by Charlotte Russell
For every child born into contemporary Western1 society, induction into a world of misogyny begins at birth—and its first manifestation is evident in the social and cultural milieu of motherhood
In this article, I’m going to explore this epigraph via a discussion of how we approach babies’ sleep and sleep safety. It represents a conclusion reached after nearly 15 years in the business of studying aspects of parenting, so while much of the discussion focuses on academic research evidence, what I hope to illuminate is the misogyny embedded in, and revealed by, the way we think, talk about, and behave around, babies’ sleep.
For almost two decades, I made my career in academia. The majority of this time was spent conducting original research in the field of parent-infant sleep, and working on the ‘translation’ of research for use in the ‘real world.’2 Early on in my career I had my own baby, giving me the opportunity to experience the subject of my work first-hand, and inspiring me to reflect on my perspective not only as a researcher but also as a participant and mother, as well as sister, friend and auntie!
Bringing the anthropological subfields — social, cultural and physical — together with evolutionary medicine, my colleagues and I fundamentally challenged popular and public health approaches to infant sleep, sleep safety, and nighttime infant care. We changed the way the relationship between mothers and babies (and the mother-baby unit, or ‘dyad’) is understood and consequently addressed in health policy. We worked with organizations across the governmental and non-governmental spectrum; with private and charitable bodies; with health-care professionals and self-employed individuals; with volunteers and educators; and with parents directly. We produced and maintained — often in our own time, and with shoestring funding — a resource for parents and health-care professionals which was met with huge enthusiasm, and for which we received the Queen’s Anniversary Prize in 2018.3
In recent years, however, as radical feminism has become increasingly important in my life, and central to my thinking, I have developed an ever-more-critical attitude to my work. In the summer of 2020 I left academia to pursue a different path. I feel that the expertise I accrued during my time in academia can now serve as an entryway to thinking about a broader range of issues that matter to women. I am currently working on a book entitled Birthing Misogyny that brings my particular kind of anthropological view of reproduction and parenting practices into conversation with a radical feminist politics.
With this piece I would like to outline part of this project. Using parent-infant bed-sharing as an exemplar, I will lay out how we can understand this parenting practice, and the ways in which our (researchers’, policy-makers’, the general public’s) attitudes reflect a deeply held misogyny, which in turn situates the mother-as-resource under patriarchy.
For many, an initial reaction to the idea of bed-sharing—by which I mean ‘an adult sleeping in an adult bed together with an infant,’ often referred to as ‘co-sleeping’ — is that it is dangerous. We have been led to believe that if you do it, your baby is going to die, and it will be your fault. This is not an exaggeration. One ‘safe sleep’ campaign in the United States explicitly cast mothers’ bodies as deadly weapons, using images of a baby in close proximity to a meat cleaver to make the point. Similar campaigns have been employed elsewhere in the US, and in the UK and Australasia.4
So far, so scary, yes?! And yet … the risk of infant death, in any context—including during co-sleeping — is actually very small. 5 Approximately 680,000 babies are born annually in England and Wales. At least half of these will have co-slept with one or both parents during their first three months of life. In 2017, a total of 183 babies sadly died of SIDS (Sudden Infant Death Syndrome — an unexpected death for which no cause can be found). That’s a 1 in 3710 risk of SIDS overall.6
Research indicates that half of these deaths will have occurred in a co-sleeping context.7 There is a lot going on here, and the data surrounding what is a very variable behaviour are extremely complicated. What is worth outlining at this point, however, is the additional information we now have about which babies are most at risk of SIDS in this context. The most recent data show that 90% of SIDS deaths that happen while sleeping with an adult occur with what researchers refer to as ‘modifiable risk factors’ present. The presence of these, in addition to co-sleeping, make the risk of death much higher. These factors include sleeping with an adult on a sofa or chair (very high risk, 1 in 203); co-sleeping plus adult alcohol or drug use (also very high risk, 1 in 203); and co-sleeping with an adult smoker (1 in 919).
- An evolutionary perspective on mother-baby sleep contact, in order to understand what we do with our babies at night in terms of evolved biology and behaviour.
- The role of epidemiological research into SIDS (epidemiology is the study of the what, who, when, where and — most challenging of all — why), to understand the source of our knowledge about SIDS and its relationship with bed-sharing.
- The underlying importance of Western (WEIRD) societies’ attitudes to babies’ sleep, and parent/mother-baby sleep contact, in order to understand why we do what we do with our babies from a socio-cultural perspective.
We can begin by thinking in terms of humans as animals.
It is easy to forget that humans—in all their complexity and diversity—are, at the end (and indeed at the beginning) of the day, ‘just’ another species of animal here on earth. Scientists and philosophers can (and do!) argue ’til the cows come home about what it is that makes us distinctly human, relative to other animals — be it a particular kind of consciousness, free will, moral agency, and so on and on (and on). The fact remains that in many ways that matter, Homo sapiens are a product of their evolutionary history just like any other animal you care to think of.
In this way, we can think of ourselves as members of the mammal family, and of the primate family. As mammals, we are warm-blooded, give birth to live young (as opposed to laying eggs), and lactate to feed our babies milk. Simplistically, mammal species can be divided into two categories. One category contains what we call ‘altricial’ species, whose infants are usually born in multiples or litters, blind, hairless and physically less developed.10 They are vulnerable to predation, and to environmental threats, and are therefore sequestered in a nest. The nest provides safety and warmth while the mother leaves to forage food. With the mother gone much of the time, these infants are fed infrequently — as little as once or twice a day — with milk that is relatively high in fat, and that consequently takes a long time to digest.
‘Precocial’ species, on the other hand, give birth to young that are usually born singly, more physically developed, able to cling to the mother or walk and follow shortly after birth, and who stay with the mother at all times, including while she forages. They are fed frequently — as often as hourly — on demand, with milk that is low in fat, high in sugar, and quickly digested.
