Issue Three

Towards a Glitter Gilead: A Review of Full Surrogacy Now

by Shambolic Neutral

Sophie Lewis, Full Surrogacy Now: Feminism Against Family (London: Verso, 2019), 224pp., £14.99.

Before I begin, let me just say that I have tried to be objective about this book, but oh my god. It is so chillingly confused and offended by the humanity of women, the mortality of humans, and basic science and nature itself that it’s really quite baffling as to who could ever think like this … until you read in Sophie Lewis’s author bio that she is “committed to cyborg ecology and queer communism.” Whatever the fuck they are.

If this review seems a little incoherent at times, it is because I can only do so much with a source material which is so wildly contradictory and inconsistent. Much of the book is a very workaday investigation and condemnation of surrogacy, using the example of a baby farm in India to demonstrate how the current model is exploitative and racist, offering little more than other work on the topic except an annoying and insulting refusal to admit that only women are vulnerable to this kind of exploitation. The introduction and conclusion focus on Lewis’s cyborg vision of a demedicalized yet hyper-technologized future, where the problems of surrogacy are transformed into a ‘work-free,’ queer communist utopia where ‘gestators’ only have babies to give up and share with others.

Lewis’s disturbing transhumanist hatred of biology is revealed from the off. The book starts with the sentence “it is a wonder we let fetuses inside us,” which neatly signals her horror towards female reproduction, the foetus posited as a rapist, an attacker, an unnatural parasite which invades anyone too stupid to prevent it. She talks about pregnancy throughout like it is forced upon us by the egomaniacal will of the foetus in order to strip a woman of her humanity and take it for itself. She calls pregnant women ‘gestators’ throughout, and likens pregnancy at various points to cancer and AIDS. Lewis says she “feels no call” to ever use the words ‘woman’ or ‘female,’ as they are apparently irrelevant when talking about reproduction, pregnancy, childbirth or parenting. In using gender to deny the reality of sex she comes out with hilarious nonsense like, “[t]o date, the gender of gestating has been ambiguous,” which she asserts on the absurd grounds that some women get hairier legs and deeper voices while pregnant. Any book about pregnancy which pretends that anyone other than women and girls can get pregnant is so deeply in denial of basic science and biology as to render it utterly pointless, and it’s so misogynist it is downright sinister. 

Lewis seems to have taken a single, true, feminist tenet—that patriarchy demands, extracts and exploits reproductive labour — and run with it. But her struggle to deny the sex-based reality of this oppression has taken her down some deeply sexist, racist, classist and, well, bonkers avenues. She accepts that patriarchy exists but refuses any material analysis of women as a sex class. Which is like training to be a nutritionist while denying the existence of food. Instead of wanting to actually tackle patriarchal exploitation or make things genuinely better for women, Lewis wants to transcend nature and the corporeal possibilities of our species, and get rid of every existing idea of pregnancy, labour, and motherhood, all because these don’t include everyone in nature. Comments such as “[m]any people excluded from the experience [of pregnancy] for whatever reason — be they cis, trans or non-binary — feel deeply bereft” pepper the text. For Lewis, it seems, it is not nature, or evolution, or mammalian dimorphism that stops some people from giving birth, but a deliberate, bigoted system designed purely to other and exclude — most of all transwomen — and upheld by women, who have made people foolishly believe that only female people can have babies. 

Lewis obviously believes that transhumanism should be dictating what life is and how making-life should be utilized to fulfil the needs and fetishistic motivations of adults. For her, surrogacy is like data-mining and file-sharing: it should be made free and open source. “Let’s bring about the possibility for open-source, fully collaborative gestation. Let’s prefigure a way of manufacturing one another non-competitively,” she writes. In her reproductive utopia, all pregnancy would be surrogacy, with ‘gestational workers’ supplying their ‘living products’ to be shared by the queer communist community. For Lewis, bearing children for one’s own family is a disruption of adulthood, of being able to participate in the vital grown-up business of transgressing and interrupting normative socio-cultural mores. It is incompatible with the humanity of female people, so we must sever any link between reproduction and women or their oppression. We must eschew anything to do with the female body, except as a series of objectified parts for transwomen to fetishize and ‘upgrade’ to, or for the “empowerment” of getting pregnant for others, or to feel nurtured and made whole by the self-affirmation of abortion (yes, really). We must become self-identifying cyborgs of shifting, unfixed — but never heterosexual — sexualities which must never result in reproduction for free, or to keep for oneself, but instead purely for the purposes of forced or ‘comradely’ surrogacy for others. And especially for transwomen. 

