Issue Two

Extra-Feminist: Damage

by Esmée Streachailt

Editors’ Note: ‘Extra-Feminist’ is a semi-regular feature designed to introduce readers to concepts and methodologies developed outside feminist critical traditions that are useful in feminist projects. Knowledge, concepts and practical experience from fields as diverse as accounting, ecology, gardening, economics, politics, activism, psychology, history, law, linguistics, sport, computing and architecture can be brought to bear on feminist questions and activities. Contact us if you have expertise that you’d like to share with the feminist movement.

FORM IS FUNCTION

Human salvation lies in the creatively maladjusted.
— Martin Luther King, Jr.

Theodor Adorno practised philosophy in Germany until the Nazi party forced the Institute for Social Research at Goethe University to close in 1933. He and a handful of colleagues fled, eventually establishing the University of Frankfurt’s Institute for Social Research in New York. These members of the Frankfurt School lived through the emergence of a brutal and murderous fascism in Germany that captured both institutions and the loyalty of friends.

Arriving in exile to the US, they quickly observed a thickening atmosphere of a softer but pernicious fascism — the one Americans recall as the corporatization and conformism of the late 1940s to 1968.1 The school originated a mode of cultural analysis grounded in Marxist critique of economic/class oppression that combined insights from Freudian psychoanalysis and anthropology to analyse culture’s underlying operations and its deeply embedded assumptions and goals. Today we call this tradition Critical Theory, and it informs the stronger forms of cultural, feminist, queer, race, and post-colonial studies.2

I believe that this moment in the 21st century, this precipice of a new fascist domination of the US and Europe, requires us to keep our eye on the deeper structures that animate ‘owning the libs,’ or ‘cancelling authors,’ or firing people from jobs for insisting that we ground our political imagination in material reality. This requires more attention from us than countering each new and ever more shocking stunt/meme/tweet.3

“It does not matter in whose name or for what progressive cause we behave like fascists. Fascist behaviour can never, never can ever, result in liberation.”4 Not even for the people who enact it. Those who traffic in accusations of wrongthink often succeed in destroying the work or lives of artists, politicians, professors, writers, lawyers, and activists, or any who are the traditional first targets of fascist energy. Even such proto-fascists/totalitarians/ideologues are trapped forever in the violent, paranoid fear that those they oppress will rise up against them and must deploy the continual generation of new ‘enemies’ to keep their followers unified. Or, and perhaps worse, their own will turn on them. It is always only a matter of time before the true believer turns on the ally who stands by them. Every misogynist eventually does damage to the women nearest to hand. Every narcissist eats their best friend’s heart eventually. Every totalitarian must shrink the circle of trust and inclusion to maintain power. Each and every one. The paranoia is justified. No one in such a world can be free or flourishing.

DAMAGE

Every work of art is an uncommitted crime.
— Theodor Adorno, Minima Moralia

Adorno quickly came to understand ‘damage’ to be a kind of rust working under the glossy order of mid-century American life. The wholesomeness of Norman Rockwell and Leave It to Beaver, while banally charming, were not optional. Eccentricity, as we still know, was not considered a leadership quality. There was/is a pervasive depersonalization and conformism at the heart of American culture. We only like our rebels in fiction, on stage. Try to walk around in mixed company as an iconoclast, and you’ll feel the friction.

Observing the carnage, genocide, and sheer ballistic annihilation of World War II followed by the nearly oceanic adaptation to its effects, these philosophers ask a big question:

How can this be? How can the progress of modern science and medicine and industry promise to liberate people from ignorance, disease, and brutal, mind-numbing work, yet help create a world where people willingly swallow fascist ideology, knowingly practice deliberate genocide, and energetically develop lethal weapons of mass destruction? Reason, they answer, has become irrational.5

Reason had always been a little instrumental. Alongside the kind of reason that generated modern democracy and leaping advances in science was a kind of reason-as-abstraction that placed fungible objects of the wild world into categories and hierarchies, including people, ethnic groups, and nations. This is the history of imperialism and enslavement. Everything was becoming commodity, product, productivity, quotient, and value. The businessman, the CEO, no longer the industrial tycoon, was the icon of success and seat of influence. What had happened was that the instrumental got the better of reason.