So there are important differences in physiology and in the way babies and mothers of altricial and precocial species behave. As mammals, which of these categories do you think humans belong to?
Like all other primates, characterized as precocial, human babies are born with some well-developed systems (sight, hearing and communication) and are fed frequently (as all mothers of newborns know!) on milk that is relatively high in sugar and quickly digested. However, because of poorly developed neuromuscular control, our babies are not able to get up and follow their mother any time soon after birth, nor are they able to cling to their mother (although you may have experienced the surprisingly strong hand grip of babies, reminiscent of our primate cousins). Humans have around 25% of our eventual adult brain capacity at birth, compared to other primates, which have around 50%. In non-human primate species, the rate of growth of an infant slows considerably right after birth. Comparatively, in humans the foetal growth rate continues more or less unchanged until the baby is about one year of age. Humans are therefore considered to be ‘secondarily altricial.’
The reason for this anomaly is a matter of hot debate. It may be to do with the evolution of bipedalism (walking upright on two legs), which changed the shape of the pelvis and limited the size of head (and therefore brain) that could pass through, or it might be to do with metabolic limitations on the size of baby that we can grow — how much energy a mother’s body can dedicate to reproduction.
Either way, the upshot is that we are rather peculiar primates ..!
In an evolutionary sense, like all precocial species, our babies ‘expect’ to remain close to their mother at all times and to be fed frequently, despite not being able to maintain that closeness themselves.11 Babies are born without a diurnal circadian rhythm (which in adults, among other things, regulates the way we sleep during the night and wake during the day) and are incapable of sleeping for more than a short period at any one time. When babies are separated from their mother (and yes, there are questions to be asked here about the role of the mother vs. the role of another caregiver), they are less able to regulate their body temperature, breathing, and oxygen levels, they experience more pain in response to stimuli, they cry more, and breastfeeding is disrupted.
So far, so logical! However, when you think about the way that we in Western societies think about babies and their care, the picture starts getting really strange …
If you ask most non-parents to imagine how babies sleep, it will probably involve images of a baby that is alone and quiet, probably asleep for long periods of time, probably in a cot, in a nursery. (Type ‘baby sleep’ into Google Images for a striking illustration of this point!) The idea of babyhood also evokes images of paraphernalia, predominantly sleep-related, such as cots, hammocks, dummies (pacifiers), swaddles, monitors, white noise devices, and so on. If it’s not sleep-related then it’s for entertainment or soothing—mobiles, play pens, play mats, etc. etc.
What should be striking in the light of the evolutionary picture I described above is that we are not really treating our babies like the primates they are. What we appear to be doing is putting them in a nest.
Now, there are plenty of reasons why we might want to do this, and to a degree, it works just fine. Babies are no longer at risk of predation (no sabre-toothed tigers here!) and our nicely heated houses keep them warm so they’re not at risk from the elements. If we can leave them safe in a cot while we get on with our lives, well, great! We can carry on as before … just with an occasional baby cuddle/feed/play/change added into the mix.
However, as anyone who has spent more than five minutes in the company of a small baby knows, this is rarely how things work in the real world.
Our babies do not know that they are safe, when out of contact with a caregiver. As far as they are concerned, that sabre-toothed tiger or hailstorm could come along at any minute, and if they are alone, then they are vulnerable. So they use that well-developed communication system to vocalize and attract attention … that is, they cry (and cry, and cry, and wail, and scream!). When newborns need feeding every hour or so, day and night, but every time they wake they need settling back to sleep in a cot, a sound night’s sleep for parents quickly becomes a distant memory (and soon after, mental health begins to suffer). And here’s the problem … We cannot reason with our babies, to tell them they are safe (and besides, both babies and mothers benefit physically and emotionally from close contact during the night as well as in the day). So parents (okay, let’s face it, mothers) must make a choice about how to deal with what quickly becomes chronically disrupted sleep.12
Much research has now been done looking at how parents make choices about how they care for their babies at night. For the purpose of this article, however, I want to focus on a couple of key findings. Firstly, most new parents do not intend to sleep with their babies. However, in the first few weeks after birth, in the UK, half of all babies will sleep with a parent or parents. This proportion is higher — 75% — for babies who are breastfed. This is a quite remarkable figure considering it occurs in a context where people are being told, quite forcefully, not to bed-share. Moreover, it is pretty consistently found in studies across Western societies. So immediately we know that parents are doing something they didn’t intend to do, soon after birth, and that this is strongly linked to feeding.13 In other words, bed-sharing is a strategic response to those disturbed nights. (Formula-feeding parents probably feel less ideologically inclined to co-sleep; they may also be more likely to put their baby to sleep in a separate room and, therefore, less likely to be disturbed. Both formula feeding and separate rooms approximately double the risk of SIDS.)14
Other options for parents include sleep training, which ranges from gentle behavioural ‘nudges’ to fairly extreme techniques emphasizing parental non-responsiveness to babies’ communication (known in the world of behavioural science as ‘extinction’ methods). Although parents often report that sleep training ‘worked,’ in the sense that they feel less disturbed by their baby at night, according to most studies it is objectively ineffective in terms of increasing actual amount of sleep, as well as being stressful for both babies and parents.15 That parents feel less disturbed by their baby suggests the baby has been taught not to signal (i.e. cry) rather than having been taught to sleep. Switching to formula feeding can help in the sense that other people can share the burden of night feeds, but it also means that babies and mothers miss out on the benefits of breastfeeding in the short, medium, and long term. It’s similarly objectively ineffective in terms of increasing amount of sleep. Exclusively breastfeeding and exclusively formula-feeding mums get a similar quality of sleep. 16 Those who are combination feeding report poorer-quality sleep. As frustration levels rise, parents may resort to medicating their baby with painkillers or sedatives, or medicalizing the sleep ‘problem’ itself.17 In extreme circumstances parents may become abusive, and babies do get injured and killed, by shaking or smothering.
