by Paula Alice
Kathleen Stock, Material Girls: Why Reality Matters for Feminism (London: Fleet, 2021), 320pp., £16.99.
Helen Joyce, Trans: When Ideology Meets Reality (London: Oneworld, 2021), 320pp., £16.99.
It was 2004 when I first realized that believing in reality could be a political position. That was when the New York Times reported a conversation with a senior advisor to US president George W. Bush, in which critics of the administration’s reckless foreign policy were labelled, derisively, “the reality-based community.” “That’s not the way the world really works anymore,” the official was quoted as saying:
We’re an empire now, and when we act, we create our own reality. And while you’re studying that reality — judiciously, as you will — we’ll act again, creating other new realities, which you can study too, and that’s how things will sort out. We’re history’s actors … and you, all of you, will be left to just study what we do.1
I remember reading those words and feeling a sharp mental jolt, like my brain had skipped a beat. Imagine thinking you could overwrite actual reality — i.e. objective independent existence — with your fantasies of domination. Imagine the arrogance of these extraordinarily powerful men, who could declare evidence, reasoned argument, and the effects of their grand visions on actual human lives simply irrelevant. Though that particular neoconservative bubble of hubris quickly popped, it seems to me that the political playbook behind it has been influential far beyond: the thought-terminating talking points, the lofty narratives removed from on-the-ground realities, the ‘with us or against us’ hostility to the mildest questioning, the media and institutions either bullied or brainwashed into compliance — sometimes I wonder if the gender-identity movement was taking notes. The mental jolts have become a familiar feeling over the last few years.
That word, ‘reality,’ features in the subtitles of two recent books that mark the introduction of gender-critical thought to the literary mainstream. While the past few years have given us several books skeptical of aspects of current transgender ideology—notably, Abigail Shrier’s Irreversible Damage (reviewed by Suffragetti in Issue One, pp. 26-27) and Debra Soh’s The End of Gender (which I reviewed in Issue Two, pp. 76-79) — the valuable contributions of those books were counterweighted, at least to those coming at the issue from a feminist perspective, by a certain gender-role traditionalism and, in the case of Shrier’s book, an inflammatory cover. These two new books, then, are the first attempts to chronicle and analyse the gender-identity movement from a broadly feminist point of view. Both are essential reading — Kathleen Stock’s Material Girls for its clear, forensic deconstruction of the concepts propping up gender-identity ideology, and Helen Joyce’s Trans for a wide-ranging look at how the movement based on those concepts took shape, and how it is affecting policy and people. Both are crucial for understanding how a strange idea — that subjective personal identities should completely overwrite the material reality of bodies — has taken hold in legislation, the media, and institutions, with consequences for all of us.
Stock and Joyce are both relatively late entrants in the TERF wars — Stock, a philosophy professor, first wrote publicly about the conflict of rights between women and transwomen, and her philosophy colleagues’ curious silence on the matter, in a Medium post in 2018; Joyce, a journalist and editor, started writing about transgender issues for the Economist in 2017. They quickly became important voices: both free thinkers with impressive logical skills who write with precision, passion, and clarity, in a way that is both deeply informed and accessible. Articles by Joyce and Stock are among the ones I’ve found most useful to share with newcomers to the issue.
Stock believes her outsider perspective — her academic specialty is not in gender studies or feminism — has helped her to see the problems with these ideologies objectively, and throughout Material Girls she maintains a refreshing independence of thought, one that is bound to bump up against dogmas of various sorts. The book begins with an enlightening “whistle-stop tour” of eight key moments that contributed to what Stock calls the “rapid intellectual onset of gender identity theory” — from misinterpretations of Simone de Beauvoir, through the clinical invention of ‘gender identity’ by psychologists in the 1960s, to the academics, writers, and international human-rights activists contributing, intellectual piece by piece, to the destabilization of sexed reality and the reification of increasingly abstruse identity claims. Stock skilfully shows how these individual ideas and trends have built on each other, stacking up to form a kind of tottering Jenga tower of bullshit: pull out just one brick and the whole thing could collapse. The familiar figures are there — Stock has a satisfying takedown of Judith Butler, to her fans “the Harry Potter of philosophy, transforming boring old truisms about the material world into something alchemical, shifting and sexily impermanent” — but she also highlights influential figures who may be less widely known, including Thomas Laqueur, whose 1990 book Making Sex argued that the concept of two distinct sexes was a socially constructed Enlightenment invention (Stock traces a certain ‘female skeleton’ tweet to his influence), and trans writer Julia Serano, whose 2007 book Whipping Girl Stock credits with popularizing the term ‘cis,’ the notion of the ‘trans lesbian,’ and the idea that gender identity is what makes one a man or woman. This opened up the “deeply radical” idea of the non-transitioned transwoman: where previously some might have argued that a male person could ‘become a woman’ in some sense by altering appearance to look female, thus fulfilling the social role associated with women, now none of this was necessary — to identify as a woman was all it took to be one.
