by Suffragetti
Robert Galbraith, Troubled Blood (London: Sphere, 2020), 944pp.
Editors’ Note: This review contains spoilers for the Cormoran Strike series.
“Man is defined as a human being and a woman as female — whenever she behaves as a human being she is said to imitate the male.”1 Simone de Beauvoir’s words are transformative to young receptionist, Gloria Conti, when she hears them quoted by her unashamedly feminist employer in 1974. Speaking 40 years later, Gloria recalls how Dr Margot Bamborough, an ambitious female GP, used de Beauvoir’s observation in a retort to her sexist partner, Dr Brenner. The older, male GP had snidely commented that “People are always asking me what it’s like working with a lady doctor, and if I ever meet one, I’ll be able to tell them” (p. 821). Margot’s unladylike offence? Swearing as she dropped her pen.
Gloria recalls this moment in a conversation with the detective partners, Cormoran Strike and Robin Ellacott, who are investigating the disappearance of Margot Bamborough, the 40-year-old cold case around which Troubled Blood revolves. Gloria’s story is just one strand in a tapestry of women’s lives, woven expertly by J. K. Rowling, writing as Robert Galbraith, throughout her epic crime novel. Indeed, many of the witness statements and interviews to the case read as testimonies to sexism and patriarchy in its many forms. In the hands of a less skilful writer these stories could read as shoehorned in, but instead Rowling is able to structure her complex plot around themes of female oppression, exploitation, and resistance. Her ability to create a vivid cast (a hallmark of her children’s fiction) enables her to humanize — in the Beauvoirian sense of the word—her female characters. Troubled Blood is a gripping crime thriller, and can be enjoyed as just that. But it’s also a powerful feminist chronicle.
Margot’s unapologetically radical ideas stay with Gloria: “they got in my head and I couldn’t get them out again” (p. 821). Although she thought she wanted to be a “fifties Mafia housewife” (p. 821), the reality of her abusive relationship with Luca Ricci, in which throttling, beating, coercive sex, and emotional blackmail were commonplace, challenged her ideals. Ending the relationship felt “like waking up, or coming up for air after being underwater” (p. 821), a particularly poignant description in light of Rowling’s recent public disclosure of surviving domestic abuse.2 However, as for many domestic abuse victims, Gloria cannot make a clean break, and this is the first of many attempts to escape Ricci’s control.3
Gloria realized how precarious her freedom from her abusive boyfriend was when the relationship became sexual: “I was sure he wanted me pregnant, because then he’d have me cornered, and I’d marry him” (p. 822). Margot gives her hope of escape by offering an alternate future and the practical assistance of contraception and access to abortion. Margot’s decision to offer the pill to unmarried women is just one of the reasons her male colleagues disapprove of her. Institutional misogyny held female medics back, and as a result their female patients suffered.
The double-edged hypocrisy of misogyny — the demand that women be sufficiently feminine and the hatred of women on the basis of their femininity — is exposed in the figure of Dr Brenner. For Gloria, Brenner was “the biggest misogynist I ever met. He’d denigrate women for not looking feminine or talking ‘like a lady,’ but he also despised Irene, who was giggly and blonde and very feminine … I suppose what he wanted was for us all to be like Dorothy, subordinate and respectful, high collars, low hemlines” (p. 828). Gloria’s remarks are not surprising to Robin, who has recently discovered that Brenner used to frequent one of the surgery’s most vulnerable patients for sex. Betty Fuller would lie there, “pretending to be comatose, while Brenner poured filthy words into her ear” (p. 828).