For women who wish to breastfeed and keep their babies close at night, or who just want to make caring for their baby at night easier, bringing the baby into bed is an instinctive and common-sense response. Bed-sharing has many benefits for mothers and babies, including more sleep, easier breastfeeding, and ability to monitor the baby, plus for a lot of families, it’s downright enjoyable too.18 On this last point, we should note that for a significant proportion of families, and in most (if not all) non-Western cultures, the decision to bed-share is a positive one, reflecting a preference for a family (or mother-and-child) bed, rather than being a reactive response to sleep ‘problems.’ In some cultures fathers expect to leave the adult bed to mother and baby, and this is done willingly in the knowledge that it brings benefits all round, and is temporary. Conversely there are families who bed-share out of necessity, due to a lack of space or money for a cot, or in order to protect baby from environmental hazards — gunfire, for example, or earthquakes. Bed-sharing, clearly, is not one single, simple behaviour.
When breastfeeding mothers and babies have been observed sleeping together, they can be seen to sleep in a particular way: they sleep close together, facing each other, with the mother curled around the baby in a ‘protective C’ in which her arm rests above the baby’s head, and her knees are drawn up beneath baby’s feet. In this position the baby is protected from the pillows, bedclothes and other people in the bed, and it is almost impossible for the mother to roll over on the baby. Babies often sleep on their side, but if they roll away from this position it is likely to be onto their back rather than their tummy. The mother’s sleep cycles become synchronized with her baby’s, and although babies feed more often when sleeping in the bed compared to a cot, mothers wake less fully and return to sleep more quickly. Frequent feeds are essential for successfully starting, and continuing, breastmilk production — the more feeds, the better. Every degree of separation of a baby from a mother, whether in a crib or separate room, results in reduced opportunities to feed, and reduced chance of successful breastfeeding.
An obvious question is about the sleep of bed-sharing dyads who do not breastfeed. Only one study has been done that looks at this. Some differences were found compared to breastfeeding bed-sharers—babies were more likely to be on a pillow, less likely to be facing mother; it was less likely that the mother would be curled around baby, and there was less sleep synchrony.19 Because of these findings, many organizations started advising formula-feeding mothers that they should not sleep with their babies. This is inappropriate, however, as the study in question was small — just ten babies and mothers — and, to my knowledge, has never been repeated anywhere (unlike the very many studies looking at the sleep of breastfeeding dyads).
I think this is a great example of the casual way in which women’s parenting labour is taken for granted, and mother-baby contact devalued. Would any other group of people be subject to such sweeping recommendations on the basis of one study and ten participants?! When I used to give talks on this subject, I would point out that we have seen formula – feeding mothers sleeping just like breastfeeding mothers … we have even seen fathers doing the same! This raises the interesting question — if only someone would consider it important enough to fund research — of whether it is possible to teach people who don’t breastfeed to sleep with their babies in the ‘protective C’ position. For now, the best we can do is suggest that people be alert to their own sleeping habits, and bear in mind the need to keep babies away from potential hazards in the bed environment.20
This characteristic bed-sharing behaviour was first studied in parents’ homes and in the sleep laboratory — and has since been observed in many studies in the UK, the US and New Zealand, in homes, labs, and on postnatal wards. First-time mothers sleep like this on their first night after birth, without any instruction, and this, together with its prevalence, suggests that it is an instinctive behaviour for mothers and babies.
For much of the past 30 years, however, official advice surrounding infant care has strongly discouraged bed-sharing on safety grounds, with parents instead being told to sleep babies in a cot.
So let’s look a bit more closely at why this is.
I have already outlined the epidemiological evidence relating to what we know now about SIDS and co-sleeping. This part of the story has a bit more to it, however, which we pick up in 1992 in New Zealand, with a study that showed babies who bed-shared were at increased risk of SIDS. Following on from the success of the ‘Back to Sleep’ campaign, public health organizations and charities in NZ started advising against bed-sharing on safety grounds.21 Public health advice in the US, UK, and Australia soon followed. Despite evidence emerging just a couple of years later that smoking and alcohol/drug use combined with bed-sharing to produce increased risk, it took many years of work, and tireless, diplomatic dedication, particularly by a few key players within the epidemiological, academic, charitable and public health communities, before this more nuanced understanding of risk was accepted, and longer still before that nuance started to feed into the information parents received.
During this journey, however, the demonization of bed-sharing itself on safety grounds was well and truly established. In part this was because the apparent danger emerged in the context of a culture that already promoted mother-infant separation and emphasized infant independence from an early age.22 In part it reflected researchers’ ingrained distrust of women and the validity and value of their embodied expertise.
In terms of sleep safety, a crucial factor was the limited view epidemiologists took of the real world of parenting and nighttime care. Early research failed to ask questions about details such as how babies were being fed, whether bed-sharing was an occasional or routine behaviour, or whether it was planned or accidental. Several research studies statistically combined babies who had died in an adult bed and those who had died elsewhere (on a sofa, or even in a cot having bed-shared earlier in the night) into one ‘bed-sharing’ or ‘co-sleeping’ group, skewing the impression of risk dramatically. To exemplify the attitude held by (some) researchers toward women, I offer you the following analogy, from the paper I cited earlier, relating to the risk of SIDS for bed-sharers: “Overlying is a serious cause of mortality in piglets. Sows are normally separated by a bar from piglets to prevent them being crushed when she turns over, but allowing her piglets to feed.”23
In a publication aimed at a radical feminist audience, I probably don’t need to say much more about the stupidity of this analogy. To suggest that breastfeeding women can be likened in any sense to factory-farmed pigs is, for a multitude of obvious reasons, utterly ridiculous and inappropriate, never mind appallingly offensive. But for many years, people for whom this resembles an acceptable attitude drove the research and public health agendas. Moreover it is clear that the impression of lactating women as subhuman and sexually aberrant has become entrenched in society at large, even as women are relentlessly told … ‘breast is best!’
