Issue Five

Editorial Statement

by Esmée Streachailt

The US never stops unfolding its fanged naiveté. From the brutal optimism of Secretary of State Rumsfeld to the facile credulity of President Biden believing the Taliban would ever aspire to international norms, the US is always sharing its crises with the world. Gullible citizens are as seduced by QAnon as we once were by charismatic snake-oil salesmen. In our denial of the generational harms of Manifest Destiny and the antebellum enslavement-based economy we have always been a ‘post-truth’ culture.

The US is an intensification mechanism for whatever industry or ideology flavours the historical soup. Anti-mask-or-vax Republicans are losing five citizens to every one Democrat to the Delta variant. Hospitals in Republican-led states are so overwhelmed that one teen’s appendix burst before he could be triaged. Meanwhile, on the left we’ve returned to a salty old patriarchal theme: are women the same species as men, or are men so much more human they can also be women? One has to wonder if the political class even senses the contradiction between Self-ID and women’s rights. They won’t have time to figure that out as they fend off the constitutional challenge to Roe v. Wade laid down in Texas this summer. The considerate patrons of OnlyFans accounts take umbrage that the platform would put their masturbation facilitators at risk of ‘real and dangerous prostitution’ rather than ever imagining how women, especially marginalized and racialized women, might live well without selling their bodies. The US didn’t invent pornography, but it did realize its ultimate form in the rape videos on Pornhub and the snuff films that so ired Andrea Dworkin. The US didn’t invent the gender system and its support of male domination, but it is the home of gender-identity ideology as conceived by a few, very rich white males bored with their side of the stereotyped coin. 

What becomes of women in this new historical situation? Given this country’s historical predisposition for rendering its Others un-human, I am not optimistic. As with our insouciant attitude toward the planet’s resources and systems, this country thinks women can continue to absorb whatever neglect or violence it dishes out, no matter how intensified the impacts might be by class, race, sexuality, or disability. Women are still America’s social safety net, expected to firebomb our careers when the nation goes into quarantine. The right codes us ‘host bodies,’ even while the left codes us ‘birthing bodies’ and thinks access to our wombs is a right of every infertile couple. Never mind that the international surrogacy industry preys on women in some of the poorest or most politically unstable places in the world.

Both incels and transactivists agree that women valuing our own bodies, life projects, and pleasure is a bigoted relic of an uncaring past and they should have sexual access to us, or our existence, for the peace of the community. What is a bigoted relic of a colonialist capitalist past is the impunity with which men working the natural gas fields in the northern Great Plains (and other regions) have assaulted Indigenous women. Where ‘host/birthing bodies’ intersect, these apparently opposed factions can be seen to agree at the deep structural level: women should shut up and serve.

THE RADICAL NOTION exists because we believe feminism needs independent spaces and platforms, created by women, where women can present and develop our own analysis, unmediated by patriarchal lenses of any kind. The need for this movement-building project is nowhere more urgent than the USA, where some feminists have taken the profoundly counterproductive decision to ally with the very organizations who are pushing deeply anti-feminist ideas around the globe.

There is no reason to trust that the US will hit the brakes on these accelerating tensions. The US’s internal contradictions have been so exacerbated by our neoliberal-action-movie car chase that we’re only a beat away from an engine exploding and taking two parked cars with us as we careen into them, freeze-frame of the Left and Right throwing punches in the front seat. But, there is reason to understand us. Our moral and intelligence failures shape the world, for now, if mostly by betraying it. I look on the Kurds, Afghans, Iraqis, and Palestinians — especially their women — with a shame that is almost impossible to articulate. Keeping a watchful eye on our fractious elaboration of patriarchy is in your best feminist interest.