Brenner might be the biggest misogynist Gloria has ever met, but readers encounter plenty throughout Troubled Blood. Nor are they restricted to 1974. Forty years may have passed by the time the detectives start work on the cold case, but woman-hatred is still thriving. One such modern-day misogynist is Carl Oakden, a self-proclaimed “award-winning writer on men’s issues including masculinism, father’s rights, gynocentrism, men’s mental health, female privilege and toxic feminism” (p. 470). Oakden’s characterization is heavy-handed, yet he nevertheless represents a particularly insidious manifestation of misogyny and the backlash to advances in women’s legal and social equality. Oakden’s sexism is evident in his lecture to Robin on the innovation of available contraception: “Late sixties, early seventies, it’s when it all started changing, isn’t it? You’ve got the pill: consequence-free fucking. Looks like it benefits the male, but by enabling women to avoid or subvert the reproductive function, you’re repressing natural and healthy patterns of sex behaviour” (p. 710). His distortion is only fully appreciated when we later hear Gloria’s account of how, as a teenager, she struggled to access contraception, had to take it in secret, and endured unwanted sex: for Gloria, there was no such thing as “consequence-free fucking” and her attempt to “avoid … the reproductive function” was her only recourse to freedom. Oakden’s “natural and healthy patterns of sex behaviour” no doubt align with those perpetuated by Ricci and Brenner.
Parallels between the misogyny of the 1970s and 2010s are numerous. The coercive sex Gloria endures is also experienced by Gemma, personal assistant to an investment banker under surveillance by Strike’s agency. Gemma’s account of her boss’s coercion will feel chillingly familiar to many women who have found themselves taken advantage of by powerful men: “I don’t really know what happened … I mean … we had sex … but I was so out of it … so drunk … I mean, it wasn’t, you know … it wasn’t rape … I’m not saying that …” (p. 783). Gemma’s resistance to name her experience as rape is based on her dread of drawn-out police procedure, the financial power of her boss and the fear of losing her job, rather than an ambiguity about the non-consensual nature of the encounter. Likewise, although Gloria says, “I’m not saying he forced me — not really,” she also admits that if she refused sex, “there’d be a slap or worse” (p. 822).
These parallels are reinforced throughout the novel in the central figures of Margot and Robin, who act as doubles for each other despite the separation of 40 years. Both are 29, managing complicated, emotionally dysfunctional marriages (and their aftermaths), navigating male-dominated spheres, and struggling against workplace sexism. Robin’s Brenner comes in the form of Saul Morris, a sub-contractor at Strike’s agency. (In the course of the novel, Morris will deceive personal assistant Gemma into a sexually exploitative relationship whilst also shaming and pressuring her to keep quiet about her boss’s assault from the year before.) Like Brenner, Morris desires women without respecting them. As Robin observes, this is constantly revealed in his glee at nicknaming a client ‘Rich Bitch’ and “his attribution of venal or provocative motives to every woman under surveillance” (p. 705). Morris constantly patronizes Robin, undermines her authority, and sexually harasses her, sending her inappropriate, crude texts and, on one memorably offensive occasion, a photo of his erect penis. Robin’s ‘grin and bear it’ attitude for the sake of agency cohesion means Morris continues with impunity, confident in his entitlement to transgress Robin’s professional and personal boundaries.
Robin knows only too well the distinction between men desiring women and liking them, that they “were different, and sometimes mutually exclusive, things” (p. 705). When Morris sneaks up behind Robin in the office, Robin reacts “without conscious thought” (p. 737), stamping on his foot, breaking his nose as she throws her head back, and grabbing a knife. What is just a joke to Morris is a trigger to Robin, who has been attacked from behind by men twice in her life. It wasn’t until the third book in the series, Career of Evil, that we learned of the trauma in Robin’s past. As a university student, Robin was raped and left for dead by a man in a gorilla mask. She consequently dropped out of her psychology degree as she battled agoraphobia and a gruelling trial. The plot of Career of Evil centres — like Troubled Blood — on male violence, and features a murderer dubbed the ‘Shacklewell Ripper’ who stalks and later attacks Robin with a knife. Her instinctive self-defence against Morris is a consequence of the extreme violence she has experienced at the hands of these men, something of which Morris is totally ignorant. By grouping Morris with a murderer and rapists, Rowling establishes a continuum of everyday sexism, harassment, and violent misogyny, demonstrating that women’s experience of the former is often influenced by the latter.
