Issue Three

Feminism and the ‘Two Cultures’: A Conversation With Emma Hilton

by Susanna Rustin

Biologist Emma Hilton, aka @FondOfBeetles, is a leading British campaigner for the retention of female sports categories and helped write a bill with this aim in South Dakota. Does the movement for sex-based rights need more scientists like her?1

Susanna Rustin: What is a developmental biologist and what made you start writing papers about sex differences in sport?

Emma Hilton: A developmental biologist is someone who studies how organisms grow from conception to death. My current academic work includes looking at how nerves grow from the spinal cord. Initially I thought sex segregation couldn’t possibly be an issue in sport because the physical differences between males and females are so obvious. So the realization that the last few years of fighting weren’t just about bathrooms and those kinds of things was very stark. I’m quite sporty, I lift weights and play netball in both single-sex and mixed-sex leagues — so I had my eye out.

Susanna: How did your involvement start?

Emma: It was very easy: I know that males are stronger, bigger, taller and have longer arms. I think everyone knows this. So I started to look at the gaps in terms of peak performance, for example what men being taller means in terms of how high they can clear a bar. It quickly became clear that the gaps are massive, much bigger than I thought.

Susanna: How do you think the campaign is going?

Emma: I think the situations in the US and UK are different. In the US, following Biden’s executive order (on combatting discrimination on the basis of gender identity or sexual orientation), you’ve got all these states rushing to make laws about whether the order should apply to sports — which would essentially mean mixed-sex sports in the female category. There’s this really manic feeling: we’re hearing that trans people are being ‘banned,’ when this is not what is happening. I wrote one of the bills [for South Dakota] and it’s interesting to see a document that you’ve drawn up cautiously and carefully being described as a mass attack on trans rights.

Susanna: But you said you think the position in the UK is different?

Emma: Yes, in our Equality Act we have a very clear exemption for sports [so males can legally be excluded from girls’ and women’s activities and competitions]. Having said that, World Rugby’s decision about the need for a female-only category has been rejected by the big ten national rugby federations, but I didn’t think things were going to change in women’s favour overnight. Since I’ve always been left-wing, I find it really annoying that it’s a Conservative government that seems as though it might be willing to make exceptions for females when it matters.

Susanna: I encountered lots of feminist ideas when I studied English and history at university. When did you become a feminist scientist?

Emma: I’ve been a feminist longer than I’ve been a scientist, I just wasn’t very politically active. It was always quite a body-centred feminism, which is where I think it’s at: reproductive rights and thinking about how our bodies affect our paths through life. I had the usual socialization as a girl, where you’re treated differently: boys ping your bra strap in the playground and you understand that they are empowered to do that and that you are disempowered from making a fuss. I think those kinds of things make feminists of an awful lot of us. So I wouldn’t say I’m a feminist scientist: it’s more like a Venn diagram.

Susanna: I’ve been thinking a lot about the role of humanities academics in setting the scene for the downplaying and denial of sex differences that are so prominent now. I’m interested in how, as a scientist, your understanding of the political importance of sex differences took shape?

Emma: I was really naïve about how this whole thing was shaping up. I’ve been buried in science for 20 years. Generally people like the idea of being inclusive and tend to revolt against boundaries, and this movement seems to me to fulfil that need without paying attention to where categories are real and then, as a subset of that, when they are relevant. From a scientific point of view, the male/female boundary is most obviously relevant when it comes to having a baby. I worked for a long time on a genetic disorder that was lethal for male babies. No matter how much you don’t like the fact that that male/female boundary is there, it is there: we know that more men are suffering with acute COVID-19 symptoms; we know that the disease burden for cystic fibrosis is very different for males and females. These are not social constructs: these are real things that affect people’s lives. So you’ve got that end of things, where being male or female might be the thing that means you live or die, and at the other end discussions about single-sex spaces and inclusion in various contexts, where people might disagree about how important sex is. But at the moment it feels as though the push is all one way, up to the point where, even in medicine, people are saying sex doesn’t matter. And I’m thinking, are you insane?