At the heart of Material Girls is a careful exploration of the concepts that matter in the debate about transgender and women’s rights — what they mean, why popular transactivist framings of them don’t work, and how we might better think about them, considering them as “cognitive tools” rather than “‘exclusionary’ weapons.” First, Stock provides a useful disambiguation of ‘gender,’ that word at the heart of the conflict that seems to mean anything and nothing. As she writes, “It is a standing feature of almost any argument between feminists and trans activists that the word ‘gender’ will appear there in several different senses, often unnoticed and in a way that increases confusion and toxicity exponentially.” (If I were the writing police, I would require everyone using the word, effective immediately, to point to which of her four definitions they mean — essentially: 1. sex; 2. sex stereotypes; 3. system of sex stereotypes; and 4. personality in relation to sex stereotypes.) She considers the questions of what sex is, what gender identity means, and what a woman is, thoroughly taking apart all the greatest hits of transactivist argumentation — from ‘you can’t see my chromosomes’ and ‘are you going to do genital checks’ to ‘what about intersex’ and ‘sex is a social construct’ — and making the case for why and where we still need to recognize sex.
Stock accepts that there is some property, at least in some people, that we can call a ‘gender identity’ (and that, in her terms, it can be ‘misaligned’), but she rejects popular explanations of what that means. Evidence for what she calls the ‘stick of rock’ model — that our gender identity is an innate, inborn property running through us, like the pattern in the centre of a rock candy — is weak, relying on small, inconclusive brain studies and not accounting for how being sex-atypical in behaviour can reinforce the sense of a ‘misaligned gender identity.’ The medical model, which views gender dysphoria as a disorder to be treated with transition, may have advantages for suffering patients, but may also pathologize gender-non-conforming behaviour (bleakly, Stock notes that gender-identity disorders were added to the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual at the same time that ‘homosexuality’ was removed). Finally, there’s the queer theory model, which, in principle at least, rejects the notions of stable identity and views transness primarily as a way to performatively fuck around with categories — fun for edgy college students, not so helpful for dysphoric people struggling with their bodies.
As an alternative, Stock endorses an ‘identification model’ of gender — as in identification with rather than as. She presents this as analogous to how we might identify with a sports team, pop star, or political movement — the sort of identification that, as long as it doesn’t become dysfunctional, can be a way of finding belonging and meaning. In this view, having a ‘misaligned gender identity’ means to see some commonality with the other sex (or with some notion of androgyny), and to want to become more like them: a “desire or yearning to be like, or sometimes even to merge with, another.” Does this sort of identification necessarily depend on a reductive or idealizing view of what the categories of ‘woman’ and ‘man’ mean? Probably, Stock admits, but that in itself isn’t a problem. I think it’s worth noting, though, that there’s a difference between identification with a group defined by actions or behaviour, and with a group defined by an unchangeable material state: if you identify with being an environmentalist or a classical-music fan, for instance, the way to become those things is simply by doing them; there’s no equivalent for ‘doing woman,’ and in any context apart from sex and gender, identifying with a group defined by immutable characteristics to the point of wanting to be them is typically considered appropriation. But as Stock points out, wanting to be a woman (or man) and being one are distinct experiences: “perceived similarities aren’t enough to make it true that you actually are identical to the object you identify with.” This way of conceiving of cross-sex identification nicely cuts through Butlerian abstractions and convoluted justifications about the stria terminalis, and it also offers flexibility: a misaligned sense of gender, Stock, says, doesn’t necessarily imply being ‘trans,’ or even having distress or struggle, although it might.
