by Vojin Saša Vukadinović
Editors’ Note: This is an edited version of an interview that appeared in German in the June 2021 edition of Jahrbuch Sexualitäten, reprinted here with kind permission. THE RADICAL NOTION is a female-only space, and this is the first time that we’ve included any words by a man. We have made an exception in this case because this interview with Jane was conducted for another publication and printed only in German: we thought readers would welcome the opportunity to read it in English.
Vojin Saša Vukadinović: Please tell me a little bit about your intellectual development.
Jane Clare Jones: I was raised in a small town on the South-East coast of England, where I went to the local state grammar school. The year before we took our A Levels, the headmaster of my school put us in his car, drove us to Cambridge, and showed us around, to try and make it seem accessible to us. The place looked like a fairy tale to me, so I thought I’d give it a go, and luckily, I was interviewed by a lovely man who was interested in what I knew rather than making me feel stupid. I was offered a place. Like most British schoolchildren, I read Nineteen Eighty-Four in my early teens, and in some ways, it is still the book that has most marked my intellectual life. I have always been concerned with the relations between individuals and society, the nature of power, structures of domination and how they impact how we perceive or schematize reality. In Cambridge I studied Social and Political Science and read a lot of Marxism, critical theory, and deconstruction. I became fascinated with understanding the way binary hierarchies distort our perception of reality, the way we fall into ‘either/or’ ways of thinking when the truth is most often ‘both/and,’ and what this has to do with the mechanics of domination. Although nowadays universities are awash with a crass idealist form of post-structuralism, the British academy has never been very interested in my work, so I didn’t get a lot of support at Cambridge and thought maybe an academic life wasn’t for me. Nevertheless, I kept thinking. In my late 20s my best friend and I started doing what I now understand to be consciousness raising with each other, analysing how our experiences of the world were affected by our being female, and she began reading a lot of feminist theory. In around 2003, she put a book by Luce Irigaray in my hand. I only understood maybe one sentence in every five, but I had a very strong visceral reaction to it. I remember sitting in my garden reading Speculum of the Other Woman, with shivers going through my body, knowing that I needed to understand it. So, at that point, I went back to start my postgraduate work, which was basically structured around reading everything I needed to be able to understand that book.
What about it appealed to you initially?
I was drawn into it because of the analysis of binary hierarchy, the account of how our intellectual systems, and Western philosophy, slice up and order the world in order to dominate and appropriate it, and because it made me understand very clearly that this distorting, hierarchizing mechanism is the intellectual core of patriarchal gender, and is bound up with the domination of women, the material world, and the earth. As I said, I had long been interested in binary hierarchy and why we keep making these stupid analytic mistakes — ‘either it is the mind or the body,’ ‘either it is nature or culture,’ when quite evidently it is both — and I was doing consciousness raising with my best friend, and Speculum brought all that together as part of the same system, and suddenly everything in me went ‘click.’ It also helped me understand what had happened to me in Cambridge, and why I kept getting quite dismissive or hostile reactions to the kinds of things I was saying; that allowed me to develop a kind of oppositional confidence in my intellectual work. If you are doing feminism in the Anglo-American academy and most men are really enthusiastic and supportive of what you’re doing, you’re doing it wrong.
You got into feminist theory when the gender paradigm was already flourishing in universities, effectively re-evaluating the entire epistemological past. Some of your major references were either officially ‘out’ at that time — Andrea Dworkin for example — or debatable, such as Carol Gilligan’s work.
Indeed. As I said, my trajectory was Marxism, critical theory, deconstruction, post-structural feminism, and then from there, radical and difference feminism. I was never interested in Foucault or queer theory. It has no explanatory power. The strand of post-structuralism I consider to be feminist — Derrida and Irigaray, coming via de Beauvoir on the one hand, and Heidegger on the other — is completely different to the one that runs from Hegel to Lacan and from there to Foucault and then Butler. Both forms of post-structuralism are critiques of identity and of a certain kind of Western, egoic subjectivity. But the masculinist strand thinks that lack of self-identity is a terrible, lamentable tragedy, and that we are necessarily trapped inside the desire for it even if it is impossible, and because of that, it also tends to think that the only way to escape the imperialism of the ego would be to smash it all to pieces, which is just another kind of phallic ‘either/or’ response — either there is all ego or there is no ego. Butler, for example, basically thinks that you can’t escape the structures of domination, that they are constitutive of subjectivity, and consequently, while you can play with gender/hierarchy, there is no possibility of getting outside it. Everything here is structured by the inheritance of the Hegelian master/slave dialectic … by the assumption of fundamental hostility, and the thought that all interrelation must be structured by me trying to impose my sovereignty on you. That’s an incredibly masculinist assumption. The truth is that we can think subjectivity in another way than the way it has been thought by the masculinist subject. We can think about mutual interrelation and mutual recognition. We don’t, it turns out, have to be narcissists. Unsurprisingly, this is more evident to the sort of people who mother, because the maternal dyad is the first form of relation, and it’s not a ‘fight to the death for pure prestige.’
The phenomenon you are alluding to, transactivism and its rhetorics, partly builds on poststructuralist thinking, though—which might seem paradoxical at first, given the staunch identitarian premises you’ve just pointed out.
Yeah, gender identitarianism retains a lot of the ostensible lingo of post-structuralism—‘smash the binary’ being an obvious example … and note again, ‘smash,’ that’s the phallic way of thinking it—but has completely betrayed its ontological roots. Butler, who is supposed to be anti-identitarian, is now sitting up there as the High Priestess of Genderology, which is the most sovereigntist, masculinist, dominating political system imaginable. Of course, this is perfectly shown by the pronoun protocol, which is precisely an exercise in imposing your own self-image onto someone else, backed up by threats of sanctions if they don’t submit to recognizing you exactly as you dictate they should. It could not get more Hegelian.
We will get back to this in a moment. I think it is important to clarify your position first. You consider yourself to be a difference feminist, a position usually labelled as ‘essentialist’ by the camp you have just criticized.