I remember the shock and dismay I felt on first reading these words in 2013. Not long after, I gave a talk at a conference of breastfeeding supporters, midwives, and health visitors — almost all of them women — in which I discussed this publication (despite its many flaws it made a splash in the media, and also prompted a NICE review of the evidence relating to SIDS and co-sleeping).24 I remember stopping mid-flow, standing on stage in front of a hundred or more people, and saying something to the effect of, “I feel like this guy really doesn’t like women!” Cue much nodding and rueful “mmm hmm”-ing from the audience! Despite their agreement, I left the venue after my talk feeling horrendously guilty, as if I had levelled some kind of ad hominem attack at a fellow researcher. As the years have gone by this quote has remained in the forefront of my mind—yet it has taken until now for me to write about it publicly. I now see very clearly that my comment wasn’t an attack on the person at all; rather it reflected the misogyny represented by his choice of words, and the view he presented of women. My professional career has been conducted predominantly within a scientific paradigm that values engagement with empirical evidence above all else, and leaves little room for experiences that cannot be evidenced via facts and figures. And yet, in order to make sense of the attitude exemplified in the quote, and the impact of that attitude on ‘the science,’ we need to be able to address it for what it is, outside of the context of the research itself.
- More difficult nighttime parenting. This burden is mostly borne by women. When breastfeeding and maternal sleep contact is rendered not just undervalued but a source of anxiety, fear and shame, fathers/partners may also be expected to take on a fair share of the additional feeding and settling work. This frequently becomes a source of resentment for exhausted co-parents.
- Judgement of bed-sharing women for ‘going against advice’ or ‘putting their baby in danger.’
- Increased cultural hostility towards bed-sharing and mother-baby contact.
- More difficulty with breastfeeding — something women are relentlessly implored to do … by all the same people telling them not to sleep with their babies!
- Increased separation between baby and caregiver, with potentially devastating consequences for emotional development and ability to form healthy social relationships.
- Increased anxiety for parents, particularly mothers.
- Anxiety for health-care professionals who want to support mothers but are afraid to talk about co-sleeping due to the toxic atmosphere. I have spoken off the record with many such professionals over the years, a majority of whom have slept with their own children, and some of whom have felt so afraid about tackling this topic, they avoid it altogether. This doesn’t just reflect a concern about tackling a contentious topic with complex evidence; in some cases they have said they are afraid of legal reprisals that might follow the death of a baby in a family with whom they have raised (not advocated for, just ‘raised’) the topic of bed-sharing.26
- Lack of information. Parents’ fear of judgement, added to the anxiety fomented in those charged with providing information to parents, results in a reluctance to talk about the issues. This means parents are denied the information we have about the benefits of bed-sharing, as well as factors that make it more hazardous, and how to make it safer. More-educated and wealthier parents fill this knowledge gap by seeking information for themselves, employing people to help them, or attending support groups. Less educated or wealthy parents find accessing such information much harder. Access to information and support becomes a class issue.
- More SIDS happening on sofas, due to parents trying to avoid sleeping with babies in bed—the sofa is the only sleep location where SIDS is actually on the rise.
Because many mothers wish to breastfeed — it being cheap, convenient once established, and beneficial in myriad ways to both mothers and babies — and in recognition of the difficulties involved in doing so, a variety of breastfeeding support communities and organizations, from the international to the local, in-person and virtual, have become well established in Western countries. There is much to be said about the positive role of these groups in supporting women, focusing on their embodied knowledge and experience, and empowering women in the absence of structural and cultural support. They also tend to be supportive of women who choose to bed-share. However, there is — unfortunately and, I think, inevitably — a flip side.
Many child-care practices have become associated with one of two approaches—one emphasizing responsiveness and baby-led parenting, and the other emphasizing the need to fit babies into a world made for adults and their needs. Mothers and their parenting practices become stereotyped, embedded in an atmosphere of tense conflict. Babies are judged as to whether they are ‘good babies’ — which basically means ‘quiet’ when adults think they should be.27 Women are judged on their performance as ‘good mothers,’ be that in producing an acquiescent infant that sleeps, eats and poops on cue, or in prioritizing baby’s needs above their own. Women can’t win—whatever they choose to do will be wrong in somebody’s eyes.
The upshot of this is that the demonization of bed-sharing, by researchers, the media and members of the public, has functioned in a similar way to the breast vs. formula debate in pushing women towards polarized positions. But the issue of bed-sharing is infused with an additional dose of urgency — we are not ‘just’ talking about whether breast or bottle is better, in questions of degrees; we are talking about something depicted as quite likely to be lethal. All or — very possibly — nothing. In this way, I believe that the way we (socially and culturally) approach the issue goes beyond judgemental. I believe it creates stigma—that women who choose to bed-share are deliberately stigmatized in society, and that this is both a consequence of, and perpetuating mechanism in, patriarchy.
Stigmatizing bed-sharing:
- Divides parents. Both within co-parenting units, and among families in communities.
- Isolates women. I have heard many accounts from women who will not tell their friends, relatives, or health professionals that they sleep with their baby. The social support available to women in the 21st century is already, frankly, minimal. Creating what amounts to a moral panic relating to one of the most fundamental ways of caring for babies weakens this support structure still further, and reduces the potential for honesty and openness between women, within family and friendship groups, and within the health-care system.
- Increases the sexual availability of women. If baby is not in the bed, male partners reclaim primary ‘rights of access.’ Obviously.
