s, ILS (Institute of Lesbian Studies) was open to new members, and Jackie would meet all kinds of lesbians in the bar, Black and white and Latina. Some she would invite to our gatherings. Once she invited a white lesbian who over time decided I was her academic mother and she should rebel. Another time she invited a white woman who, it turned out, was thinking she might not be a lesbian.

Anne and I sat down with Jackie and had a talk with her. Laughing, we all agreed that from a distance, Jackie couldn’t detect white-girl-crazy.

…

Somewhere in the late 90s, early 2000s, the group solidified into ten members, and with one other exception, Jackie was the only Black lesbian. Differences in religious background, in culture, 70s choices (e.g. hippie), in class, somewhat in age.

As the years went on, at certain times Jackie expressed her rage and despair at the destruction of the Black communities she was part of, and more generally in the country. We white women would listen, take it in, and be changed by it.

She would also on occasion talk about anger at things going on in her Black communities. Our little dog, Raven, would jump up on the back of the couch and comfort her, licking her ear, as Jackie denied that the BS she was recounting bothered her.

At one point, Anne and I realized that it was among this group of lesbians, having been gathering for 25 years, this group Jackie was fond of saying was never meant to be, it was among this group that Jackie could express her rage. With us. This space, with trust built over the decades, had become such a space for this possibility at critical times for her. In talking to us, being with us, she said to Anne and me she could remember why she wasn’t climbing a bell tower and shooting all white people. She didn’t want to climb that tower. She didn’t want to believe it was necessary.

…

In 2016, a year and four months before she died, she and I were arguing in the car, returning from the Ohio Lesbian Festival. She said that the organizers of The Womb, two Black lesbians creating a space for Black lesbians to talk of things once a month, Lucy and e nina j, with allies being welcome, Lucy and e nina j, wanted her to give a talk at the next Womb. Jackie told me she didn’t want to.

I was angry with her, “How could you not, Jackie? Your ability to put things together, the things you know and understand, the way you have of articulating things … They deeply respect you and admire you. They want to hear you. You’re a teacher, a philosophy teacher, and an activist, and you have the ability to pull so many things together in ways that get people to think.” I went on and on, haranguing her, a normal way our arguments went. (Through all the years, our biggest argument was over Plato. I thought going for perfection would lead to a boring state of being. She thought perfection was, well, perfect.) Except with this argument, this time, she remained quiet as I went on.

Then she finally said, “If I spoke at The Womb, I would have to say what I see, that there is no hope for Black people, that we have lost a generation, that we have lost, period.”

I was quiet for some time, and finally agreed: “No, Jackie, you can’t say that there.”

2018

Reading one of her poems at The Womb, South Side Chicago, spoken word/poetry monthly gathering, not that many of us there that night, Lucy began talking about writing. She described her poetry as lying. My critical ears perked up, as I have over the years countered arguments that fiction is a lie and opposed to objective fact which is truth. Ready to suggest she not downplay the work, as many who have argued that fiction is a lie have done, I and others, listening, pressed her to say more.

She said, poetry is a lie because you’re putting together, packaging, a scene.
We were not satisfied.

So she said, the lie is always standing on the rim and trying not to get wet.
Hummm.

She said the lie is trying to save myself, not looking at how bad I was hurting.
Silence.

She said, the lie: how to make the picture pretty enough to be palatable.

Sarah Lucia Hoagland is a philosopher dyke, or a dyke philosopher.