Issue Four

Invisible Queens

by Marieke Bos

as told to Paula Alice

When I was 11, I decided I wanted to learn to play chess. I had just read The Queen’s Gambit, the novel from 1983 by Walter Tevis, and I fell in love with the character of Beth Harmon, the young female chess prodigy. Beth was a geeky, gloomy, weird kid — all things I related to, as I was a bit of a strange kid too. I was intrigued by the way she played without a board, visualizing the moving pieces in her head—I thought that was amazing, and I wanted to know how to do it too.

So I asked my dad to teach me to play. He showed me the rules, the names of the pieces, and how they moved. I beat him on our first game. It wasn’t an accident: I beat him on the second game too, and the third. I really liked to play, and I must have had a natural instinct for it. I wanted to learn more and play as much as I could.

In the village where I lived there was a chess club, so I decided to join. I played with the other children at first, but right away, they could see there was no challenge for me, so after the first lesson they moved me to play against the adults. There was a nice older man, one of the top players there, who gave me private lessons, a bit like the janitor at the orphanage who teaches Beth. I learned about opening gambits and tactics, defenses, attacks, and endgames. Soon I was winning nearly every time I played.

The logic of the game drew me in; it seemed like an entirely natural fit for my brain. In my head, I could visualize the possible responses to every move, and what would follow next: if I move this here, that has to go there. That’s how my mind has always worked, imagining possibilities and branches of logical sequences, causes and effects rippling out. I could sit down at the board, make my opening move, and soon my brain would be strategizing the whole game, keeping ahead of my opponent. By the time I was 12, I was one of the top players in the village. 

The other players in the club were mostly men. When I started, there were only two women, and because I was at the highest level and all the top-ranked players were men, they were the ones I mainly played against. It was a bit strange playing with adults as a young girl, but in the beginning it wasn’t bad. Maybe I was a novelty to them, and my youth made them careful. But as I got older, as my body started developing, things started to change. 

In chess there is a rule of silence during the game, so while I was playing these men, they didn’t say anything to me. It was after the game — after I had beaten them, usually — that they would feel the need to comment: on my looks, my body, my growing breasts. When they would lose a game to me, they would say things like: “Oh, how can I win if there’s such a pretty woman sitting in front of me?” I remember feeling sort of flattered — or maybe feeling that I should feel flattered — but also feeling insulted. I knew I won because I was a better player, not because I was some sort of Lorelei luring men to defeat with my feminine wiles. Couched in a compliment, it was such a low and mean thing to say. They must have done it to spare their egos, because the men who lost to me were mocked — never for losing to a child, but for losing to a girl. (Later on there were a few boys who joined the adult club, and I don’t remember the men making those comments when they were beaten by boys my age.) But I could see what I was becoming valued for. Around the same time, the chair of the chess club asked me if I could tend the bar at the club, which sold beer on tap and other drinks. “It’s always nice to have a pretty girl behind the bar,” he told me.

There are moments sometimes when you can feel yourself turning from a person to an object. First you are present in your body, using your mind and skills to play the game you’re good at. Then an offhand comment or a touch or look reminds you that to them, you’re not a full person in the same way they are. You are a nice face, a pair of growing breasts and an ass. You are a pretty girl to stand behind the bar and serve the men. Your success is probably just a fluke. Your ambition and pride in your skills are something to joke about, something you couldn’t possibly take seriously. You’re decoration first and then a human being second, if at all.

The chess club was not the only place where I was learning what it was like to be treated as a girl. Around the same time, at the stable where I rode a horse in exchange for grooming, there was a man in his 40s who would touch my bum every time he passed me. The owner of the stable told me this was what men did, and I should just try to avoid him. Then, when I was a little older, I started taking ballroom dancing and I helped with lessons at the school, teaching the men how to dance so they could lead their partners. Sexual harassment was practically part of the job description. Some of the men would pull me in close to their body, ignoring my protests when I said we should keep some distance to learn the steps. It was all so normalized, as if I should have taken these older men’s violation of my boundaries as a compliment.

I didn’t tell anyone about any of this, of course — not the comments, not the touches, not how any of it made me feel. Maybe I didn’t even know I could. It was so normal; that’s what life is for girls, or that’s the way it seemed to me. At that time I knew instinctively it wasn’t okay, but I also didn’t realize it was a really bad thing. This was 30 years ago, and as a teenager I didn’t have the vocabulary to talk about sexual harassment or know that there was anything I could do to stop it.

