by Jayne Egerton
Antonia Burrows first visited Hungary in the 70s and has lived in Budapest, with a 15-year break, since 1988. She has long been involved in feminist organizing there and now runs a feminist and general community library, Közkincs Könyvtár (kozkincskonyvtar.com). She talked to Jayne Egerton about life for women under the right-wing government of Viktor Orbán.
Jayne: How would you describe the government’s attitude to women’s rights right now in Hungary?
Antonia: Extremely hostile, as it is all over Eastern Europe really. The women’s movement has got enough widespread support and impetus behind it to start demanding change in the national and international arena. The government are against feminism on the one hand because it challenges traditional gender roles, the bedrock of their social and political persona. Domestic violence is a ‘traditional’ part of Hungarian culture, and often without consequence. There was a member of the government a few years ago who, having shattered several bones in his wife’s face, explained it away in parliament by saying, “Oh, we’ve got a blind dog, she tripped over him.” Judges are often unsympathetic to battered women and award custody of children to perpetrators.
Another issue is that Hungary has a long psycho-history of paranoia about the Hungarian nation ‘dying out.’ Because Hungary, as a linguistic group, is isolated in Eastern Europe and has historically been subject to many conquests, losses, and occupations in its history—the Turks, the Austrians, the Soviet Union, plus the loss of Transylvania in 1919—they tend to see themselves as surrounded by hostile peoples (notwithstanding the fact that they merrily took part in the Soviet invasion of Czechoslovakia in 1968). This existential threat serves to justify very explicit pro-natalist policies and the restriction of women’s rights and legal equality, since all women should be doing is “staying home and giving us grandchildren.”1
I heard some Western male pundit saying recently, “Oh, you should see Hungary’s wonderful maternity benefits. This is real equality. You see how well they look after mothers; this is the way it should be done, we should adopt the same policies.” The problem is that only women can take parental leave and then there are huge tax benefits to be given with absolutely no backup support, so what the current policy is doing is basically imprisoning women in the home.
The third, and current, prong of the government attack on the feminist movement is that they are using Western transactivist policy demands as a kind of warning. They’re saying, “Feminism talks about gender, so the consequence of feminism is that they will start changing Hungarian boy babies into girls and girl babies into boys.” They use this sort of crude tabloid summary of transactivist demands as an argument against any kind of women’s equality, claiming the latter inevitably leads to the former. Again, it’s rhetoric about ‘our children are at risk,’ and protecting Hungarian children against all this ‘dangerous gender nonsense,’ which now handily includes every feminist endeavour from the last 50 years.
Jayne: So, the systematic attempts to remove the words ‘gender’ and ‘gender equality’ from, say, EU documents agreed by Member States — this isn’t because of a concern with the political erasure of sex that we’re concerned about, but an opposition to feminism, and to women’s equality? Orbán is at war, as you say, with ‘gender,’ or gender ideology, but he’s not using this term in a way that would be recognized by feminists who oppose the erasure of sex in law and public policy. Would you say that Hungarian feminists are grappling with this difference?
In the current political climate, we are miles from Western debates like self-ID even being on the table, since the government is busy rolling back not just trans rights but gay and lesbian rights as well as women’s rights. Of course, like in every other country, there is a division between gender-critical feminists and liberal feminists who are inclusive, and also have funding from abroad,Antonia: several popular websites, and masses of followers, especially among young people. Feminists doing key things like running the hotlines, giving legal advice to battered women, doing anti-prostitution work, are understandably choosing not to get involved in these debates, so that they can continue to do their work without attracting even more hostility than they already get from government.
Jayne: Right now, trans LGBT organizations are opposing what the Hungarian government is doing in relation to gender recognition. Hungary has now made it impossible for trans-identified people to change their names and their legal gender markers. And as I understand it, that has particular implications in a society where people do often have to show their ID.
Antonia: It does. Given the rigidity in beliefs in a very conservative society, especially among officialdom, who will all have been selected or trained for ideological bent, it can be no fun to look different from what your papers say. I can imagine that trans people are given an extremely hard time every time they have to produce ID, and you do have to produce it often. I am also divided over that, because the alternative seems to be self-ID, and we know what that means for women. On the other hand, LGBT organizations get funding largely for trans issues rather than anything else, so that seems to be their main topic on social media. The foremost lesbian organization is also inclusive, so they regularly include trans women in their campaigning and publications.