The argument running through Material Girls is that even though we might choose to recognize ‘misaligned gender identities’ in certain ways, sex is too important a variable to ignore or replace with identity-based definitions. “Gender identity theory’s proposed alternative to the traditional concepts WOMAN and MAN cannot possibly cover all of the still-pressing contexts in which we need to use the term ‘woman’, meaningfully, to refer to adult human females, and ‘man’ to refer to adult human males,” Stock writes: for instance, sex is a crucial factor in medicine, sport, sexual orientation, and in the many social inequalities that follow from the exploitation of women’s bodies and labour. By replacing sex with gender identity, she argues — in data collection, in sex-segregated spaces, in law — we are losing our ability to recognize and address problems for women that still haven’t gone away.
How, then, should we accommodate the needs of women and of people who identify as transgender? A change of sex on documents is often called a ‘legal fiction,’ and Stock, whose philosophical work is mostly in the area of fiction and imagination, thinks the idea of being ‘immersed in a fiction’ provides a model for how we think of trans people in relation to their desired sex. In the same way we suspend our disbelief when watching a movie, for instance, we can act as if — but no matter how immersed we become, some part of our consciousness stays in touch with reality. As Stock notes, immersion can be damaging if people lose themselves in it and can’t acknowledge reality when it matters. And immersing other people in your fiction can’t be coerced; it’s a state that needs to be entered into freely. I do wonder, is it too much to ask that we could see and accept even the most feminine of men or masculine of women exactly as they are, without the mutual constructing of fictions? Still, this view is an appealing alternative to the rigid literalism of ‘trans women are women,’ and perhaps a good model for a more lightly held form of identity. Reality matters, Stock seems to be saying, but we can also be flexible in our thinking — and equally, the principles of fiction can help us accommodate those who find their own sexed reality particularly difficult to bear.
Material Girls has a thought-provoking section on the objectification of women — how it’s been intensified by selfie culture and prevalent pornography, and how that ties into current ideas about what being a woman means. Many young women, Stock writes, are already primed to view themselves, and women in general, as “sexualised feminine objects” — which makes their acceptance of sexualized feminine males as women much easier. These objectified images of women, Stock proposes, also “contribute to conditions under which some men develop misaligned gender identities in the first place.” In an even-handed discussion of autogynephilia and ‘sissification,’ the phenomenon of some men being drawn to the sexual humiliation of being ‘feminized,’ she writes that this gives us “insight into the general way our culture reprehensibly objectifies and dehumanises women — with inadvertent consequences for the sexual development of both girls and boys growing up within it.” Many radical feminists, Stock assumes, will be “outraged” by such what-about-men thoughts. (Earlier in the book, in a similar vein, she writes that we shouldn’t blame transwomen for being drawn to regressive stereotypes of women, since many women are drawn to them too.) I think she is partly right — the objectification of women is bad for men too, in the sense of being unlikely to help them develop into well-rounded people who can have healthy relationships. At the same time, we can’t ignore power dynamics: it wasn’t women who decided to objectify women, however much they might participate in a system that was already rigged against them, and it’s not women who benefit from having a class of people trained to see themselves as decorative and submissive. Damaging feminine stereotypes are adopted by females and males under very different conditions.
Stock continues her refusal to stick to neat political lines in the final chapter, where she proposes some better ways forward for activism. She decries the online point-scoring between sides in the gender war, and criticizes some tendencies among trans-skeptical feminists that she sees as counterproductive — “frequent casual denigration of trans women’s characters,” referring to trans or detransitioned people as ‘mutilated,’ or refusal to use terms recognizing that ‘transition’ has any meaning at all. (Fear not, she has plenty of criticism for transactivists and mainstream feminists too.) Of course everyone has the right to choose their own words, and one person’s reasonable compromise will be another’s ideological capitulation; prescribing other people’s language from any direction won’t make you very popular. But as a great woman told us, it takes as much bravery to stand up to your friends as to your enemies, and all movements need to work out their limits for what’s politically unhelpful or ethically unjustified — if the transactivist side had ever done the bare minimum of this, things would not be nearly as fraught as they are. To my mind, Stock comes down in about the right place. She encourages us all to “be more non-binary” and try to seek compromises about issues like language or ‘passing’ transpeople using the bathrooms where they blend in best, with advocacy for third spaces as a good option. And she has sympathy for the trans people “stuck in between those trans activists who say their sex should never be referred to, and those feminists who say it always should.” As she writes, “Trans women and trans men each deserve non-inflammatory vocabulary which articulates their particular experiences.” At the same time, Stock is hardly telling women to ‘be kind’: she repeatedly defends the right of women to hold their own interests and perceptions, and to use sex-based language where it matters and sex-based pronouns if they choose to. Stock’s argument that we need to ground ourselves in reality while resisting rigidity and dogma — wherever it comes from — is a valuable and important one.