So, one answer to the ‘why?’ is clear in both the European and US contexts: race. The ‘other’ in Europe was primarily the Jewish people, just as in the US it was primarily black people. At the heart of The Enlightenment’s home was a ghetto, in every city a Jewish Quarter. And it is no secret now that Hitler borrowed much from the traditions of racial oppression in the United States, both Jim Crow laws and our genocidal Manifest Destiny. The colonial child of the Enlightenment was founded on the brutalizing and instrumentalizing of whole peoples to serve its labour and ideological needs.6

‘Damage,’ you see, is the character of the socio-cultural organization that gave us meticulous, impersonal Nazi recordkeeping and US corporate culture with its advertising, amortization, endless need for data and employee improvement. Remember, your productivity is someone else’s money. Adorno works through his analysis of damage in Minima Moralia: Reflections from Damaged Life (1951). The book is a collection of fragments and short essays, each a meditation on society and its discontents.

Let me give you a brief tour of Minima Moralia, coloured by our present social media ‘debates’ concerning rights conflicts and discursive antagonism between women’s and trans women’s rights. Not quite a ‘conversation,’ because it’s had almost entirely within the structure of the culture industry:

43. Unfair intimidation. — What truth may objectively be is difficult enough to determine, but we should not, in our dealings with people, let this fact terrorize us … One of the most dependable [obfuscating criteria] is the reproach that a statement is ‘too subjective.’ If this is brought to bear [against your analysis], with an indignation in which rings the furious harmony of all reasonable people, one has grounds … to feel self-satisfied … The notions of subjective and objective have been completely reversed. Objective means the non-controversial aspect of things, their unquestioned impression, the façade made up of classified data … and they call subjective anything which breaches that façade, engages the specific experience of matter, casts off ready-made judgements and substitutes relatedness to the object for the majority consensus of those who do not even look at it, let alone think about it … This is doubly true in the era of positivism and the culture industry, where objectivity is calculated by the subjects managing it. (pp. 69-70, emphasis mine)

It’s the ‘objectivity’ of ‘white culture.’ It’s Mike Pence, soft-spoken and vicious. A distortion field. Sex is a spectrum. Woman is a feeling, a mood even. What’s true and right is ‘managed’ for us and enforced. For instance, take gender ideology. As with the more dubious arguments of patriarchal yore, some very dodgy science is brought out to support the ‘objectivity’ of the ‘feeling’ of ‘being’ another social identity. An intensified distortion field of ‘objectivity’ comes to bear in support of the ‘feeling’ of ‘being’ another sex. Though we may critique the more virulent transactivists for being narcissistic, subjective, identitarian etc., in fact, in our culture, their view is taken to be ‘objective’ and ours is criticized as ‘too subjective’ because it’s breaking the veneer of consensus. That consensus is the enabling fiction that sex is not a thing and there is only gender/identity. This inversion spurs accusations against radical feminists of unfairness and intimidation, unkindness and conservatism.

FROM CRITICAL THEORY TO RADICAL FEMINISM

The only way to deal with an unfree world is to become so absolutely free that your very existence is an act of rebellion.
― Albert Camus

Adorno speaks in the ‘universal’ because he’s talking about deep structures in mid-century-postmodern-late-capitalism, a structure that has only expanded its reach in the information age. The blandening of which he complains is a soft fascism, and completely relevant to the contemporary experiences and discourses shaping life in the ‘advanced’ nations. Today, we worry about it in terms of the flattening effects of social media and the ironic conformity of hipsters — all effects of the culture industry.7 The corporate drone, the desk jockey, the cubicle warrior are 21st century versions of the last century’s ‘grey man’; we are offered terms that would make all people, but especially ‘gender-non-conforming’ people, into gender drones.

Rather than natural bodies with complex minds inside them, contemporary gender ideology would medicalize these specific expressions of human variability into conformity, made docile and manageable. Indeed, such bodies require a great deal of management, data tracking, paperwork. It’s all very … profitable.

I want to propose a way of thinking ‘damage’ that supports radical feminist and justice work because the built-in threat Adorno sensed in the mid-century leads to material harm and suffering. It’s the baked-in nature of the soft-serve fascism that makes its denial easy, and the denial is a kind of damage-multiplier. Radical feminism recuperates lost women’s knowledge, critiques the fantasy laid over women’s realities by men’s cultures, organizes to support/heal women harmed by men’s social order, and imagines new worlds where humans are not so fragmented and overdetermined by roles written to belittle them. Radical feminism would intervene in that damage before it can do irreparable harm to bodies, lives, and whole communities.8