- Promotes the reproductive availability of women. Since breastfeeding delays the return of fertility after birth, reduced contact with baby has the opposite effect. Reduced breastfeeding → reduced inhibition of ovulation and menstruation → quicker return of fertility and ability to get pregnant again. Shorter inter-birth intervals benefit men more than women — in part because men cannot be certain of their paternity, either of existing or future children. (Conversely, longer inter-birth intervals may benefit fathers’ foetal genetics more than mothers’ genetics! If this is confusing, the distinction here is between the benefit to ‘men’ as in potential fathers, which influences social structures and gendered roles such as monogamy, marriage, sex/breastfeeding taboos, etc. vs. the benefit to genetic fathers, whose genes may have more influence on mothers’ and babies’ behaviour.)28
- Reflects and reinforces the idea that women cannot be trusted to make decisions based on, and relating to, their bodily experience. The idea that we cannot trust female bodies has become fundamental to the way we are viewed (and view ourselves), and represents a key aspect of patriarchy as it is experienced by women. It impacts us not only when things go ‘wrong’ with our bodies (in which scenario we all are often, regardless of sex, taught to mistrust our bodies), but also, crucially, during the most biologically normal periods of our life, from menarche through pregnancy, birth, child-rearing, and menopause. In some circumstances, trusting ourselves may be punishable in law. There have been cases in the US and UK in which women whose babies have died whilst co-sleeping have been criminally charged with neglect or manslaughter. In most cases these have involved bed-sharing combined with consumption of alcohol or illegal drugs. Some thoughts: should parents who smoke be prosecuted for negligence if their babies die of SIDS (smoking increases SIDS risk regardless of where the baby sleeps)? If not, why not? What about parents who feed formula (babies fed formula are at increased SIDS risk regardless of where they sleep)? What about parents who don’t use a dummy for their child (some research suggests dummy use can reduce SIDS)? There may be some logic in charging parents with negligence who have co-slept after alcohol or drug use, but where do we draw the line? Why do we hold parents responsible when co-sleeping is the factor involved, but not another of the multitude of factors thought to be associated with increased risk of infant death?29 A problem with arguing bed-sharing is inherently dangerous is that it opens the door to charges of negligence simply for choosing to bed-share … and remember, sleep contact is a biological and behavioural norm for humans.
- Impacts our children, who are raised in a climate of secrecy, conflict, guilt, and shame, or who are deprived of the physical and emotional contact needed for normal, healthful emotional and social development. Reduced capacity for emotional attachment has obvious, and frankly scary, implications for the emotional health of society as a whole. What does it mean that we bring up our children at arm’s length? That we deny them the calming, reassuring regulation of another human presence? That we teach them that expressing their fears, getting close, or seeking physical comfort is wrong … so they learn not to ask?
Debates around parenting choices frequently make recourse to polarizing assertions—‘breast is best’ vs. ‘fed is best’ being one example. Reminiscent of the duality implicit in the way we talk about nature and culture, chaos and order, determinism and choice, these polarizations force us to entrench politically in defence of breast vs. bottle, woman vs. man, freedom vs. obligation. But this is unhelpful and misleading, and diverts us from the underlying issues. ‘Breast is best’ represents an effort to correct a hundred years or more of a deep cultural preference for promoting the early physical and emotional independence of children in society. The medicalization of childbirth and rise of ‘scientific parenting,’ through which knowledge, power and authority was removed from women (mothers, midwives, etc.) and allocated to men (scientists, doctors, formula manufacturers) has resulted in a century or more of parenting and social practices which separate children from their caregivers at every opportunity, including via the undermining of breastfeeding and bed-sharing. The ‘fed is best’ response represents a movement that spies an opportunity and nurtures polarization of women. This happens via a reaction to breast vs. formula debates, and attachment vs. happy-mummy/happy-baby parenting approaches. I don’t mean to suggest that this polarization occurs as an explicitly intended consequence of ‘breast is best’ messaging, but rather that for those of us that could not, or chose not to, breastfeed our babies, it is in some ways similar to the reaction we have to a pain stimulus—there is a sharp ‘pulling away’ from the perceived source of hurt — in this case, the pain of feeling judged, or of having not done the very best for our child. This exists within an overarching context in which no woman can be a good enough mother, in the eyes of a patriarchal society, and in which mothers are always the ones to blame.
What I don’t understand is where women suddenly get power. Because they do. The kids, who almost always turn out to be a pile of shit, are, we all know, Mommy’s fault. Well, how did she manage that, this powerless creature? Where was all her power during the years she was doing five loads of laundry a week and worrying about mixing the whites with the colors? How was she able to offset Daddy’s positive influence? How come she never knows she has this power until afterward, when it gets called responsibility?30
Bed-sharing is a practice likewise caught in the middle. Intimately linked to the heavily promoted practice of breastfeeding, it is at the same time the subject of institutional and social censure, of which women are the target. The need for close contact is deeply ingrained in human mothers and babies, many of whom find themselves bed-sharing anyway, regardless of intent or the level of social opprobrium.
In writing this article, I am most struck by the recurring theme of ‘divisiveness,’ or separation: mothers physically and emotionally separated from their children; division sown between mothers and co-parents; wedges driven between women intergenerationally and across peer groups; division among health-care professionals, struggling to support women in the face of the complex evidence base and competing ethical demands; women denied the value of their own embodied experience and knowledge — mothers with babes in arms, older and more experienced women, midwives and health visitors whose professional and personal experience is itself compartmentalized. I argue that this represents the systematic alienation of women, which crucially, amongst other things, functions to undermine potential forms of resistance to the patriarchal status quo. Successful attempts to centre women’s needs, that manifest in the creation of support groups or movements, for example, are vulnerable to corruption via the carefully cultivated atmosphere of competitive mothering, judgement, and the bitter vitriol of mother blame. And when we feel judged, of course we seek sanctuary in creating narratives that place reassuring veneers of ‘rightness’ or certainty over our life choices — which validate and justify our actions.