I know it affected my confidence, though. I can tell by what happened with my performance at chess. At first I was just going up and up and up in my progress, getting better and winning more and more games. But then, at a certain moment, the line went flat. 

Tending the bar also meant that I had to play really quickly, because people would be waiting there in between their games, wanting to be served. I’ve always been a slow player at chess — I really need to think things through before making my moves. So I started rushing my games and losing more and more. Once I had looked forward to playing chess and felt proud of my skill. Now, it made me anxious and discouraged. Eventually, at 15, I just quit.

Chess is a famously male-dominated game. At every level, boys and men outnumber girls and women, and men are the vast majority of champions. Wikipedia has a list of 1,938 people recognized as chess Grandmasters; only 38 are women.1 Before the year 2001, there were only six. To the sort of people who claim men and women have very different brains, chess is one of the prime examples of an activity that the supposedly logical, competitive male brain is ‘hardwired’ to do better. Every woman who plays chess has heard the misogynistic remarks made by some of the most famous male players. Bobby Fischer was probably the worst when he said in a television interview in the 1960s that women are “terrible chess players” and “not very smart,” that they should “keep strictly to the home.”2 Garry Kasparov said that “chess does not fit women properly” (though he eventually revised his opinion after being beaten by a woman, Judit Polgár).3 Only a few years ago, Nigel Short, a British Grandmaster, wrote an article claiming that “fundamentally different cerebral structures between the sexes” are the main obstacle to equality in chess, following it up with something scientific sounding about grey matter and testosterone.4

Female chess players have often argued that the inequality is caused by society and culture, not biology: the lack of encouragement for girls to play chess, the lack of female camaraderie and role models in environments that are largely full of men, and sometimes, outright sexism from male players. It seems that Grandmasters don’t like losing to girls any more than the men at my club did. Judit Polgár, often considered the best female chess player of all time, says that the men she was playing would often make disparaging comments or hurtful jokes, and sometimes would refuse to shake her hand after they lost. Her sister Susan Polgár, also a chess Grandmaster, described how the men who lost to her would suddenly claim to have a headache or other ailment; she famously remarked: “I have never beaten a healthy man!”

Then there is the effect of ‘stereotype threat’: when people are exposed to a situation that confirms a stereotype or belief about the group they belong to, it makes their performance worse. For example, there are many studies showing that women do worse on math tests when they are ‘primed’ beforehand with something that activates their awareness of their sex, or the stereotypes that go along with it (stereotypes like not being as good at math as men). Things like having to record their sex before a test, being in a room with mostly men, watching ads with women behaving in stereotypically feminine ways, or having teachers with subtly sexist attitudes can all make women do worse on tests.7 So reminding someone of her femaleness, in a context where she is aware that females are known to do worse, actually sets her up to do worse. As Cordelia Fine writes about studies on mathematical ability and stereotype threat, “Research suggests that the deadly combination of ‘knowing and being’ (women are bad at math and I am a woman) can lower performance expectations, as well as trigger performance anxiety and other negative emotions.”8

Could there be a similar stereotype-threat effect on women in chess? Various studies have said yes: women tend to play worse than expected, given their skill ratings in chess, when playing against male opponents than when playing against female ones.8 I read about one interesting study from 2007, which matched 41 women with male opponents of a similar skill level to play chess online.9 But they didn’t always tell the women who they were playing. When they knew they were playing against a man, they lost more often. But when they were told — falsely — that they were playing other women, they won just as often as the men. It’s just one study, but it shows something about the psychological effect of sexism — the extra mental burden that becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy. The mind under threat cannot perform well.

I think back to my experiences in chess, to every remark that reminded me I was a girl, every small violation telling me I didn’t really matter. These things happened to me, but it’s like they never happened, because I never told anyone, and I just disappeared from the game.

Recently I was talking to a colleague around my age about sexual harassment. “Sure,” she said, “it happens, but it’s not that bad.” I asked her: “Did it ever happen to you?” And she said, “Oh yes, when I was this age, there was a guy … and when I was that age, there was a man that …” As she was talking, remembering all the incidents that had happened to her, I saw the look on her face slowly change, the realization landing … Eventually she said, “Oh, but it is bad — it’s really bad,” and she started crying. “Why did I not tell anyone?” she asked. “Why did I think it was normal?”