The question of essentialism is a hard one here because I think it’s an interaction of nature and culture that, of course, we cannot take neatly apart. There are certain aspects of women’s embodied experience that differ from males’ — being pregnant or having that capacity means there are certain ontological possibilities that might be more apparent to women … our bodies can be both one and two at the same time, and that’s an ontological both/and state men’s bodies simply cannot incarnate. Therefore, certain non-phallic modes of experiencing might be more accessible to women, but it’s not determinative. What is probably more determinative is whether you are socialized into the phallic subject position, that is, the subject position of white men. Being socialized as the ‘other’ means that you are more able to see things that are inaccessible when you are trying to conform to dominant modes of subjectivity. As you know, I’m a big Prince fan, and there are really profound resonances between the theorization of the phenomenology of black music and feminist metaphysics … it’s all about the interpenetration of opposites, and how that relates to flow-based experiences of time, as opposed to linear goal-directedness. That suggests to me that access to non-phallic subjectivity isn’t principally a matter of essence, it’s a matter of socialization and what ontological possibilities that makes accessible or inaccessible to you.
Perhaps it’s noteworthy here that the discussion of Irigaray’s work—and that entire French tradition—stopped in the 1990s in Germany, right when the reception of Judith Butler and then of queer theory clocked in. She was literally deemed old, whereas her ideas continued to inspire and shape feminist theory in the UK.
Yeah, I wouldn’t say Irigaray’s work shaped feminist theory in the UK. I was always in something of an intellectual minority, and there was nowhere in the UK really to study post-structuralist feminism, which is why I ended up going to the States. At the time, I understood that as a general feature of the masculinism of philosophy in general, and continental philosophy in particular, and hadn’t yet clocked that queer theory was just another iteration of that masculinism. Rather, I was just really uninterested in it, because as I say, the idea that everything happens as the result of random historical accidents has no explanatory power … What I want to know is in whose interests power is functioning. At that time, in the mid/late 00s, the totalitarianism of the present project hadn’t yet emerged, because actually, that totalitarianism is a general feature of the culture which has developed over the last decade and in significant ways is exterior to the intellectual genealogy. Anyway, I was in a minority which mostly involved women and gay men, but within that community, what I was doing — French difference or process-relational philosophy — was still perfectly acceptable, and I considered myself to be just a normal intellectual progressive on the left, albeit a feminist one who seemed to annoy a lot of men. None of the tendencies that are occupying us in the present were on my radar. In 2010 I left the US and came back to the UK, and two or three years later I ran into transactivism.
Where, and how?
Through online feminism. I already knew I didn’t want to have an academic career — that is to say, in the university — because the university has been destroyed by neoliberalism. I look at my friends, many in very senior academic positions, and they’re having a hard time, because it’s a horrible environment to work in. There’s a huge amount of managerial nonsense and thinking about how to attract new ‘customers’ and very little space for creativity or actual thinking. I always wanted to be more of a public intellectual, to do thinking in a way that was meaningful to people in the world and not be stuck inside an abstruse little bubble. When I came back from the States, I started experimenting with writing intellectual essays in a much more creative and accessible way than is possible inside the academy and at the same time I got more involved in feminist community. That was how I ran into transactivism … I still at this point didn’t really grasp what was going on inside Anglo-American Gender Studies, because philosophy hadn’t been totally captured yet.
Was there a particular event that made you think that something was going on?
There were several things; it was kind of a three- or four-stage process. The first incident that set off alarm bells, which happened around 2012 I think, was an online conversation among a few friends where we were discussing our experiences of being gender-non-conforming teenagers and how difficult we found it to negotiate that. A trans woman, who must have been friends with someone involved, suddenly marched into this conversation and went into a meltdown, and just typed “I AM A WOMAN I AM A WOMAN I AM A WOMAN” on a loop over and over. And that was the end of the conversation. There were several things about this that worried me. Firstly, what is it about women discussing their experiences of gender non-conformity that is so threatening to you? And what does that tell me, as a feminist, about your ideas about gender or the space for women to not conform to those ideas? Because if women not conforming to femininity threatens your identity as a trans women, then we’ve got a serious problem. Secondly, what makes you think it’s okay to barge into a conversation between women, talking about something that’s important and causes us a lot of damage, and make it all about you and your identity? And then lastly, why didn’t I feel able to challenge this behaviour, and why didn’t anyone? As a result, a little space where women were discussing their experience and supporting each other was destroyed.
Were you aware that this would eventually become a recognizable sociopolitical phenomenon?
From this incident I started understanding that there was some conflict between women’s needs here and what trans women wanted, but I was still pretty naïve about it. Shortly afterwards, an activist friend of mine decided she wanted to try setting up a feminist party and invited me to help her. Because it was ever-more present in the culture, we realized right away that the issue of including trans women in the party was a question we needed to think through, and, incredibly naïvely, we thought we could deal with that question democratically, by having an open debate and a vote. Of course, because we allowed women to even discuss it, we were completely firebombed on Twitter by transactivists and intersectional feminists, and even though 90% or more of us voted to include trans women, the backlash kind of overwhelmed us and the project collapsed. At that point, because the intensity of this reaction freaked me out, I began digging more into what these people were actually saying, and that’s when I realized there were all these mad claims about sex being a spectrum, and there being no such thing as female biology, and that sex was some cultural artefact created by colonialism or whatever, and I spent a lot of time just being like ‘WHAAAAAAAT?’ I had no idea where this was all coming from at that point. I recognized some of it was from Butler, but actually, she is not the main source of this. She’s one thread that’s been pulled in to give it academic justification, but trans ideology is not, in origin, an academic discourse — it’s a legal activist discourse which uses elements of academic thinking to give it a veneer of credibility, and which has since been reabsorbed by the academy … But I suspect it’s the case that many academics from queer-theory backgrounds and whathaveyou still don’t fully understand the nature of the political discourse and movement they are supporting — that what they are supporting is gender essentialist and sex denialist.
So where did people get these ideas from?