I find Lewis’s delight in abortion very unsettling. She speaks of it far more warmly than any other aspect of fertility and reproduction, perhaps because transhumanism is fixated with having power over life and death. I can’t decide if she’s just trying to shock her American readers with her rapturous excitement over artist Aliza Schvarts, who impregnated herself then aborted the embryo every month for a year, but it is deeply immature. I’m 100% pro-choice but the thought of abortion as entertainment and art form is profoundly trivializing. And it’s an insanely privileged and crass position to take, considering how many women worldwide are forced into multiple abortions as a result of sex-selection, familial abuse or forced prostitution. 

Given her intent to undermine the existence of the mother-child bond, however, it makes a sickening kind of sense. Lewis asserts — without being able to provide their names or any evidence — that some biologists believe that DNA is meaningless: “DNA is not self-producing … it makes nothing … and organisms are not determined by it,” she claims. This conveniently means that no one really has any hereditary tie with anyone else, that the mother-child bond is a fiction, and that therefore all children should ‘belong’ to everyone and no one. Lewis also claims that, because some women don’t bond with their babies and others give them up for adoption or are surrogates, women bonding with their babies is a misogynist myth to keep women having babies with or for men (as opposed to having babies for transwomen to share). Her seemingly obsessive hatred of human attachment goes against every scrap of science, psychology, and plain old common-sense experience about our species and what everyone, from birth to end of life, needs. Comradeship, here then, is just a fancy word for making attachment disorders the new norm. The belief that women can (or in fact should) be freed from loving their children, and indeed not even see them as their children, is pure anti-evolution. It’s simply not ever going to happen. Like other animals, human beings continue the race by bonding with, and caring for, their young. 

According to Lewis, “[w]e are the makers of one another”; we exist on the basis of how (we force) others (to) see us, not because a woman has delivered us to the world. “We could learn collectively to act like it. It is those truths that I wish to call surrogacy, full surrogacy.” By “learn collectively to act like it,” I fear she means ‘make compliance compulsory,’ like all good totalitarians. “Such a move is,” she continues, “inspired by utopian traditions — those of various social biologists, queer and transfeminine scientists, antiracists and communists — that have speculated about what babymaking beyond blood, private coupledom, and the gene fetish might one day be.” It’s all a fancy way of saying that women must give up their babies to the commune, to the state, to be shared as both the means of production and the outcome of production. Note, too, how not giving your baby up is inferred to be racist, as though the solution to the racism of poor women abroad having their babies bought off them is for the same fate to befall all babies. To Lewis, surrogacy is so important in erasing women as a reproductive sex class, erasing the power of the female body, and giving men (transwomen) what they want, that these factors supersede the exploitation and racism. 

Indeed, for all the talk of ‘queer communism,’ when it comes to the matter of the exploitation of women’s reproduction, Lewis takes the classic libfem position of “if you can’t beat ’em, join ’em — but go even bigger.” She acknowledges that surrogacy is exploitative — but only because the wrong type of people are exploiting poor women of colour abroad (the high numbers of poor white women who give their babies up for surrogacy and adoption in the USA are ignored as they don’t fit her narrative). If women everywhere would just have babies to give to transwomen, then it wouldn’t be exploitative; it would be a utopian act of comradely allyship. Of course, expecting women to have babies to satisfy male need is the absolute core of patriarchy, but Lewis thinks that it’s the most radical, transformative, freeing, egalitarian ideal possible if this is done for the utopian aim of ‘queer communism.’ Her problem with surrogacy, then, is that it’s not so much the buying of women’s bodies that’s wrong, but who’s doing the buying and why.

It’s clear that Lewis’s motto is ‘gestational work is work,’ just as libfems claim ‘sex work is work.’ “What if we reimagined pregnancy and not just its prescribed aftermath, as work under capitalism,” she writes, “as something to be struggled in and against toward a utopian horizon free of work and free of value?” It’s funny how these queer communists want to ultimately abolish all labour … except for prostitution and surrogacy, as though the world is unimaginable without female bodies being used, abused and exploited. Despite her cyborg protestations, Lewis knows that the world isn’t possible without women giving birth to it—but there’s no place in her supreme egalitarian state for women to have any status that makes them different to men and for their reproductive labour to be recognized. The result is a vision of surrogacy as prostitution: supplying men with an ever-ready batch of fresh meat to give them whatever they want to extract from their bodies. She frequently insists we liken surrogacy (and prostitution) to ‘helping jobs’ like tech support, as though producing a human life is the same as telling someone to switch their internet router off then on again. I know it makes no sense to simultaneously claim that all women should be freed from ‘gestating’ yet also act as surrogates to provide the community with a fresh supply of babies, but Lewis doesn’t see the contradiction. For her, it seems more a case of being realistic by accepting that some babies have to be born, so this is the best she can come up with to disconnect the bonds of mothers and children and make children free-share objects to pass around communally.