For instance, in ‘24. Tough Baby,’ Adorno dices the homosociality of men’s culture, the kind of man Jon Hamm played in Mad Men or that is still embodied today by Jordan Peterson, Joe Rogan. At the time, he was working with some undiluted Freud, so what we read today as ‘homosociality,’ he calls ‘repressed homosexuality,’ and this is one spot where I have to correct Adorno. The sexual orientation of a man to other men is most definitely not the same thing as the jocular misogyny of men’s culture and locker-room talk. While the homosexual world is not free of misogyny, woman-hate is not the point or even a constitutive element. But of the breezy, cocksure manliness of The Rat Pack, misogyny is constitutive. There is a kind of man, a gesture, that displays virility in such a way as to call for:

suspicion. It expresses independence, sureness of the power of command, the tacit complicity of all males … and film heroes show the most insignificant bank clerk how it is done. Its archetype is the handsome dinner-jacketed figure returning late to his bachelor flat … mixing himself a whiskey and soda: the carefully recorded hissing of the mineral water says what the arrogant mouth keeps to itself: that he despises anything that does not smell of smoke, leather and shaving cream, particularly women, which is why, precisely, they find him irresistible. The pleasures of such men … all have about them a latent violence. (pp. 45-46)

It is a surliness and narcissism, Adorno goes on to argue, that masks any possible emotion, any feeling including friendly admiration for a male peer. Everyone is a master, or a tool: women, lesser men, children, creatures who might have an outward emotion. In the end, these tough guys are the dependent ones, the automatons, who “need the weaklings as their victims in order not to admit they are like them” (p. 46). Such men, these patriarchal values, loathe women for our embodiedness, our nearness to matter, that they deny themselves in a vain bid for perfection, immortality. This applies to the women they harm in domestic violence, the intellectual boys at school they taunt, and homosexuals they target for demonstrating a closeness to other men denied to these tough guys by the very codes that give them power.

Totalitarians are so dominated by their ideology that they can only serve, not live, not make their own way in the world.

Damage is both evidence of structural violence and an assumption that this violence is simply society, simply how we do life, ordained. It is not just a harm, it is not just a trigger. Damage is the deeper thing that makes us sensitive to harm or triggers. It functions at the level of generational trauma. Rather than acute trauma, it might just be the pervasive everyday fog of random malice that we visit on each other. Some people might live happily inside the damaged system, live well with the deformations visited on their personalities. That does not mean the damage is not there. If the contemporary capitalist system rewards the traits of sociopaths, and promotes people who enact those traits, then capitalism is a form of damage. And it does, to the tune of about 20% of corporate leadership.9 And while 20% is not the majority, it is the threshold for necessity.

Damage shows up in oxycontin and methamphetamine addiction roving over US farmland just as it did in the wave of crack addiction in the 1990s that ravaged mostly black communities. Both are (non-adaptive, sure) responses to a malicious impoverishment and neglect by the very larger forces that seeded the addictions in both communities. Damage lets Big Pharma and the CIA put the drugs in the communities so that the medical and carceral industrial complexes can profit from the effects.

In the kind of error one socialist feminist described on Twitter, Adorno would have seen damage:

if ur feminism doesn’t look at women as an oppressed CLASS, but believes homogeneous collection of “free choices” are enough to liberate women from patriarchy, maybe consider you’ve been conditioned to underestimate the full scope of women’s oppression by patriarchy10

The form is the function.

Damage sets in when the terms are accepted as the horizon. When you repeat and recycle and reverse the analysis of the oppressed by changing the frame, you are damaged. Feminism says the terms enforced by patriarchy are damage. Liberals say the free choices offered in terms enforced by patriarchy are freedom. The liberal position requires that we ignore most of the material, embodied, and psychological experience of women.

Freedom, Adorno might say, is as structural as oppression. To get to it, a society has to stop treating symptoms as the whole illness. This is also the point at which the body-society metaphor breaks down. Societies do not have immune systems. Where a body can fend off much illness, societies tend to have inertia — and keep running off on whatever trajectory they happen to have developed. Reason and cooler minds are not tonic. We can address immediate and historical harm with changed behaviour, and we must in order to relate to each other across differences. But healing the body social? That is deeper work yet.

Harm is serious, both a primary and an insufficient focus for justice and rights movements. Harm goes to court. Damage goes to the root. We can move among each other assuaging harm and restoring justice forever, because the harm is the effect and not the cause.

Damage is to the social more like what early childhood trauma is to the personality. It is formative. And it can be very physical. Where male sexual entitlement is a spectacular element of patriarchy’s enforcement of power, rape is a harm done to women as an extension of the damage that is sexual entitlement. White supremacy is damage that erupts in the harm of redlining in housing and credit imposed on people of colour as an enforcement of its power. It is this dynamic of damage-harm-trauma that leads radical feminists to charge a cohort of trans women with male entitlement when they argue that lesbians who would prefer not to have sexual intercourse with them are bigots who need re-education (this cohort is never seeking intimacy, just sexual pleasure).