Susanna: I’m only now starting to read the work of feminist biologists and anthropologists and it seems to me that feminism has a bad case of what C. P. Snow famously called “the two cultures” — meaning the division between science and the humanities. Do you agree with that?

Emma: I absolutely do. It’s something that seems very stark to me when I speak to a philosopher and they talk about how they view biology and it doesn’t gel with anything that I see happening in the field. Even if you look at scientists who write blogs about sex as a spectrum and so on, when you look at their academic work they aren’t writing about spectrums: they’re looking at how female flies develop or how a mouse testicle works. I find that quite an interesting disconnect. To some extent I can understand the intent: you don’t have to take things that are biologically true and use them to determine how society should work. I would make a parallel with religion: I always find it quite odd to find scientists who are very religious. Undeniably, there are lots, but I find it strange that people can create this boundary between their academic knowledge and their social beliefs or desires.

Susanna: Sarah Blaffer Hrdy, the American anthropologist, was writing 20 years ago about the roots of feminist hostility to evolutionary science. But despite her efforts, and those of others, to show that the problems of male bias in biology can be corrected (just as in other disciplines), there is still huge suspicion about any discussion of the evolution of sex differences. What do you think about this?

Emma: I often come across this: when you say men are stronger than women this is somehow viewed as anti-feminist. But in terms of their muscle mass and ability to lift weight women aren’t, on average, as strong as men. The point is that this doesn’t mean that men’s social value is greater. To me, it’s a misunderstanding of feminism to write off evolutionary facts as sexist. Most science has been conducted by males so sexist ideas are there, but you can get rid of that lens and hold on to the bare bones: quite literally, in the case of anthropology! There’s nothing sexist about saying that men have wider shoulders and women have wider hips. Males develop differently and you can map that on to evolutionary benefits: fighting, hunting and so on. Women are built for childbirth, that’s a fact: it doesn’t mean all women should have children or that you should remove choice, but our bodies are set up for a different purpose and that’s how our species works.

Susanna: Do you have any thoughts about how this gap might be bridged, or attitudes changed?

Emma: There are two different spheres — the physical and social — that are being smashed together. Some people want to believe that women are as strong as men. That’s great if it helps get women into sport, but the culture then becomes: anything a man can do, I can do. I think a social message is being used to blur material reality.

Susanna: Is it wiser, do you think, to stick to the basics of body size, strength, and reproductive roles in pushing back against the idea that sex differences themselves are sexist? Or do we need to talk about brains and behaviours too?

Emma: I think of sex differences as a hierarchy of orders. If you think about bodies, there are different medical outcomes and services that men and women need access to. And then there are things that directly stem from those bodies, such as separate sports. Then there are second-order-type effects. For example, male violence is facilitated by the fact that men are bigger and stronger, but it’s not necessary for males to be violent in most situations. As feminists we are generally averse to the idea of pink and blue brains, and from what I understand there are probably some tiny differences but nothing significant in terms of total functional output. But that’s a bit different from behavioural traits which are driven by the brain. For example, testosterone makes male bodies different but also feeds into behaviour, and I think those hormonal inputs are often overlooked.

Susanna: Many feminists object strongly to the idea that biology has anything to do with behaviour. Are you saying they are wrong?

Emma: Certainly, some feminists think male violence is entirely socialized where I would say that males have a predisposition. It is perfectly possible to hypothesize a society in which men just go and run off their aggression and are non-violent, so I’m not making an excuse for male violence. I’m saying that testosterone creates a space for certain behaviours and we can understand that in an evolutionary sense, just as we can see that it is advantageous, from an evolutionary standpoint, for women to be more caring. The problem is trying to understand how much these differences are innate and how much they are social: it’s very difficult. It doesn’t mean that men aren’t caring or women can’t be aggressive. But I think we’ve been quite slow in the UK, as feminists, to say that there are behavioural differences between males and females — that it’s okay to see that. Many people tend to hear this as essentialism, which they assume is anti-women. The Canadian science writer Debra Soh writes about hormonally driven behaviours as ‘gender,’ and they may indeed be the basis of what we understand as gender roles — although I would rather call them sex behaviours.  