Robin’s growth in confidence and ambition, and her courage to forge a new path for herself, is the defining arc of the series. Over the course of five novels, she progresses from office temp to agency partner, repeatedly advocating for herself and patiently honing her craft. Rowling’s choice to contrast Robin’s positive career trajectory with the gradual dissolution of her romantic relationship with partner Matthew offers a realistic exploration of the ‘have it all’ fallacy so often presented to women as easily achievable. This tension between Robin’s private and professional life is established in the opening scenes of the series: the first book in the series, The Cuckoo’s Calling, starts on Robin’s first day at Strike’s detective agency. It is also the day following her engagement. Her post-proposal happiness is short-lived, however, as she begins to find purpose in a career disapproved of by her fiancé. Robin has secretly harboured an ambition to be a detective since childhood, and whilst her family and partner want to wrap her in cotton wool, she is tougher than they expect, or even want her to be. The aftermath of the Ripper’s attack is explored in the fourth novel, Lethal White, which also plots, in agonizing detail, the breakdown of Robin’s marriage. Her husband’s lack of support is corrosive, as Robin hides her panic attacks from him, determined to prove she is up to the job. However, it is in fact Robin’s experience of trauma, her natural empathy, and her awareness of vulnerability which make her a good detective. Robin’s self-determination is what drives many of the feminist themes throughout the series, and the scope of Troubled Blood is only possible because Rowling has established such a well-rounded, feminist protagonist. In Robin, Rowling has created neither a superhero survivor nor a defeated victim, but a truly relatable woman, extraordinary in overcoming experiences all too common to so many of us.
Even before it was published, people were talking about Troubled Blood. An early review in the Telegraph claimed the book was about “a transvestite serial killer,” with Jake Kerridge pondering “what critics of Rowling’s stance on trans issues will make of a book whose moral seems to be: never trust a man in a dress.”4 A predictable yet bizarre media storm followed, during which everyone from writers at PinkNews to Piers Morgan furiously debated a book they had not read. It is perhaps unsurprising that Kerridge chose to focus on the character of Dennis Creed in his review, considering Rowling’s essay published in June 2020, outlining her stance on sex, gender, and the current conflict between women’s rights and trans rights. I suspect a cynical attempt to capitalize on an already fraught issue; Kerridge’s claim that the book’s moral is “never trust a man in a dress” is undermined by the fact that the murderer of Margot Bamborough (and many others) is, in fact, a woman.
The report that Creed would sometimes wear “a wig” and be “padded out in a woman’s coat” (p. 75) is a double red herring: it is intended to leave open the possibility that Margot’s last patient, the indeterminately gendered Theo, was in fact Creed, and to distract us from the witness account of two women struggling in the street shortly after Margot disappears. Investigators at the time assume this was Margot and Creed, but in fact Margot is fighting off the practice nurse, Janice, who had drugged her. A claim often made by activists is that gender (meaning sex) must always be disclosed, and cannot ever be assumed, yet this is at odds with how humans perceive the world. If asked to describe someone for a police interview, assumptions about sex will inevitably be made. Of course, these assumptions are also often based on gendered presentation, and are not always reliable. The point is that ambiguity is often at play, and as a writer of detective fiction, Rowling knows and exploits this frequently in her crime novels to create uncertainty and build suspense.
With the character of Creed, Rowling was not suggesting that transgender people are deviant, as intimated by the Telegraph review. Her sympathetic and respectful portrayal of a trans character in The Silkworm, the second book in the Strike series, is a much better indicator of her views. The character of Pippa has been used as evidence of Rowling’s transphobia, yet the argument seems to amount to an acknowledgement that the character has male secondary sex characteristics. Journalist and transwoman Katelyn Burns has also argued in the American LGBT magazine them. that Pippa’s characterization as “unstable and aggressive” is a transphobic trope.5 Yet Pippa’s attempted attack on Strike is motivated by love for another character under suspicion (she has more noble intentions than those motivating the other characters populating the novel). If it is an occasionally unflattering portrayal, it is only as unflattering as the drunk literary editor or the bitter agent also caught up in the investigation. Pippa’s youth and vulnerability explain her high emotion, as does her precarious status as a recently out transwoman. Strike’s threat that “it won’t be fun for you inside, Pippa, … Not pre-op” is offensive, but it is not an endorsement by Rowling.6 They are words spoken by an ex-soldier in the early 2010s and, moreover, a detective with the sole aim of eliciting information through provocation. The overall characterization of Pippa is sensitive (she is never misgendered, for instance) and Robin in particular shows her kindness and empathy. Most importantly, Pippa feels like a real person, not a stereotype.