Some people, and increasingly nowadays, receive trans ideology from universities, but in the early years of the last decade, it was mostly being disseminated on the internet, and especially on Tumblr, and after that, on Twitter. If you speak to some of the young detransitioners, almost all of them picked it up from Tumblr, mostly between 2010 and 2015. How exactly that happened I don’t know — there might have been older activists seeding bits of the discourse there, ‘colonialism invented the gender binary,’ ‘sex is a spectrum,’ and so on. The way trans ideology functions is in some ways a perfect example of what I think of as the Tumblrization of thought: it’s not internally coherent joined up thinking at all, it’s a bunch of slogans, many of which are just false, but have been repeated so many times people just accept them. When I first went to Tumblr, I felt like someone had smashed a jar of marbles inside my brain. I like complex, joined-up thinking, and to me Tumblr looked like a multicoloured jumble of memes. It actually hurt my head.
The endless mixture generated by that website might be irritating. Yet it also explains its appeal to young people: funky images and bits of ideas to be arranged as you please, plus the possibility to connect with others for free. It’s understandable why they might mistake shared information for resources — or for thinking, even. It also occurs to me that this is the exact opposite of what you are doing.
One of the things we’re doing in gender-critical feminism is to try to systematically unpick the structure of trans ideology — while transactivists just jump from one meme to another meme to another meme and then call you a bigot. It’s understandable that young people would pick up a bunch of memes and not understand that they are inconsistent and cannot stand up to critical interrogation. But people who are professors in universities who believe and disseminate this nonsense? That’s an entirely different matter — and unforgivable. People like Sally Hines, who was a Professor of Gender Identity at Leeds, and now has a chair at Sheffield, has taken hundreds of thousands of pounds of state money to research and disseminate this stuff, and she cannot defend it in public, at all. That’s a level of intellectual fraudulence I find genuinely immoral. The university has a civic function and duty, and if we are to publicly fund the humanities, [academics] have an obligation to fulfil that function, to interrogate public discourse and work out whether it stands up, especially when those ideas are having a massive impact on public policy. If you receive public money and are unable to defend what you’re saying, and actually make a point of claiming that you don’t have to engage with your critics because they’re all evil right-wing Nazis or something, then something has gone very, very wrong.
What about the third step in realizing that something was going wrong that you have mentioned?
After digging into the ideology, I realized not only that it was totalitarian, but that it was necessarily totalitarian, because it doesn’t stand up, and it was absolutely necessary to the political project to make sure most people didn’t really know what was happening and what is being proposed, and didn’t have a chance to examine the ideas. I’m a Marxist radical feminist, but I’m also very anti-authoritarian, and despite all their failings, it turns out I really care about due democratic processes, because they protect us from tyranny, and from people making really bad policy on the basis of the interests of only certain groups. Still, even though I was very concerned, I was still holding back, partly because the ‘be kind’ propaganda still had some hold on me, and also because I was aware of what kind of threats and intimidation are heaped on women who try to resist. Then, in 2014, the transactivist Paris Lees wrote a piece in Vice about how they liked being eye-fucked on the tube by strangers — basically saying how exciting they found it when random strange men gave them unsolicited sexual attention, and asking whether that made them a bad feminist, and kind of implying other women were all uptight and not as sexy and liberated as them. I was so angry I started ranting on Twitter so badly that a friend called me to see if I was okay. She was like, “Have you gone full-TERF then?” … That was what we called it back then, before ‘peak trans’ became the more usual term.
What about that particular incident angered you most?
One of the fundamental problems here is that people who do not go through puberty as females in this culture do not understand how frightening, traumatizing, and dehumanizing it can be. There you are thinking you are a human being, and in the course of a very short time, suddenly you are a public object, and strange men start staring at you and touching you without asking and sometimes being really aggressive about it. This objectification starts very young, basically while we are still children, and is often backed up with actual violence, or a pervasive sense of menace, and many women are carrying a huge amount of trauma around this … about the violence they are subjected to in particular, and about the stripping away of their personhood in general. Recently I’ve started saying that women are socialized into the rapeable class, and I don’t think that is an exaggeration. The bottom line is that while we were being traumatized like this, Paris Lees was a young male, and has absolutely no understanding for or empathy with what that feels like. And more than that, Lees was basically fetishizing an experience that does massive damage to women’s full subjectivity and kind of adopting a superior position. It often takes women decades to get over the damage that is done to them by going through puberty in this culture, if they get over it at all … The absolute disregard for this, while at the same time claiming to be us, really made me rage. So that’s when I realized I had to say something.
Was your opposition to these developments already identifiable as a political stance?
There was a very small number of us, and we had no traction whatsoever. Looking back now, I realize we were witnessing this phenomenon coming over the hill, just before it fully took over our public institutions. Again, I was still really naïve at this point, and thought that as soon as this reached our institutions, they’d be like ‘Pfft, what is this nonsense?’ We spent a lot of time trying to figure out the thinking — ‘sex is a spectrum,’ ‘clownfish,’ all that rubbish — and working out the arguments against it. Also, it was only when this appeared, and the ‘intersectional feminists’ all started repeating this nonsense, that I and others explicitly started to define ourselves as radical feminists. Up till that point, I just thought of myself as a ‘feminist,’ because it never occurred to me that I needed some particular label to make it clear that I thought feminism meant centring the experiences and needs of female people.
Because specification wasn’t necessary?
When I was studying, I was interested in the historical development of power and the explanation for why our society is structured around hierarchical domination, and I found that feminism was the most explanatory system to me. It might not explain everything, but it explains a great deal. I myself went down from quite an abstract engagement with feminist thinking to a much more practical level, being much more involved with the women’s movement, with the conversations being had by women who work on the front lines supporting women. I am still very strongly motivated by how explanatory and important I think the analysis is, not just in an abstract way, but because it can literally save women’s lives, by explaining to them why certain things have happened to them, and why they are not to blame. This is why I am so opposed to transactivism. If you undermine the material analysis of women’s oppression — and the significance of the appropriation of their bodies — the entire key to understanding the power structure, and how it benefits men, drops out. What young women are being fed these days as feminism doesn’t help them understand what is happening to them, or resist it, or see how it harms them … They are being actively encouraged to do things that harm them, because it benefits men, and are being told that is feminism. It is entirely unsurprising that so much money and space would be given to disseminating a version of feminism that carries on telling women to do what men want them to, while dressing it up as liberation.