Her necessary blindness to the exploitation of women as a reproductive class is possibly also why Lewis is curiously quiet about the numbers of gay men who exploit women for surrogacy. Perhaps it’s just too contradictory: it’s still men exploiting women’s bodies to give them progeny but they’re technologizing and desexualizing fertilization, as well as interrupting the conservative model of the nuclear heterosexual family. What to critique and what to support? Lewis dodges the issue, of course. Much as she dodges the issue of asking, if transwomen are women, then how come it’s okay for them to want to have babies, to be included in female reproductive processes, to be mothers? If we are all women, how come one type of woman’s desire for children should be facilitated, while the other should be broken and commodified?  

Everything that has ever been done to alleviate the lot of any group of women is described by Lewis as ‘eugenicist.’ It’s a worrying trend in postmodernist academia to describe any form of social engineering, even positive ones, as eugenics, as though having an NHS is on a par with the Nazi Lebensborn project. In particular, Lewis claims it is eugenicist to want to look after maternal and natal health and welfare. She quotes historian Laura Briggs arguing that the fact “there is even a relationship between material well-being and childbearing is a twentieth-century, middle-class, and to some extent white belief,” and distorts this to conclude that because maternal healthcare originated with better-off white women in America, it’s bad to extend this to all women. (It didn’t occur to Lewis to look for examples of women of other ethnicities also calling for this or providing it within their own communities.) Apparently, it’s also racist to say that women of colour shouldn’t be used as surrogates, straight out of the school of ‘it’s racist to criticize FGM.’ After all, what if they are choosing or identify with their oppression, exploitation and suffering?

However, handily, it’s not eugenics if you’re ‘queering’ pregnancy and birth by making it about men: 

Likewise, I have absolutely no quarrel with the trans-inclusive autonomist midwives and radical doulas, the ones lobbying for their work to become a guaranteed form of free health care. I have no quarrel with “full-spectrum” birth-work that supports people of all genders through abortion, miscarriage, fertility treatments, labor, and post-partum, often operating outside of biomedical establishments …

Yes, the problem is that midwifery, obstetrics and free healthcare for pregnant and post-natal women has been entirely focused on the female body — purely out of spiteful, fascistic bigotry — but once you make it all about trans people and pursue questionable and scientifically unlicensed medical experiments that try to play god (which is definitely not eugenics) then it instantly stops being problematic. At one stage, Lewis even refers to herself as “I — and other feminist cyborgs.” She clearly thinks this makes her look radical and edgy, but it just made me feel like I was reading Metal Mickey’s Introduction to Queer Theory (free with Smash Hits!). The whole book reads as though it’s written by an alien robot psychopath sulking because it’s been made to live amongst these humans it so despises and study their vile, primitive breeding habits. She makes baffled statements like “natural childbirth has never gone entirely out of fashion and is still extremely popular among diverse social classes,” as though she presumes we share her confusion and disgust over the female body producing life.

So much of what is argued in Full Surrogacy Now is an unsettling twist of a kaleidoscope away from sound feminist thought. Yes, reproduction has been and still is forced onto huge numbers of women. Yes, it is a disgrace that women still suffer and die as a result of pregnancy and birth the world over. Yes, it is essential and important that women and girls have access to terminating unwanted or dangerous pregnancies. Yes, we have societies where only rich white women receive acceptable maternal health care. But the fault does not lie with pregnancy or the female body itself. The fault lies with a patriarchal system which has commodified the female body and reproduction and enforced hierarchical thinking, categorization and organization. The way to tackle this is not to stop women reproducing or to make all babies available to anyone and everyone, but rather to dismantle the systems which can make reproduction oppressive, which do not care enough about maternal health, pre- or post-natally, and to make safe, free reproductive and maternal health care universally accessible to all women without exception. That would be the truly radical course of actio

Shambolic Neutral is the pseudonym of a Gen X, British radical feminist who’s been active in campaigning, studying, public speaking and writing since her teens.