Trans, like Material Girls, begins with history, but rather than tracing the intellectual development of the gender-identity movement, Joyce goes straight to the engine powering it: the desperate desire of some men to be women. She tells the fascinating stories of some early transsexual pioneers, starting with Lili Elbe, the ill-fated ‘Danish girl,’ and shows the doctors who honed their techniques on them as compassionate in their willingness to help people typically dismissed as mad at the time, but also motivated by some dubiously unscientific ideas about sex and gender. It’s interesting to observe how many features of the current trans movement were present from the very beginning: sex-role stereotypes and homophobia; unrealistic patient fantasies (Elbe expected to be able to give birth); and sex-as-a-spectrum mushiness (Magnus Hirschfeld, the German sexologist who experimented on Elbe, thought that all of us contained both sexes and could be “moved along” the pathway toward one or the other by way of hormones and surgery — a view later adopted by Harry Benjamin, who founded the organization that became the World Professional Association for Transgender Health). Marking the effective starting point of the sex-change industry in the 1950s with the sensational transition of former American GI Christine Jorgensen, which was helped along by advancing medical discoveries and surgical techniques, Joyce spans outward to explain “the key elements that have enabled transsexuality, once understood as a rare anomaly, to be converted into an all-encompassing theory of sex and gender, and body and mind.”
Joyce doesn’t bother with detailed explanations of what sex is, or why it is binary and real—Darwin’s theory of evolution, she writes, should have settled that matter for good. She cleverly explains the theory of gender identity with reference to the movie The Matrix, in which reality, or what we perceive as reality, is the enemy preventing us from accessing our true self. The dualistic idea of a mind at odds with its reshapeable meat prison is, she writes, a symptom of our disembodied digital age:
many people now spend more time in virtual worlds than the real one. Someone who rarely engages with nature or exerts themselves physically will be predisposed towards body-denialism. And if you spend a lot of time playing computer games, you will have become accustomed to identifying with avatars who can be altered on a whim.
She writes insightfully of the human tendency to understand ourselves in the terms dictated by current science and technology: think of how the brain is often described as ‘hardwired,’ or as processing or storing information — an inaccurate and oversimplified metaphor for our vastly complex biological organism, but one that encourages us to view ourselves as reprogrammable and alterable machines. Joyce quotes the biotech-billionaire transwoman Martine Rothblatt’s manifesto From Transgender to Transhuman as the logical end point of this philosophy: “We can of course self-replicate our bodies via sexual intercourse (or IVF). But we can soon also satisfy that urge to self-replicate by copying just our minds in software.”
One of the many strengths of Trans is the way Joyce places developments in the gender-identity movement within wider societal shifts and trends, allowing the reader to see echoes and parallels through history. For instance, she sets the rise of transsexuality in the later half of the 20th century within the shift to an individualistic, atomized notion of identity and the growth of bureaucracy, which effectively created a legal ‘self’ that could exist on paper, separate from our bodies. Joyce traces the changing definitions of ‘woman,’ which, it seems, are part and parcel of their time: from a “communal” definition based on reproductive role within a species to individualized identities based on a personal relationship to sex roles. The efforts to include transwomen in women’s sports have redefined women again as a consumer product that anyone can attain with the right surgical or hormonal intervention, while the purely identity-based notion simply makes ‘woman’ an empty void for the male imagination to fill. (“When women are limitless and formless, they can have no political demands,” Joyce writes.)