Susanna: One of the reasons why many progressives reject ideas about humans derived from evolution is that they are seen as right-wing and even dangerous — tainted by social Darwinism, eugenics and racism. I wonder if one of the reasons why gender critical feminism is so much stronger in the UK than in the US, and elsewhere, is that we have maintained a connection with the more progressive aspects of Darwin’s legacy: secularism, enthusiasm for natural history and so on?

Emma: We are much more secular and evolution is taught at quite a young age here. In the US they are still fighting over whether it gets taught at all. I met a student from a Southern state a few years ago and she hadn’t heard of evolution until she went to college. I also think we’re less scared than Americans of analysing power structures and how they affect different groups of people. You can see that with the pushback against critical race theory, which I would see as quite similar to radical feminism. I don’t think Americans, broadly speaking, like the idea that males are a class of oppressors any more than they like the idea that white people are.

Susanna: Women all over the world, but particularly in the US and Canada, are confronted with a dreadful choice. Sexist conservatives often want to limit women’s reproductive and other choices. But the sex denial now promoted by progressives seems to me just as bad, since it leads to women and girls losing things like their own sports and private spaces. Do you think scientists could do more to push back, particularly against the idea that sex is a social construction or a spectrum while gender identity is innate?

Emma: I think scientists have a role to play. We’re starting to see calls for very clear definitions of sex and gender as two separate things in science reporting, for example from the European Commission. When we apply for funding we now have to write a statement on how we’re going to record sex. But it’s women on the streets who will make the biggest difference. There’s nothing more powerful than hearing women who don’t have educational or class privilege talking about how the situation in refuges or prisons is affecting them. I view myself as a resource maker, so I can make letter templates but it’s the thousands of women who write to their MPs, maybe using those templates, who will make the difference. That’s where I feel I’ve had the most impact: not publishing reviews about sports in academic journals but handing out leaflets on the street in Manchester, asking women if they understand what’s going on.

Susanna: Sex denial and the idea that gender is solely determined by the individual is associated with the political left, while climate change denial is mainly seen on the right. But I think the two are linked (it’s notable, I think, that the US and Canada both have very high levels of carbon emissions and powerful gender activist movements). I see both sets of ideas as connected to human beings’ desire to transcend or deny the limits of nature. What do you think about that?

Emma: I think it’s a good observation that the disconnect of Homo sapiens from the environment is a factor in the gender-identity movement. That doesn’t mean that we shouldn’t respect trans people or that they shouldn’t have rights — of course they should. But the idea that as humans we’re special and somehow not part of the ecosystem, that we are somehow different from chimpanzees — when we’re not that different from chimpanzees — either through our own perseverance or because a god endowed us: I think that type of narcissism, on a species level, empowers people to do a lot of things. In terms of sex denial, it means you can deny your roots and decide that those boring biological relationships can’t possibly apply to you; it also entitles you to exploit other animals and other natural resources. Capitalism is a manifestation of that. It’s moving away from being part of a global ecology to a system that is economic. I don’t know how we pull back from that.

Susanna: Do you feel hopeful or hopeless?

Emma: I view the idea that gender identity trumps sex as a trend and I think it will end. It’s a cycle of politically motivated misinformation. Maybe it will be scientists who push back, but the problem is that scientists don’t think enough about social stuff. But also, these ideas don’t have much traction on the street. I live in a tiny market town and people there are not going to accept this. The understanding that females have certain requirements is not limited to 21st-century feminists.

Dr Emma N. Hilton is a researcher at the University of Manchester and one of the founders of the new campaigning organization Sex Matters.

Susanna Rustin writes editorials for the Guardian, mostly on social affairs.

1 This interview is an edited transcript of a conversation that took place on a video call in March 2021