The way we care for our babies at night deeply impacts the physical and emotional wellbeing of babies, parents, and families, which has profound consequences for society at large. We absolutely should get angry about the way bed-sharing — a simple and effective infant-care practice — was discounted, devalued and rejected as a legitimate choice, with complete disregard for the physical and emotional needs and experience of women. It occurs to me, too, that this terminology itself — ‘infant-care practice’ — applied to mother-baby contact is alienating. Perhaps this illuminates one of the central problems with which 21st-century feminists may grapple: how do we think about aspects of human social existence in terms of relationships, when the liberal language of ‘choice’ (which is also the language of 20th- and 21st-century capitalism, democracy, and patriarchy) concerns itself primarily with the individual—in which it is hard to think outside of ‘baby first’ or ‘woman first’? The relationship between mother and baby is not reducible to a kind of smorgasbord of components (suggested by the term ‘infant-care practices’) that can be thought of as discrete ‘options,’ the choosing or rejecting of which represent an expression of our individual agency. For mothers and babies these are not only matters of individual choice, expression and bodily sovereignty … they are also matters of structural influence, the meaning of choice or agency in the context of patriarchy, the existence and meaning of relationships, and of community. Perhaps instead of thinking of bed-sharing, co-sleeping or mother-baby contact as ‘infant-care practices’ we might more usefully think in terms of ‘integral aspects of the mother-infant relationship.’
In becoming a mother, a woman is, by definition, the original source, and resource, supporting her child’s existence. To a greater or lesser degree this is also true postnatally, especially if we choose to breastfeed and sleep with our babies. However, our socially and culturally constructed ideas about how babies ‘should’ behave, and how we (predominantly women) ‘should’ care for them shape elements of our lives way beyond evolved need-and-response. Mothers are positioned not only as a primary source of child-care, but, crucially and simultaneously, as a procreative and sexual resource for men. Further, these constructions effectively ensure that every child is born into a milieu that emphasizes disruption of the physiological and emotional bond between mother and baby and, ultimately, with other members of our species. In this way, denigration of the female and the feminine is perpetuated, replaced with masculinization, individualism, medicalization, and mechanization.
Some have suggested that this disruption may be adaptive (e.g. Odent) — in some sense preparing our children for existence in a patriarchal society.31 Others have suggested that in order to transcend women’s subjugation on the basis of their sex, we must transcend their reproductive role in nature (e.g. Firestone).32 These perspectives certainly lend us tools to think about our situation, but from a position of being women-in-patriarchy, and in the acute awareness of the likely-inevitable co-option of any and all technology in favour of the status quo, in my view they are not exactly aspirational. As feminists we are frequently concerned with the way we raise our girls, and with issues relating to sex, gender, and the stereotyping we deal with ourselves every day. However, I think this investigation suggests there is room, as mothers, to ask some specific questions about how seemingly ‘gender-neutral’ aspects of our parenting (such as mother-baby separation) affect boys — those destined to occupy the other half of the power hierarchy. How can we expect a boy raised in such a milieu to relate to other members of his species? How does it affect his sense of self as a male, within patriarchy?
We raise our children in a socio-cultural environment that is awash with ‘biophobia’ — against our human tendency for ‘biophilia’ — the love of, or affinity for, life. No wonder we have created a culture that proves so willing to destroy the life around us. My feeling is that, far from being adaptive, the systematic disruption of our children’s emotional and physical relationships with other humans, and the rest of nature, is profoundly maladaptive. Evidence of this ecological maladaptation mounts daily — our experience of COVID-19 being just one recent manifestation.
Alienated from healthful relationships with adults, our children become both pawns and players in this damaging reality. Alienated from each other, women — mothers, daughters, sisters, grandmothers, and friends — are rendered ignorant, disorganized, and unsupported. As women, as mothers, we do have the ability to change the game. But first, we must understand that we are being played …
Charlotte Russell is a perpetual student and recovering academic. Since jumping the higher education career ship in 2020, she continues to be fascinated by anthropological perspectives on life, especially where the evolutionary, cultural, political, and philosophical meet. Following treatment for breast cancer in 2018, Charlotte has been engaged in a long and sometimes painful reflection on what it means personally to live well, and authentically. She is currently indulging a long-standing passion for herbal medicine, while also working on channelling half a career’s worth of work out of her head and onto the pages of her book-in-progress, Birthing Misogyny.
1 ‘Western’ is used here as shorthand for ‘WEIRD,’ or ‘Western, Educated, Industrialized, Rich, Democratic’—“a particularly thin, and rather unusual, slice of humanity”—outliers on an array of human psychological and behavioural traits. Joseph Henrich, Steven J. Heine and Ara Norenzayan, ‘The Weirdest People in the World?’ Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 33.2-3 (2010), 61-83 (p. 2).
2 See Durham University’s Infancy and Sleep Centre, previously known as the Parent-Infant Sleep Lab.
3 Baby Sleep Info Source (Basis),Queen’s Anniversary Prizes, ‘Durham University: Influential research on parent/infant sleep,’.
4 In the UK, adult beds have also been depicted as deadly spaces, with radio adverts utilizing scary music, adaptations of fairy tales, shocking imagery, and media headlines all conveying to women that the very nearness of their bodies endangers their child.
5 The term ‘co-sleeping’ in epidemiology refers to sleeping with baby in a bed or on another surface such as a sofa or chair. ‘Bed-sharing’ refers to baby and adult sleeping together in an adult bed only. I use the two terms accordingly in this paper.