What I find useful about Adorno’s work around damage is that it’s a widely useful category of analysis for gauging what kinds of social/cultural values are to be encouraged and which are to be discouraged (or ideally, eliminated). I like it as a word because it has more immediate emotional appeal than ‘structural _________.’

The cheerful ease of 1950s white, suburban culture can be damage. In ‘36. The Health unto Death,’ Adorno goes at that smooth earnestness hammer and tongs:11

[one could] show the sickness proper to the time to consist precisely in normality. The libidinal achievements demanded of an individual behaving as a healthy body and mind are such as can be performed only at the cost of the profoundest mutilation … The regular guy, the popular girl have to repress not only their desires and insights, but even the symptoms that in [previous eras] resulted from repression … No science has yet explored the inferno in which were forged the deformations that later emerge to daylight as cheerfulness, openness, sociability, successful adaptation to the inevitable, an equable, practical frame of mind. [It may be that] characteristics are laid down at an even earlier phase than the neuroses; if the latter result from a conflict in which instinct is defeated, the former condition, as normal as the damaged society it resembles, stems from … an intervention which incapacitates the opposing forces before they have come to grips with each other … (pp. 58-59, emphasis mine)

Gender is damage. It deforms human-being. It deforms men as much as it does women; the difference is the form or method of the damage, the ways it’s taught to us by traumatic events of exclusion, attention, or punishment. Those are the teaching methods that create this dead-health that frightens and disgusts Adorno with its “pent-up lunacy of Fascism.” People who arrive in adulthood so deformed as to be unable to find their doubt, or the hiccup in their thinking, or the clumsy movement that reveals anxiety, or the sudden too-much joy for the social situation — these people have trained the animal creature out of themselves and missing it can do every violence, both at a distance and up close.

I watch Ivanka Trump move through the world with that implacable composure and shudder.

COLONIZATION IN THE SYMBOLIC

History shows that to colonize a people an aggressor must accomplish some combination of several kinds of alienation:

1) Remove the targeted people from or alienate them in relation to their indigenous lands: as in the trans-Atlantic slave trade, the Clearances in Scotland and Ireland, the forced marches and relocations of indigenous peoples in the Americas, or the Hmong in Cambodia.

2) Cut the targeted people off from their history/elders/ancestors. Among people who rely on oral transmission of their history through their elders, this means killing the elders and any mid-generation people who know the stories.

3) Forbid and punish the use of the native language and enforce its replacement with the aggressor language through corporal punishment/death and the forced education of children in the aggressor’s language.

4) Destroy the temples or rename them for the aggressor’s religion or deities. The Cathedral of Chartres is a double triumph, one architectural, the other cultural. A holy well, sacred to the Celtic Bretons, is buried and covered over by this beacon of Christian hegemony.12

Contemporary patriarchy performs a kind of symbolic, but historically effective, colonization against women as a class by triangulating young women against older ones. Those ‘old’ feminist ‘hags,’ those ‘man-haters,’ those ‘transphobes.’ If you want to be appreciated and approved and loved by men and other patriarchal people, you have to disavow those women and everything they have accomplished or researched and shared. You have to do it gladly, and gleefully, and you have to prove your disavowal with regular performances of disrespect toward those women. Read de Beauvoir only in light of Butler. Never read Freidan, Dworkin, Jordan, Lorde, Cisneros, Anzaldua, MacKinnon, Irigaray, Sedgwick, Mazumdar, Rege. This intentionally fostered contempt interrupts feminist lineage and disempowers women as a class. It means that a generation or two passes without knowing about the Hite Report. It means that two generations pass without knowing that the ‘computers’ who put ‘man’ on the Moon were black female math geniuses who had to walk ten minutes from their office to find a women’s bathroom on the NASA campus.

Why would you listen to those witches, you young and lovely girls so eager for male approval—the only approval you are taught to seek. Those women are un-womanly: aggressive, hairy, no longer fertile, hateful, so … un-fuck-able.

The alienation of one generation from the next, the erasure of women’s and feminist history, sociology, philosophy, policy work, literature — burying the old religions in the crypts of the new — these are symbolic colonizations.13 The forbidding of the word ‘woman’ unadorned with ‘trans’ or ‘cis’ is a symbolic colonization. It’s not just a misappropriation (borrowing without respect), it’s an overwriting, a forgetting of over 70 years of knowledge that was always meant to be built upon.