Trans provides clear insight into the way that ‘gender’ is very much culturally bound. In an early chapter, Joyce discusses researcher Paul Vasey’s research into ‘androphilic’ (male-attracted) men in various cultures, which strongly suggests that the same type of person — a very feminine gay boy — can grow up to conceive of himself in a variety of ways depending on the frameworks and options provided by his culture: “The degree to which their gender non-conformity distresses them, whether they will try to suppress it and whether they will seek to modify their bodies all also seem to be largely culturally determined.” Similarly, in a later chapter, historian Selina Todd tells Joyce about how women from the past who wished to escape the restrictions placed on them because of their sex, including those who disguised themselves as men, were also influenced by their environment and the options available to them: “If her era offers a convincing analysis of the sex-based oppression of women as a group, she is less likely to identify as a man, and more likely to stay and fight for more freedoms for all women,” Joyce writes. She also discusses the increase in dysphoric teenage girls in the context of historical social contagions, explaining how the medical system has often located their source in women’s anatomy (“Judging by the historical record, when a psychic epidemic hits, doctors often feel moved to centre interventions on the female reproductive system”).
‘Trans’ is of course not just one thing, and Joyce shows its various faces — the children who don’t fit in neat boxes, the straight men with a late-blooming ‘woman inside,’ the unhappy teenage girls. She points out the deep contradictions in current trans ideology, where on the one hand, the body must be completely transformed to match the inner self, while on the other, inner identity, rather than any kind of appearance or physical features, is all it takes to be male or female: at the extreme of this, “some cutting-edge activists now regard the very concept of transition as transphobic.” Yet it’s the ‘wrong body’ philosophy that dictates the current, highly politicized approach to gender-dysphoric children: Joyce gives sunlight to the jaw-dropping assertions of certain high-profile gender clinicians, the online forums where parents frighten each other with suicide predictions while removing themselves further and further from reality, and the “suggest-selling” of trans identities to children. As she points out, reductive stereotypical ideas in the guise of diversity and acceptance have gone beyond the gender clinic and are now being taught to all children, through picture books and teen workbooks, school curricula, and social media memes. While they claim that gender identity isn’t based on stereotypes, without reference to bodies, that’s the only concrete thing they can be based on: “For all that gender is supposedly revealed by stereotyped appearances and actions, it is defined as an inner knowing. This helps conceal how regressive it is,” Joyce writes. She notes with characteristic logical rigour that in popular educational-indoctrination tools for children like the Genderbread Person, ‘gender identity’ is defined circularly and vaguely, with stereotypes about ‘gender expression’ — meaning clothes and haircuts — as “the only objective input,” and therefore very likely the thing children will latch onto when trying to figure out their ‘gender.’ “Most children will survive this stuff without becoming alienated from their physical reality,” she writes. “Even so, it does all children harm. It confuses them about their bodies, and suggests that gender non-conformity marks people as not genuine members of their sex.”
Though many of the stories in Trans will be familiar to those in the gender-war trenches, the depth of Joyce’s research and the clarity and perceptiveness of her analysis bring new insight to even well-known narratives. This is an ambitious, wide-ranging, yet incredibly economical book, packing in a huge amount of history and information while clipping along at a brisk pace. Joyce interviews feminist campaigners and experts, psychologists and detransitioners, among others, covering many facets of the issue, and revealing the huge amounts of money, behind-the-scenes lobbying, and misplaced benevolence that have helped gender-identity theory to spread.
While Material Girls focuses mostly on the situation in the UK and developments around the proposed reforms to the Gender Recognition Act, Trans gives equal attention to North America. I am especially grateful to Joyce for bringing attention to the situation in Canada, where the complete enshrinement of gender identity in law has enabled testicle-waxing to be defended as a human right, and our federal correctional service to claim that it couldn’t provide data on males in women’s prisons “since gender was ‘too fluid to track.’” As Joyce notes about the Karen White sexual assault case, widely reported in the UK, “Worse has no doubt happened in Canadian prisons. But the UK, unlike Canada, has newspapers willing to publish stories that contradict the gender-identity narrative.” She is spot on about how huge social and legal shifts have been helped along unquestioned by a certain bizarre trend in North American journalism that “aims at bringing about change by decree rather than argument and evidence.” Analysing a one-sided New York Times article about transwomen in women’s rugby, she writes: “this article consisted only of assertions. It read as if it had emerged from a parallel universe in which humans were not sexually dimorphic, and to think they were was ‘baffling’. This sort of faux journalism [has] left governments and electorates flying blind.”