6 It’s important to note the distinction between ‘SIDS’ and ‘accidental Sudden Unexpected Infant Death’ (SUID). SIDS refers to an unexplained death, and accidental SUID to an explainable albeit unexpected accidental death. With relation to the present issue of bed-sharing/co-sleeping, it’s important to recognize that accidental death by ‘soft suffocation’ and SIDS are often indistinguishable post-mortem. The same risk factors are implicated in both, and both are most common in populations experiencing systemic disadvantage or discrimination. See Melissa Bartick and Cecília Tomori, ‘Sudden Infant Death and Social Justice: A Syndemics Approach,’ Maternal & Child Nutrition, 15.1 (2019), e12652, . A baby that is overlain and suffers SIDS was not necessarily suffocated; the overlaying could ‘just’ be (one) factor that leads to SIDS occurring. In other cases babies are clearly smothered or suffocated. (A detailed exposition of the potential mechanism of SIDS is beyond this article, but see ‘The triple risk model,’ Basis, www.basisonline.org.uk/hcp-the-triple-risk model/ for an outline.) Part of what we must be alert to is the designation of ‘accidental death’ based on the circumstances of death alone. For example, coroners sometimes see a baby that died in an adult bed and conclude the cause must be suffocation, absent any physiological or other evidence to support that conclusion. This has obvious consequences for the parents’ interpretation of events, including feelings of blame. Because of the crossover in presentation, aetiology, and risk factors, and the likely presence of accidental SUID babies in SIDS case cohorts, addressing the same factors of alcohol, smoking, drugs and sofa-sharing is appropriate for both phenomena.
7 ‘Co-Sleeping and SIDS: A Guide for Health Professionals,’ Unicef UK, 2016.
8 Robert Carpenter and others, ‘Bed Sharing When Parents Do Not Smoke: Is There a Risk of SIDS? An Individual Level Analysis of Five Major Case-Control Studies,’ BMJ Open, 3.5 (2013), 1-11,.
9 Charlotte K. Russell and Helen L. Ball, ‘Re: Bed Sharing,’ 23 May 2013,.
10 The word ‘altricial,’ used to mean, effectively, underdeveloped, vulnerable and helpless, derives from the feminine of the Latin altor, meaning ‘nourisher.’
11 For a fully referenced overview, see, for example, Helen L. Ball and Charlotte K. Russell, ‘Night-Time Nurturing: An Evolutionary Perspective on Breastfeeding and Sleep’ in Evolution, Early Experience and Human Development: From Research to Practice and Policy, ed. by Darcia Narvaez, Jaak Panksepp, Allan N. Schore, and Tracy R. Gleason (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2012), pp. 241-61,
12 The sleep disruption of babyhood happens in a context in which our WEIRD sleep patterns and environment are already dramatically altered from evolved patterns. This reflects industrialization, shifts to a 9-to-5 working pattern, availability of artificial light plus unrestricted potential for communication and entertainment. There seems to have been a tendency toward less sleep throughout much of human history, so experiencing less sleep than we need might not be solely a modern or WEIRD trait. What is unusual, however, is aiming to take all our sleep in a single session during the night, as opposed to in two or more segments, with periods of activity in between. For a good overview, see Charles L. Nunn, David R. Samson, and Andrew D. Krystal, ‘Shining Evolutionary Light on Human Sleep and Sleep Disorders,’ Evolution, Medicine, and Public Health, 1 (2016), 227-43, https://doi.org/10.1093/emph/eow018. Babies are unable to ‘force’ themselves to sleep on demand, and so results a mismatch between expectations (which are primarily cultural) and reality (reflecting evolved biology). Sleep conflict results between baby and parents, that becomes framed as baby’s ‘sleep problem.’ Parental expectations and resilience seem to be crucial in coping with the sleep disturbance of early parenthood. Research is currently underway to explore the factors that influence coping strategies, as well as interventions that might help, e.g. Helen L. Ball, Catherine E. Taylor, Victoria Thomas, Pamela S. Douglas, and the SBY working group, ‘Development and Evaluation of “Sleep, Baby & You”—An Approach to Supporting Parental Well-Being and Responsive Infant Caregiving,’ PLoS ONE, 15.8 (2020), e0237240,.
13 Helen L. Ball, ‘Breastfeeding, Bed-Sharing and Infant Sleep,’ Birth, 30.3 (2003), 181-88. It is almost impossible, from an anthropological point of view, to separate the topics of infant sleep and infant feeding. In this article, my aim is to specifically focus on mother-baby sleep contact as a parenting strategy, leaving the thorny and complex issue of infant feeding somewhat alone. However, I necessarily refer to infant feeding, in so far as it is inextricably woven into how, where and when babies sleep, and mothers’ experiences of that sleep. The topic of how babies are fed—whether by breast or formula—is characterized by adversarialism, judgement and high emotion. There is no doubt that, as a rule, the best food a baby can eat is breastmilk, for a multitude of reasons that I will resist the temptation to get into here. Breastfeeding also has benefits for women’s health, and babies’ development, that go far beyond simply providing a source of food. However, it is also true that women, in this as in every area of life, hold an irrefutable right of bodily sovereignty. If, for whatever reason, a woman chooses not to breastfeed, that is her right. Additionally, for a small number of women and babies, breastfeeding is not possible. That this is true should not dissuade us from maintaining that breastfeeding—a systematically undermined aspect of mothering and the female experience—is, in an evolutionary sense, behaviourally, physiologically and developmentally normal, and what babies ‘expect.’ Responsibility for its ‘failure,’ in most cases, lies squarely at the feet of patriarchal society, and the abject—and I argue deliberate—failure of contemporary Western social structures to support women.
14 For an up-to-date summary of the evidence, see The Lullaby Trust, ‘Evidence Base,’ March 201.
15 Objective’ as a result of using methods that record actual sleep data, e.g. via actigraphy (movement) or video monitoring, rather than ‘subjective,’ which relies on parents’ report via sleep diaries, interviews or questionnaires.
16 For more, see Alanna E. F. Rudzik, Lyn Robinson-Smith, and Helen L. Ball, ‘Discrepancies in Maternal Reports of Infant Sleep vs. Actigraphy by Mode of Feeding,’ Sleep Medicine, 49 (2018), 90-98, .
17 ‘Parental tiredness,’ Basis.
189 Helen L. Ball, ‘Reasons to Bed-Share: Why Parents Sleep With Their Infants,’ Journal of Reproductive and Infant Psychology, 20.4 (2002), 207-22.