So the political shift towards ‘intersectional feminism’ produced the theoretical label ‘gender critical’?
As far as I am concerned, you either have an analysis of male power or you don’t. I don’t think the other thing is really feminism, as I don’t know what feminism is if it’s not an analysis of male power, and a critique of gender as the means of maintaining male power. What caused the evolution of the term ‘gender critical’ was basically us being called TERFs by transactivists, and us wanting a way to name ourselves that indicated the core of what we believed, and what we objected to. As if you should have to explain that feminism is critical of gender. Of course, though, we do, because there is now a whole load of people who now call themselves feminists who don’t believe in the sex/gender distinction and are committed to a regressive gender-essentialist ideology. Butler should, by all rights, given the nature of the performative theory of gender, not actually be supporting trans ideology, but of course she is.
She has declared herself ‘non-binary’ in 2020.
I heard that. Which is fine — at least she is admitting that she doesn’t have any identification with the political interests of female people, which actually has always been pretty obvious. I’m not interested in controlling what people think; if people want to do queer theory, go ahead. My problem is being told that that is feminism, and feminism being colonized by a discourse that is actually completely uninterested in the oppression of female people and the political interests of female people.
What about her work do you criticize above all?
Butler is simply not interested in the oppression of women. There’s nothing in her analysis about pregnancy, subjectivity, the maternal dyad, rape, how women are socialized into a service class, there’s nothing that pertains to the specificity of women’s oppression, at all. That in part is the Foucauldian in her … She’s much more interested in the micro-politics of power: it’s all just random and historically accidental, and isn’t serving anyone’s interests in particular. There is no class politics here. Transactivists or intersectional feminists think they’re talking about power structures, but they’re not — there’s no analysis of how that power arose or how it functions or in whose interests. They cannot tell you why patriarchy exists, and they cannot tell you why gender exists. Gender is just some random assortment of signs that distributes some behaviour to one set of people, and other behaviour to the other set of people, for absolutely no reason at all. I call it ‘no-theory-of-patriarchy feminism’ for that reason. All these people seem to think that feminism becomes much more interesting and important once it’s not bothered with female people anymore. Well, I’m sorry, that’s what feminism is about, so if you’re not interested in female people, go somewhere else. The whole rest of the world will happily allow you to be completely uninterested in female people. We have this one space for ourselves.
You are now part of a movement that aims to re-centre the interests of women at the core of feminism. How would you describe your relation to gender-critical feminism?
‘Gender critical’ is effectively now just an umbrella term for anyone who is concerned about trans ideology and its impact. I’d call myself a ‘radical materialist feminist’ and I’ve started talking a lot more recently in terms of ‘female class politics.’ Nothing I believe has really changed. I still believe in exactly the same things as when I started this journey in feminist thinking, nearly 20 years ago now. The difference is that I have stuck to what I believe, instead of capitulating to the new ideology — which is what a lot of people I was formerly associated with in the academy are doing now, particularly the Irigarayans. I still cannot comprehend how people who were trained in the philosophy of sexual difference have managed to assimilate this while not grasping they have betrayed the whole ontological foundations. Women exist in their own right and are not men’s projection. That was the whole point. That said, if you have an academic position in continental philosophy or feminism at the moment, it’s basically not safe to speak up. So, a lot of women in positions of power who have made their entire careers in difference feminism have not said a word — despite the fact that they should well know that the entire structure of patriarchy is about defining women through male projection. This phenomenon is the most perfect instantiation of that metaphysical structure, in which female people are literally being redefined in law as patriarchal gender, in the image of their oppression, and they pretend they can’t see anything. Had I decided to have a university career, I probably wouldn’t have been able to say much either, or at least, not without very considerable cost to my career. Another big reason I’m very happy with the choice I made. I’m one of the very few academically trained difference feminists in the Anglophone world who is free to call this out for the patriarchal nonsense it is.
When did the gender-critical stance begin to form a group?
Around 2013/14. We did a lot of work behind the scenes, in private corners of the internet, trying to figure out what we thought, and how to take apart TRA arguments. We have spent a great deal more time trying to understand what transactivists think than they have spent trying to understand what we think. They actually have no idea what we think. Everything they say about us is based on projection, caricature, and the lies they tell about us to demonize us … which is actually, I think, one of the reasons we’re winning the discursive argument in the UK. Know your enemy and all that.
Wasn’t there a moment when you sat together and intentionally decided what to do?
Not really. It happened kind of organically. We encountered trans ideology on social media, and then we started analysing it and writing about it, first of all on an anonymous blog called Feminists Unknown, and then shortly afterwards under our real names. Because the mainstream media were captured, we couldn’t get any traction. We were writing blogs, some pieces were published in the New Statesman, we sent letters to left-wing newspapers, the Guardian and Observer, all of which did absolutely nothing. It felt like throwing tiny stones at a great big massive wall. And all these institutions just fell, like dominos. By 2015 I realized that there was really nothing we could do until the ideology started concretely manifesting in policy in a way that drew people’s attention to what was happening. It felt like banging your head against a wall for no reason. So, I decided to retreat for a while. The whole thing was quite traumatizing, and as I said, we had no traction at all. All that time, I gained about 500 followers on Twitter. In the last couple of years, I’ve gone from 500 to 25,000. That’s a very big difference in traction.
Around 2018, there was a build-up of energy in general, because of the GRA consultation, Woman’s Place and Fair Play had formed, women were starting to organize. I didn’t know any of the other gender-critical philosophers until then, other than Rebecca Reilly-Cooper. Lots of people are coming at this from lots of different places. How lesbians are being treated is one important question, concerns about academic freedom and democratic processes another, concerns about the medicalization of children another. The core place I’m coming from is the defence of the analysis of male dominance. That’s what’s driving me. I’m also very anti-authoritarian and I dislike control, so I am concerned about the totalitarianism, but above all I’m defending the analysis of male power; that’s what women need and, as I’ve said, I think it’s extremely explanatory, and I am not about to let a really powerful explanatory system be replaced by this kind of bullshit. I am going to do my best to defend a system that I think is vital for the liberation and wellbeing and political interests of women from being expunged by a pile of intellectual nonsense which is, in fact, a pure manifestation of the patriarchal dominance of the material by the ideal, and the belief that women are not material female persons but a projection of men’s ideas. Meanwhile, just as in patriarchy ‘woman’ is a male projection, so too are we a projection created by TRAs. They are completely tied up fighting the caricature of a ‘TERF’ in their heads. Which, as I say, is one of the reasons they’re now losing the argument.
