Issue Three

Blob’s Corner: A Storm Is Brewing

by Blob

Current pressures on women’s reproductive agency from both left and right are taking place against a demographic backdrop with significant societal, economic, and geopolitical power implications. Across the entire world, with the exception of the continent of Africa, war-torn regions including Afghanistan, Palestine, Yemen, Iraq and Syria and some Central Asian nations, populations are ageing, and in some cases doing so quite rapidly. The Lancet reports that populations in 23 nations, including Japan, Thailand, Italy, and Spain, are set to halve by 2100 if trends for total fertility rate (TFR) continue.1 In 183 of 195 countries included in their study, populations will diminish to levels that are, in many cases, significantly below current levels without sustained efforts to increase immigration.
Improvements in access to modern contraception and the education of girls and women are generating widespread, sustained declines in fertility, and world population will likely peak in 2064 at around 9.7 billion, and then decline to about 8.8 billion by 2100—about 2 billion lower than some previous estimates.2

The authors of the study stress that “population decline must not compromise progress on women’s freedom and reproductive rights.”3 However, rational factors that very much influence the number of children women have, such as the financial costs associated with childcare and housing, or physical factors such as parents being older at the time when they start a family due to lack of accommodation of child-rearing in education and career development, are not mentioned. The professional world remains, as we all know, conceptualized around a life trajectory modelled on normative man. Using history as a roadmap when we scout the future and its implications, we have good reason to assume that normative man will still be regarded as somehow outside the problem space in which this diminution of populations worldwide occurs. Women and those whose thinking is informed by a female perspective on human life and beyond will need to speak as clearly and with as much determination as we ever have.

To complicate the picture, endocrine-disrupting chemicals with actions on fertility —  particularly male fertility — are back in the spotlight. A new book by Shanna Swan points to falling sperm counts, which the author claims, on the basis of a 2017 review of 185 studies, to have been reduced by more than 50% across the Western world since the 1970s.4 The main culprits identified by the author and her team are endocrine-disrupting chemicals that are very widely used in consumer products, including phthalates and bisphenol-A. Exposure to these, especially in early life, may have far-reaching systemic consequences, including impacts on fertility in both sexes, particularly on sperm quality and count.5

We thus have a global phenomenon, with serious implications for society as we know it, and (currently) two competing narratives for its root causes — one centred on gains made for women, the other focused on the quality of sperm, and the reduction of chemicals that are ubiquitous in consumer goods. It’s a near-perfect allegory of phallocentric capitalism vs. feminism.

We have been anxious about overpopulation for a long time, and a halt to human population growth is clearly of benefit to the planet and our fellow species. If human population growth does not stabilize or diminish, we will hit a critical mass that will enforce it at some point. All other life on earth (apart from the species that populate our detritus, gut flora and factory farms) will benefit from there being fewer of us, and we are likely best served by welcoming these demographic trends. The question is how this diminution takes place — whether it is a peaceful process guided by reflection and care for all life, or one fraught by exploitation and violence.

Any economic system that depends on expansion, such as the late capitalism within which we live, relies on a steady supply of people of whom a significant proportion must be of working age. As the pressures on economies around the world increase, we will see attitudes to migration and reproduction change. This is inevitable, regardless of how the phenomenon is explained and/or addressed, and it is vital that we feminists take active part. Reproductive labour is the fundament of any economic system, including capitalism. Without it, society cannot function. Whether we think of childbearing, care labour or community-focused creativity — all vital parts of reproductive labour — women carry the lion’s share. We are facing important discussions, and we must be ready.

Blob. Vive la différence. Le Blob, @tryingattimes.

1 Stein Emil Vollset and others, ‘Fertility, Mortality, Migration, and Population Scenarios for 195 Countries and Territories from 2017 to 2100: A Forecasting Analysis for the Global Burden of Disease Study,’ The Lancet, 396 (2020), 1285-306.

2 The Lancet, ‘World population likely to shrink after mid-century, forecasting major shifts in global population and economic power,’ EurekAlert!, 14 July 2020.

3 The Lancet, ‘World population.’

4 Shanna Swan and Stacey Colino, Count Down: How Our Modern World Is Threatening Sperm Counts, Altering Male and Female Reproductive Development, and Imperiling the Future of the Human Race (New York, NY: Scribner, 2021).

5 Linda G. Kahn and others, ‘Endocrine-Disrupting Chemicals: Implications for Human Health,’ The Lancet: Diabetes and Endocrinology, 8.8 (August 2020), 703-18.