19 Helen L. Ball, ‘Parent-Infant Bed-Sharing Behavior: Effects of Feeding Type, and Presence of Father,’ Human Nature: An Interdisciplinary Biosocial Perspective, 17.3 (2006), 301-318,.
20 For more examples of what bed-sharing looks like, visit the Basis image archive
21 The ‘Back to Sleep’ campaign had a huge impact in reducing SIDS rates. This owed to the fact that although the risk of SIDS ‘only’ roughly doubled when babies were put to sleep on their front, the vast majority of babies at the time were being put to sleep this way, so the impact of changing that behaviour en masse was huge. Deaths in cots reduced dramatically thanks to this campaign; however, bed-sharing deaths were virtually unaffected, because bed-sharing babies tended not to be slept on their front in the first place. Cot deaths have now reduced to such a low level that the proportion of deaths happening in a cot vs. an adult bed is approximately equal.
22 The vast majority of cultures worldwide today engage in mother-baby sleep sharing, on beds or other similar sleep surfaces, as a matter of course. The same was true for Western cultures until the early 20th century. In the 1800s, even ‘medical men’ were still recommending bed-sharing as normal practice, e.g. “The bosom of the mother is the natural pillow of her offspring.” John Conquest, Letters to a Mother on the Management of Herself and Her Children in Health and Disease (London: 1848), . Industrialization and the relentless medicalization of childbirth later combined with Victorian ideas about hygiene, avoiding overlaying and promoting early child independence. These factors, together with reductions in family and household size, and the development of housing that provides more room for sleeping areas, resulted in a preference for separate sleep, and the sanctity of the ‘marital bed.’ By the 1920s, child-care ‘gurus’ such as John B. Watson and Frederick Truby King were advising that no baby could have too little affection, and that ‘good babies’ preferred solitary confinement to human interaction. James J. McKenna, Helen L. Ball and Lee T. Gettler, ‘Mother-Infant Cosleeping, Breastfeeding and Sudden Infant Death Syndrome: What Biological Anthropology Has Discovered About Normal Infant Sleep and Pediatric Sleep Medicine,’ Am J Phys Anthropol, 50 (2007), 133-61, . Late 20th-century concerns about SIDS found fertile ground in this earlier preference for sleeping babies in cots.
23 Carpenter and others, p. 9.
24 NICE is the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence, who, amongst other things, produce evidence-based guidelines in consultation with experts and stakeholders. In this case, although the publication of Carpenter and others’ paper prompted a review of the evidence, it resulted in the recommendations relating to bed-sharing becoming less prohibitive rather than more. I wonder if he felt his efforts had backfired …
25 E. A. Mitchell and R. Scragg, ‘Are Infants Sharing a Bed With Another Person at Increased Risk of Sudden Infant Death Syndrome?’ Sleep, 16.4 (1993), 387-89 (p. 389), .
26 It strikes me that this case illustrates the need for a radical feminist research methodology. The health-care practitioners I spoke to would never have put their names to these concerns publicly, for fear of repercussions, nor should they have to. The upshot of this, however, is that any examination of the real state of play within the community of health-care practitioners appears skewed. Concerns are diluted, and a ‘chilling’ effect occurs, which in itself harms families. There is a need to approach topics that impact women in a way that sits outside of the standard paradigms of patriarchal society, with its emphasis on the scientific, biomedical, and technocratic. Considerable useful work exists, for example, on the subject of authoritative vs. embodied knowledge in the reproductive sphere (discussion of which is unfortunately beyond the scope of this article, but for a starting point, see Brigitte Jordan, Birth in Four Cultures: A Crosscultural Investigation of Childbirth in Yucatan, Holland, Sweden, and the United States (Long Grove, IL: Waveland Press, 1992, first published 1978). However, these lack situation within a radical feminist understanding of power. My aim in Birthing Misogyny is to employ a radical feminist perspective in the evaluation of contemporary Western child-rearing practices, and the research that informs them, which we women can use to frame the knowledge thus produced through patriarchal institutions.
27 See, for example, Helen L. Ball, ‘The Infant Sleep Myth,’ Society Now, 30 (2018), 18-19, .
28 For more on this fascinating area of research see, for example, David Haig, ‘Interbirth Intervals: Intrafamilial, Intragenomic and Intrasomatic Conflict,’ Evolution, Medicine, and Public Health, 1 (2014), 12-17, ; Cristina Moya, Kristin Snopkowski, and Rebecca Sear, ‘What Do Men Want? Re-Examining Whether Men Benefit From Higher Fertility Than Is Optimal for Women,’ Phil. Trans. R. Soc. B, 371 (2016), 20150149, .
29 Overwhelmingly mothers are held responsible for bed-sharing deaths, even when there is evidence, for example, that another adult rolled on the baby, was drunk or on drugs, or brought baby into bed without the mother’s knowledge. An anecdote on responsibility: when I was a relatively young, early-career researcher I was presenting a piece of research (evidencing the harms of a simple ‘don’t bed-share’ message) to an audience of some of the most eminent SIDS researchers from around the world. When I finished, one of them—an older man—asked me: if my findings, having been presented more widely, resulted (I never found out how we would know) in a baby dying while bed-sharing in a narrow hospital bed, would I take personal responsibility for that death? Needless to say, my response then had more to do with the inadequacy of hospital beds than my potential personal culpability, but I note that I never heard similar allegations of responsibility levied at male, or more senior female, colleagues presenting similar critiques …
30 Marilyn French, The Women’s Room (New York, NY: Summit Books, 1977), p. 215.
31 Michel Odent, ‘The First Hour Following Birth: Don’t Wake the Mother!’ Midwifery Today, 61 (2002), .
32 Shulamith Firestone, The Dialectic of Sex: The Case for Feminist Revolution (New York, NY: Morrow, 1970).