And the extreme right often turn up to LGBT meetings. I run a feminist library in Budapest which is also a community centre, and — when we were still having actual meetings — lots of NGOs, especially LGBT groups, used it for their meetings. There have been large guys in black who come to Pride workshops, for example, and sit there threateningly, and even disrupt meetings by shouting and drowning out the speakers. Their gist seems to be that sex ed that includes information about LGBT people corrupts children, and endangers the family and the nation. So, again, ‘the children’ have to be protected from knowledge about alternative sexualities — and this is not even necessarily about trans people. There is a great, hard-working LGBT educational organization that used to go to schools all over the country to talk to kids about being different, and they did really good training. They went only when they were invited by teachers or principals, so the government has now made it illegal in the sense that any school principal who allows such people into the school premises is committing an offence. That project has therefore been halted.
The far-right activism also affects anti-racism work. The library is an alternative, progressive place, a community centre where feminist and other groups meet, and last year we were preparing placards and signs for the BLM protests happening outside the American embassy soon after George Floyd was killed. We advertised this on our Facebook group for anybody who wanted to come along, and we had cardboard and felt pens and whatever other simple means of communication we have. Quite a few people turned up, a multiracial group, the usual gang of friends and suspects, and we were all happily making our beautiful, rather basic placards; and then these six guys turn up, all dressed in black, and masked, although none of us were wearing masks at the time, since it was before the lockdown was imposed. We welcomed them of course, and gave them materials, and they were writing names and phrases on the placards that we hadn’t heard of. We just went on being friendly to them.
I asked them where they were from. Were they a group? And first they said ‘no,’ and then they said, “Not Antifa, but something similar.” And meanwhile they were looking at their phones all the time before deciding what to write. It was very weird. Then they started wandering over to the bookshelves, and there’s a gender section: it’s all feminism and gender stuff, it’s got big signs up, like ‘feminist theory,’ and I’ve got two massive bookshelves of LGBT books and a whole wall full of feminist stuff. One of them wandered over there and then beckoned the others over. And they got out their phones and started filming the books — it was really weird. Then they went out to the hall where we’ve got a big wall calendar with all the group events on it, and started filming the calendar. (This could have been worrying, as all the dates of the LGBT meetings are on there, but by that time, luckily, because of COVID-19, people were no longer booking the space for meetings, and the only group that was still there was a gay men’s group; the lesbian group had stopped meeting.) After they left, we googled the names and phrases they’d written on their placards, which turned out to be slogans from white supremacist groups in the US. When they’d gone, we discovered that they had scrawled swastikas all over the bathroom walls and the toilet.
Jayne: You’re describing a very fractured society, which has a great deal of poverty, where there’s a far-right government waging war against women and LGBT people as well as transgender people. What are the priorities for feminists?
Antonia: Concrete priorities are the same as ever — domestic violence, women’s rights in general — but I think we should ask some Hungarian feminists, and I would be very happy to bring some in for you to talk to.
Jayne: I think that’s a good point. I mean, presumably there are a number of different organizations, both liberal and radical feminist, but what priorities are being identified, what are women organizing around?
Antonia: The hotline for domestic and sexual violence, NANE — I think it’s the most successful longstanding feminist organization in Hungary, which we started in 1993. It’s staffed by a lot of dynamic women, dedicated activists, who, since they get absolutely no funding from the government, have to raise funds from abroad. But they are incredibly successful and good at what they do. And they do a lot of campaigning as well. However, the main obstacle to their work is the Istanbul Convention …
Jayne: Yeah, the government’s refused to ratify the standard. [The Istanbul Convention is a human rights treaty of the Council of Europe against violence against women. In May 2020 the Hungarian parliament refused to ratify the treaty, claiming the measure promoted “destructive gender ideologies” and “illegal migration.”2]
Antonia: Right, although the Hungarian government signed on to it in 2014. Interestingly enough, the liberal feminists are also campaigning for ratification, and are also firmly opposed to the liberalization of sex work; what they’re mainly liberal about is the trans issue. There are some organizations which are pro sex work, and it is part of the local Amnesty’s agenda. But the feminist faction most active on social media is very firmly against prostitution, calls it that and recognizes it as harmful to women. In the end, there is very little influence that any group in civil society can have under the current government.
Jayne Egerton has been a socialist feminist since the early 80s. She is a radio producer for the BBC.
1 In 2019, the Hungarian government announced a series of pro-natalist measures which “included a lifetime income tax exemption for mothers of four children and free IVF treatment for married heterosexual couples. These policies aim to reverse demographic decline and curb immigration, at one and the same time. Orbán argues that ‘it’s a national interest to restore natural reproduction. Not one interest among others—but the only one. It’s a European interest too. It is the European interest.’” Jayne Egerton, ‘There’s more than one way to ‘erase’ women: Women’s rights under attack in Victor Orbán’s Hungary,’ Woman’s Place UK, 18 June 2020.
2 ‘Hungary’s parliament blocks domestic violence treaty,’ The Guardian, 5 May 2020.