Despite the argument made by some commentators that the Telegraph review was in bad faith, those defending the book against inflammatory reporting did miss the mark slightly in claiming there was no wider significance to the character of Creed. The terror that he inspired in women throughout the 1970s permeates the novel, and his extreme misogynistic violence is structurally significant to its wider themes. Furthermore, Creed is there to distract the reader and obscure the real killer. Rowling experiments with not one but two serial killer tropes in Troubled Blood: the sexually motivated male serial killer who lures from the street, and the Angel of Death nurse who turns her patients into victims. Readers replicate the logic of the 1970s investigators when we focus too heavily on the former, enabling the latter to continue undetected. When Nurse Janice is revealed as responsible not only for Margot’s murder but at least three other deaths assumed to be accidents, and countless instances of poisoning (including an attempt to drug Strike), it is truly shocking. I’ve yet to speak to a reader who worked it out, despite plenty of clues.
This oversight by detectives and readers alike is partly due to social expectations and the sweeping assumptions we so often make, and partly due to the game of fiction itself! As Strike admonishes himself, “Nurses were angels, ministering to the vulnerable”: he saw Janice “through the prism” (p. 879) of the nurses who cared for him after his amputation, and the Macmillan nurse who cared for his dying aunt. “He’d been as guilty of bias as Vi Cooper,” Creed’s landlady, who had rented to “a sweet boy, bit lost and lonely” who she thought was another “pansy” like those she knew from the theatre (p. 879; p. 90). This was an assumption Creed cynically drew on, as he tells Strike, “in a wig, bit of lipstick … they think you’re harmless, odd … maybe queer … you’re the nice man that’s safe” (pp. 854-55). In his review, Kerridge characterizes Creed as a transvestite, yet Creed’s public disguises are designed to deceive witnesses and victims, not affirm his identity. His penchant for stealing his neighbours’ underwear to masturbate into seems to be motivated by a desire to violate women’s boundaries, rather than being evidence of cross-dressing. We are to infer that Creed is not “queer” or a “pansy” (to use the characters’ terminology) but rather a manipulator who, like the nurse, knows how to exploit certain sympathetic personas.
Both Creed and Janice are unsettling partly because their actions reposition apparently benign figures as threatening and pose uncomfortable questions about femininity. Some commentators may resist or reject the inclusion of such characters, but real-life examples are easy to find. Rowling took inspiration from serial killers Russell Williams and Jerry Brudos for her development of Creed.7 ‘Angels of Death’ nurses Jane Toppan, Beverley Allitt, and Kristen Gilbert all share characteristics and methods with the calculating, sadistic Janice. These women are notorious partly because they have transgressed the expected feminine role of maternal caregiver. For both Creed and Janice, femininity is a disguise. In a book which is so preoccupied with violence against women, this is both a brilliant novelistic manipulation, and a further complication of the gendered dynamics of criminality.
In Troubled Blood, Rowling threads numerous feminist themes throughout her narrative. One prominent issue is the sex industry, which touches on everything from SlutWalks to poverty-induced prostitution. When Margot vanishes, the press lead with ten-year-old photographs of her from the Playboy club, where she worked to support her parents and fund her medical degree. We learn that her participation was born of necessity rather than a passionate belief in the liberatory power of corsets and fluffy ears. As fellow Bunny Girl and friend Oonagh King tells Robin and Strike, the two women understood and disapproved of the objectification, but the money was good: “Middle-class gorls, with their mammies and daddies paying their way, they could afford to burn their bras and have hairy armpits. Margot and I, we did what we had to do [sic]” (p. 265). The harsh reality of Betty Fuller’s life in prostitution (she describes how she was subjected to injury, blackmail, and poverty), and the precarity of the sex workers targeted by Creed, represent the even darker side of the sex trade.