Why do you think that their position is losing?
Discursively they are losing. That is not to say that they are doing so politically. It is difficult to judge, because they still have fairly solid support in the left-wing and LGBT press. But wherever this conversation actually happens, they don’t come out of it very well—because they have no arguments. If they can’t just shut it down by calling us bigots and ‘Nazis,’ and if people are allowed to interrogate what they are actually saying, everything comes apart — which is why their entire strategy is based on no debate, doing everything behind closed doors, labelling and smearing everyone who disagrees.
You referred to gender-critical feminism as an umbrella term rather than a system of thought. Could you elaborate on this?
There are all kinds of people who have all kinds of reasons to object to trans ideology, and some of them make pretty odd bedfellows for radical or materialist feminists. Obviously, especially in the States, there are conservative Christians, whom I have made it clear I do not stand in political alliance with, but then there are lots of others: libertarians, classical liberals, psychologists, rationalists, biologists, intersex advocates, skeptics. This is a big battle, and I think it’s important that as many people come at this from their own perspectives as possible. I mean, if you found a political programme on such an absurd sex-denialist thesis, you are going to end up with a whole lot of different people ranged against you, because biological sex does exist, and lots of different people who have little else in common politically think so. Not everyone coming to this is going to be a feminist, or even left-wing, and within limits, that’s got to be okay. As I’ve said, I am very concerned about alliances with the Christian right, and personally, that’s where my boundary is, because it compromises the political ground I’m standing on so much that I actually can’t carry on standing if I feel that compromised. This is also one of the reasons I started THE RADICAL NOTION, because I wanted to make a space specifically for radical and materialist feminists. This movement is totally organic, there isn’t any central organizing structure, and in reality ‘gender-critical feminism’ or ‘the gender-critical movement’ is not one homogenous thing. Radical and socialist feminism are major parts of it, so I wanted to make a space specifically for us and for our ideas, somewhere away from the outrage machine that is social media.
The latter might be surprising for observers from abroad. The traditions of socialist feminism in the UK and West Germany are quite different — not least due to the fact that class consciousness in the two countries differs vastly.
Class politics, or an awareness of class politics, is, I think, one of the reasons we’ve been able to mount this kind of resistance in the UK. Americans don’t have a strong tradition of materialist class politics; their politics are completely individualist, and incidentally, this is why I think structural analysis fed through the American psyche produces this individualist mess of wokeism, where everything becomes about hunting down heretics and trying to purify their souls by subjecting them to public self-flagellation and atonement protocols. Anyway, every once in a while — actually quite often—some American progressive will come up to us and be like, ‘Oh my, why does the UK have such a transphobia problem?’ (which is kind of a joke, because we actually have much better laws protecting trans people here than the US does). I often reply: “Because we have class politics.” What that means is that we think of feminism as material class politics: we are a sex class who have shared material interests as an oppressed class. If you come along and try to destroy the fundaments of feminist class politics, a lot of British feminists will turn around and say, ‘Yeah. No.’ Also, we really dislike totalitarianism.
Still, socialist feminism and radical feminism also differed vastly from each other, too.
Historically, there was a big difference between radical feminism and socialist feminism throughout the 1980s, but I think that conflict was actually contingent, and emerged through the history of the two strands, rather than being conceptually inherent. One of the things I am really concerned with is bringing together those two strands in a radical materialist analysis. You need to understand that female people are a sex class, and that class relations are based on material appropriation. I’m a radical feminist in that I think that the oppression of women is the primary form of oppression, and that capitalism and also white supremacy are variants of patriarchy. They are particular iterations. Once you understand the fundamental structure of domination is about material appropriation of the bodies of women, you see that capitalism and patriarchy are basically intertwined iterations of each other, so there is no particular reason why these analyses should be in contradiction to each other.
The women involved in Woman’s Place UK, focused particularly on legal issues around women’s single-sex spaces, come out of the tradition of socialist feminist/trade unionist activism. One of the good things that this conflict has brought out is the very strong rapprochement between that sort of union-based, feminist class politics and radical feminism. I think that the Woman’s Place feminists probably would not have thought of themselves as radical feminists beforehand, and maybe still don’t, but in the course of this conflict, radical feminist women and women who come from the socialist tradition of feminism have been brought together through a kind of shared materialist feminist analysis, which we distinguish from trans ideology, which is idealist.
You mean idealist in a religious sense?
Yes, I mean in both the philosophical and religious sense. Metaphysically speaking, trans ideology is a kind of Christianity — it actually resembles a medieval Christian cult. What has happened with the development of wokeism in general, and trans ideology in particular, is that materialist structural analysis has been fed through this very puritan, individualist, American filter and turned, basically, into a religion. And when they try and impose this on us here, our response is, ‘What? This is religion. We’re not interested in your weird puritanism, you funny American people. We’re interested in class politics.’ Trans rights activism is all about sin, heresy, witch-burning and purification, and I don’t like that. There is a reason why the Puritans left England and went to America. You can criticize the English of course, but there are certain things about this country I really appreciate. One of them is irreverence, one is the facility with the absurd, one is the dislike of authoritarianism, and another one is a general dislike of puritanism. And this is all so puritanical.
