Issue Four

Editorial Statement

by Jane Clare Jones

Four summers ago, the summer of the consultation, the summer of ‘PUUUUULLLLLLLLLLL,’ I spent the whole season in front of the computer. For the first time since encountering transactivism, the energy was accumulating, a few hairline cracks finally appearing in the unassailable edifice of ideological bullshit. Twitter that summer felt like being trapped inside a video game, like playing high stakes discursive Tekken with an endless stream of bearded bros and anime avatars. Every few days the great homunculus Blob met me on the seafront and we’d dump ourselves into the water. The salty shock of it would jolt me out of my dissociation, and I’d splash around furiously, trying to find my way back into my body, before dematerializing again into the adrenalized Tekken tunnel. 

It’s a clanging irony that a good deal of this battle in defence of the body has been fought in the virtual. Reflections on the dissociative nature of online life run through several pieces in this collection, along with concerns about the importance of honouring our embodied animal selves. This summer, when it at last feels like we might be able to pause and take a collective breath, I find I am starting to slip much more seamlessly into the sea, and can feel the pleasure of it again, my body enlivening to the water and its expanse, the exhale of what has been held too tight for far too long. 

As Helen Joyce notes of Maya Forstater’s new organization Sex Matters, much of our work is “driven by the pure white heat of rage at what is being done”. Driven is how the last three years have felt to many of us, and there is something deeply precious, and itself invigorating, about that animating drive. But as Blob reminds us in her reflection on the warp and weft of weaving, the tying and untying of ribbons, the matrix of life is maintained by the process of “slipping-between,” which Esmée Streachailt also explores on in her long-read “Framing Radical Feminism: Welcome to the Occupation” through the Derridean thought of ‘aporia.’ Our bodies generate and sustain our drives, even while our drives are channelled (paradoxically, aporetically) into ideas, into the discursive, or virtualized, defence of the body and material reality, the watchword of the two new gender-critical books reviewed by Paula Alice. But embodied beings cannot be relentlessly driven. To sustain ourselves we must inhale and exhale, contract and relax, tie and untie. Accepting this is also a defence of reality, and a source of the significance of weaving as a metaphor for the feminist defence of life.

Of course, accepting this is not always easy. We often feel frustrated when our bodies refuse to sustain our drives or desires. Bodies can feel constricting and limiting, and the apparent liberation of frictionless dematerialization can be seductive and, indeed, addictive. Moreover, as Bec Wonders reminds us , in this objectifying world, women often experience their bodies as sites of unsafety, a fact central to our collective assertion that ‘sex matters.’ Still, in defiance of all our frustrations or escapist fantasies, the reality remains that, in Rebecca Bergfjord’s memorable formulation, “The body cannot be cancelled”. This summer, as I spend time away from the Twitter tunnel, tending to my embodied self, I, like Bec Wonders’s Ula, am taking inspiration from the sensation of water: slipping back into my body, enjoying the energy returning to my limbs, swimming out into the blue.