These issues are debated during a disastrous dinner party, reluctantly hosted by Robin and comprising an ill-assorted guest list of her mild-mannered roommate, a drunk Strike, and several young students, friends of Robin’s brother. The claim by ‘sex positive’ students Courtney and Kyle that “the literal definition of female empowerment” is women wanting “to make a living out of their own bodies” (p. 489) seems preposterous (as Betty Fuller herself later points out [p. 695]) within the context of the novel’s ongoing narrative. Critics could argue that the students’ arguments are unfairly positioned as idealistic, a strawman to which Rowling can easily set a match. Strike’s impassioned response to the students—that reclaiming misogynist slurs is futile, that “the porn industry’s full of trafficking” (p. 490), and that objectification is not solved if simply reframed as empowerment—seems to do this. Yet Robin’s reaction derails the debate. Rather than answer Strike when he demands to know her opinion on SlutWalks, she confronts him for creating a scene, dumping his aggression at her house, and leaving her to clean up the emotional fallout. Robin is strangely isolated during the dinner party, and we experience the scene completely from her perspective. Of the six guests, she has the most immediate experience of sexual trauma, yet she is the quietest. While the heated argument between Strike, Kyle, and Courtney rages, Robin’s heart beats “so fast it hurts” (p. 492). When it’s blurted out that she is “an actual rape victim,” “the room seemed to warp” around her (p. 493). She accuses Strike of laying her open to having her private experiences “bandied about in a fucking argument, in front of strangers” (p. 496). It’s a sobering moment, and we suddenly view the preceding debate in a completely different light. Rather than a nuanced interrogation of the various merits or evils of pornography (all the inebriated slurring should have been enough of a warning to us), the scene reminds us that real women’s experiences should not be reduced to soundbites to score points.
The most disturbing moment in the book is the description of a film featuring the gang rape and execution of a woman. During the course of an investigation which solves the mystery of Margot’s disappearance and finds the body of another of Creed’s victims, Louise Tucker, the detectives are also able to identify the woman in the film as Kara Wolfson. Unlike with Margot and Louise, Kara’s body is not recovered and therefore no one is held accountable for her murder. However, Strike suspects she fell victim to the Riccis—the mafia family in which Gloria, the receptionist inspired by Simone de Beauvoir, finds herself trapped. When the dust settles after reading the book, the reader is left with the sickening knowledge of just how vital it was for Gloria to listen to Margot and realize “I had to save me” (p. 831).
In a conversation with Robin, Strike claims that a previous investigator characterized a witness as “A radical feminist witch.” Robin remarks that it “sounds quite cool when you say it” (p. 636). I like to imagine Rowling grinning when she wrote this line, knowing that her latest book could very well be described as being authored by a radical feminist witch. I, for one, think that’s more than quite cool.
Suffragetti is an early-career researcher based at a UK university. She works on feminist approaches to history and literature, with a particular interest in language and the body. You can follow her @Suffragetti on Twitter.
1 Simone de Beauvoir, cited in Robert Galbraith, Troubled Blood (London: Sphere, 2020), p. 821. All subsequent references to page numbers appear parenthetically.
2 J. K. Rowling, ‘J.K. Rowling writes about her reasons for speaking out on sex and gender issues,’ 10 June 2020.
3 For information, statistics, and further reading, see ‘How long do people live with domestic abuse, and when do they get help to stop it?’ SafeLives.
4 Jake Kerridge, ‘Troubled Blood by Robert Galbraith, review: JK Rowling fails to strike again,’ The Telegraph, 13 September 2020.
5 Katelyn Burns, ‘Is J.K. Rowling transphobic? A trans woman investigates,’ them., 28 March 2018.
6 Robert Galbraith, The Silkworm (London: Sphere, 2014), p. 325.
7 See answer to ‘What are the main themes of the book?’ at the book’s promotional website. See also p. 378 of Troubled Blood.