Renaming us as our ‘objective’ bodily functions in the most brutal symbolic terms, the most instrumentalizing language, and then intimidating women into using those terms is a symbolic colonization. And all this overwriting and overdetermination supports the ongoing disempowerment and oppression of women and goes further to prefigure renewed oppressions that will demote women to being bodies without minds, things with exchange and re/productive value: menstruators, birthing bodies, people with uteruses, front-holes, fuck-holes, cunts, TERFs — chattel made for breeding. Toaster. Toaster oven. Gestator. Incubator. An incubator could produce a human child, a fresh batch of yoghurt, a clutch of chicks, a risen sponge … back to the toaster in a virtuous capitalist cycle. Never mind how this language lands on the ears of black women in the West, whose grandmothers, great-grandmothers, and on back for generations were tortured in exactly that capitalist cycle. But, no—birthing bodies, incubators, these are very inclusivx terms even with all the ‘Hansxl and Grxtxl’ associations it’s pulling up for mx.

This new erasure of woman and writing over hxr with ‘cis’ and ‘mxnstruator’ is dangerous in that it clears cultural and psychological space for re-xxcluding ‘womxn’ from full participation in society. Worse, it figures us in discourse in the same way wx think of other property and tools, in terms of thxir use for thxir owner.

Womxn is the damage before the harm.

Esmée Streachailt, PhD is a nom de guerrière. Esmée’s cultural and organizing work leverages strategic alliances across difference for the liberation and flourishing of humans. Her writing embraces feminist critical theory, cultural hermeneutics, comparative religion, and poetics. Esmée is a co-founder and contributing editor with THE RADICAL NOTION: A FEMINIST QUARTERLY.

1 The Frankfurt School did not develop analyses of either racism or sexism, nor the many forms of othering that animate progressive concern today. They were German, after all, and whatever insight they may have had into those forms of damage likely would not have been trusted by receiving audiences. Their influence has been far reaching among theorists and activists who address many forms of oppression, nonetheless.

2 Two of the mothers of post-colonial studies, for example, draw heavily on this tradition. Seyla Benhabib is still writing about the Frankfurt School and its siblings. See for example ‘Arendt and Adorno: The Elusiveness of the Particular and the Benjaminian Moment,’ in Arendt and Adorno: Political and Philosophical Investigations, ed. by Lars Rensmann and Samir Gandesha (Stanford: Stanford University Press, 2012), pp. 31-55. Similarly, Gayatri Spivak’s work was foundational. See, for example, Asha Varadharajan’s study in Exotic Parodies: Subjectivity in Adorno, Said, and Spivak (Minneapolis: Minnesota University Press, 1995).

3 Regardless of the defeat of one US administration, the real economic, environmental, and geopolitical conditions supporting that administration remain in place and must be confronted.

4 As I argue in ‘RE: Framing Radical Feminism: The Plot Twist,’ if it walks, talks, makes policy, or tweets like a patriarch, it’s a patriarch and must be treated to the critical analysis feminists afford patriarchy. Same goes for the fascism of ‘woke ideology’ and its rather masculine low tolerance for critique. See Issue One (print or PDF) of THE RADICAL NOTION, 31 October 2020, p. 34.

5 Lambert Zuidervaart, ‘Theodor W. Adorno,’ Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy online, 26 October 2016.

6 While Hannah Arendt was not a member of the Frankfurt School, both her biography and analysis of the banality and ubiquity of evil parallel their general trajectory. Videos of several interviews with Arendt at Philosophy Overdose make a good introduction to her analysis. See: Philosophy Overdose, YouTube. Alternately, the overview of Arendt’s thought at Philosophize This is a more concise introduction. The podcast is the work of one very generous philosopher, so please donate if you can: ‘Episode 136—Hannah Arendt—The Banality of Evil,’ Philosophize This.

7 All that exposed brick, distressed wood, the Edison lightbulbs, the reclaimed-boho-industrial feel of the 2010s (fucking whitewashed ‘patina’ everywhere) found its way into every hip corner of every cultural centre on the planet. Remember kids, there is always only one way to be cool.

8 One more quick nod to Seyla Benhabib. She has done some still very necessary thinking on identity, boundaries, and rights conflicts in The Rights of Others: Aliens, Residents, and Citizens (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2004).

9 Jack McCullogh, ‘The Psychopathic CEO,’ Forbes, 9 December 2019.

10 Tweet quoted anonymously at the author’s request.

11 In the first instalment of ‘RE: Framing Radical Feminism,’ I discuss Betty Friedan’s feminist analysis of this same culture of conformity (pp. 116-21).

12 They were not Druids. That’s just what people call them, and there’s a whole story there, but the wells were sacred to the Celts and were intimately connected to their goddess traditions. Sources of various credibility discuss the crypt in which the well is kept (the largest crypt ever constructed), and while Julius Caesar never conquered Brittany, the Catholics later did.