One rather uncanny aspect about this phenomenon is that its appearances and policies seem to be driven by salvation: if you change your gender, you will experience or even reach some sort of higher being …
Absolutely. It’s a messianic cult. The fundamental structure is messianic. If you think about transition, it is metaphysically analogous to the Resurrection. It is the transcendence of the body by the soul and the rebirth of the body under the sovereignty of the soul. If you look at some of the images that went around on Tumblr, aimed at teenagers … for example, images of a girl child, huddled in the corner, with cuts down her arms, tears in her eyes … and then there will be this golden boy child emerging. It is so messianic. During the BLM protests, for example, two American trans women were killed, and there were images circulating showing them with halos.
Feelings were being mobilized. Do you suggest that extends to that sort of thinking?
Transactivism doesn’t make sense as a system of intellectual thought. And it doesn’t make sense as a political ideology either. It only makes sense as a religious structure. And at the centre of this structure is the redemptive power of transition. That is what draws people in and makes them believe. You start with a situation in which everything is very dark, painful, and impossible for someone, but if they go through transition, they’ll be saved, and all we have to do is validate them — so how could anyone be so mean, cruel, and heartless as to refuse people salvation? It’s fundamentally structured by a salvation narrative, by patriarchal eschatology. It’s basically a kind of millenarian cult.
How so?
If you think about this moment in history, we are in a very bad situation. The wheels are coming off global capitalism — or rather, the wheels came off 30 years ago, and now they’re driving the car with no wheels. We’re being governed by a bunch of avaricious sociopaths who are clearly only interested in extracting as much wealth as possible before they run for the hills and leave the rest of the population to deal with the complete chaos that’s going to result from the climate crisis. It looks pretty apocalyptic right now. And we know from history that in periods of this type of social uncertainty, millenarianism becomes very compelling to people. They need something to believe in—a salvation story.
Do you have an example that supports that claim?
If you think about that recurring sloganeering — “Trans women are women, trans men are men, non-binary is valid” — you can see that it’s a trinity, that it’s fundamentally liturgical or catechistic. A little while ago I gave a speech at the Women’s Equality Party, and they couldn’t find anyone to go up against me. They asked Sally Hines and a bunch of other people who wouldn’t do it. Eventually, they found some young activist from the Green Party who didn’t address the questions at all and just repeated a bunch of memes. First, she came out with all the usual stuff about how we’re just ignorant and hateful. And in the middle of it, she went into the liturgy. She paused, and her voice changed, and then she intoned: “Trans women are women — trans men are men — non-binary is valid.” I was quite annoyed by this point, because I’d come with a really tight five-minute speech laying out our arguments, and the response was eight minutes of disconnected memes, a lot of baseless derision aimed at us, and liturgy. After she had intoned the trinity, I made the sign of the cross, like ‘Amen,’ but in an ironic ‘you are kidding me’ kind of way. I didn’t realize I was on camera, and a lot of people were pretty amused afterwards, but it was an important critique. You were asked to come here to engage in a political process, and your response is to intone the axioms of your religious faith at us. And I’m sorry, but I don’t believe your religion. This is a democracy, and I’m not politically or ethically obliged to believe your religion. I don’t hate you, I don’t hate trans people, and I don’t wish anyone any harm, but I don’t believe your religion. As is my right. This is not the 16th century. And you can’t actually burn people for heresy. Although evidently, you are going to give that a good go.
You have unpacked the religious components. Could you also elaborate on the problem philosophically?
So, the first thing to understand is that trans ideology has two parts. One part is gender essentialist, and the other is anti-essentialist sex denial. The gender essentialist part is just straight up mind-over-matter idealism, it’s all about the pre-eminence of the soul and the transcendence of the body. Straight up old school Platonism, or Platonized Christianity. The sex-denialist part however, while thinking it is anti-essentialist, is actually still trapped inside a Platonic frame, and is fundamentally still idealist. It still accords all the weight to the concept of sex over-against its materiality. What I’d argue is that the Platonic idea or eidos—what we most often think of as ‘essence’ — isn’t actually a property of things, or why things exist, it’s just an account of how it is that humans can categorize and form concepts. It’s an idealist mistake in and of itself to confuse our ideas about ideas with the existence of things in themselves. In that respect, I’m basically an existentialist, in the Heideggerian sense. Existence precedes essence. And essence is just an idea that we make up to explain how we conceptualize. Female people exist, and they don’t exist by virtue of essence. Any more than trees or mountains exist by virtue of essence.
Moreover, it’s a form of domination to think that the materiality of the world is entirely subject to our concepts, is created by our concepts … ‘Discourse all the way down’ is presented as liberatory, because it’s presented as ‘therefore we can change anything we want,’ but actually, it’s a form of conceptual imperialism, it’s a subjection of the world to the tyranny of our concepts, to the power of our god-mind. And it fails to understand that our concepts are co-created with the world, through our material interaction with it: concepts are an artefact of Mitsein, to use a Heideggerian way of phrasing it. What should have been drawn from the post-structural critique of essences, had people been able to think outside the phallic, Platonic frame, is not that things don’t have meaning, it’s that things don’t have meaning by virtue of essences. But people are still so stuck inside Platonic metaphysics that when you say ‘things don’t have an essence,’ they think that means they can’t have any meaning. That misses the whole point. In the post-structuralist tradition I was working in — particularly Irigaray, who tried to think about subjectivity otherwise — the point is not that there is no subjectivity or no meaning or no signification, but rather that meaning and subjectivity don’t work like that, don’t work according to an idealist logic of sovereign essence. The sex-denialist or ‘social constructivist’ Butlerian part of transactivism is basically then just a form of reverse Platonism: things don’t have essence, therefore they have no meaning, and we just make them up in some totally arbitrary way. But that only follows if it’s true that meaning depends on essence. Which it doesn’t. Thinking only in terms of essence or the absence of essence, this is the oldest metaphysical story in the world. And they think this is something new!
Does that relate to other phenomena of the 21st century, too?
Yes. Just look at transhumanism. It’s a death cult: trying to escape the body, trying to escape mortality — whereas the conditions of life are materiality, embodiment, dependency, vulnerability, mortality. All attempts to escape the body are, ultimately, death cults.
As opposed to such attempts, would the work of gender-critical feminism translate to a concrete plan—or is it more of an analytical tool for you?