But every time it’s just one incident, then another, then another … Each one might seem not really so bad, probably not worth speaking up about, and what would you say anyway? But it adds up to a constant drumbeat, slowly wearing away our confidence, our sense of ourselves. What are we missing from the world because of how girls are treated, how their experiences are unacknowledged, their stories made invisible?

Sometimes I wonder about girls playing chess today. Is it better for them than it was for me? How many girls today are still giving up something they once loved, something they were good at, because one incident or a steady accumulation of them has drained away their joy, whittled away their confidence?

I do know that there are more girls and women playing chess now than ever before, and that gives me hope. Twenty years ago, only 6% of players rated by the International Chess Federation were female, and now it’s more than 15% — still small, but growing.11 For girls starting out, there are great women chess players they can look up to, so many more than when I was a kid. Many clubs now make an effort to increase girls’ participation, like requiring chess leagues to include at least one female player on their teams, and there are tournaments where women can play against each other.12

Then there’s the recent Netflix adaptation of The Queen’s Gambit, which has made chess exciting for a new generation of girls and young women. But in the series, Beth is played by a glamorous model, and her fashionable outfits are as much a focus as her chess strategy. She’s not the geeky misfit I related to from the book. I understand that on TV, beauty sells, and maybe her looks and fashion sense appeal to some girls. But how many other girls will you lose because of that? There are so few stories about chess in the first place, and almost none about female chess players, so it’s sad when almost the only representation has to be an attractive, doe-eyed model. As if it’s only okay for girls to play something as brainy and ‘masculine’ as chess if they’re feminine and pretty while they’re doing it. So I wonder, how many girls and women are still not on the board? What about the ones we can’t see?

It’s all a long time ago now, but I still think, what if? What if I had been taken seriously? Maybe I could have gone much further. It’s impossible to know for sure, but what if I’d been treated as an equal?

A few months ago I started playing chess again online, but only against the computer. I hadn’t played for 25 years, and I remembered how fun it is, and how I loved it so much.

I only play against the computer, though. I don’t even want to choose a male character to play against, knowing that it might make me play worse. When I choose a character, I always choose a woman. And my mind starts imagining freely again, strategizing moves and branching out into possibilities. And I play with my love for the game undimmed.

Marieke Bos is a 44-year-old lesbian single woman who lives with her old dog near a forest. She works for a municipality at the department of social services as a counsellor and coach, mainly for people dealing with multiple problems in their personal lives. She is interested in feminism and herbalism and like gardening, sewing, making soap and drawing. 

1 Wikipedia, ‘List of chess grandmasters,’ last updated 3 July 2021; ‘List of female chess players,’ last updated 17 June 2021.

2 Internet Archive, ‘Rare Bobby Fischer interview,’ 1963.

3 Leon Watson, ‘Garry Kasparov: “I was wrong about women playing chess,”’ The Telegraph, 2 December 2017

4 Omkar Khandekar, ‘“I stand by it”: British grandmaster Nigel Short on his “sexist” remarks on women’s chess,’ 13 October 2020.

5 Dylan Loeb McClain, ‘How “The Queen’s Gambit” started a new debate about sexism in chess,’ The New York Times, 10 Nov 2020.

6 Susan Polgar, ‘Cheating a girl in chess,’ Chess Daily News, 28 June 2017.

7 Cordelia Fine, Delusions of Gender (New York, NY: Norton, 2010), pp. 31-32.

8 Fine, p. 32.

9 David Smerdon and others, ‘Female Chess Players Show Typical Stereotype-Threat Effects: Commentary on Stafford (2018),’ Psychological Science, 31.6 (May 2020).

10 Anne Maass and others, ‘Checkmate? The Role of Gender Stereotypes in the Ultimate Intellectual Sport,’ European Journal of Social Psychology, 38.2 (March/April 2008).

11 ‘Is it true that chess is generally more played by men?’ StackExchange, thread updated January 2020.

12 David Smerdon, ‘What’s behind the gender imbalance in top-level chess?’ The Conversation, 13 December 2020.