Issue Four

The Power of Sunlight: Reflections on the Passage of the Hate Crime and Public Order Act

by Lisa Mackenzie

Author’s Note: This essay is dedicated to the steel, grit, and determination of all female parliamentarians but especially Joan McAlpine, Johann Lamont, Jenny Marra, and Elaine Smith.

EARLY FEBRUARY 2021

The Holyrood Parliament is a building of many parts and contradictions. The reception area has a cavernous feel, the ceilings low and the lighting muted. As you move beyond the secure doors, you walk past a series of small windowless meeting rooms. Glass walls enable you to see inside and watch the soundless conversations of parliament staff and their visitors. You then emerge into the bright, airy Garden Lobby — the building’s junction box—where MSPs, researchers, journalists, and catering staff glide past each other at speed, clutching takeaway coffees and armfuls of folders.

Whilst the MSPs’ offices are poky and claustrophobic, I have always liked the debating chamber. Shafts of sunlight pour in, falling at different angles throughout the day. It feels very different to the Westminster chambers, which are all dark wood and leather benches.

But it is the committee rooms that offer the best views. The green shadows of Arthur’s Seat and Holyrood Park fill the windows, as do the rooftops of the Old Town stretching up the Royal Mile. At once you have a sense of the parliament being situated somewhere.

MSPs are currently debating the creation of a new criminal offence. In a few weeks’ time it will become a crime to stir up hatred on the basis of transgender identity. Women are worried. The Hate Crime and Public Order Bill arrives at a time when the debate about gender identity and women’s rights is red hot. 

When creating new laws, we expect our lawmakers to stress test every aspect of every clause. When it comes to good law, good intentions are not enough. And so they talk it out. Measure twice, cut once. 

The hard-nosed talking and testing is undertaken by the relevant subject committee, made up of an uneven number of MSPs, balanced to match the make-up of the wider parliament. Amendments are tabled, and clauses and sub-clauses picked over one by one. Rarely are there more than a dozen people in the room and the work is intense, focused. But it’s important work.

In this instance, MSPs have been trying to scope the outer reaches of this new criminal offence, to give careful thought to which behaviours should or shouldn’t meet the threshold of criminality. When it comes to placing limits on freedom of expression, the buzzword is ‘necessity.’ The government amendment is narrowly drawn. One opposition amendment applies to all the new offences equally. Another sets out in granular detail a series of topics which, it is proposed, should explicitly not be caught by this new offence. It posits that ‘stating that sex is an immutable biological characteristic’ or ‘stating that there are only two sexes’ should not be regarded as transphobic.

At teatime the night before the committee session, the government minister announces via Twitter that he and the opposition MSPs have all “agreed not to move our amendments in relation to freedom of expression” in the hope that they will “achieve consensus on a broad FoE clause for Stage 3 that covers all characteristics, so no group feels targeted.”

It quickly becomes clear that what he means is that the MSPs who proposed amendments—all but one of whom are male — will soon be called to meet with the minister to discuss the wording of a fresh amendment. This will happen not in an airy committee room or the debating chamber, but behind closed doors. In normal times, that would mean either one of the parliament’s windowless rooms or a room in the Scottish Government’s Art Deco offices on Waterloo Place. In an era of COVID, it almost certainly means a Zoom or Teams video call.

The meeting won’t be livestreamed on Scottish Parliament TV, nor a transcript published in the Official Report. The process of stress testing this aspect of the draft law will be beyond the public view. In trying to decipher the means by which our lawmakers reached an eventual form of words, there will be nothing to draw on bar supposition.

The decision feels bewildering to onlookers. Why would elected representatives shirk at the prospect of a debate? Isn’t that what we pay them to do, on our behalf? We even exempt them from defamation laws so that they can debate freely on every topic under the sun. 

Undoubtedly some will be playing politics. Bet-hedging, already anticipating their checkmate move at Stage 3. An election looms on the horizon. Very soon manifestos will be written, leaflets will go to print and the accusations will begin to fly, as candidates vie for our votes. But it is hard not to conclude that they are afraid. The debate about sex, gender identity, and women’s rights is fraught. It makes them feel uncomfortable. 

Ordinary citizens can afford to shirk this debate. They might mutter their concerns in hushed tones to friends and family, or not at all. There are many more pressing issues to contend with, not least in the midst of a global pandemic. But for our legislators, there is no such luxury. The difficult issues must be grappled with. And yet … here we are. 

In short, it would appear that, so worried are our lawmakers of being labelled transphobic themselves that they are choosing to debate the threshold for criminally transphobic behaviour away from the gaze of those who will soon be subject to the law. 

It hardly inspires confidence. And it won’t end well.

EARLY MARCH 2021

Five weeks elapse. The days have lengthened and there is the hope of spring. Science has delivered a route out of the pandemic in the form of a vaccine.

MSPs assemble in the debating chamber, carefully dispersed in accordance with social distancing rules. Others flick on laptops in their home offices, their faces looking quizzically into the camera as they seek to commandeer unruly technology. The Presiding Officer reminds members wishing to take part in the debate to “press their request-to-speak button” or “put R in the chat box.” The Hate Crime and Public Order Bill has reached the final stage in its parliamentary passage.

The debate begins at four o’clock. Natural light floods through the high windows of the chamber. A succession of female MSPs rise to speak. The frustration in their voices is palpable. How is it, they ask, that once more women’s concerns have been overlooked in the law-making process? They speak about their own experiences, and the reactions to their advocacy for women, some of which are playing out in real time, on social media. They rise to make points of order, and to challenge the assertions of their male counterparts.

Outside, the sun begins to set and for the remaining three hours of the debate, the chamber is lit only by artificial light.

And then comes a train of male MSPs. The women’s concerns are played down, their motivations called into question and their claims doubted. A recurrent theme is the need for women to place their trust in the mechanisms of state power: the police service, the prosecution authorities, the courts. The female MSPs look on, lips pursed, heads gently shaking. When they rise to speak again, their voices are quaking, as they grip the sides of their lecterns. Shortly after nine o’clock, the Presiding Officer closes the session, to be reconvened the following day.

The final hour of debate takes place in the early afternoon. Once more, it is male MSPs who dominate, but even they seem wearied and any zeal for the bill amongst its most ardent supporters seems to have waned.

Just before the debate wraps up ahead of a final vote, a small olive branch passes hands. A female MSP reaches across a party divide to another member of her sex.

In sorrow as much as exasperation, Labour MSP Johann Lamont laments: “I regret very much that at the end of the day, when I vote with my absolute conviction that the bill does not address those problems, I have no doubt that I will be characterized as someone full of hate. Please believe me that the women who want the legislation to be changed — those who have highlighted their concerns — aspire to the same as those who will vote for it.”

Her political rival, SNP MSP Shona Robison, replies emphatically: “I, for one, will support Johann Lamont’s position and I certainly support her right not to vote for the bill for the good reasons that she set out. I would support her if she is attacked in any way for that, because I do not believe for a second that Johann Lamont is against the bill for any other reason. I put that on the record.”

I believe her.

Later that day, the bill passes into law. Women have lost. But something has been gained.

Lisa Mackenzie is a former civil servant and co-founder of Edinburgh-based policy analysis group MurrayBlackburnMackenzie.