I couldn’t tell you what gender-critical feminism is in terms of a plan. We don’t have a plan. We’re working very organically, trying to respond to what is happening, trying to work out as we go along where we can most effectively challenge transactivist concepts and policy capture. However, I can tell you what the fundamental tenets are with respect to our feminist analysis: humans are sexed, and female people are oppressed by gender on the basis of their sex. That would be it. Which, until the early 1990s, was simply the fundaments of feminism — before feminism was reinvented as a form of queer theory, gender-identity ideology, or whatever you want to call it. That is to say, all gender-critical feminism is, is just the fundaments of feminism.
What is your take on J. K. Rowling and her support for Maya Forstater in 2020?
My take on J. K. Rowling is that she is an absolute shero. The first thing that I have to say about her is that what she did is the purest act of principle I have ever seen in my life. She had absolutely nothing materially or professionally to gain from what she did. She did it out of pure principle, and at considerable cost to herself. Every intervention she has made throughout this conflict has demonstrated to us that she is watching extremely closely, and that she knows exactly what is going on. And her interventions have been extremely well timed and very, very effective. I think she made a calculation and realized that she was one of the few women in the world who had enough power to really stand up to this, and she decided to use that power to defend women’s interests. Absolutely heroic.
What do you think about the reactions to her tweets?
The responses to her have been utterly horrifying. In the course of this whole conflict, it was the backlash to her, which I started calling ‘The Battle of J. K. Rowling,’ that has caused me the biggest trauma. Transactivism is entirely based around denying legitimacy to women, erasing our experience of the world, the violence we are subjected to, and why having spaces away from males matters to us. When she wrote her essay about her experiences of male violence, many of us were reading it and weeping, for a moment we thought, “Someone has said it, a woman with enough power understands and has said it.” And the response was, ‘Shut up you privileged, rich, bigoted bitch, you are just weaponizing your trauma.’ This whole ‘weaponizing-your-trauma’ argument was really too much. Firstly, the trans rights movement is a whole exercise in weaponizing trauma, based, actually, on the leveraging of really sketchy statistics. Secondly, we are not ‘weaponizing our trauma,’ we are just explaining to you why sex-based protection matters to women. I am sorry about your vulnerability, and I would like us to find a solution that accommodates your vulnerability as well as ours, but we are not going to be emotionally blackmailed into throwing away women’s protections. Also, if you want to convince us that there is no male-violence-type threat to women here, telling J. K. Rowling to choke on your dicks is probably not the way to go. The responses to her were so graphic, sexualized, and violent. I was very affected by that. Normally these days, I get angry and it doesn’t get into the core of me, but the threats being used against her, while all these men were at the same time accusing us of being hysterical and ‘weaponizing our trauma,’ that really got under my skin.
As far as I can tell, it did turn many people’s attention to the gender-critical work you are doing.
Yes, it generated a huge amount of traction. I gained around 7,000 followers in about three weeks. Suddenly, an awful lot of people were wondering, ‘What on earth is going on here?’ We have to remember that an awful lot of people don’t know what is going on. They think that this is just like gay rights and that the trans rights movement is just a request to treat trans people in a decent, egalitarian way. They’ve got no idea that the ideology is sex denialist, or about how far sex denial has captured public policy. J. K. Rowling did us a favour by drawing people’s attention to this. And we need to continue attempting to demonstrate, as clearly as possible, in public, that trans ideology is patriarchal, idealist, incoherent, antifeminist nonsense that is fundamentally hostile to the interests of women.
I assume that this attention shift also helped with new projects. In the Fall of 2020, you launched the magazine you have mentioned earlier, THE RADICAL NOTION. How did this come about?
Because of the present conflict, there are a lot of newly radicalized women who are interested in feminism and cannot get actual feminist ideas because of the anti-feminist backlash in universities and in activism. That was the main reason. I also wanted to make a space within the wider movement for those who are coming at this from a specifically radical or socialist position — a space away from the war and the day-to-day grinding conflict where we can actually develop our ideas, together. What I really hope for, ultimately, is that this horror show will lead to a revival of actual feminist thinking and activism. The analysis needs new life. There are places where it drove itself into dead ends last time around.
As I said, I ended up with this political position because I think it’s the most explanatory analysis out there. Not only with respect to the political condition of women, but to the structure of domination in this culture in general—it gives us an underlying structure which relates the appropriation of women’s bodies to the appropriation of the earth, the appropriation of labour, the development of class relations, slavery, the history of colonialism and the othering and domination of non-white people. I think that the crises we are facing now are all fundamentally crises of patriarchy: whether that concerns the environment, capitalism, or the existence of Donald Trump, they are all symptoms of the collapse of an unsustainable system of material appropriation. We have exploited all the resources. Marx was right that in the end, the system just maxes itself out, and then, or rather now, they will try to keep it running on magic beans and fairy dust. Capitalism is not sustainable. You cannot run a system that depends on infinite growth on a finite planet; that will just lead to massively destructive levels of dematerialization, which is where we are now, and ultimately will just collapse in on itself, which is also what is happening.
Did you have an audience in mind when you conceptualized this?
Yes, basically, the women’s movement, and in particular, I guess, the kind of women I interact with on Twitter and through the Institute, who understand this analysis and are on the same page, but maybe are coming from a more intuitive place and want to think it through with other women. Which is to say, I made it for witches, for materialist feminist witches. The witch is a very emblematic figure in this whole fight. Both as the women who is persecuted by a phallic idealist economy, and as the woman who stands as the defender of the wisdom of the earth and of life. Which, when it comes down to it, is the same thing.
The witch appeals to you?
Yes, very much. She is the figure that makes sense to me of where I, and the women I am standing with, have always been positioned by phallic economy, or perhaps rather, how our way of being means we stand outside phallic economy, and have long been persecuted as that outside, at least since Greece. In a sense, we stand in a long line going all the way back to the Furies, to the chthonic women who look at idealist phallic violence and say, ‘No. We will not let you harm life like this.’ The edifice of phallic power is enormous. And for most of my life I have been pretty much politically paralysed by how enormous it is. One of the incredible things about this conflict is that it has brought all the witches together — witches by training and witches by instinct. But we understand each other on some level. And J. K. Rowling, the queen witch, also understands this, I think.