oyce also provides a solid analysis of the clusterfuck in the US, where political polarization and inappropriate analogies with America’s shameful racial history threaten to turn the situation around sex and gender into another of the country’s intractable “frozen conflicts.” She gives a sympathetic airing to American feminists who have allied with right-wing groups to get their concerns about gender-identity legislation heard. I was grateful to see a European writer take the obstacles North American women face in this fight seriously: it is difficult to know what to do when seemingly every left-to-centre organization and media outlet is completely captured by ideology, and frighteningly hostile to dissenting women. Still, I wish she had acknowledged the costs of these alliances, including how they damage the possibility of gaining broader support; the association of gender-critical arguments with the extreme religious right creates a feedback loop, alienating many left-leaning and moderate women and men who might otherwise be sympathetic to protecting sex-based rights.
Trans is an enormously readable and widely accessible book, full of righteous anger and common-sense feminism. Joyce has a way of eloquently cutting to the point, and there were so many perfectly distilled quotes in the book that I couldn’t stop writing them down. On the ‘cis’ men who aggressively defend self-identified transwomen’s rights to use female spaces, she writes:
Such a man is the most profound type of misogynist: the type that, perhaps unconsciously, sees women as supporting actresses in men’s lives. When a woman’s words or actions reveal that she regards herself as the lead character in her own story, he is outraged by her stepping out of what he regards as her proper place — the background. It is also worth noting that his empathy with transwomen is the clearest possible evidence that he does not truly see them as women. If he did, he would not care about their well-being at all.
And, in one of the most incisive critiques I’ve read of the language of disembodied female parts:
This is not just dehumanising: it also obscures the fact that these body parts and functions come as a package. The same type of person ovulates, menstruates, gestates, gives birth and requires abortions, and possesses the physical features that heterosexual men desire to look at, touch and penetrate. It is the type of person who has been oppressed throughout history, precisely because men want to dominate and control the possessors of this type of body… Dividing women up like this attenuates their power as a constituency.
(Like others before her, Joyce notes the one-sidedness of this demand for inclusivity: “Factsheets about prostate cancer start by saying: ‘Only men have a prostate.’ If you google ‘testicle havers’, you will be asked if you meant ‘testicle shavers’.”)
Both Joyce and Stock emphasize the need for truly intersectional thinking to resolve the conflicts between feminists and transactivists, and to address the needs of various groups — including poor and racialized women, who are disproportionately likely to need safe single-sex spaces, and the Latin American and black American transwomen, often trapped in the sex trade, whose vulnerabilities are rhetorically exploited for sympathy by the transgender movement even as their activism focuses largely on identity validation for well-off, mostly white people. Stock argues that we desperately need more specific, objective data to help trans people and women, not more lofty theorizing from gender-studies academics.
Are Joyce and Stock — and the rest of us — just studying the new reality, catching up while history’s actors are already building new castles in the sky? Will their hundreds of pages of careful evidence, analysis, and argument carry weight against a movement that has simply declared such things irrelevant? As Joyce points out, keeping the public in the dark has been key to advancing an extreme agenda so quickly: “Even as one country after another introduces gender self-ID, very few voters know this is happening, let alone support it.” The discussion can only be rebalanced when the public is properly informed, and it’s hard to imagine anyone but the most committed ideologue reading Material Girls or Trans and thinking: no, there are no problems here at all. Denying reality is unsustainable, and the material consequences of an ill-considered idea are already adding up: young people with pain and scars they regret, women hurt in the places meant to keep them safe, and the absences — from sports, from organizations, from public life — we will likely never be able to count. We shouldn’t have to be brave to say that reality matters — that women matter — but with these brilliant books, Stock and Joyce have both done more than their part to help us say it loudly and without fear.
Paula Alice is an editor, writer, and mother who lives in Canada.