Let’s speak about another relevant subject for you — one that also concerns the outside of the phallic economy you just named. You are interested in the work of Prince, who died in 2016. And your interest in it is, as far as I know, theoretically driven — not because of the musician’s appearance, style or transgressions, but because of his qualities as a composer.
The thing about Prince I’m most interested in is not that he was gender non-conforming, although that’s not irrelevant to the thing that really interests me, which is the phenomenology of his live music. Prince in performance is the greatest instance I’ve ever seen in my life of pure creative flow, of the enactment of jouissance. It is an incredibly precious material inscription of jouissance, and because he was so spectacular at it, and people went to great lengths to record almost everything he ever played, his body of work is an unsurpassed record of that material inscription.
Do you think he had conceptualized it like that?
As jouissance, no. But he knew perfectly well he was channelling the energy of a specifically female-type orgasm, of the motherlode, we might say — he was asked in the 90s about his ideal guitar tone, and his reply was “a woman in climax,” so yeah, he knew exactly what he was doing. There is also a very powerful communication of jouissance in the groove, and he was a complete virtuoso of the groove. I’m very interested in the relationship between deconstruction and the groove. When Western thinking thinks about deconstruction, it tends to think the aporia as stasis. But the thing is that the aporia is lived, and when you are inside it, it isn’t static at all, it oscillates, it moves. A deconstructed binary is a constant oscillation between poles, just like the yin yang, which is designed to suggest a circle spinning. If you look, say, at the epistemology of funk, it gives you an explanation of where deconstruction goes, when it’s lived as practice. You can’t actually deal with the aporetic through contemplation, and you shouldn’t, because it’s the structure of life, and it has to be lived as process. You have to be inside the oscillation or movement, and then you realize it produces a wave, and that when you immerse yourself inside that wave, what you get is jouissance.
What came first, reading Speculum or listening to Prince?
Oh, reading Speculum. I loved Prince when I was teenager, but then the 90s happened, and he kind of lost it, and I lost track of him. And then he died. The weekend after his death I went to a party with a bunch of old friends of mine, and we are all kind of devastated, because he was such a massive figure when we were growing up. So, we played his music all night, and then in the small hours we sat down and listened to as much of Purple Rain as we could get off the internet, and during the climax of the ‘Purple Rain’ guitar solo, a massive burst of electricity went up my spine and I just burst into tears. The next morning I came home, and crawled into bed with a hangover, and googled ‘Prince’ and found that all these performance videos he had kept off the internet while he was alive were flooding, and flooding is an important word here too, onto YouTube—hours and hours and hours of him on stage, from his early 20s to just before his death, channelling this incredible wave … I became obsessed with the way he would throw his head back while he was playing, and his whole body would sort of arch back into it, like The Ecstasy of Saint Teresa, which Lacan famously discussed in the Seminar on women’s jouissance, and how it isn’t possible to grasp from within phallic economy … True, but here was a man who could pick up a guitar and just lay it down … It’s not true that we can’t grasp or understand it, actually, we have material inscriptions of it that we can analyse, and when we do, what it tells us is that the structure of jouissance is deconstructive. So this became very philosophically important to me, and also personally very important, because I just sat there for several months watching these videos and listening to bootlegs of the live performances and, it’s hard to explain, but it felt like I just kind of absorbed the energy he was transmitting, or had transmitted across the whole of his life, in one really condensed chunk, and in that process, somehow he communicated to me how to create, or manifest things. This sounds kind of overblown, but he communicated the energetic frequency of creation, or how to be inside that wave … And I could just feel it. By that point I had been writing publicly for around five or six years, since I’d come back from the States, but I was still all very anxious about it and holding everything much too tightly. Something in that transmission changed the way I was making work, and everything that’s happened since then has basically come out of what Prince communicated to me about how to create: commit, stop second guessing or monitoring yourself, let go of your ego, dissolve into the wave, into the process of the unfolding of the wave, and what you get it a kind of fearlessness … Except it’s not exactly, because it’s produced because your ego isn’t there while you create, so where could the fear be coming from?
Do you think that the fact that a man created this music makes for an interesting twist?
A male person performing a phenomenological expression of female sexual pleasure is very philosophically significant, yes, as well as being devastatingly sexy. The philosophical point is this: there is an outside of non-phallic economy, that outside might be more accessible to women, but it is actually accessible to everyone, female or male, and as I said earlier, is probably more accessible to people not socialized into the phallic subject position. And that outside is not some unintelligible hysterical chaos that will shatter the ego to smithereens and needs to be resisted. That’s just what it looks like from the perspective of the mastery of the phallic ego. It’s actually perfectly intelligible within its own terms, and more than that, it’s salutary, and nourishing, and profoundly generative.
You just suggested Prince provided a differentialist rebuttal of Jacques Lacan?
Yes, Lacan denies any intelligibility to the outside of phallic economy, or to the being of female pleasure, and Irigaray makes the point that that denial exists not because it’s true, but because it’s central to the maintenance of the whole phallic economy. Jouissance gives the lie to the whole justification for the erection of the phallic ego, and tells us that real human generativity exists outside of all that … Outside of the identitarian logic of patriarchy, and also, importantly, outside of the sort of goal-directedness that governs a type of Freudian/capitalist productivity (which, incidentally, is not just a non-climactic plateau, in Deleuzian terms … Because again, Deleuze just performed a phallic reversal on male orgasm, and never bothered to think about women’s pleasure in itself, in its own terms. Again, this is why we must always resist any form of erasure here). What Prince gives us is a material inscription of the outside of phallic economy, of the performance of non-phallic ontology. That is staggeringly important. And we have very, very few representations of that in our culture. We have it in his guitar playing, and we have it also in the organic deconstructive structure of the groove. And what he shows us is that what happens when you let the aporetic structure of the groove move is fluid-electrical flow, the unfolding of the process-wave of life. Groove is a material manifestation of life force. As we say at THE RADICAL NOTION, “We serve the groove.” I take that very seriously.
